And unlike other Fandoms where this is true (Undertale AU multiverse, SCP, Backrooms, etc), its not even because it's community made! It's just because the official Canon is secret and none of us fully understand it. Which somehow makes this comparison funnier, at least to me.
Thomas Astruc would rather disintegrate than let anyone outshine Marinette from being the Mary Sue she is (aka Catnoir having no plot relevance despite being advertised as the secondary protagonist)
What I like the most about Don't Starve's lore is that any inaccuracy (like gold tools being more durable than rock tools) can be explained with “Maxwell doesn't know shit about science”
honestly, the biggest thing I've learned being the DC fandom is to just pick what you like out of canon and throw aside what you don't, then bullshit your way to victory.
@@VNightmoon maybe not ALL of it. there were some nice things that came from the New 52; i personally just ignore MOST of it. plus with the Omniverse and Infinite Frontier it's all irrelevant anyway lol.
You really can’t expect Warrior cats to be realistic. It just was never the goal, the writers themselves said they wanted to write more about little furry humans more than actual real cats. The whole concept of warrior cats is unrealistic, really.
I knew that it was unrealistic the moment they mentioned cats building dens out of bracken and sticks like this wasn’t extremely advanced behavior for animals to literally build homes (idk if cats ACTUALLY do this but it seems unlikely.) And Rusty having dreams about cat heaven.
@@Midnightlunar10 yeah cats definitely don’t build houses. Everything down to the ere concept of the clans itself is unrealistic. They have a leader, a second in command, a doctor-priest, a whole religion, and more.
Riordan at least tried to explain that Thalia's tree form kept her from aging normally. But .... Yeah. Getting actual calendar dates to map out the timeline would be nice
Yeah, that single thing makes sense. If someone turns into a tree, the type of tree matters to me though because that’s going to affect their aging. They age at tree speed (which might be faster as well as slower than human speed, depending on the tree)
Rick Riordan did that because he wanted Percy to be the demigod who fulfills the great prophecy. The prophecy says that Olympus shall fall to a child of the big three once they turn 16. If she ages normally, Thalia would already be 19 and would have fulfilled the prophecy, that's why the author intentionally made her age slower
@@othamneil8958Honestly, he could’ve just let her be 19. The prophecy doesn’t specify that it will be the next child of the Big 3 that will fulfill the prophecy, just “a”.
@@othamneil8958 He could’ve literally solved all his problems by making Thalia 13 when she died, then over the 5 years she was dead, she could’ve aged in “tree years” (10 human years in 1 “tree year”) making her 13.5-14 (depending on how long she’d been 13), that way the timeline would’ve made sense *and* she’d still be older than Percy.
The Sonic age one is so real. Silver and Sonic are the closest to acting like silly teens, and it's just because Silver is naive and anxious and Sonic doesn't shut up- and neither of those have anything to do with their age, just their situations. Cream is the only one with a believable age tbh. Tails feels like he could be 10, and Charmy seems like he's 9.
Agreed. Especially w Charmy. Like as a six year old, he just doesn’t make much sense. Where did he come from? How long has he been a Chaotix? Why does almost no one act their age???
@@cinders-xs2zn Exactly! If he joined the Chaotix when he *was* six, that makes more sense, but it seems less like a found family if he's been around the whole time. And you really want to tell me Vector is 20? Please, he acts like hes 17.
Sonic ages are all kinda fucked up. Sonic is 15 Amy is 12 Tails is 8 Knuckles is 16 Rouge is 18 Cream is 6 Shadow is simultaneously 50 and 5 due to his time in stasis Blaze is 15.... Almost all of the main cast except Robotnik and Vanilla are teens or kids, which really says a lot about Mobius as a whole.
In one of the Heroes of Olympus books, Percy states his zodiac sign is a Leo, which is a summer sign. Sally and Poseidon hooked up in the summer. Either Sally was pregnant for one month, one year, or all demigods have weird birth rules, not just Athena kids.
Well, they're children of literal gods, so it would make sense that their rules are weird. There's basically nothing keeping the godly parent or the demigod's to influencing the pregnancy and causing it to be abnormally short or long. Plus the goddesses can do whatever too, I think I remember seeing that Aphrodite in particular has some weird ass rules about her pregnancies and all.
tbh that sounds like the most likely and realistic answer. This is my new headcanon. "Oh my children tend to need longer gestation times because they are so powerful, we will have to split the pregnancy"@@YouveBeenMegged
My favorite example of Ash always being 10 is this; Kukui and Burnet. The two aren't in a relationship at the beginning of the Sun and Moon series but then they begin to date, then Kukui proposed to her on screen, they got married also on screen within the same episode, sometime between the marriage episode and the ultra beast arc, Kukui and Burnet had sex (obviously not on screen because kids show) because towards the end of the Sun and Moon series, Burnet is pregnant. Then later, Ash visits them and they have their son who looks like he's a few months to maybe a year old at this point. Yet Ash is still 10 despite realistically that would have all happened within at least 2-3 years.
I used to be really into HP and I noticed that Ron’s mum creates pasta sauce out of nothing and it just comes out of the tip of her wand in one of the first books. Then in the seventh Ron says “my mum can create food out of nothing” and Hermione is all like “no she can’t that’s against ____s third law.” And that pissed me off.
tbh the 7th book pissed me off so much that I just jumped to watch the part 2 movie. "Oh no, we are wizards and can't figure out how to fish or hunt, its not as if we have a spell that can kill with one hit". If a bunch of kids can survive a plane-crash and then the amazon jungle IRL then three adult wizards can hunt for food.
@@oceanmythjormundgandr3891tbh idk if food that was killed with avada-kedavra would be healthy to eat. Something about it makes me imagine it would be full of evil magic toxins or something. Still no excuse though
Winx Club timeline is a mess. Can't decide whether things happened a couple decades ago or thousands of years before. Also, inconsistent character/relationship development. They'll develop nicely one season then regress within 1-2 seasons (once it was 3-4 seasons later) with no explanation besides "for the drama".
Especially with the whole "Daphne" thing, I'm currently rewatching Winx and I could see why younger me immediately stopped watching a few episodes in after season 6 or 7 (i cant really remember). I think it's just Nick trying hard to keep the show running as much as possible. There are also some things/powers shown in previous seasons that are completely forgotten about. Like Blooms ability to see peoples souls or something
It made me really sad when people said that Musa x Riven was toxic whilst ignoring that he wasn't supposed to be toxic in the first place. He got character development and became a decent guy but it was taken away from him for like no reason
For this reason i consider only the first 3 seasons and the first movie to be canon, the consistency of basically everthing gets really shitty otherwise But i have a pet peeve with domino, like when i first watched it i thought it was death for like 300 years already but acording to canon it's only been 16
Azula’s psychological profile was so complex and well done in the series… the comic completely messed it up 😭😭😭 and it’s disappointing knowing that the comics are 100% canon.
I always try to be positive when reading or watching showd but the ATLA comics are not the best when it comes to characterizations. Just the first chapters made Aang so trigger happy against Zuko... On the other hand, the Kyoshi books are masterpieces in my opinion.
@@ceve Tbf though, Aang being so trigger happy against Zuko was only because of Roku. He was so distrusting of "The Fire Nation forcefully expanding their territory" when they just wanted to unite the people that lived in the Earth Kingdom colonies, which were around for so long that the people who lived there were a mix of both Earth and Fire Nation people. Roku was also extra paranoid of Zuko planning to betray Aang behind his back, projecting that onto him so hard that Aang started to feel paranoid too. After Aang and Zuko have their big confrontation, in which they almost kill each other before they realize that "No duh! My friend doesn't secretly want to kill me!", Aang goes to talk to Roku and basically tells him "Hey, your issues are your own, I won't be taking advice from you anymore. Zuko is my friend, and I almost killed him today because of you. Uniting the nations is a good thing, and we'll keep working to achieve that. Thank you for everything, but I think it's time for you to rest", and that was that. And I honestly really like that that was a plot-point, because re-watching ATLA you can blatantly see that Roku is hot-headed, not great at communicating, stubborn and unilateral in his advice. Which worked great against a tyrannical dictator hellbent on everyone's destruction but his own - it doesn't take much to be right in that situation - but when it comes to complex/delicate political issues he completely drops the ball. I mean, he's not entirely at fault, but let's not forget that his incompetence played a role in what started the 100 year old war, ok? And I mean before the volcano, because the problem should've been solved before he ever got that old, but that's just my opinion. And I always thought that what inspired Zuko and Aang to unite the nations was Iroh. They both learned that nature and bending work in harmony best when they're connected and together: bending techniques, the swamp, the AVATAR itself, etc. It would make sense that they both reached the same conclusion, and I don't disagree, I think the world became better for it. Aang rejecting Roku is not only him rejecting the old for the (slightly less old) new, but coming into his own as the Avatar in a political sense. And it's a great post-canon add-on because of it. Tl;dr - Aang says "Ok, boomer", hits the griddy on Roku, leaves him in the dust and makes up with Zuko. It's actually a really cool plot-point.
@@alfalldoot6715 I mean, if you mean Roku then I'd have to disagree. Bro confronted the Fire Lord once and then fucked off to his island until he grew old, thinking he solved the problem. And Sozin didn't start the war until after Roku died, so he experienced none of it. And Aang is better than me, if I were him I'd be so pissed at Roku for how things turned out. And I could maybe forgive it, but then you try to make me kill one of my best friends too? Because _you're_ a distrustful asshole now? No wonder Aang cut ties immediately, I would've done the same thing. Good for him, honestly.
I'm pretty sure the Ace Attorney world has no such thing as "conflict of interest;" like, seriously, the series starts out with Phoenix defending his childhood friend. Then 50% of the rest of the series is either a friend or relative. And 10% is Maya. Also, the bad guy can do all the shady things they want while on the stand, and you *still* need to present that final, decisive evidence before an arrest can be made.
Honestly, I can see why they only really accepted Phoenix Wright after Apollo Justice the game: at that point, he actually pulled off bizarre amounts of strings to randomly change the justice system to catch one person. This is probably corruption on par with Damon Gant or Manfred Von Karma, who were respected before being dethroned. The Ace Attorney world seems to rewards abuse of the justice system so long as you can get away with it, and the trick in Apollo Justice is what makes people think that Phoenix Wright is masterful enough to do that. Therefore, Phoenix Wright is now able to be manipulative enough to be accepted in law circles and make real change.
Ace Attorney is infamous for having a bizarre & inconsistent tech level, wherein they're still using old-timey security tapes but have advanced AI robots. The police can submit & get results from gel electrophoresis in like 15 minutes. There's 2 AA games that take place in 1896 that feature 2 way-too-advanced inventor characters, which is also itself an inconsistency to be ignored, but I personally like to hc they're why the tech level is so wild in the modern games. Also on the topic of those 2 games: there's a character who is the Chief Justice, but the design team preferred style over accuracy, so he dresses like a slutty priest. It's hilarious and I love it.
Also the fact that Phoenix still has a flip phone in like 2028 but Athena, who works with him, has a literal robot necklace and two almost-sentient robot friends (Clonco and Ponco). And then we have to also consider Apollo's backstory as a big inconsistency because he gets a new past every game lol
For the thing with the sonic characters, I really like how the movies have so far portrayed Sonic as just being a little shit. He saves the world but he's still a dumb and impulsive kid
The movie was pretty much the first time he actually acts his age, so naturally, people in the fandom were bitching about how this version isn't cocky and in control 100% of the time.
If the Clawthorne's curse in The Owl House is sentient, what happened when Eda and Lilith split the curse? Did Lilith ever make piece with it? Also, they handwave away what happens to the government after the Emporer dies. In three years, the Boiling Isles have become a utopia.
The first one we don't know but the Boiling Isles were basically a utopia before Belos showed up as shown in "Elsewhere and Elsewhen" so like it's not that crazy
10:45 PRECISELY Obliviate needing to be an Unforgivable Curse, someone finally agrees with me Toying with memory isn’t anything to be taken lightly, as someone who is writing a story on it. You can’t just do that and receive no consequences. It’s objectively wrong.
The ONE singular exception is "rebooting" someone from something incredibly traumatic (such as the ticket vendor's family in Goblet of Fire, I completely understand the memory of being levitated hundreds of feet in the air being erased.)
I don't like HP because of all the stuff around it, but what if in-universe a person was like "I should write this as an unforgivable curse" and then someone casted it on them so it wasn't put as a curse?
@@headphonesaxolotl Depends how traumatic. How far can we go with that? Should the person have to give permission? Are they in a state to? It’s all very complicated
I read "PRECISELY" in my head like the guy from Ratatoing who's voiced by Mike Pollock whose name I can't remember despite having watched the movie like 3 times
Pokémon lore is often only hinted at and not fully explained, but whenever they do explain stuff you know it's going to be confusing, lead to inaccuracies, and sometimes be completely different depending on which canon you're looking at (and there are a lot of different pokémon canons). Thank you for the world, but we'll take it from here...
*coughs and looks pointedly at the paradox forms of Raikou and Suicune* Yes, hi, hello, Game Freak, did you forget that these legendaries were not around from prehistoric times and came into being relatively recently according to the timeline of both universes? Why did you not make them the future paradox forms and give the Musketeers the past forms? You cannot even use the excuse of the Gen 1-5 worlds being destroyed by the Ultra Beasts since we are in a different timeline altogether since you haven't displayed that the current version of Johto has a different history yet.
@@FizzieWebb That's the main reason I believe the theory that paradox pokémon aren't *actually* from other time periods, they're just believed to be and really are physical forms of what the explorers imagined. I was hoping we would get more fuel for that theory/something similar or have it outright confirmed in the dlc, but no luck.
@@bugtypeeeveeThat's actually canon, there's a secret cutscene if you bring terapagos to the Kitakami lake and they say that Paradox Pokémon came from different timelines. Considering Pokémon has had a multiverse since ORAS, I'd say it checks out.
3:59 I pulled off an interspecies baby in my novel via genetic modification. Rather than being produced sexually, the baby was grown in a lab from a combination of the parents’ genetic materials modified to be compatible with one another. I suppose, biologically, the test-tube baby is an entirely new species.
I will have to point out Homo Sapiens and Homo Neanderthalesis had babies together and they're separate species. IRL there's like 26 different definitions of Species and the interbreeding one is only one of them.
"Authors (creators in general, really) are a group not generally known for their math skills." Yep, that's accurate. I feel like a lot of creative people struggled with math in school. When your mind is in a different world 90% of the time, real life math doesn't make sense.
As a writer myself, I just really cannot be bothered. I already have to pretend to be a sociologist, economist, linguist, geologist, biologist, psychologist, historian and architect on top of being a good writer (plus engineer, chemist and physicist if we're talking scifi), and math is really the last thing I want to worry about. I'm not a big fan of large inaccuracies either and will do my best to do adequate research, but researching for a fantasy or scifi world is such a tedious work, it's easy to miss something at some point, or be lazy with something because the work just doesn't end.
I blame American education. Some parts of math are really fun and feel like puzzles, but nobody's going to see them that way if you have to rote memorize them
@@Saga_Anserum I wouldn't blame the american education specifically because i have never been in the US and still suck at math. But yes, math isn't really taught in a way that helps those who struggle. I could memorize the formulas and maths that had to do with geometry since it reminded me of art and shapes, but everything else? Nope. It felt like a different language. I caught and memorized some things and got a vague idea of the topic but didn't really understand the language.
@@oceanmythjormundgandr3891 I know some other countries also do rote memorisation stuff, I just don't wanna call them out because I haven't experienced them personally. I straight up don't even remember most of my math classes, except when I had a foreign exchange teacher for my precalc class. I'm gonna try to think about the shapes as art things now
@@Saga_AnserumThat's not really a fault of the education system. Some people are going to dislike math no matter what you do and with everything on top of writing the book, inconsistencies like these are easy to miss
1. The moon constantly being full in ATLA. The most popular theory is that Yue is both new to being the moon while also helping the waterbenders, and I think that’s great. 2. The Maw looking different when you play as Six vs when you play as the Runaway Kid in the DLC. I don’t understand how it changes seemingly so fast, but I also don’t care that much.
