f(x) has always been a trendsetter alongside with Shinee in all aspects, such as music genres, outfits, and everything. Sad to see that f(x) is nowhere to be found already.
“My name is Sulli, 'sul' means snow and 'li' means pear flower. So I might be reborn as a small flower but full of vigor” -Sulli- Rest in Peace...Sulli
I never listened to F(x) nor knew Sulli but the thought of what the world did to her is depressing. If anyone sees my message pls remember what I say. The world will always try to pull you down when you are at your best, don’t care of what people say, don’t let someone else become the next Sulli..
이때 한창 레벨 탄력받고 밀어줘야할 시기였는데 뭐 어쩌라고; 에펙이랑 레벨이 동 세대에 나왔는데 레벨만 밀어준거면 당연히 잘못된거지만 다른 기획사들도 다 3세대로 세대교체 하고 있는 상황에서 레벨을 주력으로 미는건 당연한거 아니야? 너같은 애가 감정에 휩쓸려서 에프엑스ㅜㅜ 이러고 있는거랑 대형 기획사가 회사 미래 달려있는 사업에 어마어마한 돈 투자하고 이성적으로 실행하는거랑 비교좀 해봐라
2016: when is f(x) comeback? SM: ..nope 2017: ehem, f(x) comeback? SM: ..uhuh no 2018: ..f(x)? SM: Too many comebacks 2019: weve been waiting for 4 years now.. wheres the goods? SM:
F(x) is really the only girl group in kpop whose constantly pushing the boundaries with their sound with each comeback. Just like shinee, fx's comebacks are always creative, unique and showcase their vocals and talent every single time. I feel bad for the kpop fans who don't know about fx
Well, if they don't know about f(x) then clearly they don't know that much about kpop in general, and that's a pitty... but for them, not for us, while we enjoy f(x)'s music and shows and we laugh hard with them, they don't. Don't feel bad, they're the ones who should be crying right now xDDD.
Merywaja sadly there are new fans who claim themselves to be kpop fans when they're only really third generation boy group stans. that in itself isn't much of a problem, but when combined with their ignorance in other groups other than the popular ones and the ones that do comebacks often is just sad.
Iluvthings Well, it's sad, but we started like that too, a decade ago i just knew the new ones, the popular ones BEG, SJ, GG, and i didn't know about H.O.T, S.E.S., etc, there weren't so many kpop fans so there was nobody outside Korea saying something like that, kpop wasn't so big and there weren't so many groups, yeah, but we do started like them too xD (facts are facts xD). And i think we have to accept that new kpop fans can be kpopers without knowing all the groups (that's going to be hard... ), they SHOULD know the old popular ones at least (specially if they want to have fun not because they have to know them to call themselves something, kpop is not a university degree or a subject yet (but it would be cool (*v*)) it's entertainment and if you like a few kpop groups, well, you like kpop, congrats! You're a kpoper now!), but if you think about it, there are a lot of groups! XD a new stan has to know this generation and other 3 more! I don't expect that a... What? 13 years old girl? (Yeah, they could be older, but the majority of those you mentioned are teenagers) Is going to be so focused on kpop beyond her new favourite group or the few groups that made her go into kpop, i think we even have to thank if they know all the ones who are making comebacks now xD. Maybe with time, they will want to know more about other generations (let's have faith xD), and there are groups that never become popular so it's difficult to remember them even for me, so knowing all the groups is quite difficult, but even knowing the old popular ones isn't an easy thing for a new stan. And remember that there is going to be a generation/s (1 or 2) that you're going to like the most (in my case the 2nd and the 3rd one). So let's not going to be so hard with them. And think that a lot of kpop fans are going to be young, inmature, ignorants and/or arrogants (really i meant it when i said "let's not be hard with them" xDD i ..just... Shut up! I need to explain something!! I have an excuse! XD) so don't be upset, and just let them be, (and don't waste your time "fighting", it's not worthy and you're not going to convince them), yeah, like you said it's sad, but let's have fun and enjoy by ourselves, if they want to join let's open them the doors and welcome them, if they don't want to join to the dark side where the best cookies are, well, that's their problem, let's not let that affect us... more cookies for us!! \(ÒvÓ)/
Guys lets cry together. Amber said in the podcast of Eric Nam, that they are not disbanded and will work on something. She also said that every member is down for producing music qwq
이 노래 저도 좋아해요. Fx는 한국과 Kpop에서 가장 뛰어난 걸그룹 1위입니다. 정말로 Fx는 전설이었습니다. Sm 엔터테이먼트가 놓친 인재이고 fx의 대표 노래들은 다 뛰어나고 너무 좋습니다. Fx가 예전 걸그룹이기도 하고 당신이 외국인인데도 이 노래와 fx를 알아본다니 당신은 정말 휼륭한 감각과 시각을 지녔습니다. Fx와 4 walls를 좋아해주셔서 감사합니다! 민희진이 프로듀싱한 최근 걸그룹은 newjeans지만 newjeans는 감히 fx의 발끝도 못 따라갑니다. 비주얼, 분위기, 노래, 미적 감각, 소속사 등 모든 면에서요.
this is probably the best comeback from SM groups in the past 2 years. the mv is very aesthetic and FINALLY a song that doesn't sound like a billion songs mixed together. very pleasing for the eyes and the ears.
2024 I still listen to this song. It was actually 9 years ago but only now do they remember it the most. We only remember it when it can't come back damn it
I think the got their fair share in promotions last year considering individual activities! Cause Victoria completely stopped her Chinese activities for this comeback! In my opinion tho!
