Conversely, last week I heard the North Korean refugee Yeonmi Park say about the mental health of young adults today: “Their problem is not having a problem.”
@@brantpam222 yeah funny enough, they keep on claiming the whole land is theirs, I havn't seen even once an arab stick to the facts of so many lands been sold to jews ashkenazim and mizrahim, before and at the dawn of modern zionism, I honestly dont care about these sayings usually but its frustrating to work with people who deny historically proven facts, take for example my city of Hadera, its name originally was al-khadara which means in arabic the green one, or something similiar you can check me if you want, it was purchased by yeusha hankin at 1891and was then developed into a small town. the jews of this era didn't want any conflict nor to contront anyone, but when your neighbor is trying to kill you for who you are, and because of the rise of nationalism, yes I do support the nakbaa, you cant expect a group of people who had been prosecuted for so long and reached its peak after thousands of years of exile, to do nothing when you are trying to take their most precious thing of all, freedom and properity. And even after you try to take it and still loses you cant whine about it for 70 years, well today you can and for some dumb retarded reason it works but yeah that's just humans being humans hahaha...
@brantpam222 there's soft-ass living where the color of the carpet can be traumatizing and then there's the real world, where if you don't look for problems with your neighbors, you're not likely to find many.
I'm confused by this woman. First she claims that it's all their land and all of it is Palestine. But then when she's asked, she says she doesn't want to be Palestinian? Which is it? It makes no sense to me.
Although for it, you get a lot more than we do in the US. I mass the same comment about Europeans paying way more than 40%, and I got jumped! No one believes me!
Indeed we israelis are blessed to live happily with our arab community and many of the arabs too Although there are exceptions in both sides who commit terrorism but fortunately settlers are getting jailed in Israel btw if you want to learn about iskam a good channel is apostate prophet
Nothing but the truth. Real Arab Israelis love Israel because it's the only free country in the middle east. They can be and do whatever the want. This only happens in israel.. Try different Arab country and you will not go far.
My step-dad was a WWII Vet. When I was a young girl back in the 70's he told me something about Israel/Palestine that history books & media ignore. After the discovery of what happened to the Jewish people in Europe they began to move back to their homeland, Israel (God said that would happen in the Bible). At the time the people were making their move back, a call went out in the middle east to the (more radicalized) Muslims to move TO Israel. They wanted to over take the land and prevent them from RETURNING to their homeland. Many of them say today they want "Israel to be wiped off the map" and "the name Israel to be remembered no more". Interestingly, the Bible said they would say that in the latter days, nearly verbatim, written 2500 to 3500 years ago. Most of the "Palestinians" in Israel live there in peace and live happy normal lives. It's the radicals there and in other countries, such as Iran, that cause the chaos. Israel started being called Palestine during the time of the Roman occupation just over 2000 years ago. As a play on the word Philistine, it was made to be an insult to them as their historical enemies were the Philistines (the giant tribe of Goliath).
yes she probably prefers the demographics of her people but wants want the jews have built same in america minorities want the quality of life mostly built by white people but want the demographics to be mostly people of color
They probably called themselves "Arabs." Before the KGB and Arafat invented the "Palestinian people™" in the 1960s, it was an insult to call An Arab there a "Palestinian," it was tantamount to calling them a "dirty Jew." They insisted on being called "Arabs" or sometimes "Syrians."
Ami what's going on in universities there? Would you ever get a chance to visit the same uni our Ms Wannabe-Lawyer is graduating from? Are the universtities there suffering from the same diseases our universities are suffering?
These people basically said “I want to live and let live and so do they.” Kinda hard to argue for Palestine. The one chick said it perfect, she wants Israeli laws but to be called Palestine but knows that doesn’t work like that
Isreal is a progressive country, but there are Jewish and Muslim extremists. As far as the West Bank and Golan Heights, those are high grounds from which enemies of Israel tried to rain down hell from. If Israel gives those to their enemies, that would put them in an extremely vulnerable position - again.
i'm confused, the woman who was so passionate about how the land is palestinian, and things were so unjust, and palestinians are second class citizens doesn't want to be a palestinian?
It's because she's a hypocrite , her reasoning for it being unfair in Israel is not true as well, everyone pays the same taxes, she doesn't pay more than other Israeli citizens. She's not "Class B citizen" there's no such thing in Israel, but deep down she knows she's privileged to live in a democratic country that is flourishing and giving her equal rights, even pushes her to study (by giving lower acceptance requirements in universities and financial support for Arabs who want to study) , replacing that with a dictatorship that pushes for war and does not care for their citizens is not even an option for anyone who knows what's good for them even if they identify with Palestine more than Israel.