For two I think that’s primarily because Seven and Six are kind of on different parts of the maw! (It’s a really massive place after all) with the two having only a a little over lap in terms of placement
I see this “cats don’t meow at each other” thing going around the internet, and I must say, I have taken care of MANY cats, and observed them in different environments. They absolutely do. Like, loudly. They stop and stare at each other and meow constantly, either conversationally or aggressively.
Cats meow to communicate with their mothers as babies and if they are raised by humans they keep that behavior and also meow at humans and other cats. But really feral cats without any human contact rarely ever meow. It is basically baby babbling for them. Just like baby stop to babble and start to speak, cats stop to meow and communicate in a different way. But nowadays baby babble is useful for them so they keep it.
As others have said, cats raised by humans keep the meowing. They know we respond to it, so it becomes part of their communications with humans and cats alike. Feral cats, meanwhile, mostly stop meowing when they grow up. Yours meow because you raised them / had contact with them.
@@katherinesmallbean3594 when I say “different environments” I mean it. I’m talking about feral street cats who hiss and run away when a human gets near, cats in human frequented areas, cats in dark alleyways, in the mountains along basically deserted trails. (Because that is a totally normal thing for a normal person to do lol)
The complexity of the family tree is my favorite part lol. But the timeline is indeed a mess, their biggest mistake was giving us any numbers sorrunding the dark one, it's not that hard to crunch out those numbers and realize that the life expectancy of the average Dark One is awfully low for a being that has op dark magic powers and can only be hurt by one specific magical knife
Rumple manages to show up in everyone's story. like the biggest things that happened prior to the present day he's either directly or indirectly played a part in. ok "the power of the dark one" might cover some of that but the timing of where and when he shows up i'm guessing is on the list of things that complicate the timeline for those that try to fully examine it. Also the writing prioritising certain characters over others (snow white and charming kept being focused on meaning they had to come up with dumb plot reasons to have them around) really hurt the show more and more with each new season
Whenever I write Pokemon fanfics and I have to deal with people's houses I always have to add extra rooms. There's no way Arven grew up in a lighthouse with no restroom! There's no storage space in that building either! So I added a back hallway where the entryway is obscured by one of the heavy bookshelves. Also there's a multiverse and people KNOW there's a multiverse and nobody ever brings it up?
I literrally did the exact same thing for my Pokemon fanfic. Even if this was about a fangame, the rooms still felt off. Poor kid didn't even ad a room !!!
Pokemon towns are incredibly tiny too, like plenty of them have less than 10 buildings. So at least the lack of rooms is consistent logic in-universe lol
3:54 Okay, some of this is fair, some of this isn't. She canonically aged more slowly as a tree, this is directly brought up and the third book took place the winter following the second, not a whole year later.
Yes! Also, they didn't mention the main thing I noticed in the books --- Nico's age does not line up with other characters/timeline. In the titans curse, he is 10 and Percy is 14. In the trials of Apollo, he is ~15 and Percy is 17. So he aged 5 years in 3.
@@rachel6239Hum, another reason to highly suspect the Trials of Apollo saga was written by a ghost writer because of how bad it is. If i could uncanonize that shit, i would.
In almost any otome manwha the “that’s not how corsets work” or “that’s not how fashion works” or “why is everyone with their hair down in a setting akin to the Victorian Period?!” are frequent
In HP I think it would’ve been more hilarious if Mr. Weasley asked Harry something about muggles no 12 year old boy would know. Mr. Weasley assumes that just because Harry grew up Muggle, that he’d know about every aspect of Muggles. Something that’s so far out of the realm of knowledge for a kid to know kind of stuff.
Easy example: how a tube television works. CRTs would still be very much the norm at the time the books take place, right? Though on the subject of the year given for the Potters' death in Book 7, do I remember correctly that it makes a) Bonfire Night the same week as Halloween that year, in contradiction to the broadcast in Book 1, and b) make Dudley's PlayStation an anachronism? It's been awhile since I read the series.
As a warrior cats fan and fnaf fan and Harry potter fan and- let’s just say we would be here all day if I were to say any wrong logic with my fandom that I have to ignore lol
Yeah, like the FNAF timeline. How does it make sense realistically that William Afton's arms are that far apart from his torso?? And how does the flesh wrap around springlocks even if they are *in the middle of a limb* how did it get there? And how does the suit arms of Endo 1 stay on without falling off? Does it float??? And William did NOT die during 1993. That is when FNAF 1 took place. He most likely died in 1994-1998 MAYBE 1999. And why does FNAF 3 take place in 2024-2028 have a NEWSPAPER at the end??? EVERYTHING IS VIRTUAL!! And the handprints on Freddy Fazbear are BOTH RIGHT HANDS!!
im a splatoon fan. there arent too many gripes i have, but here they are. splatfests take place over how much time in canon? a night? three nights? how much water does it take for an inkfish to die? can rain kill them? what about a shower? what happened to the octarians who heard the inkantation who werent octolings? where did they go?
I just wonder about how ink warfare works. Does it contain some sort of acid/enzyme that only targets those with a different color? We know it can harm vertebrate life like Grizz and Salmonids. Does the ink also corrode stage materials like wood or concrete? Did people actually die in the great turf war? Now we have spawners but perhaps military-grade weapons would destroy the souls of inklings and octolings, or maybe spawners weren’t invented. How does a killer wail or pearl’s voice relate to ink? How would actual kinetic weaponry like bullets or just a hammer affect an inkling? What do the adults do? Are turf war/ranked viable career paths? We know they pay money, so maybe there’s professional college and adult turf leagues like with human sports, but we only play as young inklings who have the time to play simply for fun and thus don’t see those.
Uggh the water think has always bothered me in splatoon. Like what do these guys drink? Why is water the only liquid that seems to affect them? Also how it seems they literally created resurrection devices??? Like it's heavily implied the little ghost that comes out when your character dies IT'S YOUR ACTUAL SOUL and that you straight up die without the spawn. So you're supposed to tell me these kids straight up DIE in every turf war but just come back like nothing??? LIKE HELLO???
Honestly, I just chuck the water thing as more of a "they're terrible swimmers as a species" and that they don't actually implode when they come in contact with water, since they'd all get wiped out the moment it starts raining. I consider the water explosion more of a gameplay thing (when you fall out of bounds and into water, instantly dying and respawning is much more convenient for game flow than your character waiting to be picked up by some rescue boat or something)
In the Gen 6 Pokémon games, Mega Evolution is established to be this awesome thing that can only be achieved through a trainer’s strong bond with their Pokémon. However, from a gameplay standpoint, you don’t need a strong bond with your Pokémon to Mega Evolve them; you just need the appropriate Mega Stone for their species. This is particularly egregious, since your Pokémon’s friendship and affection toward you is an actual game mechanic. To make things even more confusing, Gen 7 came along and added dex entries describing Mega Evolution as painful and miserable for Pokémon to go through. Obviously, the out-of-universe explanation for this is that the developers wanted to push Mega Evolution into the background to make room for their new mechanic, Z-Moves, but I’ve come up with a theory that makes the Mega Evolution lore make sense in-universe. I think Mega Evolution is just as wonderful as stated in Gen 6, but only if there is a truly strong bond between Pokémon and trainer. If a trainer forces Mega Evolution without that bond, it’s just as miserable and painful for the Pokémon as described in the Gen 7 dex entries.
I always theorised the gen 7 dex entries were to make players mortified so they could quietly take mega evolutions out, because they players wouldn't be as upset if it was a thing that potentially hurt the Pokémon. (though this is just a guess so take it was the biggest grain of salt you can muster)
@Cinnamonraisin_Bagel Yeah, that’s what I think too. They wanted to get Mega Evolution out of the way to make room for Z-moves, then Dynamax, and now Terastallization. I just felt like coming up with an explanation that would make sense in the world of the games too. “Because the author wanted to write them out,” wouldn’t be an accepted explanation for a real-world phenomenon, and I wanted something that the characters could make sense of as well.
For the gen 7 painful megas thing, while it wasn't truly explained, i like to imagine it's because z moves don't require any sort of bond between the trainer and pokemon, and as such alolan people comparing the two stone based gimmicks just force mega evolution not knowing about the bond thing, hurting the pokemon. However that would make the "can only be achieved through a trainer and pokemons relationship" part bullshit so idk anymore
Honestly, the big thing I have to ignore when writing for the Simpsons fandom is the inaccurate way that the Springfield Nuclear Power Plant is portrayed. Nuclear power plants are actually one of the cleanest energy sources we have, and the "smoke" that comes out of them is actually water vapor. Your average nuclear power plant would not produce enough waste to mutate the fish in the rivers. And yet in the show, it's continuously portrayed as a massive source of pollution, on the verge of meltdown, and having casks of nuclear waste just out in the open where anyone can handle them. It's an artifact of the post-Chernobyl nuclear power paranoia that, as nuclear power becomes more and more necessary due to the realities of climate change, I think we should leave in the 1990s. I primarily write Mr. Burns x Smithers fanfics, so I have to write about the SNPP often- and when I write about it, I try to portray it in a more realistic and neutral light than the overwhelmingly negative way that it's portrayed on the show.
To be fair, while I trust nuclear power, I wouldn't trust the Springfield plant one bit. We've seen how terribly it's run, and when they tried to bring in advisors who actually knew what they were doing (that German crew for instance) they basically quit in disgust.
They actually lampshade that in one of the episodes of the newer seasons. Basically Mister Burns points out that nuclear power plants are actually environmentally friendly and that the new rich character (Smiters boyfriend), despite being nicer, is WAY more evil than him because he works in fast fashion.
The sorting into school houses in Harry Potter is not only depicted in the books themselves as being a tradition that not everyone is 100% pleased with, but is in fact based on a real life aspect of British-influenced education systems, particularly in boarding schools where the need for something to substitute for family has (at least historically) been significant. But yeah, the wizards' ignorance of "Muggle" behavior was definitely written in for the comedic opportunities rather than any actual logic of how life as we know it would seem to an outsider community, despite all the other opportunities for legit satire J.K. Rowling did go for. Like, the people in the community where the first self-defense they learn is "the disARMing charm," which is "expeliARMis" can't understand where the "arm" in "firearms" comes from?
I believe Professor McGonagall is the one who doesn't like it and wishes that they wouldn't sort the kids so young. Throughout the movies, you can see kids who have traits more fitting for different houses than the one they replaced it. Percy Weasley is when the great examples of this because a lot of people said he should’ve been in Slytherin, especially in the later movies where he basically just up in abandoned family because he his family was holding him back.
@@madisonyomans9004 Well, it's actually Dumbledore who says "Sometimes I think we sort too young" (in a pensieve memory in Book 7) but yes, good points.
in The Vampire Diaries, the first episode, Damon has a bunch of cool powers including possessing? a crow, and summoning fog, which is promptly never mentioned again after he uses it for a creepy entrance. (Guess who has a fic where Damon only shows up as a crow for like the first 7 chapters...)
Never even watched The Vampire Diaries but I'm now more interessted than I would have ever thought lol Dude that's such a cool concept, I aspire to make connections like that!!
the timeline for Lego Ninjago is an absolute disaster. It's never clearly told what goes where chronologically, and the ages of both Wu and Garmadon are heavily in debate as being hundreds or thousands of years old because we don't know when the serpentine war happened.
I was looking for someone to say Ninjago!! Stuck with the show since its earliest days, but mannnnnnn they had more plot holes than sound storyline sometimes. It's gotten a lot better with the new team and soft reboots lately, but even now they're still struggling to clean up the timeline and canon mess created by the early seasons.
How old are the ninja at any given time? We just don't know! How much time passes during or between seasons? And this one's just a minor one that bugs me, but why the hell does Jay have a different accent to Ed and Edna? Accents aren't genetic! They come from the environment around you! Jay should have a Midwestern accent
@miraculousmoonsanddragons yep! Confirmed vaguely to be teenagers at several points, but where in their teens? Who knows! Also new nightmares unfold any time the show does try to say exactly how many years passed between events, because then you end up with things like "Ninjago advanced from medieval vibes to sentient computer programs....in 10 years," or "welp, 40 years have passed. Wu, you're like 100 years older now. Misako, Krux, you aged 40 years, good job. Ray, Maya, you haven't aged AT ALL. Cool guys, strong work."
YES, having watched up till Master of the mountain, ninjago is quite lierally superemely inconssitent! They always say "before time had a name", but what does that even mean!??! It began innocently enough with kai somefucking how considering the serpentine a myth despite his parents having fought them, but it got worse and worse! We got more and more lore, and we learned that garmadon was what, middle aged, at the time when the serpentine war happened. So did they go from ninjago being a brand-new continent to it being a technologically advanced civilization in sixty years? Maybe a hundred? And don't get me started on all the different lore they added later on, the realms and time travel and the omi!?!I love the series but worldbuilding isn't it's strong suit
My context for the story is entirely based on old memes and the movie game (I picked it up during a free weekend years ago and played through it a month or two ago.) The amount of times I unlocked someone and went "I have no idea who this is" or made fun of characters' actions was... immense.
Man, Ash Lynx is one of the most unlucky and depressing characters I have seen in my life... I guess it isn't inaccurate, I am sure there are people with lives as horrible as Ash.
one thing that makes me cry is the fact that, I watched Banana Fish when I was 16, I'm about to turn 21, I'm older than Ash, and the fact that there are people that want to do nasty things with Ash, who is still a god damn minor (or 18, but is still so young)
This is just a minor thing, but in Regular Show, it's shown that Rigby is allergic to eggs because of the coma he goes into during the eggcellent challenge in season one. Then in season six (I think?) he's shown drinking raw eggs out of a blender as he trains for the pull-up episode. Honestly it just made me headcanon that Rigby faked going into a coma because he knew that Mordocai would win the hat for him, because as messed up as that is.. it's 100% something season one Rigby would do.
To be fair, that is definitely something Rigby would do to get the hat during that time. However, the doctors would have called him out on it about not been allergic to eggs unless he paid the doctors or something. Instead of him being allergic to eggs, you could have said he fell into a coma due to some food or something. it would tie better with the end of the episode where he sees another food related challenge. and everybody in the room was basically like if we take the hat off of him, would we go back into a coma?w but I do like your head canon get props to Rigby for faking being in a coma for that long.
My favorite series ever is a Call of Cthulhu campaign run by my beloved, niche, D&D podcast, Just Roll With It. Set in 1984, the three main characters were childhood best friends who lost contact with each other after they graduated in 1969, but met again nearly two decades later because they never finished the D&D campaign that they used to play in high school. D&D wasn’t actually invented until 1974, so there is no way they could have been playing it before they graduated, but shhhhhhhh don’t think about it too hard
The one thing that wasn’t said about the Riordanverse inaccuracies is the characters’ cannon heights. Most of the boys are 6’0” Annabeth is 5’9”, Leo is 5’6” Frank is 6’3” Hazel is 5’3” and Nico is 5’6.5”. Not to mention that Leo is canonically the same height as a SEVEN YEAR OLD GIRL. I have an OC for the Riordanverse, but the thing is: I’m 5’1.5”. My character is 5’2” and my personal head cannon is that the gods give their kids the tall genes and my OC just got VERY unlucky.
I only count inaccuracies that contradict how something is stated to work within a series, cause in works of fiction, sometimes people just arbitrarily draw the line of what is and isn't reasonable. As someone who recently got into dragon ball, it's like someone saying "How does Goku fly? That makes no sense!" like the guy can't cup his hands and fire a beam of energy capable of destroying the planet a few thousand times over. Unless it was specifically stated that they can't do that, then they can, _especially_ in nebulous power systems.