They do! They are one of the only few possible kpop groups to break into US markets. They have so much potential. I can already imagine even luna having a successful solo when I think about it. The fact that they gained so much attention without being promoted properly shows a lot. Really.
+Sam .B compare to most kpop groups that are NOT under sm , yes maybe. But compare their promotion to groups under sm , no.They got their first concert after 7 years , that alone speaks how they don''t get enough push.
GRETAX VV f(x) definitely has my attention for the pass 3 years with them 😘😩💕💕and yes! I hope to see them on the billboard or mama awards soon! And I’m hoping they have their comeback very soon!! I miss them so much!!
Well, that's true! I'm from the "new wave" of kpopers, and I really like old and new groups (like f(x)and 2ne1) but I have some friends that say they are experts with KPop and they don't even know about the "before generation". I wish they knowed ;_;
Amber and my bias Luna leave sm my bias vic stuck in china and my bias krystal won't be an idol anymore im sorry yall must get over. We have red velvet get a help and move on
I think I finally figured this Mv out it took me a while (*few years). (don’t judge me 😭) 1st Wall: Love is confusing (the entire Mv) 2nd Wall: Love can break (The tea cup Amber dropped) 3rd Wall: Love can hurt (Luna stepping on the broken Tea cup and Victoria falling) 4th Wall: Love can be suffocating (Krystal, Luna And Victoria in the water/Bathtub)
I always thought that it was “since love is four walls, it can’t have support without each other”. Since the music video kinda shows a butterfly effect. Amber dropped the cup, which causes Krystal to pour tea on the floor, which causes Victoria to slip, which causes Luna to step on the broken shards of the tea cup too.
fx가 edm을 활용을 많이했는데 이곡은 진짜 퓨처하우스가 나온지 1~2년밖에 안된 상황에서 거의 국내 최초로 퓨처하우스를 선보였죠... 이때까지만 해도 실험정신의 장르라 제대로 정돈되지도 않았던 장르였는데.. 국내에서 이정도 퀄리티 곡이 나온것도 그땐 놀라웠고 (특히 한국 edm pop은 장르 세분화가 안된 짬뽕 트랙이 많았음) 이 이후로 엠버랑 루나도 dj들이랑 활동한것도 몇곡있고... 조금만더 계약 했으면 어땠을까 생각이 듭니다.. 요약- 한국에서 초라한 edm장르를 어느정도 인지도를 올려준 그룹 진짜 클럽음악이 아닌 대중음악으로 선보일수 있다는 가능성을 열어줌
Letícia de Lioncourt Typically the middle child gets neglected the most, and ignored. Depends on your parents though, in this case, SM is a terrible parent.
kpop’s trendsetters - f(x) it sucks to be a fan after your disbandment. you’re the most unique k-pop group i’ve stumbled upon, from the concept to the music. the members have great visuals and talents. how did sm waste these girls without feeling regretful?
i don’t think sm wasted them, i think they were just unlucky. victoria was stuck in china because of politics conflict with korea and then luna solo debut wasnt reallt successful and they just couldn’t come back together because they were so busy
@@edenpffen that was in 2016. how about the 7 years before that? f(x) was mistreated their whole career. 6 albums in 10 years, no lightstick, their fandom name was provided and their first and only concert tour commenced after their last comeback which is roughly seven years after their debut.
Luna said that the song she wanted to make as a title track for this comeback is not on this album. so that means f(x) got another song and we have no idea bout it. so stay tuned.
f(x) is one of the most iconic groups that SM has ever produced yet received little recognition. Every each of the members are in all honesty, individually talented. They really lived up to their group name. f(x) where the X factor can be replaced with anything. f(actresses), f(singers), f(producers) and not to mention, f(visuals)
I like how 4 walls introduced in k-pop industry a new style of music that is currently explored by many new k-pop groups.
f(x) has always been a trendsetter alongside with Shinee in all aspects, such as music genres, outfits, and everything. Sad to see that f(x) is nowhere to be found already.
@@ALMINHO "nowhere to be found" cause they disbanded...
Sylvaine not yet , but it’s look like it’s gonna happen really soon,with almost all the members leaving SM and this freaking 5 years hiatus
@@doyouknowwatermelon9407 Yes, not officially, but since Amber and Luna's contracts were not renewed... It implies that there will be no more music
Sylvaine Victoria leave SM?
This song single-handedly birthed a whole new era of house music in kpop
i agree-
literally
This and View introduced a new genre to a whole country. F(x) and SHINee are really sibling groups. MeU fighting!!
@@yeetusdeletus2563 True! That song was also *chefs kiss*.
Agree
진짜 스엠만 모르는 스엠 최고의 작품
쌉인정..... 진짜 래전드지 이건
알면 이렇게 안하지ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
와 아이돌 뮤비에서 한글댓글 이라니 감격스러워
에버포 아 진짜 이 노래 한번만 다시 해줘 진짜 fx 싫어하는 사람은 없던데 제발여
Wtf
민희진,에프엑스 조합이 아직도 나한텐 최고야 ㅠ....
Which the reason why Newjeans is very successful
I can’t believe this mv is 5 years ago but they all look so trendy
f(x) really a trendsetter
A little throwback just because can't get over this song while it is 2020 already..hahha
yes they are.
Yeah 😊
it's already 2021 but still this song is so...
