"Il balen del suo sorriso" - APOLLO GRANFORTE (1930)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 161

  • @simonbrown6441
    @simonbrown6441 2 роки тому +14

    One of the greatest voices of all time. Thanks.

  • @DominicR-y5d
    @DominicR-y5d 4 місяці тому +4

    Just lovely! What a joy to hear this great voice from the past--makes the phonograph invention even more appreciated!

  • @diegoreviati5166
    @diegoreviati5166 3 роки тому +24

    One of the most masculine voices among baritones, whitout losing an ounce of squillo! I wonder how big the voice was live! Also a very respectable man that was not only a great singer, but also an inventor and a businessman. All of this after being abandoned as a child. Admirable and inspiring.

    • @jasonblack4208
      @jasonblack4208 3 місяці тому +1

      Had to double check....yup, everything you mentioned is peak Lost Generation. He embodied the best of their tendency to make the best of neglected, dangerous childhoods and grow up to become charismatic musicians and lucrative businessmen.

  • @gemmadestate3216
    @gemmadestate3216 4 роки тому +26

    Una delle voci baritonali nell'olimpo con Titta Ruffo,Ettore Bastianini,Battistini...grandi,immense e bellissime voci!

  • @lz43p15
    @lz43p15 8 місяців тому +7

    Nato a Legnago a 15 km da Montagnana dove è nato A.Pertile. Due stratosferici interpreti di questo Trovatore.

    • @marcoc.8386
      @marcoc.8386 20 днів тому

      Anche Giovanni Martinelli è nato a Montagnana...altro cantante notevole e amico di Pertile

    • @lz43p15
      @lz43p15 20 днів тому

      @marcoc.8386 Erede di Caruso al Metropolitan.

  • @giuseppinascapparone3303
    @giuseppinascapparone3303 6 років тому +24

    Voce stupenda, per timbro e dizione. Magnifico baritono. Assolutamente perfetto, che emozione ascoltare questo interprete eccezzionale!

  • @jordipanadesribera6890
    @jordipanadesribera6890 Рік тому +5

    Mi piace molto. Grazie.

  • @Winnepausakee
    @Winnepausakee 9 років тому +90

    This is not a voice that should (have been)be forgotten. It is a baritone that is clear and resonant where many baritones cover to the point of the words being "lost" or distorted beyond recognition. Why is this voice not considered when the "greats" are discussed?

    • @vilhelmhammershoi4631
      @vilhelmhammershoi4631 6 років тому +18

      Indeed! the commercial baritone greats get so much buzz, when this man's voice, style, technique and mastery are simply glorious! He should forever be mentioned at every turn, when great singing is part of a conversation.

    • @liedersanger1
      @liedersanger1 6 років тому +13

      I think he is the greatest of all In Verdi... even more impressive, less woofy than Ruffo and with more bite than Warren. And still capable of those soft mezza voce effects at the ends of phrases, as here.

    • @vilhelmhammershoi4631
      @vilhelmhammershoi4631 6 років тому +11

      @@liedersanger1 Absolutely!!! The true line for Bastianini, was Apollo Granforte. No other baritone had that absolutely gorgeous voice!

    • @liedersanger1
      @liedersanger1 6 років тому +7

      Vilhelm Hammershoi Not to mention the diction, which, as a choral conductor of mine once put it, “you could take dictation with.”

    • @robertwbecker
      @robertwbecker 5 років тому +10

      To me he is one of the very Greatest of all!

  • @janetkenny1974
    @janetkenny1974 4 місяці тому +2

    Listen to the clarity of his words and the way he phrases using their meaning. Yes he had a splendid voice but above all he was an artist. He not only had a Stradivarius, he knew how to play it.

  • @paolopecchioli9793
    @paolopecchioli9793 Рік тому +4

    Questa è la voce naturale del vero baritono, fantastici.

    • @СветланаЗабаева-я7б
      @СветланаЗабаева-я7б Рік тому

      Господи чтобы не забыть вот так звучит природный красивый густой баритон!

  • @Ferrutius
    @Ferrutius Місяць тому

    Voce Incredibile e meravigliosa. Curiosamente la cabaletta è in tono ma l'aria è eseguita un semitono sotto. Sempre bellissima

  • @peterschmitz8364
    @peterschmitz8364 2 роки тому +6

    eine. wundervolle stimme eine der schönsten baritonarien die Verdi komponiert hat.

