Will Trump lose 2024 race over jobs rebound? Historian Goodwin on Obama-FDR lessons
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
- Pulitzer-prize winning historian Doris Kearns Goodwin joins "The Beat" on presidents in times of crisis, what she calls "the mystery of leadership" and Biden's rebound.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/...
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/...
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#biden #2024election #msnbc
Plenty of jobs in the Midwest where I live. And many are good paying union jobs!
Name them!
Name one?
Curious? Do union workers support open borders?
Not for Americans
@@JudyStroyer-bk6fb I don’t know what part of America you live in, but like I mentioned to two others the names of great companies here where you can find great employment. Maybe it’s time for you to leave your state. Because the top 8 poorest states led by Republican governors are doing a lousy job on education and employment. And for these great jobs you have to be an American citizen.
OxyMoron45: I am holding a convention in a horrible city.
To be fair, there will be more criminals in Milwaukee, when he shows up.
I respect Doris Kearns Goodwin. I miss so much the good interviews she had, many years ago, with Tim Russert. ON reflecting back, even with the liberal democrat leaders, life WAS BETTER politically than it is now. Its all about corruption, hate, and money now.
Looks as if HATE has a lead?
15M+ jobs (800k in manufacturing) since Biden took office & our unemployment rate has been at or below 4.0% for 30 straight months! Never forget January 6th! Biden 2024 🇺🇸
That’s just people going back to work after Covid. Stupid.
@@DustyNickelz Not true. And so what if it was? Then good on him after tRUMP ruining it!!
unemployment rate has been at or below 4% for 30 months ~ so around 2022 it began ~ I'd say this percentage has nothing to do with covid! we have the strongest economy in the entire world
@@DustyNickelz The stimulus spending and rescue plan enabled businesses to reopen. You cannot reopen a coffee shop if everyone sat out lockdown without income. This is how you recover an economy and induce a little inflation to allow the Fed to finally come off the free money policy. On the other hand, look at the sluggish "trickle down" supply side recovery under Obama and pushed by the Republicans.
@@DustyNickelz Fiscal stimulus and the American Rescue plan enabled those jobs.
What's sad is job counts they use,include part time,limited, one day jobs. Not real count that pays the bills.
BS, troll. So did you guys, The pipeline was a limited job and you all complained about that!
@@nofybn7794 Yes. They’re union pipe fitters who work on projects and when they’re complete, they move on to the next job. That’s how they work.
Wealth tax under FDR 45%
We need to tax the 1% more!
And somehow FDR won over the Great Depression and the Axis Powers.
@@Forrest666 That's insane..... and really really stupid....ffs dude
@@Forrest666Multiple countries have tried a wealth tax and failed. The problem is how you determine a value of a business and other non liquid assets.
@@JudyStroyer-bk6fb Why? Your mom one?
gotta remember WHY these crisis situations occurred to begin with!!
they basically started with the deregulation of various "rules" that where there to protect the system and keep the crisis from happening.
Ari has jumped the proverbial shark.
In what way?
Well, Trump could lose to a Democratic party that promises actual fixes for employment, healthcare, tax, and privacy laws and policy instead of dollar bill band-aids. Trump could lose to a real progressive candidate looking to actually accomplish those goals instead of pretending to care about literally anything else to please corporate beancounters. They could lose to *that*...
True. Only if Americans want to fundamentally change the United States of America. That change is from a Representative Republic to a Communist Dictatorship.
BIDEN and the Democrats equal SOCIALISM
TRUMP and the Pubs believe in CAPITALISM
AMERICA WAS BUILT ON HARD WORK AND FREEDOM
The democrats are not for the blue collar worker their for mandates and regulations which we all no are job killers
not much the democrats can do with a one-vote "majority" in the senate and no majority in the house and a conservative scotus that knocks down any of their laws challenged by right wing lawyers. the president has little actual influence on inflation or the markets (no matter what some ex-president might claim) though they can maintain good trade relations, keep us out of wars, and direct their various cabinet members to spend their departments' dollars wisely.
