We are still slaves... Aren't we?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 чер 2024
- 1420 is one of a kind in Russia, you can support the channel at the following links:
✨ Patreon: / issafourteentwenty
✨ Paypal: www.paypal.me/daniil1420
PayPal email: issafourteentwenty@gmail.com
PayPal name: Daniil Orain
✨ Buy Me A Coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/1420
Cryptocurrencies:
🪙 ETH: 0x1F7402dE513afDB5906a174eF22C7030D19651DF
🪙 BTC: bc1qvns4pkvcs6hzktpcnudvgz5sr06u7phwhej0cg
✉️ Business: hello@1420.today
🧢 1420 clothes and accessories: 1420.clothing
Timestamps:
0:00 - What is slavery?
1:44 - Examples
5:08 - Are we slaves?
7:02 - We were slaves for a long time
10:00 - Will we get back to slavery?
Filmed by Nikita.
Edited by Daniil Orain.
We have a discord channel, which is available only to those who’re subscribed to our channel. You can subscribe on either UA-cam or Patreon, in both of them I publish the link to our discord every month on 10th.
🇧🇾 We recently filmed interviews in Belarus, I will publish them soon!
If you have any ideas what we should ask Belarusian people, feel free to write your ideas on our Patreon post + the link to our discord is still available (for the next day) in another Patreon post:
www.patreon.com/posts/what-should-we-94597739
Discord:
www.patreon.com/posts/our-discord-94380998
What will happen if Lukashenko dies, are they afraid that Russia will annex them, what they think abouyt Poland now.
RuzZia, DPRK, China, Saudi Arabia, Syria, some African nations. Anywhere you can be taken away for any reason and never seen again. They should know the topic well. But they still don't realize how screwed they really are in ruzZia. Or as I call it "Future ground zero"
Russia is a democratic country ua-cam.com/video/5MyUixig7hU/v-deo.html
Please ask Belarus people why most of the Ruzzian politicians sending their children to the rotting west for educational purpose.
3:30 There were so many ridiculous answers, and some were worse than this guy's but this nevertheless made me laugh. The idea that the USA and Russia are on the same level, where life is similar and society is essentially the same. Laughable.
Just to be clear, insulting royalty isn't a crime in the UK. In fact, its practically mandatory to insult royalty
Absofuckinglootly 🤙
Was going to say.... this is something with a long and bloodied history and you can say whatever you like heh.
In UK you could be canceled for saying something wrong about sexual, national minorities
@@malkontentniepoprawny6885canceled by government?
@@malkontentniepoprawny6885 Nowhere that I know of has completely unbounded Freedom of Speech. And in the UK, like I suspect many places elsewhere, for example I think making racist comments constitutes hate speech, for which you can be prosecuted, by the state effectively. If some kind of private body 'cancels' you for eg hate speech, that is their freedom of speech to do so. The same as "No shirt, no shoes, no service."
The bearded guy who said criticizing the Royal in the UK is a crime certainly doesn’t have access to the news. If Britts couldn’t criticize the Royal Family, half of the UK news reports would disappear.
no you get arrested for teaching a dog sieg heil as a joke welcome to the UK.
yeah I stopped watching at that point, too much nonsense to handle for a Saturday night!
А само наличие королевской семьи, которая сидит на шее британцев в 21 веке, это не рабство? 😂 А обычные люди заискивая обсуждают, какие у этих бездельников собачки, сумочки, платья). Анохронизм.
Harry had to take one of the newspapers to court and eventually won a settlement for invasion of privacy(his phone was hacked).
They live in their own bubble.
Like North Korea they just dont get it.But unfortunantly i feel the most countries have much less freedom in these days then like 10 or 20 years ago and this goes for the most countries in the world.
The perfect slave is one who doesn't know they are a slave.
- yes, in several western countries people pay way more than 50% of their income in tax, and still they don't consider themselves enslaved....
@@peterwulff469
Perhaps they aren't!
In general a slave does not get paid.--Only sustenance!--probably a lot like in RuZZia.
@@WangAiHua - but they are. Confiscating a large part of peoples money equals taking a large part of their freedom. And for what? - for upholding a huge welfare state that corrupts and literally degenerates a majority of the population.
@@peterwulff469when you see where your 50% of taxes go, why not? What's your tax level idea when you are definitely not a slave? 0%?
@@alexeyigonen3170 - 20% suffice for the basics that a state should provide.
A future doctor is dumb enough to believe that insulting the British royals is a crime? Wow
Who cares about your clown King?Instead of King you can put the LGBT community.
You don't know what kind of doctor he will be - and somehow even Zoidberg got his title.
@@wookie2222probably a proctologist
And I'm sure you're dumb enough to believe that Navalny was a serious opposition leader, that people in Russia go to jail simply for uttering the word "war", that Russia's economy is in shambles, that Russians are forced to vote for V. Putin, that V. Putin wanted to "take Kiev in 3 days", that Russia is losing etc...
Ignorance is not necessarily stupidity. It’s a crime in Thailand. He may have been confusing the 2 countries
Criticizing the Royal Family is not a crime in Britain. People do it all the time in public.
I agree. That guy was not very well informed overall.
@@telebubba5527 none of these people are 😂
one quesiton was : "examples of less slave like states"
hes says: " high gdp places like emirates" oh really the emirates was all domestic work done at minimum wage pay in a 1st world country. im sure they did im sure no one got abused and stripped of their passport to work
also one of the women say its hard to get rid of a stigma over a period of decades or centuries . THE GERMANS, JAPANESE, AND ITALIANS ARE IN NATO ??!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
А существование королевской семьи в 21 век не является признаками рабства и анохронизма?😂 Вы не критикуете, да, вы раболепствуете перед этими бездельниками). Они не сходят со страниц ваших таблидов. Что они кушали, во что одеты, какие стразы на ошейнике у собачки😂 И вроде вы при встрече обязаны кланяться и приседать.
