Sandy lam and faye wong are two very different vocal style . But I personally feels that sandy has been giving me more surprises and wider in her vocal range . Faye wong do best in her comfort zone with her unique voice .gaia has proven sandy's potential in excelling into a broader range of music be it ambience new age jazz R&b etc etc and the list goes on .
Her big win at the awards should be able to shut all critics up . Just face it sandy lam is a true diva and she is always getting better and better . Less commercial but more artistic and honourable .
You are amazing Sandy~~~ Nobody click in to check in here doesn't mean anything at all, you are simply the pride of all HK ppl, along with Danny, Lesile, Roman,家駒and Anita, I am very proud of you, yes, Very Very Much.
To Oliver .I think her big win at the music awards and the awesome Chinese album gaia will be able to convince you . But thanks for taking the time to watch this video .I am sure sandy takes every comments seriously ...That's why she's only getting better and better .can't really think of many artiste her era doing as well as her .
Oliver J, you only ranked this song by commerical sense / value. This is not an Mega IPO that every investor would chip in, instead it was a break through for her own music career. Though I think the MV could have been done better. For her voice, its just awesome. I gave it 8 out of 10 (1 mark deducted from the MV & another 1 mark deducted from being a bit late to release this in her career time line). After all, I admired her courage and persistence.
This has to be one of the most stunning MV in recent years. The music and the visual blend in so perfectly. A new direction from my beloved Sandy Lam. I am so so very proud of you! ;)
I kinda agree that the video is not the best, but I don't think she's trying to appeal to the younger crowd. However, this is one of the songs that the more you listen to, the better it gets
So many people can hear the resemblance with Tori Amos's [god], so u cannot deny the fact the similarity is a lot there. Oh please dont be such a hardcore diehard fans to defend blindly. Btw, we're not accusing her being bad, it's just a very strong resemblance, n that's a fact, even the Sandy said the composer write it in English, so i'm not surprised the composer is a huge fan of Tori too. I bliv Sandy has good taste,n Tori is one of it. As long as she dont claim that she created this style
上週意外發現這首歌，到現在已經聽了好幾十次!!!!
多數人佩服林憶蓮的唱功, 我更佩服作詞人喬星的毅力
"枯榮"的歌詞非常棒
文字裡擁有類似強烈的溫度的東西 一觸碰就傳達到心的最深處
本來感覺微微神經質而偏執的旋律
配著林憶蓮歌聲中美麗的尖刻 在彼此的襯托下
尖刻變成一種爽快而準確的疼
真美。
好聽到爆！特別係月有陰晴虧盈輪遞不停呢句！勁sexy！
沒話說的，憶蓮就是天后中的天后。其他都望塵莫及。
這首歌第一次聽，感覺跟我們常常聽的歌很不一樣，但聽多幾次，我竟然滿腦子整天都是這個旋津和憶蓮的唱法，不斷的重復，這首歌太特別了，真的好好聽，又列入了廣東金曲在歷史上其中最好的作品之一，唱歌的方法，我就不會規定要怎樣，只要唱得好，就應該去唱，不論什么聲線，不要局限自己，唱得完美就是完美，枯榮這首歌雖然說有枯有榮，但落墨點都是在枯，榮也只是枯的開始，最後一切都歸枯，富貴名利是枯，生命是枯，所有結果也是枯，這不是消極，而是認清楚事實真相，不要只看到眼前的榮而己
中~~0心0
中
開頭一聽呢首歌,我分唔出係王菲定林憶蓮唱.......
你閉上眼,腦想起王菲,聽這歌......真的會以為是王菲唱的......把聲有些位好似王菲.....
林憶蓮同王菲我也支持.....實力才是王道
Sandy lam and faye wong are two very different vocal style . But I personally feels that sandy has been giving me more surprises and wider in her vocal range . Faye wong do best in her comfort zone with her unique voice .gaia has proven sandy's potential in excelling into a broader range of music be it ambience new age jazz R&b etc etc and the list goes on .
