As far as I could tell he wasnt able to cite one verse from the Quran Where it says that Imams are better than prophets. Because there is no such verse.
وَ إِذِ ابْتَلى إِبْراهِيمَ رَبُّهُ بِكَلِماتٍ فَأَتَمَّهُنَّ قالَ إِنِّي جاعِلُكَ لِلنَّاسِ إِماماً قالَ وَ مِنْ ذُرِّيَّتِي قالَ لا يَنالُ عَهْدِي الظَّالِمِينَ “And when his Lord tried Ibrahim with commands, he fulfilled them. He said: Surely I will make you an Imam for mankind. (Ibrahim) said: And of my offspring (will there be leaders)? He said, my covenant does not include the unjust”. (2:124) Nabi Ibrahim a.s was already an messenger and got elevated to the position of imam for mankind, so imamat is the highest position.
@@j.3628 where are 12 shia Imams though? You brought a verse about Prophet Ibrahim and we know from his progeny there were many prophets including Prophet Mohammad the last of them.
@@KindBatman Ali’s (as) Imamate is higher than the Imamate of other prophets (as) because he was born with his Imamate but the prophets had to earn it and Ali (as) is the rightful successor of Muhammed (saw) he is the husband of Fatima (as) he is the father or Hasan and Hussein (as) he is apart of the Ahlul bayt (as) he is the cousin of Muhammed (saw) he is soul of Muhammed (saw) shown in the event of mubahala
@@wb3123 Quran 17:71 on the day of judgment we will bring everyone with the imam of their time. Now you tell me who is the imam of our time? Us Shias believe imam Mahdi a.s is the imam of our time where is the imam of this time for the sunnis?
Zaib Shah How so? By misquoting Sunni scholars. By applying verses to the imams that are directed to the prophets By claiming that over 600 verses have been revealed on the virtues of Hz Ali when he can't provide a single verse with Hz Ali رضي الله عنه name in it.
O mushrik this verse is about prophet PBUH not about Ali. وَيَقُوۡلُ الَّذِيۡنَ كَفَرُوۡا لَسۡتَ مُرۡسَلًا ؕ قُلۡ كَفٰى بِاللّٰهِ شَهِيۡدًۢا بَيۡنِىۡ وَبَيۡنَكُمۡۙ وَمَنۡ عِنۡدَهٗ عِلۡمُ الۡكِتٰبِ (13:43) The unbelievers claim that you have not been sent by Allah. Tell them: "Allah is sufficient as a witness between me and you; and so also do those who know the Scriptures."62 62. That is, everyone who has the knowledge of the divinely revealed Books will bear witness to the fact that my teachings are the same that were imparted by the former prophets.
Allah says: "The faithless say, ‘You have not been sent [by Allah].’ Say, ‘Allah suffices as a witness between me and you, and he who possesses the knowledge of the Book." Here, "he who possesses the knowledge of the book" refers to Ali (a.s.). When the non-believers said that they don't believe in the Holy Prophet (s.a.w.w.) because he has not been sent by Allah, Allah revealed to the Holy Prophet this ayah which says that as a witness of Prophet Muhammad's (pbuh) prophethood, between the holy Prophet and the non-believers there are two witnesses: Allah (swt) and Ali a.s. because Ali (a.s.) possesses the knowledge of the book. Now you'd say "Why and how does Hazrat Ali possess the knowledge of the book?"---for that, the scholar in the video mentioned the Hadith of the holy Prophet (s.a.w.w.) which says "Ana madinatul 'ilm wa Aliyyun Baabuha" meaning "I am the city of knowledge and Ali is the door".
@@mohdqayemhussain5553 the most ridiculous argument I have ever heard. Are you saying that the prophet arguing with the disbelivers says that my witnesses are Allah and Ali even though the name Ali is not mentioned in the verse, and saying he who understands the book is Ali make the verse completely make no sense. It like saying that if you don't belive me ask my son (cousin), he will tell you l'm truthful. The legitimate response of the other party would be off course he is, he is your cousin!!! At this rate, you can insert the name of Ali a.s. in every verse of the quaran and make the quran look like the book of Ali a.s. If Ali a.s was this Important, Allah would have mentioned his name explicity in the quran. But, since he hasn't, you have to resort to this mental gymnastics by destorting the clear meaning of the quran.
@@abdulshkuradem7651 there are 1.24 lacs prophets but only 26 names are mentioned.is this not mental gymnastics....u foolish?Allah has said that some ayats i have revealed explicitly and some not as to check the iman of munafiqs like u
@@AbuFadl Chapter (32) sūrat l-sajdah (The Prostration) And We made Imams guiding by Our command when they were patient and [when] they were certain of Our signs. Clearly "Guiding by our command"! Allah says i have made them imams and they Guide by my command! Command of Allah comes through revelation dude!
@@AbuFadl ITS ABOUT HOW IMAMS GUIDE MEANS THEY Recieve Divine REVELATION DUDE. not only imams of isreal recieved it but every imam gets orders from Allah almighty i think you should read the verse again! This verse is not meant to prove imamte in lineage of Ismail A.S but this verse shows a quality of an Imam! Further Allah celarly says thay he made them imams, imamate is given by Allah Almighty and the one who is made imam by Allah almighty, he gets Allahs orders! Bani sireal has nothing to do with what i want to convey!
@@AbuFadl Our Prophet S.A.W is above all the prophets yet you consider Imams he made( As per Allahs order) inferior to others by saying they don't get divine revelation? Allah has clearly said that whom he made imams, he guided them by his command! Thus saying Imams recieve divine revelation isn't at all a shirk but is what Allah has said!
Are you guys saying that the Quran we have for the last 1400 years is useless, since there is no imam? What was the point of prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) even coming if the Quran he bought us is not used? If hazrat Ali RA was supposed to be an Imam, why did he not just Become an Imam straight after the death of prophet? Why did he wait for 3 caliphs before he became the 4th caliph. Why did he accept the caliphate of Abu Bakr, umar and uthman? This guy with a turban couldn’t even give a single verse from the Quran that states the concept of Imamate or that Ali RA should be an Imam.
Bismillahirrahmanirrahim يٰٓاَيُّهَا الَّذِيْنَ اٰمَنُوْٓا اَطِيْعُوا اللّٰهَ وَاَطِيْعُوا الرَّسُوْلَ وَاُولِى الْاَمْرِ مِنْكُمْ 4:59 Allah(swt) makes it clear throughout the Qur'an that Leadership and Guardianship of the Ummah is and has always been by Divine Order, never from the ways of mankind: A few examples: 2:124 - And remember that Abraham was tried by his Lord with certain commands, which he fulfilled: He said: “I will make thee an Imam to the Nations.” He pleaded: “And also (Imams) from my offspring!” He answered: “But My Promise is not within the reach of evil-doers.” 21:73 - And We made them leaders( Imams) guiding by Our command. And We inspired to them the doing of good deeds, establishment of prayer, and giving of zakah; and they were worshippers of Us. 35/43 - But you will never find in the way of Allah any change, and you will never find in the way of Allah( Sunnatuallah) any alteration. 3:102 -104 O you who have believed, fear Allah as He should be feared and do not die except as Muslims [in submission to Him]. And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided. And remember the favor of Allah upon you - when you were enemies and He brought your hearts together and you became, by His favor, brothers. And you were on the edge of a pit of the Fire, and He saved you from it. Thus does Allah make clear to you His verses that you may be guided. And let there be [arising] from you a nation inviting to [all that is] good, enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong, and those will be the successful.
It's not useless. There is hadith from sahih muslim, حدیث الثقلین To cling to quran AND aho bayt, and he emphasizes on ahl bayt three times. Qur'an is one source of guidance, but the other source of guidance is ahl bayt which is also very important and useful. Qur'an is great bit it's guidance is only complete with the help ahl bayt, Quran is like the chest of treasure, the key is ahl bayt. Just like prophet said, انا مدینه العلم، و علی بابها
Why the Imams are superior to the Prophets? His answer was vague and had nothing to do with the question. If U read 3:61 not 3:67, it doesn't say anything about Imams or Ali ra. In the same Surat, 3:33, Allah swt chose Adam, Noah, Ahl Ibraheem, (ra) above all mankind.
I’m not claiming to have one view or the other, but the verse you used there is a caveat that it refers to the people of their time. This is obvious because prophet Muhammad (pbuh) is the greatest creation of Allah but is not in the verse. Another example of something similar is verse 3:42 where it is said Mary (as) has been chosen over all the women in the world, however according to the Hadith either Khadijah or Aysha are the best of women.