They were ahead from their time
에프엑스 그리워하고 인정해주는 사람들이 많아서 너무 좋다 .. 미유는 이름 생기고 에프엑스가 불러주는 걸 몇번 듣지도 못함
Q
그니까요 ,,
그니까요 ,,
이름만 틱 내주고...진자 화남
제 2의 전성기가 시작된 4walls가 마지막 일줄은 몰랐음 .. 단콘도 데뷔 10년동안 딱 한 번 해주고 .. 슴빠인 나에게는 여러모로 아픈 손가락 같은 존재임 .. 함수니들은 ㅜㅜ
COME SM, WE NEED AN F(X) COMEBACK!
AGREED!
^
IN DECEMBER THEY WILL
lWhiteboy0908 l WHAT REALLY!?
Bluepingie Luna is having a comeback in December :)
지금 나와도 초대박날듯ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 하나도 안촌스럽고 너무 이쁘다 다들...
초대박까진 아니고 .. 잔잔바리로 꾸준한수익은 낼 수 있음 뭣보다 멤버들이 물의를 빚은 게 없고 깨끗함 스엠아 전멤버 계약해지해줘서 너무 고맙다 나 맘놓고 에프엑스 응원한다 컨셉을 잘잡았다고 생각함 나이들어서도 뼈아작나지 않을 안무 무대조성 가능
@@minaroh9377 다필요없고 다시 무대위에 서는거보고싶은데 40대되기전에 봤으면ㅠㅠ
It would
수정아 탈스엠 축하해 사실 스엠에서 솔로로 활동하는 크리스탈도 보고싶었는데 너가 가고싶은 길을 더 응원할래💜💜
몽환적이면서 세련된 노래.. 역대급 유행안타는.. 지금 나와도 위화감 없는 노래ㅠㅠ 내기준 칠감이랑 4walls는 들을때마다 명곡임...
ㅇㅈㅇㅈㅇㅈㅇㅈ
YG messed up 2ne1
JYP messed up missA
And SM messed up f(x)😭😭😭
I'm hoping
YG will not be messed up blackpink
Jyp will not be messed up twice
SM will not be messed up red velvet
@@nishu3978 YG already messed up blackpink:(
@@modelstatus3456 yeah still a hope
Jyp succeeded with twice
But Yg with blackpink? I jus have to laugh
@@nishu3978 Yeah same
우연히 차안에서 라디오로 들었는데, 진짜 최근에 나온 곡인줄 알았어요. 곡 코드가 랑 비트 깔리는게 되게 트랜디하네요. 8년전 노래라고 믿기지가 않네요
Repeat with me:
*COMEBACK!* *COMEBACK!*
*COMEBACK!* *COMEBACK*
*COMEBACK!* *COMEBACK!*
Listen to Nct - comeback
Tiara Ko *this is for f(x)*
Beyonce
lets pray for this sis!!!
COMEBACK!
“My name is Sulli, 'sul' means snow and 'li' means pear flower. So I might be reborn as a small flower but full of vigor”
-Sulli-
Rest in Peace...Sulli
😭
_STOP MAKING ME SADDER THAN I ALREADY AM!_
Lost_ illusion :(
Tung Dao clout chaser
I never listened to F(x) nor knew Sulli but the thought of what the world did to her is depressing.
If anyone sees my message pls remember what I say. The world will always try to pull you down when you are at your best, don’t care of what people say, don’t let someone else become the next Sulli..
This would have been a really big hit in the west if this was released now. Especially in the UK, we listen to this type of music a lot
it just shows that f(x) is ahead of its time
@@kurisurin4001 yh true
yes because the guys who made the song us from UK they sellnthe demo to SM ent. search for it
Thank lord there’s some UK buddies around here
Solar Station. not from uk tho but yes f(x) is so much ahead of its time
F(x) were really ahead of their time😭
레벨한테쓴 뮤비제작비 반이라고 써주지... 진짜 간단하게 찍었는데 멤버들 분위기가 다함 진짜 fx그립다 새로운 시작인줄 알았는데 시작이자 마지막이였네ㅠ
그래도 5년전껀데 에스파보다 나은듯ㅋㅋㅋ
그냥 에펙은 에펙이고 레벨은 레벨인거지 댓글이랑 답글 피해의식 자격지심 안타깝다ㅋㅋ
이때 한창 레벨 탄력받고 밀어줘야할 시기였는데 뭐 어쩌라고; 에펙이랑 레벨이 동 세대에 나왔는데 레벨만 밀어준거면 당연히 잘못된거지만 다른 기획사들도 다 3세대로 세대교체 하고 있는 상황에서 레벨을 주력으로 미는건 당연한거 아니야? 너같은 애가 감정에 휩쓸려서 에프엑스ㅜㅜ 이러고 있는거랑 대형 기획사가 회사 미래 달려있는 사업에 어마어마한 돈 투자하고 이성적으로 실행하는거랑 비교좀 해봐라
@you tube 얘는 열등에 사로잡혀서 레벨을 쳐패노ㅋ 즈그언니들 공중분해 파괴되고 한명은중국으로 튀어서 쳐돌아버렸나 보네 어떻게 아이들이랑 1군 레벨이랑 비교를 하냐 아이린있는 그룹 꼴보기 싫은데 이때싶 후려치는 열폭러들은 더 꼴보기 싫네
@you tube ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 저기요 레벨이랑 에펙 둘 다 좋아하는 사람인데 에스엠에서 일을 그따구로 한골 레벨 탓으로 돌리면 안되죠 메인 멤버인 설리 탈퇴하면서 망한건데
i'm crying i miss them sooo much, SM WE NEED COMEBACK
comeback with suli all 5 members
@@lanyaazad9184 sulli already debuted as soloist. I don't think sm is going to realize that Fx isn't the same without her
Same, I sometimes come back to their old music and t really makes me miss this group
If you didn’t you should check out amber’s UA-cam channel
Well...