OKAY!!! MIRACULOUS TIMELINE: In season 1, the cast is in 10th grade. In season 3, Marinette turns 14, implying the cast is in EIGHTH GRADE But in sesson 5, it is revealed they are in NINETH GRADE!!!!
Also are Luka and Juleka twins or not? Are they 16 or 14? Show: Yes, but also no. And speaking of twins, let's not forget about Chloe's "Irish Twin". LOL XD
I was gonna comment about Batman/Batfam because trying to find a coherent timeline/character ages for all their bs is impossible ... so like seemingly most of the fandom, I pick and choose what I want where to cobble together a storyline that makes *some* sense
it's because of the constant retcons and reboots of the DC Universe tbh. you literally can't track the entire history of ANY of DC's characters because of this. lots of stuff just gets completely wiped from existence, altered or retconned, takes place on an alternate Earth, etc. DC even acknowledges how convoluted their universe is and how their isn't an actual canon timeline because of it, which is why they decided to make their canon more fluid by merging all of the timelines into one and making all past and current continuities canon simultaneously via The Omniverse. now DC and their writers don't have to worry about how they don't actually have a set canon timeline for everything, and fans can pick and choose what they like and what they don't. personally that's how i engage with all of my fandoms anyway, not just comics, so i for one love this approach and think it's a genius way to solve DC's canon timeline issues.
yes 💀💀 i cant tell if bruce wayne is like damn near 80 or in his mid forties. i dont know if im the only one confused by the ages of any given robin. esp i dont think theres a for sure date that any of the recent comics. assuming grayson was born in the 80s, that puts us in like 2000-2010 but then you throw jason todds resurrection clusterfuck and its like... what is happening
1:41 okay as a warrior cat fan thats just being picky. like, yeah, the highly humanized cats with a concept of religion, medicine, and goverment make choices, shocker. also, not all queens that stay in the nursery keep having kits, Goldenflower (arc 1 until mid arc 2) stayed a nursery queen after her second litter left, to help raise other queens' kits. Daisy (Arc 2 onwards) is a recongised permenant queen who has an entire side thing (Daisy's Kin) that ends in the cats she's helped raise thanking her for her job. and yeah, the medicine cats take vows of chastity, their doctor nuns. Warrior Cats is written like tiny humans in cat fur. Also, technically an apprentice has had kits before, Scorchfur of Shadowclan in Arc 3, but that was due to a timeline consistency issue because the warriors writers have admitted to using the fandom wiki as their lore bible. if you wanna talk about cat biology in warrior cats, why dont they constantly have worms? they are never described removing the GI tract of animals they eat, and they eat meat raw, they almost certainly should have worms. And the fleas, there is no reason the elders should constantly have fleas, not only are those bad for their health, it would also spread to everyone else immediately. the heat thing is a fair point, but yeah, kids book. also european badgers are almost entirely docile and are not like the american-esque ones portrayed in the books. and theres only been 1 deaf blue eyed white furred kit in the entire series, even though theres been at least a dozen blue eyed white furred cats before and since Snowkit, and genetically a least a few of them would be deaf. sorry for the wall of text but i've put 8 years of my life into this fandom and i know far too much about it
I recently got into MASH (the series) and boy, the timeline. It takes place in the Korean war, which took place in 1950-53, HOWEVER the series has 11 seasons. The fandom jokes about time loops, and the general horrors of war. I'm not angry about this, I just find it kinda funny.
Different species cannot reproduce together, that is the definition of a species. Chimpanzees and humans too have a common ancestor, but good luck having a child with one. The same biology should technically apply to aliens as well.
The Persona 5 one is just straight-up incorrect--the dates do, in fact, match up with the 2016 calendar. That's why the general fandom consensus is that it takes place in 2016 in the first place.
The OP also complaining about having to write around the year, don't worry bud so did Atlus. The canon year is 20XX. Even in Q2, they say "well we don't know what year it is but it ain't 2014!"
I wrote a (no joke) novel of a fanfic. At the time, there were only four games. Four years later (when I finished), we got like three more. I basically kept the story based around the first three games (with the AU element that the Springtrap suit was found empty because I wanted the murderer alive) and kept to them, and only added elements from later games where I could fit them without derailing the story (i.e., Security Puppet's costume became main!Puppet's costume to show a time skip because main!Puppet got disassembled, then fixed, the OG owner had a circus theme planned as a potential sister location that never happened, Afton Robotics got a mention as a rival company that folded offscreen, etc.)
Me, too! Eventually I decided to stop complying with canon and just take it completely off the rails. If they’re not going to play by their own rules, neither will I.
@@BlackplaaagueBro for fucking truth. My AU is primarily Security Breach-based so I’m no stranger to… let’s say stretching the canon to make things a lot less stupid, but it was around the time the books came out and just dumped all sorts of bullshit lore that took a wrecking ball to my carefully constructed narrative that I just decided to say “fuck it” and just split it off into my own AU.
I thought it was really weird when Buckbeak hurt a student and the school's reaction was to take him from Hagrid and have him put down, yet in the first book/movie, Hogwarts punished Harry and Draco by having them go into a dark forest that they know is dangerous. Hogwarts likes to pick and choose when they care about their students' safety.
Also the house points system. It’s so inconsistent and has a lot of plot armor, that people make memes about it (my personal favorite being the Mean Girls reference).
That wasn't the school; Draco's father - who works in the government - was specifically spitefully trying to kill Buckbeak just to be cruel. (In general, though, the school is not a safe place and Buckbeak's trial was obviously very stupid, but it wasn't put on by the school.)
There are a lot of fandoms where the canon age is very obviously drawn out of a hat. Like Sonic. You could tell me he’s fourteen or twenty-five and I’d believe you, because it doesn’t matter. Someone just scribbled down random ages in the Sonic Heroes manual one time, with only a base logic for all their ages relative to each other, and we’ve all treated it as gospel ever since. Some fandoms, the only reason characters are teens are because the creator wanted to write stock school scenes.
I don't know if this applies to this, but one thing that bothered me about Steven Universe was the characters' resistance levels: for example, apparently Peridots are very resistant, to the point where a giant rock would fall on them and they wouldn't crack or poof, but it was quickly poofed by Garnet about 2 seasons ago, when the pearl was pierced for the first time, she still resisted and spoke to Steven for about 5 seconds, but Bismuth spent more than 10 seconds talking to Steven, and in the " false" shattering of the Pink Diamond itself is instantly poofed by the rose's sword, so I ask myself, how come a diamond is less resistant than a bismuth?
Pink Diamond wanted to be poofed in that particular instance. I could see a gem being able to hang on a little longer if they really wanted to, especially when they're war veterans like Pearl and Bismuth. Peridot's newfound resistance is pretty much rule of funny though. I guess you could argue that being merged with her limb enhancers made her easier to poof, but the show never states that.
I'm not an expert on metals but something that immediately stuck out to me was Bismuth's ability to swim in lava. Irl bismuth has a melting point so low that you can melt it on your stove.
I did have a headcannon that gem weapons and piercing objects do cause a gem to poof, because gem weapons are made to fight other gems, and piercing weapons can puncture a gem's form, like a needle to a balloon. Meanwhile, blunt objects dont cause that same effect. Amethyst had her gem cracked from falling on a rock because her gem was exposed, which is a weak spot for any gem, but peridot's gem was fine cause she has a visor protecting her gem.
@@anothermiddleschoolburnout8816 i did recall a video saying that a gem's gem isnt actually made out of the same material they name themselves, otherwise lapis would've dissolved her gem ages ago from summoning her wings. its most likely just named after coloration/shape
My first fandom was star wars. I was so used to having a beautiful timeline (even if it was insane) that canon/legends fans already had made that transitioning to disney cartoons drove me nuts. GRAVITY FALLS’ TIMELINE IS NONSENSE!
Someone said Ash is 10 years old always and this. I agree. Because... The fact that the Sun and Moon anime is the way it is makes Ash staying 10 make no sense!! Because of Kukui and Burnet. Within the series, they were friends that started to have romantic feelings for each other, then Kukui proposed to Burnet and they got married. This was the same episode. Now you could argue this could have happened within the same week or month. AND THEN sometime between that wedding episode and possibly the Ultra Beast episodes, they had sex because the end of the Sun and Moon series reveals Burnet is pregnant. It looks like she may be 5 months pregnant there? THEN ASH VISITS THEM IN JOURNEYS AND NOT ONLY IS THE BABY BORN, BUT HE LOOKS LIKE HE'S ABOUT 5 MONTHS TO A YEAR OLD!! yet Ash is somehow still the same age. So like, realistically, 2-3 years should have passed.
For the Miraculous Ladybug one, the events are not exactly put in a timeline. The Christmas specials are not even considered canon for the most part, as they're not referenced almost anywhere in the rest of the series, besides the literal one shot from one of them appearing in a different episode. Season 1 has basically no timeline and you can usually put most episodes into any order, as it's just the show getting its footing and also being an extremely episodic show. Season 2 and 3 mostly solve this issue, although they still don't have complete consistency, but Season 4 onward, all episodes come one after another.
Anytime a historical setting, fiction or otherwise has something that shouldn't exist yet, I affectionately call it, "Chocolate in King Author's Court."
Freddy vs Jason The separate series established that Freddy lives in Ohio and Jason lives in New Jersey But somehow in the crossover, the kids drive an unconscious Jason from Springwood to Crystal Lake in what seems to be a matter of minutes. Ohio to New Jersey is a minimum 9 hour drive assuming light traffic. Even longer because Crystal Lake is on the coast
i read a lot of my hero academia fics, and there is one main thing that annoys me for some odd reason: midoriya’s height. istg, he ain’t that short- and when they compare him to bakugo, he might as well be the height of an ant 💀
11:45 Hylian vs Hyrulean, there are also two seperate official timelines that either add or remove a Link depending on which one you prefer. Also the manga are soft canon, if they don't contradict the games, it's canon. For the timeline I say the less Links for the games, more Links for the manga
9:50 half gripe about the Harry Potter cannon, half gripe about the fandom Squibs Why are they treated like wizard-born-muggles when not only does "wizard with a learning disability" have way more canon evidence (Squibs can see dementors, there are claims of them using spells, the Quicky Spell manual) but it would also be an interesting way to take the concept? Just, more Squibs being used in general would have been nice
The whole "either you are born with magic or you are not" concept lost the appeal on me over time. Muggles can't even brew potions, even if they would study potions for years and do everything exactly as a wizard would when brewing the potion. No wonder there are barely any substantial muggles and Squibs characters, they can't do sh*t
Yeah, The way I see it, Squibs are just magically disabled. Specifically, they cannot innately use _spells._ Other magic is fair game. The reason they're treated as "wizard-born-muggles" is because the Greenwich area, canonically, only looks for _Accidental Spell Casting._ Something that, by nature, Squibs cannot do. I have a crossover fic centering on a Squib whose gifted at magic contracts and seersight (not prophesies; he sees different paths the future could take), but his bio parents rejected him due him being a Squib, and then his magic developed in his teens. He was on track to become an engineer, as his lack of spell casting meant he could safely build and operate both magic and muggle tech
@@fruity4820 That concept especially doesn't make sense when you consider how some mages are able to use magic that others can't; for example, Tonk's Metamorphism or Seers Not to mention how one mage can be terrible at one type of magic yet brilliant at another can bring the "all-or-nothing" concept into question. So yeah, doesn't make sense to me either
The birthday one reminded me of the Mob Psycho 100 fandom's gripes with Inukawa's birthday, wich is supposed to be on leap day, except he was born in a non-leap year 💀
@@BJGvideosLugia is only psychic type because the developers wanted him to feel more powerful. If Lugia was introduced in a later gen, he would be the correct typing of Water and Flying. Lugia is based on Ryujin, a Shinto sea god and it's shiny is based on Ryujin's palace. The original creator, Takeshi Shundo, for Lugia created it with ocean symbolism in mind as the 2nd movie shows(it was supposed to be anime only). Its 40 day storms feat is based on the 40 day storm that flooded the world in Christain mythology(which includes water, not pychic). Part of it's name origin could come from beluga, deluge(to flood), and/or Lutiya(old name for Bahamut, and was orginally described as a giant fish).
that she-ra comment was quite obnoxious. Some of their points were valid but by the time they got to "How can this cartoon hero jump so high" I was like "Shut up already, if you don't like fiction, don't watch fiction."
I actually recognize the author, so I wanted to say: they like fiction. They like it a lot. Almost too much. That is the author of World War Etheria, a 540,000 word epic with more worldbuilding than you could ever dream of. They're not nitpicking, they're just the second coming of Tolkien.
@@BookWyrmOnAString Even being Tolkien himself would not absolve them of being so nitpicky. Questioning "Why can this character jump so high?" without having enough awareness to realize said character is named CATra and is a CAT-human hybrid is just plain dumb. You might not like the explanation the show gives you, but the fact of the matter is that there IS an explanation for it, and it's that cats are famously acrobatic and CAN jump up several times their own body height, just like Catra does. In the end, that's what "suspension of disbelief" is for, things don't have to follow real life logic so long as they're internally consistent, so for a cartoon aimed at children/younger teens it's completely reasonable to say "This character can do the stuff a cat can do because they're half-cat, even if they look mostly human". The way they talk about it, it really sounds like they're full of themselves and come from a place of "Nobody knows how to do proper world building except for myself"
@@dokchampa9324 Exactly. Plus with the whole going toe to toe with she ra thing, whilst i do also find it annoying can easily be explained by the fact that catra and adora have a personal conflict, of course they need to fight and adora can't just win every battle with ease, that would be boring. I do get the confusion with spinerella and netossa though. Most of what they say in the comment doesn't need to be explained in detail.
Anachronisms, or when something from the present exists in the past, even if that didn't existed yet at the time. I often go to fandoms that are set in fantasy settings, some of them also setting in the past. I see them everywhere. Sometimes, it's just very minor things, like when Greed, a character from FMAB, an anime which is set in 1914, was wearing modern sunglasses. That can easily be ignored. But Natsu, a character from Fairy Tail, an anime which was set in X793, using what appear to be a modern cellphone ? Not so much.
There are precursors to modern sunglasses too, so the sunglasses thing could probably be explained away well enough anyway, if you wanted to bother doing it
Sometimes they can be used just for comedy, which I don't mind. Usually it's better when it doesn't line up with a real timeline (E.x. a generic fantasy world where someone uses a cellphone is more acceptable than someone eating a modern-style candy car in something set in the 1740's.)
Tbf, the sunglasses is part of the Tiffany Problem when it comes to fantasy or sci fi (tldr: when something seems too modern despite having properly existed within that time, example namer Tiffany for example was in use as a name as far back as the 12th century). BUT i assuming you meant the aesthetic of said glasses, which judging from the few ads I could find from the 1920s, look more like those ancient Chinese glasses than the trends at the time. The sunglasses I saw were round, rested on the bridge of the nose, and covered the whole eye. Not the smaller ones that seem to be fashion like Greeds eyewear. Maybe it was intentional? It is an alternate timeline, so I guess something happened that sunglasses trends became different?
