How to Choose a Home Fireplace | Ask This Old House

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
  • Ask This Old House host Kevin O’Connor explores the best options for home fireplaces. (See steps below.)
    SUBSCRIBE to This Old House: bit.ly/Subscrib...
    Expert assistance was provided by Alan Davis, general manager of Yankee Fireplace and Grill City [www.yankeefire...]. Alan describes several fireplaces options including a traditional wood-burning fireplace. Alan says this should be for ambience only as it is only 15 percent efficient. A gas log is another option, but is equally as inefficient as a traditional wood-burning fireplace at 15 percent. However, there is zero clean up involved. A better option would be a gas-fueled insert into an existing fireplace. That runs at 70-80 percent efficiency. For those without an existing fireplace, there's a gas zero-clearance fireplace. That can be built into almost any wall and exhaust directly out of an exterior wall. Alan also shows Kevin a standing gas-fueled oven. That can be placed almost anyway and vented through an exhaust pipe. A pellet stove is fueled by sawdust pellets and runs on electricity. It's convenient for someone looking to burn wood and more efficient than a traditional wood-burning fireplace. However, if you already have a gas option Alan recommends you stick with gas. Finally, Alan shows Kevin several electric fireplace options. These fireplaces produce some heat, but are primarily for ambience. They do not need any venting.
    Steps for How to Choose a Home Fireplace:
    1. Alan describes several fireplace options, including a traditional wood-burning fireplace. This should just be for ambience as it is only 15% efficient.
    2. A gas log is as inefficient as a traditional wood-burning fireplace, at 15%, but requires zero cleanup.
    3. A better option would be a gas-fueled insert in an existing fireplace. That runs at 70% to 80% efficiency.
    4. For those without an existing fireplace, there’s a gas zero-clearance fireplace that can be built into almost any wall and will exhaust directly out of an exterior wall.
    5. Alan also shows Kevin a standing gas-fueled oven. That can be placed almost anywhere and vented through an exhaust pipe.
    6. A pellet stove is fueled by sawdust pellets and runs on electricity. It’s convenient for someone looking to burn wood, and more efficient than a traditional wood-burning fireplace. However, if you already have a gas option, Alan recommends you stick with gas.
    7. Finally, Alan shows Kevin several electric fireplace options. These produce some heat but are primarily for ambience. They do not need venting.
    Looking for more step by step guidance on how to complete projects around the house? Join This Old House INSIDER to stream over 1,000 episodes commercial-free: bit.ly/2GPiYbH
    Plus, download our FREE app for full-episode streaming to your connected TV, phone or tablet:
    bit.ly/34RYEP5
    Follow This Old House and Ask This Old House:
    Facebook: bit.ly/ThisOldH...
    Twitter: bit.ly/ThisOldH...
    bit.ly/AskTOHTw...
    Pinterest: bit.ly/ThisOldH...
    Instagram: bit.ly/ThisOldH...
    bit.ly/AskTOHIG
    For more on This Old House and Ask This Old House, visit us at: bit.ly/ThisOldH...
    How to Choose a Home Fireplace | Ask This Old House
    / thisoldhouse

КОМЕНТАРІ • 82

  • @edttt4491
    @edttt4491 Рік тому +2

    This was a great segment. His knowledge is unmatched. Small business owners know their stuff!

  • @Luna_Potato
    @Luna_Potato 5 років тому +64

    I know they're super inefficient but man you can't beat the smell and sound of a real wood fireplace. I have one and I build a massive fire every Christmas just to make it feel that much more special.

    • @marylandsirensfirebuff9664
      @marylandsirensfirebuff9664 5 років тому

      thats cool man i wish i had one

    • @floridapielady
      @floridapielady 5 років тому +2

      I agree! We have heated the entire house with our wood burning fireplace. Mind you we are in Florida and it doesn't get that cold but still it is gorgeous and smells like home. I wouldn't have anything but wood burning. Great video.

    • @enceladusfox2247
      @enceladusfox2247 5 років тому +1

      I totally agree !

    • @XJon2011
      @XJon2011 8 місяців тому

      Efficient for basically free and renewable resources

  • @kylepost4
    @kylepost4 5 років тому +4

    I know several people who have the electric fireplaces (i.e. glorified space heaters) and love them! Since I live in Florida there is not a lot of demand for fireplaces, but the electric ones still give the ambiance of a fire without the heat.