@@InZainGamer The Quran takes precedence over the hadiths, it was revealed for ages til the end of time. Also, is in the Quran that we dd not make any distinction between any of the messengers.
@@Carlito_El_Gooner Yes and no. A more accurate statement is that the hadith gives us a context in which we can understand the Quran. Verse 3:33 does not specify a restriction on the word ٱلْعَـٰلَمِينَ, so we don't know if it talks about the current worlds, the past worlds, or all worlds both past and present. Because there is no restriction, we can look at the hadith and apply context to it. Ironically, if you look at the verse, it specifically mentions the "family of Abraham." All 12 imams are from Quraish, meaning they are a part of the family of Abraham. If we take your meaning that because the Quran is for all ages till the end of time, then the verse must be talking about all people past and present, then the 12 imams would be greater than all the prophets not mentioned in verse (which is not my personal belief). This brings me to my second point: the verse of not distinguishing between any messengers 2:285 does not mean comparing the messengers. Instead, the verse is about believing in some messengers and rejecting others, according to tafsir Ibn Kathir. Moreover, If we take your understanding of verse 3:33, we would have a contradiction as how is it on one hand, God tells us that he chose some messengers over others, and then on the other hand, tells us not to make a distinction between them. Finally, I would like to add that Prophet Muhammad is the greatest of all prophets and Allah's greatest creation
Because some of these stuff other sunnis believe in in Afghanistan we do have more common believes with shias than salafis so your question is their brother biased maybe because you think all sunni have the same beleif you might have learned your relaigon through wahabis unknowingly
@@KindBatman it's not Kufr, Kufr was actually committed by Omar ibne Khattab who used to say that Allah says this but I say that. You can check your own Sunni books where he said these type of statements
@@KindBatman Jesus would pray behind the Imam Mahdi , and Imam would do Imamat of prayer, this is not Kufr Hazrat Adam (as) Prayed to Allah for forgiveness and used the names of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) , Imam Ali, Hadhrat Fatima (sa), Imam Hassan (as) , Imam Hussain (as) as Waseelah and then Allah Forgave him
Where does امام بيضاوي say that this proves Imam Ali is better than all the Sahaba and prophets Imam Baidhaawi's words are و هو دليل علي نبوته و فضل من اتي بهم من أهل بيته And in this is proof of his(prophets)nubuwwat(prophethood) and a virtue(Fadhl)for those who he brought with him Where in this quote does lmam Baidhaawi claim that this makes them better than Sahaba and prophets. Its like saying the prophet's (صلي الله عليه و سلم )taking Abu Bakr(R.A) with him on migration to Madeenah is a great virtue(fadhl) for Abu Bakr (which it undoubtedly was) but you won't find any Sunni claiming this makes Abu Bakr better than everyone else.
Further on he claims imam is a special position only given to those who are tested by Allah and they pass that test. Weren't all prophets tested and didn't they all pass that test. Allah mentions in Surah Anbiyaa after naming Ibrahim,Lut,Ishaq and Yaqub عليهم السلام وجعلناهم اءمّة يهدون بامرنا. Verse 73 Ambiya Which shows they were all imams So whose better Someone who gets direct Wahi and who Allah says he's made an imam or someone who's name hasn't been mentioned in the Quran
abdalla. ibn. sabaa told. shia. that ali. is. god. in. human . form when. ali. heared. he burned. them. a llive who. believeded ali. ra. was. a god. shia. naver. leave their. old. pagans believe. bifore. they. use to. . worship. fire. but. now. they. worship. human and. this. video. is the. prove. shia. believe. ali. is. more then. human and... thy. openly accepting only. rasool. nabi. ambiyaa. allowed to. have. wahi. .. not. sahaaba.
If Ibrahim & Adam were Imams & prophets, that means he's better than Ali because Ali was only an imam. Btw, if theirs a hierarchy in the Quran of Prophethood & Imamate- how can Ali achieve Imamate without prophethood? Because those prophets in Quran were Imams & Prophets. In fact, after being a prophet Allah raised the rank of Ibrahim to Imam, right? So how can Ali be better with lower qualifications? makes no sense
The Prophet said, "Will you not be pleased that you will be to me like Aaron (Harun) to Moses (Musa)? But there will be no prophet after me." Sahih al BukhariVolume 5, Book 59, Number 700 If Allah had not made Prophet Muhammad (saw) as the final prophet then surely from the above hadith it is evident that Ali(as) was a worthy person to be a prophet after him by God. Since Prophet Muhammad (saw) is the final prophet then why would Allah make Ali(as) as a prophet?
Imma Ali's name was mentioned in tons of hadiths yet you guys choose to remove him from them. Imagine if it was in the holy Quran. What would you guys do then?
@@HassanAli-qk9nq Actually u can't affect Quran But people who were munafiq could use the same names as were mentioned in Quran. As many Hadiths were self made. Maybe That's why Allah in Quran told characteristics not names of Imams..
@@HassanAli-qk9nq he means Enemies of Imam Ali like the Ummayyads may have said anyone else ALi , and may have said that he is the one whom Quran is telling us about
No imam can ever be more superior than any one single prophet of Allah. There are hadith to back that up. Namely hadith narrated by our Prophet's beautiful companions Shia in fact reject and label Kafir. Nauzobillah. So no surprise there. No imam has ever received divine intervention, that's just not true. And Hazrat Ali r.a was to come back now he would instantly go to Jihad against the Shia. May Allah guide the Shia for very baseless beliefs. Final question: if Shia are truthful why is it that in 14 centuries Allah has not allowed them to lead a single prayer in Haram of Makkah? Has Allah forgotten them? You bet He has!
Because the leaders of Saudi Arabia have nothing to do with islam. They're the ones building temples and opening alcohol shops in mecca. Why did Allah allow that then? Dumbass
The immam is higher then the prophet there is a story in the quran were allah promoted a prophat to a immam the only reason why prophet mohammed (sai) is higher then immam ali is because the prophet also an immam. The prophet is an immam, messanger and a prophet. The prophet name is prophet ebrahim (AS). He was already a prophet but like i said allah promopted him to a immam. So if prophet out ranks immam why did he get the promotion to immam.
@@mohamadkhateeb402 Because Imam Ali is the succesor of Imam ul mursaleen, The prophet saw who is superior of all prophets, it's the family of Prophet Muhammad saw
@@mohamadkhateeb402 there are countless ahadith in sunni books that imam mahdi will lead the prayer and prophet Jesus as will pray behind him since when a superior prays behind someone inferior to him ? Does that make sense to you ? No disrespect but I come from a sunni hanafi background myself and using our brains is a taboo we were raised and programmed to accept stupidty
Kamadev888 it is because the Holy Prophet (SAW) went to mubahila with the him. When he was told in the Quran take your sons he took Imam Hassan (AS) and Imam Hussain(AS) and he was told to take his women he took Bibi Fatima(AS) and when he was told to gather himself or his nafs he took Imam Ali (AS). All sects agree that these five went to the mubahila.
When Rasul s.a.w went for hijrah that night Allah swt asked Rasool s.a.w to let some one sleep in his s.a.w place but the one who sleeps in his s.a.ws place must be same as Rasool s.a.w
@@KindBatman and when did such thing happen?? On the day of Rasool s.a.w demise he s.a.w pulled abu bakr from qibla and lead the prayer and Rasool s.a.w has already said Ali a.s. is your mola after me than how one can call himself above Ali a.s. Ali a.s. is Ala in every thing he possesed the knowledge of Rasool s.a.w he was the husband of Fatima a.s. leader of all ladies in paradise and father of hassan a.s. and hussain a.s. who are leaders of youth and Ali a.s. is the one who prayed with Rasool s.a.w when he s.a.w used to pray alone before he was gifted with prophethood doesnt matter how much you people deny but deep down you all know that Ali a.s. is haq but your ignorance dont let u accept it
I see a Lion right here god bless him whats his name he talks like a eagle and thinking like a rhino the sunni guy off topic as usual normality of hyprocites in islam disrespecting the knoledge of imams.
what is wrong with those Shia’s and rafidiya sects? They are really not good in there heads. do they really not see that they are on the wrong road? They elevate Ali ra as much as the Christians do to Isa as! Forget about that political nonsense and worship Allah swt and follow the prophet saw! This is the most important! Stop shirk Oh people and ask Allah swt protection against the fire!
