Thank you so much! And yes they were super robbed, TD wasn’t even meant to leave (idk why they chose to keep SB) and Pencil got out by a stupid twist even though she won AND they were decently liked so…
@HandledPleasuresure, but it was stated the two with the most votes will be chosen by the other team which means pick the two people who should be up for elimination by the winning team, with teardrop not doing much and snowball actually helping his team, teardrops elimination IS fair
I think that in this timeline Pen would gain lots of popularity, even without his friends. Pen was already somewhat popular back then, only falling one rank short of joining BFDIA (excluding TV because he was hosting).
I actually have suggested before what if Woody was picked on the Grapes. I actually feel like this would be pretty influential, considering he wouldn't be eliminated fourth due to how great the Grapes did
23:23 The only reason why they wanted Icy out was because neither of them were able to voice her anymore and both were shocked to see that she was surviving against characters with ACTUAL personality and on top of that, they both absolutely hated her at the time of making BFDI. So they decided that enough was enough and decided to get rid of her on the spot. Honestly, this MIGHT sound horrendous, but I wouldn't call it inaccurate
The editing on this is great Anyways, I legitimately think it would’ve come down to Teardrop and Flower for that rejoin, as people wanted more from the both of them at the time and we didn’t have any real antagonistic forces.
Yeah, I agree but literally the only reason for Flowers rejoin in the original one is because she was first eliminated, and back then antagonists werent the "hottest" thing to exist.
Just a note, if the second rejoin was a vote, Match would've probably not gotten out ( or at least gotten out in a different way ). In all 3 BFDI rejoins and debuts, there were no contestants getting eliminated via voting in that episode.
I wish match made it further, no one really talks about it, but match's elimination was rigged too, micheal said I and interview Rocky was supposed to get out instead of match, but bc they don't like match, they recounted the votes and match got out
video idea. what if the unfairly eliminated contestants were in season five? (match, tennis ball, pencil, possibly david, ice cube, donut, dora, teardrop, liy, balloony, possibly ruby, taco, gelatin, cloudy) i thought it could be cool?
List Of Ideas What if TPOT never had a debut What if Teardrop wasn't Unfairly Eliminated in BFDIA What if there were no rejoins in BFDI What if Players not Present were able to join BFDIA What if Purple face replaced Loser (This was acctually what was gonna happen before Loser was created) What if Winner never Existed in TPOT IK you gotta alot of suggestions so You dont have to Do any of these if you Want, also I really do like your what If's there fun
I think for top 6 6th pen 5th td 4th flower 3rd pencil 2nd bubble 1st ic Doesnt lest in blocky flower pin gb david profily yf bomby Flower steals it while flower bubble woody nonexisty gobe and top 24 instead of top 22 So original 22 and leafy plus tv
Idea:What if Rocky got out in BFDI 14? (That’s what was gonna happen in the original BFDI 14 and then match got more elimination votes, and that’s why she got out instead of rocky)
What another great vid!! Good job! Also, I have a bit of a problem. I know you said Google Slides was the last option but its my only choice but when I try to upload it to UA-cam, it keeps saying: "processing abandoned". Do you know what I should do?
“original writing for Ice Cube’s elimination was horrendous and inaccurate”… to what?? THAT’S how they were written. Just because you don’t like the scene doesn’t mean you can pretend it doesn’t exist. Ice Cube was FORCED out of the show by Michael and Cary.
@@Cypher4290 You wanna know who wrote BFDI? Michael and Cary. You wanna know how Ice Cube was eliminated? She was effectively written out by getting voted to be eliminated by the eliminated contestants. WRITTEN BY MICHAEL AND CARY.
@@beatboxmario5006 she was only voted off Becuase of snowball thinking she can "cool down the tlc" what kind of logic is that, not to mention that no one really hates icy around this time so if snowball didn't say anything, icy would have gone further
“original writing for Ice Cube’s elimination was horrendous and inaccurate”… to what?? THAT’S how they were written. Just because you don’t like the scene doesn’t mean you can pretend it doesn’t exist. Ice Cube was FORCED out of the show by Michael and Cary.