5년이 된 지금 꾸준히 회자되고있는 모두가기다리는 그룹
언제나기다릴게 기다리는거 잘하는거알잖아
기다리는거 잘한다는게 너무..슬프다ㅜ
ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ다들 소속사가 달라져서ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 점점 희미해지고 있는것 같아서 정말 슬프네요
이게 8년전 노래라는게 진짜 안믿긴다 지금들어도 너무 세련된 노래.. 뮤비 느낌도 짱임.. 어케 이게 8년전???
2016: when is f(x) comeback?
SM: ..nope
2017: ehem, f(x) comeback?
SM: ..uhuh no
2018: ..f(x)?
SM: Too many comebacks
2019: weve been waiting for 4 years now.. wheres the goods?
SM:
This hurts man
I miss them 😢damn sm just love hurting us
@@rh9197 maybe SM let fx comeback this year. Keep positive
But i still miss fx so bad
it’s been three years
@@kitzacrush2862 🙏🏻
*f(x), We miss you so much*
THE MOST AESTHETIC SONG I'VE EVER KNOWN
Ikr
Gooooo 50M please st
Fact.
Got this stuck in my head for a while. It’s so catchy
If you want aesthetic songs and mvs, check out "Karma" mv by Demian.
この曲ほんと何年経っても色褪せないな…当時も聴いてたけど今聴いても全く古臭く感じない不思議…
the most aesthetic music video in kpop history
fact!! But you must check loona butterfly mv too
Top 4 most aesthetic mv in kpop for me after loona butterfly and jinsoul singing in the rain, Choerry love cherry, Kim lip eclipse
@@fairyfloss2614 i am going to comment this
@@peachysehun6531 YAS ODD EYE CIRCLE
You should see gwsn mvs they are aesthetic too hehe
Dear SM
*WE*
WANT
A
*COMEBACK*
*CAN NOT* *UNDERSTAND????!*
더이상 f(x)를 보지 못한다는 걸 알면서도 이 노래를 들을 때마다 너무 그립고 지금 당장이라도 활동할 것만 같아서 슬프다... 4walls정말 너무 세련된 곡이라 아무리 들어도 안 질리고 당장 오늘 나온 노래라 해도믿을 수 있음
ㅇㅈㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ...
😢
처음으로 빨았건 걸그룹이얐는데
라차타 츄 누예삐오 첫사랑니 다 깨쩌는데
you don’t understand how badly i need songs like this to be a trend in kpop
theres gwsn :>
no thank you
@@sa0ko434 okay… idgaf if you don’t want it
@@kr1spyfish ok... what are you gonna do?
@@sa0ko434 side eyeeeeeeeeee
F(x) is really the only girl group in kpop whose constantly pushing the boundaries with their sound with each comeback. Just like shinee, fx's comebacks are always creative, unique and showcase their vocals and talent every single time. I feel bad for the kpop fans who don't know about fx
Well, if they don't know about f(x) then clearly they don't know that much about kpop in general, and that's a pitty... but for them, not for us, while we enjoy f(x)'s music and shows and we laugh hard with them, they don't. Don't feel bad, they're the ones who should be crying right now xDDD.
Merywaja
sadly there are new fans who claim themselves to be kpop fans when they're only really third generation boy group stans. that in itself isn't much of a problem, but when combined with their ignorance in other groups other than the popular ones and the ones that do comebacks often is just sad.
Iluvthings Well, it's sad, but we started like that too, a decade ago i just knew the new ones, the popular ones BEG, SJ, GG, and i didn't know about H.O.T, S.E.S., etc, there weren't so many kpop fans so there was nobody outside Korea saying something like that, kpop wasn't so big and there weren't so many groups, yeah, but we do started like them too xD (facts are facts xD). And i think we have to accept that new kpop fans can be kpopers without knowing all the groups (that's going to be hard... ), they SHOULD know the old popular ones at least (specially if they want to have fun not because they have to know them to call themselves something, kpop is not a university degree or a subject yet (but it would be cool (*v*)) it's entertainment and if you like a few kpop groups, well, you like kpop, congrats! You're a kpoper now!), but if you think about it, there are a lot of groups! XD a new stan has to know this generation and other 3 more! I don't expect that a... What? 13 years old girl? (Yeah, they could be older, but the majority of those you mentioned are teenagers) Is going to be so focused on kpop beyond her new favourite group or the few groups that made her go into kpop, i think we even have to thank if they know all the ones who are making comebacks now xD. Maybe with time, they will want to know more about other generations (let's have faith xD), and there are groups that never become popular so it's difficult to remember them even for me, so knowing all the groups is quite difficult, but even knowing the old popular ones isn't an easy thing for a new stan.
And remember that there is going to be a generation/s (1 or 2) that you're going to like the most (in my case the 2nd and the 3rd one). So let's not going to be so hard with them.
And think that a lot of kpop fans are going to be young, inmature, ignorants and/or arrogants (really i meant it when i said "let's not be hard with them" xDD i ..just... Shut up! I need to explain something!! I have an excuse! XD) so don't be upset, and just let them be, (and don't waste your time "fighting", it's not worthy and you're not going to convince them), yeah, like you said it's sad, but let's have fun and enjoy by ourselves, if they want to join let's open them the doors and welcome them, if they don't want to join to the dark side where the best cookies are, well, that's their problem, let's not let that affect us... more cookies for us!! \(ÒvÓ)/
LMAO ya'll talking smack about this generation not knowing older bands? You ever even heard of 1TYM or Baby VOX?