Every answer that Vasilij gave was idiotic.
Try criticising Putin in public if you fancy taking your chances
"we are free to criticize but protests are forbidden" - enough said
I think the construction worker has a better grasp of freedom vs slavery than the PhD student.
Exactly!!!
this is because the goal of russian universities, at the moment, is to spread propaganda and brainwash the young.
He's actually worked in the real world, as opposed to academia.
That "PhD" student seems woefully uneducated, simple minded, or just simply thoroughly brainwashed.
Ironically, I agree. He seemed like a much more reasonable bloke!!!
Criticizing the Royalty is a crime in Thailand, with up to 15y per offence.
However not in the UK.
But is a crime to insult the LGBT community.
@@devansa125no it’s not
@@devansa125 'In order for a comment to be considered hate speech, it must be more than just offensive or insulting. It must also be threatening, abusive or insulting, and it must be intended to stir up hatred on the grounds of race, religion, sexual orientation, disability or transgender identity.''
@@devansa125 And in russia is a crime to the defend the LGBT community, but not to insult, threaten and mock it.
@@JS-ip8xm You can critise the politicians, authorities,generals ect.Many telegram bloggers critisise military very harshly.Putin doesn't hate the LGBT community but as a smart pilitician he knows this will affect demography in the long run.
Vasilij the "future doctor" seems somewhat confused, it is not illegal in Great Britain to "insult the queen" , actually , the queen has been dead for some time. Let's hope he has more luck with his medical education.....
"the emirates have no slavery" excuse me mate
Female slaves are *bought* in markets in Northern Uganda, etc., with the deliberate intention to end up in the Gulf states.
(And, yes, this is actually true in 2023, not a historical comment about 200 years ago.)
chill, they're just russians.
-@blengi-
-0 seconds ago-
|2ussians aren't the most educated people, they rank well below even Am,eric,an's in the international PISA education rankings in reading and science
I agree with your outrage regarding the UAE. However, please note that the countries named are worthy comments given in their category, where the concept of slavery in the modern state at issue is reflected in this way. Japan is an example of such an Asian island state, Singapore is as a dwarf state, the Emirates (I bet the leader in commitment to an objective assessment of the degree of freedom) is a Middle Eastern state, and Norway is an example of a European state. Taking into account Vladislav’s opinion about the similarity of everyday life of Russia and the United States (in the original the statement has exactly this meaning), apart from Canada, I personally did not add a single other state of America to this list. Let me note that this is just my observation, and if this discussion diverges from this guy’s opinion, I apologize in advance. Thank you for reading
@@blengi Just wondering, as an uneducated Russian) And how the sampling and analysis of these results is carried out, I do not deny that Russia is not the most academically developed country, but it is funny to read that we are mostly uneducated
They are very articulate in rationalizing their slavery.
They are not articulate. It’s word salad.
It’s rationalizations of their train of thought, a mixture of lies, have truths and propaganda.
These idiots couldn’t answer a simple question for $1 million.. you’re hopeless, serfs forever
We humans are fundamentally flawed when we can just forget being objective and rationalize anything and believe it, even if it doesn't make logically any sense.
Nation states go to a lot of trouble and expense to indoctrinate their citizens.
It doesn't matter where you go.
Some however are worse than others.
Chomsky made the simple observation that it's much more important to work on US citizens than it is to indoctrinate New Zealanders for obvious reasons.
What slavery - what propoganda you are influenced😊😊😊
@@mermilena Are you braindead?
For a future doctor, Vasilij is extremely unintelligent, I fear for his patients 😔
I think you lie and mirror your own IQ.
Он очень умный
@@user-li1ey3us6yyou think so?
@@user-li1ey3us6y Русская нацистская свинья! Станьте удобрением!
- Vasilij is only twenty so you shouldn't expect too much, and he is probably much less deluded than many students in the West.
Life is the same in the US as in Russia?
🎉😂😂😂😂😂
Actually(in orig) he talks about Russian people’s everyday lifestyle
Almost everyone who moved from Russia to the USA says about the same thing.
😂😂
You can say what you want about royalty or anyone else in the U.K. including police, government and politicians......
I'm English and I think freedom of speech and the press so important in this time we live in.
I can't imagine living under the restrictions that Russian people are forced to live under!!!
Me neither! Perish the thought.
Give some examples.
@@devansa125examples of what?
@@devansa125 Examples of restrictions in ruzzia? Waving a white sheet of paper in the street and be jailed for it seems restriction enough.
@@devansa125 or better yet, just "No war!" on A4
We have tv shows in England that ridicule the Royal family.
Yes. Royalties in all western countries are being ridiculed by people and media. All the time. But in many countries, the royalties have no or very little power. I don’t know if the pro-Russian commentators don’t know that or if the just play silly.
You have royalty that ridicules the royals! 😎
Why do some Russians insist on insulting other countries by agreeing that things in Russia are bad but everywhere else is the same? Like no, things here definitely aren't like in Russia. That's why we're watching these videos in the first place
We were fed the lies about blood-thirsty West and that “helped” us (I grew up in the USSR) not seeing the brutality of our “progressive” society. Nobody is perfect but Russia is at its own disgusting level.
This is part and parcel of all dictatorships; "Yes things may not be good here - but it is MUCH worse everywhere else! So we are still #1!".