  • @bodiloto
    @bodiloto 9 років тому +50

    ottima interpretazione !
    magnifico !
    meraviglioso !
    sublime !

    • @jobeshufe06
      @jobeshufe06 4 роки тому +3

      Non so come dirlo:
      Grandforte è stato il Bastianini del passato o Bastianini è stati il Grandforte del suo tempo.
      Grande Grandforte! ❤🔥 Voce oscura ma brillante come il fuoco!
      Saluti!

    • @GiovanniGGori
      @GiovanniGGori 2 роки тому +2

      In quel Trovatore lui e Pertile fanno faville!

    • @lz43p15
      @lz43p15 8 місяців тому +1

      ​@@GiovanniGGoriperfettamente d'accordo. Una della migliori registrazioni del trovatore. Solo quella di Corelli con Shipper direttore d'orchestra gli sta alla pari.

    • @GiovanniGGori
      @GiovanniGGori 8 місяців тому

      @@lz43p15 Io adoro anche la versione diretta da Karajan e con protagonisti Di Stefano, Panerai, la Callas e la Barbieri

  • @ancamg
    @ancamg 4 роки тому +14

    What a voice, diction, amazing! I really understand every word he is singing, and I am not Italian, but I speak several latin languages. It's such a pity there are not many recordings of Apollo, due to the limits of the time he lived. Thank you a lot for uploading!❤️❤️❤️

  • @HellasItalia4
    @HellasItalia4 8 років тому +40

    sono veramente commosso.... che voce , che interpretazione che rabbia di non avere oggi queste vocalita' !!! E come aver perso la conoscenza di certe cose..... Super-Apollo!!!

    • @bodiloto
      @bodiloto 8 років тому +17

      ti capisco è come !
      anch'io come te 50 anni fa davanti il mio vecchio giradischi ammiravo questa voce meravigliosa e cercavo di produrre dei suoni che somigliavano
      à questa voce divina...
      non puoi trovare questa vocalità al giorno d'oggi per la colpa delle case discografiche,le agenzie e i direttori dei teatri.
      per ''creare'' una voce come quella di Granforte ci vuole l'amore,il Talento vero e lavoro duro...
      e soprattutto il rispetto verso l'artista che ha il talento vero.
      l'estetismo ''moderno'' ha ucciso la bellezza divina della voce.
      chi rispetta oggi i giovani cantanti lirici?...
      i registi moderni che gridano,urlano durante le ripetizioni quando i giovani cantano ?!...
      o i loro assistenti ?!....
      lasciamo à pace la parola ''rispetto'' ... oggi fanno cantonare le vocine piccoline per tantissime ragioni che non hanno niente à vedere con il lato artistico e la vera arte lirica...
      una vocalità grande per svilupparsi deve cantare in un ambiante lirico vero.
      oggi l'orchestra lirico vero non esiste più, i grandi direttori d'orchestra tipo Serafin ancora meno.
      quasi tutti teatri del mondo stanno usando dei microfoni per ''aiutare'' i cantanti ''eletti'' odierni o le vecchie mummie i che non lascio mai del spazio libero ai giovani ....
      stasera avevo sentito una Lucia giovane che aveva una voce più ''grande'' di quella della Sutherland...
      in realtà la mia nonna à 90 anni aveva una voce più bella di questa ragazzina...ma i microfoni oggi fanno delle meraviglie !...
      viviamo in un altro mondo mio caro amico molto diverso del mondo dell'arte lirica vera al quale apparteneva Apollo Granforte e i suoi colleghi.
      purtroppo la commedia è finita .
      cordialità .

    • @HellasItalia4
      @HellasItalia4 6 років тому +3

      malgrado le modernita' varie l'appuntamento e' qua, da Apollo e la compagnia.... Abbiamo perso il maestro Bonaldo, l'avrai sentito.... Tra gli ultimi sinceri....

    • @bodiloto
      @bodiloto 6 років тому +6

      HellasItalia4
      mi dispiace,non sapevo che il grande Giaiottti l'ultimo basso vero non fa più
      parte di questo mondo ...
      Bonaldo Giaiotti era l'ultimo BASSO Artista Onesto e Vero .
      adesso canta per i dei accanto alla Callas ...
      cordialità

    • @romearomeo
      @romearomeo 5 років тому +8

      @@bodiloto Parole sante...sono pienamente d'accordo...che tristezza oggi la lirica...

