Who Wants To Know What? - Ramesh Balsekar -- Courtesy of advaita.org

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 268

  • @meeraesq
    @meeraesq 3 роки тому +17

    Krishna gave the Gita to Arjuna because he asked great questions. This interviewer had the maturity to understand and ask great questions to Ramesh. Thank you for this wonderful video.

  • @sedonastacy
    @sedonastacy 8 років тому +48

    Thank you for the most comprehensive explanation of totality. His discourse could not be anymore clear. I am ecstatically grateful : )

  • @cianvdw2435
    @cianvdw2435 9 років тому +54

    I sat in that room for three weeks.
    How blessed .

    • @Man_with_no_name
      @Man_with_no_name 6 років тому +1

      namaste

    • @Hexhex66
      @Hexhex66 Рік тому +2

      I hope Ramesh sat in that room too when you did … 😅 (Just kidding.)
      I think it must have been a great experience for you. I wish I knew Ramesh Balsekar already when he was still alive. I love his books too, they are very helpful.

    • @ShockwaveZero
      @ShockwaveZero 11 місяців тому

      nice story

  • @NewNow4u
    @NewNow4u 5 років тому +12

    She did such a good job with her clarifying questions!

  • @roryoconnor861
    @roryoconnor861 9 років тому +23

    Love it. Amazing interview, not a single word wasted. Golden leaves for a crying child. Beautiful.

  • @xamehc
    @xamehc 11 років тому +8

    By far the BEST explanation of advaita I've ever heard...
    simply 'simple' =)
    Thanks for the post.

  • @Emptiness512
    @Emptiness512 9 років тому +20

    Great interview, i appreciate and love the person who is asking and identifying with Ramesh

  • @christiano4873
    @christiano4873 7 років тому +20

    Saw this decades ago. A beautiful classic.

  • @elshisu
    @elshisu 11 років тому +6

    Complete, thorough, unsweetened, just the plain truth! Thanks!!!!!

    • @albundy9597
      @albundy9597 6 років тому

      THEORIES ABOUND EVERYWHERE, Truth is relative, wait until you are dead first then it won't matter anyway.

    • @zazzyz4558
      @zazzyz4558 3 роки тому

      It’s not a theory

  • @victoriafilmproduction6803
    @victoriafilmproduction6803 2 роки тому +2

    For me one of the most clear and thorough conversation about nonduality and it's roots . It explains the real basis of religion. And very wonderfully lead by Rifka Hirsch. A Classic so to say!

  • @mariahetlelid1342
    @mariahetlelid1342 9 років тому +35

    So clear, so beautiful

  • @babycriminalchan5803
    @babycriminalchan5803 4 роки тому +5

    With in 5 minutes after the video started everything becomes crystal clear to me 👁️🏵️🙏❤️

  • @bilimoriafirdaus
    @bilimoriafirdaus 2 роки тому +2

    Understanding got deeper with repeated viewing of this vdo alongwith Ramesh's other vdo's... Extremely grateful for posting this classic..🙏🧡

  • @hemamalinirs1002
    @hemamalinirs1002 4 місяці тому

    Beautiful ,Immense gratitude and love for this video ❤🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @Drew3KW
    @Drew3KW 12 років тому +2

    This is very special. I know it is still a golden leaf, but to me it is gold. Deepest thanks.

  • @rajendramirji5830
    @rajendramirji5830 6 років тому +2

    Mind blowing discourse. My salutes from bottom of heart.

  • @ngprovidence1275
    @ngprovidence1275 11 років тому +3

    Excellent interview. Thanks for posting.

  • @shantihealer
    @shantihealer 12 років тому +2

    What a wonderful life-changing video interview.

  • @PatsieSmithspiritpond
    @PatsieSmithspiritpond 11 років тому +1

    Thank you for sharing this beautiful interview that was very well done. Beautiful words of truth and wisdom.

  • @bajawalla
    @bajawalla 6 років тому +1

    Rifka Hirsch, one of the best interviewers ever. As enlightened as her interviewee! 🙏🏽🌹💞

  • @axutgautam1187
    @axutgautam1187 2 роки тому +3

    Pure gold.

  • @satsangsmoothie9086
    @satsangsmoothie9086 8 років тому +4

    Timeless wisdom transported very clear by Ramesh!

  • @krissyramsey6524
    @krissyramsey6524 7 років тому +1

    Outstanding interview! It doesn't get more clear than that. Thank you for sharing.

  • @ganeshjagdishan
    @ganeshjagdishan 11 років тому +2

    love this...gr8 understanding, gr8 wisdom, Thanx!!!!