Don’t be confused my friend 😂she’s dreaming fantasyland 😂. Go watch David Woods archives/ CIRA international. They explain very well the condition of women ❤
Rhodesia had black vote Rhodesian military was over half black Hugh Masekela said in youth they would sneak out of curfew and it was so safe and the streets were immaculate We have lost so much Betrayed so much Palestinians will never undo Israel Only Israelis can make that happen
same here in the U.S., for those of us who prefer freedom, but with government intervention you don't get freedom. all governments any where are anti freedom. and same here with taxes, we have to pay taxes for things we don't want and didn't ask for
I recently spent time working in Israel. I lived in Jafo in Tel Aviv and in my neighbourhood most of the restaurants, businesses, shops were Arab owned. Jews, Christians and Moslems lived together peacefully and I will point out to the ignorant that many Arabs are Christian. I have no axe to grind here, I’m not Israeli, I’m not Jewish. I was a foreigner who saw what he saw. The only threat came from madmen in Hamas sending fools across the border to kill and to die uselessly.
funny how disaffected people believe that a social change will hand them a golden life. Yet inevitably it would be much worse within a system without the social safety nets they currently have.
One person said things are ok until the government gets involved (no details though). The one complaining about taxes seemed to imply that her taxes were different than those of an Israeli Jew(?) - That wasn't too clear. Didn't hear anyone say that they were being oppressed by police, army etc. 1 lady: "the best" we have everything, compared to other countries really really good, then, later: would prefer it was palestine(?)
Fantastic video again Ami -- Thanks. This video needs to have 179 million views.. Maybe for a video you could visit a town in US and ask how safe it would be for Jews if the Government offered a deal similar to what PA gives to its people (Families of individuals killed by Israeli security forces are paid stipends of about $800 to $1,000 per month. The families of convicted Palestinians serving time in Israeli prisons receive $3,000 or higher per month. Douglas J. Feith calls the stipends "cash incentives" to spur Arabs to undertake car ramming and stabbing) I want to be like Ami !!!!
There is a journalistic mistake in the opening of the video. When critics refer to Israel as an apartheid state, it is because it holds jurisdiction over the West Bank and the Palestinians who live there via a military occupation, but does not grant the Palestinians in the West Bank the right to vote or have legal representation in the Israeli government. In other words, Palestinians in the West Bank are ruled by the Israeli government, but do not have the legal rights that Israelis have. And, critics are not referring to the status of Israeli Arabs (Palestinians who live in Israel) when claiming Israel practices apartheid, but rather the status of Palestinians in the West Bank who are under Israeli control.
And there are a couple mistakes in your comment. :P Gaza is now an independent nation. Tragically, their government has been a terrorist ran for years, hence the abysmal loving conditions. :/ On the West Bank, can you explain how the situation came about in the first place and how every peace treaty has ended? :/
Most uninformed people dont know that there are 2 million Arab Israeli citizens with full civil rights. This is an inconvenient truth that peddlers of the Israel is an Apartheid State skip over.
West Bank is not governed by Israel. PLO has control and governance of the region. They vote for their own leaders. They just elect terrorosts constantly
Well, the only issue that the law student has, is that she wishes that Muslims holidays would be honored, too, which is a valid point. However, she still likes Israel better. 😃❤️ But, there are five mosques in Jerusalem. And, there are only five synagogues in the United Arab Emirates, in the Arab countries. 😃❤️
Now go to Taiwan and ask the people if they consider themselves Chinese. The game of politics is played on the people, no matter what country you go to.
Oke that's interesting. The women want Palestine but only one thinks it will be better if the Palestinians make the law.. and she is going to be a lawyer.
I guess governments all over the world create division among their people. I'm glad it's not just my government, but sad that it happens at all. Great video.
Jaljuliya is a tiny Arab town of 10,000 in the middle of the Central District of Israel, where the population is >90% Jewish and is the most developed part of the country. They could've tried speaking to Arabs in Nazareth, which is solid 99.8% Arab with a population of 80,000, and see what their opinions were. Or maybe Haifa, and actual metropolis where 20% of the city is Arab. Regions where the Israeli government has neglected education and infrastructure for decades and the locals routinely complain of being mistreated by the central government. The fact that Ami and PragerU think we can't do a simple Google search is really telling.