    • @Eva-j8g
      @Eva-j8g 2 місяці тому

      ​Πόσο δίκαιο έχετε ,απλά θλίβομαι για την σημερινή κατάντια.

  • @haroldgaffney246
    @haroldgaffney246 5 років тому +26

    A combination of Ruffo and Bastianini. Fantastic

    • @oiuyuioiuyuio
      @oiuyuioiuyuio 4 роки тому +5

      Granforte is much better than Bastianini... are people deaf or what? Bastianini had a small voice and his vowels weren't clear at all.
      How can someone be so clueless as to group Ruffo and Bastianini in the same category? They're totally different leagues. Ruffo is probably the GOAT while Bastianini isn't even in the top 50, or even 100. If you have a developed ear it's impossible to listen to him.

    • @andymanland
      @andymanland 3 роки тому

      @@oiuyuioiuyuio totally agree!! Who's your top 10?

    • @diegoreviati5166
      @diegoreviati5166 3 роки тому +3

      @@oiuyuioiuyuio I am absolutely against what you said. Bastianini was a great artist and a great baritone. And I never heard him live, but his voice was not small, It can be heard in the live recordings. Bastianini was among the best IN HIS GENERATION, Granforte is Legend.

    • @simonbrown6441
      @simonbrown6441 2 роки тому

      A fabulous analogy.

  • @amadyktiv
    @amadyktiv Рік тому +2

    Voce STUPENDA!!!!! BELLISSIMA!!! BELLISSISSIMA!!!!

  • @romearomeo
    @romearomeo 5 років тому +9

    Sublime! Divino! Queste si che erano ancora voci! Oggi la lirica è diventata un'unica tristezza...

  • @65attila
    @65attila 7 років тому +9

    BRAVO -- SO GLAD HE INCLUDED THE RECITATIVO & CABALETTO. WHAT EASY SINGING.

  • @MrTrackman100
    @MrTrackman100 Рік тому +2

    Wow! Thanks so much for this post. I have to say that this great baritone should be better known. Truly one of the great voices!

  • @Diego-ok7vn
    @Diego-ok7vn 4 роки тому +7

    Its incrdible to hear such a clear recording from that date. thanks

  • @driveopera2541
    @driveopera2541 3 роки тому +4

    I wish I had a baritone singer to work with)) Great singer, hope we will hear such a hero in our days!

  • @vioricabalteanu8564
    @vioricabalteanu8564 3 роки тому +3

    GRANDIOSO! Mirabilissima versione interpretativa di un artista eccellente. Beati coloro che ebbero la fortuna di applaudirlo alla Scala o in altri templi della grande lirica!

  • @denisaubry4698
    @denisaubry4698 4 роки тому +4

    voila un vrais baryton superbe voix que nos barytons d' aujourd' hui prennent une leçon nous n'entendons plus de chanteurs comme lui

  • @ronnieince4568
    @ronnieince4568 4 роки тому +4

    When you are named aftet a God -Apollo and a name like Granforte you really have to deliver and he certainly does .!!!

  • @alexanderkutaladze5334
    @alexanderkutaladze5334 4 місяці тому +1

    Великолепный певец и прекрасный педагог!

  • @pepeelsordo
    @pepeelsordo 2 роки тому +4

    Fantastic recording. Clear phonation. I wish I could hear this sound in any singer today. Just for the sake of elucubration, after having heard this a couple of times. Bellow "A" natural his volume decreases significantly. His outstanding sound is from B flat to e flat., which is the typical phenomenon of a Verdi Baritone. The majority of his high notes are very good. The "e" (in Italian) vowels of some high notes are modified to position of "a" vowel . Which is very intelligent of his. Il balen is a very taxing aria even for Verdi Baritones and at the end I detect some tiredness.
    But, again, this is like every one should sing.

  • @s.slyshadow8689
    @s.slyshadow8689 8 років тому +13

    The best ever! No doubt

  • @luigimazzucco9102
    @luigimazzucco9102 6 років тому +5

    Meraviglioso interpretazione straordinaria questo e' un. Vero baritono

  • @cimbassovr
    @cimbassovr 2 роки тому +1

    Chiedo venia se aggiungo un altro commento ma un interpretazione magistrale come quella regalataci da Apollo Granforte merita un ulteriore plauso.Voce straordinaria sorretta da una tecnica solidissima.
    È incredibile il "gusto"raffinatissimo e molto moderno proposto dal baritono veronese.
    Grazie ancora di ❤👍per la condivisione

  • @道-p2e
    @道-p2e 4 роки тому +13

    Wow, operatic singing is going backwards, this is obvious the very top, if not the best baritone...after hundred years now we are looking still to land that old one. Bravo!

