honestly what makes me sad is that this is all in homura's mind, meaning she wished being a magical girl was something heartwarming and fairy tale-like and not so cruel as the incubators made it to be...
@Jefri Anata That's not the point, yes it's true kyubey used this as a trap to get the old system back, but this shows that homura just wants a good life, just like anyone else.
Nope Hitomi was actually invited into her labyrinth So this was the actual Hitomi People who were invited into the labyrinth and not conjured up by homura-Hitomi,Madokas Family,The teacher I'm not sure if that's everybody that was invited but it's less than 10 people for sure
Yeah... it's tragic enough how, even if Homura's wish for the others is purely a function of an idea of the world that Homura believes Madoka would accept and cherish and find fulfilling, it'd still be a nice enough place for them, the sort of cliche-ridden, complexity-averse power-of-friendship action-adventure story they knew to be impossible at the exact moment Charlotte's jaws snapped shut.
This scene hits me like a truck. Seeing how Sayaka has grown up as a character besides all the stuff that happened to her, and by how she consoles Hitomi is clear that she doesn't hold any grudge against her. Truly heartwarming.
In the third timeline sayaka did hold a grudge against hitomi that time, considering that her familiars that route are distorted versions of hitomi, stupidly giggling and dancing waiting to be flattened by Octavia's gears
maybe its just me overanalyzing something, but i like to think this scene sort of represents how sayaka had officially come to terms with everything that had happened, and showing how much she overcame her jealousy and spite over hitomi and kyousuke's relationship i just think theres a reason why they had sayaka to be the one who consoled hitomi and show her a good dream of kyousuke
Sayaka had overcome her feelings and gave her blessing to Kyousuke and Hitomi at the end, but it's still nice seeing it play out like this. She also knows she has Kyoko... Sayaka was taken into the Circle and Madoka shared her knowledge and experiences. Sayaka knew what Kyoko went through for her sake after Sayaka's death in the original universe and probably countless other timelines. And just like Madoka only knew Homura was her best friend after she became the Circle, Sayaka knew Kyoko was her truest companion. Near the end of the movie, Sayaka outright states that missing Kyoko was her greatest regret and Kyoko was the main reason she came back.
The romance thing never was sayaka's true thorn, it was the truth about witches, but hitomi taking her crush just made it worse, since she realized she wanted kyosuke to appreciate her.
its been 6 years since i wrote this and im just like... wow good job 15 year old me you understand basic literary analysis LOL so glad you pointed out the obvious😶
Vicente isaac Lopez valdez yeah sayaka’s purpose was to show that magical girls will turn to witches. i think her wish was selfish and she realized it. tbh, sayaka was boring to me lol
wish this was the real Madoka story...so warm and happy... So glad Sayaka wasn't in love with Kyosuke anymore. The scene where Sayaka is holding and petting Hitomi's head blob shows how much Sayaka cherishes Hitomi as a friend. Kyosuke really isn't worth these good girls.
+chrisroserva We have very little information about Kyosuke. Why is he not worth? (unless you're into girls relationship,then i can understand your statement .)
yeah but if hitomi was refused by kyousuke she would be thirsty for homura (i'm serious, it happens in the game "madoka portable", and honestly it could be one of the MANY alternate timelines)
@@Yarikkk14 In this movie, Kyosuke repeatedly blows Hitomi off, says that he's too busy for her, and makes plans on days that they're supposed to spend together even though they're dating. Also, Sayaka does call him either a jerk or an idiot or oblivious. It varies version to version. Point is, he isn't a very good boyfriend, and that's actually why Hitomi has this nightmare, she falls asleep after he is clearly bored talking on the phone with her.
Shes probably is still. But realised that it is ok to be jealous and be angry over a relationship. But it is not the end of the world, people who you love may not love you back. And thats okay. Like the original Little Mermaid and Hans Anderson.
This scene makes me sob every time I see it, the visuals are so stunning and it's such a small moment of relief from the otherwise incredibly painful reality of what these magical girls face. Watching Sayaka make peace with the situation that previously caused her to despair, and watching the Hitomi fish swim around Kyosuke makes me cry every time I see it. This entire franchise is genius regardless of the direction they go in.
Everyone in the comments is talking about Sayaka, but what strikes me the most is how this conclusion mirrors Homura's conclusion at the end of the movie. Notice that Homura's and Hitomi's anguish are actually the same: they're both sad because their beloved ones are too focused on their life purposes (for Kyousuke, that's the violin, and for Madoka, that's her wish, the thing that she can fight for) and don't give enough attention to them. In the case of Hitomi, she comes to peace as she's reminded by her friends of how much she loves Kyousuke's passion, so she continues to support him. As for Homura, well... Even though everyone around her tries to help her the same way they helped Hitomi, the outcome is exactly the opposite. This comparison is even more powerful if you remember that witches attract mentally unstable people who shares their saddness to their labyrinths, so that's probably the reason why Hitomi's there in the first place.
Thank goodness Hitomi wasn't a magical girl. She might have died and Sayaka would go through a BUNCH more grief. It's best they put her in for other reasons.