  • @lynntaylor7513
    @lynntaylor7513 2 роки тому +2

    I learned a lot!!! I have a 120 year old, three story house and wanted to get an understanding and find out my options! Great job!!! Appreciate what you all do!!!

    • @thomasreedy4751
      @thomasreedy4751 Рік тому

      They missed one: wood burning insert.
      Which in my mind would be best if you have a pre-existing wood burning fireplace, and a natural gas furnace. So you have 2 potential heat sources available to you.

  • @hotsauce2007
    @hotsauce2007 8 років тому +108

    amazing seller with a lot of patience and knowledge about fireplaces, congratulations for this store to have this employer

    • @emmag9362
      @emmag9362 6 років тому +5

      I found myself staring at your profile pic to see if you're the sale guys. But yes, agree.

    • @jakesarms8996
      @jakesarms8996 6 років тому +2

      Knowledgeable in selling gas and electric units. That's for rich folks

    • @robertwalton3823
      @robertwalton3823 6 років тому +1

      hotsauce2007 yflavel gas fire vents

    • @unknowncuyler5449
      @unknowncuyler5449 3 роки тому +1

      that is the difference in an employee an an owner.

    • @jedidiahpablo4311
      @jedidiahpablo4311 3 роки тому

      I guess im randomly asking but does anybody know a trick to log back into an instagram account?
      I stupidly forgot my account password. I appreciate any tricks you can give me.

  • @TuanNguyen-kj1rz
    @TuanNguyen-kj1rz Рік тому +1

    This stove works exceedingly well and is well worth the price.

  • @752brickie
    @752brickie 6 років тому +4

    I noticed they sell a lot of Jotul stoves. They are amazing units !!! I highly recommend them.

  • @tylerdunnam1813
    @tylerdunnam1813 5 років тому +10

    Why didn't they mention wood burning inserts with a convection blower?

  • @jamesr.3460
    @jamesr.3460 2 роки тому +1

    Great video but you never mentioned the ventless gas fireplace option (not sure the location of where the video was produced ventless option could be against code for that location). Ventless fireplaces are 100% efficient. Besides the elevated humidity wand obvious carbon dioxide concerns what are the cons against this option?

  • @plumbingpassionandwork9859
    @plumbingpassionandwork9859 8 років тому +1

    Nice video wery informative, but there is another fireplace which is connected with central heating and there is the coil in it which is connected to the cold wather line.On that wather line must be installed on a special valve to cool down the fire place if the temperatule increase to 95 degrees.In Europe we use the fireplace as the second source of heat ,gas boiler is the main source of heat in this case. I like to watch your videos they are amazing.

  • @gh0s1_t
    @gh0s1_t 5 років тому +2

    Nice! If the house does not come with a fire place can I still install the gas fireplace during renovations?

  • @davidlizama223
    @davidlizama223 6 років тому +3

    Great video, the employee was very informative.

  • @thunderfan747
    @thunderfan747 3 роки тому +2

    i wonder what the temperature in that store is?

  • @kevkou44
    @kevkou44 6 років тому +37

    getting a lot of tarantino vibes from this guy

  • @thomasreedy4751
    @thomasreedy4751 Рік тому +1

    No wood burning inserts at the time of this episode?

  • @alano2875
    @alano2875 2 роки тому

    Shopping for a gas fireplace... Way too may choices (which sounds good, but really makes choosing difficult). Any advice on choosing make/model?

  • @samsquires2877
    @samsquires2877 4 роки тому

    I spy a Heat N Glo 6000CLX. Love that unit.

  • @randolphgarcia3494
    @randolphgarcia3494 3 роки тому +1

    BRIEF NOTE: IN CALIFORNIA, CHECK W/THE DEPT OF BLDG INSPECTION FIRST BEFORE ANY WORK STARTS JUST IN CASE. A ELECTRICAL PERMIT(MAYBE) MAY BE REQUIRED FIRST BEFORE ANYWORK CAN LEGALLY BEGIN. ALSO RESEARCH PRICES TOO. REMEMBER TO BE AN INFORMED CUSTOMER. USUALLY PRICES CAN BE BETWEEN $5-7 THOUSAND DOLLARS, POSSIBLY MORE, DEPENDING ON WHAT STATE YOU LIVE IN.