And why it is very important for these dictators to control media - and strike down on anybody who challenges the view, to maintain this gaslighting.
Just look at NK - people there are convinced it is the greatest country in the world (because everywhere else is much, much worse).
🤣😂🤣👏🏻
Their usual types of cope, delusions, propaganda and whataboutism
Give me some examples to prove your point.
To all those who say Russia is just like any other country ; Why do they have a negative population growth; why are there no large lines to immigrate into Russia; Why is their economy in a consistent downward trend?
I think these questions are enough to cause concern and to be reflected upon. Best of luck, with that.🙄😎
If it wasn't for the petroleum and methane, ruzzia would be bankrupt and prostrate ...That would lead to a revolution and hopefully better things eventually, as in Japan after Tojo (with compassionate help from the US); but under extreme stress a country's situatoin can also get worse (Russia turning to the Bolsheviks; Germany turning to Hitler).
Your second "argument" is absolutely laughable (migrants arrive into Russia not in "lines", but in DROVES).
@@ravie7966 Thanks for your kind news update! So if Russia is in such a wonderful situation and Germany is in ruin and depression, why don't the thousands of Russians who insist on living in "miserable" Germany go home? The sooner the better!
@@ravie7966you realize the birthrate in Russia isn't even at replacement rates, right? It is like 1.5/woman. So if you don't have enough immigrants, like you say under the false flag of "mass immigration," then how is Russia going to not only replace the literal millions of people it has lost to both emigration and KIAs, but actually grow?
Doesn't add up, because the answer is that Russia is not and will not be growing much of anything but despair in the coming years and decades.
@@ravie7966Russia doesn't even report this.
3:24 i'm sorry, the emirates? no slavery? Maybe if you forget about all the foreigners working there?
- or the women.
Indeed, a problematic issue according to a 2021 report by Human Rights Watch.
I agree with your outrage regarding the UAE. However, please note that the countries named are worthy comments given in their category, where the concept of slavery in the modern state at issue is reflected in this way. Japan is an example of such an Asian island state, Singapore is as a dwarf state, the Emirates (I bet the leader in commitment to an objective assessment of the degree of freedom) is a Middle Eastern state, and Norway is an example of a European state. Taking into account Vladislav’s opinion about the similarity of everyday life of Russia and the United States (in the original the statement has exactly this meaning), apart from Canada, I personally did not add a single other state of America to this list. Let me note that this is just my observation, and if this discussion diverges from this guy’s opinion, I apologize in advance. Thank you for reading
They are working for money. Are you communist?
I always like how the older people still speak with the confident assurance of an apparatchik reciting the latest five year plan, and how they are working hard to absolutely fulfill it and make the central committee proud!
I hope people stop seeing progress as inevitable, it's possible, yes, but only if people work for it.
When your construction workers are better educated than your doctors, you have a bit of problem.
But it's better than sitting in non-politics
Propaganda at the university
Taking one example and projecting it onto the whole population is as non scientific as it can be. Don't do that, it doesn't work. You end up in misconceptions.
The buildings in the background are a sad sight, poorly built, poor workmanship. Video's of Ukraine show how badly building was done, especially in rural areas. Soviet era building practices.
Vasilji claims that insulting royalty is a crime in the UK. That's not true. For example, already in 1977, the Sex Pistols made the song "God save the queen" insulting the queen. There was no legal sanction for it, but it just wasn't played on the radio.
The fascist regime 🎶🎶
Selling LPs was prohibited too.
That's a timeless classic. Still a great song.
After which their lead singer died. Supposedly from drugs, but...
@@Esm_Psevdonimov Bro. You're a conspiracy nut job.🌰
Sorry to tell you Vasilij, but insulting the monarchy is part of our tradition in the UK. Gillray's hillariously obscene cartoons of the Monarch were published in the 18th century. Imagine if a Russian did that to Putin today.
Sorry, but you are also wrong. On the Russian Internet, Putin is often insulted and a lot of anger and aggression is poured out.
Да никто тебе ничего не скажет в России за карикатуру Путина)
Даже сейчас
Is it the norm that the unclaimed property of the dead goes to the king? The fact that the King does not pay taxes, and part of the seats in parliament is inherited, is this democracy, equality and freedom?
Why I need something to "imagine"??
Vitaliy Podvoyskiy, for example, drew a lots of caricatures with Putin. So??
Maybe you are to try to understand russian traditions. Speaking about "slavery" is provocative, and disrespectful, I'd say trash talk about royal family is well deserved.
What's really sad is that people who are slaves are too afraid to say anything or complain. That's how you can tell who's a slave and who isn't. Thank you Daniil for your outstanding post on this topic. I look forward to more!!!
You are a slave
Just like in the 1975 book ‘The Russians’ by Hedrick Smith, they always compare themselves to the USA. Russia has an economy the size of Italy’s or Canada, countries with a fraction of Russia’s population. it has slightly less than 1/3 the population of the USA, and 1/12 the economy.
Russians should be comparing themselves to Pakistan or North Korea, other poor countries with nuclear weapons…
Right you are ..
Have you been to Russia to confirm this? or do you just get information from TV?
- naah, Russia is definitely more technologically and culturally advanced than countries like Pakistan and North Korea.
@@julybones3808 Why would anyone go to russia...? No one needs to go to north korea to know what's going on there, and the same goes for russia. There are plenty of sources, some personal, some official, some independent, all more or less saying the same thing. You need to accept that your gaslighting doesn't work on most of the world anymore.