Sayaka restoring his arm so he can create beautiful music again is truly such a selfless gift never once demanding him or telling him the truth so he can feel indebted to her she’s rlly sweet but that can be a hard burden
You know,if the anime was like this,As in five magical girls fight "nightmares" with thier cute pet (Bebe) ,I think it would've made a decent anime,Don't get me wrong,I absolutely love the story as it is ,it's amazing, but I guess the idea of them being happy like this is also nice
That’s the thing though, this part is so great solely because of the suffering they’ve gone through. The tragedy of the original series makes these happy moments all the more precious to us. That’s what they were going for.
Yeah, I know exactly what you mean, but... As fun as that would have been, it... Would have just been another bog standard Magical Girl series, albeit with insane visuals.
Welp. Since we're talking about all the Hitomi and Sayaka thing. Did you know there's a timeline where Sayaka and Kyosuke DO end up together? The thing is... Sayaka becomes a Witch anyways because Kyosuke's priority is the violin and not her... Like... It was worthless because it seems Kyosuke doesn't love Sayaka as much as she loves him... *Or he's just a terrible boyfriend* I think that's why Hitomi is here... She just discovered the same thing... Kyosuke's priority is all that violin stuff...
Sayaka dies or becomes a witch in every timeline It's one of the things that homura can't change regardless if she gets kyosuke or not.gets over him or not.its because of her own black and white views of the world.shes just a kid that doesn't want to accept that the world isn't full of happy endings Fact.not fun though
There is a timeline where there happy together in the psp game Hitomi lets Sayaka have Kyosuke she tells him she's a magical girl and transforms infront of him Kyosuke tells her hes sorry for making her use her wish on him also she doesn't fight Kyoko, Mami lives and becomes an idol, Madoka has a better mentality, also Kyoko and Sayaka fight a bunch of witches and build a huge pile of grief seeds in the church unfortunately they don't win against walpurgisnaght even if they have seemingly endless magic, and Homura goes back in time (AGAIN) even kyubey admits it was a good strategy
For Kyosuke, as a musical prodigy, his music and the violin had to be the center of his life. Everything else, no matter if he wanted it or not, had to be second. That level of talent is also a curse that takes control of every aspect of his life. Everything must be focused on it and it alone. So anyone involved with him would have to accept they will never be the main focus of his attention. It's also the reason he reacted so severely to the injury he suffered. As he saw it, without being able to play the violin, he was nothing. As Sayaka said when she learned the truth about magical girls, he was "a corpse pretending to be alive.
0:50 you can see here that Madoka's Soul Gem doesn't glow like the others' do. It could be more foreshadowing to the fake world and how this Madoka isn't technically real.
I love how Sayaka has moved on from Kyou. She has forgiven Hitomi (who actually did nothing wrong in the first place-she told Sayaka about her crush and set a good deadline for when she planned to confess, which was reasonable), and will hopefully be with Kyoko.
That’s like saying Homura did nothing wrong. Check the third movie. Anyway, Hitomi did not set a fair guideline. She knew Sayaka was confused about her feelings towards Kyosuke and that she wouldn’t be able to gather her thoughts and feelings in time to ask him out. What kind of friend does that? She did this because she is an entitled little snob who just has to get everything she wants. Hitomi is the reason Sayaka turned into a witch. Hitomi did a lot of shit wrong. And she even has the audacity to try to complain in this movie because they can’t go on dates every week. I get that they’re dating, but come on, Hitomi! He has a life, you know. Don’t get mad because you’re not the sun he orbits around. This is all the bad stuff that Hitomi did.
I cry everytime watching this. Its just so adorable and it shows how much sayaka has moved on. And how much hitomi loves violin kid. Plus the faces she makes as a head blob are so adorable
Obviously my favourite scene from this movie, it shows Sayaka's character development from coming to terms with Hitomi's and Kyosuke's relationship together, she cares for them and wants them to be happy together.
Funny how when knowing why this is all happening it makes for a very nice and even a little touching scene, and as other's pointed out, a nice degree of growth and maturity on Sayaka's part. Out of context... it makes for a totally "what drug did I just unknowingly take" vibe. :)
I love how it shows Sayaka blessing their relationship to a degree here and consoles Hitomi because she knows what she is going through. The point is further nailed home by when Sayaka calls Kyousuke Captain Oblivious and when she confesses to Kyouko later on.
If you read the classic version of The Little Mermaid? That's what happens. The mermaid dies but she's made an Angel who helps the lost and broken and starts by blessing the Prince and his bride.
Old comment, but I hope you see my answer... I don't think Hitomi turned into that blob thing, exactly. Everything that happens after the... String blood and fishes (?)... Comes from beneath her bed is her nightmare taking the physical form the others fight. The weird puppet thing is kinda like it's "battle armor" that the MGs have to destroy to get at the real problem, which is... How Hitomi feels at that moment. Which they do by turning it into a cake which Charlotte eats, who then expels the badness as pretty sparkles like some kind of insane tree->carbon dioxide->oxygen relationship. Personally I feel it was a GREAT representation of how someone, and especially young girls, feel when first wading into the waters of relationships. She loved violin boy, obviously, but not being able to see him a lot was leaving her upset and discombobulated (discomblobulated?) And that was reflected in the core of her nightmare as blob Hitomi. I don't think Hitomi ever left her bed at all.