From what I remember, Fairy Tail cellphones were improved versions of communication lacrimas (they were showed as crystal balls for most of the series). And honestly, given that FT has trains, what's basically magic-fueled cars, guns, cameras and live TV, I don't think that a magical cellphone is unrealistic, no matter what number the author chose to use as a year. It may kill the vibe, but unrealistic? Nah
Also we have two time goddesses but they're also just one time goddess who split herself into sisters because one of them turned hot for Link and somehow this made her evil, but we're not supposed to talk about them because they're not canon
Cuphead’s DLC has two bosses that take place during the same day, the Moonshine Mob and the Howling Aces. The Moonshine Mob is a gang of bootleggers that worked during Prohibition times, which ended 1934. The Howling Aces use a specific Allied Military Phonetic Spelling (taking the first letter of each word to be more understood through radio) used in 1939 in their death quote
I'm a Murder Drones fan. Disassembly Drone (and Solver Drone by extension) wings would _not_ fit inside their torsos. Even if you assume that the reason N didn't have any lasting damage other than malfunctioning optics (that lasted all of maybe 15-25 minutes in-canon until J slapped him) when Uzi literally blew his head off is because everything intangible (memories, personality traits, etc) is stored in the core and their torsos are completely empty otherwise (which they physically can't be since there do need to be connections to everything), their wings are just simply too long to be able to only fold at the visible joints and fit inside. The longest of the 'feathers' is literally almost twice the length of their torso. And that's not even mentioning there being no visible holes in their clothing for the wings to fit through. They just kinda appear on top. Even if you assume that the nanites repair their clothes as well when they pull the wings back in (they repaired N's hair and hat in the pilot, when we know that those are not attached), it would still result in them ripping their own clothing every time they extend their wings. The way I usually end up explaining the wing size discrepancy for Disassembly Drones is to make it so the wings actually form from nanites when they extend them, and when they have them retracted they're basically just a liquid. That doesn't really explain it for Solver Drones though, given that Solver Drone wings appear to be organic ^^'
Yeah I've seen similar things happen in other shows as well but I let it go because it's animation so it doesn't have to make sense, plus it looks really cool. But yeah it makes no sense and definitely wouldn't work in real life
And this is why I just take everything and throw it in a blender. Keep the canon I like, discard the rest, add some fun headcanons and try to pull out *just* enough sense to suspend disbelief. Then again, I'm a little too good at believing any exposition the author feeds me so maybe my perspective's a bit skewed. Oh well
Sounds like my experience at building my own SCPF Canon (but without the suspension of disbelief stuff), albeit it's necessary, since it's a collective writing effort, some things will be contradictory.
As someone who makes Zelda X pokemon Fan fiction as a personal form to cope with capitalistic America since I was about 10 It feels nice to have a country government generally makes since. That and most of the gym leader in concept actually make sense. It's been 10 years since I've, and looking back on it I should have seen a therapist earlier, because I've learned how not to commit copyright infigment with my own ideas! Now I do bs with dragon, and messing around with spacetime continuum.
I'm a total drama fan and I basically have to ignore the entirety of all stars for the characters to even make sense after world tour, I'm pretty sure the entire old cast is derailed in all stars somehow what is both impressive and horrifying. Though at least it did Scott fairly well, he was pretty enjoyable and I'm one of the rare few who didn't absolutely hate his romance with Courtney (until it was ruined by the stupid cameron kissing Courtney drama.)
If I'm remembering correctly, warrior cats Bluestar's Prophecy opens with the main character being 2 days old and already able to talk in complex sentences. She also knows all about how clan life works and can identify pretty much everyone in the clan
To be honest some of these "this doesn't make sense" really just feels like the person posting this has no suspension of disbelief, like saying magic or superpowers are "illogical" is just ridiculous, like yeah? It's fiction? So long as the magic/superpowers are consistent in-universe then what's the problem?
Well, sometimes the problem isn't that there's no way they could think of it happening, but that no explanation was given for something that they think should be explained
@@PhoebeTheFairy56 if how it happens isn't needed to tell the story then we don't need an explanation. Like one person complained about the super human cat lady being able to jump high and cut through metal.
I think every person has a different limit in their suspension of disbelief. I study biology and of something in fiction relating to biology is royally wrong I can't keep my suspension of disbelief up. I was a real problem for me a few years ago, but nowadays I am trying to be less "picky" about scientific inaccuracies, but some still get me angry lol
I think this may be a difference in suspension of disbelief vs verisimilitude. The former is the audience's willingness to accept a premise, while verisimilitude is the work's ability to uphold said premise. Let's take an example in, "this story is about dragons". Some people just can't suspend their disbelief on premise alone, which is fine, not everything is for everyone, but it's everything else that matters. There are two types of ways verisimilitude is re-enforced, and that's from internal rules and external rules. Internal rules would be something like, "dragons need to ingest a steady supply of metal to keep their scales hale and hearty," so if the writer is inconsistent in how long it takes for the scales to become brittle from a metal deficit (two weeks for one, four months for another, and a year for yet another) with no plausible argument within the text itself, that's a failure to maintain internal verisimilitude. External verisimilitude would be taking real-world knowledge and applying it to the story. Clearly dragons are not real, and we've already established this is part of the premise, so no rupturing of verisimilitude over the dragons just existing. But how are these dragons structured? If they're not purely magical beings like an elemental would be, then they're more like a beast. Enhancing verisimilitude would be extending the wing webbing down the length of their bodies to their tail for better lift when flying instead of having the webbing end at the hip like most depictions show. Rupturing verisimilitude would be having a dragon the size of a freight truck have its hunger satiated by a single mouse or squirrel. That thing's gonna need at least two sheep. And then there's the tottering moments, where it just kinda makes sense in hindsight. The girl aged wonky as a tree? Hm, trees do age slowly, don't they?
10:40 Also, it's weird that Hermione, of all people, likes the smell of parchment. I get that she loves schoolwork, but she's very much the kind of person who'd be against skinning animals.
Danny Phantom once had Danny transform where his classmate (Wes) would have obviously seen him, so the fandom made it Fanon that he KNEW Danny was Phantom and constantly tries to convince everyone, but no one ever believes him
Most arabs have a tan skin which is technically on the white spectrum but not full on white. I do agree that many depictions make him as white as European nobility but the color change is as minor as all the 007 actors differences.
People see what they expect to see when perceiving the Lord. He has to filter your perceptions because the human brain isn't equipped to comprehend things from the divine realm outside of 4 dimensional spacetime. The only people who can come close are extremely intelligent and disciplined mathematicians and theoretical physicists, or the violently insane.
I am a Hetalian, there is literally a whole part of the fandom that tries to decipher what is happening historically and how to make it make more sense when the characters are immortal beings that exist just to represent a human concept that itself is complicated. I was part of this for some months and decided to give up, it's too complicated. Not even talking about things that don't make too much sense because Hima forgot about something and fucked up the whole timeline or we have to research it and correct it to write fanfics. But well Hetalia is a comedy, not a history book.
The Fandom I read for is set in the late 1800’s there’s a lot of modern AUs but there will still be fics tagged “Canon-Era” and then say a character is wearing a hoodie, has modern electricity and appliances or use modern slang when they talk :| some of it irl okay with but seriously? It’s not that hard to know modern clothes didn’t exist in the 1890’s
Jack McCoy from Law & Order is the only prosecutor in the common law world who gets to make the final speech in a criminal trial. I know that's only scratching the surface of the legal inaccuracy in those shows, but that was always the thing that got me.
so. The strongest they can possibly reach is Enchantix. They reach that. Then apparently there’s another one? And various more? And then there’s the whole subplot of the nemeses? And then WHAT THE HELL IS BLOOMIX??
@@L-ghtlessSky Thomas Vacaro explains it better, but I feel what they were originally going for was different transformations for different locations and situations. For example, Sirenix so they could go to the Infinite Ocean, Mythix for the Legendarium, etc. Unfortunately, the way it was executed makes it seem like they were more powerful than the supposed “ultimate transformation”, rather than their own thing
@@L-ghtlessSkyalso as for Bloomix, it’s supposed to be Bloom giving the other girls a bit of the Dragon Flame after they had the rest of their magic stolen away. This also had questionable executions
@@cureidolsmile9820 Yeah, I understand it was like, different situations and ‘everyone else has lost their magic!!1!1!1!’ but why name it BLOOMIX. It could’ve been DRAGONIX. It could’ve been executed SO MUCH BETTER. it is my opinion that winx peaked at that one girl who poisoned flora and made the vampire things with the trix.
the actual hellscape that is the sims timeline. The first 3 sims games are all set around 25 years apart from each other, the order being Sims 3 --> Sims 1 --> Sims 2. With some characters appearing in multiple games, however the ages don't match up AT ALL especially not in comparison with each other. To make things worse every world in the sims 3 is on a slightly different timeline than the rest of them, ranging from 25 years before sims 1 to hundreds of years in the future with some being out only a couple years from each other (why 😭) If you can still get through all of that (including the xbox and extra sims 3 games which all also have timelines). U have the sims 4, which is on a COMPLETELY DIFFERENT TIMELINE AGAIN. And messes completely with the families of sims and their ages. (why is don lothario dating the caliente sisters' mum??) I tried making my own sims savefile which continued on the stories of some of the characters from the older games for FUN but honestly the amount of maths and confusion was way too stressful to me cuz wtf 😭 (Ik the sims team definitely weren't thinking of a complex canon timeline when putting these sims into random situations but I couldn't help trying to make sense of it 😔) Edit: I didn't even MENTION the random graves everywhere in the sims 3 and their weird connections to already existing characters.
6:56 In the games, Tails (who's canonical age fluctuates between 8 and 12 I believe) owns and flies several aeroplanes and owns property. I'd call the comics better about this, but thanks to Ken Penders, that would mean that several canonically grown adults were hitting on these teenagers (and he wanted one of said grown adults to be confirmed to have had sex with one of said teens), so personally I just headcanon that anthropomorphic characters in the games hit adulthood much sooner than humans.
When it comes to fantasy or anthropromorphic creatures or objects, I THINK you can afford to be unrealistic on some things unless that’s your goal. If a main focus of your story is to present something in a way that’s as scientifically-accurate as possible (saying you’re going to write a dog’s perspective as accurate as possible and then have him see his toy ball is red), that’s not good. You don’t have to break your back over getting every single detail right, though adding some of those details (like the moon actually changing phases in different scenes) will give it more believability. What you DO need is to make sure you’re not throwing every scrap of logic out the window and turning your story into a word version of an abstract painting. Not everyone knows cats restrict meowing to communicate to mother and kitten. What everyone DOES know is that a cat meows. Having a cat just hooting like an owl for no reason or explanation, especially if they can’t talk, is going to put a lot of readers off very quickly.
2:25 this is why I only consider the original show canon and completely block everything else out of my mind. I've also heard people say her mental problems come out of nowhere and aren't done well in the original show, but I disagree and I could tell she was crazy from when she first clapped and smiled when Zuko was burned. I'd say her losing it as soon as her best friends, who she's known her entire life, left her for the biggest threat to her empire makes a lot of sense. Especially since she just got the power she's been training her entire life for just to lose it to a child and her dishonored brother.
I think it was the change in the way her crazy showed itself. Manic smiles, high physical violence, grasping for control of others and situations vs sobbing and gibbering, losing control of self. Personally, I like to imagine that someone poisoned her and it was effecting the brain.
Even so, it doesn't really mean the mental illness was portrayed correctly or in a good way. (I've never actually watched atla though so take this with a grain of salt)
In Wings of Fire, Wren and Sky can speak both the dragon and human language fluently, it’s believable for them to know the human language since Wren was 7 and could already speak well enough when she found Sky, but how the hell did they learn to speak dragon?? Sky was a hatchling when Wren found him so there’s no way he would be able to speak well enough for Wren to learn from him and they both had very little contact with any other dragons.
ikr? like that's not how language works, you have to learn it?? especially with a spoken language like dragon is stated to be. if it was a nonverbal "language", like how irl cats communicate, that'd be one thing, but this is on a whole different level.
In wings of fire, one of the side characters, Deathbringer, is assumed/implied to be the age as the main characters in the book he is introduced in. Yet, in a later off-shoot book that details his backstory, the year the story takes place in would mean he is muuuuch older in the present day. Which wouldnt be too bad if it werent for the fact that when he meets the main characters, they are all 6 years old (late teens for dragons), and one of the main characters, Glory, is his love interest. Meanwhile the the book about his backstory would set him as being 13 years old (around like 30s maybe?). However most people (including me) just ignore this as Tui (author) not being the best at keeping timelines in check. Also, side note; dragon aging isnt the most consistent in the books, with dragons seeming to age very quickly from ages 1-7 and then just slowing down the aging from there, as its normal for dragons to live past 100.
Its odd that headcanoning him as a child soldier lines up better. Like, its horrifying, but i can see the faction he works for doing it, and it makes shipping line up better.
In the Wings of Fire fandom, tribe evolution is a mess. Before book 15 (where the author introduced a few ancient dragons from millennia before the events of the books via flash blacks) I had a well constructed, scientifically-viable theory on how all the tribes could have evolved, and half an explanation for hybrids. With book 15 however, I've had to work around a lot of stuff, and frankly it's extremely frustrating. Just don't get me started on canon biology in general (for reference, dragons are considered adults at 7; 8-year-olds founded a school where a 20-year-old is going, and no one questions it. Dragons _keep growing_, albeit slowly, after they turn 7. She should be at least a third bigger than all the others, especially since the school was intended for dragonets (think 2-5 year-olds). ) I've also worked a hopefully scientifically-viable theory for that. Oh and the worst part in the languages. Someone help me.
I personally handwave the languages with an animus dragon who didn't know about pantala, and the pantalan dragons just assuming its a result of the now-deified clearsight. So maybe everyone's been speaking icewing for the past 1500 years.
Army size in Star Wars. In Episode 2, Obi-Wan is informed on Kamino regarding the clone army that 200,000 units are ready, with a million more well on the way. So the clone army is 1.2 million men strong. And they are the main Republic force in a galaxy wide conflict. Considering Germany invaded the Soviet Union in 1941 with an army more than twice that size, it makes absolutely no sense. The clone army would be way to small to fight in a war that spans the entire galaxy.
A unit is Star Wars is a group of soldiers, not individual soldiers. I don’t remember how many soldiers there were per unit, but I know there are billions of clones total
@@wapple4240 They should be in the quadrillions of soldiers. More if SW used even a tiny fraction of the bounty of space they have access to. A single K2 Dyson Swarm would be home to more living space than every planet in our galaxy many times over, even building multi km high buildings to the limit of the planets ability to radiate away waste heat. But it's not a science fiction story or setting, it's a fantasy adventure in a stolen space suit.
@@bmobmo6438tbf droids we're cheap and easy to make so it's probably not that much of a stretch to think they would be outnumbering the clones 9/10 times, especially since in the e.u they had factories all across the outer rim that even the empire had to deal with, what I want to know is how in the hell is one planet with one cloning facility supplying a galactic army? Surly there must have been billions of offworld cloning facilities across republic owned territories in order to keep up with the droid army and yet I can only vaguely remember seeing only like one cloning station in space from the the show that never gets brought back up again after one or two episodes and kamino getting most of the attention.
If you’re gonna get into Ace Attorney, you’re gonna have to accept that the games abide by their own court system and therefore allows SO MUCH insane shit to occur.
in a birthday letter from kaeya, just after the TCG came out in genshjn, he started the letter with “yo” which. he would NEVER. and the entire letter just felt like an ad for the tcg…. like, cyno is already the biggest ad for it ever, because he’s canonically obsessed with the game and we were already in sumeru so we got to see cyno often. it was perfect. we didnt NEED kaeya to advertise the game. i swear hoyo just uses kaeya as a way to advertise things. first his demo barely even being about him, then this?? how much more are they gonna disrespect him like this……
I’m not sure if this fits but I have to say. The Worldbuilding in Steven Universe is kinda iffy. Earth was the first planet to have intelligent, sapient beings on it. So why were there already diplomats and armies? Who were they negotiating and fighting with? It doesn’t seem like each other, at least until Pink’s rebellion. What did the zoo amethysts do all day? What does anyone do all day? They only consume resources when they make more gems, and I guess their building materials.