@@1midnightfish it means you have bad sources. Russia is much more technologically advanced, cleaner and safer than many European countries. I travel constantly, unlike you, and can compare. (I've been to 16 countries) In Russia, people have the opportunity to run their business without high taxes. I make about 20,000$ a month at a clothing store, which is normal for a big city. Maybe you should still broaden your horizons and see everything with your own eyes, rather than rely on the media? The hero of the video may have been to the USA (but you haven't been to Russia) and he formed the opinion that the USA and Russia are similar, and shaming him for this opinion is not good.
03:30 OMG, the USA is nothing at all like in Russia. The only thing that comes close is the Russian's affinity for American sports wear.
I don’t quite agree, but 👍 for sports wear😂
Finally I have a good example of how a PhD can make you just as stupid as a janitor.
the construction worker was smarter than the PhD student.
Not as smart as the experts on reddit
The janitor is the classic example of a slave, she doesn't even understand she is enslaved, everything that is wrong with Russia...
I'm surprised that people who have access to the Internet in a cozy warm place and spend more than a few seconds thinking about the answer to a question are not able to grasp the clear subtleties in the answer of a PhD student. It is sad
@@user-mf3uy5mx2ryou are not surprised as you have copied this very comment multiple times
looking for excuses seems to be national sport in russia...
- Are you slave? - Nope. - Honesly? - Yes. - Maybe you're going to be slave in future? - Nope. (Ah, why so many excuses?)
A young girl wrote an anti war message on school papers resulting in her teacher reporting the case to authorities. Her father was subsequently imprisoned for his young daughter’s thoughts.
One case of a thousand since Russias invasion into Ukraine.
How can these people say they are progressing and not slaves?
Watching Russians voice state propaganda is depressing. I couldn’t imagine the level of depression these people carry
Do zombies ever get depressed?
@@JS-ip8xm Russia ranks third in suicide (WHO 2022) and their alcoholism rate suggest zombies do in fact become depressed.
Their economic outlook things will go from bad to worse which will widen their doom and gloom outlook.
This channel once interviewed two young women, approx 16-18 years of age and they stated they don’t want to have children in Russia and feel sorry for the children already present.
If that isn’t an epitaph for a country, I don’t know what is.
There is one simple definition of the word "slavery": a system of social relations in which a person is allowed to be owned by another person or the state. What you are talking about cannot be slavery.
@@user-fs6ow9qd1tYou conveniently omitted other elements of slavery. Here, I’ll fill in the blanks
“a condition compared to that of a slave in respect of exhausting labor or restricted freedom”
@@HeadHunter-Six exhausting or forced labor combined with restricted freedom is quite a long way from slavery. Slaves literally don't count as people. If a slave owner kills a slave, he will get nothing for it. He also has every right not to feed the slave. Is there anything like this in Russia?
Life in the USA is the same as Russia?? It’s sad that he really has no idea what life could be like if Russia actually embraced Democracy and freedom for its people.
Just look at the massive wave of Americans who desperately try to get japanese or singapoorian citizenship to finally leave their slavery!!!
Как же ты глуп. В России есть демократия
It will be if trump gets reelected
How does Russian autocracy differ from American "democracy", in which people can actually choose only between two almost identical parties?
Like losing your job because you "misgendered" someone?😂
Where do they get India from as an example... This is the best bit 2:21 Insulting royalty is apparently a crime in the U.K. It's actually a pastime here.
hahaha yes, it makes a change from moaning about the weather or public transport!
Most of them speak about "progress" as some linear evolution from "bad" to "good", in such a well-articulated and really alike manner. It's quite scary.
The janitor clearly is completely brainwashed
All slaves are oppressed but not all the oppressed are slaves, to be a slave you are first trapped in a situation against your will because someone else is taking advantage of your weaknesses plus you are likely not receiving correct compensation for your labour.
'you can criticize but protests are forbidden here, but hey did you see how they suppress protests in france?!' facepalm.
Whataboutism at its best
He claimed France suppressed all demonstrations, not just the riots
Se avessero la consapevolezza di quello che pensa l' occidentale quando parlano, non so quale potrebbe essere la loro reazione. È veramente avvilente l' arretratezza culturale e la sottomissione al pensiero unico: giovani già vecchi.
“You’re all a bunch of slaves.”
~ (Jim Morrison)
He was a slave to booze and drugs. Too bad, I loved his music.
Jim Morrison was establishment 100% his father was Admiral Morrison the one that faked the Gulf of Tonking incindent that brought the USA into the Vietnam war.
All the music scene was CIA and all their music was written by Frank Zappa in Laurel Canion in Los Angeles. The same studio was used to fake the moon landings.
Its all interconnected because (((those))) in control like to be hands on. It's not paranoia when they're out to get you and (((they))) know that their crimes are without limit so they're permanently afraid that the golem will turn in them.
Now you know.
Daniil, thank you for your job
One can advance horizontally in Russia indeed... first you are mobilized, sent to Ukraine and then being carried off the battlefield.
😂😂😂😂😂 exactly
But only if you're fortunate. It seems that most of the wounded are left on the battlefield to expire horizontally, and their corpses are left there to rot or be eaten by rats and wild dogs. TVP has a video showing a field littered with frozen RF corpses.
@@Comm.DavidPorter I saw a video of some cute stray puppies eating the🧠of a liquidated Russian. If was funny because the puppies were growling at the cameraman. "Grrrrr. Back off human. Our meaty chunks not yours".
fkng love the music in the background
makes me feel ready to consider what is being said
The US and Russia are the same? Sorry, that's not accurate.
It is ridiculous narrative, but this is what the most of them believe: basically, that US is like Russia. The same laws, the same quality of life, the same mentality… just a different flag.
