Is Tool - You Lied As Good As You Guys Said It Was?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 195

  • @poloreacts27
    @poloreacts27  Рік тому +42

    What's good Tool Army 🌀I just want to say thanks for watching my crazy reactions! If you enjoy what I do on this channel consider supporting me. 70% of my videos are not monetized. Between setting up the studio daily, filming, editing, thumbnails, and research which all take away from my family, you guys motivate me to put out content daily. Consider buying me a coffee here www.buymeacoffee.com/poloreacts or my Patreon www.patreon.com/poloreacts PEACE!!

    • @munkeeBraynStoo
      @munkeeBraynStoo Рік тому +2

      Milk by Jimmie's Chicken Shack. Milk them chickens and pluck them cows!!!

    • @munkeeBraynStoo
      @munkeeBraynStoo Рік тому +1

      When You Die You're Dead by Jimmie's Chicken Shack. It's a banger and so full of truth in every line. The last line is the title, but I have to add,.. but you're NOT!!!, cos only the body dies. Spirit is eternal

    • @tylerhaas611
      @tylerhaas611 Рік тому +1

      Dont know if your community has tried to get you into karnivool yet but i think youd like them if u like tool id suggest "goliath" "new day" "we are" to start. I love the channel just started watchin the past few weeks, hopefully they make the 4runner they have great production

    • @munkeeBraynStoo
      @munkeeBraynStoo Рік тому

      @@tylerhaas611 Wheel is pretty awesome, too

    • @harperlewis1526
      @harperlewis1526 Рік тому

      Sounds like AmenRa with Colin doing clean vocals

  • @chriswaitzman5356
    @chriswaitzman5356 Рік тому +59

    With so many youtubers jumping on the Tool band wagon these days it nice to see someone who actually appreciates the music... I've been a member of the Tool army since the 90's and I can tell you're a real one. Keep it up dude.

    • @hawks7775
      @hawks7775 Рік тому +7

      check out
      skulz reacts tool
      he had great Tool reactions and analysis

    • @ftboomer1
      @ftboomer1 Рік тому +4

      ​@@MidwestFarmToys I love the pot. Mostly the reason is I hate lawyers and the pot sounds like it is directed towards those lowlifes.

    • @chrono050
      @chrono050 Рік тому

      Tool fans will watch anyone react to songs by tool same with Deftones and Slipknot you add all three of them together and you got a successful reaction channel... It's redic

    • @Pigwig83
      @Pigwig83 Рік тому +1

      @@hawks7775 Yeah man his reactions are excellent

    • @studentaccount345
      @studentaccount345 Місяць тому

      Replace "Tool army" with "a fan of Tool," and your comment will be far less cringe inducing. You're not the only one... but c'mon 😅

  • @sixzty1524
    @sixzty1524 Рік тому +37

    Been watching your reactions for almost a year now, your genuine interest in tool, music, and your appreciation for art kept me coming, keep going 🔥🔥

  • @spiderslim
    @spiderslim Рік тому +64

    So this is a cover by Peach, an Aussie (I think) band, they opened for Tool supporting Undertow. Long story short.... Justin was the Bassist for Peach, and Paul wanted more control over the band (Unverified, but probs true) Paul was out, Justin was asked to audition, and now Tool is one of the most legendary bands of all time!!

    • @ethosfm1262
      @ethosfm1262 Рік тому +15

      They're English.

    • @Gideonite
      @Gideonite Рік тому +4

      I was going to say both Justin and Peach are from London England. 😅 Fact check much?

    • @Andrew46_2
      @Andrew46_2 Рік тому +4

      This is a Cover of a Peach song by tool. Although Justin Chancellor left Peach to become Tools new bassist. But you got it 1/3 right. Justin Chancellor is in fact British.

    • @thomastaylor9579
      @thomastaylor9579 Рік тому +3

      well said my friend...............tool army est. 1993...........

    • @stephenmorelli6741
      @stephenmorelli6741 Рік тому

      ThI beginning is basically descending

  • @jimmanes4681
    @jimmanes4681 3 місяці тому

    Best concert I've ever seen... Seeing them live you get to feel that bass go right through you , sound quality second to none

  • @5piral0ut
    @5piral0ut Рік тому +11

    I always feel the bass on this song gives it a Sabbath vibe

  • @isaiahgarens5674
    @isaiahgarens5674 Рік тому +20

    The whole Salival album is WELL worth a full listen. You will not be disappointed if you're a Tool fan. Enjoy this trip my friend!

