J vs Ben: We FAILED Even More Harry Potter Trivia - REDEMPTION Quiz
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 січ 2025
- Go to factormeals.com... and use code jvsb50 to get 50% off your first box.
DoorDash app in the App Store and enter code JVSB for 50% off your first order up to a $20 value.
Today J and Ben Face off once more to find out who knows more about the Wizarding World of Harry Potter - BUT the real question is.. Were they paying attention last time, because today all of the questions they BOTH failed from old quizzes!
#supercarlinbrothers #HarryPotter #JvsBen
Edited by :: Riley Murtagh
Chapters:
01:54 - Q1: What ad was not at the World Cup?
03:06 - Q2: What was in Dumbledore and Snape’s Christmas cracker?
07:30 - Q3 How many floors are in the Burrow?
08:58 - Q4: What color PJs was Slughorn wearing?
11:25 - Q5: What flavor ice cream did Hagrid get Harry?
13:02 - Q6: Who did Mrs. Weasley see in her Boggart?
14:24 - Q7: How did Lockhart decorate for Valentines?
20:32 - Q8: What pudding did Petunia make for the Masons?
23:05 - Q9: Who should have arrived at the Burrow first?
24:11 - Q10: Who bet Ludo Bulgaria would score first?
25:44 - Q11: What did Lily say she would choose over James in year 5?
26:26 - Q12: How long was Dudley’s tongue?
27:37 - Q13: What did Hagrid’s class not feed the Skrewts?
28:40 - Q14: What was the first year’s Transfiguration exam?
30:02 - Q15: What other shop sells wands?
Carlin Brothers Coffee ►► www.CarlinBrot...
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► www.SuperCarlin...
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
T W I T T E R➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..) - Фільми й анімація
Think you can stump us?! Become a Quiz Master and Submit your own questions!
www.patreon.com/SuperCarlinBrothers
Hi!!!
@@ThechosenoneeditsHello :)
Wassup guys.
BEN WIN
I wanted to make Harry Potter videos, should i start a new channel for it?
My favorite part of j vs Ben is when they have different answers so Ben just assumes his is wrong, but then it turns out that j is actually wrong. The pure joy on bens face after that I love it! I feel this exact same way with my husband cause he always knows more trivia than me and is usually right so when I think it's different I'm convinced I'm wrong. Nice feeling when it's the other way
Ben clearly has high-level expectation management skills
You guys should do a quiz on the movie-only scenes. I think that would be so funny! Sometimes I forget which scenes are book-only and which are movie-only.
they do have one movies quiz posted
yes, they do I searched it up on UA-cam for you. because I knew it was a quiz, I had watched recently in my current harry potter hyper fixation, here's the link I hope you enjoy.
ua-cam.com/video/eFByKEGbJ2M/v-deo.html
@Skye Johnson replying so I can find this link later. Don't mind me lol
If curious minds want to know, Lilac is a lighter purple with pink undertones & Lavender is a deeper purple with violet undertones. My aunt was a florist for 20 years & she made sure to engrave that random fact into my brain for some reason.
It's both purple -> they're basically the same
@@Jan_Koopman They are both shades of purple, but lilac leans closer to the red side of the spectrum while lavender leans more toward the blue.
I know it’s so much extra work but I’d love to see their previous answers on screen to compare to their current answers
Ya agree would be brutal for the editor but super fun for viewers
They did that last time I believe
Ya! It would be great to see the clip of their original attempt followed by their current
Yes, that was so funny last time!
Yeah it is a lot of extra work for Riley, but it would be funny to see what they said last time.
Ben clearly has a vault in his brain that does its best to store all forgotten Harry Potter knowledge 😂
Yep. I love the way Ben's brain works. He seems to have a locker room in his brain that is helping him get better at remembering obscure facts.