我好鍾意將枯榮x情誡x關於我一pair咁聽, 紙飛機同旋木, 飛翔同天空...將歌曲能夠量投放到極至...
林憶蓮
枯榮
作詞：喬星
作曲：常石磊
編曲：常石磊
一呼一吸 一眨眼睛
年華如同流雲 化作泡影
出生一刻心跳聲
床前彌留時辰去細聽
驟爾來 在哭聲 驟爾回 沒笑聲
﹡滴答滴答光陰過隙
童年俄而成年 秒秒壓逼
一絲一點想記憶
回頭原來搖籃 悄悄褪色
驟爾來 沒珍惜 驟爾回 未歇息
月有虧盈陰晴 輪遞不停
換到功名虛榮 轉眼如幻影
花事哪可敵過一枯一榮
明艷過 磨蝕了 過程
Sandy, 我打從87年 [ 憶蓮 ] 大碟, 已經成為你的follower, 真的很高興看到你的新嘗試. 從歌詞中聽得到你現在對生命的感受. 長久追隨你的歌迷如我都經歷不少, 人生又豈止只有愛情呢? 這次的內容在你過去的主打歌中是絕無僅有的. 畢竟你和你的歌迷都長大了. 坦白說, 近年來我的耳朵悄悄地被Shirley Kwan吸引過去, 她09年的 [ 山水 ] 給我很大的感受. 我的心問: 為什麼 Sandy 除了愛情的主題外, 很少在主打中流露其他想法呢? 所以很驚訝這次的新曲. 新唱腔方面, 真的給我觸動神經感受, 憶蓮有膽唱, 我就有膽聽呵! 在這裡希望你keep住勇於嘗試的心, 我期待著你的新大碟和9月的演出. JEFFREY
太令人驚艷了
雖然金曲獎入圍的是無言歌, 但這首歌一樣給人震撼的感受, Sandy真的太棒了:)
驚訝! 憶蓮這個mv, 對一直喜歡她的我, 很驚喜! 回想起93年的天大地大, 被dancer抬橋出場那個現場表演, 或者係91年的再生戀mv, 都給我同樣的感覺. 勁!
Her big win at the awards should be able to shut all critics up . Just face it sandy lam is a true diva and she is always getting better and better . Less commercial but more artistic and honourable .
终極地"放縱" 好正~!!!
雖然我不懂廣東話，但是這首歌太棒了！
曲•詞•歌手完美演繹•MV•憶蓮的肢體語言，優秀脫俗，現今亞洲樂壇根本無人可比，真正用心為音樂添上靈魂的好歌者。
喬星 作詞
一呼 一吸 一眨眼睛
年華如同流雲 化作泡影
出生一刻 心跳聲
床前彌留時晨去細聽
驟爾來 在哭聲 驟爾回
沒笑聲
滴答 滴答 光陰過隙
童年俄而成年 秒秒壓逼
一絲一點想記憶
回頭原來搖籃 悄悄褪色
驟爾來 沒珍惜 驟爾回 未歇息
月有虧盈陰晴 輪遞不停
換到功名虛榮 轉眼如幻影
花事哪可敵過一枯一榮
明艷過 磨蝕了過程
一呼 一吸 一眨眼睛
年華如同流雲 化作泡影
出生一刻 心跳聲
床前彌留時晨去細聽
驟爾來 在哭聲 驟爾回 沒笑聲
春光秋色 不堪滿足
回頭沿途繁華 那裡駐足
一章一章演奏曲
如何迷人仍然要結束
驟爾來 但一生 驟爾回
像借宿
月有虧盈陰晴 輪遞不停
換到功名虛榮 轉眼如幻影
花事哪可敵過一枯一榮
明艷過 磨蝕了過程
我雖然唔係林憶蓮既Fans，但我都幾中意聽呢首歌！歌詞好之餘，憶蓮仲演繹得好有韻味！！呢首歌絕對聽得過！仲好洗腦:D
我愛勇於做自己的憶蓮...