  • @tonyliang8099
    @tonyliang8099 2 місяці тому

    Like a choir haunting vibe and the band punches it just right throughout the song. A masterpiece.

  • @4177895
    @4177895 Рік тому +12

    Their cover of zeppelins "no quarter" is also amazing

  • @grntbggr126
    @grntbggr126 Рік тому +24

    Yes, it's as good as we say it is.

  • @tonyliang8099
    @tonyliang8099 2 місяці тому

    One of the best. Got that opera atmosphere, prolly the only one in their entire catalog. Maybe wings for Marie part 1 and 2. A real gem

  • @jasontaboada6855
    @jasontaboada6855 Рік тому +13

    I love the interplay of the guitar work by Adam Jones and Buzz Osborne (from The Melvins).

    • @halfalligator6518
      @halfalligator6518 Рік тому +3

      Buzz is a legend. Big Melvins fan here.

    • @pabloscobar958
      @pabloscobar958 Рік тому +1

      I thought buzz was in this, love when hes involved with AnYtHiNg

  • @chrisclements4676
    @chrisclements4676 9 місяців тому

    First of all….it’s great to see a brotha appreciating good music!! I was introduced to Tool in 2007, while stationed in Germany. I hate that I was late to the scene but, I’m thankful nonetheless. “You Lied”…..that’s just a hard ass tune! Just when you think it’s over…..Maynard CRUSHES the ending with that hyper-extended yell…..”You Lied”!!!!!! Awe man!! Salute to Tool for the gems…..salute to you Polo for the recognition👍🏾👍🏾

  • @VandalJace
    @VandalJace Рік тому +3

    Maynard sounds like he's doing Gregorian chants in this song. So epic.

  • @boomshakalaka8457
    @boomshakalaka8457 Рік тому +5

    Wow I forgot about this song. That riff!!

  • @markwillis675
    @markwillis675 Рік тому +2

    The first time I saw Tool live, "The Melvins" opened.

  • @Jeezusehchrist
    @Jeezusehchrist Рік тому +1

    One of my all time fave’s. You liiiiiiiiiiiiieeeeeeeddddd. YOU LLLLLLLLLLIIIIIIIIIIIEEEEEEEEDDDDDD
    \m/

  • @nicholasreilly9755
    @nicholasreilly9755 Рік тому +5

    Hey Polo love your Channel. Don't forget about some good old tool undertow or their first album opiate

  • @chriswebb7822
    @chriswebb7822 Рік тому +2

    This is LIVE, cannot forget that...Crazy good!

  • @randyman1331
    @randyman1331 Рік тому +3

    For some reason I always get a Christmas feel from Maynards singing on this one.

  • @pabloscobar958
    @pabloscobar958 Рік тому +3

    UNDERTOW COMING SOON LOVE THAT ALBUM :DDDD

  • @daveeyde9622
    @daveeyde9622 Рік тому +1

    Amazing video as always Polo. Great choice. I too had forgotten about this song. Thanks for bringing it back to the front

  • @sharileighretsof4790
    @sharileighretsof4790 Рік тому

    How many times can I watch this on repeat? Well, infinite! ❤ love this reaction. Love this song. Love this band. ❤❤❤

  • @dominicfergie
    @dominicfergie Рік тому +4

    Best.Band.Ever. I stand firm behind that.

  • @mfreshwhite3092
    @mfreshwhite3092 Рік тому

    Ok, the out scene...FIRE! That's why I subd. Tool is in a category by themselves.

  • @shannons1331
    @shannons1331 Рік тому +9

    Can't believe I've been listening to Tool for 30 years and never heard this song! Badass!! Still haven't reacted to my fav off Undertow...Intolerance!

    • @garrettmarshall1288
      @garrettmarshall1288 Рік тому +1

      Yes that’s my fav off undertow. It’s A-MAY-zing!

    • @marcreed4031
      @marcreed4031 Рік тому +1

      intolerance is insane!

    • @garrettmarshall1288
      @garrettmarshall1288 Рік тому +1

      @@marcreed4031 I think it’s the song that was most like a precursor of what was to come on future albums; if that makes sense. It’s the most like their later songs.

