Hey guys, this is what singing while dancing ACTUALLY sounds like!! It’s anything but perfect, but they’re still hitting those notes while exhausting themselves. Kudos to them!
Yeah this is music bank Most groups aren’t allowed to lipsync on this music show BUT what’s more surprising is groups are still allowed to have a prerecorded track as long as they are still singing live over it. Lesserafim don’t seem to be using a full pre-recorded track here. It’s actually fully live and you can hear their movements on the mic and them stopping at points to breathe. Not editing. Not many groups do this. Well done girls!
yea but their editing team sucks!! they cant even hide the heavy breathing!! its like simplest thing in editing, camera work sucks too, its like they just uploaded the vods
@@yeellinu4900 yeah like you could hear the fabric moving and everything as if the mics are on their clothes or something. They def could’ve gotten rid of those sounds me thinks
people should realise that singing low notes while dancing is a lot harder than singing high notes. notice how they become more stable in the pre chorus and that's cuz the part is higher. with this kind of song and with this kind of choreo, having shaky/unstable vocals is natural.. like it's bound to happen no matter how good of a singer you are.
Why do you justify their unstable vocals? As vocalists training for their debut for several years, they should be able to sing steadily and dance at the same time. Let's stop normalizing this lack of talent. Besides, you are wrong, low tones are easier to control than high tones because your voice won't break. Let's start with the fact that in the pre-chorus they do not sing, because they played backing track that is so loud. A girl who sings unstably a few lines earlier suddenly has a perfect vocal? No, it doesn't work that way.
Okay but this is the most live “live” performance I’ve heard in a WHILE. Most of the live performances you hear the backtrack rather than the live vocals. I honestly appreciate it. The stomping sounds at the beginning had me shook
Agreed. Just like 2nd Generation of KPop performances when You can hear them took a breath or their accessories clinging. I really miss this kind of performances a lot.
@@marmalade751 sorry but why are you blaming the mic? They should know how to control their breaths. U guys were feeds with a lot of pre record vocal and backtrack during performance until live vocal sounds weird to you. Its okay, by the time pass, le sserafim will improve more.
@@nfrhyh I am not only blaming the mic, I am just saying that, because IT Is a bad mic, they have troubling breathing, yeah, but that doesn't change the fact, that these are still bad microphones.
@@solarspowervocalsoutdidyou8594 aiyoo thats basic thing idol will learn. If other idol can control their breath why not LS? Its not like they hv to stop breathe for 4 min its about breathing at the right time..ish you google lahh waste my time explain simple thing like that.
THIS IS WHAT YOU CALL A LIVE PERFORMANCE! They didn’t tone down the choreo or anything, still performed it with the same energy as they did for the very first stage while singing completely live! So brave and powerful for a group that has just debuted and gone through soooo much. Y’all are so used to loud back tracks that you think this is not good enough …. This is amazing, it’s authentic and it shows how you really sound while doing such intense choreo and singing at the same time.
@Peacemaker why did you say about that in many comment section in this video? Doing that just make other fandom hate your Idol. Don't put other Idols down, that's not gonna make your Idols up. I'm not an Aespa fans, not Le Serafim fans either, but I saw your comment on other comment in this video saying the same thing is very annoying.
it’s okay to admit when a stage or group has flaws lol kpop fans learn how to handle criticism challenge (when it isn’t even targeted at YOU for you to take it so personally lol)
@Lily there's been a ton of evidence that verify her being a bully tho. It even caused a stir because of the severity of her bullying (level 5,out of 9 iirc). Most of international fans and kfans agree that they won't be supporting if Garam stays, which says a lot about the severity of her actions and how irrefutable the accounts/evidences on her being a bully are. I for one definitely won't be supporting if she's still there next cb. I can't support a group that has someone that pushed someone to the brink of unaliving themselves.
most of artist sing live just that for youtube they tend to manipulate the sound and video so that for example the air that you can hear in the microphone cant be heard, the most lazy ones just remove the audio and change it with the track audio and thats all, if you think about it that is not really a problem being honest, there is a lot of people that doesnt like to have to hear the air in the microphone or the movement of this, not even the heavy breathing when they are singing, theres people like that too, not because they are supposed to be perfect just doesnt like to hear those, but yeah most of the groups actually sing live and have these kind of sounds, more with those mics, thats why mamamoo doesnt like those kind of mics
@@Cinnamo_eya sakura singing those English Lines so Gorgeously. Like bro Her first language is Japanese. Then she worked hard to Learn Korean. NOW She is singing in English ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥 Hardworking Queen 👸many are appreciating Sakura. Though she is not main Vocalist like chaewon and yunjin. Sakura did well during her Parts.
@@amazingsong485 many people say Sakura can't sing and was only added for popularity which is so false, she improved her vocals and dancing so much and is very stable now plus lead dancer and center material.
@@zuza_0613 yes. But not many of idols can actually sing live while performing (doesn't mean they are not good tho). They are just debuted and we can praise them a little bit for singing live. Singing while dancing is hard even thought it is a part of their job. No one can master it in just short period of time. We all work hard to improve day by day so be nice
@@zuza_0613 exactly like the comment above mine! respect to your opinion of course, but remember they’re just rookies and it’s much harder to sing in a low register while dancing which is exactly why you can hear that they sound much better when theyre singing higher notes (notice in Chaewon’s second line) :)
This is the real definition of fearless, they aren't afraid to be judged by their flaws they're showing who they really are AND IT'S SO ADMIRABLE NOT EVERY ROOKIE CAN DO THIS. FIGHTING GIRLS!!! 💜
a lot of fans from other groups laughed at them🤦many said that someone deliberately turned down the music so that their voices sound bad because dancing while singing is not easy keep the sound stable
Bc its muuuuch harder to keep your voice quiet, low and calm instead of letting it all out by screaming / raising your voice. They did so good for that
i mean most of them has a really high pitch so it is not a surprise ther you can see this with kkura where she sings the high part really great then she get a low part and she cant reach that down, then another high part where she is mor stable even though they are dancing, maybe her experience in izone and akb has helped there idk, but yeah you got a point
It's great to hear live vocals instead of a prerecording that a lot of people mistake as being live. Just the fact that they went ahead and did this and did it pretty well considering the choreography and the low pitch of the song is pretty incredible. Fearless indeed!
@@AliaAlisah for me its if you can hear the breathing (can still be pre recorded), if the noises of the jewelry they wear(if any), and if like this one, i can literally hear each of then steps and their throat is moving ... I can be wrong but this is my observation,
@@AliaAlisah usually lives will always sound a little worse than studio, even if they sing amazingly well. There's more background noise, like heavy breathing, jewelry clinging, clothes rustling, etc. Also their voices will sound more raw and u can hear the backtrack or just the music if they pause to take a breather
To be fair, this is one of the rawest live performances I've seen for awhile. This does remind me of the old days when idols sang live every performance.