KeiRo Multiverse it's funny you brought up baby vox, I was legit just listening to them on spotify lol
Guys lets cry together. Amber said in the podcast of Eric Nam, that they are not disbanded and will work on something. She also said that every member is down for producing music qwq
i'm so happy to see someone today watched the mv
WAIT REALLY where can i find that?
@@annika9998 In the poscast episode with eric nam which was recently released
Even Krystal was down to work on music?
It won't be the same without Sulli😭
THIS the kind of music you blast when cooking up breakfast before a beautiful day :D
+Woojong bruh i see u everywhere
+Woojong i love your vids btw
+andreina ramirez Thanks, friend ^^
+Woojong I wish you would upload more often though.
+Sophia Nguyen Someday - I promise to do so.
kpopの中で1番好きな曲です。4wallsのステージ衣装はどれもシンプルなのに上品かつ存在感もあって大好きです。pinktapeも大好きなアルバムですが、この曲の耽美で独特な雰囲気はf(x)にしか出せません。もう8年前になることが信じられないです。今日も彼女たちに思いを馳せながら聴いています。
이 노래 저도 좋아해요. Fx는 한국과 Kpop에서 가장 뛰어난 걸그룹 1위입니다. 정말로 Fx는 전설이었습니다. Sm 엔터테이먼트가 놓친 인재이고 fx의 대표 노래들은 다 뛰어나고 너무 좋습니다. Fx가 예전 걸그룹이기도 하고 당신이 외국인인데도 이 노래와 fx를 알아본다니 당신은 정말 휼륭한 감각과 시각을 지녔습니다. Fx와 4 walls를 좋아해주셔서 감사합니다! 민희진이 프로듀싱한 최근 걸그룹은 newjeans지만 newjeans는 감히 fx의 발끝도 못 따라갑니다. 비주얼, 분위기, 노래, 미적 감각, 소속사 등 모든 면에서요.
it's 2021 still fx's 4 walls is visually pleasing, sweet and melodious to ears
so true bestie!
re-listened to the album now after quite some time and this is just so true. queens.
Trueeee
Is this their latest mv?
@@abbyjones3645 this is their latest official comeback but you can check out 'All Mine' but it's not a comeback its just a SM Station
I CANT WAIT FOR THAT F(X) COMEBACK
luhan's nipples i see your name everywhere
luhan's nipples me too😢
Chloe Lee he/she really kpopers *lol
Me too but your name is everywhere. UR FAMOUSSSOSJDGDSKE
Whats your username?
생각해보면 이 뮤비에 춤추는 장면은 단 하나도 나오지 않음 오로지 스토리로만 풀어낸 게 대단함
숲으로 전환되면서 화면 비율 달라지는것도 너무 섬세하고 좋음...
설리 내놔라
@@라따이-c2e 웬 설리...?
@@너에겐내가있잖아 설리님 탈퇴하신후 4명이서 나온 노래예요.. 지금은..돌아가셨자나요..
@@구-m4d 아는데요...? 뮤비 얘기 하고 있는데 갑자기 설리 내놔라 이러니까 웬 설리 이런 거예요
민희진 기자회견 보다가 함수니들 보러왓다... 그땐 이래될 줄 몰랏겟지.. 뭔가 그리운 시절
😢😢😢😢😢
this is probably the best comeback from SM groups in the past 2 years.
the mv is very aesthetic and FINALLY a song that doesn't sound like a billion songs mixed together.
very pleasing for the eyes and the ears.
I agree ♡ !!!
true
true af
I think this definitely ties with shinee's odd for me in terms of SM's best in the past 2 years
+Ben Clarke oh yeah that mv is pretty amazing but I didn't have that big of an impression as this.
내일 나온다고 해도 믿어주겠어 영원히 사랑해
use me as “f(x) needs a comeback” button
ok
It wouldn't be the same without sulli
·Jinverse· only one thing,i miss ot5
@@yunjins0124 yeah :(
well amber and luna didn't renew their contracts so. i don't think F(x) is coming back.
2024 I still listen to this song. It was actually 9 years ago but only now do they remember it the most. We only remember it when it can't come back damn it
함께했던 시간보다 기다린 시간이 더 길어서 그런지 함수 생각만 해도 마음이 아프다 이해할 수 없을 정도의 방치였지만 남은 기억들이 너무 좋아 떠나가지 못하는 팬들을 보면 스엠에게도 f(x)은 아픈 손가락이 아닐까
I really cant understand why SM wont promote f(x) properly, seriously they have a big potential as a group.
They don't care about f(x) as much😭
I think the got their fair share in promotions last year considering individual activities! Cause Victoria completely stopped her Chinese activities for this comeback! In my opinion tho!
They do! They are one of the only few possible kpop groups to break into US markets. They have so much potential. I can already imagine even luna having a successful solo when I think about it. The fact that they gained so much attention without being promoted properly shows a lot. Really.
+IceCrepeGG Sone they're promoted very well compared to most kpop groups...
+Sam .B compare to most kpop groups that are NOT under sm , yes maybe. But compare their promotion to groups under sm , no.They got their first concert after 7 years , that alone speaks how they don''t get enough push.
5년 전 노래인데 이렇게 세련되었었다고?..... 그때도 즐겨 들었지만 지금도 좋네
IS:SUEがカバーしたのをきっかけにこの曲を知り、MVを拝見しました。本当に神秘的で美しいMVでめちゃくちゃ感動してます…｡この曲が出た当時はK-POP自体全然知らなかったから、もっと早くに出会えたら良かったなぁ😢
*COMMENTS*
98% is that THEY NEED A COMEBACK
2% This song is really good
both true
f(x) deserves more attention
please support Luna's comeback this December!