How is it a democracy when there is only 1 political party! Deluded!
There are 23 parties in Russia more than in the US.
I can't understand which country you are talking about.
@@devansa125but there can only be one winner. The Party of Putin😂
@@devansa125 North Korea has four parties, but only one has won all the "elections" since 1948. Can you tell me when was the last time an opposition party won a national election in Russia?
They reveal the results the day before the election!
thanks for posting
I think that guy has mistaken Britain for Thailand, on the matter of insulting royalty.
It also occurs to me that you might get more honest and critical responses if you blur faces and don’t take names, because right now I think people are afraid to speak the truth.
Seeing critical thinking and not being afraid to voice your opinion is somewhat encouraging. Refreshing from the I don't do politics bs.
There are different people.
Coward, crazy, realist.
1st - won't speak. 2nd - will speak. 3rd - will speak sometimes (based on person's experience may or may not refuse to speak when laws regarding that topic aren't clear to him).
I put a diner point on defining slavery. "Slavery" here is a euphemism for bad conditions, unwanted attention, loss of rights. They are still out in public and complaining. Slaves are prisoners and cannot move about. The, are fed and kept by owners/overseers/legal system; families are separated, or subjected to capricious logic & changing events.
this is wonderful, thank you
Criticizing the Royal Family is not a crime in Britain, it's a national pastime.
It is interesting (but not surprising) that no one mentions the elephant in the room.
The USA?
You mean Putler?
Dear Russians - No, insulting the Royalty of the UK is not a Crime.
Happens all the time... plenty dont like the Royals.
Personally I'd like King Charles to retire and the Monarchy be dissolved and the UK become a Constitutional Republic
No one persucutes anyone for such views, and I can shout insults about the king in the street all day long and no one would care. I'd only potentially be arrested for being a nuisance and disturbing the peace of others.
Not well informed: Emirates - there is slavery. There are agents who will bring Indians there as factory workers. Sometimes, they work and money does ot arrive. They have no say in the worker`s rights. They can be chased at any time. They are subject to law which is not their country, their language, they are only entitles to holiday, if it is decided so. So , Emirate the worst of all examples.
Then why do any Indians go there? Hey, I like Indians. My dentist came to America from India. Nice guy and good dentist.
They are not academic. Have you been to india@@JoeZorzin
I agree with your outrage regarding the UAE. However, please note that the countries named are worthy comments given in their category, where the concept of slavery in the modern state at issue is reflected in this way. Japan is an example of such an Asian island state, Singapore is as a dwarf state, the Emirates (I bet the leader in commitment to an objective assessment of the degree of freedom) is a Middle Eastern state, and Norway is an example of a European state. Taking into account Vladislav’s opinion about the similarity of everyday life of Russia and the United States (in the original the statement has exactly this meaning), apart from Canada, I personally did not add a single other state of America to this list. Let me note that this is just my observation, and if this discussion diverges from this guy’s opinion, I apologize in advance. Thank you for reading
well, I guess every country has its slaves. Austria eg has refugees from Afganistan doing the most difficult jobs. Besides, if they enter these industries of the "least wanted" jobs, they might get a visum to stay longer. If not, they would be expelled. ....@@user-mf3uy5mx2r
Yes! " DIANA& ALINA", it's very tricky in Russia now. Keep your head down ,your eyes and ears open, and watch for the time of change. When it comes, embrace it with your mind and heart.
I do like the diversity…a construction worker who has a better handle on things than a PHD student, or other videos where 70 year olds are aware they live in an authoritarian state, but teenagers are enthusiastic supporters of Putin….
- you shouldn't be surprised. Academics nowadays, especially those from the so-called social sciences, are not seldom exceptionally deluded.
Russia did have a form of involuntary servitude in its history. It was called serfdom.
Don't forget the Soviet gulag.
slavery and serfdom had little in common. The serf had the right to have a family, property, farm and livestock. He had the right to work half the time for himself and not for the feudal lord.
@@maestro6458
Just like in RuZZia today!
Only 30% of the population were serfs. The north of Russia, the Urals, Siberia did not have serfdom. The entire population of Europe during feudalism also did not have legal protection from their feudal lord.
@@BearPivepex29
Does your whataboutism change anything?
Muscovy was an EMPIRE ruled by a DICtator--basically they were ALL serfs of one kind or another!---And still are!
An entire society weaponizing.
If they can't admit Ru struck first, are they slaves or is it conscience ignorance?
The concept of bringing all Ru soldiers home to solve the war would be the dividing line for me.
Dallas, Texas 🌻
The question is utterly ignorant. "Slaves" are not "citizens of a non-democratic regimes". Slaves didn't have rights or freedoms, they could be sold, even apart from their families, their civil rights were broken, they couldn't have any property. Unfortunately, there's still illegal slavery in the world, but most of the world is not democratic, so it is laughable to compare slavery and authoritarian regimes.
@@georgiy7882 first you must realize that there are different levels of slavery as opposed to what you have been taught from the movie: Roots.
It's not just a noun, it's a verb. I would say protesting Ru's have had their civil rights trampled on. Gulags are making a comeback.
@@EdjieboaNova you're taking "freedom" to an absolute impossible level. What happened to the protesters who burst into Capitol? And, unlike Russia, USA is considered to be a democratic country. Nobody is absolutely free while we live in society, order will prevail over chaos.
А как насчёт того, чтобы забрать всех воюющих американских солдат домой, раб?😂
@@EdjieboaNovaВсе верно. ГУЛАГ возвращается. Но вы промахнулись с адресом. Он возвращается не в Россию, а к вам
Are you guys able to even ask about Navalny now? What do people think of him disappearing?