This choreo is ridiculously hard and requires so much stamina, so that fact that they did this completely live like this is kinda insane, the girls are shining! EDIT - Eunchae revealed in an interview with Music Bank, before she became MC, that this was a broadcast mistake. It seems like their mic feed was accidentally aired instead of the audio from the stage, which means they are always live, it's just that the sounds on earrings should not be heard, this is what they can hear from their in-ears so it's rare to get to hear it so live for us. Still I think this was good
Obviously they won’t sound 100% like the studio version because they are “humans” but singing live without being 100% stable is WAAY BETTER for me than pre recorded. I really appreciate that they sang live Edit: for those who bringing other groups here, my ults are ateez and Dreamcatcher I’m used to live vocals in but im talking about lesserafim here.
@@hereiamnair7744 O.O has mostly high notes and notes between high and low which are easier to sing. Fearless has low notes specially in the chorus and rap which is were they sound shakier, you can clearly hear they sound better and more stable during prechorus. Singing low notes while dancing is way harder than singing high notes. Still, there’s no need to mention other ggs when this is Le sserafim.
Same! Cause it sounds much pure and original. Sometimes I feel if we just hearing recording, it’s almost like watching the same thing over and over again or it’s too similar to just chilling while putting on the music
of course there's flaws! but we prefer to hear these flaws and the breathing instead of the official audio which they always sound the same, right? this way we also can recognise their voices more ❤️ sorry for my bad english, this is not my 1st language
Just found out that this LIVE stage was actually some kind of broadcast accident, that's why we can hear their voice, breath, & footsteps clearly. So this wasn't intentional at all, yet they still nailed the performance.
This is what every idol group is gonna sound like singing completely live (no backtrack) while doing demanding choreography. It’s humanly impossible that the voice is gonna be unaffected when you’re squating, jumping and running across the stage. Le Sserafim did AMAZING
Chaewon sounds the most stable. Like, her live singing while dancing is scary good. Yunjin is clearly weak on the lower notes but as soon as she hit the high registers, she sounds like a goddess ! Sakura breathing is almost perfect. She controls her breathing to the sound of her singing to make it sound good. VERY good technique. Ugh this group, wtf they’re so good !!!!
I think this is the first time on KBS WORLD that I heard the real vocals and breathing through the dancing. I really appreciate that. And props to the girls they completely killed it!!
Seventeen, iKON, Stray Kids, Ateez also have this. Treasure also have but sadly, the actual live vocals got deleted cuz many knetz thinks they are unprofessional but as treasure said before they just love enjoying their live performances. That vid can actually hear them laughing and many adlibs happened. As i remember, Treasure MMM is that performance
They are literally Fearless. They show how the real live singing is. There’s nothing to worry about girls because dancing while singing live is really really hard.
Now I completely realised singing low notes is way harder than singing high notes while dancing when I sing this song I can't even sing the chorus properly
Really depends on your voice imo, my voice is on the deeper end for females (even a handful of Taemin choruses are too high for me) and this chorus is right in my natural super comfortable range
@@munfaredafatma2633 There’s tons of women out there with great deeper voices but unfortunately most songwriters and companies tend to equate vocal skill to how high of a note you can reach.
Kpop stans literally don’t know what live performances even are so when we hear them we are confused, this is such a great performance, especially how hard they are moving
lol it's so funny seeing kpop fans say "it's not perfect but.." like they clearly have not been to shows where they sing live, even rock shows where they just stand still and play guitar it's not perfect.. i mean just look at Kazuha's move at 1:25 how do you expect them to sound doing that? if you wanna hear them sound like the CD go watch the MV
despite the fact that they are still beginners, they are not afraid to perform live.I am proud of them, I hope they will have great success in the future!!!!!
@@whiteheartsr idk wtf are your standards but what im hearing isnt that horrible sure i do hear them breathing in the mic but u have to understand that the choreo is really hard and energetic so they couldnt sing it perfectly their voices will be more stable if they sing without dancing so their vocals arent that bad
Now THIS is LIVE. Slaying the choreo and can clearly hear them a little shaky in some parts. This is AWESOME and should be the standard for groups nowadays. Not some "perfect" vocals while dancing hard.
@@nurnadirah6029 Dude but they still they've backup of loud backtracks which almost cover their real voice and it sounds robotic,but if you are talking about senior groups like Bts, Exo, Bigbang,etc. Then I can agree with you but try to understand the fact that these girls (except 2 of them) are rookies and still did their job pretty well as their position rn.
@@sanikajadhav6262 SNSD literally preformed ITNW live on their very first stage and sounded 10x better. I don’t even understand why companies debut these girls if they can’t sing and dance.
@@zsantana5643 snsds choreo wasn’t even that hard and the girls barely moved when it was their part to sing which is why they sounded better but they were still the better vocalists overall.Also 9 and 5 members is quite a difference
I totally respect what they did here, it takes so much effort to do actual live singing while dancing this hard, while singing out of range (low notes)
Their stage presence keeps improving a lot and the girlies singing live!?!?!? and the girls look so happy and I'm proud of them!!! also and eunchae's husky voice is just everything let's go queens!!!
This stage should be acknowledged as a reference for what live singing (with a minimum backtrack) while dancing sounds like. it is not perfect and it's fine because it is humanely impossible to be moving around constantly and sing flawlessly.
This is for all the people that keeps criticising them for never singing live. Yes this performance is far from perfect and they sound unstable at times but they are a new group and most importantly, they still attempted live singing. The first step is always the hardest and one day they'll get so good that even the haters will have to acknowledge their hard work and talent. Also i've been a Kkura fan for years but even i was surprised at how deep her voice is here. I know she has a naturally low and deep voice since she sang like that in a few izone songs but wtf gurl, never knew kkura has an inner felix straykidz in her lol 🤣🤣🤣
Yes ppl should be happy and applaud them for singing live so they can keep doing it , because if they get criticized they won’t sing live anymore I’m so proud of them
It's just quite disappointing that it took them this long to sing live but I'm glad they still did!! I love how low their voices sound! Also I don't get the people who did criticize their live singing when they won bc it wasn't even that bad?
@@NiNi_trolls yes the more we encourage the members, the more confident they will get in the future. Some of the members literally only had a few months worth of training like eunchae and kazuha so we can't expect them to suddenly be mamamoo level or something.
i love that they’re singing completely live, because it shows how hard it really is, especially with how whisper-like and low the song really is. they did a wonderful job!
they're rookie and so brave, this choreo is full of power jump and dance and do live singing !!? consuming a lot of stamina, i hope they getting better and better
wow penampilan "ter live" yang pernah gue tonton sepanjang sejarah kpop. big applause untuk leeserafim, meskipun suara banyak ilang tapi wajar bggtttt gilaaa. ini keren bgt, sesuai judul lagunya "fearless"
Ini kok bisa gitu ya musicnya lebih gede volumenya dan cenderung nggak kedengeran. Malah lebih jelas nafas mereka dibanding musicnya. Mubank tumben tumbenan?