@Sadhbh Corr yeah and I love that they talk out their thinking to there answers even if they get it wrong. Mainly because I do the same when I do quizes but still it is fun hearing there logic to their answers
The vault stores it fine, he just stores the combo in the vault
This may seem random, but THANK YOU for using the proper form of "its" in your post! It drives me crazy when people use the contraction in place of the possessive pronoun. Way to go! 🎉
Love that I stumped at least Jay twice and Ben once. Worth the price of quizmaster patreon admission!
YES! Another Redemption quiz! This is my favorite subcategory of J vs Ben quizzes. I agree with J's theory about the vulture hat for Snape (Lupin setting up the joke and Dumbledore rigging the popper).
Suggestion: showing their previous response would be great!!
They did that on the previous quiz like this
J sounds so much like Ben in this quiz 😂
"I have an answer, im not confident"
I happened to pause this right when they were told that ron and tonks was the right answer to one of the questions, and their expressions are priceless 😂 love it!
Please never stop making this series currently binge watching all the Harry Potter quizzes
This video was a lot of fun, but I'm really disappointed they didn't have their previous answers available the way they did for the other failed questions videos. That's part of the fun - to see if they fall into the same answer traps as last time.
Ben peeking at the cake during the DoorDash ad confirms that he is slowly turning into a dog considering he has two of them!!!!
For future reference to everyone, Benjy Fenwick never appeared in the main story in person. Moody mentioned him when he showed Harry the photo of the first Order of the Phoenix. Benjy was a member who got cornered by Death Eaters and, as Moody put it, the Order "only found bits of him".
Who else would love a 'wrong answers only' HPquiz?
Yes!
Yes please
Ooo, sounds fun!
would love this, and who ever has the funniest answer gets the point. ez
OMG yes! What does Percy offer Harry at the start of term feast: A Red Lightsaber. J and Ben, please do it. Make it happen, I would be very down for that.
THAT "8th story" sounds honestly SOOO much better than "The Cursed Child"!! Would TOTALLY go watch THAT story!! Oh, my gosh!! Maybe you guys could write a Wizard Comedy or something!! 🤣🤣🤣
3:53 “it’s something that bothers snape….” So pretty much anything then 😂😂
12:49 I love how excited they were by the fact that we call sprinkles hundreds and thousands
BEN my man winning big! Awesome love it when Ben wins.
I enjoy the quiz, but I enjoy just as much their interaction, stories and other peripheral knowledge.
The thing about them feeding grass snakes to the skrewts is weird, because Harry would be able to talk to the snakes....I can sort of imagine Harry being like "Do you want to be fed to a skrewt?" and the snake being like "no", and Harry just letting it slither off to the Forbidden Forest.
A quiz where you ask questions like "According to SCB, what magical creature is Argus Filch?"? That sounds pretty dang fun. I'd definitely watch that. Though hopefully at least some of the questions are harder than that one :P
Maybe go SUPER far back and ask "In SCB's revised rules of Quidditch, what extra role were Seekers given?" That one might be a bit trickier :D
That would be really interesting to see how many of their own theories they remember haha
You know what would be interesting? A what if quiz, including answers from all their what if videos
Ben STOMPED J. My life is finally complete ❤
As he cheated.
Ben's been winning quite a bit lately its been nice
@@w0rmfarts because hes been cheating? Kinda defeats the point of the competition if you ask me. I used to always route for Ben but with his cheating problem it makes it really hard to do so now.
@@mreevee7785 are you joking I can't tell
@@w0rmfarts no, why would i be joking?
LOL I love watching you guys take these quizzes. J is becoming more and more charming when he gets them wrong. LOL
I’ve looked back in the book, and actually for the first question all of them were advertisements for the Quidditch World Cup
1st question was a trick question. The book had Mrs SKOWER’S All-Purpose Magical Mess-Remover. The incorrect answer here was Mrs SHOWER’S
The hat question gets me everytime but I knew a vulture would be too obscure to be wrong
I always remember that one cause it was Nevilles grandma's hat
I only remembered it as soon they brought up about Neville's Boggart.