Just to think... .... Homura was the one who made this "magic system" in her World, one that had mutual benefit for those who suffered and those who fought... ...and they kept telling me she wasn't a good person. 😕
@@JustEverton she isn't really bad person, she said shes the devil because she thought she is. She created world where everybody is happy, there are no witches, kyubey isn't manipulating anybody (althought it wasnt his intention) and Madoka can finally live happy, without being alone. Sort of perfect world, everybody is alive and definetly not happy.
I get this is supposed to be a sweet moment but I can’t help noticing that it’s still Hitomi chasing after Kyousuke when she flies up after him. He’s always flying backwards away from her while she keeps flying forward to get close to him. He even seems to flick her away just before they start to spiral at the end. I might be looking too much into it but I thinks it shows Kyousuke’s first priority will always be his violin and not the girls who love him.
DIVINE, Sayaka doesn't show any hate against them just because Kyosuke decided to be with Hitomi, but made a good dream for her instead, i'm just hurt about the pain she suffered in the first movie :(
I have not watched this movie yet. and frankly I'm to scared too, But this scene really makes me all teary eyed and happy. I have not watched the anime but i know that Sayaka loved Kyosuke and yet Hitomi loved him, and he liked her. And in the anime i think thats what made her soul gem fill with grief. But in this, she is not mad. She sees how upset and small Hitomi is, and Sayaka comforts her. Giving her a dream of him. she holds no grudge against her, and she sees how happy it makes Hitomi. and she watches them dance and become one, and just smiles. cause her friend is happy.
Ohhh throwback to the main series when everyone hated or simply disliked Sayaka simply because she was weak and turned insane. Now after Rebellion, she got the recognition she deserves. I feel like a hipster thinking about it, because it's like "I loved Sayaka before it was cool" xD
I want to ship sayaka and him but ik it cant happen its so sad how realisticaly dark about this scene's message is. That sometimes love doesn't work out.
I agree. I like it if Kyousuke is with Sayaka cause their childhood friends. My sister and I believe that lovers that known each other since kids have stronger bonds.
Julia Tjandra i am so glad that someone understands me on this note. Many people ship her with the other magical girls. I'm not against it but it's clearly depicted that Sayaka truly loves him.
I honestly think Kyousuke isn't a good person to be with her...my OPT is Kyoko x Sayaka, but not just because is yuri, but because he didn't even accepted her feelings, he treated her so bad, even knowing his situation still this isn't a reason to be so rude with someone who cares about you. Kyoko suicided to be with Sayaka, such a beautiful scene...
@@ninjashoujogirl6566 by shipping her with the other girls, no one is trying to invalidate she loved him, that she made her wish for him. that's canon. what's also canon is how this scene depicts how he will always put his goals above anyone else. which doesn't make him a bad person either, they're all just people, with feelings and passions. moving on from your feelings doesn't erase the memories or lessons you learned, so I think people who ship her with kyoko like that she can understand sayaka on a deeper level.
@@katylepetsos7512 in the show, hitomi was talking to sayaka and madoka and thought that they had liked each other. she started saying "girls can't like girls!"
Wait it’s been so many years and I just realized that when the soul gems are restored, only Homura’s does not have a dark spot while the rest of them do, showing that she is not a magical girl anymore. The subtle details in this series are phenomenal
this is incredibly impactful especially with the music, I can hear some parts of Disney's Little Mermaid theme in there and I'm sure it's intentional, seeing mermaid symbolism practically everywhere for Sayaka
i think this is sad for the three of them, sayaka, hitomi and kyousuke, i dont dislike kyousuke because he too was suffering and couldnt move on by the fact he could never do what he likes again, the three of them were just 14 years old kids who were suffering so hard because life sucks seeing this, i wish this was what actually happened
I've wondered what to make of this exact moment in _Rebellion,_ given how the setting here is an artificial, hallucinogenic psychic womb, a birthing chamber for a future being that wants control of the entire cosmos so it can enforce its will on an object of personal affection. I guess I don't like to think too hard about it, besides how it's a conscious attempt to build tension and dread in the third part of a trilogy by presenting what the likely audience might want to see, knowing they will also realize that it will soon come crashing down.
What really sucks is that THIS is what their lives as Magical Girls should have been, instead of the nightmare they actually exist in. And it's a witch's labyrinth.
Sayaka was able to get closure about her selfishness, not moralizing her motivations, while homura never had that revelation, equating her selfishness to love. So sayaka is able to let go while homura clings onto it with every fiber of her being.
![Madoka Rebellion Nightmare Ballet & Mada Dame Yo まだダメよ [I Dream of Dawn]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6P49pNzDiq0/mqdefault.jpg)
honestly what makes me sad is that this is all in homura's mind, meaning she wished being a magical girl was something heartwarming and fairy tale-like and not so cruel as the incubators made it to be...
Indeed
@Jefri Anata
That's not the point, yes it's true kyubey used this as a trap to get the old system back, but this shows that homura just wants a good life, just like anyone else.
Nope
Hitomi was actually invited into her labyrinth
So this was the actual Hitomi
People who were invited into the labyrinth and not conjured up by homura-Hitomi,Madokas Family,The teacher
I'm not sure if that's everybody that was invited but it's less than 10 people for sure
@@vicenteisaaclopezvaldez2450 nope you're over thinking it
That was the real Hitomi
She was invited by homura into her labyrinth
Yeah... it's tragic enough how, even if Homura's wish for the others is purely a function of an idea of the world that Homura believes Madoka would accept and cherish and find fulfilling, it'd still be a nice enough place for them, the sort of cliche-ridden, complexity-averse power-of-friendship action-adventure story they knew to be impossible at the exact moment Charlotte's jaws snapped shut.