Thank Sandy for showing us how a woman can still be creative and beautiful even in the face of time.
You are amazing Sandy~~~ Nobody click in to check in here doesn't mean anything at all, you are simply the pride of all HK ppl, along with Danny, Lesile, Roman,家駒and Anita, I am very proud of you, yes, Very Very Much.
這麼多年依然專心執著地做著自己喜歡的音樂，很高興香港還有這樣的歌手存在。Sandy是不老的天后！
by far one of the best canto song this year. feels like i'm back to the glorious days of canto pop in the 90s.
绝对是个值得尊敬的天后。和王菲不同的是这独一无二的尚子到目前也没人能模仿到。
因為我阿媽成日睇套你是我的命運所以有留意到呢首歌 很佩服SANDY的唱功依然頂級 從綠水清風開始都係咁正
一呼一吸 一眨眼睛
年華如同流雲 化作泡影
出生一刻心跳聲
床前彌留時辰去細聽
驟爾來 在哭聲 驟爾回 沒笑聲
﹡滴答滴答光陰過隙
童年俄而成年 秒秒壓逼
一絲一點想記憶
回頭原來搖籃 悄悄褪色
驟爾來 沒珍惜 驟爾回 未歇息
月有虧盈陰晴 輪遞不停
換到功名虛榮 轉眼如幻影
花事哪可敵過一枯一榮
明艷過 磨蝕了 過程
單論唱功王菲真係比唔上林憶蓮，3:14嘅真聲王菲基本上只能夠用假音處理，而林憶蓮嘅高音係有胸腔共鳴做支撐，更加紮實
林憶蓮唱功很全面 本錢其實普普 但後天技術開發到爐火純青
@@hugovictor5441 是，林憶蓮本身是小嗓，細聲線，先天機能和大嗓門歌手沒法比。但她對歌曲的理解和處理能力一直很強
赞同你说的，但我认为单就审美原因王菲也不会用高音处理那一处。其实我一直觉得这里的高音有点破坏氛围，每次听到都让我跳戏
To Oliver .I think her big win at the music awards and the awesome Chinese album gaia will be able to convince you . But thanks for taking the time to watch this video .I am sure sandy takes every comments seriously ...That's why she's only getting better and better .can't really think of many artiste her era doing as well as her .
很感動! 不能想像一位唱了近30年的歌手還有如此的生命力，仍然每日在挑戰自己，是藝術家的氣節和膽量。
Sandy it's absolutely stunning, so different from what you've done before.
憶蓮完美駑駕這曲風，令樂迷驚喜和享受
新唱法!忆莲永远最棒!希望早日出专辑!
one of the better Canto songs in a long time
太好聽了,好久沒這麼棒的歌曲了.....詞也寫的這麼好^^
支持！ 大爱！
在現在香港樂壇，難再找一個像sandy的歌手了。
之前覺得這首歌很哲，看完MMXI，覺得這首歌SEXY到爆
佢地鍾意點講就點講, 我只覺得林憶蓮今次隻碟既歌世上未必有另一個人carry得到....
好到沒話說！
超正
棒棒棒..最強
天后
Bravo 👏 👏👏👏
Another masterpiece after wild flower!!
Sandy still alive and she is not 無主孤魂！不是枯魂也不是孤榮
好耐聽的一首歌~
omg, this is what i am talking about!!!! sandy in canto = awesome!!!!
Amooooo❤ que atmosfera nostálgica
其它diva消失晒，係得憶蓮仲係走係創作既最前線。d無主枯魂咪入黎踩地盤。憶蓮加油!