  • @johnbarber8663
    @johnbarber8663 8 років тому +2

    Beautifully stated and clear. Soooooo Comprehensive!!!!

  • @QuestingNeurons
    @QuestingNeurons Рік тому

    Treasure talk. The brightest, the highest, the greatest a man can achieve is the realisation that "there is nothing to achieve" and ultimately "there is no 'man' whatsoever".

  • @bilimoriafirdaus
    @bilimoriafirdaus 4 роки тому +1

    Lovely interview!!

  • @abdonnp
    @abdonnp 7 років тому +3

    Muchas gracias por la traducción.

  • @bradstephan7886
    @bradstephan7886 7 років тому +6

    Excellent.

  • @SathyAnna7
    @SathyAnna7 11 років тому +4

    Its so clear! Thank you very much...! :)

  • @sunil1968
    @sunil1968 4 роки тому +3

    Great master..🌹

  • @monikavarma4
    @monikavarma4 2 роки тому

    Absolutely fabulous

  • @TadRapidly
    @TadRapidly 13 років тому +1

    at 44:00 Rifka speaks of enlightenment-joy. The episode of enlightenment is a joyless state--there is no emotional component. Relative 'joy" is experienced afterward and onward but that comes from the understanding / clarity that the enlightenment episode brings.

  • @gurugeorge
    @gurugeorge 12 років тому +1

    Good interaction, intelligent questions eliciting clear answers.

  • @innerlight617
    @innerlight617 2 роки тому

    Many Thanks for uploading!ॐ ❤

  • @tapashchatterjee8567
    @tapashchatterjee8567 8 років тому +2

    Thankyou Beloved RameshJi.......

  • @Kajun666
    @Kajun666 12 років тому +1

    Profound information. amazing.

  • @1237shanti
    @1237shanti 11 років тому +1

    omg... this is ultimate knowledge. THANK YOU!

  • @mobiustrip1400
    @mobiustrip1400 2 роки тому

    This is it! I'm seeking something that I never lost, because "I" is not separate, I am already.

  • @ralters2000
    @ralters2000 11 років тому +1

    Great interview by both participants

  • @vvk594
    @vvk594 6 років тому +2

    Blessed

  • @solomit1
    @solomit1 3 роки тому

    Thank you nice message 💓

  • @uptown4life13
    @uptown4life13 12 років тому +3

    Agreed to the fullest.

  • @JatinderSingh-cs8dt
    @JatinderSingh-cs8dt 10 років тому +13

    Excellent talk for the seekers.

    • @gaungadhara
      @gaungadhara 10 років тому +3

      who is seeking what?

    • @indianmilitary
      @indianmilitary 9 років тому +1

      +gaston cardoso us (humans/matter) seeking our true self (consciousness)

    • @Lawrence.Bennett
      @Lawrence.Bennett 9 років тому

      +kashsoldier But consciousness just is like dreaming dog-shit.

    • @tretayug3500
      @tretayug3500 8 років тому

      Lawrence Bennett you look like a mugger!

    • @fractalofgod6324
      @fractalofgod6324 5 років тому +1

      @@gaungadhara nothing to seek everything is just as is.

  • @bodhimedia1
    @bodhimedia1 6 років тому +1

    God’s banker. The highest wisdom so simply expounded! 🙏🏻

  • @tapashchatterjee8567
    @tapashchatterjee8567 8 років тому +1

    The Expression Of An EXPANDED CONSCIOUSNESS........

  • @i__am__no__body__
    @i__am__no__body__ Рік тому

    destiny bought me here thankyou gurujii

  • @sidharthachauhan4830
    @sidharthachauhan4830 4 роки тому

    Beautiful..thankyou

  • @sajithstephen9166
    @sajithstephen9166 3 роки тому

    Thank you❤

  • @youlong1234
    @youlong1234 3 роки тому

    Bravo !!! Namo Unity

  • @brenca8694
    @brenca8694 9 років тому +1

    so concise and thorough... and excellent discourse which breaks through the "veil" of humdrum existence.

  • @sharmilapenmetsa7249
    @sharmilapenmetsa7249 2 роки тому +1

    Amaging

  • @PeterMastropasqua-rk7tp
    @PeterMastropasqua-rk7tp Рік тому

    Thank You for This Clarity 🙂🙏

  • @pillettadoinswartsh4974
    @pillettadoinswartsh4974 6 років тому +1

    Practical Advaita. Very much needed, if only to cut through all the woowoo out there, surrounding eastern teachings.

  • @AndrasNagy2001
    @AndrasNagy2001 2 роки тому

    Well put.