Ari Horowitz goes to a village in Israel asks questions: What's it like for Arabs living there: #1: Everyone is together #2: Everywhere I go with joy, with happiness. It's so nice. We live in a country that gives us many thing. From the perspective of the laws it's the best. In comparison to other countries gets really good #3: Very good. Good job. good money #1: But the people the relationships with each other is great. It's just the politicians. #4: I think it's the politicians that create problems for us. I've been working with them for many years never have I had a problem #5: It sucks. I am against the country. If I work 10 hours the government . takes 4 hours in taxes. We are second-class here. #6: Israel has more benefits and more democracy Palestine doesn't
That hateful woman lied; we Jews in the state of Israel also pay the same taxes. In fact, we pay slightly more. She should recognise her privilege...And she doesn't want to be Palestinian xD
That one woman is funny cause if she lived in Palestine or an Israel controlled by Palestinians, she wouldn't be able to dress the way she does. And the other woman saying she wants to live in Palestine with the laws of Israel. Well that aint happening, EVER and she as a Muslim should know that.
@@amihorowitz "I spoke to Arabs living in Israel to find out what it's like to live there" sounds more clickbaity and also interesting but your title is fine tbh
@@kobi2024 True, but there is also only one Denmark and one Sweden and.. But why is he trying to find out how well muslims are living in Israel do you think?
The term "apartheid state" has been used to describe the situation in which around 2 million Palestinians are living under Israeli military administration. This arrangement, which has been ongoing for many years, has become a source of tension and controversy. Some Israeli friends warn that if this situation persists, it could lead to allegations of apartheid, which would be damaging to Israel's reputation. There are different viewpoints on how to address this issue. Some suggest that the Palestinians living under military administration should be granted citizenship, but this option is not without its challenges. Others propose that the Palestinians should become citizens of the Palestinian Authority, which would require significant changes to the political and legal structures of the region.
It's false to say that 2 million "Palestinians" are living under an Israeli military administration. The "Palestinians" haven't lived under a military administration since 1994, almost 30 years. 97% of Arabs in Judea and Samaria and 100% in Gaza, live under their own rule, the PA and Hamas, respectively.
@@microchip470 you're right the numbers are incorrect. According to estimates by the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), there are approximately 300,000 Palestinians living in Area C of the West Bank, which is under full Israeli control. what should do with them almost half a million Palestinians?
@@yigalgurevitch2936 From what I have read, those under occupation refuse Israeli citizenship as well, but also refuse to give up the region they live in. If that is the case with every peace treaty being rejected at the international level, I’m not sure peace is possible until the unreceptive side can offer an olive branch. :/
@@yigalgurevitch2936 It depends on what Israel wants to do with the territory. If Israel wants to apply its sovereignty over all of Area C, then the Arabs that live there will be given legal residency with the option to obtain citizenship. This is similar to what happened to the Arabs who live in eastern Jerusalem. Many Arabs prefer to be legal residents because it entitles them to receive welfare benefits, but they largely reject citizenship for ideological reasons. It's also possible that Israel will apply sovereignty to areas without a(n) (large) Arab population. In this case, the Arabs would become the PA's responsibility. These are all hypothetical scenarios, and it depends on Israel and to some extent the PA as to what exactly happens.
Brother the Jews have been living in Palestine for such quite time before they even was a Zionist regime and there are anti-Zionist orthodox Jews that would be by your side to say designers regime doesn’t represent the Jews and that the Jews do not support the Zionist regime And at one point Jews and Arabs were babysitting each other’s children at one point But even so civilian population on both sides of this argument would have their fair share of what they would think about life living on this particular side of the argument regardless of the politics best I can say 🇮🇱🇵🇸
No they are not. Bruh wtf. They protest with fakestenian flags and call for Israel’s destruction and still live there very well. If it was up to me I would deport them to their imaginary country they would be crying.
LOL, its funny to see that everyone in the video agreed to your so called positive side of Israel(Occupied Palestine), but how come, all people of one village have almost same thinking, dude, if you're lying then lie intelligently not blindly. There is a saying: Be careful when you follow the masses because sometimes M is silent.
Well because there are to be a lot more than that but even so they are on the Israeli side of the argument this is not the West Bank and many Arab citizens on the Israeli side of the argument are glad to be part of it when seeing this as a society of freedom and democracy And wouldn’t trade that for anything but even so doesn’t change the fact of how things are going on the soils of places like the West Bank and so on and it comes to Palestinians being occupied by Israeli troops But the civilian population can have their own opinions of things in these matters regardless of the politics best I can say 🇮🇱🇵🇸
The problem with Islam is that it doesn't recognize the Western principles of separation of "State and Church" Islam is not compatible with Free Democracy. And when there is no Democracy there's no Freedom and no prosperity.