The way this performance feels like MR Removed video at the point there's only a tiny amount of backtrack. This is 'the most live singing' stage of 4th gen girl groups I've ever watched. This is how live singing works. You'll hear the imperfection, no matter how great the idol is. Imperfectly perfect. Imagine hitting some notes while spinning or jumping around. If there's anyone who throws hate or malicious comments on these girls for this performance, just admit that you're so used to polished pre-recorded vocals, auto-tuned studio vocals, and having too high expectations or obsessing over perfectionism.
it’s absolutely hard to sing the low parts while dancing but they honestly slayed as a rookie group. doesn’t matter if the low parts sounded breathy and shaky, the high parts were really good while dancing!
The fact that they are singing this live with this choreo as rookies is impressive!! Le Sserafim fighting! They will improve in confidence and ability every performance. KKura is my ult idol exactly because she constantly works hard and improves her craft! These outfits look gorgeous! First I loved the pink, then no the red, and now I think blue is best! KKura keep slaying!! 💮💮💮💮💮💮
True but I doubt everyone in the industry will do it though like if they can they can but I won't criticize anyone hwo can't do it like like it does take so many retakes so I can understand there voices will just give out at some point
Im not being negative here but IT IS POSSIBLE. For example is their labelmates, if you have watched some of BTS concert full video, its amazing. I have one from their 2016 concert and I cant bring myself to delete it. Its just amazing. They're dancing excessively but their voice is very very very stable. Its amazing to be honest. One of
Regardless of how people think they did, what a breathe of fresh air this was! Brought me back to the live performances I'd watch during the 2nd and 3rd gen. Just real and organic. Thanks for the treat, girls!
I DON'T CARE IF THE VOCALS Weren't AS PERFECT AS IN THE STUDIO VERSION, IM JUST GLAD THEY PERFORMED LIVE!!! THIS HASN'T HAPPENED IN MUSIC SHOWS LIKE THIS 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭AT LEAST THE ONES I KNOW OF
She isn’t stable but that’s okay. There’s probably a good majority of kpop idols that aren’t ‘stable’ in general and wouldn’t be able to do notes this low while dancing
@@moluvbot when we're talking about the choreography and her first time singing live she did very well compared to others so we can say she's "stable" at the moment and let's hope for the better in the future 💖
I don’t think y’all realize how insanely difficult it is to sing in a lower range while dancing. If anything it’s so much easier to sing in a high mid range while dancing (speaking from experience). The girls did great and y’all always talk about “how you’d rather have a live performance with imperfections than a perfect lipsynched stage” so I better not see any hate.
this right here! I did a cappella for 2 years and when we had to do choreo (which wasn’t as intense as this) it was so hard to sustain stable notes and stay in tune, especially in our lower registers. and most of my group was made of vocal music majors. I bet the ppl trashing them for the live singing can’t even go on a brisk walk and keep their voice stable lmao
I was thinking the same from the very beginning, people tend not to see that singing in the lower register while dancing so actively is really a hard task to acomplish
![CRAZY - LE SSERAFIM ルセラフィム 르세라핌 [Music Bank] | KBS WORLD TV 240830](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GRQ4luUX15w/mqdefault.jpg)
![CRAZY - LE SSERAFIM ルセラフィム 르세라핌 [Music Bank] | KBS WORLD TV 240830](/img/tr.png)
Hey guys, this is what singing while dancing ACTUALLY sounds like!! It’s anything but perfect, but they’re still hitting those notes while exhausting themselves. Kudos to them!
And actually chaewon and yunjin high note were very very good I was so impressed
Yeah this is music bank
Most groups aren’t allowed to lipsync on this music show BUT what’s more surprising is groups are still allowed to have a prerecorded track as long as they are still singing live over it.
Lesserafim don’t seem to be using a full pre-recorded track here. It’s actually fully live and you can hear their movements on the mic and them stopping at points to breathe. Not editing. Not many groups do this. Well done girls!
yea but their editing team sucks!! they cant even hide the heavy breathing!! its like simplest thing in editing, camera work sucks too, its like they just uploaded the vods
@@moalalisa3201 wow this freak keeps watching the group they hate🥹😭😂🫢😶🥰😍🫢☠️👏 What a pathetic😤🥰💖🍭😅😤💖🍭😭
@@yeellinu4900 yeah like you could hear the fabric moving and everything as if the mics are on their clothes or something. They def could’ve gotten rid of those sounds me thinks
people should realise that singing low notes while dancing is a lot harder than singing high notes. notice how they become more stable in the pre chorus and that's cuz the part is higher. with this kind of song and with this kind of choreo, having shaky/unstable vocals is natural.. like it's bound to happen no matter how good of a singer you are.
Ye this is my point because Also this is not a boy group this is a girl group so yeah their voices are high pitched
True af !!
Why do you justify their unstable vocals? As vocalists training for their debut for several years, they should be able to sing steadily and dance at the same time. Let's stop normalizing this lack of talent. Besides, you are wrong, low tones are easier to control than high tones because your voice won't break. Let's start with the fact that in the pre-chorus they do not sing, because they played backing track that is so loud. A girl who sings unstably a few lines earlier suddenly has a perfect vocal? No, it doesn't work that way.
yasss
Yeah, they can will up like perfect gfriend, sing live vocal with crazy killing dance too (sorry for my bad English)
Okay but this is the most live “live” performance I’ve heard in a WHILE. Most of the live performances you hear the backtrack rather than the live vocals. I honestly appreciate it. The stomping sounds at the beginning had me shook
Agreed. Just like 2nd Generation of KPop performances when You can hear them took a breath or their accessories clinging. I really miss this kind of performances a lot.
How long have I not heard real live performances like this?!(like you can literally hear their breathing sound too?!) LESSERAFIM SLAY!❤️❤️❤️❤️
NMIXX
STAYC
@@gabrielaaus they’re great too, it’s just majority of 4th gen have lip synced only. Even though they’re super talented singers
You can literally hear their foot stamps, breathing and imperfect pitch yet still they performed perfectly without fear. They're indeed fearless
Chaewon’s vocals please 👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻✨✨✨✨✨✨
Kpop fans are so used to pre-recorded vocals and lipsync that they forgot how real vocals while dancing sound like
agree with you
I think they had malfunction mic, one of the member mic sounds so loud. But then we know that they're singing live
I'm pretty sure they will not improve in the future,,sigh
Chaewon sounds like the recording. Her vocals are so stable and strong
@Peacemaker everyone knows Kim Chaewon can SING.🤣
@Peacemaker Aespa sing live when? A year and a half after they debuted? 🤣
@@ispeakcockney5387 Didn't you see aespa's chochella debut ?🙄
@@alishakhisa6427 bro you cant even spell ..