I remembered it because it was a big talking point in their "Dumbledore Hates Snape" video lol
Actually guys, there is a big difference between lilac & lavender! Lilac is always a pale purple that is definitely leaning toward pink, meaning it has more red to its tone than blue. Lavender can be pale to medium in intensity & is always a blue-purple or equally balanced purple that can't be mistaken for pink in any way. To help remember you can think of the old poem that says "lavender's blue, dilly dilly..." referring to the flower color.
Fact Check!
Benjy Fenwick was a member of the Order of the Phoenix. Apparently, they "only ever found bits of him"
Probably thinking of Marcus Belby, the only Slug Club train meeting person who doesn't show up later (the others being McLaggen, Zabini and of course Ginny Neville and Harry)
And a Grass Snake is one of the three kinds of snake that can be found in the UK. Along with that escaped Boa from the zoo apparently
Benjy Fenwick was the kid in the 70's who got hit by the Whomping Willow and went blind in one eye because some of the younger students were playing a game where they were trying to get as close to the trunk as possible without getting hit and he got hit
I think in the movie it’s Robbie Fenwick that bites Hermione’s father, so Ben was pretty close lol!
I thought that was someone Gudgeon and they said like maybe he was related to Gladys Gudgeon (the Gilderoy Lockhart fan)?
Wait, have there been edited in this, or was this how it got recorded?
9:01 - Question 4: "What colour pyjamas was Horace Slughorn wearing, when Harry and Dumbledore paid him a visit?"
-and the answer is Lockhart's favorite colour, Lilac? Have I missed something?
In the movie, the actor playing Slughorn is wearing a blue-white striped pyjamas
I caught this as well and had to go back and re-watch it then went straight to the comments to see if I was the only one who caught it.
@@1wildhorsefeather I had to go read the book....! But yep, sure. It does indeed say, well, Danish name; purple/lilac... I still find it odd, with the pyjamas in the movie then
Not sure if the quiz got the first question wrong, but if you read the chapter in book four, all the options were actually advertised
So that was a movie only question. Glad to see I'm not losing it after reading book 3 last week.
The options said mrs. showers magical mess remover and the actual product is mrs. scowers magical mess remover
I need kat to know that I always wave right back at her (even though she can't see)
Ben is eating good training for a marathon and then
J is door dashing cakes Infront of him 😂😂😂
I’m literally listening to the series again right now. Ant wait to see how I go in the quiz alongside you guys. Bring it on.
We call sprinkles 100’s & 1000’s in Australia too. I got 1 more question right than Ben. Well done guys, funny upload as always.
I'm from QLD and 100's & 1000's are round and sprinkles are the long ones.
Your trivias are so cool! Love them! Keep the videos coming!
4:13 Fun fact: according to psychologists and others who would know, when we remember things we don't really remember them, we remember the last time we remembered them. So like, Ben won't be remembering the book so much as remembering when they took the quiz and failed and was told the answer. Unless he read the book since the previous quiz.
After the Hundred and Thousands chat, please can we have a 'Is it magical or british?' Quiz lol
The tea cozy thing was part of dobby's outfit later on in the books... it was his hat
Get this so they will actually read it!
...
...
...
...
Kat, you are right, Jimmies are a New England thing! But the name only applies to the chocolate sprinkles, the multi colored ones are called Sprinkles.
I was looking forward to the questions from the World Cup quiz, because it remains to this day the funniest and most miserable episode you guys have ever done.
I have always wondered about all the cool stuff you guys have displayed behind you when you do these quizzes, where did you get the captain america shield, as to me that's the comic book shield and not the movie and I'd love to hunt it myself
YAAA More Quizzes! I love y'all and how much you do for us!
They can’t even help writing AU fanfic now. I love it 🥰
Oooooooh! I watch a lot of British TV shows (Taskmaster, Would I Lie to You, etc), and they would frequently mention hundreds and thousands. I always thought they were talking about a chocolate bar.