    • @eggstu
      @eggstu Рік тому

      You should force yourself to listen to the Salival album then. You probably missed Merkaba as well, it's primarily a instrumental song with some lyrics but just a typical Tool musical experience like no other band does

    • @chrisnichter9895
      @chrisnichter9895 Рік тому

      ​​@@eggstuool broke out merkaba when I saw them in 2019. Epic night

  • @pabloscobar958
    @pabloscobar958 Рік тому +3

    The bass tone is glorious! This a song by the band their bass player was in before joining for aenima!

  • @bigdaddypiggy
    @bigdaddypiggy Рік тому +1

    It’s really cool to be able to watch someone come to the same realization I did about this band decades ago 😉🖤🥶y’all be safe

  • @joecreekmore6218
    @joecreekmore6218 Рік тому

    I like your fair and balanced disposition and general love of music. Cross culturally music units us and I live your personal takes on your reaction videos. Keep up the good work.

  • @SC-g-cox
    @SC-g-cox Рік тому +10

    Yes, Buzz helping Adam on this song of greatness.
    I mean live and no mistakes I hear. Led Zep used 2 b my fav, but now Tool is and their cover of Led's song No Quarter is amazing also. U spot on about Adam. He is not a ripper on solos, but they are precise, strong and stay within the song and so powerful.

    • @aaroncole3941
      @aaroncole3941 Рік тому +1

      Adam is next level on Fear Inoculum. Shockingly more advanced than all previous albums.

  • @disgustipated_462
    @disgustipated_462 Рік тому +1

    Getting closer and closer to the cries of the carrots.

  • @YUNGDEATHNOLIFE
    @YUNGDEATHNOLIFE Рік тому

    Such hauntingly beautiful vocals masked under the disgustingly hard riffs and droning melody. One of their best behind sober.

  • @alexl8065
    @alexl8065 Рік тому +4

    Let’s goooo! I’m ready for some tool!

  • @MsMtheory
    @MsMtheory Рік тому

    READS TITLE, hell ya it is...Proceeds to watch your video.

  • @kurtpiron838
    @kurtpiron838 Рік тому +2

    I love AJ’s guitar feedback! Each to their own. 👍🏼🇦🇺

  • @Supermann98
    @Supermann98 Рік тому +2

    Eulogy is next, I think that’s one of the last major songs you have to still get to, as well as Opiate^2

  • @markwillis675
    @markwillis675 Рік тому +6

    Not sure if you've done anything from the "Opiate" album. I've requested "Cold and ugly" several times.

    • @betweentheair
      @betweentheair Рік тому +1

      Buy the man a damn coffee

    • @paultullo3275
      @paultullo3275 Рік тому

      Oooohh, the guitar tone in the intro, one of the dirtiest and most beautiful things I’ve ever heard! 😍

  • @niveKOnBass
    @niveKOnBass Рік тому +1

    heres one a lot of people don't know about. there's a justin chancellor remix of Puscifer's Simultaneous. It's got less than 100k views, but i really like what he added to the original

  • @MrBrokoli99
    @MrBrokoli99 Рік тому +4

    Justin joining Tool....best thing since sliced bread.

  • @dan.j.boydzkreationz
    @dan.j.boydzkreationz Рік тому +2

    12th Century Gregorian Chant is Maynard's melody, invented by Monks

  • @DoomMuffens
    @DoomMuffens Рік тому +1

    This is my 25th+ time hearing it and i still get chills!

  • @tonyliang8099
    @tonyliang8099 2 місяці тому

    Very dark and godly piece.

  • @OMC-WILDCAT
    @OMC-WILDCAT Рік тому +3

    My favorite Maynard scream.

  • @ryancoke777
    @ryancoke777 Рік тому +1

    The original Peach version is fire as well

  • @thebgd6669
    @thebgd6669 Рік тому

    Wasn’t Buzz from the Melvins jamming jamming with them on this song from when they were touring at one point or just as a guest.. I believe I read this on the sleeve from when I bought the Album.

  • @hello-dh4hx
    @hello-dh4hx Рік тому

    You have got to see the video!!!!

  • @unowhavethebiggay1430
    @unowhavethebiggay1430 Рік тому

    Yours completely right about Adam as someone who does know about his guitar playing is on another level because of his intention with the note

  • @d1sp0s1t10n
    @d1sp0s1t10n Рік тому

    Great song. There is a more recent live version were Justin sings backup vocals. This one, I believe Buzz Osbourne from The Melvins played guitar with them as well. (if you havent check them out, you should. Anything from their album 'Houdini' )

  • @crystalscolza1663
    @crystalscolza1663 Рік тому +2

    Not on the top top top of my list. But there's something hypnotic about the way he sings this one.