@Peacemaker show us how you sing when you are dancing POWERFULLY
It is a live performance,you can hear their breaths and footsteps. They actually did good. It's better than not trying at all.
Normally you shouldn't be able to her them breathing, these are bad microphones
@@marmalade751 sorry but why are you blaming the mic? They should know how to control their breaths. U guys were feeds with a lot of pre record vocal and backtrack during performance until live vocal sounds weird to you. Its okay, by the time pass, le sserafim will improve more.
@@nfrhyh I am not only blaming the mic, I am just saying that, because IT Is a bad mic, they have troubling breathing, yeah, but that doesn't change the fact, that these are still bad microphones.
@@nfrhyh control thier breath? like not breathe or sum? wtf?
@@solarspowervocalsoutdidyou8594 aiyoo thats basic thing idol will learn. If other idol can control their breath why not LS? Its not like they hv to stop breathe for 4 min its about breathing at the right time..ish you google lahh waste my time explain simple thing like that.
So THIS is what a LIVE stage sounds like... never heard one before, it's incredible
Many kpop groups song live but its less obvious because they also use backtrack while singing. Its very clear here because the backtrack is very low
Why is there only 5 members which member is missing ?
@@k-poplover2087 garam! she’s in hiatus rn :)
@@nara4787 ok
@@k-poplover2087 what why so mean
THIS IS WHAT YOU CALL A LIVE PERFORMANCE! They didn’t tone down the choreo or anything, still performed it with the same energy as they did for the very first stage while singing completely live! So brave and powerful for a group that has just debuted and gone through soooo much. Y’all are so used to loud back tracks that you think this is not good enough …. This is amazing, it’s authentic and it shows how you really sound while doing such intense choreo and singing at the same time.
@Peacemaker why did you say about that in many comment section in this video? Doing that just make other fandom hate your Idol. Don't put other Idols down, that's not gonna make your Idols up. I'm not an Aespa fans, not Le Serafim fans either, but I saw your comment on other comment in this video saying the same thing is very annoying.
@Peacemaker who’s that
@Peacemaker you don't deserve your DN with how you behave
it’s okay to admit when a stage or group has flaws lol kpop fans learn how to handle criticism challenge (when it isn’t even targeted at YOU for you to take it so personally lol)
@Peacemaker ure probably isnt a my lmao. find some other things to do rather than creating unnecessary fanwars here.
eunchae is shining so much these days. she's getting the attention she deserved
She really is, I fell in love with her more the more I see her, such a charming young lady.
She's better than the one who left, right
She's always shining, people was blind when they were still 6
I really hope they officially kick that one member out because all of them shine more with 5, as opposed to 6.
@Lily there's been a ton of evidence that verify her being a bully tho. It even caused a stir because of the severity of her bullying (level 5,out of 9 iirc). Most of international fans and kfans agree that they won't be supporting if Garam stays, which says a lot about the severity of her actions and how irrefutable the accounts/evidences on her being a bully are.
I for one definitely won't be supporting if she's still there next cb. I can't support a group that has someone that pushed someone to the brink of unaliving themselves.
OMG IT'S LIVE 💗
Its crazy right?!💗💗
Eu fiquei ofegante só de assistir. Que dlç 🤧
SIIIIIM AI QUE PERFEITO
Hahahaha yes
@Peacemaker lol go away
The fact u can hear the girls breathing shows that they are singing live!!! And i love it! This is what singing live actually is
I've never heard actual BREATHING in any kpop live stage ever. wow
most of artist sing live just that for youtube they tend to manipulate the sound and video so that for example the air that you can hear in the microphone cant be heard, the most lazy ones just remove the audio and change it with the track audio and thats all, if you think about it that is not really a problem being honest, there is a lot of people that doesnt like to have to hear the air in the microphone or the movement of this, not even the heavy breathing when they are singing, theres people like that too, not because they are supposed to be perfect just doesnt like to hear those, but yeah most of the groups actually sing live and have these kind of sounds, more with those mics, thats why mamamoo doesnt like those kind of mics
@@Тварина-х6ч bruh watch IDLE stages, they always sing live. As well as Stayc
I think it's just an audio issue lmao, pop filters should filter that out
@@thundercloudss um did you just get into kpop bc most dont but okay
You can see Chaewon and Sakura's experience and professionnalism, however they all slay that
FR tho! Everyone appreciates chaewon and yunjin (as we all should) but didn't notice how stable sakura was as well.
@@Cinnamo_eya sakura singing those English Lines so Gorgeously. Like bro Her first language is Japanese. Then she worked hard to Learn Korean. NOW She is singing in English ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥 Hardworking Queen 👸many are appreciating Sakura. Though she is not main Vocalist like chaewon and yunjin. Sakura did well during her Parts.
Sakura can't sing.
@@amazingsong485 many people say Sakura can't sing and was only added for popularity which is so false, she improved her vocals and dancing so much and is very stable now plus lead dancer and center material.
@@Cinnamo_eya stable? I'm sorry I absolutely love her but she was not stable. Out of all 5 members, she was the least stable one.
This gives so much humility to kpop artists. They're so brave by doing this live vocals! You know we'll stan this queens for a very long time.
calling them brave for this is a bit much tbh, singing is literally their job
@@zuza_0613 yes. But not many of idols can actually sing live while performing (doesn't mean they are not good tho). They are just debuted and we can praise them a little bit for singing live. Singing while dancing is hard even thought it is a part of their job. No one can master it in just short period of time. We all work hard to improve day by day so be nice
@@zuza_0613 exactly like the comment above mine! respect to your opinion of course, but remember they’re just rookies and it’s much harder to sing in a low register while dancing
which is exactly why you can hear that they sound much better when theyre singing higher notes (notice in Chaewon’s second line) :)
@@zuza_0613 this is definitely praise worthy.
i agree with this bc no other female group sings live nowadays (4th gen)
This is the real definition of fearless, they aren't afraid to be judged by their flaws they're showing who they really are AND IT'S SO ADMIRABLE NOT EVERY ROOKIE CAN DO THIS. FIGHTING GIRLS!!! 💜
YEAHH 🔥🔥🔥🔥
this, lesserafim fighting 💗
3.5 for 5
Those who are here after Beamon debut
Low note is the hardest than high note while singing live and dancing. Let just apreciate them
a lot of fans from other groups laughed at them🤦many said that someone deliberately turned down the music so that their voices sound bad because dancing while singing is not easy keep the sound stable
So trueee
Agree!!!!
coz low notes require chest voice but chest is constantly moving when dancing while they used head voice for high notes where is relatively stable
@@TTM0730 u can sing low notes in head voice and high in chest can’t u?