Он сидит по уголовной статье. Его адвокаты периодически рассказывают о том, как он сидит. А Запад это максимально раздувает. При этом вас совершенно не интересует, что там с Ассанжем, почему преследуют Сноудена и т.д. Фигура Навального изрядно раздута за границей. В России о нем вспоминают не часто
Patriarch Kirill said that they have freedom like nowhere else, so they do not believe in slavery. They probably killed Navalny, and the MP convicted of discrediting the army is kept in prison without access to medical help.
@@user-ee9dl2yq1e You are not up to date. Navalny has disappeared. No one has had contact with him for weeks. The prison says he is no longer an inmate, nothing more.
@@user-ee9dl2yq1eпочему ты считаешь что их не интересует что происходит Ассанджем и Сноуденом?
@@user-ee9dl2yq1e Мы уже знаем, что о нем нечасто упоминают, как в советские времена павших иерархов просто вычеркивали из газет. Но остается вопрос: где он сейчас? Он был задержан российским государством, а теперь российское государство не знает, где он?
Офигеть. 33 года, 37 лет. Люди выглядят на 50 минимум!
Также хотел сказать. После 20-и лет все уже становятся пенсионерами.
насчет возраста могли соврать. челик которому 37 явно на 37 не тянет
They need to tell the trainee doctor the UK is a constitutional monarchy and the RF work for us we are no longer an absolute monarchy
Hey Daniil! when are you coming to the 🇬🇧? I would love to see some reaction videos there
As a young man I also thought that humankind can only develop to the better. Being older now, I have a broader view on life and history. And history tells us, that there were times when life was better and there were times, when life was worse than before. Circumstances were very different, but hunger, bad harvests, war, pandemics, political turmoil, climate change: all these factors led to deterioration of lifes. Civilizations developed and died. And in current times we have a lot of circumstances, that led to the downfall of civilizations in former times, climate change in the first place, political tensions and wars in the second.
There's big question, imo.
Slavery in big meaning - most of us under slavery. Because of money, for example. Slavery in different countries... Somewhere it's harder, somewhere lighter. This is not good to shame people, who lives in situation when group of government guys rules whole country live. Where if you disagree with government on public - you will have a big problems and your family and friends maybe too. It's scary... 😢
It's like shaming North Korean people or people in Afghanistan. Yes, somebody can support government from heart, but not all people. And it can be difficult task to find and calculate real statistic.
If you're not willing to stand up for your freedom, you're probably not worthy of it.
@@patrickclaessen8114 fight for "freedom" is question about strategy. If you and your comrades are weaker than your opponents - you already lost the battle and it will be selfbeating to do something like that. 😔
@@lafej7439 Yep, that's true.
But let's assume very broadly that there is 1 Putler, 1000 oligarchs, 10 000 government leaders, 100 000 siloviki, 1 000 000 helpers and another 10 000 000 pro-government forces (police, Omon and soldiers) = 11 111 001. For a population of, let's say, +/- 121,111,001 (for easy calculation), not including the fallen and runaways, there are still approximately 110,000,000 slav(e)s left.
Of course the chain is only as weak as its weakest link, and an erzatz country may have mainly weak links.
Still, the truth is probably more like that one put it, and it's more of a feudal system. Of course, slave or serf what's in a word? 🤔
I suppose you shall not call "slavery" anything you like. If you're not free in some way, it doesn't mean you're a slave. I's meaningless to use such terms - it is just unclear what you imply.
When discussing slavery in Russia, remember that asking such a question today on video in Kyiv would be simply impossible and life-threatening.
When talking about slavery in Russia, remember that until now its borders have never been closed, unlike Ukraine.
When talking about slavery in Russia, remember that Russia supplies its economy and army with its own resources or with partners, and does not crawl on its knees begging for a batch of 30 decommissioned tanks.
In Uk, believe me, "insulting royalty", is a satiric genre. Look up the work of Gillray, or Rowlandson of the late eighteenth century, or read Private Eye. There is no such crime here. Many people are republicans, but regardless of attitude to the monarchy, in this culture, a robust and ancient tradition of satire - making fun - of the royals continues to blossom. I don't think the quasi-monarchical autocrat Putin would tolerate such activities in Russia.
I wonder what people would say in REALLY rural Russia.
For example in the 'stan regions, where a disproportionately high number of conscripts come from.
Ого, это же в Таганроге? Круто было бы познакомиться с автором
Russia a democracy? Of course! People have always a choice. They can either elect Putin, Vladimir, or Vladimirovich as their tsar. Already Dimitri Peskov, the speaker of the Kremlin stated in the last summer, presidential elections in Russia are only a waste of time and money, when everybody knows, the current tsar will be the next tsar. Peskov disappeard for this statement for three weeks. After, he couldn't excuse enough for his words.
And after that there was a huge surprise for the public recently when Putler announced he was running for President. Nobody expected that )
@@alexeyigonen3170 better him than Zelensky-like, who brought his country to hell. Literally.
@@user-ct1zo2ri2c victim-blaming. Do it with your folks, if you have any
The majority of Russians vote for Putin in the elections, this is the choice of the people
@@user-ct1zo2ri2chow is that better? You think Russia is better now that it was 10 years ago?
It seems that most of them missed the point behind your question. Being forced to fight against your will is not slavery? Being shot by your own army for refusing to fight is not slavery? Being treated like meat to rot in the ground in Ukraine is not slavery?
shot?
They can't retreat or they get shot by their own side.@@Xo4y_HeXo4y
Then many countries have slavery during wartime.