  • @cucvcanada5844
    @cucvcanada5844 4 роки тому

    MagikFlame from Nashville, TN, has the best quality flame technology, sold direct from the factory.

  • @spiritualservicesgodbless7641
    @spiritualservicesgodbless7641 4 роки тому

    Thank you for explaining everything. 🐏🐆🐖

  • @ultimatefireplaces8701
    @ultimatefireplaces8701 5 років тому +1

    Thank you

  • @xDEATH4SIGHTx
    @xDEATH4SIGHTx Рік тому

    I have a fireplace that is like the first one but its empty at the top and empty at the bottom but it has like fan controls around it to push the air. I'm guessing this is more then 15% efficient.

  • @jeanhossry
    @jeanhossry 5 років тому +1

    hello Guy's. can you advise me about pellet fireplace , if give smoke or smell outside ?

  • @boedillard8807
    @boedillard8807 2 роки тому

    Three things I doubt I'll see in my lifetime - graphene batteries, a balanced federal budget and a gas fireplace that looks like a real fireplace. Every time I see one, I think GROOVY BABY time to play some Burt Bacharach and roll out the faux bear skin rug. I loved him laughing at the most rediculous ones.

  • @adamguymon7096
    @adamguymon7096 5 років тому +1

    It would be nice to have the ability to have the different flames turn the color you want the flame? It would be nice if the flame could be color changing so no matter what mood you are in you can set a theme to your desire. The key is to make the unit so it will use less electricity than a LED Light Bulb. Make a unit that can produce better heat than any Gas of wood/coal fire place but use electricity and put a battery back up system in that will power this unit for 65 day's straight on high non stop on back up battery power.

  • @bandcampkid07
    @bandcampkid07 4 роки тому

    Great video!

  • @hypnosiscenternyc
    @hypnosiscenternyc 5 років тому

    Great video.. Thanks

  • @LL-em3od
    @LL-em3od 2 роки тому

    I have a gas fireplace just installed. Having a problem with condensation on the vent pipe for direct venting. Any help or suggestions? The house is tight spray formed.

  • @Lisa-vs3ys
    @Lisa-vs3ys Рік тому

    Umm, we get plenty of heat from out Fireplace. We love it s9 much.

  • @paulmlemay
    @paulmlemay 4 роки тому

    could you please tell me the details of the gas stove that runs without electricity?

  • @bobbg9041
    @bobbg9041 3 роки тому

    Ok guys, I have a gas fireplace vent type A. It burns gas and pulls inside air for combustion, becuse this unit also backs to a back deck, id like it to pull outside air in for combustion and be both gas or wood burning. Can that be done in the same space id also want to have a blower unit to force heated air into the room.

  • @Gale4ce1
    @Gale4ce1 2 роки тому +1

    He never mentioned the efficiency of the electric insert.

  • @jeff2178
    @jeff2178 8 років тому +2

    Very interesting..

  • @sissymurphy9620
    @sissymurphy9620 7 років тому

    what about propane vented or vent free ,which is better .I already have a wood fireplace that I am looking to convert all we have is propane available .I want something that can keep a room warm in case of a power outage

    • @chivimbe
      @chivimbe Рік тому

      Just do a wood burning stove insert

  • @rickydavis5541
    @rickydavis5541 5 років тому +1

    Electrical fireplace is cheaper than woods and gas and woods stove is messy and very dangerous and woods is getting harder to get anymore gas stove is too expensive but looks amazing but electrical is way to go

  • @calvinpang7144
    @calvinpang7144 3 роки тому +1

    Sounds like the presenter isn't interested in the electric fireplace insert (or didn't think that would be a heat source) and didn't ask the energy efficiency question as he did in all other fireplace options. It would have been great to have a comparison between the electric fireplace insert vs gas fireplace insert. Safety aside, which heat source is more energy efficient?

  • @hemi08911
    @hemi08911 6 років тому

    I just bought a home with a converted double door garage turned into a den. It doest have air duct system what type of heater should I posibly use to heat the room?

    • @JonT1137
      @JonT1137 5 років тому

      Ronnie Emerson well that’s a tough question. But if you like the look of a wood fire, I would suggest a wood stove. There are a variety of styles, they can be quite efficient and create a lot of heat if needed

  • @BoomhauerWorldwide
    @BoomhauerWorldwide 4 роки тому +2

    Lol he said nobody uses a wood fireplace to actually heat. It did fine for centuries. 19th century homes always had at least a couple fireplaces. If you want to burn gas get a gas furnace, 90+ efficiency.