Notice that the part where they're unstable is only at the lower voice part. But when they raise their voice it sounds so GOOD💖
agree!
Yes i noticed the same
Love the performance
Exactly
Bc its muuuuch harder to keep your voice quiet, low and calm instead of letting it all out by screaming / raising your voice. They did so good for that
i mean most of them has a really high pitch so it is not a surprise ther you can see this with kkura where she sings the high part really great then she get a low part and she cant reach that down, then another high part where she is mor stable even though they are dancing, maybe her experience in izone and akb has helped there idk, but yeah you got a point
It's great to hear live vocals instead of a prerecording that a lot of people mistake as being live. Just the fact that they went ahead and did this and did it pretty well considering the choreography and the low pitch of the song is pretty incredible. Fearless indeed!
how do you differentiate between live and lip sync? I can hardly tell
@@AliaAlisah for me its if you can hear the breathing (can still be pre recorded), if the noises of the jewelry they wear(if any), and if like this one, i can literally hear each of then steps and their throat is moving ... I can be wrong but this is my observation,
@@AliaAlisah usually lives will always sound a little worse than studio, even if they sing amazingly well. There's more background noise, like heavy breathing, jewelry clinging, clothes rustling, etc. Also their voices will sound more raw and u can hear the backtrack or just the music if they pause to take a breather
To be fair, this is one of the rawest live performances I've seen for awhile. This does remind me of the old days when idols sang live every performance.
But in the olden days they wouldn’t get bashed for singing bad
This is such a satisfying performance bc it’s 100% live
true, idk why i am so happy about this jejdunwdknknejc
I think the prechorus are mostly backtrack (0:27-0:45 and 1:32-1:50), but thats just nitpicking. The amount of live vocals is still amazing
@@flarfquiet 2692 people apparently dont find it obvious
@@flarfquiet i dont understand what youre trying to get at. The comment said that this is 100% live and i pointed out that it isnt.
@@flarfquiet im not only talking about the "adlibs" but the entire prechorus
これ動揺しないで咄嗟にちゃんと歌えてるのがすごいなって思った。
パート振り分け多い二人お疲れ様だしみんなマジでプロ。
Now this is what an actual live stage sounds like.
we can literally hear thier breath thru the mic
Exactly
Mostly in mnet's stages, I can't understand if the artists are singing or not
why they singing live today ? artist always lipsync on stage what was the reason ?? (no hate)
@@ihugsuno idk, maybe they ask for it ? . or different stage have different set of mic . idk~
by the way, they still slay it . no doubt . period .
This choreo is ridiculously hard and requires so much stamina, so that fact that they did this completely live like this is kinda insane, the girls are shining!
EDIT - Eunchae revealed in an interview with Music Bank, before she became MC, that this was a broadcast mistake. It seems like their mic feed was accidentally aired instead of the audio from the stage, which means they are always live, it's just that the sounds on earrings should not be heard, this is what they can hear from their in-ears so it's rare to get to hear it so live for us. Still I think this was good
😑
Yessss
How long have I not heard real live performances like this?!(like you can literally hear their breathing sound too?!) LESSERAFIM SLAY!❤️❤️❤️❤️
idk about "ridiculously hard" but..
true
Obviously they won’t sound 100% like the studio version because they are “humans” but singing live without being 100% stable is WAAY BETTER for me than pre recorded. I really appreciate that they sang live
Edit: for those who bringing other groups here, my ults are ateez and Dreamcatcher I’m used to live vocals in but im talking about lesserafim here.
Heard of NMIXX?
@@hereiamnair7744 we are not talking about NMIXX rn.
@@hereiamnair7744 we're talking about LE SSERAFIM not NMIXX
@@hereiamnair7744 O.O has mostly high notes and notes between high and low which are easier to sing. Fearless has low notes specially in the chorus and rap which is were they sound shakier, you can clearly hear they sound better and more stable during prechorus. Singing low notes while dancing is way harder than singing high notes. Still, there’s no need to mention other ggs when this is Le sserafim.
*humans
トラブルだったとはいえ、激しいダンスの中生歌で力強く歌っている姿を見てまじでかっこいいって思った
Chaewon is so stable. She’s an amazing vocalist and dancer. She has everything. She’s main vocalist and main dancer material. Main slayer chaewon
Kim chaewon fighting 😍😍😍
Also yunjin chaewon and yunjin so stable
Pengalaman tidak pernah mengecewakan. Dia adalah salah satu lead vocal di ex-IZ*ONE.
@@SOOLEEHAHMAY_85 barusan liat live mreka di vlive. Chaewon ga sengaja ngmong. “Konniciwa iz*one desu” 😂😂
@@qiqi769 hihi lucu dia masih terngiang-ngiang sama Iz*one.. Huhu Chaewon
I prefer this live version way too much than the pre-recorded one, even tho there’s still a little flaw, but these girls are doing sooo great
Same! Cause it sounds much pure and original. Sometimes I feel if we just hearing recording, it’s almost like watching the same thing over and over again or it’s too similar to just chilling while putting on the music
of course there's flaws! but we prefer to hear these flaws and the breathing instead of the official audio which they always sound the same, right? this way we also can recognise their voices more ❤️
sorry for my bad english, this is not my 1st language
Same , I would rather have a "imperfect" live performance than precorderd ones at any day
the flaws make it pretty and more original/pure tbh
Sameee
I mean you can clearly see how stable chaewon’s vocals are I don’t understand why no one is talking about her, she has improved a lot by comparing
Chaewon's vocal is stable as always😍😍😍
Who is she?
@@nicolerose3546 she is the short haired girl. She is also their leader 😁
She's amazing
Yes lol, she's amazing. i was lookin for comment like this hahaha
Just found out that this LIVE stage was actually some kind of broadcast accident, that's why we can hear their voice, breath, & footsteps clearly. So this wasn't intentional at all, yet they still nailed the performance.
Source: trust me
@@kanghyewon3004 Nope it's been confirmed and has even been said on the very first ep of eunchae's star diary
@@kanghyewon3004no there’s an actual source this time
@@kanghyewon3004it was said by a music bank staff and Eunchae on Eunchae star diary
That’s disappointing because I was looking forward to more like this😭
This is what we mean when we say "their mic is ON". I hope kpop would start to return to this type of performance on music shows.