Yeah, the show being Steven's perspective only really hurt the worldbuilding, we never saw how Homeworld operated on a larger scale before it got turned into a democracy after the timeskip. There also was this whole thing about a resource shortage creating smaller Era 2 Gems with diminished powers that just… never comes up again. I think the handwave is supposed to be that they ran out of Pink Diamond's essence when making more Gems, but Rubies that would need mostly red coloring essence from Pink are still considered common throwaway soldiers while Peridots which would mostly need blue and yellow coloring essence have diminished capacities? Doesn't really make a lot of sense. We also never see any Era 1 Peridots that are the "correct" size or any diminished Era 2 versions of other Gems for that matter. It feels like there was a whole arc there that got aborted.
@@rainpooper7088The show being in Steven's perspective is what makes the show work. It would actually be restrictive and take away from the story otherwise. All of these are pretty small details tbh that likely we would have learned if Cartoon Network actually let the series play out to full completion.
I feel like there was supposed to be some sort of "Galactic War" the Diamonds, and thus all of gemkind, had been fighting for hundreds of thousands of years, hence the need for more and more gems- a war so large that they'd need the Cluster, and that they were willing to wait thousands of years for the Cluster to emerge so they could use it.
Fnaf lore is like Uno. The rules are what you can convince everyone else the rules are
I love this
Agreed lol
This is so accurate lol
So true
And unlike other Fandoms where this is true (Undertale AU multiverse, SCP, Backrooms, etc), its not even because it's community made! It's just because the official Canon is secret and none of us fully understand it. Which somehow makes this comparison funnier, at least to me.
Cat Noir: *kicks the miracle box* SCORE!!!
Cat Noir within the SAME SEASON: “I know nothing about football, m’lady.” *tries to use his hands*
Thomas Ass truck
Honestly any excuse for the writers to downplay Catnoir for a situation is taken and it made watching the show unbearable for me
MLB is the hiding spot for a ton of plotholes and inconsistencies
Thomas Astruc would rather disintegrate than let anyone outshine Marinette from being the Mary Sue she is (aka Catnoir having no plot relevance despite being advertised as the secondary protagonist)
I still don't understand why they made him so stupid. He has a TV in his room! He has a football table! Football is popular in France! WHY?!
What I like the most about Don't Starve's lore is that any inaccuracy (like gold tools being more durable than rock tools) can be explained with “Maxwell doesn't know shit about science”
this made me giggle
Maxwell being the creator or a character?
@@abbycollins Character
@@abbycollinsI do not know dst lore that well. Aren’t they the same people?
@@abbycollinsMaxwell is a character, he created the world in which the other characters have to survive
honestly, the biggest thing I've learned being the DC fandom is to just pick what you like out of canon and throw aside what you don't, then bullshit your way to victory.
This. Also, to ignore the New 52 era entirely.
same for marvel tbh
@@VNightmoon maybe not ALL of it. there were some nice things that came from the New 52; i personally just ignore MOST of it. plus with the Omniverse and Infinite Frontier it's all irrelevant anyway lol.
one tag I've seen on AO3 is "DC stands for Disregard Canon" and I think it sums things up pretty well
@@toricon8070I love that tag so much
You really can’t expect Warrior cats to be realistic. It just was never the goal, the writers themselves said they wanted to write more about little furry humans more than actual real cats. The whole concept of warrior cats is unrealistic, really.
Seriously, do they expect the books about religious cats, who literally fought against *hell* at one point, to care about realism ?
I knew that it was unrealistic the moment they mentioned cats building dens out of bracken and sticks like this wasn’t extremely advanced behavior for animals to literally build homes (idk if cats ACTUALLY do this but it seems unlikely.) And Rusty having dreams about cat heaven.
@@Midnightlunar10 yeah cats definitely don’t build houses. Everything down to the ere concept of the clans itself is unrealistic. They have a leader, a second in command, a doctor-priest, a whole religion, and more.
So like that musical? Got it
@@abbycollins NO NOT LIKE THE MUSICAL LMAO 😭
Riordan at least tried to explain that Thalia's tree form kept her from aging normally. But ....
Yeah. Getting actual calendar dates to map out the timeline would be nice
Yeah, that single thing makes sense. If someone turns into a tree, the type of tree matters to me though because that’s going to affect their aging. They age at tree speed (which might be faster as well as slower than human speed, depending on the tree)
Rick Riordan did that because he wanted Percy to be the demigod who fulfills the great prophecy. The prophecy says that Olympus shall fall to a child of the big three once they turn 16.
If she ages normally, Thalia would already be 19 and would have fulfilled the prophecy, that's why the author intentionally made her age slower
@@othamneil8958Honestly, he could’ve just let her be 19. The prophecy doesn’t specify that it will be the next child of the Big 3 that will fulfill the prophecy, just “a”.
@@darkstarr984 pretty sure they did say it's a pine tree
@@othamneil8958 He could’ve literally solved all his problems by making Thalia 13 when she died, then over the 5 years she was dead, she could’ve aged in “tree years” (10 human years in 1 “tree year”) making her 13.5-14 (depending on how long she’d been 13), that way the timeline would’ve made sense *and* she’d still be older than Percy.
The Sonic age one is so real. Silver and Sonic are the closest to acting like silly teens, and it's just because Silver is naive and anxious and Sonic doesn't shut up- and neither of those have anything to do with their age, just their situations. Cream is the only one with a believable age tbh. Tails feels like he could be 10, and Charmy seems like he's 9.
Agreed. Especially w Charmy. Like as a six year old, he just doesn’t make much sense. Where did he come from? How long has he been a Chaotix? Why does almost no one act their age???
@@cinders-xs2zn Exactly! If he joined the Chaotix when he *was* six, that makes more sense, but it seems less like a found family if he's been around the whole time. And you really want to tell me Vector is 20? Please, he acts like hes 17.
It's no use
He's not 17 or 20, he *NEEDS TO FIND THE COMPUTER ROOM*@@coyotix
Sonic ages are all kinda fucked up.
Sonic is 15
Amy is 12
Tails is 8
Knuckles is 16
Rouge is 18
Cream is 6
Shadow is simultaneously 50 and 5 due to his time in stasis
Blaze is 15....
Almost all of the main cast except Robotnik and Vanilla are teens or kids, which really says a lot about Mobius as a whole.
In one of the Heroes of Olympus books, Percy states his zodiac sign is a Leo, which is a summer sign. Sally and Poseidon hooked up in the summer. Either Sally was pregnant for one month, one year, or all demigods have weird birth rules, not just Athena kids.
His birthday is August 18th and it is mentioned by Sally in Chalice of the Gods that her pregnancy with Percy was longer than usual
I once saw a headcanon that Poseidon essentially pulled a seahorse (if you know what I mean) because gods can ignore things like gestation periods.
I mean… they could’ve hooked up multiple times
Well, they're children of literal gods, so it would make sense that their rules are weird. There's basically nothing keeping the godly parent or the demigod's to influencing the pregnancy and causing it to be abnormally short or long.
Plus the goddesses can do whatever too, I think I remember seeing that Aphrodite in particular has some weird ass rules about her pregnancies and all.
tbh that sounds like the most likely and realistic answer. This is my new headcanon.
"Oh my children tend to need longer gestation times because they are so powerful, we will have to split the pregnancy"@@YouveBeenMegged
That ash is still 10…
I mean Pokémon just has a floating timeline. That’s not an inaccuracy, it’s just how the show works.
The concept of Ash is a time paradox. There is no correct age!
@@magicalgirllaurie But then we have people aging as you expect them to around him and yet he's still 10?!
I’m pretty sure he’s 11 as of Black and White, might just be in the dub tho
My favorite example of Ash always being 10 is this;
Kukui and Burnet.
The two aren't in a relationship at the beginning of the Sun and Moon series but then they begin to date, then Kukui proposed to her on screen, they got married also on screen within the same episode, sometime between the marriage episode and the ultra beast arc, Kukui and Burnet had sex (obviously not on screen because kids show) because towards the end of the Sun and Moon series, Burnet is pregnant. Then later, Ash visits them and they have their son who looks like he's a few months to maybe a year old at this point.
Yet Ash is still 10 despite realistically that would have all happened within at least 2-3 years.
I used to be really into HP and I noticed that Ron’s mum creates pasta sauce out of nothing and it just comes out of the tip of her wand in one of the first books. Then in the seventh Ron says “my mum can create food out of nothing” and Hermione is all like “no she can’t that’s against ____s third law.” And that pissed me off.
The only explanation I can think of is she had the ingredients at the ready and summoned them.
tbh the 7th book pissed me off so much that I just jumped to watch the part 2 movie.
"Oh no, we are wizards and can't figure out how to fish or hunt, its not as if we have a spell that can kill with one hit". If a bunch of kids can survive a plane-crash and then the amazon jungle IRL then three adult wizards can hunt for food.
I love how this is worded like this was the catalyst for not being as into HP anymore ahsdkljfha
@@oceanmythjormundgandr3891tbh idk if food that was killed with avada-kedavra would be healthy to eat. Something about it makes me imagine it would be full of evil magic toxins or something. Still no excuse though
I mean, all I'm seeing here is that Ron doesn't know very much, which is pretty much expected for Ron.
Winx Club timeline is a mess. Can't decide whether things happened a couple decades ago or thousands of years before.
Also, inconsistent character/relationship development. They'll develop nicely one season then regress within 1-2 seasons (once it was 3-4 seasons later) with no explanation besides "for the drama".
Especially with the whole "Daphne" thing, I'm currently rewatching Winx and I could see why younger me immediately stopped watching a few episodes in after season 6 or 7 (i cant really remember). I think it's just Nick trying hard to keep the show running as much as possible. There are also some things/powers shown in previous seasons that are completely forgotten about. Like Blooms ability to see peoples souls or something
Feel that first one in my soul as a kamen rider fan
It made me really sad when people said that Musa x Riven was toxic whilst ignoring that he wasn't supposed to be toxic in the first place. He got character development and became a decent guy but it was taken away from him for like no reason
Oh lord, that's so real. And I'm not even close to being into the outer circles of the fandom
I send you strength, friend
For this reason i consider only the first 3 seasons and the first movie to be canon, the consistency of basically everthing gets really shitty otherwise
But i have a pet peeve with domino, like when i first watched it i thought it was death for like 300 years already but acording to canon it's only been 16
Azula’s psychological profile was so complex and well done in the series… the comic completely messed it up 😭😭😭 and it’s disappointing knowing that the comics are 100% canon.
I always try to be positive when reading or watching showd but the ATLA comics are not the best when it comes to characterizations. Just the first chapters made Aang so trigger happy against Zuko... On the other hand, the Kyoshi books are masterpieces in my opinion.
@@ceve Tbf though, Aang being so trigger happy against Zuko was only because of Roku. He was so distrusting of "The Fire Nation forcefully expanding their territory" when they just wanted to unite the people that lived in the Earth Kingdom colonies, which were around for so long that the people who lived there were a mix of both Earth and Fire Nation people. Roku was also extra paranoid of Zuko planning to betray Aang behind his back, projecting that onto him so hard that Aang started to feel paranoid too.
After Aang and Zuko have their big confrontation, in which they almost kill each other before they realize that "No duh! My friend doesn't secretly want to kill me!", Aang goes to talk to Roku and basically tells him "Hey, your issues are your own, I won't be taking advice from you anymore. Zuko is my friend, and I almost killed him today because of you. Uniting the nations is a good thing, and we'll keep working to achieve that. Thank you for everything, but I think it's time for you to rest", and that was that.
And I honestly really like that that was a plot-point, because re-watching ATLA you can blatantly see that Roku is hot-headed, not great at communicating, stubborn and unilateral in his advice. Which worked great against a tyrannical dictator hellbent on everyone's destruction but his own - it doesn't take much to be right in that situation - but when it comes to complex/delicate political issues he completely drops the ball. I mean, he's not entirely at fault, but let's not forget that his incompetence played a role in what started the 100 year old war, ok? And I mean before the volcano, because the problem should've been solved before he ever got that old, but that's just my opinion.
And I always thought that what inspired Zuko and Aang to unite the nations was Iroh. They both learned that nature and bending work in harmony best when they're connected and together: bending techniques, the swamp, the AVATAR itself, etc. It would make sense that they both reached the same conclusion, and I don't disagree, I think the world became better for it. Aang rejecting Roku is not only him rejecting the old for the (slightly less old) new, but coming into his own as the Avatar in a political sense. And it's a great post-canon add-on because of it.
Tl;dr - Aang says "Ok, boomer", hits the griddy on Roku, leaves him in the dust and makes up with Zuko. It's actually a really cool plot-point.
@@LoreCatanAang ducks on a victim of war and everyone claps lmao.
@@alfalldoot6715 I mean, if you mean Roku then I'd have to disagree. Bro confronted the Fire Lord once and then fucked off to his island until he grew old, thinking he solved the problem. And Sozin didn't start the war until after Roku died, so he experienced none of it.
And Aang is better than me, if I were him I'd be so pissed at Roku for how things turned out. And I could maybe forgive it, but then you try to make me kill one of my best friends too? Because _you're_ a distrustful asshole now?
No wonder Aang cut ties immediately, I would've done the same thing. Good for him, honestly.
I'm pretty sure the Ace Attorney world has no such thing as "conflict of interest;" like, seriously, the series starts out with Phoenix defending his childhood friend. Then 50% of the rest of the series is either a friend or relative. And 10% is Maya.
Also, the bad guy can do all the shady things they want while on the stand, and you *still* need to present that final, decisive evidence before an arrest can be made.
And almost every prosecutor in the series can just assault Phoenix in the courtroom and nobody cares lol
And apparently the prosecutors can just tell the judge what to do and he'll do it (although that might just be that specific judge being incompetent)
AA can get away with it since the legal system was rebooted at the start of the 21st century. Otherwise none of the stories could work at all.
Honestly the villain of Ace Attorney is their absolutely terrible judicial system
Honestly, I can see why they only really accepted Phoenix Wright after Apollo Justice the game: at that point, he actually pulled off bizarre amounts of strings to randomly change the justice system to catch one person. This is probably corruption on par with Damon Gant or Manfred Von Karma, who were respected before being dethroned. The Ace Attorney world seems to rewards abuse of the justice system so long as you can get away with it, and the trick in Apollo Justice is what makes people think that Phoenix Wright is masterful enough to do that. Therefore, Phoenix Wright is now able to be manipulative enough to be accepted in law circles and make real change.
Ace Attorney is infamous for having a bizarre & inconsistent tech level, wherein they're still using old-timey security tapes but have advanced AI robots. The police can submit & get results from gel electrophoresis in like 15 minutes. There's 2 AA games that take place in 1896 that feature 2 way-too-advanced inventor characters, which is also itself an inconsistency to be ignored, but I personally like to hc they're why the tech level is so wild in the modern games.
Also on the topic of those 2 games: there's a character who is the Chief Justice, but the design team preferred style over accuracy, so he dresses like a slutty priest. It's hilarious and I love it.
Phoenix with his flip-phone in 2028
The world order of Ace Attorney is very unrealistic and BIZZARE, love it so much❤
And the AA legal system makes no sense at all, but I guess that makes it more exciting than any real one
You got a dude with a fucking cyberpunk ass visor
Also the fact that Phoenix still has a flip phone in like 2028 but Athena, who works with him, has a literal robot necklace and two almost-sentient robot friends (Clonco and Ponco).
And then we have to also consider Apollo's backstory as a big inconsistency because he gets a new past every game lol
For the thing with the sonic characters, I really like how the movies have so far portrayed Sonic as just being a little shit. He saves the world but he's still a dumb and impulsive kid
To be fair… Sonic is canonically 15 - 16 years old. He should have the freedom to act like a kid
And the movie shows how being isolated has messed him up
The movie was pretty much the first time he actually acts his age, so naturally, people in the fandom were bitching about how this version isn't cocky and in control 100% of the time.
What “world” does he save? American?