I don’t like Ice Cube that much but it was. Characters like Pencil shouldn’t have voted Ice Cube “to cool down the tlc” when they already has SB. PLUS some of their enemies where there (again Pencil and Match with Rocky AND Spongy) But they STILL voted Ice Cube their ALLIANCE MEMBER. JnJ completely forgot everyone’s relationships to get out Ice Cube and that is terrible writing and Ice Cube got out for something she couldn’t control, usually there is a reason for people elimination (Flower, being mean, Blocky and Pen, cheating etc.) and Icy’s is TO COOL DOWN THE TLC?
The fact that pencil and teardrop consistently make it far in these what ifs show how unfair their eliminations were in canon. Great video as always!!
Thank you so much! And yes they were super robbed, TD wasn’t even meant to leave (idk why they chose to keep SB) and Pencil got out by a stupid twist even though she won AND they were decently liked so…
why don’t you do bfdi if instead golf ball got eliminated instead of flower and woody got eliminated instead of spongy?
@@MalwareSucks457 ooooh maybw
Teardrops elim wasn’t unfair but ok
@HandledPleasuresure, but it was stated the two with the most votes will be chosen by the other team which means pick the two people who should be up for elimination by the winning team, with teardrop not doing much and snowball actually helping his team, teardrops elimination IS fair
When the rejoin was pin, coiny, needle, and td, I immediately thought ‘Woah! It’s WOAH Bunch!’ *a few seconds later* “Woah it’s WOAH Bunch!”
LOL WOAH BUNCHH
I mean they were all on Woah bunch at the same time (episode 3)
30:16 this finale looks familiar...
I think that in this timeline Pen would gain lots of popularity, even without his friends. Pen was already somewhat popular back then, only falling one rank short of joining BFDIA (excluding TV because he was hosting).
22:45 Woody would want to bring the least scariest preson
I actually have suggested before what if Woody was picked on the Grapes.
I actually feel like this would be pretty influential, considering he wouldn't be eliminated fourth due to how great the Grapes did
I’m so sorry but i’ve been getting more then 100 requests AND i have my own! once i do my own i’ll pick some from comments but i’ll keep this in mind.
@@pencilsanimationWhat's the font you use?
@@Spitiphone it’s called “Shag-Lounge” you have to download it off google
@@pencilsanimationOh ok thanks!
I have one of the mist unpopular opinions on the internet
Pencil making it further is an instant W
TYSM i swear if that twist didn’t happen she would’ve easily made it to final 5/4 especially given the circumstances of the early immunity stage
fr pencils probably one of the best characters pretty much the only thing was when in Bfb 1 one of the writers decided to ruin freesmart
@@Tsum1231 YEAH apparently a writer didn’t like her so it’s not her fault (it’s proven more by her writing after BFB 2)
*instant L
Also i’m David and.. u prob get why I said that
@@EvilCatlol Hello Mr. Get Pencil out and immediately leave the next episode. Also isn't Pencil friendly to you now?
I love how the finalists are all water based
LOL
I love how now instead of the finalist being all under 3 miligrams they are now all have or related to water
LOL
19:40 Pencil becomes nice lol, also this is great as always!
19:50 She's evil again
23:23 The only reason why they wanted Icy out was because neither of them were able to voice her anymore and both were shocked to see that she was surviving against characters with ACTUAL personality and on top of that, they both absolutely hated her at the time of making BFDI. So they decided that enough was enough and decided to get rid of her on the spot. Honestly, this MIGHT sound horrendous, but I wouldn't call it inaccurate
The editing on this is great
Anyways, I legitimately think it would’ve come down to Teardrop and Flower for that rejoin, as people wanted more from the both of them at the time and we didn’t have any real antagonistic forces.
Yeah, I agree but literally the only reason for Flowers rejoin in the original one is because she was first eliminated, and back then antagonists werent the "hottest" thing to exist.