@@carlbook2051 It stands to reason, what did he expect Palestinians in Israel to say? I hate the country I work and make a living in, among anything else they may want to get off their collective chests? I'd imagine they'd foster some kind of negative feedback if their employeer knew. I'm sure the interviewer would've got differing answers had he went into what little area Palestine has and continues to lose via illegal settler annexation. I much prefer an unbias channel like "Ask Israelies/Ask Palestinians", where the interviewer, interviews many walks of life in both Israel and Palestine, and gets a various amount of answers from all sorts of topics. You get a more precise sense of the pov of the people and some really surprising insights I myself haven't entertained.
The best line in this video is if you want problems, you will find problems.
Conversely, last week I heard the North Korean refugee Yeonmi Park say about the mental health of young adults today:
“Their problem is not having a problem.”
@@brantpam222 yeah funny enough, they keep on claiming the whole land is theirs, I havn't seen even once an arab stick to the facts of so many lands been sold to jews ashkenazim and mizrahim, before and at the dawn of modern zionism, I honestly dont care about these sayings usually but its frustrating to work with people who deny historically proven facts, take for example my city of Hadera, its name originally was al-khadara which means in arabic the green one, or something similiar you can check me if you want, it was purchased by yeusha hankin at 1891and was then developed into a small town.
the jews of this era didn't want any conflict nor to contront anyone, but when your neighbor is trying to kill you for who you are, and because of the rise of nationalism, yes I do support the nakbaa, you cant expect a group of people who had been prosecuted for so long and reached its peak after thousands of years of exile, to do nothing when you are trying to take their most precious thing of all, freedom and properity.
And even after you try to take it and still loses you cant whine about it for 70 years, well today you can and for some dumb retarded reason it works but yeah that's just humans being humans hahaha...
That's how it works.
@brantpam222 there's soft-ass living where the color of the carpet can be traumatizing and then there's the real world, where if you don't look for problems with your neighbors, you're not likely to find many.
And if you work hard to get more problems, you most certainly will achieve your goal.
This video needs to get pushed to the top of the UA-cam algorithm right now.
Bless you for the work you do Ami, and thank you for doing this work.
SCAM >>> @ᴀᴍɪ ʜᴏʀᴏᴡɪᴛᴢ
One spoiled brat hates it there but you know she won't leave 🙄
THis was exactly my thought!
scary to think a hateful one like her is gonna become a lawyer.. she gonna cause so much harm if she gets into a position like that.
Annoyed that they don't celebrate Muslim holiday. Watch her become one of those politicians that everyone else complained about.
Just shows there are white guilt Democrats everywhere and of course she still wouldn't leave but had to bitch.
I'm confused by this woman. First she claims that it's all their land and all of it is Palestine. But then when she's asked, she says she doesn't want to be Palestinian? Which is it? It makes no sense to me.
"Hey can I please trade places with that woman paying only 40% in taxes?!" said every European tax-payer.
No one said that 😂😂... 40% is ridiculous
@@IAmZanderStewart Of course it's ridiculous, but Europeans pay more!
@@IAmZanderStewart ... in Belgium it's more like 55 %.
She’s not paying any taxes I guarantee you
Although for it, you get a lot more than we do in the US. I mass the same comment about Europeans paying way more than 40%, and I got jumped! No one believes me!
Love when I see a notification that Ami has posted a new video 😊😊😊😊
Ami is my second favorite jew
@@jhallin5185 After whom?
@@justingolden21 jesus
@@jhallin5185 🤣
@@rafirosin it seems like I found someone I know
I am amazed and surprised. Nothing is as simple as it seems. Thanks Ami.
I enjoyed the joyful lady in black. She seemed very honest with her answers and had a pleasant smile.
Indeed we israelis are blessed to live happily with our arab community and many of the arabs too
Although there are exceptions in both sides who commit terrorism but fortunately settlers are getting jailed in Israel
btw if you want to learn about iskam a good channel is apostate prophet
" I'm studying to be a lawyer "..... try that in Saudi arabia.
Nothing but the truth. Real Arab Israelis love Israel because it's the only free country in the middle east. They can be and do whatever the want. This only happens in israel.. Try different Arab country and you will not go far.
🤔 no one believes that crap i visited hifa and Jerusalem the settlers treat Arab badly
I love how you are speak for us isreal is the least democratic country on earth and is currently expelling Christian’s from the holy land
Jews are expelling the Christian’s of Nazareth and bethehelem no Arab is safe
@@Mudmuffin what drugs are you on
My step-dad was a WWII Vet. When I was a young girl back in the 70's he told me something about Israel/Palestine that history books & media ignore. After the discovery of what happened to the Jewish people in Europe they began to move back to their homeland, Israel (God said that would happen in the Bible). At the time the people were making their move back, a call went out in the middle east to the (more radicalized) Muslims to move TO Israel. They wanted to over take the land and prevent them from RETURNING to their homeland. Many of them say today they want "Israel to be wiped off the map" and "the name Israel to be remembered no more". Interestingly, the Bible said they would say that in the latter days, nearly verbatim, written 2500 to 3500 years ago. Most of the "Palestinians" in Israel live there in peace and live happy normal lives. It's the radicals there and in other countries, such as Iran, that cause the chaos.