    • @abcdefgh-db1to
      @abcdefgh-db1to 4 роки тому +3

      Maybe not the best best but definitely in the top 3 greatest

    • @道-p2e
      @道-p2e 4 роки тому

      @@abcdefgh-db1to Yes. And when I say best, I never meant to be like olympic game 100 meter dash. If one is at top 3 or 5 range, it is not illegal to use best word. I always love titto ruffo, and bastianini and...
      What be your favorite?

    • @abcdefgh-db1to
      @abcdefgh-db1to 4 роки тому +2

      @@道-p2e personally my top three favourite baritones is Ruffo, Granforte, Bastianini, in this order !

    • @道-p2e
      @道-p2e 4 роки тому +1

      @@abcdefgh-db1to Bastianini is the one with strongest personable charisma. But there are so many great voices in the past, not only italian, American baritones' list is long too. Today's is disappointing to me.
      There is a guy who sounds quite close to Ettore,
      ua-cam.com/video/mlDEGv7ZcNo/v-deo.html

    • @williamadolphe7921
      @williamadolphe7921 3 роки тому

      @@道-p2e I don't hear the bastianini sound in him. while the sound is lovely. it is not Bastianinian.

  • @numetutelare
    @numetutelare 2 роки тому +1

    Ho riascoltato di recente anche Galeffi...altro gigante dimenticato. Perché queste voci non tornano... Che pena e che nostalgia....

  • @Sabininho
    @Sabininho 4 роки тому +5

    Huge vocal power

  • @familypondman
    @familypondman 4 роки тому +4

    What a voice!!!!!

  • @bernardodemuro3692
    @bernardodemuro3692 5 років тому +3

    Grandiosa voce dal timbro ampio e metallico, padrone delle vocalità espressive che si calano nelle profondità più intense. Semplicemente grande, degno partner di Aureliano Pertile che fanno del Trovatore un'opera a loro congeniale, dieci e lode

  • @numetutelare
    @numetutelare 10 років тому +21

    Bel timbro, piglio nobile da grand seigneur. Una interpretazione da manuale

  • @alligatoruno6975
    @alligatoruno6975 2 роки тому +1

    Monstruo! Que vozarron

  • @lidiacastellani8078
    @lidiacastellani8078 7 років тому +3

    Grazie Lorenzo Ma di averci proposto questo meraviglioso cantante, una voce splendida!

  • @johnblasiak607
    @johnblasiak607 5 років тому +3

    His Name is true to his ART
    Clear as a bell diction so pure a master of his craft

  • @franzbernasek4058
    @franzbernasek4058 2 місяці тому

    Apollo Granforte , a true Super-Baritono, perfect voice

  • @rowley555
    @rowley555 4 роки тому +2

    Simply brilliant....

  • @blascortes8391
    @blascortes8391 4 роки тому +2

    Maravilloso

  • @cimbassovr
    @cimbassovr 3 роки тому +3

    La classe non è acqua!!! Interpretazione notevolissima plausibile anche oggi ai giorni nostri.Del resto il baritono veronese(nato a Legnago prov.di Verona) fu anche un validissimo maestro!

    • @gianlucagalbiati9646
      @gianlucagalbiati9646 2 роки тому

      Non era di Gorgonzola?

    • @cimbassovr
      @cimbassovr 2 роки тому

      @@gianlucagalbiati9646 no era della prov.di Verona Legnago appunto patria anche di Antonio Salieri.

  • @MrSkylark1
    @MrSkylark1 7 років тому +8

    SUPERIOR TO ALL WHO FOLLOWED HIM ESPECIALLY IN OPERA TODAY

  • @Luifernal6
    @Luifernal6 2 роки тому +2

    Perfecto

  • @321abcable
    @321abcable 11 років тому +9

    Granforte sings the best version of this wonderful aria IMO.

    • @321abcable
      @321abcable 9 років тому

      ***** Who is Placebo?

    • @darklord220
      @darklord220 8 років тому +3

      +sven sundquist placido domingo. addio is making a joke.

    • @icebabyellen5495
      @icebabyellen5495 4 роки тому +2

      How about Bastianini?