Just a note, if the second rejoin was a vote, Match would've probably not gotten out ( or at least gotten out in a different way ). In all 3 BFDI rejoins and debuts, there were no contestants getting eliminated via voting in that episode.
27:44 my jaw dropped.
22:22 I doubt that SB would vote for Firey as he'd give anything to cool down the TLC, not warm it up
23:35 brown firey
Keep it up! Your vids are the best!
THANK YOUUUUU
@@pencilsanimation I've got a video request idea! Do you wanna hear it?
@@alphamations2009 sure!
@@pencilsanimation What if rejoins/debuts never happened? And also can you do What Ifs? on other object shows as well?
@@alphamations2009 Okk!! i’ll see! also i’ll try to make my next one on I.I!
11:24 This will always play in my head if I ever see Episode 16 again
30:24 BLUE CREW
YESS
I wish match made it further, no one really talks about it, but match's elimination was rigged too, micheal said I and interview Rocky was supposed to get out instead of match, but bc they don't like match, they recounted the votes and match got out
yeah she got a surge in votes randomly WHILE the episode was in production :(
video idea.
what if the unfairly eliminated contestants were in season five? (match, tennis ball, pencil, possibly david, ice cube, donut, dora, teardrop, liy, balloony, possibly ruby, taco, gelatin, cloudy) i thought it could be cool?
@@bryanyayy IT WOULDDD YEAHH
@@pencilsanimation ❤️
Nah bubble had that plot armor tho
she would be the most liked out of the final 7 so…
1:22 now it’s the w.o.a.h bunch
Idea: if non existy joined in bfdi 18
i like how you use Home - We're Finally Landing when you do an elimination
hahaha thank you so much!
if the announcer didnt remove the third digit from the points, pencil could of gotten more further. she was so robbed
she was
List Of Ideas
What if TPOT never had a debut
What if Teardrop wasn't Unfairly Eliminated in BFDIA
What if there were no rejoins in BFDI
What if Players not Present were able to join BFDIA
What if Purple face replaced Loser (This was acctually what was gonna happen before Loser was created)
What if Winner never Existed in TPOT
IK you gotta alot of suggestions so You dont have to Do any of these if you Want, also I really do like your what If's there fun
these will be my backup! :) thank you
I think for top 6
6th pen
5th td
4th flower
3rd pencil
2nd bubble
1st ic
Doesnt lest in blocky flower pin gb david profily yf bomby
Flower steals it while flower bubble woody nonexisty gobe and top 24 instead of top 22
So original 22 and leafy plus tv
i love this!
Idea:What if Rocky got out in BFDI 14? (That’s what was gonna happen in the original BFDI 14 and then match got more elimination votes, and that’s why she got out instead of rocky)
yeahh i was thinking abt that!! i should do it tbh
1:22 woah bunch
Okay but the needle was honestly robbed this season. Like she used her win token but apparently that still wasn't enough to save her
YEAHHHH i should make a video on her…
9:08 so she subtracts so she subtracts
@@Diogo77787 how’d i not notice
13:33 what’s this song called
1:25 WOAH BUNCH!
Great video!
thanks!
5:05 what? Blocky chose the barf bag challenge originally, why would that change? Balancing it really isn't needed tbh
well i wanted to keep in equal like the original 🤷🏽♂️🤷🏽♂️
the first song is evokelaf, isnt it?
off the top of my head, yes
Three water based Contestants in the finale
Idea:
What If All Rejoins Are Contest?
oooo cool!! i’ll see
Pencil amd rocky are my fav
You should do BFDI but Eraser cut his arms off (BFDI 14). The ten sympathy points would have pushed him out of the danger zone.
ooooo
BFDI but Profiley was able to join.
W for making pen get farther
yea
Wheel ooze a hole bunch
I know you probably have a lot of recommendations, but an idea I have is what if JnJ didn’t scrap Blocky and Woody Rejoining in Episode 7
ooooo yes! I'll include it in my next batch!