Israel started being called Palestine during the time of the Roman occupation just over 2000 years ago. As a play on the word Philistine, it was made to be an insult to them as their historical enemies were the Philistines (the giant tribe of Goliath).
Christ was born 2023 years ago. The Bible, in its entirety, is much MUCH younger than Jesus by several hundred years.
Yes. The 'Palestinians' are just migrants who took advantage of the situation and now claim that they always lived there.
@@TingTingalingyHave you ever heard of the Dead Sea Scrolls in the Qumran caves?
Outstanding video, comes off as very balanced. Keep up the good work Ami
"Every person I spoke to on camera is represented in the video"
What a cool thing to do. Wish more people could make this claim.
hijab lady: "I prefer to keep the laws of Israel, but to live in Palestine" you hear Ami giggles.🤭
yes she probably prefers the demographics of her people but wants want the jews have built
same in america
minorities want the quality of life mostly built by white people but want the demographics to be mostly people of color
3:57 yea her grandparents were the first ones in her family to ever call themselves a “Palestinian”.
They probably called themselves "Arabs." Before the KGB and Arafat invented the "Palestinian people™" in the 1960s, it was an insult to call An Arab there a "Palestinian," it was tantamount to calling them a "dirty Jew." They insisted on being called "Arabs" or sometimes "Syrians."
Ami what's going on in universities there? Would you ever get a chance to visit the same uni our Ms Wannabe-Lawyer is graduating from? Are the universtities there suffering from the same diseases our universities are suffering?
Hi, I am Israeli, in short - no.
@@kronosDking Do you live in Israel? Just curious.
@@RetrowaveUniverse Yup.
"If government doesn't get involved, life is great". Say that in any language and it still true.
Unless you happen to live in a place with no government.
Ami, I love your work. No music over the interviews next time please.😊
The gentleman at 4:58 says in Hebrew: “This is a democratic country”. Unfortunatly it was rendered as “dictatorial” in the translation.
Thanks, I thought he was contradicting himself.
Excellent video as always, Ami! Keep telling it like it is!
Love that you disclose you showed ALL interviews!! Appreciate that.
These people basically said “I want to live and let live and so do they.” Kinda hard to argue for Palestine. The one chick said it perfect, she wants Israeli laws but to be called Palestine but knows that doesn’t work like that
Ami truly doing the Lord's work. Keep it up man. We need this kind of journalism.
4:55 He said "this is a democratic country" not "dictatorial".
This was probably an accidental mistake.
Isreal is a progressive country, but there are Jewish and Muslim extremists.
As far as the West Bank and Golan Heights, those are high grounds from which enemies of Israel tried to rain down hell from. If Israel gives those to their enemies, that would put them in an extremely vulnerable position - again.
i'm confused, the woman who was so passionate about how the land is palestinian, and things were so unjust, and palestinians are second class citizens doesn't want to be a palestinian?
It's because she's a hypocrite , her reasoning for it being unfair in Israel is not true as well, everyone pays the same taxes, she doesn't pay more than other Israeli citizens.
She's not "Class B citizen" there's no such thing in Israel, but deep down she knows she's privileged to live in a democratic country that is flourishing and giving her equal rights, even pushes her to study (by giving lower acceptance requirements in universities and financial support for Arabs who want to study) , replacing that with a dictatorship that pushes for war and does not care for their citizens is not even an option for anyone who knows what's good for them even if they identify with Palestine more than Israel.
Don’t be confused my friend 😂she’s dreaming fantasyland 😂. Go watch David Woods archives/ CIRA international. They explain very well the condition of women ❤
She has white people problems 😂
I got emotional seeing this, love will win.
Rhodesia had black vote
Rhodesian military was over half black
Hugh Masekela said in youth they would
sneak out of curfew and it was so safe
and the streets were immaculate
We have lost so much
Betrayed so much
Palestinians will never undo Israel
Only Israelis can make that happen
same here in the U.S., for those of us who prefer freedom, but with government intervention you don't get freedom. all governments any where are anti freedom.
and same here with taxes, we have to pay taxes for things we don't want and didn't ask for
Ami, thank you for this video.