BTS/bang PD legacy..mic on
This is what every idol group is gonna sound like singing completely live (no backtrack) while doing demanding choreography. It’s humanly impossible that the voice is gonna be unaffected when you’re squating, jumping and running across the stage. Le Sserafim did AMAZING
and singing in that register too. insanely hard to sing low notes while dancing
Watch NMIXX live singing and dancing OO. They are so good thought. Le Sserafim is so good not gonna lie. I appreciate their hardworking.
it's not impossible if you're miss hyolyn though!
@@rochellemalfoy6593 nmixx song are easy to sing. This one is hard
Hmmmmm, not to discredit Le sserafim but I've seen a couple of live performances (though through videos only) of Itzy. They're really amazing.
Chaewon sounds the most stable. Like, her live singing while dancing is scary good.
Yunjin is clearly weak on the lower notes but as soon as she hit the high registers, she sounds like a goddess !
Sakura breathing is almost perfect. She controls her breathing to the sound of her singing to make it sound good. VERY good technique.
Ugh this group, wtf they’re so good !!!!
Chaewon best girl
Yes the breath control had me stressed but you can clearly see they know when they need to stop singing to take deep breaths. They are so amazing!!!
I'm waiting for the chance to hear Sakura on her register. I know that the right music would be GOLD.
it's harder to hit lower notes than higher notes while dancing especially when your natural voice isn't deep to begin with
Sakura don't have a "very good technique", she's just stable, and it's nothing wrong with that
For some reason this performance is very satisfying.
asmr Lol
@@somber087 LMFAOAOOAA
@@somber087PLS
@@somber087 LMAOAOAOA
@@somber087 JzjjsjsHAHAHAHJSJN LMAO
The success of live singing has increased their self-confidence. The more confident you are, the better your next performance will be.
huh yunjin is such a performer she was born to be on stage. her charismatic visual is no joke
SHES THE BEST.❤️❤️❤️❤️
YAS OUR MAIN SLAYER ❤️
guess u're indonesian
When I first saw them, I thought she was the center.
My bais
I think this is the first time on KBS WORLD that I heard the real vocals and breathing through the dancing. I really appreciate that. And props to the girls they completely killed it!!
Actually Red Velvet also have similar stage with Rookie. You can search Red Velvet Seulgi Rookie
Seventeen too
Seventeen, iKON, Stray Kids, Ateez also have this. Treasure also have but sadly, the actual live vocals got deleted cuz many knetz thinks they are unprofessional but as treasure said before they just love enjoying their live performances. That vid can actually hear them laughing and many adlibs happened. As i remember, Treasure MMM is that performance
STAYC sang live too :>
day6: what am i to you
チェウォンの生歌うますぎる😭
こんだけ激しいダンスしながらこんなに歌えるのみんなすごいけど特にチェウォンが安定してて凄すぎて🥺踊りながら口から音源はやばい👏🏻✨
everyone is complimenting their vocals, but can we just take a minute to appreciate how the cameraman gave the members equal screen time
ITS THEIR WORK
@@user-oq6wr6iw2h Their job is to film not to film everyone fairly
Yes, i noticed this one too
@@user-oq6wr6iw2h appreciate this camera Man,most of them only cover the famous member...
@@carl859 and eunchae got a lot of screen time despite barely having lines
They are literally Fearless. They show how the real live singing is. There’s nothing to worry about girls because dancing while singing live is really really hard.
Now I completely realised singing low notes is way harder than singing high notes while dancing when I sing this song I can't even sing the chorus properly
Fr!!!
You have to keep a low tone of voice while you dance, and if your timbre is not so serious you consume a lot of air 😭😭
Really depends on your voice imo, my voice is on the deeper end for females (even a handful of Taemin choruses are too high for me) and this chorus is right in my natural super comfortable range
@@MuSicNvrsLeEpS97 tbh I have a huge respect to everyone who can sing in low register I can't tell you how much I love this 😭
yup exactly
@@munfaredafatma2633 There’s tons of women out there with great deeper voices but unfortunately most songwriters and companies tend to equate vocal skill to how high of a note you can reach.
踊りながらこんな力強い声出るチェウォン超人すぎる
Kpop stans literally don’t know what live performances even are so when we hear them we are confused, this is such a great performance, especially how hard they are moving
lol it's so funny seeing kpop fans say "it's not perfect but.."
like they clearly have not been to shows where they sing live, even rock shows where they just stand still and play guitar it's not perfect.. i mean just look at Kazuha's move at 1:25 how do you expect them to sound doing that? if you wanna hear them sound like the CD go watch the MV
It’s so cool to hear such low registers they’re really singing with their chests👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
It must be so hard...
@@diarythatyouforgot8704 yes you can hear their breathing 😯
So cool.. i dont even know that
@@diarythatyouforgot8704 kdqkdqkdqkdqkqda
despite the fact that they are still beginners, they are not afraid to perform live.I am proud of them, I hope they will have great success in the future!!!!!
There Beginniers so what it doesn't mean there vocals are supposed sound awful also Sakura and chaewon debuted before
@@whiteheartsr idk wtf are your standards but what im hearing isnt that horrible sure i do hear them breathing in the mic but u have to understand that the choreo is really hard and energetic so they couldnt sing it perfectly their voices will be more stable if they sing without dancing so their vocals arent that bad
@@whiteheartsr thay are not standing still and singing they are moving and getting up form the floor
@@ringo2ne199 ik-?
@@whiteheartsr people like u is why the industry it plaged with lipsync
定期的に見に来ちゃう。
FEARLESSステージで1番好きなステージ。
生歌も生歌でも一切妥協のないダンスや表情も凄いけど、やってやろうっていうみんなの気迫が伝わってくる最高のステージだと思います！まさにFEARLESS！！
すごい。機材トラブルとはいえ、ここまでリアルな歌声を聞けて幸せだ。
しかも驚くほどハイクオリティ。
他のアイドルだったら放送事故になりかねない。
LE SSERAFIMの実力があったからこそできたこと
これ音響トラブルがあってこんな息遣いまで聴こえるパフォーマンスになったんだよね
トラブルがあっても最高のステージを見せてくれたルセラフィムの皆ありがとう！！かっこい！！
トラブルってどこ情報なんですか？
@@hea4123 情報というか通常ならこのようにならないのでトラブルがあった、と言われています
@@aaesc 憶測かい
Now THIS is LIVE. Slaying the choreo and can clearly hear them a little shaky in some parts. This is AWESOME and should be the standard for groups nowadays. Not some "perfect" vocals while dancing hard.
Agreeeeddddd
many groups have perfect vocals while dancing hard and its live. you just haven't discover them yet.
@@nurnadirah6029 Dude but they still they've backup of loud backtracks which almost cover their real voice and it sounds robotic,but if you are talking about senior groups like Bts, Exo, Bigbang,etc. Then I can agree with you but try to understand the fact that these girls (except 2 of them) are rookies and still did their job pretty well as their position rn.