    • @道-p2e
      @道-p2e 4 роки тому +1

      @@icebabyellen5495 Ettore Bastianini has similar quality, just from records, not sure of their volume of live. But I think he has much cleaner diction and unique style of his own.

    • @道-p2e
      @道-p2e 4 роки тому

      @Barone Vitellio Scarpia this guy you be sent to your scam or permanent delete status.

  • @ronnieince4568
    @ronnieince4568 6 років тому +5

    Wonderfully clear recording for era at a time when baritones like Ruffo Urbano Stracciari Schnulus were still active -I love Urbano's version -not the refinement or elegance of this recording but a dark baritone off immense power and charm .

  • @francopace8146
    @francopace8146 4 роки тому +2

    Che bella voce !!!

  • @leonoradelagardie
    @leonoradelagardie 7 років тому +3

    I LOVE this wonderful artist!!!

  • @sts1957
    @sts1957 5 років тому +3

    Wonderful!!! Fantastic technique and musical instincts!

  • @alessandrocorsi7518
    @alessandrocorsi7518 4 роки тому +1

    Sublime ed immenso!!

  • @Operafiend22
    @Operafiend22 8 років тому +19

    Before there was Bastianini, there was Granforte.

    • @DonDonadio
      @DonDonadio 8 років тому +2

      Don't forget Leonard Warren, the suavest IL Balen ever.

    • @icebabyellen5495
      @icebabyellen5495 4 роки тому

      But Bastianini was a dramatic bartione,Granforte was a lyric baritone.

    • @andymanland
      @andymanland 4 роки тому +1

      Definitely dramatic!

  • @leontinatasso4394
    @leontinatasso4394 5 років тому +1

    Increible la grabación una voz marabillosa

  • @hashatz
    @hashatz 4 роки тому +3

    Granforte, indeed!

  • @mimmodicara7729
    @mimmodicara7729 2 місяці тому

    Una delle voci più belle che sia mai esistita nel mondo baritonale.

  • @alfredbernasek861
    @alfredbernasek861 Рік тому +4

    EINE DER SCHÖNSTEN UND MÄCHTIGSTEN BARITONSTIMMEN DER OPERNGESCHICHTE

  • @andreweinberger1305
    @andreweinberger1305 6 років тому +3

    Great voice & unfortunately not represented enough,would like more.Rene

  • @matthiastvillwock
    @matthiastvillwock 9 років тому +3

    Thanks for posting

  • @lucianobresciani1034
    @lucianobresciani1034 6 років тому +10

    He taught: "The voice must float on the breath as a cork on the water" and also " The breath is to be understood as the bow (the violin) that plays the chords (voice): finally the sound must be amplified by the mask (facial) that is the natural resonance box. His Masters Guido Capocci and Nicola Guerrera at the Conservatory of the Prensa in Buenos Aires where he emigrated, were generous in teaching him.

    • @wilmvanvelsen2275
      @wilmvanvelsen2275 5 років тому +6

      wilm van velsen a voice cannot be PLACED this is a stream of gold...pure gold!!!!

  • @СветланаЗабаева-я7б

    Аполон Гранфорте очень красивый, убедительный голос настоящего Графа Луны,который страстно влюблен и полон сдержанности

  • @fedecastaldi
    @fedecastaldi 7 років тому +4

    eccezionale! che meraviglioso conte di luna.
    perchè lo si ascolta poco?

  • @carlosaleman1135
    @carlosaleman1135 4 роки тому +11

    Granforte, Stracciari,Ruffo,Bastianini!!

    • @道-p2e
      @道-p2e 4 роки тому +2

      He is the godfather of Baritone, great solid voice, like a gigantic rock. Trained as tenor at younger age, I cannot find anything on youtube of that singing. Thank You.

    • @道-p2e
      @道-p2e 4 роки тому +2

      Glorious baritones, anyone will certainly rock and wow the whole opera houses...

    • @piero7322
      @piero7322 4 роки тому +3

      Danise,Guelfi

    • @道-p2e
      @道-p2e 4 роки тому +1

      @@piero7322 Danise???

    • @piero7322
      @piero7322 4 роки тому +1

      @@道-p2e Yes.Giuseppe Danise.

  • @andymanland
    @andymanland 4 роки тому +3

    Is this half a tone down? Anyway, an incredible sound and performance!! Bravo!

  • @321abcable
    @321abcable 8 років тому +4

    The other guy is Bruno Carmassi to answer- J J Ryunahnea a top notch bass of the era.