I recently spent time working in Israel. I lived in Jafo in Tel Aviv and in my neighbourhood most of the restaurants, businesses, shops were Arab owned. Jews, Christians and Moslems lived together peacefully and I will point out to the ignorant that many Arabs are Christian.
I have no axe to grind here, I’m not Israeli, I’m not Jewish. I was a foreigner who saw what he saw. The only threat came from madmen in Hamas sending fools across the border to kill and to die uselessly.
the man with the shades on his head straight up looked mexican. he could be my uncle
Arabs and Hispanics do look similar. Both are brown-skinned.
@@alexanderkreynin5257 very similar indeed
I still don't understand people who say they are Palestinian or want Palestine. What does that even mean? Under Ottoman rule?
funny how disaffected people believe that a social change will hand them a golden life. Yet inevitably it would be much worse within a system without the social safety nets they currently have.
Wait! Thats not what the MSM tells me. I'm confused.
But Al Jazeera told me otherwise
All of the interviewees looked prosperous - just sayin'.
Excellent video.
Great video, I think it would be cool if you went to area C and talked to the Arabs there as well. Unless you already have?
You do great work Ami.
@amihorowitz. why are you trying to scam like that?
Excellent timing
Now do this in a muslim dominated country/region...I dare you🤨
Unfortunately, Jews are habitually killed in Muslim countries. It wouldn’t be safe for Ami. :/
Another awesome video Ami... Chazak Chazak
Well, they love Europe too because they love what others can provide
Wow very insightful.👍🏻
This is the kind of journalism that must be difficult because of the weight from your iron balls. No one else has this kind of chutzpah!
One person said things are ok until the government gets involved (no details though). The one complaining about taxes seemed to imply that her taxes were different than those of an Israeli Jew(?) - That wasn't too clear. Didn't hear anyone say that they were being oppressed by police, army etc. 1 lady: "the best" we have everything, compared to other countries really really good, then, later: would prefer it was palestine(?)
Cool shirt, Ami!
Ami, at 5:00 there’s a bad mistranslation. It says “dictatorial” but it should be “democratic”.
Fantastic video again Ami -- Thanks.
This video needs to have 179 million views..
Maybe for a video you could visit a town in US and ask how safe it would be for Jews if the Government offered a deal similar to what PA gives to its people (Families of individuals killed by Israeli security forces are paid stipends of about $800 to $1,000 per month. The families of convicted Palestinians serving time in Israeli prisons receive $3,000 or higher per month. Douglas J. Feith calls the stipends "cash incentives" to spur Arabs to undertake car ramming and stabbing)
I want to be like Ami !!!!
Ami Horowitz has the best bang for the YT minute!!
This is the kind of interaction that Vice will NEVER show lol
OmG that’s so true
There is a journalistic mistake in the opening of the video. When critics refer to Israel as an apartheid state, it is because it holds jurisdiction over the West Bank and the Palestinians who live there via a military occupation, but does not grant the Palestinians in the West Bank the right to vote or have legal representation in the Israeli government. In other words, Palestinians in the West Bank are ruled by the Israeli government, but do not have the legal rights that Israelis have. And, critics are not referring to the status of Israeli Arabs (Palestinians who live in Israel) when claiming Israel practices apartheid, but rather the status of Palestinians in the West Bank who are under Israeli control.
And there are a couple mistakes in your comment. :P
Gaza is now an independent nation. Tragically, their government has been a terrorist ran for years, hence the abysmal loving conditions. :/
On the West Bank, can you explain how the situation came about in the first place and how every peace treaty has ended? :/
Most uninformed people dont know that there are 2 million Arab Israeli citizens with full civil rights. This is an inconvenient truth that peddlers of the Israel is an Apartheid State skip over.
West Bank is not governed by Israel. PLO has control and governance of the region. They vote for their own leaders. They just elect terrorosts constantly
Well, the only issue that the law student has, is that she wishes that Muslims holidays would be honored, too, which is a valid point. However, she still likes Israel better. 😃❤️
But, there are five mosques in Jerusalem. And, there are only five synagogues in the United Arab Emirates, in the Arab countries. 😃❤️
How many Arab countries celebrate Jewish holidays? Tell me, I'll wait. Oh, wait. No I won't.
OMG!..the horror!..she has to pay taxes
Now go to Taiwan and ask the people if they consider themselves Chinese.
The game of politics is played on the people, no matter what country you go to.
Oke that's interesting. The women want Palestine but only one thinks it will be better if the Palestinians make the law.. and she is going to be a lawyer.
I guess governments all over the world create division among their people. I'm glad it's not just my government, but sad that it happens at all. Great video.
Jaljuliya is a tiny Arab town of 10,000 in the middle of the Central District of Israel, where the population is >90% Jewish and is the most developed part of the country.