GRETAX VV f(x) definitely has my attention for the pass 3 years with them 😘😩💕💕and yes! I hope to see them on the billboard or mama awards soon! And I’m hoping they have their comeback very soon!! I miss them so much!!
actually they were so popular. Sm didnt treated them right.
Amber's voice is so deep compared to other girl rappers in kpop groups, i love her so much
DONT SLEEP ON MOONBYUL GIRL
ilove her tho
f(x)の存在は知ってたけど、詳しく見てなかったから最近見始めたけど、とんでもなく良すぎてビックリしてる。
これが8年前の映像だとは本当に思えない
4 walls
4 years without f(x)
Yuna K.A shut up
.... Actually 3 Years
@@natlus_ its gonna be 4 years in october so they arent wrong
maybe they waited until its 4 years to have a comeback lol xd
@@mileycyrus201198 yeah maybe that's why they named the song 4 walls so there gonna comeback this October
I'm here after hearing Krystal to leave SM. I'm happy for her cause she deserve better. But SM, how can you treat your artist so bad?
iam always here..
@@moonlightbae7015 me too
when you bite the hand that feeds you...tsk tsk tsk
@@maynunal shut up lmao. SM has been giving f(x) the bare minimum for so many years. It only makes sense that krystal wants to leave
@@maynunal pretty sure you are referring to sm biting(mistreating) krystal who feeds them rite?
에프엑스는 뭔가 향수 같아
이미지도 그리고 그리워
After 8 years, this mv still amazed me. No other girl groups can perform like F(x)'s unique concept.
im begging for a comeback
glitter jin me too!!!! Their music is so awesome I love it but it’s so sad that you don’t hear anything from them anymore 😢
Next year is f(x) 10 year's anniversary..i hope they renew the contract and making a comeback..please sm
haizzul zzul I hope they can find a better agency rather than renewing the contract.
:O so true, i hope f(x) comeback in 2019
@@bubbles1209 no one wants to sign flop groups
Aeshiryzen Aeschirett f(x) are not a flop group. They might not be as big as SNSD, but they were still bigger than a lot of other ggs
even after 3 years this song is still refreshing and never gets old, one f(x) have a comeback they will shake the kpop industry
단순히 뮤비만 좋았던게 아니라 앨범자체가 평단에서도 극찬 받았음
I can't believe they predicted the next popular kpop genre 2 years in advance
Gobbikins sm is always their time ahead
fx did that! their minds 😍😍😍
Trend setters
Disclosure did this style 3 years before.
@@heg1098 disclosure is not kpop
함수에서의 엠버 역할이 진짜 컸던 것 같다... 밸런스가 딱 맞춰지고 그래서 더 좋은 곡이 나왔을 수 있었던 것 같음
ㅇㅈ
영어가 편하다고 빼지 않고 연습 열심히 해서 포월즈에서 한국어 랩하는데도 딕션 좋아서 가사가 엄청 귀에 잘 들어옴…
4walls 엠버 랩 진짜 미침 앤 아 헤드 디 앤설... 할 때 진짜 심장이 확 조이는 기분
낫 디 앤설임
amber's rap got me in a way that I can't explain
you'll never have ma swag can i like this comment a million times
Amber is a girl realy
Especially her first line! Sounds so unique!
a bop is still a bop
say word
Blinks: No comeback for whole year? This must be a joke
MeU’s: *first time?*
🥺 I really Miss them
And until now I'm still hoping for their comeback
Ronalyn Botabara same here😭😭😭
fx aint coming back no more
at least f(x) has an actual full length album instead of 6 2.0s and some bsides skskkssk
After School: ...
it's been 7years ago, and still love this beautiful song
Yahh😭❤️
yeah...miss them sooo much. esp amber ssi :)
yesss 😭
I miss sulli rip
i miss them so much
Love is 4 walls 😢
이때 너무 그립다…함수만의 감성이 너무 좋음 노래도 에프엑스 최대 명곡
There is a new wave of Kpop fans who don't even know who they are... THIS IS SAD... PLEASE COME BACK.
KpopNiDontStop omg I just discovered them and I’m in LOVE. Ugh I wish I knew them earlier
That’s so sad lmao easily the best group smh
I think I'm parte of this new wave and I can tell you that you are exaggerating.
Well, that's true! I'm from the "new wave" of kpopers, and I really like old and new groups (like f(x)and 2ne1) but I have some friends that say they are experts with KPop and they don't even know about the "before generation". I wish they knowed ;_;
True I love this song💕😍
Didn't realize I was holding my breath the whole time until the song stopped omg that's how beautiful this was.
me tooooooo~
f(x) slaying their fans.....literally
sameee
OH MY GOSH me too i swear i was just idk not breathing either they are so good
same here .I especially at the end !I 😮
I remember from somewhere that 4 walls was for SHINee and f(x) was for View
??? WHAT?
@@RGDancer Yes, I just heard
it was supposed to happen like that, but i am glad it didn't😂😂
it has the same vibe tbh
@@coldcole why?
IS:SUEがカバーしてるのを聴いてこの曲を知りました！今見ても素敵な曲・衣装・メイク・MVで本当にすごい
It's 2022 and I'm still here jamming to this song
Trust me, fx's 4 walls is THAT masterpiece, it never ages.
BC
I completely agree with you. Music that never gets old
SAME PLS
Preach it. FX = Life. I can never get enough.