@@Xo4y_HeXo4yor whatever the MSM tells him.
are ukrainians who are forced to fight also slaves?
5:51 "But it's probably like that everywhere"
No, Sirgay, not everywhere, believe me.
This is an interesting question about slavery because there seems to be clear definition of what had happened widespread in certain places in which folks were dominated by owed debts, sexual dominance, or legal measures in a society that widely accepts devaluing some human beings as less than others, and may even be considered like property. People in prison might be taken advantage or, I think, if they are forced to participate in dehumanizing behaviors, but jailers can be sued for inhumane treatment. From what I read about China under Mao Zedong, people could be forced to do things against their will.
Insulting royalty is a crime in Thailand, not UK. You can insult any royalty or leaders in Europe and USA.
To Vasilij; as a Brit I can tell you for certain insulting our royalty is certainly not a crime. It happens with regular frequency - ask Prince Harry and his 1st wife who would have nothing to do if they desisted in doing so.
Unlike criticising Putin for example, where those people are poisoned, shot or fall out of windows - with alarming frequency.
in Russia they do anything but shoot
Funny. I've been criticizing Putin for years on social media and I'm still well and haven't been poisoned or imprisoned once despite being born and raised and living in Russia. Seems like CIA puppet problem to me.😊
If Vasilij were to become a future doctor he needs to first heal himself. I prescribe a reading of Gulag Archipelago by Solzhenitsyn. Learn how much of Russias infrastructure was built by slaves and how this system is used to create modern day cannon fodder.
Thanks for the quote at the end!
That saves me time with this comment.
Our civilization is what we make of it together, for better or for worse.
And all things come to an end.
✌
The more education, the more brainwashed.
Russian average salaries haven't gon up if taking in account inflation last 12 years. For some groups it has so others it has gone down. If keeping people busy surviving but not starving they don't have time protesting. That is why it's mostly in Moscow and St.P. there is some opposition but hardly non in regions. So keeping salaries low so people cannot afford not protest or move is a modern form of slavery. That form exists in many countries.
Russians should watch 'The Windsors"....if somebody did in Russia "The Putins" (in the same funny style) nobody will be able to see it and the all actors,writters, producers and directors would be pushed to jump from windows or would die from too strong "English" Tea.
К рабству приводит невежество.
Пропаганда ведет к невежеству
@@maladjustedmalcontent1532Так она у всех.Сегодня я смотрел австрийского офицера,кто сказал более менее правду про контранаступ, так многие иностранцы были в приятном удивление, что хоть кто- то из НАТО говорит правду.
К рабству приводит террор, давление и отсутствие возможностей к противостоянию. 🤔
Люди могут многое понимать и своё печальное положение тоже, то есть не быть невежественными, однако всё равно находиться в рабстве. Не потому, что хотят, а потому, что их "захватили". Если альтернатив нет, то приходится адаптироваться.
Рассматриваемый как диссидент может быть мучительным опытом, отмеченным маргинализацией, изоляцией, преследованием и даже угрозами насилия. Вы оказываетесь отлучены от общества, ваша репутация испорчена, а безопасность поставлена под угрозу.
_Маргинализация и изоляция_
Как диссидент вас часто отлучают от ваших бывших кругов, включая друзей, семью, коллег и даже ваше собственное сообщество. Вас могут игнорировать, игнорировать или даже оскорблять словесно, поскольку теперь вы считаетесь врагом государства. Эта изоляция может быть глубоко травмирующей и эмоционально разрушительной, поскольку она оставляет вас одиноким и не поддержанным.
_Преследование и угрозы_
Как диссидент вы также можете столкнуться с преследованием и угрозами со стороны властей, сторонников правительства или даже организованных групп. За вами могут следить, ваш дом или workplace могут быть целями, и вы можете получать угрозы убийством или другие формы запугивания. Это может создать атмосферу страха и паранойи, что затрудняет вам вести нормальную жизнь.
В крайних случаях диссидентов могут даже физически нападать или задерживать без суда. Эти действия могут отправить леденящий душу сигнал другим потенциальным критикам, препятствуя им высказываться против правительства.
Российское правительство имеет долгую историю подавления инакомыслия, и падшие диссиденты часто рассматриваются как законная игра для преследования и злоупотребления. Это может иметь охлаждающий эффект на свободу слова и политическую активность, поскольку люди боятся высказываться из-за страха возмездия.
@@maladjustedmalcontent1532 прям как на этом канале
Daniil Orain- I believe Sirgay is spelt Sergei in English
I think for slavery you need to actualy lose most of your human rights. Actual slaves for sure cannot vote, cannot own real estate or even any property, receive no compensation, are given food and shelter directly so they can stay alive and working, and have no legal protection against violence by their masters.
Slavery is a really harsh term and should not be diluted I think.
Russians beeing force-conscripted to fight and die in the war while partially not receiving any money and having no way to refuse without beeing imprisoned .... and beeing shot by their own people when retreating or refusing to fight ... now that is actually coming really really close to actual slavery. These Russian soldiers arguably are forced by violence and have no human rights anymore.
I think you meant Ukranians.
@@devansa125 Even if that were true, it is still a big difference if you are trying to defend your country from an invasion that sends missiles into your capital and schoolbuildings.
@@DevineAbyss Those schools are being occupied by the AFU forces.There are no children in those schools.So it is a legitimate target to hit.Distant learning is s common thing in slmost all schools in Ukraine except Kiev and western Ukraine.Just compare Jewish and Russian bombings.Russians are very careful at target hitting.
@@devansa125 Oh yes like the hospitals with pregnant women in Mariupol and the shopping centers with lots of civilians.... very careful. Sure. That is why ruzzians are so beloved by Ukrainians.