They could've tried speaking to Arabs in Nazareth, which is solid 99.8% Arab with a population of 80,000, and see what their opinions were. Or maybe Haifa, and actual metropolis where 20% of the city is Arab. Regions where the Israeli government has neglected education and infrastructure for decades and the locals routinely complain of being mistreated by the central government.
The fact that Ami and PragerU think we can't do a simple Google search is really telling.
Those Mexicans speak a weird Spanish 🌮
Haha
Ari Horowitz goes to a village
in Israel asks questions:
What's it like for Arabs living
there:
#1: Everyone is together
#2: Everywhere I go with
joy, with happiness.
It's so nice. We live in
a country that gives
us many thing. From
the perspective of the
laws it's the best. In
comparison to other
countries gets really good
#3: Very good. Good job.
good money
#1: But the people the
relationships with each
other is great. It's just
the politicians.
#4: I think it's the politicians
that create problems for
us. I've been working with
them for many years never
have I had a problem
#5: It sucks. I am against
the country. If I work 10
hours the government .
takes 4 hours in taxes.
We are second-class
here.
#6: Israel has more benefits
and more democracy
Palestine doesn't
Liberals: nooooo you are all oppresseddddd
That hateful woman lied; we Jews in the state of Israel also pay the same taxes. In fact, we pay slightly more. She should recognise her privilege...And she doesn't want to be Palestinian xD
The woman in the red shirt was a walking contradiction. "I hate this country. This land is Palestine...I don't want to be a Palestinian" 🤔🤷🏼♀️
Biden should watch this video. He may learn some
thing!
They have far better relationships there than we have here in the US with the Tumblr girls vs the 4chan boys culture.
עם ישראל חי 💙 🇮🇱
“The ✡cries out in pain as he strikes you” - old Polish proverb
That one woman is funny cause if she lived in Palestine or an Israel controlled by Palestinians, she wouldn't be able to dress the way she does. And the other woman saying she wants to live in Palestine with the laws of Israel. Well that aint happening, EVER and she as a Muslim should know that.
Why the hell can't America be like this?
Everyone there looks like someone you want to live next to you, except that student lawyer.
The title of this video is giving me a headache and sounds like a high school girl lol I love you’re content though Ami! Keep up the good work
Thanks! What would be a better title?
@@amihorowitz " 20% off on flights to Israel"
@@amihorowitz "I spoke to Arabs living in Israel to find out what it's like to live there" sounds more clickbaity and also interesting but your title is fine tbh
I think the title is perfectly fine: short and descriptive
@@amihorowitz any chance you can visit and interview arabs about what life is like in The west bank towns like Ramala or Nablus?
That one complaining about taxes sounds ridiculous. I bet ethnic Jews pay the same taxes.
A salary of 10,000 Sheqels (equal to 3,000 $) Pays hardly 20% and it includes the Health care fee. Everyone in Israel is paying the same.
😮😮😮. This I great report, because we always see Palestinian people being attacked by settlers,thank you for report👏👏👏
Gotta love when someone who doesn't have a job complains about taxes they don't pay.
The one negative response is university student. Says something in itself. And her reasons turn out to be frivolous, indefensible. Says still more.
Surprised this video is allowed by UA-cam.
It’s easy to live a happy life if you let go of all the bullshit.
Def Leppard?
Fuck ya!
a rich arab neighbourhood?
Fantastic, I hope all the muslims here in Europe will move to Israel and live vey happy lives there:)
Haha, they have 50 Muslim countries why go to the only Jewish country in the world?
Your Governments did a big mistake by allowing Muslims into their countries. In a decade or two it will be much worse.
@@kobi2024 True, but there is also only one Denmark and one Sweden and.. But why is he trying to find out how well muslims are living in Israel do you think?
Ami, you should take a tip from Scott Adams and ask Black Americans what they think of White Americans. Completely different story.
Remember when South Africa had Blacks in their parliament during Apartheid?🤣
Re-upload?
Sounds like they need some Critical Race Theory teaching... /S
Nice people just get along together.
Love you Ami. 🕎 ☪ 🇮🇱 ‼
Interesting to note that every single respondent spoke in Hebrew
😏
The term "apartheid state" has been used to describe the situation in which around 2 million Palestinians are living under Israeli military administration. This arrangement, which has been ongoing for many years, has become a source of tension and controversy. Some Israeli friends warn that if this situation persists, it could lead to allegations of apartheid, which would be damaging to Israel's reputation.
There are different viewpoints on how to address this issue. Some suggest that the Palestinians living under military administration should be granted citizenship, but this option is not without its challenges. Others propose that the Palestinians should become citizens of the Palestinian Authority, which would require significant changes to the political and legal structures of the region.