The jokes and tangents make me want them to write a book series even more.
Woo Ben! 🎉
Redemption quiz! Let's go! I really like these!! :D
I feel a really torturous idea to do would be make a 15 question quiz there 7 of the questions J got wrong, and 7 of the questions Ben got wrong, but the other person got right, and 1 question where they both got it wrong (this is mostly just to keep it fair and keep w/ the pattern of 15 question quizzes), but you never say who got which ones wrong, that way they'll always be second guessing themselves.
I don't really agree with the "number of floors that the Burrow has" question... It should at least be defined what constitutes a "floor". The only reason I thought about this at all is because I've been doing another readthrough recently and noticed a point in CoS that says Ron's room is on the fifth floor. Since I consider the attic to be a floor (although I know that's debatable), I would have said 6 since he lives right underneath the ghoul, but checking it out just now, I realized I had forgotten this is a European layout which starts at the ground floor followed by the first and then second and so on meaning the number of floors should really be at least 6 and 7 if you count the attic. Regardless, great content as always - please keep it up!
Congratulations you’re the lucky winner of the ongoing giveaway dm me to claim your prize 🏆 🎉🎉…
Seeing J make a friends reference made me want to watch them do a friends quiz
Vulture hat and lilac are the ones I could remember and it was solely because of the discussion around those answers when you both previously got them wrong. And I thought it was mouse into a tea cup but maybe that was the scene in the movie.
5:57 “I kept thinking yea cozy but that’s not a hat” Dobby would beg to differ my good sir
Ben is right in the book Neville envisions Snape wearing a big hat with a stuffed vulture because it's what his grandmother usually wears. Of course soon the whole school knows about it and let's just say Snape is not amused about it because everyone laughs about it (and for a kid that experienced mobbing in the past that must feel really bad for Snape remembering him of his school time in Hogwarts)
Benjy Fenwick was a member of the original Order, Moody said he was essentially blasted apart. "Benjy Fenwick, he copped it too, we only ever found bits of him . . ."
The boy that bit Hermione's father was ROBBIE Fenwick :)
In Hogwart Legacy one of the characters is giving player literal quiz with multiple choices. I wish you could take this one :D (Edit, I checked - it was Sophronia Franklin in the library and there was 25 question, 5 very easy but it was getting harder and harder)
i am pre sure the burrow question comes from that quiz actually if my memory serves me correctly, probably how i remember that the answer was actually and not 5 since i played through that part of the game and was having a difficult time with the quiz myself at some points.
Came here from the trivia, thanks for the good time guys!
Gudgeon's Revenge... still a better story than Cursed Child lol
I actually got a few questions right, including (but not limited to) the number of levels to the Weasley home and about the 1st Year Exam of turning mice to snuffboxes. Of course, I only remembered the exam one due to the Harry Potter Trading Card Game from 2001. I still have a ton of those cards.
14:30 maybe bc he works with dragons, Molly just thinks Charlie’s somehow invincible
I was waiting for this kind of quiz to happen.
I live in New England and I grew up calling chocolate sprinkles Jimmies. I never got the rainbow ones because they didn't taste like anything special. I still do love the chocolate ones on maple walnut ice-cream.
Your Harry Potter quizzes are amazing.
Harry Potter/ Friends crossover! Love it. The two things I have in my ears on repeat constantly 😂
13:35 The names are in the order that Mrs. Weasley met them in universe. Starting with her husband, then her offspring from oldest to youngest, then Harry, then Hermione.
This is what we’re supposed to be learning in school
I’d love to see a J vs Ben SCB theories quiz.
Can we for a moment admire how powerful Ron is? He semi successfully transfigured a human.
Hey guys. Thanks for the entire day's worth of fun content. 😊
I just got off the Kahoot! Love this channel!
Yes, please do a past theories quiz!!!
Brilliant once again!