The reason why humans need imams is the exact reason why angels and shaytan were ordered to prostrate to Adam. To destroy their ego and gain total obedience. Shaytan couldn't bow to Adam because his 6000 years of praying only had grew his ego, as he thought he has a special connection with Allah. Now that Allah tell him to bow to someone else, his ego doesn't let him. ابا واستکبر We humans if we don't have imams that we have to follow, our orayers to Allah will be like shaytan prayers. Only growing our ego
Aslam o alykum my brother’s first a fall we have to know this that in Islam there is no Shia and Suni we are Muslim and Muslim is the one who follow quran and Hadith of the prophet Muhammad saw and it’s mention in Quran so many place that follow quran and teaching of the prophet Muhammad saw may peace and blessing of Allah be upon all of them so don’t make Islam so hard for the people to benefit the enemy’s of Islam don’t make your religion in to pecs and this is the beauty of Islam one book one Islam one religion not Shia not Suni and request u all brothers open the Quran and read by your own first and find where it does said to be Shia or Suni no where so follow this word ... follow Quran and teaching of the prophets that is it as the all imams said if any fatwa of Mine goes against teaching of Allah and his rasoul Throw that fatwa on the wal so think about this and don’t waste your time with something which Quran and Hadith of the prophet saw never said about if u do so u will burdens your self and make tired of your self May Allah guide all those who called them self Shia and Suni
he has to lie against Umar and say Umar said "We don't want your progeny"... Why do Shia have to try to make the whole world to be the worst of creatures only to prove Ali was suppose to be imam....wow
Salam alaikum, how can with all my respect 'Ali or the other Imams be "better" than the Prophets before Mohammed (saws)? Alone Jesus (a s) and the way he is born and his coming at the end of the time. If the Imams who are according to the Shi'a superior and are here to protect the message, how it is that the majority of the Muslims not Shi'a? It would mean that only 10 or 15% from the last revealed message and religion are saved? This would mean that the last religion failed.
Imams have shown so many miracles by the help of Allah, and Last Imam and succesor of Holy Prophet (pbuh) would also come in this world just like Jesus by the Permission of Allah
@@kataangsucks But all the Imams were not Prophet. If the 12Shia would have right then why all these différents groups like the Zaydid, Ismailis and many others who didn't exist anymore now; if the 12 Shia would have right, the Prophet (saws) would have transmit this doctrine since the very beginning and this would be clear in the Quran. And as it is the last revealed religion, you think that only a little group is on the right way?. Don't misunderstand me please, I don't support Moawiya and his son and believe Ali and his family are with truth.
I am Shia and don't believe this! This is absurd,it is because of these beliefs Shias get accused of extreme veneration of these Imams,the Imams never claimed these things,it is we that bestow these qualities on them,if we study their lives,they never claimed any of these qualities,they never considered themselves infallible either,these are just man's own beliefs that the Imams should possess these qualities,they themselves never proffessed that,however with a Prophet he actually declares his Prophethood,this belief in Imam getting divine knowledge directly from Allah(swt) is your own belief. The Imams followed the Sunnah of the Prophet (Sawas),they added nothing to it and took away nothing from it.
he does not know what he is talking about he keep mentioning sourat from the quran witch is not saying what he is ....he keeps laying and you call your self an imam !!!!
Brother stop making fun of islamic scholars....If you dont believe their beliefs then leave upto them...who are you to tell that they are wrong and abusing that he is wearing tires btw it is amamah you idiot....Allah will Judge Them....
@@KindBatman From the words of Imam Ja’far ibn Muhammad Al-Sadiq (as), one of the most honorific titles a Shia can receive is the title Rafidha, the one who rejects the legitimacy of the caliphate of the first three and condemns the caliphs that came after Hassan ibn Ali (as).
Ali ra is great bt not greater than prophets u cannot compare him to adam as thry were rasool and moula both n prophet also is rasool and moula bt how come he is not greater than prophet Muhammad sws bt greater than all prophets just extra exaggeration !
12 imams. . run shia. head. all. the.. time. they. even. believe. ali. fatima. is. apart. of. god. christian. believe.. jesus. is . apart. of god. all. disbelievres have. same. logic god. save. us from their. shirki. kufri
ali. ra. he. is. not greater . then. great. sahaaba. but. he. was. 1of. them. he. was. good follower. of. Prophets. saw. teaching. like. other great sahaaba. . do. for. me. ali. is. simple great. sahabi. and. i♡ khulafaau raashideen they. r. ahlul . jannah i love. all. of. them ♡ ♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡
@@fardowdo30yaayamaxammed6 Imam Ali is the greatest Man after the holy prophet(s).....No one ever had the nearest position to rasoolallah..He is One of the Member of ahlulbayt..and the first Imam of the 12 imams...he is the gate to madinatul ilm....it goes on forever like these if we want to talk about his accolades...So Don't compare Lion of Allah with Khulafa Rashideen..it is like comparing Gold with aluminium
Can someone please provide reference to the incident maulana quoted where Abu Bakr/ Omer refuted progeny and considered Quran to be sufficient. Where after, they came to Hazrat Ali when they failed to answer the jaws questions.
It's written in Sunni Books, open them and see, you will find Thousands of similar incidents, and also fake fabricated Narrations praising Omar ibne Khattab
How is it that our Sunni brothers know the tafsir of the holy Quran when it was sent down on prophet Muhammad. Meaning he is a prophet. The Quran is the word of Allah. If all that is true and you believe it then how does the word of Allah come down to the prophet and us normal people understand so easily?
Because Allah azza wa jalla is the most judge, and he made the deen simple for everyone to understand. So that on the day of judgement no one has an excuse why he did not follow the prophet mohammed sallalahu aleyhi wa sallam. Whats the point of sending down the message that is hard to understand for the people? There are enough verses that indicated that muhammed is the final prophet. Even a whole chapter named Surah Muhammed. And still you guys follow Ali radiya Allahu 3anhu. Soo deluded may Allah guide you or break your back
@@promocro1 lol you do know that after the prophet you follow abu bakr and umar. Right? Lmao. We follow ali bc no one followed the prophet to the dot like ali did. He was raised and taught by the prophet. And in the Quran it says clearly. That I am a Warner and to every nation there’s a guide. Go look up who the guide is than talk to me. Don’t speak out of ignorance. You say we follow ali like it’s only him we follow. Which is all false. We follow what Allah tells us, the prophet and ahlulbyat.
@@mmsaf17 and where in the quran says that you must follow ahlul bait specifically? And why dont you shia then dont follow abu bakr and umar radiya Allah 3anhuma?
@@promocro1 plenty verses mention ahlulbyat. I don’t ask anything of you except love for my near kin. Near kin isn’t anyone. Allah says in Surah 5:55. I am ur wali and so is the prophet and those who give charity while in prostration. That verse is about imam ali. Altabri says that in his book. It just so happens that ali is part of his ahlulbyat as well. Imam ali was appointed by the prophet on many occasions. Now show me where in the Quran does it specifically say we need to follow abu bakr and umar
Hazrat Ali R.A was just a man. He did not receive revelation. Stop creating lies about the companions of the Rasool Allah. You lack reason. They were great *men* and the best of the generations. But thats about it, you cannot compare the two. Chosen by Allah and Chosen by Rasool Allah.
Hazrat Ali RA was not a man only. He was Waliullah . There is no doubt that the companions of the Holy Prophet SAW are great man but Hazrat Ali RA was the first imam. Maulla Ali RA was the greatest man after the Holy Prophet SAW. He was the city of knowledge and he was spiritually blessed. It's your common sense, a Prophets friends are greater or their family. Be sensible and only review the concept of shiaism with cencerity and patience.
A cursory glance: Shias have conflated imam with prophet, which is dangerous. They’ve also surrounded the term with superstition and non facts. Imagine believing that anyone surpassed gods chosen prophets who receive direction from Allah SWT through Gabriel. Do imams only appear after prophet Muhammad SAW? Who was the “imam” between Jesus AS and prophet Muhammad SAW? Allahu Akbar
hujat al islam? pakistani syed?? what a complete joke. he supposedly comes from the lineage of the prophet saw, and cant recite quran properly. fear your creator.
Prophet Ibrahim is also Imam, Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) is also Imam, and Allah (swt) blessed them Imamat after Risalat (prophethood), so Imamat is Superior. And Imam Ali is the Imam , he (as) is the succesor of Imam ul mursaleen (Prophet Muhammad who is superior to all prophets). Allah (swt) has described Virtues of Imam Ali in Quran and about thousands of verses are revealed about Imam Ali (as) Imamat is Superior to prophethood is proved by logical evidences as well as from Qura'an and Shia'a Books. That's for sure. You have to be very Intelligent if you wanna be a true Muslim or true believer or Momin ❤️
Didn'nt you say Ali a.s is the nefs of the prophet s.a.w, how can the prophet s.a.w then say he the city of knowledge and Ali a.s is the gate (by the way I appreciate a sahih reference for that). Shouldn't he have said I'm the city of knowledge and Ali is too???