It's false to say that 2 million "Palestinians" are living under an Israeli military administration. The "Palestinians" haven't lived under a military administration since 1994, almost 30 years. 97% of Arabs in Judea and Samaria and 100% in Gaza, live under their own rule, the PA and Hamas, respectively.
@@microchip470 you're right the numbers are incorrect. According to estimates by the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), there are approximately 300,000 Palestinians living in Area C of the West Bank, which is under full Israeli control. what should do with them almost half a million Palestinians?
@@yigalgurevitch2936
From what I have read, those under occupation refuse Israeli citizenship as well, but also refuse to give up the region they live in. If that is the case with every peace treaty being rejected at the international level, I’m not sure peace is possible until the unreceptive side can offer an olive branch. :/
@@microchip470
Good constructive addition mate! :)
@@yigalgurevitch2936 It depends on what Israel wants to do with the territory. If Israel wants to apply its sovereignty over all of Area C, then the Arabs that live there will be given legal residency with the option to obtain citizenship. This is similar to what happened to the Arabs who live in eastern Jerusalem. Many Arabs prefer to be legal residents because it entitles them to receive welfare benefits, but they largely reject citizenship for ideological reasons.
It's also possible that Israel will apply sovereignty to areas without a(n) (large) Arab population. In this case, the Arabs would become the PA's responsibility.
These are all hypothetical scenarios, and it depends on Israel and to some extent the PA as to what exactly happens.
Now go behind the walls
You mean Gaza? they are not Israeli citizens so the Apartheid claim does not involve them.
i dont believe it, i will see for myself soon
Lose the trap beat next time man lol. distracting and irritating
Hi
Get rid of that envy!!
Now go do the West Bank 🙄
Gaza.
But, still that girl thing like muslim, munafikun
" What is it like for Jews living in Palestine ? " ... try working on this one next time
Brother the Jews have been living in Palestine for such quite time before they even was a Zionist regime and there are anti-Zionist orthodox Jews that would be by your side to say designers regime doesn’t represent the Jews and that the Jews do not support the Zionist regime
And at one point Jews and Arabs were babysitting each other’s children at one point
But even so civilian population on both sides of this argument would have their fair share of what they would think about life living on this particular side of the argument regardless of the politics best I can say 🇮🇱🇵🇸
So you would like him to upload a black screen with no audio?
They are being watched very carefully, even closer than their brothers and sisters living in the occupied territories!
No they are not. Bruh wtf. They protest with fakestenian flags and call for Israel’s destruction and still live there very well. If it was up to me I would deport them to their imaginary country they would be crying.
They are not being truthful or they are truthful but coached to speak in a manner which seems untruthful
LOL, its funny to see that everyone in the video agreed to your so called positive side of Israel(Occupied Palestine), but how come, all people of one village have almost same thinking, dude, if you're lying then lie intelligently not blindly.
There is a saying:
Be careful when you follow the masses because sometimes M is silent.
Well because there are to be a lot more than that but even so they are on the Israeli side of the argument this is not the West Bank and many Arab citizens on the Israeli side of the argument are glad to be part of it when seeing this as a society of freedom and democracy
And wouldn’t trade that for anything but even so doesn’t change the fact of how things are going on the soils of places like the West Bank and so on and it comes to Palestinians being occupied by Israeli troops
But the civilian population can have their own opinions of things in these matters regardless of the politics best I can say 🇮🇱🇵🇸
The problem with Islam is that it doesn't recognize the Western principles of separation of "State and Church"
Islam is not compatible with Free Democracy.
And when there is no Democracy there's no Freedom and no prosperity.
This guy's must've done alot of editing to get the answers he wanted
Given how most Palestinians live outside of Israel, I think the responses were in line with what I expected.
@@carlbook2051
It stands to reason, what did he expect Palestinians in Israel to say?
I hate the country I work and make a living in, among anything else they may want to get off their collective chests?
I'd imagine they'd foster some kind of negative feedback if their employeer knew.
I'm sure the interviewer would've got differing answers had he went into what little area Palestine has and continues to lose via illegal settler annexation.
I much prefer an unbias channel like "Ask Israelies/Ask Palestinians", where the interviewer, interviews many walks of life in both Israel and Palestine, and gets a various amount of answers from all sorts of topics.
You get a more precise sense of the pov of the people and some really surprising insights I myself haven't entertained.
@@mutalix I appreciate your perspective, Mutalix. I agree that the reality is more complicated than what we saw in the video.
He stated that everyone he interviewed is in the video. There was no selectivity.