  • @Sablemae76
    @Sablemae76 11 місяців тому

    It's a heavy lullaby

  • @thespookybuilding
    @thespookybuilding Рік тому

    I love this song. It also gives me some Black Sabbath vibes

  • @bobtaylor7192
    @bobtaylor7192 Рік тому

    I have loved tool since the eighties,badass band

  • @RunawayOcelot
    @RunawayOcelot Рік тому +1

    Countless Maynard screams throughout their discography. This is my fav, with H and Pushit close behind

  • @sergi0YT
    @sergi0YT 3 місяці тому

    this is an awesome pick! and you weren't lied to, this is as good as they guys said.

  • @chrismontaigne6288
    @chrismontaigne6288 6 місяців тому

    10:26 your take on his guitar is so fucking spot on its like you took the thoughts out of my head

  • @profoundpronoun4712
    @profoundpronoun4712 Рік тому

    ❤❤❤ I go back and forth on wether 10,000 days is my favorite album or Eanema…or Lateralus…ooh, or Undertow. I definitely get into an Undertow mood…Opiate is great for some old school Tool though. Salvia is a must listen though…

  • @79derik
    @79derik Рік тому +1

    Have you checked out another Maynard band Puscifer? Try The Humbling River

  • @snarkyguy2657
    @snarkyguy2657 Рік тому +3

    I'd be curious as to your thoughts on the original (it's available on UA-cam) & Tool's version it. Not necessarily as a reaction video (unless you want to), but just as a comment.

  • @garrettmarshall1288
    @garrettmarshall1288 Рік тому +2

    So that sound that you don’t find pleasing is called feedback. You are right about it generally being unpleasing to the ears. But a lot of 90’’s bands used feedback in their music as an artistic tool.(No pun intended) it’s can be used to convey a range of emotions but generally rage and is also used for ambience. Or to represent destruction. To set the tone. As well as cleanse the pallet as you you were saying. But mainly to make you feel uneasy.
    Nirvana is notorious for using feedback to convey pure rage. It’s quite a useful tool and sometimes fits the song/mood. If used right it can be a beautiful thing.

  • @Consider00
    @Consider00 Рік тому +3

    I stand by what I said.

  • @lontollison6771
    @lontollison6771 Рік тому

    Alright I might have 2re listen to ur reaction my blood sugar was low when I was listening 2this but I think I caught on @the end

  • @johncarpenter3751
    @johncarpenter3751 Рік тому +2

    I love tool they are one of my favorite bands. Adam was a huge influence on my guitar style and playing. I never could play fast like Dimebag from pantera. He’s my favorite guitar player but at some point we have to look in the mirror and admit we just don’t have big enough hands to do what Dime did. But we can do what Adam does and we need to be more like Chewie

  • @xTheToolx
    @xTheToolx Рік тому

    Cheers.

  • @brandonhinrichs4393
    @brandonhinrichs4393 Рік тому

    I always thought this sounded like an early A Perfect Circle song

  • @johnnalowell592
    @johnnalowell592 Рік тому

    Anyone know where to find Salival on streaming?

  • @soth1sol
    @soth1sol Рік тому

    "pushit (live)" reaction needed

  • @michaeldinsen7641
    @michaeldinsen7641 Рік тому +2

    Greatest live band in History

    • @soth1sol
      @soth1sol Рік тому

      greatest studio band in history, too

  • @Veritas-TheGoader
    @Veritas-TheGoader Рік тому

    Didn’t Justin come from the band Peach?

  • @BadNews501
    @BadNews501 Рік тому +4

    Yes. It's ugly and beautiful. And epic.

  • @patricialea4024
    @patricialea4024 Рік тому

    Tool and Primus have done a recent gig together, it's on here. :-) worth a watch

  • @dayna8409
    @dayna8409 Рік тому +7

    Watch the O'Keefe kids play Tools Forty six and two.

  • @seanlucas4674
    @seanlucas4674 Рік тому +2

    When Tool covers one of your songs...two things happen. 1. You should feel honored. 2. Your version isn't as good anymore lol

  • @ryaneverett6185
    @ryaneverett6185 Рік тому

    You have quite a lot to go my friend!