10:13 Just saying but won't that look weird? I think Firey AND Pen will be immune. Firey for scoring a strike and Pen for having the most points.
maybe, but i’m just going off the episode
leafy has leaft the chat
Snowball would make all vote icy...
Make Firey get 1-2st/nd.
But Is okay
First of all in 22:12 I think the same thing would happen and Icy would be eliminated
it could it couldn’t idk
What another great vid!! Good job! Also, I have a bit of a problem. I know you said Google Slides was the last option but its my only choice but when I try to upload it to UA-cam, it keeps saying: "processing abandoned". Do you know what I should do?
Thanks! Well are you uploading it as a video or slides? If so it HAS to be a mp4 file if it’s anything else it won’t work
When it said pen is here i thought it said something else
AHAHAHA
Hello! How Do You Do That Letter Animation When Its Swapping To The Letters You Put In The Other Word
i use “morph” and change it to the character mode
@@pencilsanimation how do i do that
@@pencilsanimation I know you use powerpoint
@@thatleafyfan u need powerpoint for it
@@pencilsanimation i have it already so where do i need to go
I also requested neverbutter to make this
OOP LOL
Idk how this hasnt been recommended, but
BFDIA but Firey let Leafy onto Dream Island?
it has! just worded differently… i’ll try!
Idea: What if tennis ball won the tiebreaker instead of leafy in BFDI 18?
okkk
Theres already a what if of that, unless this comment was made before the video
idea: what if every time someone with a win token was up for elimination, they used their win token?
OMG okayy
Someone likes the alliance :P
(rip match tho)
i don’t like them. I LOVE THEM (but i’m not even kidding they ended up there by happenstance that’s why pencils elimination is a bit abrupt.)
I think needle will rejoin because atleast she does something td was just their in season 1
but td still had the second most votes and only lost cuz flower was first eliminated
ıdea: what if strongest team on earth losed instead of death pact again in tpot 1
OOOO!!
Apples
“original writing for Ice Cube’s elimination was horrendous and inaccurate”… to what?? THAT’S how they were written. Just because you don’t like the scene doesn’t mean you can pretend it doesn’t exist. Ice Cube was FORCED out of the show by Michael and Cary.
Bro does not understand writing
@@Cypher4290 You wanna know who wrote BFDI? Michael and Cary. You wanna know how Ice Cube was eliminated? She was effectively written out by getting voted to be eliminated by the eliminated contestants. WRITTEN BY MICHAEL AND CARY.
@@beatboxmario5006 she was only voted off Becuase of snowball thinking she can "cool down the tlc" what kind of logic is that, not to mention that no one really hates icy around this time so if snowball didn't say anything, icy would have gone further
@@Cypher4290 Yeah, and who wrote Snowball to say that?
Shhh I made it 136 likes don't tell anybody here's a dollar
My top three are the same as the top 3 in this what if! (In the same order to.)
OOO cool!
First one here
niceee
10,000th viewer :)
Also no one cares
I CAREEE THANK YOUUUU
“original writing for Ice Cube’s elimination was horrendous and inaccurate”… to what?? THAT’S how they were written. Just because you don’t like the scene doesn’t mean you can pretend it doesn’t exist. Ice Cube was FORCED out of the show by Michael and Cary.
I don’t like Ice Cube that much but it was. Characters like Pencil shouldn’t have voted Ice Cube “to cool down the tlc” when they already has SB. PLUS some of their enemies where there (again Pencil and Match with Rocky AND Spongy) But they STILL voted Ice Cube their ALLIANCE MEMBER. JnJ completely forgot everyone’s relationships to get out Ice Cube and that is terrible writing and Ice Cube got out for something she couldn’t control, usually there is a reason for people elimination (Flower, being mean, Blocky and Pen, cheating etc.) and Icy’s is TO COOL DOWN THE TLC?
EVEN BFDIA TEARDROPS ELIMINATION HAD A REASON BEHIND IT ICYS IS JUST SO BLAND AND PLAYES FOR A JOKE