Thank God the communists don’t have a majority. We’d all be speaking Chinese by now if they did. Progressives are the ones who create problems and conservatives fix them. The President doesn’t directly control prices and inflation, but their policies have a large influence. Prime example Biden’s disdain for fossil fuels which are the cheapest source of energy. When he announces he’s going to eliminate them, energy companies raise their prices. Especially when his policies and executive orders increase the cost of extraction of energy. Energy is the bedrock of the American economy. It is necessary for any economic activity. If it’s cheap and plentiful, we thrive. When government throws hurdles at energy companies, those costs all get passed onto the end user. It happens every time. Why can’t leftists understand this simple concept?
And one more thing with Trump he says we have a bad economy but never has receipts to prove his arguments or make a good point
The only proof you need is to go grocery shopping or to a gas station.
Trump is not good with money, he bankrupted and had to be bailed out by Russian swill@@mikee2923
I’ve had to survive on cereal and toast for weeks on end so that I could make sure my dogs ate first. My husband and I own a business, customers are putting off work they usually have done yearly, or they don’t pay. Then we have to decide which bills get paid, which are left unpaid to destroy our credit. No receipts? I have receipts that show the price of groceries have doubled. You can continue to gaslight people. They aren’t buying it. They are living the truth and they see your lies.
The only receipt he has is from McDonald's 🍔🍟🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤪
Grocery prices aren't lying
Not sure who needs to know this. Returning to work after the coofy was released is definitely not creating jobs.
Pres. Biden's done a great job and will continue doing so after he wins again this November. Biden 2024!!!
We can't afford more joe.
TROLL ALERT!
THIS USER HAS BEEN AN UNWELCOME USER! FOR MONTHS AND MONTHS! PAY NO ATTENTION To This USER who has multiple accounts!
Here's the price difference between Jan 2021 and June 2024.
Safeway 6 bagels: $4 to $6 - 50% increase
Subway footlong: $5.99 to $8.99 - 50% increase
Dry Clean Depot: $1.99 to $3.49 - 75% increase
Chipotle Bowl : $7.49 to $9.95 - 33% increase
Walmart cream cheese: $1.68 to $2.23 - 31% increase
Home insurance: $1000 to $1300 - 30% increase
Numbers speak for themselves. How much did your income increase after paying taxes in the last 3 years? Do you like the same for another 4 years? Think.
This is worldwide... blame the greedy corporations
Every depression in U.S. history has happened with a Republican in the White House. "The economy always seems to do better under Democrats." -Donald Trump
"Everything Trump says is a lie."
-The Lying Democrats
Like under Dem FDR? or Carter? ..you failed History
That video is on my playlist!
@@thebilboshow168waaa
@@marklasky3555waaa
With Trump he is so not focused on policy and more on entertainment that keeps people focused on nonsense and their real lives
He was entertaining enough to preside over the middle class seeing its first wage gain against inflation in over 40 years. What has poopy pants accomplished?
I wouldn't be so complacent. Trump's agenda is deadly serious, he wants absolute power and he wants to throw us all into gulags or worse...just like Hitler did.
@@mikee2923 under biden wages have increased and surpassed inflation.
there were no wage gains under trump because he had no policies that would grow wages. The states where wages did grow is where states increased their minimum wage. It had nothing to do with trump.
@@mikee2923 It's still going up. And people are back to work after Donnie's failure.
@@mikee2923 Getting expensive paying for another mans crimes?
GOP: "Our job isn't to solve problems. Our job is to create problems for the Dems to solve. Why do you think America's economy always does better under Dem leadership? Why do you think that the only two Presidents to leave office with fewer
jobs than when they came into office are republicans? Trump, and Herbert Hoover."