This scene hits me like a truck. Seeing how Sayaka has grown up as a character besides all the stuff that happened to her, and by how she consoles Hitomi is clear that she doesn't hold any grudge against her. Truly heartwarming.
Syries
Saaaaaame! Plus, the unsettling balloon of hitome's head? Yikes
no I wouldn’t say Sayaka “held a grudge” as she knew she could never love Kyosuke because she’s a magical girl now.. a zombie..
In the third timeline sayaka did hold a grudge against hitomi that time, considering that her familiars that route are distorted versions of hitomi, stupidly giggling and dancing waiting to be flattened by Octavia's gears
666 likes never thought it would happen to me
CrystalOtaku93 lol
さやかいい子だな、ほんと。
あの時は人の幸せを願ったばかりに妬みの感情がいっぱい集ってしまってあんな結果になったけれど
こうやって笑って2人を見守れてるのが凄く感動する
ほんとにさやか最初この中で一番どうでもいいキャラだったけど今や一番好きなキャラになったよ
さやかは好き
しかし恭介、何故さやかを選ばなかった
でもひとみも素敵な子だから好き
恭介は何故モテるんだ、デリカシー
無い癖に...
新宿のロボ公
ゲーム版ではさやかと恭介付き合った世界線(？)があったみたいだよ
んで、恭介は｢さやかは僕みたいなタイプが好きだと思ってなかった｣と言ってた
でもアニメ(映画？)では恭介、ひとみとも付き合ってるよね…
恭介にちゃんと恋愛感情があるか分からんな…
@@曲専用-y1l
ゲーム版だと、二人とも好きって感情はあったんだけど前に出る勇気がなかったって言ってた。付き合った世界軸のは確かほむほむがサヤカの告白手伝ってたきがする。
仁美の良さがわかる人は真のまどマギ好き
maybe its just me overanalyzing something, but i like to think this scene sort of represents how sayaka had officially come to terms with everything that had happened, and showing how much she overcame her jealousy and spite over hitomi and kyousuke's relationship
i just think theres a reason why they had sayaka to be the one who consoled hitomi and show her a good dream of kyousuke
Sayaka had overcome her feelings and gave her blessing to Kyousuke and Hitomi at the end, but it's still nice seeing it play out like this.
She also knows she has Kyoko... Sayaka was taken into the Circle and Madoka shared her knowledge and experiences. Sayaka knew what Kyoko went through for her sake after Sayaka's death in the original universe and probably countless other timelines. And just like Madoka only knew Homura was her best friend after she became the Circle, Sayaka knew Kyoko was her truest companion.
Near the end of the movie, Sayaka outright states that missing Kyoko was her greatest regret and Kyoko was the main reason she came back.
It's so nice to see someone with a Helvetica profile pic 😭
The romance thing never was sayaka's true thorn, it was the truth about witches, but hitomi taking her crush just made it worse, since she realized she wanted kyosuke to appreciate her.
its been 6 years since i wrote this and im just like... wow good job 15 year old me you understand basic literary analysis LOL so glad you pointed out the obvious😶
Vicente isaac Lopez valdez yeah sayaka’s purpose was to show that magical girls will turn to witches. i think her wish was selfish and she realized it. tbh, sayaka was boring to me lol
ほんとさやかちゃん天使すぎる
やっぱり女の子の理想の性格だよね
これまでもこれからも好きなアニメキャラの一番はさやかだよ。
自分で言うかww
アイコンがなwwwまぁでもわかるよ。いいこだものね
俺の推しはさやかに変わりはない！
wish this was the real Madoka story...so warm and happy...
So glad Sayaka wasn't in love with Kyosuke anymore. The scene where Sayaka is holding and petting Hitomi's head blob shows how much Sayaka cherishes Hitomi as a friend. Kyosuke really isn't worth these good girls.
Truly. I hope that their relationship gets more explored in the supposedly upcoming movie/series : 3
+chrisroserva We have very little information about Kyosuke. Why is he not worth? (unless you're into girls relationship,then i can understand your statement .)
yeah but if hitomi was refused by kyousuke she would be thirsty for homura (i'm serious, it happens in the game "madoka portable", and honestly it could be one of the MANY alternate timelines)
@@Yarikkk14 In this movie, Kyosuke repeatedly blows Hitomi off, says that he's too busy for her, and makes plans on days that they're supposed to spend together even though they're dating. Also, Sayaka does call him either a jerk or an idiot or oblivious. It varies version to version. Point is, he isn't a very good boyfriend, and that's actually why Hitomi has this nightmare, she falls asleep after he is clearly bored talking on the phone with her.
Shes probably is still. But realised that it is ok to be jealous and be angry over a relationship. But it is not the end of the world, people who you love may not love you back. And thats okay. Like the original Little Mermaid and Hans Anderson.
Hitoblob. Hitoblob is a thing now.
A literal moeblob.
Hito means "catfish" in our language...
Why in the world of fudging talking white and pink cat-bunnies did that came into my mind? °-°
***** Hm...
I guess so. :/
Hitoblob.... cat-blobfish....
blob-catfish....catfish-blob... >.>
BlobBLABLABLABLABLABLA!!