@@doggoadexx2680 Mobius, obviously
If the Clawthorne's curse in The Owl House is sentient, what happened when Eda and Lilith split the curse? Did Lilith ever make piece with it? Also, they handwave away what happens to the government after the Emporer dies. In three years, the Boiling Isles have become a utopia.
The first one we don't know but the Boiling Isles were basically a utopia before Belos showed up as shown in "Elsewhere and Elsewhen" so like it's not that crazy
No idea about the first, but yes, Lilith did make peace with her curse, you can see her in her harpy form in the epilogue montage.
How the boiling isles got like that is the plot of a fic I want to write… someday…
I just imagined the curse split, kind of like naruto and Minato having a share of kuramas power
Spoilers,much?
But yes,apparently without dictators a state/governmental problem just solves itself.
10:45 PRECISELY
Obliviate needing to be an Unforgivable Curse, someone finally agrees with me
Toying with memory isn’t anything to be taken lightly, as someone who is writing a story on it. You can’t just do that and receive no consequences. It’s objectively wrong.
The ONE singular exception is "rebooting" someone from something incredibly traumatic (such as the ticket vendor's family in Goblet of Fire, I completely understand the memory of being levitated hundreds of feet in the air being erased.)
I don't like HP because of all the stuff around it, but what if in-universe a person was like "I should write this as an unforgivable curse" and then someone casted it on them so it wasn't put as a curse?
@@headphonesaxolotl Depends how traumatic. How far can we go with that? Should the person have to give permission? Are they in a state to? It’s all very complicated
@@_AstaLily I meant where the person is clearly negatively impacted AND clearly indicates they want to no longer remember that.
I read "PRECISELY" in my head like the guy from Ratatoing who's voiced by Mike Pollock whose name I can't remember despite having watched the movie like 3 times
Pokémon lore is often only hinted at and not fully explained, but whenever they do explain stuff you know it's going to be confusing, lead to inaccuracies, and sometimes be completely different depending on which canon you're looking at (and there are a lot of different pokémon canons). Thank you for the world, but we'll take it from here...
The last sentence is full of words to live by
And sometimes it's different games in the SAME canon on account of version differences
*coughs and looks pointedly at the paradox forms of Raikou and Suicune*
Yes, hi, hello, Game Freak, did you forget that these legendaries were not around from prehistoric times and came into being relatively recently according to the timeline of both universes?
Why did you not make them the future paradox forms and give the Musketeers the past forms?
You cannot even use the excuse of the Gen 1-5 worlds being destroyed by the Ultra Beasts since we are in a different timeline altogether since you haven't displayed that the current version of Johto has a different history yet.
@@FizzieWebb That's the main reason I believe the theory that paradox pokémon aren't *actually* from other time periods, they're just believed to be and really are physical forms of what the explorers imagined. I was hoping we would get more fuel for that theory/something similar or have it outright confirmed in the dlc, but no luck.
@@bugtypeeeveeThat's actually canon, there's a secret cutscene if you bring terapagos to the Kitakami lake and they say that Paradox Pokémon came from different timelines. Considering Pokémon has had a multiverse since ORAS, I'd say it checks out.
3:59 I pulled off an interspecies baby in my novel via genetic modification. Rather than being produced sexually, the baby was grown in a lab from a combination of the parents’ genetic materials modified to be compatible with one another. I suppose, biologically, the test-tube baby is an entirely new species.
That's one way to do it! 😂
This is something we need to see more of.
i mean, humans cross animal species sometimes, so...
I will have to point out Homo Sapiens and Homo Neanderthalesis had babies together and they're separate species. IRL there's like 26 different definitions of Species and the interbreeding one is only one of them.
@@lucyla9947 One of the species in question originated on another planet.
"Authors (creators in general, really) are a group not generally known for their math skills."
Yep, that's accurate. I feel like a lot of creative people struggled with math in school. When your mind is in a different world 90% of the time, real life math doesn't make sense.
As a writer myself, I just really cannot be bothered. I already have to pretend to be a sociologist, economist, linguist, geologist, biologist, psychologist, historian and architect on top of being a good writer (plus engineer, chemist and physicist if we're talking scifi), and math is really the last thing I want to worry about. I'm not a big fan of large inaccuracies either and will do my best to do adequate research, but researching for a fantasy or scifi world is such a tedious work, it's easy to miss something at some point, or be lazy with something because the work just doesn't end.
I blame American education. Some parts of math are really fun and feel like puzzles, but nobody's going to see them that way if you have to rote memorize them
@@Saga_Anserum I wouldn't blame the american education specifically because i have never been in the US and still suck at math. But yes, math isn't really taught in a way that helps those who struggle.
I could memorize the formulas and maths that had to do with geometry since it reminded me of art and shapes, but everything else? Nope. It felt like a different language. I caught and memorized some things and got a vague idea of the topic but didn't really understand the language.
@@oceanmythjormundgandr3891
I know some other countries also do rote memorisation stuff, I just don't wanna call them out because I haven't experienced them personally. I straight up don't even remember most of my math classes, except when I had a foreign exchange teacher for my precalc class.
I'm gonna try to think about the shapes as art things now
@@Saga_AnserumThat's not really a fault of the education system. Some people are going to dislike math no matter what you do and with everything on top of writing the book, inconsistencies like these are easy to miss
"How does Catra work?"
Simple.
Cat.
Cat is always the answer.
this is the opposite logic of warrior cats
1. The moon constantly being full in ATLA. The most popular theory is that Yue is both new to being the moon while also helping the waterbenders, and I think that’s great.
2. The Maw looking different when you play as Six vs when you play as the Runaway Kid in the DLC. I don’t understand how it changes seemingly so fast, but I also don’t care that much.
On 1, anybody who has seen overanalyzing avatar knows this.
For two I think that’s primarily because Seven and Six are kind of on different parts of the maw! (It’s a really massive place after all) with the two having only a a little over lap in terms of placement
Ok the fan theories about number 1 is cool but I wished it was addressed in the canon. Does nobody notice how the moon is full more often?
@@fruity4820 I mean it's not too big of a deal, but it is VERY weird.
I see this “cats don’t meow at each other” thing going around the internet, and I must say, I have taken care of MANY cats, and observed them in different environments. They absolutely do. Like, loudly. They stop and stare at each other and meow constantly, either conversationally or aggressively.
It’s mostly cats that were born feral that don’t meow, I’m pretty sure.
Cats meow to communicate with their mothers as babies and if they are raised by humans they keep that behavior and also meow at humans and other cats. But really feral cats without any human contact rarely ever meow. It is basically baby babbling for them. Just like baby stop to babble and start to speak, cats stop to meow and communicate in a different way. But nowadays baby babble is useful for them so they keep it.
As others have said, cats raised by humans keep the meowing. They know we respond to it, so it becomes part of their communications with humans and cats alike. Feral cats, meanwhile, mostly stop meowing when they grow up.
Yours meow because you raised them / had contact with them.
@@katherinesmallbean3594 when I say “different environments” I mean it. I’m talking about feral street cats who hiss and run away when a human gets near, cats in human frequented areas, cats in dark alleyways, in the mountains along basically deserted trails. (Because that is a totally normal thing for a normal person to do lol)
It’s like humans yelling at each other, it might not have any words but there is a point trying to be made
"However, I am not a wise person." was probably the best line to end this on
The main family tree in Once Upon A Time…it’s bordering on a wreath…we don’t talk about it in fanfics and the fandom in general-
(also the timeline…😭)
I'm watching once upon a time right now. I'm in the middle of season 4 and I have already given up on trying to figure out the timeline
@@dandelionhood4508 Yeah you just gotta stop at one point or another
The complexity of the family tree is my favorite part lol. But the timeline is indeed a mess, their biggest mistake was giving us any numbers sorrunding the dark one, it's not that hard to crunch out those numbers and realize that the life expectancy of the average Dark One is awfully low for a being that has op dark magic powers and can only be hurt by one specific magical knife
Rumple manages to show up in everyone's story. like the biggest things that happened prior to the present day he's either directly or indirectly played a part in. ok "the power of the dark one" might cover some of that but the timing of where and when he shows up i'm guessing is on the list of things that complicate the timeline for those that try to fully examine it.
Also the writing prioritising certain characters over others (snow white and charming kept being focused on meaning they had to come up with dumb plot reasons to have them around) really hurt the show more and more with each new season
Whenever I write Pokemon fanfics and I have to deal with people's houses I always have to add extra rooms. There's no way Arven grew up in a lighthouse with no restroom! There's no storage space in that building either! So I added a back hallway where the entryway is obscured by one of the heavy bookshelves.
Also there's a multiverse and people KNOW there's a multiverse and nobody ever brings it up?
I literrally did the exact same thing for my Pokemon fanfic. Even if this was about a fangame, the rooms still felt off. Poor kid didn't even ad a room !!!
Pokemon towns are incredibly tiny too, like plenty of them have less than 10 buildings. So at least the lack of rooms is consistent logic in-universe lol
I swear there's no toilets in the Pokémon franchise, like at all it's so strange.
@@Cinnamonraisin_Bagel I don't think there are bathrooms in general either??
@@checkerhat327 I honestly can't think of an example what's kinda strange like why hide Bathrooms of all things
3:54 Okay, some of this is fair, some of this isn't. She canonically aged more slowly as a tree, this is directly brought up and the third book took place the winter following the second, not a whole year later.
Yes! Also, they didn't mention the main thing I noticed in the books --- Nico's age does not line up with other characters/timeline. In the titans curse, he is 10 and Percy is 14. In the trials of Apollo, he is ~15 and Percy is 17. So he aged 5 years in 3.
I was about to say that! thank you!
@@rachel6239Hum, another reason to highly suspect the Trials of Apollo saga was written by a ghost writer because of how bad it is. If i could uncanonize that shit, i would.
@rachel6239 Percy's birthday is late summer, and Nico's birthday is unconfirmed as far as I know so it may just be that
@emanuelborges4458 Oh I definitely have in my own head. Everything with Jason and Piper alone was enough for me to do that.
In almost any otome manwha the “that’s not how corsets work” or “that’s not how fashion works” or “why is everyone with their hair down in a setting akin to the Victorian Period?!” are frequent
In HP I think it would’ve been more hilarious if Mr. Weasley asked Harry something about muggles no 12 year old boy would know. Mr. Weasley assumes that just because Harry grew up Muggle, that he’d know about every aspect of Muggles.
Something that’s so far out of the realm of knowledge for a kid to know kind of stuff.
Not that I disagree, but some examples would be nice.
@@fictionfan0 Like Mr. Weasley took a computer and Harry wouldn't know what it is considering the Dursleys wouldn't let him use it.
"You're a muggle, right?"
"Yeah"
"Might I ask something?"
"Sure?"
"How exactly does a quantum computer work?"
"I have always been very curious at how exactly you muggles managed to create the nuclear bomb. Would you mind explaining it for me?"
Easy example: how a tube television works. CRTs would still be very much the norm at the time the books take place, right?
Though on the subject of the year given for the Potters' death in Book 7, do I remember correctly that it makes a) Bonfire Night the same week as Halloween that year, in contradiction to the broadcast in Book 1, and b) make Dudley's PlayStation an anachronism? It's been awhile since I read the series.
As a warrior cats fan and fnaf fan and Harry potter fan and- let’s just say we would be here all day if I were to say any wrong logic with my fandom that I have to ignore lol
Yeah, like the FNAF timeline. How does it make sense realistically that William Afton's arms are that far apart from his torso?? And how does the flesh wrap around springlocks even if they are *in the middle of a limb* how did it get there? And how does the suit arms of Endo 1 stay on without falling off? Does it float??? And William did NOT die during 1993. That is when FNAF 1 took place. He most likely died in 1994-1998 MAYBE 1999. And why does FNAF 3 take place in 2024-2028 have a NEWSPAPER at the end??? EVERYTHING IS VIRTUAL!! And the handprints on Freddy Fazbear are BOTH RIGHT HANDS!!
Scott needs to make that cash some how@@Raviolling
@@Raviollingwait I thought fnaf 3 took place in 2023?
@@Raviollingalso I’m 99% sure newspapers still exist
@@The_lamb_sauce no, it doesn't really make sense. It would be more realistic to take place in the mid to late 90's, I love your PFP btw
im a splatoon fan. there arent too many gripes i have, but here they are.
splatfests take place over how much time in canon? a night? three nights?
how much water does it take for an inkfish to die? can rain kill them? what about a shower?
what happened to the octarians who heard the inkantation who werent octolings? where did they go?
I just wonder about how ink warfare works. Does it contain some sort of acid/enzyme that only targets those with a different color? We know it can harm vertebrate life like Grizz and Salmonids. Does the ink also corrode stage materials like wood or concrete? Did people actually die in the great turf war? Now we have spawners but perhaps military-grade weapons would destroy the souls of inklings and octolings, or maybe spawners weren’t invented. How does a killer wail or pearl’s voice relate to ink? How would actual kinetic weaponry like bullets or just a hammer affect an inkling? What do the adults do? Are turf war/ranked viable career paths? We know they pay money, so maybe there’s professional college and adult turf leagues like with human sports, but we only play as young inklings who have the time to play simply for fun and thus don’t see those.
@@broce8126 very true! i was kinda just listing off what i could think of off the top of my head, but these are also things i think about a lot.
Uggh the water think has always bothered me in splatoon. Like what do these guys drink? Why is water the only liquid that seems to affect them?
Also how it seems they literally created resurrection devices??? Like it's heavily implied the little ghost that comes out when your character dies IT'S YOUR ACTUAL SOUL and that you straight up die without the spawn.
So you're supposed to tell me these kids straight up DIE in every turf war but just come back like nothing??? LIKE HELLO???
I always think about how the idols can constantly sing and dance for days straight without getting tired during splatfests, and also do news reports
Honestly, I just chuck the water thing as more of a "they're terrible swimmers as a species" and that they don't actually implode when they come in contact with water, since they'd all get wiped out the moment it starts raining.
I consider the water explosion more of a gameplay thing (when you fall out of bounds and into water, instantly dying and respawning is much more convenient for game flow than your character waiting to be picked up by some rescue boat or something)
In the Gen 6 Pokémon games, Mega Evolution is established to be this awesome thing that can only be achieved through a trainer’s strong bond with their Pokémon. However, from a gameplay standpoint, you don’t need a strong bond with your Pokémon to Mega Evolve them; you just need the appropriate Mega Stone for their species. This is particularly egregious, since your Pokémon’s friendship and affection toward you is an actual game mechanic. To make things even more confusing, Gen 7 came along and added dex entries describing Mega Evolution as painful and miserable for Pokémon to go through. Obviously, the out-of-universe explanation for this is that the developers wanted to push Mega Evolution into the background to make room for their new mechanic, Z-Moves, but I’ve come up with a theory that makes the Mega Evolution lore make sense in-universe. I think Mega Evolution is just as wonderful as stated in Gen 6, but only if there is a truly strong bond between Pokémon and trainer. If a trainer forces Mega Evolution without that bond, it’s just as miserable and painful for the Pokémon as described in the Gen 7 dex entries.
I always theorised the gen 7 dex entries were to make players mortified so they could quietly take mega evolutions out, because they players wouldn't be as upset if it was a thing that potentially hurt the Pokémon. (though this is just a guess so take it was the biggest grain of salt you can muster)
@@Cinnamonraisin_BagelThey could have just said "oh it only works in certain regions" instead
@Cinnamonraisin_Bagel Yeah, that’s what I think too. They wanted to get Mega Evolution out of the way to make room for Z-moves, then Dynamax, and now Terastallization. I just felt like coming up with an explanation that would make sense in the world of the games too. “Because the author wanted to write them out,” wouldn’t be an accepted explanation for a real-world phenomenon, and I wanted something that the characters could make sense of as well.
