These are markings written by the pianist by hand to help him remember something with a particular emphasis or with a particular phrasing. These are not Tchaikovsky's markings in any way. I hope I was able to help...!
Michael Paul Smith as a piano player myself (and many others who play intruments) I can confirm that we do this. Can be for many different reasons. Sometimes we highlight entire passages we need attention too.
+MattWeisherComposer Someone here mentioned unprepared key shifts, and it's a feature of modern pop music and it's super annoying but I don't know what that is lol, the unprepped key shifts
The only thing I can think of in (almost) "modern pop music" that would really paint the picture of "unprepared key shifts" would be that 80's song "If You Leave." Other than that I really don't know haha
This Sonata was composed when Tchaikovsky was 25. Any opus number after 75 are posthumous publications either of early or unfinished works that Tchaikovsky never wanted published.
And thus, our dear Tchaik gave birth to one of the most annoying features of modern pop music: the repeated unprepared key shift. (Great peace, though.)
Quotenwagnerianer Yes, you are right. I have chainged my point of view drastically and now, I absolutely agree with what you said... It is like comparing a marathon runner and a sport fisher, they both do something very different and thus can't be really compared :)
Well, I suppose strictly speaking anyone has a right to state their opinion, but if this is all they have to say and they don't provide any reasons for their dislike of the piece, then they're better off not wasting their time complaining about something that was uploaded for people who enjoy this piece. No one is telling them they have to listen to it.
![[Alfred Brendel] Schubert: Drei Klavierstücke -- D946](/img/n.gif)
Love Tschaikovsky's almost amateurish roughshod approach to piano composition, very similar to his countrymen of the same era.
There's something charming about Tchaikovsky's piano music, even if from a technical and pianistic standpoint, it is lacking.
5:25 such a fine theme, shame that it wasn't orchestrated or used it in a more significant composition
Heh, did you hear the scherzo of Schuberts D-major piano sonata? (D850)
What do mean about circled notes?
These are markings written by the pianist by hand to help him remember something with a particular emphasis or with a particular phrasing. These are not Tchaikovsky's markings in any way. I hope I was able to help...!
Michael Paul Smith as a piano player myself (and many others who play intruments) I can confirm that we do this. Can be for many different reasons. Sometimes we highlight entire passages we need attention too.
First movement very Beethovenish...!!!!
...and the second too...
He's playing the very beginning as triplets instead of eighth notes...wat.
They were a little rushed, but they weren't really triplets or "wat" worthy. lol
+MattWeisherComposer Someone here mentioned unprepared key shifts, and it's a feature of modern pop music and it's super annoying but I don't know what that is lol, the unprepped key shifts
The only thing I can think of in (almost) "modern pop music" that would really paint the picture of "unprepared key shifts" would be that 80's song "If You Leave." Other than that I really don't know haha
Dave Conway No, she isn't
Well played, i do however think his version is best
la ultima pieza de Tchaikovsky
Querrás decir una de las primeras piezas...
Eu pensâj l’piucia finali d’Ciaikovski erat “L’Simpiunia Pateticâ”
This Sonata was composed when Tchaikovsky was 25. Any opus number after 75 are posthumous publications either of early or unfinished works that Tchaikovsky never wanted published.
Um
Shelley Shao ?
huh?
And thus, our dear Tchaik gave birth to one of the most annoying features of modern pop music: the repeated unprepared key shift.
(Great peace, though.)
wat
Thats what I call a proper sonata.. So much better than Mozart..
+Maky Tondr Quite pointless comparing composers that lived a hundred years apart.
Quotenwagnerianer Yes, you are right. I have chainged my point of view drastically and now, I absolutely agree with what you said... It is like comparing a marathon runner and a sport fisher, they both do something very different and thus can't be really compared :)
@@makytondr8607 so I finally found the polite part of youtube
EPIC
Mozart's are better and Tchaikovsky would say so as well
Quotenwagnerianer it’s what they believe
Irritating & rather unpleasant.
If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all.
This just in: "negative" opinions are never allowed to be expressed, and nothing can be criticized.
Well, I suppose strictly speaking anyone has a right to state their opinion, but if this is all they have to say and they don't provide any reasons for their dislike of the piece, then they're better off not wasting their time complaining about something that was uploaded for people who enjoy this piece. No one is telling them they have to listen to it.
The sonata or the performance? If the performance, then I recommend Rashkovsky.
Fergus Maclachlan many songs sound unpleasant but that’s legit a style, don’t get heated it’s what they hear