  • @paulpetzar7401
    @paulpetzar7401 4 роки тому

    Does anyone know what company he works for? I'd like to look up their showroom & website.

    • @paulpetzar7401
      @paulpetzar7401 4 роки тому

      nmind. I should've done more searching first. Its Yankee Fireplace Grill & Patio in Massachusetts.

  • @briancuprisin4571
    @briancuprisin4571 4 роки тому +1

    The problem with a sealed gas or electric fireplace is that you can't pull out a flaming log and rampage throughout the neighborhood, intimidating your neighbors and generally sowing chaos for extended periods of time.

    • @davem6685
      @davem6685 3 роки тому

      So you’re saying this type of unit isn’t good for democrats who when pissed off at the smallest thing, like to burn down their community? Gotcha.

    • @briancuprisin4571
      @briancuprisin4571 3 роки тому +2

      @@davem6685 Awww, look, it's a tribalist. How cute. :)

    • @davem6685
      @davem6685 3 роки тому

      @@briancuprisin4571 all true. I know you guys don’t like facts, oh well. When do you think the layoffs will start? March?

  • @Jemalacane0
    @Jemalacane0 5 років тому +1

    What? No coal fireplaces? Is it extremely hot in that room?

  • @davidholt4216
    @davidholt4216 4 роки тому +1

    No discussion of ventless gas?

  • @KCBanjo27
    @KCBanjo27 5 років тому +1

    Buyer Beware Heat & Glo, you have to use their controller, can't integrate into your Thermostat that controls the rest of your house, And it won't work with any wifi or iphone or other phone apps.

  • @user-fl4wn9dn2c
    @user-fl4wn9dn2c 6 років тому +4

    Amazing a fireplace company saying just get a gas unit,,,, the point of a fireplace is beauty and don't need electricity or gas

  • @BigBeef20
    @BigBeef20 3 роки тому +1

    Propane, wood pellets, electric... Might as well just run your furnace if you’re not burning wood

  • @brycehilt858
    @brycehilt858 3 роки тому +2

    So this what Quentin Tarantino do as a side hustle? Selling home fireplace?

  • @spiritualservicesgodbless7641
    @spiritualservicesgodbless7641 4 роки тому

    I want a fireplace for my trailer. 🍻🐏🐆🐖

  • @LisaMurphy
    @LisaMurphy 4 роки тому

    He's got no wood burning stoves? Why?

    • @naweedsediq1299
      @naweedsediq1299 4 роки тому

      bcs it maybe in a rich neighborhood and rich people don't like trouble and cleaning

    • @LisaMurphy
      @LisaMurphy 4 роки тому

      @@naweedsediq1299 right, rich people got that way by sitting around doing nothing.

    • @naweedsediq1299
      @naweedsediq1299 4 роки тому

      @@LisaMurphy i never said that. some people work really hard to get rich, some inherit wealth and some simply steal from others.

  • @fontuckygamer5353
    @fontuckygamer5353 2 роки тому

    Gas I have.

  • @fontuckygamer5353
    @fontuckygamer5353 2 роки тому

    gas have I.

  • @fontuckygamer5353
    @fontuckygamer5353 2 роки тому

    I have gas.

  • @fontuckygamer5353
    @fontuckygamer5353 2 роки тому

    I got gas.

  • @Darkseid001
    @Darkseid001 2 роки тому +1

    The gingers lack of knowledge and condescending tone.

  • @victoruriostegui1822
    @victoruriostegui1822 8 років тому

    1st

  • @RICHIE_RICH89
    @RICHIE_RICH89 5 років тому +1

    I see these new fire places there cheap junk the ladie that had my home bought a custom made fire place its a beast super thick steel a heatilator fresh air intake and all my ash goes in a room in the basement in a wall 6 humans could fit in this is a 5 foot wide box it heats my house so hot i can open the doors in winter and its a 3900 square foot home this fucker gets hot one of a kind the people who custom made it did a fuck of a job super heavy guage steel this new stuff is thin shit and this puppy needs no bricks either best ive seen im sure the price tag was 10k to 15k easy but worth it . Fuck gas why pay for gas wood gets hotter looks better and i dont need the world to depend on if shit goes south