@@sanikajadhav6262 SNSD literally preformed ITNW live on their very first stage and sounded 10x better. I don’t even understand why companies debut these girls if they can’t sing and dance.
@@zsantana5643 snsds choreo wasn’t even that hard and the girls barely moved when it was their part to sing which is why they sounded better but they were still the better vocalists overall.Also 9 and 5 members is quite a difference
I totally respect what they did here, it takes so much effort to do actual live singing while dancing this hard, while singing out of range (low notes)
They're blessed to have Yunjin and her years of professional singing training. She slayed
Yunjin my love
SHE IS SO TALENTED
Chaewon slayed live performance more than her tbh
@@nonec9907 agree
But yunjin carried too
I really apreciate every idol who sing their song live, they are so brave
How is that brave? Its literally their job?
@@Niks_184 if you know you know
Their stage presence keeps improving a lot and the girlies singing live!?!?!? and the girls look so happy and I'm proud of them!!! also and eunchae's husky voice is just everything let's go queens!!!
i agree!!
これだけ踊って歌声も全て安定させろって絶対無理だけど、サビの高音になるにつれARと変わらないような安定した歌声になるの凄くない？！
俄然ルセラ応援するわ
たぶんサビの囁く感じが踊りながらだと難しいんだよね
This stage should be acknowledged as a reference for what live singing (with a minimum backtrack) while dancing sounds like. it is not perfect and it's fine because it is humanely impossible to be moving around constantly and sing flawlessly.
Nmixx????
Nmixx are monster performers but I haven't seen them perform while dancing with such little amount of backtrack.
@@jungwonsbouncyhair1878 Kcon Chicago
Class:y?
Try watching latest Viviz Bop Bop from Queendom 2.. now that's perfect live but as rookies, these girls are already amazing 😁
i LOVE that they didn’t have them lip sync. I wanna hear more raw vocals, they sound so good!
Singing this low while dancing is harder than dancing while singing high notes. I really applaud them for trying anyway
咲良ちゃんめちゃめちゃ歌上手くてびっくりした。ボイストレーニング頑張ったんだなぁ、凄い
こんなに激しいダンスをしながら、一生懸命歌いきってすごい！
you can see their smiles throughout the whole performance..im so proud of them for singing live. eunchae did soo well and all of them are so stable.
This is for all the people that keeps criticising them for never singing live. Yes this performance is far from perfect and they sound unstable at times but they are a new group and most importantly, they still attempted live singing. The first step is always the hardest and one day they'll get so good that even the haters will have to acknowledge their hard work and talent. Also i've been a Kkura fan for years but even i was surprised at how deep her voice is here. I know she has a naturally low and deep voice since she sang like that in a few izone songs but wtf gurl, never knew kkura has an inner felix straykidz in her lol 🤣🤣🤣
Yes ppl should be happy and applaud them for singing live so they can keep doing it , because if they get criticized they won’t sing live anymore I’m so proud of them
I think yujin was singing sakura’s part
It's just quite disappointing that it took them this long to sing live but I'm glad they still did!! I love how low their voices sound! Also I don't get the people who did criticize their live singing when they won bc it wasn't even that bad?
@@NiNi_trolls yes the more we encourage the members, the more confident they will get in the future. Some of the members literally only had a few months worth of training like eunchae and kazuha so we can't expect them to suddenly be mamamoo level or something.
@@praveenw.4393 no, they sing together. because Sakura's voice is very soft and low.
i love that they’re singing completely live, because it shows how hard it really is, especially with how whisper-like and low the song really is. they did a wonderful job!
they're rookie and so brave, this choreo is full of power jump and dance and do live singing !!? consuming a lot of stamina, i hope they getting better and better
さくらちゃんこんな低音でかっこいい声出るんか...
The chereo is insane, every one of them tried their very best and that's the best of all especially Kazuha >< GOOD JOB GIRLS !!
さくちゃんの歌がこんなに上手くなってたなんて…すごい
wow penampilan "ter live" yang pernah gue tonton sepanjang sejarah kpop. big applause untuk leeserafim, meskipun suara banyak ilang tapi wajar bggtttt gilaaa. ini keren bgt, sesuai judul lagunya "fearless"
Jujur mereka yng nyanyi gw yng sesak nafas
Ini kok bisa gitu ya musicnya lebih gede volumenya dan cenderung nggak kedengeran. Malah lebih jelas nafas mereka dibanding musicnya. Mubank tumben tumbenan?
Walopun g sempurna tetep okey.. Klo gue pasti dah mangap2,nyanyi live sambil nari..
Duh mbaknya nggak pernah nonton snsd 2ne1 dkk jaman 2nd gen ?
coba nntnn second gen sama stayc cocer way to go kak. mereka ga goyah samsek
The way this performance feels like MR Removed video at the point there's only a tiny amount of backtrack. This is 'the most live singing' stage of 4th gen girl groups I've ever watched. This is how live singing works. You'll hear the imperfection, no matter how great the idol is. Imperfectly perfect. Imagine hitting some notes while spinning or jumping around. If there's anyone who throws hate or malicious comments on these girls for this performance, just admit that you're so used to polished pre-recorded vocals, auto-tuned studio vocals, and having too high expectations or obsessing over perfectionism.
Yes 👏🏾👏🏾
Yunjin and Chaewon's high notes are great. Also, Eunchae is really good too
it’s absolutely hard to sing the low parts while dancing but they honestly slayed as a rookie group. doesn’t matter if the low parts sounded breathy and shaky, the high parts were really good while dancing!
I can do it without being shaky no hate for them I just said it
@@Jeezthatbitchsexy no need to brag like that
@@Jeezthatbitchsexy We don’t know what to do with that information, no hate for you, I just said it 😅 We’re all here for LS.
@@Jeezthatbitchsexyu deff cant
The fact that they are singing this live with this choreo as rookies is impressive!! Le Sserafim fighting! They will improve in confidence and ability every performance. KKura is my ult idol exactly because she constantly works hard and improves her craft! These outfits look gorgeous! First I loved the pink, then no the red, and now I think blue is best! KKura keep slaying!! 💮💮💮💮💮💮
Kkura fan here!!! Go go go Kkura!!!
@@giovannateixeira2512 how is that? Eunchae only trained for a couple of months. Kazuha was a ballerina. Sounds like rookies to me!
mr除去並にみんなの生歌が聞こえる、、意図したものじゃなかったとしても結果的にみんなの実力が想像以上に高くて感動した😭
特にさくちゃん、昔と比べて信じられないくらい声もでててすごい、泣く😭
この5人、安心して推せる。がんばれー！！
가라오케에서도 에코를 넣는데 방송사고에서 이정도라면 정말 대단한거임…
wow, sakura's stage presence is getting better day by day. she really stands out
Yes even her voice is getting stable inspite of hard breathing steps
@@lindziep6319 p
P0
@@lindziep6319 0p
Bruh sakura's voice us really bad, wtf are u talking about 😂😂
やっぱチェウォンうめえな、努力が伝わってくる
This needs to be normalized in kpop.