Would be great to have bits of the originals intercut with the redemption quiz :)
I love the J vs Ben videos. I really enjoy the banter between you two! ❤
These quizzes are my favorite on this channel. I would love if you guys added clips from the first time you tried the questions, to remind us what you guessed last time, or clips of your reactions to hearing you got it wrong the first and second times 😂
Ben I want to let you to know that I'm always rooting for you during trivia.
The problem with the vulture hat thing is that Boggart Snape wears one as Neville’s Gran. So I always think it’s just in that instance. But no, that’s also why it upsets him at Christmas. 😂
I love that Kangaroo Kat says BYE!! At the end too!!
Woah I got the Molly’s boggart question right! I remember getting it wrong last time and being irritated. 😂
Stoked about a factor code. I've gotten 2 boxes. Super great for my adhd!
Just an FYI “hundreds and thousands” are normally the ball shaped sprinkles rather than rods… but I’ve heard people use it for the sugar strands too… people normally call the little wands just “sprinkles” in my experience in the UK but feel free to use it for both!
Raise your hand if you're coming here from the trivia stream ✋
🙌
🖐
✋
Yes, but after watching the replay of the trivia haha. I sadly have a prior engagement every Friday night.
You know now you will need to write that book right? Cause I want Auror Harry fighting James 😂
2:40 NO! Mrs. Skowers was absolutely one of the ads!
Unless it's because her name was spelled wrong?
Bertie Botts wasnt there, though?
Trivia Stream, J v.s. B . and Box Breakers, I guess it's "Super Carlin Super Friday"
Huzzah for Ben! What an awesome quiz. I'm sure J will reclaim is King of Quizzes title soon.
Oh, Ben, such growth ♥ Good job! So proud
This is the first time i hear americans say that hundreds amd thousands is a better name for sprinkles
As someone from the U.K., now I want to buy a tub of hundreds and thousands and take them with me the next time I visit Roanoke (which I do regularly) on the off chance I may ever run into Jay or Ben and be able to gift them.
God, I love these, the lore videos and the theories so much
I like how both times, they remembered the mess remover ad, but failed to recognize that it was "Ms. Skower" in the book, not Shower.
I just read the Like a Red Headed Stepchild fanfic, and I can’t recommend it enough. Lockhart is a total boss and becomes the legendary wizard he was meant to be
I do have to wonder... is there such thing as 'food grade' wandwork? Like, is it advised that people using wandwork in culinary arts 'cleanse' their wands in some way before cooking with it?
hey bros, I was thinking you guys need to play through all the harry potter games
I feel like lilac (and how it's not lavender) needs a t-shirt.
So J and Ben, you actually have an out for the first question, because some versions of Harry Potter and The Goblet of Fire (specifically the pdf version I'm currently rereading) list ALL FOUR options given as ads during The World Cup
I recently watched the previous redemption episodes. The last one had a multiple choice limit of three times.
31:24 actually Gladys Gudgeon's husband could be Davies Gudgeon! He's mentioned in Prisoner of Azkaban as beeing th kid that was severely injured by the whomping willow.
Ron made it snow after losing Lanvender Brown after he'd been saved from the poisoning from eating the love potion chocolate. It's a movie thing, I don't remember it happening in the book(s).
I have an an idea for a quiz:
Theory trivia, so long story short you could do questions about like when you did this theory or like the name of Fox’s original owner. (mostly older theories to make it harder.) This would be hard but maybe a fhn idea?
some of these kinda feel like trick questions, like #1 is actually d and that is only because it is misspelled, #3 UK and US have different numbering schemes, UK starts at G then 1,2,3 whereas the US, Ground floor is 1st floor, so while Ron's room would be 5th floor in UK, it's actually the 6th floor for US, and not counting the attic as a floor itself, #15 requires a very keen movie eye, as for the flowered bonnet and rear admiral's hats those were from the first year Christmas crackers Dumbledore got the bonnet Harry got the admiral's, matches to needles was start to transfiguration, porcupine (hedgehog) to pin cushion was a lesson in either 3rd or 4th year