Im expecting this to be a meme...
IM WAITING! *-*
Hahahahaha!
I really, really love Sayaka. Some may see her as foolish or naïve but she's really just ready to give all of herself for anyone that needs her.
あのときはひとみに対する恨みと憎しみでソウルジェムを濁らせて魔女になった。いまは幸せを願う魔法少女。いまのさやかは好きだな。
もぶ さやか推しの私は今のさやかも全てが愛おしくて好き。
もぶ 仕方ないよな。願い事で好きな人の体を治したらその好きな人を親友に盗られて、魔法少女になるってことは子供を作れない体になるって言われて、もし俺が近くにいたらさやかに「俺が忘れさせてやるよ」ってするのに
@@_user_TM_ 別にみんながみんなさやかのこと好きなわけじゃないから仕方ないな
親友に同じ事をされてみてください。好きになれなくても前のさやかちゃんの気持ちは分かれるようになるはずです。
僕はマミさん推しだよ🎵
Sayaka and Nagisa is savoring every last second of Homura’s labyrinth before it all goes wrong
This scene makes me sob every time I see it, the visuals are so stunning and it's such a small moment of relief from the otherwise incredibly painful reality of what these magical girls face. Watching Sayaka make peace with the situation that previously caused her to despair, and watching the Hitomi fish swim around Kyosuke makes me cry every time I see it. This entire franchise is genius regardless of the direction they go in.
I wanna cry when I see Sayaka's smile. It looks so genuine, she really is happy for Hitomi and wish her well, despite how it may feel.
このシーン見てからさやかのイメージめっちゃ変わったすごい優しい子だよなあ
全部知っててブレイクダンスしてたり、仁美に対してあんな優しい表情出来るとかもう聖母さやかだと思うの。
さやか本当にいい子だわ…
さやかちゃんホント可愛い。性格も良いし音楽のセンスも凄いしホント完璧。んでも
何より「まっかせなさーい！」とか言ってるお調子者な所が1番好き
0:40 is no one going to talk about how friggen adorable Bebe's smile is?
Both from the beauty of the scene, and the aftereffect of eating that giant cake.
Honestly Bebe (in all forms, witch and magical girl) is my favorite character I love her sm
@@asoggyflipflop let’s pinch her cheeks
Bebe in this scene is just an adorable little piece of cheese :3
さやかにはまだまだいい人が現れるよ
でもその相手が見つかる前に魔女にならないといいね
もう現れてるんだよなぁ…
すでに同棲してるんだよなぁ…😌
Everyone in the comments is talking about Sayaka, but what strikes me the most is how this conclusion mirrors Homura's conclusion at the end of the movie. Notice that Homura's and Hitomi's anguish are actually the same: they're both sad because their beloved ones are too focused on their life purposes (for Kyousuke, that's the violin, and for Madoka, that's her wish, the thing that she can fight for) and don't give enough attention to them. In the case of Hitomi, she comes to peace as she's reminded by her friends of how much she loves Kyousuke's passion, so she continues to support him. As for Homura, well... Even though everyone around her tries to help her the same way they helped Hitomi, the outcome is exactly the opposite.
This comparison is even more powerful if you remember that witches attract mentally unstable people who shares their saddness to their labyrinths, so that's probably the reason why Hitomi's there in the first place.
Underated comment right here
Thank goodness Hitomi wasn't a magical girl. She might have died and Sayaka would go through a BUNCH more grief. It's best they put her in for other reasons.
Alihma David what if hitomi is the catalyst that set Madoka free from homura’s grasp
@@Gooberwares what? Why?
It was confirmed that it’s practically impossible for Hitomi to become a meguca. Still, I’d love to see how massive of an impact her death could be
@@thestranger4894wait but how?
シャルロッテええ顔しとるわ
げんぞー自称革命児
マミがマミってしまった時の事を想像すると、、、
げんぞー自称革命児 人間の姿になるともっと可愛いよ
一方通行
だな
一方通行 百江なぎさのことですよね確かにとても可愛いです
さやかほんと天使
Sayaka restoring his arm so he can create beautiful music again is truly such a selfless gift never once demanding him or telling him the truth so he can feel indebted to her she’s rlly sweet but that can be a hard burden
You know,if the anime was like this,As in five magical girls fight "nightmares" with thier cute pet (Bebe) ,I think it would've made a decent anime,Don't get me wrong,I absolutely love the story as it is ,it's amazing, but I guess the idea of them being happy like this is also nice
yes
That’s the thing though, this part is so great solely because of the suffering they’ve gone through. The tragedy of the original series makes these happy moments all the more precious to us. That’s what they were going for.
@@hithere4893 And when the truth of the dream is revealed,the descent to Hell become even more thrilling.
Yeah, I know exactly what you mean, but... As fun as that would have been, it... Would have just been another bog standard Magical Girl series, albeit with insane visuals.
Welp. Since we're talking about all the Hitomi and Sayaka thing. Did you know there's a timeline where Sayaka and Kyosuke DO end up together?
The thing is... Sayaka becomes a Witch anyways because Kyosuke's priority is the violin and not her... Like... It was worthless because it seems Kyosuke doesn't love Sayaka as much as she loves him... *Or he's just a terrible boyfriend*
I think that's why Hitomi is here... She just discovered the same thing... Kyosuke's priority is all that violin stuff...