It factually doesn’t you can’t name a single statistic in our economy that’s doing better the best you can do is fabricate a quote from the gop to serve your narrative. If what you said was true his polls wouldn’t be down
joes 40 year high inflation.
Democrats have done such a good job in Detroit... and Baltimore... and Memphis... and Chicago... oh.... oh my.
@@kelperdude brought on by Trumps pandemic.
Tell that to people barley making 😂😂😂it's over the democrat party has been exposed
MSNBC, “We Gaslight The Gullible!”
$787,500,000,000.00!!! Sorry, couldn't hear you. Those biggly numbers drowned you out!
Go watch more doctored videos of Joe in the Faux bubble, they miss you.
Nah, that's not even close. It's MAGA, "we swallow the BS."
Proud member of the Trump Drooling syndicate.
Biden rebound is when he gets up off the floor from constantly tripping.
I lost my home in 2009.
A Single-Mom to a Brilliant Son.
I signed what I THOUGHT WAS A 30 Year fixed… but under the influence of pain medicines cuz I just had my FOURTH SPINAL SURGERY!
It’s illegal to knowingly let someone sign a contract while under the influence.
I ended up signing a BUBBLE CONTRACT! Wells Fargo I hope that you all sleep well at night. No consciousness!
I hope you remember that and don’t vote democrat.
did you seek legal advice!
Obama did that
But it makes you feel better the people of Ukraine and south America thank you for your hard work.
If you can prove you were impaired, a lawyer could get you out of the contract. That is unless you knew you were impaired at the time of the signing. In which case you should not have signed.
Your own finances can be just fine but you can still believe the cost of living is too high. My finances are fine. I have no crisis. But inflation is killing me.
Yeah we need like 3 jobs just to pay the bills thanks for all the inflation Joe. No inflation is not going down.
You should have learned a trade 3 jobs bullcrap
TranSlaytion: "I live in a red state. Waaa!"
That's on you as the fact is wages are up 4.1%
C'Mon man its Transitory..........
@@niclewis9610 how much has the dollar decreased?
Most of the job growth has been in government and most of the new hiring are illegal immigrants...... That's not a good thing...... That's terrible for the future of this country and you should Be deeply concerned if you care at all about the people in this country
False.
@@danriley5848 true
@@danriley5848 Oh, I'm sorry which part?..... You think it's good for the country?.....it's not....
JD Vance dropped that BS straight into your mouth baby bird style. Legal foreign-born workers are not the same as illegals. Asylum seekers can't work without work permits. Baby boomers retiring account for the drop of native-born workers.
Vance pointed to a study that showed 183,000 fewer native-born workers in the fourth quarter of 2023 compared with the fourth quarter of 2019, while foreign-born employment rose by almost 2.9 million over the same period.
This growth in foreign-born workers includes recent migrants and foreign-born workers who have been U.S. citizens or lawful permanent residents for decades, long before Biden became president.
From Biden’s first full month in office in February 2021 to February 2024, the number of native-born workers increased by 5.7 million. That was over half of all jobs created in that period.
We rate Vance’s statement Mostly False.
Retail sales increased at a slower-than-expected pace in May as high interest rates and inflation continued to weigh on consumers. MSNBS lies
What is Biden’s path to 270 currently? Drop out Joe
WTH? HUH????? MAKE SENSE!
HE WILL WIN EVERY STATE HE DID BEFORE.
You wish because Trump will never be president again. 😂
trump's voting numbers peak was in 2020. J6 changed everything. Biden will win easily. 🤠
@@bunnycox1046 he’s going to win Georgia!?! Michigan!?! Tied in PA!?!
Jobs Rebound 😂😂😂😂
They have! Better employment rate since President Lyndon Bain Johnson!
Get Educated and learn Political Science, History, Geography, Science, Economics, and Especially CIVICS!
VOTE BLUE 💯💙😊
That's facts so wake up.
Yep.
ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT JOB REBOUND? That’s the only job rebound going on.
TranSlaytion: "waaa."