Imamat Allah ki taraf se hai, imamat risalat se arzal hai, imam Allah ka representative hota hai, imamat aur risalat aik hee tara ki cheez hen, Muhammad Rasool Allah as k 12 jaan nasheen hen, 11 ko yeh umat katal ker chukki hai barwen ka daur jari hai,........in bara k lie mujje Huzoor as ki wo hadees yad a rehi hai k " meri umat k Ulma bani israeel k anbia se afzal hen"......yeh umat ulti ho jai tab b is hadees ko na chupa sakti hai na badla sakti hai
You were born a Shia and reject the superiority of Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib (as), after Rasoolullah SAWW? Being born a Shia and being a Shia are two different things.
Where did Omar r.a say we don't need your progeny? Please offer sahih evidence for that. Also, sahihi evidence would be nice for the conversation between Ali and Abubeker redyellah anhuma, Ali a.s. saying didn't you say the quran is sufficient for us. Also what part of the quran didn't the Caliphs know that they had to ask Ali a.s about it. I'm not saying Ali a.s. is not knowledgeable; to the contrary, he is extremely knowledgeable. But it seems very strange that the prophet s.a.w teaches the sahaba for 23 about Islam and Quran which is meant for the entire world, but only one person understands it and this is because he belonged to the prophets household.Are you sayin Fatimatu zahrah a.s. didnot know nor accept Abubeker as the leader? Why did she address him as caliphetu resul when she asked for her inheritance of Fadek???
where does it say Imam. oh Mushrik وَكَمۡ اَهۡلَكۡنَا مِنَ الۡقُرُوۡنِ مِنۡۢ بَعۡدِ نُوۡحٍؕ وَكَفٰى بِرَبِّكَ بِذُنُوۡبِ عِبَادِهٖ خَبِيۡرًۢا بَصِيۡرًا (17:17) Many a generation has been destroyed by Our command since Noah's time. Your Lord is well aware and fully observant of the sins of His servants.
Shias such a liers...the verse is all about the prophets being imams...it has nothing to do with the imams or khalifas after the prophet...so every nation will be brought forward with their imam(prophet)..if your claim is true....who is the imam of the people after nabii issa before the coming of our propher mohammad???who was the imam of the nation after the death of nabii musa???shias always interprate ayas upside down....
According to SHIT ,OOPS I MEAN SHI'TE, that reza can heal anyone who calls on him but how ironic that reza couldn't heal himself by growing arms, ha ha ha, Khoorofart thats khoorofart TAQQIYA is is 9/10 off Shi'te sect, Ali head is lost, and the Shi'te sect are looking for it and ali you would think that ali maddad can find it, till today Shi'te cant find ali head.
اعوذ بالله من الشیطان الرجیم. Mr you are changing the verse of The { Noble Qur'an } to suit your own false interpretation. This is real verse, Sura Al Imran - 3 - aya - 67 - In Urdu. مَا كَانَ إِبْرَاهِيمُ يَهُودِيًّا وَلَا نَصْرَانِيًّا وَلَكِنْ كَانَ حَنِيفًا مُسْلِمًا وَمَا كَانَ مِنَ الْمُشْرِكِينَ. ابراہیمؑ نہ یہودی تھا نہ عیسائی، بلکہ وہ ایک مسلم یکسو تھا اور وہ ہرگز مشرکوں میں سے نہ تھا. ( سورة آل عمران - 3 - 67 ) In Farsi ( Persian ) مَا كَانَ إِبْرَاهِيمُ يَهُودِيًّا وَلَا نَصْرَانِيًّا وَلَكِنْ كَانَ حَنِيفًا مُسْلِمًا وَمَا كَانَ مِنَ الْمُشْرِكِينَ. ابراهیم نه یهودی بود و نه نصرانی، بلکه یکتاپرست و حق گرایی تسلیم بود، و از مشرکان نبود.. ( سورة آل عمران - 3 - 67 ) In English. مَا كَانَ إِبْرَاهِيمُ يَهُودِيًّا وَلَا نَصْرَانِيًّا وَلَكِنْ كَانَ حَنِيفًا مُسْلِمًا وَمَا كَانَ مِنَ الْمُشْرِكِينَ. Abraham was neither a Jew nor a Christian, but he was one inclining toward truth, a Muslim [submitting to Allah]. And he was not of the polytheists. Al Quran. ( سورة آل عمران - 3 - 67 ) May Almighty Allah guide you people to to the right teaching of , ISLAM , خان.
Hazrat Ali RA was one of the greatest Muslims to ever have lived and will be promised Jannah, but he is not an Imam, nor does he have some special knowledge of the Quran.
Prophet Said : Ali Is with Quran and Quran is with Ali Many other Ahadiths and narrations tells us that Quran And Ahlebait (as) cannot be divided. These are special , and no one could compare himself with Ahlebait. Ahlebait is the pure and special family of Last Prophet who is Imam ul Mursaleen (Superior to all prophets) Don't tell your Jewish views about Prophet's Successor.
@@paktechniques2012 prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam also said many things about hazrat Umar r.a and hazrat Abu baqr siddique r.a. why you only believe in that saying which is according to your school of thought?
As far as I could tell he wasnt able to cite one verse from the Quran Where it says that Imams are better than prophets. Because there is no such verse.
وَ إِذِ ابْتَلى إِبْراهِيمَ رَبُّهُ بِكَلِماتٍ فَأَتَمَّهُنَّ قالَ إِنِّي جاعِلُكَ لِلنَّاسِ إِماماً قالَ وَ مِنْ ذُرِّيَّتِي قالَ لا يَنالُ عَهْدِي الظَّالِمِينَ
“And when his Lord tried Ibrahim with commands, he fulfilled them. He said: Surely I will make you an Imam for mankind. (Ibrahim) said: And of my offspring (will there be leaders)? He said, my covenant does not include the unjust”. (2:124)
Nabi Ibrahim a.s was already an messenger and got elevated to the position of imam for mankind, so imamat is the highest position.
@@j.3628 What about all the other imam prophets lol.
Prophets = Imam + prophet
Ali = Just an imam.
So the prophets are GREATER!
@@j.3628 where are 12 shia Imams though? You brought a verse about Prophet Ibrahim and we know from his progeny there were many prophets including Prophet Mohammad the last of them.
@@KindBatman Ali’s (as) Imamate is higher than the Imamate of other prophets (as) because he was born with his Imamate but the prophets had to earn it and Ali (as) is the rightful successor of Muhammed (saw) he is the husband of Fatima (as) he is the father or Hasan and Hussein (as) he is apart of the Ahlul bayt (as) he is the cousin of Muhammed (saw) he is soul of Muhammed (saw) shown in the event of mubahala
@@wb3123 Quran 17:71 on the day of judgment we will bring everyone with the imam of their time. Now you tell me who is the imam of our time? Us Shias believe imam Mahdi a.s is the imam of our time where is the imam of this time for the sunnis?
MashaAllah.very well given answers.
Zaib Shah
How so?
By misquoting Sunni scholars.
By applying verses to the imams that are directed to the prophets
By claiming that over 600 verses have been revealed on the virtues of Hz Ali when he can't provide a single verse with Hz Ali رضي الله عنه name in it.
@@abukhadeejah ua-cam.com/video/eCh_Y-3-40I/v-deo.html
Subhanallah....ali raza rizvi saheb is the gem of our treasure
O mushrik this verse is about prophet PBUH not about Ali.
وَيَقُوۡلُ الَّذِيۡنَ كَفَرُوۡا لَسۡتَ مُرۡسَلًا ؕ قُلۡ كَفٰى بِاللّٰهِ شَهِيۡدًۢا بَيۡنِىۡ وَبَيۡنَكُمۡۙ وَمَنۡ عِنۡدَهٗ عِلۡمُ الۡكِتٰبِ
(13:43) The unbelievers claim that you have not been sent by Allah. Tell them: "Allah is sufficient as a witness between me and you; and so also do those who know the Scriptures."62
62. That is, everyone who has the knowledge of the divinely revealed Books will bear witness to the fact that my teachings are the same that were imparted by the former prophets.
Allah says: "The faithless say, ‘You have not been sent [by Allah].’ Say, ‘Allah suffices as a witness between me and you, and he who possesses the knowledge of the Book."