  • @yankumar5280
    @yankumar5280 10 років тому +5

    thanks for sharing Wayne Liquorman

  • @TadRapidly
    @TadRapidly 13 років тому

    What he speaks about around 35:00 is absolutely essential to understand--enlightenment is NOT a sustained state, it is a short-lived episode of unity-consciousness.

  • @ganeshjagdishan
    @ganeshjagdishan 11 років тому +2

    just amazing!

  • @TheColbertois
    @TheColbertois 12 років тому +1

    I love the way the presenter ended the interview : she was a little bit caught short... :)

  • @stevendoyle9002
    @stevendoyle9002 11 років тому +2

    The point of existence is existence. To realize this is to be love, god, the self

  • @Emptiness512
    @Emptiness512 8 років тому

    The realization of the individual is fallacy, this is when there is enlightenment...love that

    • @albundy9597
      @albundy9597 6 років тому

      On the other hand why bother ? I don't understand all this concept of suffering, I am not a seeker (but I love philosophy) am not enlightened and yet I don't suffer, I see things impersonally and have done even as a child, it is as it is.

    • @neva.2764
      @neva.2764 Рік тому

      ​@@albundy9597Because you don't label everything?

  • @SuperBendecido666
    @SuperBendecido666 10 років тому

    MUCHAS GRACIAS RAMESH

  • @igqx5662
    @igqx5662 7 років тому

    Gran mensaje!

  • @theunamed2039
    @theunamed2039 6 років тому

    Incredible

  • @TheHilde2008
    @TheHilde2008 4 роки тому

    Escuchar a este señor es taladrar el 🥥 coco. Pero aún no lo escuché..

  • @anonranger6428
    @anonranger6428 10 років тому +8

    Consciousness is all that is - Advaita Vedanta
    Advaita Vedanta is one of mankind’s oldest philosophy that cannot be tied to a single religion or within geographical borders. It belongs to the entire mankind. Ramana Maharshi and Adi Sankara are modern religious scientists have explored Advaita Vedanta in their life and shared their learnings from their practise.
    Psychological Base :
    It is a modern psychological tool to deal with stress and sorrow and helps a man/woman be compassionate to a fellow living being. Associating with I, the ego is the source of all sorrow. You are not alone, you belong to the brotherhood called consciousness. When you have stress, sorrow don't carry it alone, understand that you belong to the brotherhood called consciousness that is eternally happy.
    Do not be powerless or feel your capability is limited. You belong to the powerful, the most intelligent brotherhood called consciousness.
    Meditation - Self Inquiry Who am I? Dhyana Yoga
    [BODY]
    Imagine yourself lying on the burning pyre, after death. What happens to you after death?
    Close your eyes and ask the question, ‘Who am I’ ?
    You are not the transient body that rots after death.
    [MIND]
    Are you the mind that generates the thoughts?
    When you close your eyes and meditate on a single entity, random thoughts or desires fill your mind. Chasing the thoughts or desires is sorrow. Freedom and happiness is in the thoughtless mind.
    When a thought or desire arises , kill the thought immediately with the question,
    To whom do the thoughts come for?
    The thoughts come to serve I, the ego, your name - your imagination of what you are. When there is no I, the name, the ego - the thoughts have no one to serve and they die. Stay in meditation with a thoughtless mind.
    Keep reminding yourself there is no I, the name, the ego. There is no body or mind. All that there is consciousness. When there is no I, the name, the ego, there is no you, this or that - the world disappears
    When is no subject, where is the object to desire for? All that there is consciousness.
    [HEART]
    The awareness that swells in your heart in the thoughtless mind is consciousness. Consciousness is all that is. Stay in the consciousness and be blissful and happy.
    Stay in the consciousness and be blissful and happy.
    How to stay in Consciousness? - Waking state - Karma Yoga
    Say Aham Brahmasmi - I am consciousness in both deep sleep, dream and in the waking state.
    Intellect is Consciousness, the supreme knowledge required to perform an action in the waking state. Intellect and Consciousness are one and same and not separate.
    Getting lost in the passion of work, without remembering I, the ego is the doer of the work is practising consciousness in the waking state. Also called Karma Yoga.
    Researchers, Scientists, Programmers, Engineers, Doctors and other professionals who get lost in the passion of work without realizing that they are the doer are practising consciousness in the waking state.
    Three Ethical values are prescribed to ward off associating I, the ego as the doer and to stay in Consciousness in the waking state. They are as mentioned in Sanskrit as the 3 Ds Damyata (Self Control), Datta (Charity) and Dayadhvam (Compassion).
    A person who knows he/she is Aham Brahmasmi (I am consciousness) in the waking state.
    identifies a fellow living being (human or non human) as one the same and as no different than himself as consciousness.
    is empathetic and compassionate towards another living being (human or non human)
    gets lost in his passion for work, does not credit I, the ego as the doer of the work nor personally own the fruits of the labor. He credits his work and the fruits of the labor to his intellect or consciousness, which are one and the same.
    takes the happiness, sorrows and pain with equanimity with the fact that his true state consciousness is always blissful and happy.