@@devansa125 Nice try, Russian bot. Russia has destroyed 3790 educational facilities since February 2022. And most of them are in far back towns without Ukranian military personel. Why would Russian soldiers be stationed in a school hundreds of kilometers from the front line?
And yes, Russia is very specific with their target hitting. I am sure they kidnapped 70.000 Ukranian children because they thought of them as Ukranian soldiers and took them as prisoners of war ... out of orphanages....
Sorry, but Russia's actions in this war are way WAY too horrible for any nitpicking to work. It is just that extreme and horrible.
11:32 when the blind is claiming nobody sees as much as her.. incredible
Hi from Paris. Anyone who says protests are not allowed in France obviously has never visited. 😂 We even have a daily or weekly ‘protest forecast,’ like for the weather, so that taxis and others no which neighbourhood to avoid for the day.
1:08 stalker pda sound? was that edited or did he change his notification sound to that lmao.
“I’ll never work your butt, but I’ll kick it for free!” Frederick Douglass
I guess the "future doctor" isn't familiar with the Sex Pistols lol.
Over the last videos, Daniil is not showing on screen, is everything fine ? (We certainly hope so)
It is not a crime in the UK to insult the royal family, people do it all the time. They just risk upsetting people who royalist.
Slavery doesn't have to be violent 🤷🏻
And laws aren't there to force you to do something you don't want to do, laws are there to protect victims or punish criminals.
It depends on how one defines the word 'slavery'.
@@stlouisix3 "A slave is an individual held in forced servitude", slavery is defined as: "the state of being a slave". Not to hard.
Something you do not want to do is absolutely dumb definition. In this case there is parental slavery in any mobile device. :-D Slavery is well defined term and means posession one human of another. With all that property rights enforced by state. But there is not a single country in the world where slavery is legal.
In Russia there are only laws to protect Don Putler and his gang. They are not victims but criminals. If there were laws according to your statement, they would all be in jail already.
Russian freedom is a special state of mind. I once told a Russian that they don't have freedom like we do. He asked me for proof. So I said I could call my king a fool without consequences. His answer was that Russians can do that too. We can also call your king a fool without any repercussions. 🤣😂😅
Life in usa is same as in russia. A good one...
It's even more similar than you might think
@@egribanov You only wish so. Keep living in lies.
@@egribanov Anyone whose name ends in "ibanov" might well lack any accurate knowledge of "life in the USA." Or at least you just proved your ignorance by that statement. We don't have forced conscription at all, much less one that would send half a million of our men to die for a thorough evil cause.
@@Comm.DavidPorteri hope everywhere would be the same
@@Comm.DavidPorterbut i agree with the previous guy
Sir Gay, the construction worker, that was a good one.
Why does a 37 year old man look like he is 50?
I wonder, how many Russians are aware of the origin of the word slavery. Not "rabstvo" (рабство), slavery.
The best slaves were ukranians. The turks turned those child slaves as fierce warriors..
Демократическое государство😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Анекдот
Along with others, I have to add that insulting royals in UK is not a crime, but what has not been said is that in Russia insulting the president is now a crime. I don't recall the text of the exact law but it was introduced about 3-4 years ago and applies to others in authority too.
An elderly woman had a sign on a snowman that read---"FOR PEACE"--she got a visit from the FSB.
@@WangAiHuaone person got taken away for holding up a blank piece of paper, vid on UA-cam
@@Phoenix-ov5gg
Yes! Disgusting--isn't it!
Freedom in any country is determined by the length of the leash.
Didn't pootin say he wanted those young girls breeding, is that not slavery??
Min 2:16
False - Insulting the monarchy in the UK is not a crime.
National sport more like.
Please do get it straight. Believe it or no, we like to think that Russians are smart and that they are snobby for a reason.
That guy has never watched a Frankie Boyle DVD
🤔🤔🤔
Everyone in England is free to cuss out the king as much as he or she wants LOL
ideological slavery is muchs harder to organise as a consept ,then slavery that is structured around forced labour .Still both can have very similar effect on the inviduals experiencing them and they meny times simultiouslinly gross each other meaning.
Hard life in ruzzia, everyone looks +20 years older than they are 👵🧓
Hi, I just want to add not everyone))) Have a nice day)
Мне максимально противно от того что выкладывается на этот канал.
Я многое не поддерживаю в моей стране, много с чем не согласна. Но когда я выезжаю заграницу я всегда с теплотой говорю о России и людях которые тут живут.
Политика это грязная и неприятная вещь, она ссорит , разъединяет народы, семьи. Но есть вещи, которые объединяют всех людей, делает всех равными, и нет разницы в национальности, вере, культуре.
Но этот канал транслирует политическую повестку и это максимально мерзко и отвратительно, я никогда не пойму, как можно преследуя свои личные цели так подставлять людей.
Особенно нравится когда интервью берется у людей, которые даже не знают что такое UA-cam и их ответы оценивает ЦА UA-cam, вы же осознаете, что это максимально не логично?
Пока мы были в Париже, нам очень много взрослых и пожилых французов говорили о том, что они поддерживают Россию, вы понимаете как тут бы из-за этого порвало местных комментаторов?
Not many Europeans support Russia on this. Maybe those who don't follow what's going on? There's ofcourse some ppl still believing in Russian propaganda also around the world, I bet a lot of them are Russians.
Адекватный комментарий
Если это вопрос, тогда ответ - нет.@@maxajax9181
@@leoniferr почему?
0:50 in functional democracies the people can change the government that they're paying taxes to if it doesn't meet their demands