Here, "he who possesses the knowledge of the book" refers to Ali (a.s.). When the non-believers said that they don't believe in the Holy Prophet (s.a.w.w.) because he has not been sent by Allah, Allah revealed to the Holy Prophet this ayah which says that as a witness of Prophet Muhammad's (pbuh) prophethood, between the holy Prophet and the non-believers there are two witnesses: Allah (swt) and Ali a.s. because Ali (a.s.) possesses the knowledge of the book. Now you'd say "Why and how does Hazrat Ali possess the knowledge of the book?"---for that, the scholar in the video mentioned the Hadith of the holy Prophet (s.a.w.w.) which says "Ana madinatul 'ilm wa Aliyyun Baabuha" meaning "I am the city of knowledge and Ali is the door".
@@mohdqayemhussain5553 the most ridiculous argument I have ever heard. Are you saying that the prophet arguing with the disbelivers says that my witnesses are Allah and Ali even though the name Ali is not mentioned in the verse, and saying he who understands the book is Ali make the verse completely make no sense. It like saying that if you don't belive me ask my son (cousin), he will tell you l'm truthful. The legitimate response of the other party would be off course he is, he is your cousin!!! At this rate, you can insert the name of Ali a.s. in every verse of the quaran and make the quran look like the book of Ali a.s. If Ali a.s was this Important, Allah would have mentioned his name explicity in the quran. But, since he hasn't, you have to resort to this mental gymnastics by destorting the clear meaning of the quran.
@@abdulshkuradem7651 there are 1.24 lacs prophets but only 26 names are mentioned.is this not mental gymnastics....u foolish?Allah has said that some ayats i have revealed explicitly and some not as to check the iman of munafiqs like u
I would just mention with divine knowledge , Lady Maryam (AS) received revelation from Allah SWT and she is not regarded as a Prophet .
provide similar statement of any imam in the Quran and you have a point.
@@AbuFadl Chapter (32) sūrat l-sajdah (The Prostration)
And We made Imams guiding by Our command when they were patient and [when] they were certain of Our signs.
Clearly "Guiding by our command"! Allah says i have made them imams and they Guide by my command! Command of Allah comes through revelation dude!
@@syedalimehdi-english read the verse before it in context its speaking about must and the children of Israel. Got anything else?
@@AbuFadl ITS ABOUT HOW IMAMS GUIDE MEANS THEY Recieve Divine REVELATION DUDE. not only imams of isreal recieved it but every imam gets orders from Allah almighty i think you should read the verse again! This verse is not meant to prove imamte in lineage of Ismail A.S but this verse shows a quality of an Imam! Further Allah celarly says thay he made them imams, imamate is given by Allah Almighty and the one who is made imam by Allah almighty, he gets Allahs orders! Bani sireal has nothing to do with what i want to convey!
@@AbuFadl Our Prophet S.A.W is above all the prophets yet you consider Imams he made( As per Allahs order) inferior to others by saying they don't get divine revelation?
Allah has clearly said that whom he made imams, he guided them by his command! Thus saying Imams recieve divine revelation isn't at all a shirk but is what Allah has said!
Are you guys saying that the Quran we have for the last 1400 years is useless, since there is no imam? What was the point of prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) even coming if the Quran he bought us is not used? If hazrat Ali RA was supposed to be an Imam, why did he not just Become an Imam straight after the death of prophet? Why did he wait for 3 caliphs before he became the 4th caliph. Why did he accept the caliphate of Abu Bakr, umar and uthman? This guy with a turban couldn’t even give a single verse from the Quran that states the concept of Imamate or that Ali RA should be an Imam.
Bismillahirrahmanirrahim
يٰٓاَيُّهَا الَّذِيْنَ اٰمَنُوْٓا اَطِيْعُوا اللّٰهَ وَاَطِيْعُوا الرَّسُوْلَ وَاُولِى الْاَمْرِ مِنْكُمْ 4:59
Allah(swt) makes it clear throughout the Qur'an that Leadership and Guardianship of the Ummah is and has always been by Divine Order, never from the ways of mankind:
A few examples:
2:124 - And remember that Abraham was tried by his Lord with certain commands, which he fulfilled: He said: “I will make thee an Imam to the Nations.” He pleaded: “And also (Imams) from my offspring!” He answered: “But My Promise is not within the reach of evil-doers.”
21:73 - And We made them leaders( Imams) guiding by Our command. And We inspired to them the doing of good deeds, establishment of prayer, and giving of zakah; and they were worshippers of Us.
35/43 - But you will never find in the way of Allah any change, and you will never find in the way of Allah( Sunnatuallah) any alteration.
3:102 -104 O you who have believed, fear Allah as He should be feared and do not die except as Muslims [in submission to Him].
And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided. And remember the favor of Allah upon you - when you were enemies and He brought your hearts together and you became, by His favor, brothers. And you were on the edge of a pit of the Fire, and He saved you from it. Thus does Allah make clear to you His verses that you may be guided.
And let there be [arising] from you a nation inviting to [all that is] good, enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong, and those will be the successful.
It's not useless.
There is hadith from sahih muslim, حدیث الثقلین
To cling to quran AND aho bayt, and he emphasizes on ahl bayt three times.
Qur'an is one source of guidance, but the other source of guidance is ahl bayt which is also very important and useful. Qur'an is great bit it's guidance is only complete with the help ahl bayt, Quran is like the chest of treasure, the key is ahl bayt. Just like prophet said,
انا مدینه العلم، و علی بابها
Why the Imams are superior to the Prophets? His answer was vague and had nothing to do with the question. If U read 3:61 not 3:67, it doesn't say anything about Imams or Ali ra. In the same Surat, 3:33, Allah swt chose Adam, Noah, Ahl Ibraheem, (ra) above all mankind.
I’m not claiming to have one view or the other, but the verse you used there is a caveat that it refers to the people of their time. This is obvious because prophet Muhammad (pbuh) is the greatest creation of Allah but is not in the verse.
Another example of something similar is verse 3:42 where it is said Mary (as) has been chosen over all the women in the world, however according to the Hadith either Khadijah or Aysha are the best of women.
@@InZainGamer The Quran takes precedence over the hadiths, it was revealed for ages til the end of time. Also, is in the Quran that we dd not make any distinction between any of the messengers.
@@Carlito_El_Gooner Yes and no. A more accurate statement is that the hadith gives us a context in which we can understand the Quran. Verse 3:33 does not specify a restriction on the word ٱلْعَـٰلَمِينَ, so we don't know if it talks about the current worlds, the past worlds, or all worlds both past and present. Because there is no restriction, we can look at the hadith and apply context to it.
Ironically, if you look at the verse, it specifically mentions the "family of Abraham." All 12 imams are from Quraish, meaning they are a part of the family of Abraham. If we take your meaning that because the Quran is for all ages till the end of time, then the verse must be talking about all people past and present, then the 12 imams would be greater than all the prophets not mentioned in verse (which is not my personal belief).
This brings me to my second point: the verse of not distinguishing between any messengers 2:285 does not mean comparing the messengers. Instead, the verse is about believing in some messengers and rejecting others, according to tafsir Ibn Kathir. Moreover, If we take your understanding of verse 3:33, we would have a contradiction as how is it on one hand, God tells us that he chose some messengers over others, and then on the other hand, tells us not to make a distinction between them.
Finally, I would like to add that Prophet Muhammad is the greatest of all prophets and Allah's greatest creation
But they omitted the wa'ala Muhammad in this ayah.. bani Muawiyah...
@@sheedicd4350brother no modem alim amongst the Shia holds such a view. Where are you getting this?
Why can’t you just say Sunni? Nothing about that question was Wahhabi. Anyone who calls themselves a Sunni would ask that question, not just Wahhabis
Because some of these stuff other sunnis believe in in Afghanistan we do have more common believes with shias than salafis so your question is their brother biased maybe because you think all sunni have the same beleif you might have learned your relaigon through wahabis unknowingly
Wake up world these guys speak truth!
Nah. This is straight up kufr
But hes too knowledgeable about this topic
@@KindBatman it's not Kufr,
Kufr was actually committed by Omar ibne Khattab who used to say that Allah says this but I say that.
You can check your own Sunni books where he said these type of statements
@@KindBatman Jesus would pray behind the Imam Mahdi , and Imam would do Imamat of prayer, this is not Kufr
Hazrat Adam (as) Prayed to Allah for forgiveness and used the names of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) , Imam Ali, Hadhrat Fatima (sa), Imam Hassan (as) , Imam Hussain (as) as Waseelah and then Allah Forgave him
@@KindBatman this is not Kufr
Where does امام بيضاوي say that this proves
Imam Ali is better than all the Sahaba and prophets
Imam Baidhaawi's words are
و هو دليل علي نبوته و فضل من اتي بهم من أهل بيته
And in this is proof of his(prophets)nubuwwat(prophethood) and a virtue(Fadhl)for those who he brought with him
Where in this quote does lmam Baidhaawi claim that this makes them better than Sahaba and prophets.