Perfect, clean vocals during dancing is IMPOSSIBLE.
They did so well!!!!
True but I doubt everyone in the industry will do it though like if they can they can but I won't criticize anyone hwo can't do it like like it does take so many retakes so I can understand there voices will just give out at some point
Im not being negative here but IT IS POSSIBLE. For example is their labelmates, if you have watched some of BTS concert full video, its amazing. I have one from their 2016 concert and I cant bring myself to delete it. Its just amazing. They're dancing excessively but their voice is very very very stable. Its amazing to be honest. One of
EXACTLY THIS SHOULD BE THE NORM
Regardless of how people think they did, what a breathe of fresh air this was! Brought me back to the live performances I'd watch during the 2nd and 3rd gen. Just real and organic. Thanks for the treat, girls!
They slayed so HARD 🤌🏼🤌🏼🔥
Agree!! There was a reason for choreography to be calm and organic, cause they did sung live everytime before !!
If you love the live performances I suggest checking out stayc!! They have been singing live since debut for every performance!!!
Check out class:y too heheh they are doing live performances☺️☺️
@@angelcomeo3065 their song HITS so HARD 🤌🏼🔥
THE LIVE SINGING?!?!?!?! I’m obseeeessed they sound even fiercer wth they have so much energy i love them so much!!!
😑😶
踊りながらここまで歌いきるのは凄いと思うんだけど!?
ダンスも上手いしプロ意識を感じるめっちゃいいパフォーマンスだった！
I DON'T CARE IF THE VOCALS Weren't AS PERFECT AS IN THE STUDIO VERSION, IM JUST GLAD THEY PERFORMED LIVE!!! THIS HASN'T HAPPENED IN MUSIC SHOWS LIKE THIS 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭AT LEAST THE ONES I KNOW OF
It's been a long time right? I miss this kind of performances. Just like 2nd generation's of Kpop performances. Love it. ❤❤❤
what? their perfect this stage this choreo actually harder to sing
i think their vocals are perfect. the only problem is we can hear their breathing but they sounded great if you remove the breathing sounds.
How long have I not heard real live performances like this?!(like you can literally hear their breathing sound too?!) LESSERAFIM SLAY!❤️❤️❤️❤️
Imperfections of live stages make everyone of them different and unique even if its the same artist with the same song every time
咲良が堂々と自信を持って歌ってる姿に感動しました😭♥️
5명이 되고 나서 새롭게 알게 된것이 채원이 진짜 보석이라는 사실이다... 하이브가 괜히 채원과 계약한 것이 아니었다...
동감! 여자아이돌 중에서 탑급일 듯!
에**는 립싱크나 하고..한심!
@@이봉재-p3iㅋㅋ
このステージみんなちょっと楽しそうでいい
Finally they are singing live. Eunchae is shining, I love that.
ダンスをしながら表情を作って、息を切らして歌っている一生懸命な姿に感動して涙が出た
激しい振り付けと低音の歌は本当に難しいだろうに…
ルセラフィム、ファイティン！
花道だけを歩こう💐
体制が5人になったかつ、マイクの不具合があるのにもかかわらずすごくいいステージ！！
プロだね！
ちょっとくらい崩れててもいいし生歌の方がとても好き ほんとに歌ってるんだなあ
Eunchae is so stable. She’s an amazing vocalist and dancer. She has everything. She’s an ace
She isn’t stable but that’s okay. There’s probably a good majority of kpop idols that aren’t ‘stable’ in general and wouldn’t be able to do notes this low while dancing
@@moluvbot agreed plus the choreo was hard so yeah
@@moluvbot when we're talking about the choreography and her first time singing live she did very well compared to others so we can say she's "stable" at the moment and let's hope for the better in the future 💖
高音はもちろん低音の方が音とるの絶対むずいはずやのに、低音が目立つこの曲でこの生歌ってえげつない🥹🤍
the mics are real sensitive the breathing sounds are sending me 💀 but this is what shows yunjin & chaewon as being AMAZING live vocalists!!
Lmfao same I feel bad for laughing 🤣 they worked so hard but the soundssssss 🗿🗿🗿 i feel like this is meme material
이런게 진짜 실력파 걸그룹인둣. 치마도 짧아서 불편할텐데 안무 완전 열심히 추고 표정까지 신경쓰면서 저정도 라이브라니... 그리고 사쿠라 저 독기 가득한 눈이 너무 좋음........ 멋있어.........
こんな生の声初めて聴いたかも・・・皆こんな激しく踊ってるのに上手すぎない！？びっくり！
yunjin's style is no joke, she literally pulls off everything
咲良ちゃん本当に凄い…
チェウォンちゃんと咲良ちゃんの歌声？歌い方？好き過ぎる
I don’t think y’all realize how insanely difficult it is to sing in a lower range while dancing. If anything it’s so much easier to sing in a high mid range while dancing (speaking from experience). The girls did great and y’all always talk about “how you’d rather have a live performance with imperfections than a perfect lipsynched stage” so I better not see any hate.
Yeah. You can tell because they sound amazing during the pre-chorus which is higher.
this exactly
Yeah, lower range while dancing the choreo really hard are insane. But the girls did really well, mad props to them.
Depends on the person imo, if your voice is naturally deep then those lower notes will feel AMAZING
this right here! I did a cappella for 2 years and when we had to do choreo (which wasn’t as intense as this) it was so hard to sustain stable notes and stay in tune, especially in our lower registers. and most of my group was made of vocal music majors. I bet the ppl trashing them for the live singing can’t even go on a brisk walk and keep their voice stable lmao
보정된 노래보다 이렇게 라이브가 생생하게 느껴지는 무대가 더 좋네요!!
The song is way too low for them but they still managed to perform it so well.
This song is honestly low, I'm a countertenor guy and it's even low for me
I was thinking the same from the very beginning, people tend not to see that singing in the lower register while dancing so actively is really a hard task to acomplish
얼마나 연습을 많이 했는지 알수있는 라이브임.진짜 대박
I am so happy that EUNCHAE gets more recognition as she deserves. LESSERAFIM FIGHTING!!!
The way they MR removed themselves. So refreshing to hear something like this. Proud of you my girls!!!
特にチェウォン上手すぎる完璧じゃん
LE SSERAFIM全員好きだからリアルな声を聞けて嬉しい。
これだけ踊って被せ無しの生歌はかっこいい。