@@BJGvideosLike they did literally two generations later with Sword and Shield
For the gen 7 painful megas thing, while it wasn't truly explained, i like to imagine it's because z moves don't require any sort of bond between the trainer and pokemon, and as such alolan people comparing the two stone based gimmicks just force mega evolution not knowing about the bond thing, hurting the pokemon. However that would make the "can only be achieved through a trainer and pokemons relationship" part bullshit so idk anymore
Honestly, the big thing I have to ignore when writing for the Simpsons fandom is the inaccurate way that the Springfield Nuclear Power Plant is portrayed. Nuclear power plants are actually one of the cleanest energy sources we have, and the "smoke" that comes out of them is actually water vapor. Your average nuclear power plant would not produce enough waste to mutate the fish in the rivers. And yet in the show, it's continuously portrayed as a massive source of pollution, on the verge of meltdown, and having casks of nuclear waste just out in the open where anyone can handle them. It's an artifact of the post-Chernobyl nuclear power paranoia that, as nuclear power becomes more and more necessary due to the realities of climate change, I think we should leave in the 1990s.
I primarily write Mr. Burns x Smithers fanfics, so I have to write about the SNPP often- and when I write about it, I try to portray it in a more realistic and neutral light than the overwhelmingly negative way that it's portrayed on the show.
To be fair, while I trust nuclear power, I wouldn't trust the Springfield plant one bit. We've seen how terribly it's run, and when they tried to bring in advisors who actually knew what they were doing (that German crew for instance) they basically quit in disgust.
Honestly I'm willing to bet it's Mr Burns' evil presence and the employee's general incompetence that makes the power plant the way that it is
They actually lampshade that in one of the episodes of the newer seasons.
Basically Mister Burns points out that nuclear power plants are actually environmentally friendly and that the new rich character (Smiters boyfriend), despite being nicer, is WAY more evil than him because he works in fast fashion.
Nah Mr burns would make the plant and its waste less safe on purpose
I mean, most of that can be chalked up to Mr. Burns being a penny-pinching old coot.
The sorting into school houses in Harry Potter is not only depicted in the books themselves as being a tradition that not everyone is 100% pleased with, but is in fact based on a real life aspect of British-influenced education systems, particularly in boarding schools where the need for something to substitute for family has (at least historically) been significant.
But yeah, the wizards' ignorance of "Muggle" behavior was definitely written in for the comedic opportunities rather than any actual logic of how life as we know it would seem to an outsider community, despite all the other opportunities for legit satire J.K. Rowling did go for. Like, the people in the community where the first self-defense they learn is "the disARMing charm," which is "expeliARMis" can't understand where the "arm" in "firearms" comes from?
I believe Professor McGonagall is the one who doesn't like it and wishes that they wouldn't sort the kids so young. Throughout the movies, you can see kids who have traits more fitting for different houses than the one they replaced it. Percy Weasley is when the great examples of this because a lot of people said he should’ve been in Slytherin, especially in the later movies where he basically just up in abandoned family because he his family was holding him back.
@@madisonyomans9004 Well, it's actually Dumbledore who says "Sometimes I think we sort too young" (in a pensieve memory in Book 7) but yes, good points.
"Biology doesn't work that way" is the new winner for the most frightening sentence I've ever read
in The Vampire Diaries, the first episode, Damon has a bunch of cool powers including possessing? a crow, and summoning fog, which is promptly never mentioned again after he uses it for a creepy entrance. (Guess who has a fic where Damon only shows up as a crow for like the first 7 chapters...)
Never even watched The Vampire Diaries but I'm now more interessted than I would have ever thought lol
Dude that's such a cool concept, I aspire to make connections like that!!
It's more mentioned in the books but does get dropped after a while too iirc
the timeline for Lego Ninjago is an absolute disaster. It's never clearly told what goes where chronologically, and the ages of both Wu and Garmadon are heavily in debate as being hundreds or thousands of years old because we don't know when the serpentine war happened.
I was looking for someone to say Ninjago!! Stuck with the show since its earliest days, but mannnnnnn they had more plot holes than sound storyline sometimes. It's gotten a lot better with the new team and soft reboots lately, but even now they're still struggling to clean up the timeline and canon mess created by the early seasons.
How old are the ninja at any given time? We just don't know! How much time passes during or between seasons? And this one's just a minor one that bugs me, but why the hell does Jay have a different accent to Ed and Edna? Accents aren't genetic! They come from the environment around you! Jay should have a Midwestern accent
@miraculousmoonsanddragons yep! Confirmed vaguely to be teenagers at several points, but where in their teens? Who knows! Also new nightmares unfold any time the show does try to say exactly how many years passed between events, because then you end up with things like "Ninjago advanced from medieval vibes to sentient computer programs....in 10 years," or "welp, 40 years have passed. Wu, you're like 100 years older now. Misako, Krux, you aged 40 years, good job. Ray, Maya, you haven't aged AT ALL. Cool guys, strong work."
YES, having watched up till Master of the mountain, ninjago is quite lierally superemely inconssitent! They always say "before time had a name", but what does that even mean!??! It began innocently enough with kai somefucking how considering the serpentine a myth despite his parents having fought them, but it got worse and worse! We got more and more lore, and we learned that garmadon was what, middle aged, at the time when the serpentine war happened. So did they go from ninjago being a brand-new continent to it being a technologically advanced civilization in sixty years? Maybe a hundred? And don't get me started on all the different lore they added later on, the realms and time travel and the omi!?!I love the series but worldbuilding isn't it's strong suit
My context for the story is entirely based on old memes and the movie game (I picked it up during a free weekend years ago and played through it a month or two ago.)
The amount of times I unlocked someone and went "I have no idea who this is" or made fun of characters' actions was... immense.
In canon warrior cats and in fanfiction cat genetics are nonexistent. Makes for some interesting and fun designs though.
Not inaccurate per say, but how EVERYONE just constantly falls in love with ash lynx and... *Checks notes* wants to assault him??
Hey, what is love if not the sensation of wanting to hug the other person and strangle them at the same time?
@@fictionfan0 Oh, no. They want to s3xually assault ash. but your idea is nicer
Man, Ash Lynx is one of the most unlucky and depressing characters I have seen in my life... I guess it isn't inaccurate, I am sure there are people with lives as horrible as Ash.
one thing that makes me cry is the fact that, I watched Banana Fish when I was 16, I'm about to turn 21, I'm older than Ash, and the fact that there are people that want to do nasty things with Ash, who is still a god damn minor (or 18, but is still so young)
Oh boy, I've never heard about this manga before but i can tell with with absolute certainty Ao3 is having fun with this.
This is just a minor thing, but in Regular Show, it's shown that Rigby is allergic to eggs because of the coma he goes into during the eggcellent challenge in season one. Then in season six (I think?) he's shown drinking raw eggs out of a blender as he trains for the pull-up episode.
Honestly it just made me headcanon that Rigby faked going into a coma because he knew that Mordocai would win the hat for him, because as messed up as that is.. it's 100% something season one Rigby would do.
To be fair, that is definitely something Rigby would do to get the hat during that time. However, the doctors would have called him out on it about not been allergic to eggs unless he paid the doctors or something. Instead of him being allergic to eggs, you could have said he fell into a coma due to some food or something. it would tie better with the end of the episode where he sees another food related challenge. and everybody in the room was basically like if we take the hat off of him, would we go back into a coma?w
but I do like your head canon get props to Rigby for faking being in a coma for that long.
I thought it was due to the challenge itself.....
My favorite series ever is a Call of Cthulhu campaign run by my beloved, niche, D&D podcast, Just Roll With It. Set in 1984, the three main characters were childhood best friends who lost contact with each other after they graduated in 1969, but met again nearly two decades later because they never finished the D&D campaign that they used to play in high school.
D&D wasn’t actually invented until 1974, so there is no way they could have been playing it before they graduated, but shhhhhhhh don’t think about it too hard
It's a world with cosmic horrors, maybe DnD was invented earlier to help people cope with the horrors
holy shit blood in the bayou mention?????
blood in the bayou mention!!
bitb!!! hell yeah!!!
When you say "set in 1984" do you mean set in the same world as the book "1984", or set in the actual year of 1984?
The one thing that wasn’t said about the Riordanverse inaccuracies is the characters’ cannon heights. Most of the boys are 6’0” Annabeth is 5’9”, Leo is 5’6” Frank is 6’3” Hazel is 5’3” and Nico is 5’6.5”. Not to mention that Leo is canonically the same height as a SEVEN YEAR OLD GIRL. I have an OC for the Riordanverse, but the thing is: I’m 5’1.5”. My character is 5’2” and my personal head cannon is that the gods give their kids the tall genes and my OC just got VERY unlucky.
That’s not an inconsistency tho
That’s called being a short king
@@zaynab-to-a it is an inaccuracy though, I do know about you, but I’ve never seen a 5’6” seven year old girl
@@isabelwonders8711 ohhh yeah that’s weird. What character in PJO is the same height as Leo?
@@zaynab-to-a Georgina, Em and Jo's adopted daughter
I only count inaccuracies that contradict how something is stated to work within a series, cause in works of fiction, sometimes people just arbitrarily draw the line of what is and isn't reasonable. As someone who recently got into dragon ball, it's like someone saying "How does Goku fly? That makes no sense!" like the guy can't cup his hands and fire a beam of energy capable of destroying the planet a few thousand times over. Unless it was specifically stated that they can't do that, then they can, _especially_ in nebulous power systems.
Your example kinda makes me esp mad because goku is based off one of the most op deities in mythology, so if anything goku is Nerfed 😭
OKAY!!! MIRACULOUS TIMELINE:
In season 1, the cast is in 10th grade.
In season 3, Marinette turns 14, implying the cast is in EIGHTH GRADE
But in sesson 5, it is revealed they are in NINETH GRADE!!!!
Oh yeah no that's just a retcon that not a lot of people are happy with
Don't forget that those five seasons took place over a single year on top of that
@@Asexual_Individual *9 months 😮
@@Asexual_IndividualOH YEAH!!! these kids grades getting mixed up every few months then.
Also are Luka and Juleka twins or not? Are they 16 or 14?
Show: Yes, but also no.
And speaking of twins, let's not forget about Chloe's "Irish Twin". LOL XD
I was gonna comment about Batman/Batfam because trying to find a coherent timeline/character ages for all their bs is impossible ... so like seemingly most of the fandom, I pick and choose what I want where to cobble together a storyline that makes *some* sense
Then resetting everything every 3 months doesn’t help
I like what Lego Batman did and just had him go through wild and random phases to explain his different incarnations
it's because of the constant retcons and reboots of the DC Universe tbh. you literally can't track the entire history of ANY of DC's characters because of this. lots of stuff just gets completely wiped from existence, altered or retconned, takes place on an alternate Earth, etc. DC even acknowledges how convoluted their universe is and how their isn't an actual canon timeline because of it, which is why they decided to make their canon more fluid by merging all of the timelines into one and making all past and current continuities canon simultaneously via The Omniverse. now DC and their writers don't have to worry about how they don't actually have a set canon timeline for everything, and fans can pick and choose what they like and what they don't. personally that's how i engage with all of my fandoms anyway, not just comics, so i for one love this approach and think it's a genius way to solve DC's canon timeline issues.
yes 💀💀 i cant tell if bruce wayne is like damn near 80 or in his mid forties. i dont know if im the only one confused by the ages of any given robin. esp i dont think theres a for sure date that any of the recent comics. assuming grayson was born in the 80s, that puts us in like 2000-2010 but then you throw jason todds resurrection clusterfuck and its like... what is happening
I tried making a family tree - Bruce has too many ancestors and I don’t know exactly how ANY of them are related but they’re all going in the dam tree
1:41 okay as a warrior cat fan thats just being picky. like, yeah, the highly humanized cats with a concept of religion, medicine, and goverment make choices, shocker. also, not all queens that stay in the nursery keep having kits, Goldenflower (arc 1 until mid arc 2) stayed a nursery queen after her second litter left, to help raise other queens' kits. Daisy (Arc 2 onwards) is a recongised permenant queen who has an entire side thing (Daisy's Kin) that ends in the cats she's helped raise thanking her for her job. and yeah, the medicine cats take vows of chastity, their doctor nuns. Warrior Cats is written like tiny humans in cat fur.
Also, technically an apprentice has had kits before, Scorchfur of Shadowclan in Arc 3, but that was due to a timeline consistency issue because the warriors writers have admitted to using the fandom wiki as their lore bible.
if you wanna talk about cat biology in warrior cats, why dont they constantly have worms? they are never described removing the GI tract of animals they eat, and they eat meat raw, they almost certainly should have worms. And the fleas, there is no reason the elders should constantly have fleas, not only are those bad for their health, it would also spread to everyone else immediately. the heat thing is a fair point, but yeah, kids book. also european badgers are almost entirely docile and are not like the american-esque ones portrayed in the books. and theres only been 1 deaf blue eyed white furred kit in the entire series, even though theres been at least a dozen blue eyed white furred cats before and since Snowkit, and genetically a least a few of them would be deaf.
sorry for the wall of text but i've put 8 years of my life into this fandom and i know far too much about it
I recently got into MASH (the series) and boy, the timeline. It takes place in the Korean war, which took place in 1950-53, HOWEVER the series has 11 seasons. The fandom jokes about time loops, and the general horrors of war. I'm not angry about this, I just find it kinda funny.
Main dude somehow had a modern day smartphone in the early 2000's??? Like huh????
This is the opposite of what's going on in ace attorney, where the characters are still using flip phones in the year 2028
3:56 Aliens and humans must have a common ancestor. Maybe someone abducted cavemen to or from various planets to spread the supply of organ doners.
Different species cannot reproduce together, that is the definition of a species. Chimpanzees and humans too have a common ancestor, but good luck having a child with one. The same biology should technically apply to aliens as well.
The Persona 5 one is just straight-up incorrect--the dates do, in fact, match up with the 2016 calendar. That's why the general fandom consensus is that it takes place in 2016 in the first place.
I was confused with that "wait didnt they not give us the year, but people math'd out from the dates we have?"
The OP also complaining about having to write around the year, don't worry bud so did Atlus. The canon year is 20XX. Even in Q2, they say "well we don't know what year it is but it ain't 2014!"
I’m writing a FNAF fanfiction… my agony knows no bounds
I wrote a (no joke) novel of a fanfic. At the time, there were only four games. Four years later (when I finished), we got like three more.
I basically kept the story based around the first three games (with the AU element that the Springtrap suit was found empty because I wanted the murderer alive) and kept to them, and only added elements from later games where I could fit them without derailing the story (i.e., Security Puppet's costume became main!Puppet's costume to show a time skip because main!Puppet got disassembled, then fixed, the OG owner had a circus theme planned as a potential sister location that never happened, Afton Robotics got a mention as a rival company that folded offscreen, etc.)
Me, too! Eventually I decided to stop complying with canon and just take it completely off the rails. If they’re not going to play by their own rules, neither will I.
@@Blackplaaague fr. Eventually I just decided “Canon is dead. It’s always been dead. Don’t question it.”
@@BlackplaaagueBro for fucking truth. My AU is primarily Security Breach-based so I’m no stranger to… let’s say stretching the canon to make things a lot less stupid, but it was around the time the books came out and just dumped all sorts of bullshit lore that took a wrecking ball to my carefully constructed narrative that I just decided to say “fuck it” and just split it off into my own AU.
I thought it was really weird when Buckbeak hurt a student and the school's reaction was to take him from Hagrid and have him put down, yet in the first book/movie, Hogwarts punished Harry and Draco by having them go into a dark forest that they know is dangerous. Hogwarts likes to pick and choose when they care about their students' safety.
Also the house points system.
It’s so inconsistent and has a lot of plot armor, that people make memes about it (my personal favorite being the Mean Girls reference).