I guess we will see what people think about Biden soon.
is Biden going to steal the election again?. We need a Smart man for the job.
WTH? 😅😂
The Majority Of Voting American Citizens WILL BE VOTING BLUE 💯💙😊💙👋💙✌️💙👌💙🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊
BIDEN/HARRIS 🎉2024 🎉 STRAIGHT TICKET DEMOCRATS ONLY!
NO MORE RepubliCONS! We DEMOCRATS Are Keeping The Senate And Taking Back The House, of three extra seats!
Stop Whining like Crazy, DEMENTIA Trump! And his MAGGOT'S!!
DEMS GOT THIS! 💙🌊🌀💧🚎🚌🚙🛴✈️🛸🧳🚢🌐💯💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
Didn’t that lady who filmed G. Floyd overdosing get a Pulitzer. Shows how reputable that award has become.
No. Geez, it's the two people who wrote a book about him who won the Pulitzer prize.
@@misfitmolly8308 Darnella Frazier.
@@Dittxxyinc no sh!! Unbelievable!
He will lose because he refuses to close the southern border and constant spending
I prefer Trump’s Closed Border Policy over Biden’s Open Border Policy.
I prefer Presidents that aren't felons.
TranSlaytion: "I matter. Waa."
The GOP sabotaged the deal, their fault now.
I prefer Presidents whose policies allow the country to prosper. Not ones whose policies take inflation from 1.4% to 9% in record time, allow gas prices to double and keep supporting an unwinable war to continue to cover up for his corruption while his own country suffers and stands by while the US Dollar is about to be replaced as the world’s reserve currency.
Our Democratic party is too liberal, Biden's border crisis alone has lost my support. Moderate and Conservative democrats for Trump, stop the corruption and hatred of liberal lunatics.
Biden's Rebound: 💩
I was 20 times better off financially when Trump was in office..glad i bought a house with 3% interest and payed it off compared to Biden's 8% .. food gas and taxes were way down and I had more money to invest plus take vacations with the family.. now everything is up 20% higher snd because of his illegals first our taxes are going to skyrocket.! Trump for American's first peace through strength prosperity and to bring glory back to America 🇺🇸
Nope America knows the truth mo matter how much you lie about it
Corrupt lying Trump is no alternative
Shouldnt be even allowed to hold any office??? BUT?????????? Still allowed to run as a candidate
“Too senile to prosecute “ but able to run for reelection!!????😲
VOTE BLUE FOR ALL BALLOTS😊❤😊❤❤❤😊
Let Americans vote not the courts
You forgot, Legally.......
Them trump sycophants are hapless, not one valid argument out of their swilled brain comes out as valid.
Says brain dead senile Joe
Sycophants? It's too bad that you pathetic Bidenites want this country I fought for turn into a 3rd world country. I would speak more plainly, but UA-cam would cancel me. Get my drift?
So. Trump already Won if you haven't noticed
And lies coupled with insults is all you on the left seem to know how to do.
Blame everyone except your selves
Well said
No
Sidebar...None of this is fact checked.
Right like Fox....who NEVER give out unfactual reports....Didnt they have to pay billions for their lies.....FU Fox!
WRONG!
It's propaganda.
It's msnbc lol it's as reliable as cnn 😂😂😂😂
Ari is a little punk he doesn't even know what a woman is. 🤔😆😆
TranSlaytion: "I am hot for Ari!"
Jobs rebound?!?! 😂
15M jobs added in the U.S. Economy under Biden's leadership since he took office in Jan '21
And even before that, job growth was slightly slower in Trump’s first three years before Covid than it was during the last three years of the Obama administration, when the economy added 2.7 million jobs a year on average. Under Trump, that average was 2.2 million...
Trump had worst jobs record of any President since Herbert Hoover...
Ten million illegals and no jobs for Americans. And Biden is your hero ?.