Oliver J, you only ranked this song by commerical sense / value. This is not an Mega IPO that every investor would chip in, instead it was a break through for her own music career. Though I think the MV could have been done better. For her voice, its just awesome. I gave it 8 out of 10 (1 mark deducted from the MV & another 1 mark deducted from being a bit late to release this in her career time line). After all, I admired her courage and persistence.
超耐聽.
a song fllled with style, and
the one who fills it with soul and heart is a true stylish artist,
Sandy
旋律写得这么跳跃，只有Sandy能唱了
这是跟《暗涌》一个级别的歌曲。两个天后。
I love this music video. very creative.
我覺得各位應該試下唔好睇住個MV，再合上眼，聽一次先，欣賞下林憶蓮的唱歌技巧，你會發現同以前唔同，對佢黎講係一個新唱法，而且係聲音中感情表達很好，再來就係睇下D歌詞，思索佢想表達既意思，最後再睇MV...你應該會覺同王菲係唔同
原以為MV裡你是比較安靜的，沒想到有這麼多跳舞的動作，想起古老民族祭祀那樣，不知您要表達什麼..但歌曲歌詞都非常喜歡，喜歡你的突破，加油！！
刚开始听还真的觉得像王菲但又不像王菲，后来听介绍才知道是林忆莲出新歌了~
一看MV就深深被吸引， 发现到或许一些转音真的有王菲的影子，但肯定的是两位都是毋庸置疑的天后，各有各的特色!
好好听
我看見您在真的活着!
Simply Perfect!!
其實個唱腔好似王菲後生個時，超迷幻既中文唱腔，個時王菲 + 張亞東呢個組合好正，好多歌都走得好前衛，但王菲既高峰期都過左了，林憶蓮依家都仲同常石磊玩呢類較破格既歌，夠膽唔跟主流走係好事。
你有無聽過憶蓮再生戀，憶蓮係90年代王菲未出土時,已經好有玩味，鍾意創新加中西混合，可能你一向無留意，先話sandy似王菲腔
B S Kok 神仙唱歌粉丝打架哈哈！
Good
这首歌实在是近期歌坛佳作，sandy 三十年仍在不懈努力，实在让人钦佩！！ 可惜youtube 上这首歌的效果不太好，要听她自己上载的就好的多。
我有一个意见，我觉得她这首歌的MV 不应该自己跳舞，或者跳舞也可以，但MV应该截动态图，然后剪接进行后期制作，不应该用动态拍摄的方法。
perfect!!!!!!!!!!
Nice song... MV style made reference to World End Girlfriend and Gossip.
very meaningful song ...........
i love this song!!
好期待9月演唱會啊
Welcome Back!! I love this song and vedio much. :)
amazing.
一呼一吸 一眨眼睛
年華如同流雲 化作泡影
出生一刻心跳聲
床前彌留時辰去細聽
驟爾來 在哭聲
驟爾回 沒笑聲
滴答滴答光陰過隙
童年俄而成年 秒秒壓逼
一絲一點想記憶
回頭原來搖籃 悄悄褪色
驟爾來 沒珍惜
驟爾回 未歇息
月有虧盈陰晴 輪遞不停
換到功名虛榮 轉眼如幻影
花事哪可敵過一枯一榮
明艷過 磨蝕了 過程
一呼一吸 一眨眼睛
年華如同流雲 化作泡影
出生一刻心跳聲
床前彌留時辰去細聽
驟爾來 在哭聲
驟爾回 沒笑聲
春光秋色 不堪滿足
回頭沿途繁華 哪裡駐足
一章一章演奏曲
如何迷人仍然要結束
驟爾來 但一生
驟爾回 像借宿
月有虧盈陰晴 輪遞不停
換到功名虛榮 轉眼如幻影
花事哪可敵過一枯一榮
明艷過 磨蝕了 過程
This has to be one of the most stunning MV in recent years. The music and the visual blend in so perfectly. A new direction from my beloved Sandy Lam. I am so so very proud of you! ;)
i love this song
good song good lyrics.. :)
歌词填得好。。曲风就不是我的茶！但是还是最爱忆连！
SL 三个字"你好ye!!!!!"難以望懷
diva sandy is D Best.