YESSSSSSSS
dear SM, what's the point of giving them gold discography if you don't promote them
shining flowers true
Deserves to be on top comment
LOUDER
literally the most talented people... wasted
Damn yes please say it louder for the people at the back
It's been 4 years years years years.
And we didn't have a comeback, comeback.
It's been 4 years years years years
SM we want comeback, comeback.
@@Elxosonia it was just sarcasm dear, I know all of that
I need your remix, is hilarious ahddhdjdhd
I want a song from this!
I CAN HEAR THIS HAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Amber and my bias Luna leave sm my bias vic stuck in china and my bias krystal won't be an idol anymore im sorry yall must get over. We have red velvet get a help and move on
와 이게 어떻게 8년전 노래야 비트 미쳤네 ㄷㄷㄷ
딥하우스 퓨처하우스는 아직도 현역으로 인기 많은 국밥 장르...
그런 종류 노래추천 좀 부탁
웬만한 아이돌노래들 전부 하우스 느낌이 가미돼있음
SM.
LISTEN.
F(X) NEEDS THAT COMEBACK.
LIKE WYD SM
They are not marketable anymore. SM ain't investing on damaged goods.
@@aeshiryzenaeschirett5415 it's a vicious cycle
@@aeshiryzenaeschirett5415 F(x) is always the best !!!!
I think I finally figured this Mv out it took me a while (*few years). (don’t judge me 😭)
1st Wall: Love is confusing (the entire Mv)
2nd Wall: Love can break (The tea cup Amber dropped)
3rd Wall: Love can hurt (Luna stepping on the broken Tea cup and Victoria falling)
4th Wall: Love can be suffocating (Krystal, Luna And Victoria in the water/Bathtub)
Wait... What if her catching the cup at the end meant that she was trying to save the relationship?
WE NEED THE COMEBACK NOW
I would recommend kpop junkee for best explanation...thnks
I always thought that it was “since love is four walls, it can’t have support without each other”. Since the music video kinda shows a butterfly effect. Amber dropped the cup, which causes Krystal to pour tea on the floor, which causes Victoria to slip, which causes Luna to step on the broken shards of the tea cup too.
I think that the falling teacup represents falling in love
what a great vocal, honestly, SM should invest more in these girls
umm...you forgot amber
Volga Senpai ??
+jimin trash She means you forgot the rapper which Amber is.
jimin trash yeah amber has a different style of rapping. She should get more credit...
Volga Senpai I'm sure she didn't mean to insult her, she just took Amber in the vocal group.
누군가 그랬다. 스엠 최고의 작품. ...하지만 ... 잊혀진 명곡.
쉽게 이야기해서 fx 는 앞으로도 절대로
나올수없을만큼 유니크하고 대단했던 그룹이었음
아이돌로 치부할수없을만큼 곡 하나하나가
해체한지 수년이 지난 지금까지 되새김질하면
할수로 미쳤다고밖에 볼수없습니다
개인적으로 국내음악계에서 전무후무했던
그룹이었다고 생각합니다
공감+인정합니다
목소리도 예뻤어요.
(f)x가 지닌 특유의 분위기도 빠질 수 없습니다
Fx 가 aesthetic을 만들어낸 장본인 이라 생각함 ㅇㅇ
텀블러 감성을 케이팝 장르에 대중화 시킨건 2015년 ~ 케이팝임 갓 민희진
@@Alwayslovepurely 민희진이 아무리 뉴진스를 잘 키워도 fx와 결합된 그 감성 아무도 못 이김ㅠㅠ 핑크테이프 감성 누가 해도 못 따라간다ㅠ
Imagine f(x) still active till now, they might conquer all the award shows
amber confirmed that the group did not disband, they’re still together and always will be, as she said; don’t spread false rumors. period
Thanks best
hope they make an album without SM. But i guess most of them are busy hopefully in the future we can get one
True
R.I.P Sulli 😭 Sending my deepest condolences to all her families and friends
R.I.P 💔 sulli :‹
推しグループがカバーしてて原曲聴きにきました！
本当に好きです…
Love is 4 walls, walls, walls, walls...💔
Love 4 walls
이거진짜 이번주에 컴백해도 전혀 손색이없다.. 이게 4년전 퀄이라니... 노래부터 뮤비 다 완벽...
thank you amber and thank you f(x) ❤️
거의 10년전에 2스텝개러지-딥하우스를 한국 아이돌판에 들고와서 이런 사운드를 냈다는게 진짜 개쩐다
에스엠만 몰라....함수들이 에스엠 분위기 제일 잘 살리는 그룹이었다는 거...아니 지들이 만들어 놓고 왜 그걸 모르지
함수...ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ그냥 갑자기 빵 터졌네...
꽃이 지고 나서야 봄인줄 알았습니다.... 이제야 진가 파악한 내자신 저기서 손들고 서있어....
에프엑스 샤이니때가 딱 민희진 아트디렉터 임기였어서 그런듯..
@@쁫 민희진 작품 크리스탈 솔로 못본게 진짜 아쉬울뿐 ....
fx가 edm을 활용을 많이했는데 이곡은 진짜 퓨처하우스가 나온지 1~2년밖에 안된 상황에서 거의 국내 최초로 퓨처하우스를 선보였죠... 이때까지만 해도 실험정신의 장르라 제대로 정돈되지도 않았던 장르였는데.. 국내에서 이정도 퀄리티 곡이 나온것도 그땐 놀라웠고
(특히 한국 edm pop은 장르 세분화가 안된 짬뽕 트랙이 많았음)
이 이후로 엠버랑 루나도 dj들이랑 활동한것도 몇곡있고... 조금만더 계약 했으면 어땠을까 생각이 듭니다..