Its like saying the prophet's
(صلي الله عليه و سلم )taking Abu Bakr(R.A) with him on migration to Madeenah is a great virtue(fadhl) for Abu Bakr (which it undoubtedly was) but you won't find any Sunni claiming this makes Abu Bakr better than everyone else.
Further on he claims imam is a special position only given to those who are tested by Allah and they pass that test.
Weren't all prophets tested and didn't they all pass that test.
Allah mentions in Surah Anbiyaa
after naming Ibrahim,Lut,Ishaq and Yaqub
عليهم السلام
وجعلناهم اءمّة يهدون بامرنا.
Verse 73 Ambiya
Which shows they were all imams
So whose better
Someone who gets direct Wahi and who Allah says he's made an imam or someone who's name hasn't been mentioned in the Quran
Translation of the verse quoted above
"And we made them imams who guide by our command........"
abdalla. ibn. sabaa
told. shia. that ali. is.
god. in. human . form
when. ali. heared. he burned. them. a llive who. believeded ali. ra. was. a god.
shia. naver. leave
their. old. pagans
believe. bifore. they. use to. . worship. fire. but. now. they. worship. human
and. this. video. is
the. prove. shia. believe. ali. is. more
then. human and...
thy. openly accepting
only. rasool. nabi. ambiyaa. allowed
to. have. wahi. ..
not. sahaaba.
Wow awesome 👍 answers I m fully satisfied
he’s a liar. The prophets Isa ibn Maryam is Superior than Ali and any Imam idk what ur on.
one of the best maulana I've heard mashallah
Some of the comments criticizing the man did not watch the video even fir 30 seconds.
If Ibrahim & Adam were Imams & prophets, that means he's better than Ali because Ali was only an imam. Btw, if theirs a hierarchy in the Quran of Prophethood & Imamate- how can Ali achieve Imamate without prophethood? Because those prophets in Quran were Imams & Prophets. In fact, after being a prophet Allah raised the rank of Ibrahim to Imam, right? So how can Ali be better with lower qualifications? makes no sense
The Prophet said, "Will you not be pleased that you will be to me like Aaron (Harun) to Moses (Musa)? But there will be no prophet after me."
Sahih al BukhariVolume 5, Book 59, Number 700
If Allah had not made Prophet Muhammad (saw) as the final prophet then surely from the above hadith it is evident that Ali(as) was a worthy person to be a prophet after him by God. Since Prophet Muhammad (saw) is the final prophet then why would Allah make Ali(as) as a prophet?
Imma Ali's name was mentioned in tons of hadiths yet you guys choose to remove him from them. Imagine if it was in the holy Quran. What would you guys do then?
Allah says He revealed the Quran and promises to protect it...so ur approach is weak
Imam Ali refutes shia.
The Batman no he doesn’t
@@HassanAli-qk9nq Actually u can't affect Quran
But people who were munafiq could use the same names as were mentioned in Quran.
As many Hadiths were self made.
Maybe That's why Allah in Quran told characteristics not names of Imams..
@@HassanAli-qk9nq he means Enemies of Imam Ali like the Ummayyads may have said anyone else ALi , and may have said that he is the one whom Quran is telling us about
This man is grounded and have no hatred In his face and stress unlike other scholars.
Shias are so misguided one can only make Dua that they turn to Haq and not fabrications.
No imam can ever be more superior than any one single prophet of Allah. There are hadith to back that up. Namely hadith narrated by our Prophet's beautiful companions Shia in fact reject and label Kafir. Nauzobillah. So no surprise there.
No imam has ever received divine intervention, that's just not true. And Hazrat Ali r.a was to come back now he would instantly go to Jihad against the Shia.
May Allah guide the Shia for very baseless beliefs.
Final question: if Shia are truthful why is it that in 14 centuries Allah has not allowed them to lead a single prayer in Haram of Makkah? Has Allah forgotten them? You bet He has!
Because the leaders of Saudi Arabia have nothing to do with islam. They're the ones building temples and opening alcohol shops in mecca. Why did Allah allow that then? Dumbass
No, the Prophets are superior than the Imams and the one talking is an innovator who is not to be taken knowledge from.
The immam is higher then the prophet there is a story in the quran were allah promoted a prophat to a immam the only reason why prophet mohammed (sai) is higher then immam ali is because the prophet also an immam. The prophet is an immam, messanger and a prophet. The prophet name is prophet ebrahim (AS). He was already a prophet but like i said allah promopted him to a immam. So if prophet out ranks immam why did he get the promotion to immam.
@@shiaofimmamali7028 So if Ibrahim is an Imam and a prophet then how come he is not superior to Ali?
@@mohamadkhateeb402 Because Imam Ali is the succesor of Imam ul mursaleen, The prophet saw who is superior of all prophets, it's the family of Prophet Muhammad saw
@@mohamadkhateeb402 there are countless ahadith in sunni books that imam mahdi will lead the prayer and prophet Jesus as will pray behind him since when a superior prays behind someone inferior to him ?
Does that make sense to you ?
No disrespect but I come from a sunni hanafi background myself and using our brains is a taboo we were raised and programmed to accept stupidty
Evidence??
How in the world does it turn out that the nafs of the Prophet is 'Ali, where does it say this in the Quran and how on earth can this be inferred?
Kamadev888 it is because the Holy Prophet (SAW) went to mubahila with the him. When he was told in the Quran take your sons he took Imam Hassan (AS) and Imam Hussain(AS) and he was told to take his women he took Bibi Fatima(AS) and when he was told to gather himself or his nafs he took Imam Ali (AS). All sects agree that these five went to the mubahila.
When Rasul s.a.w went for hijrah that night Allah swt asked Rasool s.a.w to let some one sleep in his s.a.w place but the one who sleeps in his s.a.ws place must be same as Rasool s.a.w
@@mustafahaidery2809 Abu Bakr used to lead prayer when the prophet did not.
@@KindBatman and when did such thing happen?? On the day of Rasool s.a.w demise he s.a.w pulled abu bakr from qibla and lead the prayer and Rasool s.a.w has already said Ali a.s. is your mola after me than how one can call himself above Ali a.s. Ali a.s. is Ala in every thing he possesed the knowledge of Rasool s.a.w he was the husband of Fatima a.s. leader of all ladies in paradise and father of hassan a.s. and hussain a.s. who are leaders of youth and Ali a.s. is the one who prayed with Rasool s.a.w when he s.a.w used to pray alone before he was gifted with prophethood doesnt matter how much you people deny but deep down you all know that Ali a.s. is haq but your ignorance dont let u accept it
@@mustafahaidery2809
You're very funny
I see a Lion right here god bless him whats his name he talks like a eagle and thinking like a rhino the sunni guy off topic as usual normality of hyprocites in islam disrespecting the knoledge of imams.
Zoarostatism is still in shites. Imam is never even said by allah's rasool to any of their iman. They have just said it by themselves
what is wrong with those Shia’s and rafidiya sects? They are really not good in there heads. do they really not see that they are on the wrong road? They elevate Ali ra as much as the Christians do to Isa as! Forget about that political nonsense and worship Allah swt and follow the prophet saw! This is the most important! Stop shirk Oh people and ask Allah swt protection against the fire!
Who on earth told you that we worship Ali like christians😂 that's such a stupid assumptions😂
The reason why humans need imams is the exact reason why angels and shaytan were ordered to prostrate to Adam. To destroy their ego and gain total obedience.
Shaytan couldn't bow to Adam because his 6000 years of praying only had grew his ego, as he thought he has a special connection with Allah. Now that Allah tell him to bow to someone else, his ego doesn't let him. ابا واستکبر
We humans if we don't have imams that we have to follow, our orayers to Allah will be like shaytan prayers. Only growing our ego
Wow very nice and solid answers..... thats what i like.....