@@khizar4990 really did you count the shutdown from Covid? Obama dropped 10x the missiles as bush and more Americans lost their homes to foreclosures than any president at any point in history including the great depression
@@khizar4990 name the economic statists that are better for Americans under Biden because it isn’t interest rates, gas, groceries, cost of living, housing, crime, overdose, homelessness, number of wars, illegal immigration, tax or starvation and if he hadn’t counted the jobs from releasing the economy after Covid he wouldn’t be able to try and trot that one out either. The only thing that’s going well is the stock market for the top 10% pelosi appreciates your support though I have no doubt.
THAT, AND MANY OTHER REASONS!!!!!!!!!!!!
Name one!
@@Kheti1234 HOW ABOUT 34 REASONS??!! WOULD THAT MAKE YOU, FEEL BETTER??!!
@@FranklinWilson-ev9dq You don’t even know what those 34 reasons are!! Try again! Give me one thing Biden or Harris has done that has helped Americans. Allowing people to go back to work is not on Joe.
@@Kheti1234 they didn't try to take over!!!!!!! Your friend, did!!!!!! and the collective denial, won't change anything!!!!!!!!!!!
Listen….last thing this country needs right now is a husk of a human being trying to pretend he’s running the show….
The jobs rebound has nothing to do with Biden.
🥇
$7.00 for a pound of butter. "Jobs" aren't going to fix that.
Where is butter $7 a lb? I live outside of Chicago and get it for under $5, less when on sale.
@@PaulaTrent I work in a supermarket in New England. $6.99
@@turdferguson3475it's New England dude. Get out of there
Weekend at biden's 😂😂literally looks like a walking corpse
"Biden rebound" ???? Lol
Yes, rebound. 20 million jobs and 200k business lost under Trump, in a severe depression. Biden brought the economy back, stronger than it's been in 70-years. He's brought inflation down from 9% to 3%, all while maintaining record job growth and stock market growth. That's a rebound, loser!!
Biden will slay at the debate while Dump rambles about sharks more lol.
@@MarkSav1 Jackie???? Where's Jackie???? - jOE
@@ryblack5032 “What would happen if the boat sank from its weight, and you’re in the boat, and you have this tremendously powerful battery, and the battery’s now under water, and there’s a shark that’s approximately 10 yards over there, by the way a lot of shark attacks lately, do you notice that, a lot of shark… Do I get electrocuted if the boat is sinking, water goes over the battery, boat is sinking.” - Don. Is this a policy position or some profound parable we’re all missing out on? 🤔
They’re both showing senescence, but only one is deranged.
Level Gaza no such thing as Palestinians, no such place as Palestine, made up by Egyptian born Arafat, FACT
WHERE DID YOU GET YOUR " FACT" ACTUALLY PALESTINE HAS BEEN THERE FOR MANY MANY YEARS..ISREAL WAS CUT OUT OF PALESTINE AFTER WW2...BLESS YOUR HEART!...HOW OLD ARE YOU?? IN YOUR 20S I WOULD GUESS..THINK7NG YOU KNOW SOMETHING WHEN THE OPPOSITE IS TRUE. PALESTINE WAS WHERE JESUS WALKED ..2000 YEARS AGO DEAR!!! HAHAHAHA
@@bunnycox1046 cry harder
@@bunnycox1046When did "Palestine" become a country?
2000 YEARS AGO..CANT YOU READ??@@MikeHunt-no2kt
@@bunnycox1046 Source: Trust me bro.
No, he will not lose over this. TRUMP2024
😂😂😂😂😂😂
The Book 2020 will provide you some information ..
Yes, that the RepubliCONS ruined our economy plus........ it's always about Greed with them. VOTE BLUE 💯💙😊
Fun fact, president Trump is leading Joementia in every swing state
the same polls that had Hillary leading Drumpf in 2016? pick a narrative and stick to it, son
Actual fact, Pres. Biden crushed the orange criminal in '20, and will crush him again this November. You're in a cult, GET OUT!!!