    • @tim13354
      @tim13354 10 років тому

      All bullshit.

    • @indianmilitary
      @indianmilitary 9 років тому +4

      +tim13354 yeah "virgin birth" "original sin" are not bullshit right?

    • @tim13354
      @tim13354 9 років тому

      +kashsoldier Yes. So?

    • @garyvalentine2
      @garyvalentine2 7 років тому

      nice

    • @siddharthjoshi6811
      @siddharthjoshi6811 7 років тому

      Are you really saying that there is something like ' Virgin birth' ... or you are just being sarcastic ??

  • @rjsillysaga
    @rjsillysaga 5 років тому +1

    This is a dream. Remember it always

  • @tapashchatterjee8567
    @tapashchatterjee8567 8 років тому

    The REAL LIBERATION Comes From The REALIZATION That He CANNOT Be A Separate ENTITY...He Is Just A Part Of The UNBROKEN WHOLENESS [TOTALITY], Which Is A UNIVERSE... .......Thankyou Beloved Ramesh Ji.......

  • @AmiraAroraOfficial
    @AmiraAroraOfficial Місяць тому

    🙏🏼

  • @ZuZungu
    @ZuZungu 2 роки тому +1

    Ramesh at one point , I think he says "consciousness has to be aware of something, it can't just be conscious". My question is, can't there be just a primordial consciousness where there is consciousness of Itself?

    • @Hexhex66
      @Hexhex66 Рік тому

      Well, who knows. I think Ramesh regards consciousness as of a similar nature as light: light can‘t be seen until it hits an object.

  • @pradeepmenon2240
    @pradeepmenon2240 5 років тому

    Thanks

  • @shantihealer
    @shantihealer 12 років тому +1

    I think he said that in duality (ordinary life) the totality of consciousness is operating through an object which is identified with itself as the doer. In this state of mistaken identification it becomes attracted to one pole or another of all sorts of dualities. Such opposite poles include passionate love and passionate hate - hence hate crime.

  • @barbarahemming3841
    @barbarahemming3841 6 років тому +1

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @LEDCircus
    @LEDCircus 12 років тому +1

    One need not follow a structured system in order to realise self-enlightenment. To say to another, you can only be in this state by following these instructions goes against the nature of truth. Enlightenment, by definition is subjective. It must be a personal journey of discovery. Yes, there are scriptures and gurus which can guide one in the general direction, but this is a matter of self-realisation. No one can show you the path, you must create your own.

  • @avatareyes100
    @avatareyes100 10 років тому +6

    the impersonal consciousness, identified with the mind-body organism, leads to the imagined schism from which one needs to find "liberation". That impersonal consciousness itself *is* freedom.
    with realization, a block of ice becomes flowing water. the basic substance is the same, however its properties have changed

  • @aminabdollahi1909
    @aminabdollahi1909 6 років тому

    pure love

  • @virenderyadav707
    @virenderyadav707 2 роки тому

    🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @yosivin1
    @yosivin1 5 років тому

    Perfect

  • @TadRapidly
    @TadRapidly 13 років тому +1

    @ajetk what would you ask?

  • @dparansky
    @dparansky 10 років тому +8

    Wake up to find out that you are the eyes of the world...

    • @N8_Presents
      @N8_Presents 10 років тому

      Amen.

    • @jameelisaac7628
      @jameelisaac7628 7 років тому +1

      Rnickey Lidack Are you blind or aware of blindness? you can't be both because there not the same. also is blindness aware?

  • @MrYahya0101
    @MrYahya0101 4 роки тому

    Very clear. Much clearer than this New Age talk.

  • @carlosirles8382
    @carlosirles8382 2 місяці тому

    Uauuu this is like an open hand slap

  • @undergroundbullshit
    @undergroundbullshit 12 років тому +2

    I was bush walking earlier in the year with John Wheeler while he was down visiting 'Sailor' Bob Adamson, he mentioned when he visited Ramesh that he had completely turned his back on advaita in his final years of life. I found this quite shocking considering his teachings, perhaps being on the death bed really determines how clear one is...anyhow

    • @albundy9597
      @albundy9597 6 років тому

      Fear of death just happens, quick get a priest just in case !!!