This...This is evidence that make me remove Hitomi from my hate list now..
Honestly, poor Hitomi. Kyosuke's an asshole through and through.
Sayaka dies or becomes a witch in every timeline
It's one of the things that homura can't change regardless if she gets kyosuke or not.gets over him or not.its because of her own black and white views of the world.shes just a kid that doesn't want to accept that the world isn't full of happy endings
Fact.not fun though
There is a timeline where there happy together in the psp game Hitomi lets Sayaka have Kyosuke she tells him she's a magical girl and transforms infront of him Kyosuke tells her hes sorry for making her use her wish on him also she doesn't fight Kyoko, Mami lives and becomes an idol, Madoka has a better mentality, also Kyoko and Sayaka fight a bunch of witches and build a huge pile of grief seeds in the church unfortunately they don't win against walpurgisnaght even if they have seemingly endless magic, and Homura goes back in time (AGAIN) even kyubey admits it was a good strategy
For Kyosuke, as a musical prodigy, his music and the violin had to be the center of his life. Everything else, no matter if he wanted it or not, had to be second. That level of talent is also a curse that takes control of every aspect of his life. Everything must be focused on it and it alone. So anyone involved with him would have to accept they will never be the main focus of his attention. It's also the reason he reacted so severely to the injury he suffered. As he saw it, without being able to play the violin, he was nothing. As Sayaka said when she learned the truth about magical girls, he was "a corpse pretending to be alive.
AWWW What is this cuteness with Hitomi's face?
She's a moeblob!
I'm so shipping Sayaka with Hitoblob now.
Hitoblob is best moeblob!
0:50 you can see here that Madoka's Soul Gem doesn't glow like the others' do. It could be more foreshadowing to the fake world and how this Madoka isn't technically real.
I love how Sayaka has moved on from Kyou. She has forgiven Hitomi (who actually did nothing wrong in the first place-she told Sayaka about her crush and set a good deadline for when she planned to confess, which was reasonable), and will hopefully be with Kyoko.
Finally, someone who thinks that Hitomi was being fair with Sayaka about Kyousuke.
She did nothing wrong.
24 hours is not reasonable lol
Karmillina While I agree u could have given Sayaka a complete year she still wouldn't have confess
KyoSaya is out there.
That’s like saying Homura did nothing wrong. Check the third movie.
Anyway, Hitomi did not set a fair guideline. She knew Sayaka was confused about her feelings towards Kyosuke and that she wouldn’t be able to gather her thoughts and feelings in time to ask him out. What kind of friend does that? She did this because she is an entitled little snob who just has to get everything she wants. Hitomi is the reason Sayaka turned into a witch. Hitomi did a lot of shit wrong.
And she even has the audacity to try to complain in this movie because they can’t go on dates every week. I get that they’re dating, but come on, Hitomi! He has a life, you know. Don’t get mad because you’re not the sun he orbits around. This is all the bad stuff that Hitomi did.
I cry everytime watching this. Its just so adorable and it shows how much sayaka has moved on. And how much hitomi loves violin kid. Plus the faces she makes as a head blob are so adorable
Obviously my favourite scene from this movie, it shows Sayaka's character development from coming to terms with Hitomi's and Kyosuke's relationship together, she cares for them and wants them to be happy together.
仁美はネットでクズ言われてるけど素敵な子だし好き
でも一番大好きなのはさやか
恭介は反吐を吐くほど嫌い
という私はただいま複雑な心境に陥っております…
Alv
おいしいしじみ それな
なんだかんだここで1番泣いた
さやか推しは辛いのう...（幸涙）
ソウルジェムを全員均等に浄化してくれるのいいな。奪い合いすることもないし。
Did anyone else notice when Sayaka let go of Hitomi's blob head, Hitomi became like a mermaid.
How did I not notice this!?!?!? I really hate the symbolism with the little mermaid
I know this is alleatory but i really want a timeline where Kyoko Sayaka and Hitomi become a trio
夢の為に二人の女の子を泣かせる男の子が
夢を掴んで沢山の人を感動させてるんだから世の中ワケワカメだじぇ
さやかちゃんいい人すぎる…
Funny how when knowing why this is all happening it makes for a very nice and even a little touching scene, and as other's pointed out, a nice degree of growth and maturity on Sayaka's part. Out of context... it makes for a totally "what drug did I just unknowingly take" vibe. :)
Rob Hunter The best kind of drugs... imagination
さやかちゃんいい子だなぁ
I love how it shows Sayaka blessing their relationship to a degree here and consoles Hitomi because she knows what she is going through. The point is further nailed home by when Sayaka calls Kyousuke Captain Oblivious and when she confesses to Kyouko later on.
If you read the classic version of The Little Mermaid? That's what happens. The mermaid dies but she's made an Angel who helps the lost and broken and starts by blessing the Prince and his bride.
If only the magical girl system ran exactly like this.
It would be awesome :)
brings tears to my eyes. music is so powerful ♥
0:05 ここの表情すこ
さやかちゃんの優しさ…
Beautiful. Pergo Pugnare was and is my favorite song on the Official OST.
Thanks, finally I know the song name.