Why you dont put complete ending......
please put
Aslam o alykum my brother’s first a fall we have to know this that in Islam there is no Shia and Suni we are Muslim and Muslim is the one who follow quran and Hadith of the prophet Muhammad saw and it’s mention in Quran so many place that follow quran and teaching of the prophet Muhammad saw may peace and blessing of Allah be upon all of them so don’t make Islam so hard for the people to benefit the enemy’s of Islam don’t make your religion in to pecs and this is the beauty of Islam one book one Islam one religion not Shia not Suni and request u all brothers open the Quran and read by your own first and find where it does said to be Shia or Suni no where so follow this word ... follow Quran and teaching of the prophets that is it as the all imams said if any fatwa of Mine goes against teaching of Allah and his rasoul Throw that fatwa on the wal so think about this and don’t waste your time with something which Quran and Hadith of the prophet saw never said about if u do so u will burdens your self and make tired of your self May Allah guide all those who called them self Shia and Suni
he has to lie against Umar and say Umar said "We don't want your progeny"... Why do Shia have to try to make the whole world to be the worst of creatures only to prove Ali was suppose to be imam....wow
Who's the imam of this time? According to shia.
Imam Mehdi just like for Sunnis.
@@Bxseer sunni believe mahdi will come at the end. Isn't ruling at the moment.
In shia, is almahdi the current imam who's ruling?
@@huntsman2877 it's written in Shia'a books and also they prove it from Quran and Gives us logical proofs about it
@@paktechniques2012 go for it. Prove it for us the imam number 6 or 7 from the quran.
@@Ali-fo4uv OK. Who's you're imam.
Let's test your understanding of the Ayah.
Salam alaikum,
how can with all my respect 'Ali or the other Imams be "better" than the Prophets before Mohammed (saws)? Alone Jesus (a s) and the way he is born and his coming at the end of the time. If the Imams who are according to the Shi'a superior and are here to protect the message, how it is that the majority of the Muslims not Shi'a? It would mean that only 10 or 15% from the last revealed message and religion are saved? This would mean that the last religion failed.
how many humans in the world according to your study ? Allah ? 1 right ? if i may, majority always win ? realy ?
Don't count the Numbers
Imams have shown so many miracles by the help of Allah, and Last Imam and succesor of Holy Prophet (pbuh) would also come in this world just like Jesus by the Permission of Allah
Some shias believe all prophets were imams and therefore dont make the distinction
@@kataangsucks But all the Imams were not Prophet. If the 12Shia would have right then why all these différents groups like the Zaydid, Ismailis and many others who didn't exist anymore now; if the 12 Shia would have right, the Prophet (saws) would have transmit this doctrine since the very beginning and this would be clear in the Quran. And as it is the last revealed religion, you think that only a little group is on the right way?. Don't misunderstand me please, I don't support Moawiya and his son and believe Ali and his family are with truth.
Shia's 12th Infallible Imam is hiding in the cave for the last 1300 years, who is supposed to guide the Shias 😂😂😂
I am Shia and don't believe this!
This is absurd,it is because of these beliefs Shias get accused of extreme veneration of these Imams,the Imams never claimed these things,it is we that bestow these qualities on them,if we study their lives,they never claimed any of these qualities,they never considered themselves infallible either,these are just man's own beliefs that the Imams should possess these qualities,they themselves never proffessed that,however with a Prophet he actually declares his Prophethood,this belief in Imam getting divine knowledge directly from Allah(swt) is your own belief.
The Imams followed the Sunnah of the Prophet (Sawas),they added nothing to it and took away nothing from it.
he does not know what he is talking about he keep mentioning sourat from the quran witch is not saying what he is ....he keeps laying and you call your self an imam !!!!
Is that a Michelin or Pirelli car tyre on his head??
Brother stop making fun of islamic scholars....If you dont believe their beliefs then leave upto them...who are you to tell that they are wrong and abusing that he is wearing tires btw it is amamah you idiot....Allah will Judge Them....
@@mirzaali7968 He is not an Islamic scholar. He is a rafidi scholar.
Michelin all the way.
@@KindBatman From the words of Imam Ja’far ibn Muhammad Al-Sadiq (as), one of the most honorific titles a Shia can receive is the title Rafidha, the one who rejects the legitimacy of the caliphate of the first three and condemns the caliphs that came after Hassan ibn Ali (as).
Least it ain’t a towel or a table cloth
I just cant wait untill judgement day, then we will know that Shi'te are not MUSLIMS
Tuqiyyah... Lying is part of the shi'a religion.
Terrorism is a part of Sunni religion
Ali ra is great bt not greater than prophets u cannot compare him to adam as thry were rasool and moula both n prophet also is rasool and moula bt how come he is not greater than prophet Muhammad sws bt greater than all prophets just extra exaggeration !
12 imams. . run shia. head. all. the..
time. they. even. believe. ali. fatima. is. apart. of. god.
christian. believe..
jesus. is . apart. of
god. all. disbelievres
have. same. logic
god. save. us from
their. shirki. kufri
ali. ra. he. is. not
greater . then. great. sahaaba. but. he. was. 1of. them. he. was. good follower. of. Prophets. saw. teaching. like. other great sahaaba. . do.
for. me. ali. is. simple great. sahabi. and. i♡ khulafaau raashideen
they. r. ahlul . jannah
i love. all. of. them ♡
♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡
@@fardowdo30yaayamaxammed6 true it's just that these people do to much of extra exaggeration that it becomes problematic for him
@@fardowdo30yaayamaxammed6 Imam Ali is the greatest Man after the holy prophet(s).....No one ever had the nearest position to rasoolallah..He is One of the Member of ahlulbayt..and the first Imam of the 12 imams...he is the gate to madinatul ilm....it goes on forever like these if we want to talk about his accolades...So Don't compare Lion of Allah with Khulafa Rashideen..it is like comparing Gold with aluminium
Can someone please provide reference to the incident maulana quoted where Abu Bakr/ Omer refuted progeny and considered Quran to be sufficient. Where after, they came to Hazrat Ali when they failed to answer the jaws questions.
ua-cam.com/video/J0K0gwabRiw/v-deo.html
No need for thanks ❤️
It's written in Sunni Books, open them and see, you will find Thousands of similar incidents, and also fake fabricated Narrations praising Omar ibne Khattab
I ask the same answer too, but the answers unreadable ( there are two answers) but ... Not appearing.
Go and read ur hadith books you will know😊
How is it that our Sunni brothers know the tafsir of the holy Quran when it was sent down on prophet Muhammad. Meaning he is a prophet. The Quran is the word of Allah. If all that is true and you believe it then how does the word of Allah come down to the prophet and us normal people understand so easily?
Because Allah azza wa jalla is the most judge, and he made the deen simple for everyone to understand. So that on the day of judgement no one has an excuse why he did not follow the prophet mohammed sallalahu aleyhi wa sallam. Whats the point of sending down the message that is hard to understand for the people?
There are enough verses that indicated that muhammed is the final prophet. Even a whole chapter named Surah Muhammed. And still you guys follow Ali radiya Allahu 3anhu. Soo deluded may Allah guide you or break your back
@@promocro1 lol you do know that after the prophet you follow abu bakr and umar. Right? Lmao. We follow ali bc no one followed the prophet to the dot like ali did. He was raised and taught by the prophet. And in the Quran it says clearly. That I am a Warner and to every nation there’s a guide. Go look up who the guide is than talk to me.
Don’t speak out of ignorance. You say we follow ali like it’s only him we follow. Which is all false. We follow what Allah tells us, the prophet and ahlulbyat.
@@mmsaf17 and where in the quran says that you must follow ahlul bait specifically? And why dont you shia then dont follow abu bakr and umar radiya Allah 3anhuma?
@@promocro1 plenty verses mention ahlulbyat. I don’t ask anything of you except love for my near kin. Near kin isn’t anyone.
Allah says in Surah 5:55. I am ur wali and so is the prophet and those who give charity while in prostration. That verse is about imam ali. Altabri says that in his book. It just so happens that ali is part of his ahlulbyat as well. Imam ali was appointed by the prophet on many occasions.
Now show me where in the Quran does it specifically say we need to follow abu bakr and umar
Hazrat Ali R.A was just a man. He did not receive revelation. Stop creating lies about the companions of the Rasool Allah. You lack reason. They were great *men* and the best of the generations. But thats about it, you cannot compare the two. Chosen by Allah and Chosen by Rasool Allah.
Hazrat Ali RA was not a man only. He was Waliullah . There is no doubt that the companions of the Holy Prophet SAW are great man but Hazrat Ali RA was the first imam. Maulla Ali RA was the greatest man after the Holy Prophet SAW. He was the city of knowledge and he was spiritually blessed. It's your common sense, a Prophets friends are greater or their family. Be sensible and only review the concept of shiaism with cencerity and patience.
What the hell....Hazrat Ali better than all the prophets?
Nauzbillah...
This is Kufr The Shia theology is Kufr
cry cry cry and cry
You are actually....