  • @davidbird461
    @davidbird461 Рік тому

    Always my answer to best cover song

  • @headsicknation1365
    @headsicknation1365 Рік тому +1

    Tool didn't write this song. The bassist Justin was in a band before TOOL called Peach and they wrote the song. Cool song.

  • @dichotomous9403
    @dichotomous9403 Рік тому

    Tool introduced me to Failure and Peach. If I hadn't already owed them my life for their own music, I definitely would have for their recommends.

  • @Santiago6553e
    @Santiago6553e Рік тому

    Now you’re my favorite UA-camr

  • @uncletaco916
    @uncletaco916 Рік тому +1

    Somehow at 42 years of age I never got to this one. I’m gonna hear it with you. 😎
    Edit: Um… while not identical I can’t unhear Descending out of this baseline. Yes this came first but I heard it after. Quite the opposite but the same as I can’t unhear Flood within Tempest main/initial riff.

  • @steventheurer6956
    @steventheurer6956 Рік тому

    Most of the Salival Album was live from a concert. There may be a song or two, like Harry Manback, that isn't but most of it for sure is.

  • @scottferry2625
    @scottferry2625 Рік тому

    Great react with ..YOU LIED!! The song is from a band called Peach, which was Justin's band before TOOL. KEEP UP THE GREAT REACTIONS!! 🔧🔧🪛🛠⚒️⛏️🪓🔨

  • @theresashadwell9060
    @theresashadwell9060 Рік тому

    Yes 😊

  • @johnjohn37371
    @johnjohn37371 Рік тому +1

    Nobody tell me that Buzz can't play, dammit...I love the fact they incorporated one of Justin's songs from his old band onto their live album...and it's a great fucking song...

  • @johncarpenter3751
    @johncarpenter3751 Рік тому +1

    You have All of Opiate to check out…. Most of Undertow… and a few good ones left in their later catalogs

  • @RunawayOcelot
    @RunawayOcelot Рік тому

    Wings for Marie please and thank you

  • @susansummers6891
    @susansummers6891 Рік тому

    The 90 where so great for rock and metal that's what this nation needs great bands like this even rappers are sick of posers all over when ur just not about that.. rock was like so tuff man I think most military love rock metal.. guy I know said they blasted it in iraq.

  • @spittinjustice
    @spittinjustice Рік тому

    When the next album drops you should react to one after the other from the beginning.

  • @umuligpipe
    @umuligpipe Рік тому

    Buzz Osborne from The Melvins also played on this track (it was recorded live with him as a guest). Check out "A History of Bad Men" by The Melvins. Good shit.

  • @betweentheair
    @betweentheair Рік тому

    Pretty sure they’re touring this fall.
    You going?

  • @TheArisar
    @TheArisar Рік тому

    Have you done Opiate?

  • @lateralus9244
    @lateralus9244 Рік тому

    Idk if you said this because I didn't have enough time to watch the whole reaction but, "You Lied" is actually a TOOL cover of Justin Chancellor's old band called PEACH.

  • @TheSgtFarmer
    @TheSgtFarmer Рік тому

    Intolernce is one to check out

  • @ted1976hailspiralout
    @ted1976hailspiralout Рік тому

    🤘🏻🌀

  • @davidbird461
    @davidbird461 Рік тому

    Sabbath and Zeppelin

  • @wr3add
    @wr3add 7 місяців тому

    Peach-You Lied

  • @vanilla_milkshake
    @vanilla_milkshake Рік тому

    this was played live! Its also a cover of a song by Justin's old band Peach (this was recorded a few years after he joined) They don't sound anything like Tool so I don't know if you'd like them.

  • @ty_the_RetoVideo_guy5543r
    @ty_the_RetoVideo_guy5543r Рік тому +6

    This entire album is live and is completely amazing, I stand by Push it live is the definitive version and somehow they did a better job on No Quarter than Zepp...and that is saying a lot

  • @tracishumaker498
    @tracishumaker498 Рік тому +1

  • @marcbeardsley9985
    @marcbeardsley9985 Рік тому

    Stank face 5:41!!!! 😮

  • @richardwilcox3643
    @richardwilcox3643 Рік тому

    tool is amazing obviously.
    Check out the original Peach version. It's pretty dope.

  • @ReflectionTool637
    @ReflectionTool637 Рік тому +1

    Yeah, like lots of Tool fans. I would be happy to hear another band that can surpass, but, at least for me, nothing has come close for 25+ years .....