요약- 한국에서 초라한 edm장르를 어느정도 인지도를 올려준 그룹 진짜 클럽음악이 아닌 대중음악으로 선보일수 있다는 가능성을 열어줌
WE WANT A COMEBACK!!!!
Eduardo Rios everybody wants fx comeback cause I know I do
(In order of debut) Girls' Generation > f(x) > Red Velvet.
f(x) is the middle child. It suddenly all makes sense.
Agrippina Volturi Whitlock I didn't get it...
Letícia de Lioncourt Typically the middle child gets neglected the most, and ignored. Depends on your parents though, in this case, SM is a terrible parent.
safa_alpaca_ I get it now, and it really does make all sense '-'
You forgot S.E.S, The Grace and other SM's girls groups.
Li Alexandra is the biggest fan of old K-Pop era
Don't forget MILK, Blackbeat and other boy groups and girl groups
真的好喜歡這首，已經過了好幾年依然想到就會回來聽，f(x) 全部的主打歌裡面，4 Walls 在我心中是排第一 ❤❤
I heard this song on the radio in my country in the H&M. Thats really special lol. I live in The Netherlands so.. FIGHTING
Kim LuNa I live in The Netherlands :) Where do you live?
Kim LuNa Omg! Ik zeg liever niet precies waar ik woon maar ik woon vlakbij Rotterdam ^^ Jij?
Kim LuNa Leeuk, ben je al lang fan van Kpop?
Kim LuNa Woah ahaha ik ongeveer anderhalve jaar ofso
+Kim Ngo dit nummer afgespeeld in nederland??
has that chill feel good vibe and I love the aesthetics. amber ftw! :)
that horse outa nowhere aha
steven :) love your kpop vids >.< and love this song!
great reaction! new subbie
Steven ,love your vids jsjsjsjs 💕 i didn't expected to see you in the comments XD
Im still waiting for a comeback lol
this song is legendary... i will never forgive sm for what they did to f(x), this girls deserved so much better
@Sarajimin Chimin they stop promoting them, no comeback etc.
THE AESTHETICS OF THIS MV. I miss themmm
kpop’s trendsetters - f(x)
it sucks to be a fan after your disbandment. you’re the most unique k-pop group i’ve stumbled upon, from the concept to the music. the members have great visuals and talents. how did sm waste these girls without feeling regretful?
i don’t think sm wasted them, i think they were just unlucky. victoria was stuck in china because of politics conflict with korea and then luna solo debut wasnt reallt successful and they just couldn’t come back together because they were so busy
@@edenpffen that was in 2016. how about the 7 years before that? f(x) was mistreated their whole career. 6 albums in 10 years, no lightstick, their fandom name was provided and their first and only concert tour commenced after their last comeback which is roughly seven years after their debut.
@@kpopenthusiast2180 true
Because they didn't drink SM water. 😌
@@brodslucky8597 haven’t heard of luna, eh?
Luna said that the song she wanted to make as a title track for this comeback is not on this album. so that means f(x) got another song and we have no idea bout it. so stay tuned.
***** no idea. Hope so
+CCX SONE I HOPE SO
***** never mind. Its okay
+Are Gee Gee Yeah Amber wrote a song, but is saving it for a later album.
Dinah Graham cant wait for the next next year
뮤비 보다가 예술작품이라고 느낀건 첨인듯 민희진과 에펙의 조합은 다시나올수 없는 조합... 애초에 에프엑스는 두번다시 돌판에 나올 수 없는 조합임
Hiiii
@@signingoffbye hiiiii
ㅇㄱㄹㅇ
동의함 솔직히 스엠이 에프엑스 제대로 서포트했으면 지금은 배로 포텐 터졌을거임 그때도 인기 많았지만 중요한건 몇년이 지나서 들어도 좋은노래가 에프엑스는 너무 많음 그리고 컨셉도 독보적이라고 생각함 너무 아까운 그룹인데 스엠만 몰랐네
@@thebiguncutone el
아 에프엑스 다시 보고싶다ㅜㅜㅜ이번 슴콘때 꼭 나와줬으면…수정언니 보고싶어요
*My favorite FX title track!!*
+SΔL-V [MAKNAE] same. It was worth the wait
+Elena Rodriguez Is it just me or have the views not gone up at all this hour?
+Jaz Miah Its probably broken lol too many fans watching, it will fix itself eventually
+Sonef(x)StarlightPopGirl Lol, well as long as they're not lost views :)
+SΔL-V [MAKNAE] ua-cam.com/video/Ek6Monh4qIM/v-deo.html Please watch my new video!
f(x) is one of the most iconic groups that SM has ever produced yet received little recognition. Every each of the members are in all honesty, individually talented. They really lived up to their group name. f(x) where the X factor can be replaced with anything. f(actresses), f(singers), f(producers) and not to mention, f(visuals)
pink tapes and 4 walls cemented them as icons but yet sm paid more attention to snsd.
Priorities messed up 💔
@chaosjelly106 people are also criticizing sm for not propelling red velvet to be on the same global level as blackpink and twice.
I literally get anxious when I think of how long it's been since we've seen them together
I just want new music from them. I miss seeing them together. ;_;
Me too. Watching Luna & Amber perform this song at SMT Dubai made me feel really sad. Hope there's comeback in 2018.
What happened to them? Im new.
Mido Mido Midori x
Mido Mido Midori - 11
와 진짜 봐도봐도 명곡이자 명작이자 그리운 그룹