@@sheedicd4350 no The Shia rafidah are Kuffar
@@mxhsvn_b7866 you're gonna cry in jahannam
This guy is wrongly presenting verse of Mubahila
Another proof that shia is different from islam
@Abbas Ali Lol. Those are fabricated Ahadiths. No one is impressed by your fake stuff.
This is rafidha, they're more radical in there views
A cursory glance: Shias have conflated imam with prophet, which is dangerous. They’ve also surrounded the term with superstition and non facts. Imagine believing that anyone surpassed gods chosen prophets who receive direction from Allah SWT through Gabriel. Do imams only appear after prophet Muhammad SAW? Who was the “imam” between Jesus AS and prophet Muhammad SAW? Allahu Akbar
I have a question can any one be a resul without bein a nebiy
Prophet Muhammad is the final prophet of Allah.
And the greatest
hujat al islam? pakistani syed?? what a complete joke. he supposedly comes from the lineage of the prophet saw, and cant recite quran properly. fear your creator.
Height of fabricated stories.
May Allah guide these people.
Wahhabi brother?! I don't think who u call wahabies actually call themselves wahabies.
Prophet Ibrahim is also Imam,
Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) is also Imam,
and Allah (swt) blessed them Imamat after Risalat (prophethood), so Imamat is Superior.
And Imam Ali is the Imam , he (as) is the succesor of Imam ul mursaleen (Prophet Muhammad who is superior to all prophets).
Allah (swt) has described Virtues of Imam Ali in Quran and about thousands of verses are revealed about Imam Ali (as)
Imamat is Superior to prophethood is proved by logical evidences as well as from Qura'an and Shia'a Books. That's for sure.
You have to be very Intelligent if you wanna be a true Muslim or true believer or Momin ❤️
Lol
when Imam Ali dies, who replaced him as imam..?
Didn'nt you say Ali a.s is the nefs of the prophet s.a.w, how can the prophet s.a.w then say he the city of knowledge and Ali a.s is the gate (by the way I appreciate a sahih reference for that). Shouldn't he have said I'm the city of knowledge and Ali is too???
This man is a fool
Imamat Allah ki taraf se hai, imamat risalat se arzal hai, imam Allah ka representative hota hai, imamat aur risalat aik hee tara ki cheez hen, Muhammad Rasool Allah as k 12 jaan nasheen hen, 11 ko yeh umat katal ker chukki hai barwen ka daur jari hai,........in bara k lie mujje Huzoor as ki wo hadees yad a rehi hai k " meri umat k Ulma bani israeel k anbia se afzal hen"......yeh umat ulti ho jai tab b is hadees ko na chupa sakti hai na badla sakti hai
Rasoolullah(saww) khudd bhi Imam the aur Hazrat Ibrahim(a) bhi Imam the...Hazrat Ibrahim(a) ko Nabuwat aur Risalat milne ke baad Imamat mili thi...lehaza Imamat afzal hai👍
Muslims imam in the day of judgment is our prophet Muhammad puh
I’m a born shia and I refute this man’s claims
And on what basis??
@@mustafahaidery2809 It is kufr
@@KindBatman 🤡
You were born a Shia and reject the superiority of Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib (as), after Rasoolullah SAWW? Being born a Shia and being a Shia are two different things.
Weakest of the arguments just super exaggerated interpretations of verses playing with words.
These people are worst
But Why
Masha’allah aap na bahut acha answer diya hamre ilm me or ezafa hua hai allah aap ko salamat rakhe
Where did Omar r.a say we don't need your progeny? Please offer sahih evidence for that. Also, sahihi evidence would be nice for the conversation between Ali and Abubeker redyellah anhuma, Ali a.s. saying didn't you say the quran is sufficient for us. Also what part of the quran didn't the Caliphs know that they had to ask Ali a.s about it. I'm not saying Ali a.s. is not knowledgeable; to the contrary, he is extremely knowledgeable. But it seems very strange that the prophet s.a.w teaches the sahaba for 23 about Islam and Quran which is meant for the entire world, but only one person understands it and this is because he belonged to the prophets household.Are you sayin Fatimatu zahrah a.s. didnot know nor accept Abubeker as the leader? Why did she address him as caliphetu resul when she asked for her inheritance of Fadek???
Simply Stupid, changing Quranic message
where does it say Imam. oh Mushrik
وَكَمۡ اَهۡلَكۡنَا مِنَ الۡقُرُوۡنِ مِنۡۢ بَعۡدِ نُوۡحٍؕ وَكَفٰى بِرَبِّكَ بِذُنُوۡبِ عِبَادِهٖ خَبِيۡرًۢا بَصِيۡرًا
(17:17) Many a generation has been destroyed by Our command since Noah's time. Your Lord is well aware and fully observant of the sins of His servants.
Shias such a liers...the verse is all about the prophets being imams...it has nothing to do with the imams or khalifas after the prophet...so every nation will be brought forward with their imam(prophet)..if your claim is true....who is the imam of the people after nabii issa before the coming of our propher mohammad???who was the imam of the nation after the death of nabii musa???shias always interprate ayas upside down....
According to SHIT ,OOPS I MEAN SHI'TE, that reza can heal anyone who calls on him but how ironic that reza couldn't heal himself by growing arms, ha ha ha,
Khoorofart thats khoorofart TAQQIYA is is 9/10 off Shi'te sect,
Ali head is lost, and the Shi'te sect are looking for it and ali you would think that ali maddad can find it, till today Shi'te cant find ali head.
🤡
اعوذ بالله من الشیطان الرجیم.
Mr you are changing the verse of The { Noble Qur'an } to suit your own false interpretation. This is real verse, Sura Al Imran - 3 - aya - 67 -
In Urdu.
مَا كَانَ إِبْرَاهِيمُ يَهُودِيًّا وَلَا نَصْرَانِيًّا وَلَكِنْ كَانَ حَنِيفًا مُسْلِمًا وَمَا كَانَ مِنَ الْمُشْرِكِينَ.
ابراہیمؑ نہ یہودی تھا نہ عیسائی، بلکہ وہ ایک مسلم یکسو تھا اور وہ ہرگز مشرکوں میں سے نہ تھا.
( سورة آل عمران - 3 - 67 )
In Farsi ( Persian )
مَا كَانَ إِبْرَاهِيمُ يَهُودِيًّا وَلَا نَصْرَانِيًّا وَلَكِنْ كَانَ حَنِيفًا مُسْلِمًا وَمَا كَانَ مِنَ الْمُشْرِكِينَ.
ابراهیم نه یهودی بود و نه نصرانی، بلکه یکتاپرست و حق گرایی تسلیم بود، و از مشرکان نبود..
( سورة آل عمران - 3 - 67 )
In English.
مَا كَانَ إِبْرَاهِيمُ يَهُودِيًّا وَلَا نَصْرَانِيًّا وَلَكِنْ كَانَ حَنِيفًا مُسْلِمًا وَمَا كَانَ مِنَ الْمُشْرِكِينَ.
Abraham was neither a Jew nor a Christian, but he was one inclining toward truth, a Muslim [submitting to Allah]. And he was not of the polytheists.
Al Quran. ( سورة آل عمران - 3 - 67 )
May Almighty Allah guide you people to to the right teaching of , ISLAM ,
خان.
This guy has no knowledge about what Quran says, he is just a copy and paste guy
Laminate
He has falsely interpreted the Qur'anic verse. He is a liar.
Att ..not him but the progeny itself told in their hadis...
🌞LA ilaha Ill YHWH ❤️
Shia makes me Cry 😢
Why
@@mohammedmoe1347 because this is kufr
@@KindBatman hey hey you dropped this 🤡
Hazrat Ali RA was one of the greatest Muslims to ever have lived and will be promised Jannah, but he is not an Imam, nor does he have some special knowledge of the Quran.
Prophet Said : Ali Is with Quran and Quran is with Ali
Many other Ahadiths and narrations tells us that Quran And Ahlebait (as) cannot be divided. These are special , and no one could compare himself with Ahlebait.
Ahlebait is the pure and special family of Last Prophet who is Imam ul Mursaleen (Superior to all prophets)
Don't tell your Jewish views about Prophet's Successor.
Nasbiyat ki boo aa raha hai
@@paktechniques2012 prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam also said many things about hazrat Umar r.a and hazrat Abu baqr siddique r.a. why you only believe in that saying which is according to your school of thought?
Ye batao waman indahu ilmul kitab kiske liye kaha gaya h
@@tufailkhan1205 but not more than Imam Ali a.s 😌
What a liar