さやか乗り越えられたんだなって感動した
絶望が溜まったら魔女化するなんてシステムがなけりゃさやかならきっと長くかかっても立ち直ってもっと生きていられたのに…
人魚の魔女も浄化されれば普通に強いだけだね。
さやかが、仁美の頭ナデナデするシーン泣ける。
さやか良い子すぎて。
Taking the term "moeblob" a bit too literally there, aren't we, Shaft?
I don't know why Hitomi turned into this blob-thing, but it was just so dang adorable... I cried oceans.
Old comment, but I hope you see my answer...
I don't think Hitomi turned into that blob thing, exactly. Everything that happens after the... String blood and fishes (?)... Comes from beneath her bed is her nightmare taking the physical form the others fight. The weird puppet thing is kinda like it's "battle armor" that the MGs have to destroy to get at the real problem, which is... How Hitomi feels at that moment. Which they do by turning it into a cake which Charlotte eats, who then expels the badness as pretty sparkles like some kind of insane tree->carbon dioxide->oxygen relationship. Personally I feel it was a GREAT representation of how someone, and especially young girls, feel when first wading into the waters of relationships. She loved violin boy, obviously, but not being able to see him a lot was leaving her upset and discombobulated (discomblobulated?) And that was reflected in the core of her nightmare as blob Hitomi. I don't think Hitomi ever left her bed at all.
さやかちゃんはそれで幸せなの…？
作成アカウント 一年前のコメに返信してすみません。
きっと、さやかちゃんは、好きな人が幸せになれれば、それだけでも幸せなんですよ。
@@NAGYO_HENKAKU そうかもね
@@NAGYO_HENKAKU 本編でいろいろあった後の乗り越えたさやかなんで大丈夫なだけで、当時は・・・ただ、普通なら立ち直るのを待てばいいのに一回でも絶望したら即魔女行きってあたり救えない魔法少女。
幸せだよ
オクタヴィア・フォン・ゼッケンドルフ 本物やあああああああああああぁぁぁ(((((()))))
Just to think...
....
Homura was the one who made this "magic system" in her World, one that had mutual benefit for those who suffered and those who fought...
...and they kept telling me she wasn't a good person. 😕
Just because you’re a bad person, doesn’t mean you have bad intentions.
@@JustEverton she isn't really bad person, she said shes the devil because she thought she is. She created world where everybody is happy, there are no witches, kyubey isn't manipulating anybody (althought it wasnt his intention) and Madoka can finally live happy, without being alone. Sort of perfect world, everybody is alive and definetly not happy.
Somehow this scene makes me feel sad for Sayaka :'(
Me too. I keep thinking about how Sayaka turned into a witch in the series and how they had to kill her
Me too!! I don't know why i fell sad for her if she looks so happy now. Happy with kyouko :p
***** I feel glad because she managed to be happy for them.
I get this is supposed to be a sweet moment but I can’t help noticing that it’s still Hitomi chasing after Kyousuke when she flies up after him. He’s always flying backwards away from her while she keeps flying forward to get close to him. He even seems to flick her away just before they start to spiral at the end.
I might be looking too much into it but I thinks it shows Kyousuke’s first priority will always be his violin and not the girls who love him.
More heartwarming than the flower field scene.
The flower field scene was more like heartbreaking
It's so beautiful *cries uncontrollably until all the water in body is out*
DIVINE, Sayaka doesn't show any hate against them just because Kyosuke decided to be with Hitomi, but made a good dream for her instead, i'm just hurt about the pain she suffered in the first movie :(
さやか優しいから大好き
It's sad how you see Hitomi dancing with the fake Kyusoke knowing that she just want him to pay more attention to her and not always on that violin.
Cinnamon roll
that violin guy is Holger, one of Oktavia's minion.
I have not watched this movie yet. and frankly I'm to scared too, But this scene really makes me all teary eyed and happy. I have not watched the anime but i know that Sayaka loved Kyosuke and yet Hitomi loved him, and he liked her. And in the anime i think thats what made her soul gem fill with grief. But in this, she is not mad. She sees how upset and small Hitomi is, and Sayaka comforts her. Giving her a dream of him. she holds no grudge against her, and she sees how happy it makes Hitomi. and she watches them dance and become one, and just smiles. cause her friend is happy.
The reason her soul gem corrupted was after she learned the truth about the magical girls / witches, Sayaka saw herself as an inhuman monster.
Awww... Sweet dreams, Hitomi.
さやかは優しすぎるよ
魔女化のときは、魔法少女になるということの本当の意味と、見返りが欲しかったのかもしれないという迷いと、ひとみとのことが重なって重なってもうどうしようもないくらいの絶望だったんだろうな
Ohhh throwback to the main series when everyone hated or simply disliked Sayaka simply because she was weak and turned insane.
Now after Rebellion, she got the recognition she deserves. I feel like a hipster thinking about it, because it's like "I loved Sayaka before it was cool" xD
これ、リアタイで見たけど、このお菓子の魔女の顔といいみんなの幸せそうな…ほんとたまらんって感じだった…表せない…
I want to ship sayaka and him but ik it cant happen its so sad how realisticaly dark about this scene's message is. That sometimes love doesn't work out.
I agree. I like it if Kyousuke is with Sayaka cause their childhood friends. My sister and I believe that lovers that known each other since kids have stronger bonds.