  • @nicm1411
    @nicm1411 7 років тому +1

    Hi, thank you for posting this interview. Does anyone know the name of the woman asking the questions please? Thanks.

    • @tejasjoshi3946
      @tejasjoshi3946 7 років тому

      Rifka Hirsch. Found it in comments.

    • @TheWorldTeacher
      @TheWorldTeacher 7 років тому +1

      Actually, her name appeared above the Spanish subtitles at at least one stage during the video..

  • @suerayss
    @suerayss 12 років тому

    I should get this. I am indian and hindu but the explanation is so winding that it ties my brain into knots.

    • @albundy9597
      @albundy9597 6 років тому

      Nothing complicated there, you are a disposable object, finished.

  • @Hexhex66
    @Hexhex66 Рік тому

    The final reality is so simple. But very few people can see it, because almost nobody wants to give up his little, jealous and anxious ego… I don‘t exclude myself. Still too often I forget who I really am. (Referring to Ramana Maharshi‘s question: Who am I?)

  • @ikrethos
    @ikrethos 10 років тому +1

    La ilusión de que todo es Ilusión , es de los Hipnotizados y los auto hipnotizados

  • @suerayss
    @suerayss 12 років тому

    Gosh this is so hard to understand! I am trying so hard. I have unidentified myself from my body mind. Do I need to keep my job and do I need to pay my credit card bills or pay for my meals at restaurant ?

  • @vedicastroyogas6295
    @vedicastroyogas6295 9 років тому

    11:41 what does lado mean?

    • @fernandopavan1
      @fernandopavan1 9 років тому

      +Anup Thapa lado means "side" in this context means also "by the other hand/other point of view"

  • @medicineman6664
    @medicineman6664 10 років тому +2

    That RAW food for ya soul!!!

    • @albundy9597
      @albundy9597 6 років тому

      you missed the point, there is no soul. No heaven, no hell, no loving God, no afterlife, you are a disposable instrument and you will be disposed of.

  • @xamehc
    @xamehc 11 років тому

    whoa??! where can I get info on this?

  • @FlyedPiper
    @FlyedPiper 2 роки тому

    Very different from his later talks.

  • @MikeRoePhonicsMusic
    @MikeRoePhonicsMusic 12 років тому

    I want to know if gluons, which bind quarks together inside of atomic nuclei, can come to a state of rest or not. Perhaps this is not possible (possibly because gluons can interact with other gluons.) The reason I ask is because gluons have a non-zero mass. Since the kinetic energy of the gluons inside of the proton & neutron contribute to the vast majority of mass for the proton & neutron, & single quarks are never found in isolation, AND quarks are bound together by gluons, they can't rest.

  • @joaoextrela
    @joaoextrela 6 років тому +1

    between two ferns

  • @LEDCircus
    @LEDCircus 11 років тому +1

    Is your experience of life subjective?

  • @calvin3005
    @calvin3005 11 років тому +2

    he was about 88 at the time of that allegation, so if it's true, it's pretty impressive!
    and even if it is true, it wouldn't contradict his teaching anyway

    • @nnsrinivas
      @nnsrinivas 2 роки тому +1

      What is the allegation?

  • @namewithheld9716
    @namewithheld9716 9 років тому +1

    I don't think he's necessarily saying that we couldn't have memories of past lives.

    • @shrikramalei9091
      @shrikramalei9091 8 років тому

      None But we can easily assume that he has no knowledge about his future incarnations as well! LOL

    • @namewithheld9716
      @namewithheld9716 8 років тому +1

      I don't understand the intent of your reply.

    • @edzardpiltz6348
      @edzardpiltz6348 5 років тому

      No, what he is saying that there never was a separate entity that ever could remember past lives. All there is is remembering happening in conciousness and thought creating the concept of personhood claiming memory as personal. Got it?! 😉😘

  • @OwenPrescott
    @OwenPrescott 11 років тому +2

    The soul is everything and everything is the soul or consciousness as he describes. On the contrary, this idea gives one every reason to exist because there is no existence otherwise. It is an all or nothing situation, the thinking mind has just dismantled the all into smaller parts, our meaning in to exist as the entirety. Is a new born baby pointless without a sense of individual, no because the baby does not require individualism to be.

  • @agrippa9
    @agrippa9 12 років тому

    Wow at least one banker turned out okay, and I thought it was impossible for them to even feel anything.

  • @zatoichiable
    @zatoichiable 8 років тому +15

    No artistic going round the bush style. direct, straight, short.simple.