    • @JJ-vv5id
      @JJ-vv5id 6 років тому

      i saw your reply now haha after two years later.. maybe it's too late but better late than never! thanks a lot!

  • @splodsquadubdob
    @splodsquadubdob 2 роки тому +1

    Hello! Thought I'd mention that this is a semitone too low. Need to fix to hear his true voice. But thanks for sharing though.

  • @MDM679
    @MDM679 10 років тому +6

    Great redintion

  • @giuseppedimarco8358
    @giuseppedimarco8358 9 років тому +3

    Powerful and Charm!

  • @andymanland
    @andymanland 4 роки тому +3

    Was listening to a recording from La Scala. And he sounded way lighter than here. Wonder if that's a recording that gives him this sound or maybe takes away in that recording. Or maybe he's older here? Just a thought.
    What do you guys think?

    • @zomgisha
      @zomgisha 4 роки тому +3

      The record sounds half a step lower than the normal pitch this aria is performed, so it could be that the transfer was too slow, which makes the voices sound bassier. Or, in case he was actually singing it in a lower key, it would sound a bit different in any case.

    • @andymanland
      @andymanland 3 роки тому +2

      @@zomgisha I just listened to Cappuccilli singing in Verdi key 432 and I tried it and it SOO much easier. Don't understand why they had raise it 440, it's way difficult for the singer.

    • @zomgisha
      @zomgisha 3 роки тому +1

      @@andymanland i like 432 better as well, sounds more round and dark and relaxed... but the only way you're singing like that nowadays is with a piano. :)

    • @andymanland
      @andymanland 3 роки тому +1

      @@zomgisha yes, unfortunately it's not easy to tune the whole orchestra down to 432 😄😄 and even harder to convince a conductor 😅😅

  • @cristovaomendoca8164
    @cristovaomendoca8164 4 роки тому +2

    4:10 😱😱

  • @JJ-vv5id
    @JJ-vv5id 8 років тому +3

    who is the other guy here at the beginning part? anyone?

  • @deadwalke9588
    @deadwalke9588 4 роки тому +2

    This sounds better in the lower key of E.

  • @vittoriomaurinotosi718
    @vittoriomaurinotosi718 7 років тому +4

    Mi chiedo se sia mai esistito un timbro baritonale simile. A me pare di no.

  • @femistokll_Moskalkov
    @femistokll_Moskalkov 4 роки тому +1

    What happens with the pitch?!
    It's half tone under.((

    • @Yondal
      @Yondal 3 роки тому

      Ниже только ария, стретта в тональности.

    • @femistokll_Moskalkov
      @femistokll_Moskalkov 3 роки тому

      @@Yondal
      Кого волнует стретта?!))

    • @Yondal
      @Yondal 3 роки тому

      @@femistokll_Moskalkov Мне казалось вас волнует запись целиком, а не половина...

  • @diegomr6969
    @diegomr6969 2 роки тому

    el mejor baritono argentino, en paz descance

  • @HD3670
    @HD3670 6 років тому +2

    マエストロ!!

  • @ricardobedini5345
    @ricardobedini5345 4 роки тому +3

    M A R A V I L L O S O * * * * * !!!!!!!!

  • @игорьбабий-о5ю
    @игорьбабий-о5ю 4 роки тому +1

    изначально именнл апплло мванович был есть и будкт королем баритонов совремменник руффо именно он станет главным певцом в жизни такого же гения как этторе бастивннини любмм обоих ипреклоняемся пред гениями

  • @남윤홍-s9n
    @남윤홍-s9n 4 роки тому +1

    Amazing cabaletta.......LoL

  • @christianroider118
    @christianroider118 8 місяців тому

    Bis 🎉❤😅

  • @francop5033
    @francop5033 9 років тому +3

    Beautiful, but down a 1/2 step....

    • @abcdefgh-db1to
      @abcdefgh-db1to 4 роки тому +4

      It was very frequent at the time, even composers didn't mind, Puccini allowed Caruso to lower che gelida manina by a whole step. Puccini still said that it was god himself who sent Caruso to him !

  • @Tkimba2
    @Tkimba2 3 роки тому

    Great voicw but no expression.
    All sung stentorean, authoritative booming fortissimo.
    The pianissimo on the low notes do not count. Anyone can do that.
    This aria is supposed to be of a man in love. You dont hear love here.
    Give me De Luca anyday