Julia Tjandra i am so glad that someone understands me on this note. Many people ship her with the other magical girls. I'm not against it but it's clearly depicted that Sayaka truly loves him.
I honestly think Kyousuke isn't a good person to be with her...my OPT is Kyoko x Sayaka, but not just because is yuri, but because he didn't even accepted her feelings, he treated her so bad, even knowing his situation still this isn't a reason to be so rude with someone who cares about you. Kyoko suicided to be with Sayaka, such a beautiful scene...
@@ninjashoujogirl6566 by shipping her with the other girls, no one is trying to invalidate she loved him, that she made her wish for him. that's canon. what's also canon is how this scene depicts how he will always put his goals above anyone else. which doesn't make him a bad person either, they're all just people, with feelings and passions. moving on from your feelings doesn't erase the memories or lessons you learned, so I think people who ship her with kyoko like that she can understand sayaka on a deeper level.
I totally did not have tears in my eyes caused by the vision of beauty before me during the watching of this.
Trust me.
K.
...
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)!
I don't know. Sayaka's story shatters my heart while homura and madoka's story kills me
Im so proud of sayaka 😭💗
Am I the only one that was expecting [when watching the trailer] something horrible to happen to Hitomi in this movie, but instead got this..?
:X
今も昔もさやかはいい子だな…
言葉にできないくらい好き
何があってもさやかのことが好き
(あ杏子もね！！)
大好きだよ！
なぜ報われないのかな？
落ち込んだ時にこれ見るとこうでありたいって立ち直れる
Oh look, it's the homophobic avocado.
"Is the keki Hitomi?"
"No, it's not me. I'm just a homophobic avocado."
I don’t remember Hitomi being homophobic.
@@katylepetsos7512 in the show, hitomi was talking to sayaka and madoka and thought that they had liked each other. she started saying "girls can't like girls!"
@@tsuksaamane5191, I mean.... Can't blame her
@Cherry Chel ASMR I replied to a deleted comment that said Hitomi started to like Homura. Wow, how do I remember that...
This was the most beautiful scene in the rebellion movie 😭😭😭
i think the Hitomi head blob looks really cute for some reason ??
Sloane Perry I think so too
Same here,, '
さやか、大好き。
Wait it’s been so many years and I just realized that when the soul gems are restored, only Homura’s does not have a dark spot while the rest of them do, showing that she is not a magical girl anymore. The subtle details in this series are phenomenal
さやかは、良い奴だよな
Beautifull scene, the boy dancing with violin.
One thing about the idea of fighting nightmares is the magical girls solve the problem from inside the person, not from the outside.
she turned into a new species of pokemon
このシーンだけ唯一癒される
0:19 it looks beautiful...😭😭😭
this is incredibly impactful
especially with the music, I can hear some parts of Disney's Little Mermaid theme in there and I'm sure it's intentional, seeing mermaid symbolism practically everywhere for Sayaka
さすがに泣く
さやかまじで好こ。叛逆までは正直
普通だったけど一気に惚れた。
推しの杏子と合わせて杏さやは目の保養
ここのコメ欄さやかちゃんへの愛情がこもってて安心した☺️
i think this is sad for the three of them, sayaka, hitomi and kyousuke, i dont dislike kyousuke because he too was suffering and couldnt move on by the fact he could never do what he likes again, the three of them were just 14 years old kids who were suffering so hard because life sucks
seeing this, i wish this was what actually happened
さやかちゃん可愛い
awwww this music is so beautiful 😄
さやかお前やっぱり天使や
シャルロッテを味方と思って見ると可愛いけど、これを敵にまわしたらまじで怖い 笑
恭介と仁美、大学進学と同時に片方が留学で遠距離に耐えられず終わるパターンとみた
I've wondered what to make of this exact moment in _Rebellion,_ given how the setting here is an artificial, hallucinogenic psychic womb, a birthing chamber for a future being that wants control of the entire cosmos so it can enforce its will on an object of personal affection. I guess I don't like to think too hard about it, besides how it's a conscious attempt to build tension and dread in the third part of a trilogy by presenting what the likely audience might want to see, knowing they will also realize that it will soon come crashing down.
Esta es una de tantas escenas que me encantan♡
Yo tambien...♡
マミさん推してるけどさやかちゃんの事をちゃんと見てたらさやかちゃん推しくらいになりそうです… 。 さやかちゃんもマミさんも大好きです… 本当にさやかちゃんみたいな性格になりたいしマミさんみたいに文句1つ言わさせない女になりたい。あとは2人の合わせた顔になりたい ()
What really sucks is that THIS is what their lives as Magical Girls should have been, instead of the nightmare they actually exist in. And it's a witch's labyrinth.
人魚姫は最後に風の精霊となり
人々を幸せにする使命を背負うんだと教わりました
王子様には微笑みをお后様には祝福を
優しいさやかちゃんに
そんな人魚姫の強さを感じました
Sayaka was able to get closure about her selfishness, not moralizing her motivations, while homura never had that revelation, equating her selfishness to love. So sayaka is able to let go while homura clings onto it with every fiber of her being.
あんまりまどマギ知らなくて今から見ようかなって思ってる私でも涙腺やばい
The soundtrack of this scene is as beautiful as Tsubasa.
Blobtomi is my fave PMMM character