Fun fact, he's not.
😂😂😂😂😂😂 suuurrreee 😂😂😂😂😂
Donmentia has definitely kicked in and is spreading among republican voters, forgetting all the turmoil hes put you all through, time to break away and wake up to truth
We republicans would vote none of the above over joe biden!
Donald is dictator
Joe is canceling student loan debt without Congress approval
Joe had to be led off stage by barack.
Lie, Biden walked off stage just fine. Your orange criminal's diaper is full, you should change it!
Do your research it was cut off please quit being so naive !
@@ryblack5032Shut up and don’t believe your lying eyes. We’ll tell you what the facts are. What do you expect from a network that won’t allow you to hear Trump’s speeches. They’ll instead tell you what if anything he says is true or important😂
LIAR
@@ryblack5032 IT was AI via the RNC ! PAY ATTENTION! AND DON'T LISTEN TO TROLL KAPERNICK
MSNBC ❤TRUMP! 😍
Too short
Right and inflation was at 9% when the great one took office. Do your homework people.
Thats one of many bidens lies
Loser Ari
I guess you David as a loser yourself know one......welcome to the loser club.....
There was no jobs rebound.
YES. THERE WAS. AND MANY NEW JOBS ARE 6 FIGURES WITH NO COLLEGE. YOU MUST REALLY BE LIVING ABOVE YOUR MEANS!!
You must live under a rock.
The plan Demic give me a break, dude
Have you not seen all the democrates supporting his stance on bumpstocks he is gaining new votes
Look let the blind lead the blind and may the man lead the people TRUMP 24...
rumpie34
Bidens open border increases competition , etc
I have two questions: 1) How did the Bidens get so rich? And 2) Who is running the country because it ain’t grandpa? Dude can barely speak.
TranSlaytion: "Reee!"
1) Corruption
2) Obama via the WEF/UN
Nope.
Nope ? What?
This administration loves open borders !!
No, Trump killed the bipartisan border bill Biden was prepared to pass for political gains; Criminal Dump’s not good for the border at all.
"Jobs rebound" should be about 8th on the list of reasons Trump should lose the election.
I seriously doubt it .
It's like this all those people did was go back to work from the pandemic hello!!! 😂😂😂
Where’s the jobs rebound? I haven’t seen it. Ghost jobs and layoffs are prevalent though.
We are sick of wars we had peace under trump and 1.4 percent inflation wages were out paceing inflation
Donal.tronp escribir do base
Person. Woman. Man. Camera. TV.
LOCK TRUMP UP!
Biden and Hunter too. Corrupt old man. Dont worship Biden.
Ten million illegals and no jobs. Biden is your hero?. Grow up and dont worship your 100 years old man. Biden.
jobs...HA,A,HA,HA,HA... rebound... HA, HA, HA, HA .........AS IF !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bang bang boom boomer sooner it's going to be the BIGGEST Independence Day!! hip Hip HOORAY 🎉
Hahahaha.
Orange man bad
Nope!
Biden looks ridiculous lol
Trump the rediculess is not FDR... He is more like Homma Simpson....
Far Left extremist propaganda
Ok fascist.
hi troll bot hows putin
You don't know what far left means. Crack open a book, ydoncha? 🤠
@@zzzT. do you even know how to read traitor? hahahaha
Yeah the democrats are telling lies to cover up Joe Biden’s dementia
Biden2024
WHAT A STUPID HEADLINE
Who the best fdr or trump?.
Biden 2021 "Inflation is an asset" Nice guy...
We won't have a country left with geriatric Joe gets in there again
Ari, Ive become to dislike you as a journalist, you do have a law degree, perhaps you need to continue a pursuit in law. For the past several months Ive noticed, paid attention to the difference in you're Journalism skills, its been shameful with arguments of left wing guests. MSNBC needs to address the issues. I use to like you, but no longer.