very strange melody and mtv ... its crystal clear she manage it in a immaculate fawless way :)
作曲：常石磊
作詞：喬 星
編曲：常石磊
監製：林憶蓮、常石磊
Mixed By：Kelvin Avon
主唱：林憶蓮
一呼一吸 一眨眼睛
年華如同流雲 化作泡影
出生一刻心跳聲
床前彌留時辰去細聽
驟爾來 在哭聲 驟爾回 沒笑聲
＊ 滴答滴答光陰過隙
童年我而成年 秒秒壓逼
一絲一點想記憶
回頭原來搖籃 悄悄褪色
驟爾來 沒珍惜 驟爾回 未歇息＊
月有虧盈陰晴 輪遞不停
換到功名虛榮 轉眼如幻影
花事哪可敵過一枯一榮
明艷過 磨蝕了 過程
春光秋色 不堪滿足
回頭沿途繁華 哪裡駐足
一章一章演奏曲
如何迷人仍然要結束
驟爾來 但一生
驟爾回 暫借宿
沒錯，MV一開始我就想到lotus flower。。。"枯榮"這首歌是什麼時候發行的? 其實不止MV本身，連編曲都有RH的味道
其實令人最感興趣的是說跟Tori Amos Precious Things相似的人，其耳朵是不是有什麼問題？
想聽莫文蔚唱唱看也...
很喜欢这首歌，应该没人比忆莲更适合演绎。话说......, 忆莲啊，新专辑几时发呀？颈长了呀！！！！！！！
如果憶蓮這樣唱也聽不到每一個字，現在的歌手看來要送進集中營勞改！一字一語，清淅無瑕，可能真的是聽者耳朵有問題！
Wow
Sandy多發發微博吧🥺
sandy有骨氣..知道林夕在媒體前公開的抱怨她後.sandy從此就沒再找過林夕寫詞了.
因為她是憶蓮！別人求她合作也來不及，但她也在歌手唱了多得他！ 其實骨了裡她是重有感情兼義氣的！❤️
覺得王菲和她追求的東西在某些方面是相同的。
I kinda agree that the video is not the best, but I don't think she's trying to appeal to the younger crowd. However, this is one of the songs that the more you listen to, the better it gets
歌風是有點像tori, 但感覺就完全不同, 我唔會因聽"枯榮"而想起tori 任何一首歌, 至於唱得像faye 的只有一句尾最後的一個高音,(但真的很像),而其它完全是憶蓮的聲音, 真的很佩服憶蓬廣東話咬字的工力, 唱得很好聽 A++++
@highartfan01 Thank you, it's pretty good, will she include it in her latest album? I mean a studio version.
So many people can hear the resemblance with Tori Amos's [god], so u cannot deny the fact the similarity is a lot there. Oh please dont be such a hardcore diehard fans to defend blindly.
Btw, we're not accusing her being bad, it's just a very strong resemblance, n that's a fact, even the Sandy said the composer write it in English, so i'm not surprised the composer is a huge fan of Tori too.
I bliv Sandy has good taste,n Tori is one of it. As long as she dont claim that she created this style
thought it's a faye wong's new song when i heard it the first time... ^^
@highartfan01 Thank you for the information! :-)
@lilithdvs13 the main 2 similarity that really obvious are the progression in Piano and also the use of the percussions... :)
歌，好不好听，见仁见智吧。歌，不是每首朗朗上口就好听。
第一次听，也觉得还好罢了。可是，听多几次就不一样了，而且还是越听越好听。
再注意Sandy的唱功，更加不一样。这首是有难度的歌~
听起来（看起来也）很王菲
開心舞?!
btw,首歌好型~!
同埋我諗呢個mv亞視遲d都應該會播下既 (純為宣傳套韓劇)