That wasn't the school; Draco's father - who works in the government - was specifically spitefully trying to kill Buckbeak just to be cruel.
(In general, though, the school is not a safe place and Buckbeak's trial was obviously very stupid, but it wasn't put on by the school.)
There are a lot of fandoms where the canon age is very obviously drawn out of a hat. Like Sonic. You could tell me he’s fourteen or twenty-five and I’d believe you, because it doesn’t matter. Someone just scribbled down random ages in the Sonic Heroes manual one time, with only a base logic for all their ages relative to each other, and we’ve all treated it as gospel ever since. Some fandoms, the only reason characters are teens are because the creator wanted to write stock school scenes.
To be fair, Sonic has always been stated to be a teenager.
I don't know if this applies to this, but one thing that bothered me about Steven Universe was the characters' resistance levels: for example, apparently Peridots are very resistant, to the point where a giant rock would fall on them and they wouldn't crack or poof, but it was quickly poofed by Garnet about 2 seasons ago, when the pearl was pierced for the first time, she still resisted and spoke to Steven for about 5 seconds, but Bismuth spent more than 10 seconds talking to Steven, and in the " false" shattering of the Pink Diamond itself is instantly poofed by the rose's sword, so I ask myself, how come a diamond is less resistant than a bismuth?
Pink Diamond wanted to be poofed in that particular instance. I could see a gem being able to hang on a little longer if they really wanted to, especially when they're war veterans like Pearl and Bismuth. Peridot's newfound resistance is pretty much rule of funny though. I guess you could argue that being merged with her limb enhancers made her easier to poof, but the show never states that.
I agree
I'm not an expert on metals but something that immediately stuck out to me was Bismuth's ability to swim in lava. Irl bismuth has a melting point so low that you can melt it on your stove.
I did have a headcannon that gem weapons and piercing objects do cause a gem to poof, because gem weapons are made to fight other gems, and piercing weapons can puncture a gem's form, like a needle to a balloon. Meanwhile, blunt objects dont cause that same effect. Amethyst had her gem cracked from falling on a rock because her gem was exposed, which is a weak spot for any gem, but peridot's gem was fine cause she has a visor protecting her gem.
@@anothermiddleschoolburnout8816 i did recall a video saying that a gem's gem isnt actually made out of the same material they name themselves, otherwise lapis would've dissolved her gem ages ago from summoning her wings. its most likely just named after coloration/shape
My first fandom was star wars. I was so used to having a beautiful timeline (even if it was insane) that canon/legends fans already had made that transitioning to disney cartoons drove me nuts. GRAVITY FALLS’ TIMELINE IS NONSENSE!
Why? They got the infinite summer syndrome but other than that it was pretty ok with the timeline
Someone said Ash is 10 years old always and this. I agree. Because... The fact that the Sun and Moon anime is the way it is makes Ash staying 10 make no sense!! Because of Kukui and Burnet.
Within the series, they were friends that started to have romantic feelings for each other, then Kukui proposed to Burnet and they got married. This was the same episode. Now you could argue this could have happened within the same week or month.
AND THEN sometime between that wedding episode and possibly the Ultra Beast episodes, they had sex because the end of the Sun and Moon series reveals Burnet is pregnant. It looks like she may be 5 months pregnant there?
THEN ASH VISITS THEM IN JOURNEYS AND NOT ONLY IS THE BABY BORN, BUT HE LOOKS LIKE HE'S ABOUT 5 MONTHS TO A YEAR OLD!!
yet Ash is somehow still the same age.
So like, realistically, 2-3 years should have passed.
To say nothing of how anniversaries are celebrated. That one short where Ash celebrates the anniversary of meeting Pikachu comes to mind.
It's just using a floating timeline, it's a basic narrative device tons of series use. Very useful.
It's like detective Conan. Even if each case just magically lasted a day that guy should have been at least in middle school.
For the Miraculous Ladybug one, the events are not exactly put in a timeline. The Christmas specials are not even considered canon for the most part, as they're not referenced almost anywhere in the rest of the series, besides the literal one shot from one of them appearing in a different episode.
Season 1 has basically no timeline and you can usually put most episodes into any order, as it's just the show getting its footing and also being an extremely episodic show. Season 2 and 3 mostly solve this issue, although they still don't have complete consistency, but Season 4 onward, all episodes come one after another.
Anytime a historical setting, fiction or otherwise has something that shouldn't exist yet, I affectionately call it, "Chocolate in King Author's Court."
I like that!
Freddy vs Jason
The separate series established that Freddy lives in Ohio and Jason lives in New Jersey
But somehow in the crossover, the kids drive an unconscious Jason from Springwood to Crystal Lake in what seems to be a matter of minutes.
Ohio to New Jersey is a minimum 9 hour drive assuming light traffic. Even longer because Crystal Lake is on the coast
i read a lot of my hero academia fics, and there is one main thing that annoys me for some odd reason:
midoriya’s height.
istg, he ain’t that short- and when they compare him to bakugo, he might as well be the height of an ant 💀
11:45 Hylian vs Hyrulean, there are also two seperate official timelines that either add or remove a Link depending on which one you prefer. Also the manga are soft canon, if they don't contradict the games, it's canon. For the timeline I say the less Links for the games, more Links for the manga
9:50 half gripe about the Harry Potter cannon, half gripe about the fandom
Squibs
Why are they treated like wizard-born-muggles when not only does "wizard with a learning disability" have way more canon evidence (Squibs can see dementors, there are claims of them using spells, the Quicky Spell manual) but it would also be an interesting way to take the concept? Just, more Squibs being used in general would have been nice
The whole "either you are born with magic or you are not" concept lost the appeal on me over time. Muggles can't even brew potions, even if they would study potions for years and do everything exactly as a wizard would when brewing the potion. No wonder there are barely any substantial muggles and Squibs characters, they can't do sh*t
Yeah, The way I see it, Squibs are just magically disabled.
Specifically, they cannot innately use _spells._ Other magic is fair game. The reason they're treated as "wizard-born-muggles" is because the Greenwich area, canonically, only looks for _Accidental Spell Casting._ Something that, by nature, Squibs cannot do.
I have a crossover fic centering on a Squib whose gifted at magic contracts and seersight (not prophesies; he sees different paths the future could take), but his bio parents rejected him due him being a Squib, and then his magic developed in his teens.
He was on track to become an engineer, as his lack of spell casting meant he could safely build and operate both magic and muggle tech
@@fruity4820 That concept especially doesn't make sense when you consider how some mages are able to use magic that others can't; for example, Tonk's Metamorphism or Seers
Not to mention how one mage can be terrible at one type of magic yet brilliant at another can bring the "all-or-nothing" concept into question.
So yeah, doesn't make sense to me either
The birthday one reminded me of the Mob Psycho 100 fandom's gripes with Inukawa's birthday, wich is supposed to be on leap day, except he was born in a non-leap year 💀
One inacuaccy in Pokemon is that Lugia is a Psychic/Flying type despite it being a sea god.
It didn't originate *from* the sea. It came to the sea to hide its power.
And Palkia is a water type.
@@BJGvideosOkay, but it has water bending.
@@BJGvideosLugia is only psychic type because the developers wanted him to feel more powerful. If Lugia was introduced in a later gen, he would be the correct typing of Water and Flying.
Lugia is based on Ryujin, a Shinto sea god and it's shiny is based on Ryujin's palace. The original creator, Takeshi Shundo, for Lugia created it with ocean symbolism in mind as the 2nd movie shows(it was supposed to be anime only).
Its 40 day storms feat is based on the 40 day storm that flooded the world in Christain mythology(which includes water, not pychic).
Part of it's name origin could come from beluga, deluge(to flood), and/or Lutiya(old name for Bahamut, and was orginally described as a giant fish).
It's not a sea god, it just has a lot of water-related abilities and went to live in/near the ocean. Kyogre is the sea god.
15:00 I took one glance at the DC comics and immediately knew not to try and make sense of the timeline. Saved me a lot of headaches 😂
i'm in most of these fandoms myself,but i'd like to give my own: in the Star Wars fandom, pretty much everything.
that she-ra comment was quite obnoxious. Some of their points were valid but by the time they got to "How can this cartoon hero jump so high" I was like "Shut up already, if you don't like fiction, don't watch fiction."
I actually recognize the author, so I wanted to say: they like fiction. They like it a lot. Almost too much. That is the author of World War Etheria, a 540,000 word epic with more worldbuilding than you could ever dream of. They're not nitpicking, they're just the second coming of Tolkien.
@@BookWyrmOnAString Even being Tolkien himself would not absolve them of being so nitpicky. Questioning "Why can this character jump so high?" without having enough awareness to realize said character is named CATra and is a CAT-human hybrid is just plain dumb. You might not like the explanation the show gives you, but the fact of the matter is that there IS an explanation for it, and it's that cats are famously acrobatic and CAN jump up several times their own body height, just like Catra does. In the end, that's what "suspension of disbelief" is for, things don't have to follow real life logic so long as they're internally consistent, so for a cartoon aimed at children/younger teens it's completely reasonable to say "This character can do the stuff a cat can do because they're half-cat, even if they look mostly human".
The way they talk about it, it really sounds like they're full of themselves and come from a place of "Nobody knows how to do proper world building except for myself"
@@dokchampa9324 Exactly. Plus with the whole going toe to toe with she ra thing, whilst i do also find it annoying can easily be explained by the fact that catra and adora have a personal conflict, of course they need to fight and adora can't just win every battle with ease, that would be boring. I do get the confusion with spinerella and netossa though. Most of what they say in the comment doesn't need to be explained in detail.
Anachronisms, or when something from the present exists in the past, even if that didn't existed yet at the time. I often go to fandoms that are set in fantasy settings, some of them also setting in the past. I see them everywhere. Sometimes, it's just very minor things, like when Greed, a character from FMAB, an anime which is set in 1914, was wearing modern sunglasses. That can easily be ignored. But Natsu, a character from Fairy Tail, an anime which was set in X793, using what appear to be a modern cellphone ? Not so much.
There are precursors to modern sunglasses too, so the sunglasses thing could probably be explained away well enough anyway, if you wanted to bother doing it
Sometimes they can be used just for comedy, which I don't mind. Usually it's better when it doesn't line up with a real timeline (E.x. a generic fantasy world where someone uses a cellphone is more acceptable than someone eating a modern-style candy car in something set in the 1740's.)
Tbf, the sunglasses is part of the Tiffany Problem when it comes to fantasy or sci fi (tldr: when something seems too modern despite having properly existed within that time, example namer Tiffany for example was in use as a name as far back as the 12th century). BUT i assuming you meant the aesthetic of said glasses, which judging from the few ads I could find from the 1920s, look more like those ancient Chinese glasses than the trends at the time. The sunglasses I saw were round, rested on the bridge of the nose, and covered the whole eye. Not the smaller ones that seem to be fashion like Greeds eyewear. Maybe it was intentional? It is an alternate timeline, so I guess something happened that sunglasses trends became different?
From what I remember, Fairy Tail cellphones were improved versions of communication lacrimas (they were showed as crystal balls for most of the series). And honestly, given that FT has trains, what's basically magic-fueled cars, guns, cameras and live TV, I don't think that a magical cellphone is unrealistic, no matter what number the author chose to use as a year. It may kill the vibe, but unrealistic? Nah
@@Ilit015 Your comment is yet another proof that i don't know crap about Fairy Tail despite watching it, thank you very much for clarifiying.
The legend of Zelda one is so true! I just don't mention what timeline it's supposed to be and mush things together anyway 😅
Also we have two time goddesses but they're also just one time goddess who split herself into sisters because one of them turned hot for Link and somehow this made her evil, but we're not supposed to talk about them because they're not canon
Ikr??
I had no clue the Sonic cast were all TEENAGERS???? I assumed they were just that vague adult vibes like a lot of video game characters
Cuphead’s DLC has two bosses that take place during the same day, the Moonshine Mob and the Howling Aces. The Moonshine Mob is a gang of bootleggers that worked during Prohibition times, which ended 1934. The Howling Aces use a specific Allied Military Phonetic Spelling (taking the first letter of each word to be more understood through radio) used in 1939 in their death quote
WoF sizing is so inconsistent. Sometimes dragons are the size of whales, sometimes they're not much bigger than a large horse
I'm a Murder Drones fan.
Disassembly Drone (and Solver Drone by extension) wings would _not_ fit inside their torsos. Even if you assume that the reason N didn't have any lasting damage other than malfunctioning optics (that lasted all of maybe 15-25 minutes in-canon until J slapped him) when Uzi literally blew his head off is because everything intangible (memories, personality traits, etc) is stored in the core and their torsos are completely empty otherwise (which they physically can't be since there do need to be connections to everything), their wings are just simply too long to be able to only fold at the visible joints and fit inside. The longest of the 'feathers' is literally almost twice the length of their torso.
And that's not even mentioning there being no visible holes in their clothing for the wings to fit through. They just kinda appear on top. Even if you assume that the nanites repair their clothes as well when they pull the wings back in (they repaired N's hair and hat in the pilot, when we know that those are not attached), it would still result in them ripping their own clothing every time they extend their wings.
The way I usually end up explaining the wing size discrepancy for Disassembly Drones is to make it so the wings actually form from nanites when they extend them, and when they have them retracted they're basically just a liquid. That doesn't really explain it for Solver Drones though, given that Solver Drone wings appear to be organic ^^'
Yeah I've seen similar things happen in other shows as well but I let it go because it's animation so it doesn't have to make sense, plus it looks really cool. But yeah it makes no sense and definitely wouldn't work in real life
Murder Drones! :D
Ig its just magic, same as the DD's hand-swords
And this is why I just take everything and throw it in a blender. Keep the canon I like, discard the rest, add some fun headcanons and try to pull out *just* enough sense to suspend disbelief. Then again, I'm a little too good at believing any exposition the author feeds me so maybe my perspective's a bit skewed. Oh well
Sounds like my experience at building my own SCPF Canon (but without the suspension of disbelief stuff), albeit it's necessary, since it's a collective writing effort, some things will be contradictory.
As someone who makes Zelda X pokemon Fan fiction as a personal form to cope with capitalistic America since I was about 10
It feels nice to have a country government generally makes since.
That and most of the gym leader in concept actually make sense.
It's been 10 years since I've, and looking back on it I should have seen a therapist earlier, because I've learned how not to commit copyright infigment with my own ideas! Now I do bs with dragon, and messing around with spacetime continuum.
I'm a total drama fan and I basically have to ignore the entirety of all stars for the characters to even make sense after world tour, I'm pretty sure the entire old cast is derailed in all stars somehow what is both impressive and horrifying. Though at least it did Scott fairly well, he was pretty enjoyable and I'm one of the rare few who didn't absolutely hate his romance with Courtney (until it was ruined by the stupid cameron kissing Courtney drama.)
If I'm remembering correctly, warrior cats Bluestar's Prophecy opens with the main character being 2 days old and already able to talk in complex sentences. She also knows all about how clan life works and can identify pretty much everyone in the clan
To be honest some of these "this doesn't make sense" really just feels like the person posting this has no suspension of disbelief, like saying magic or superpowers are "illogical" is just ridiculous, like yeah? It's fiction? So long as the magic/superpowers are consistent in-universe then what's the problem?
Well, sometimes the problem isn't that there's no way they could think of it happening, but that no explanation was given for something that they think should be explained
@@PhoebeTheFairy56 if how it happens isn't needed to tell the story then we don't need an explanation. Like one person complained about the super human cat lady being able to jump high and cut through metal.
A girl getting turned into a tree doesn't age normally, shocking
I think every person has a different limit in their suspension of disbelief. I study biology and of something in fiction relating to biology is royally wrong I can't keep my suspension of disbelief up. I was a real problem for me a few years ago, but nowadays I am trying to be less "picky" about scientific inaccuracies, but some still get me angry lol
I think this may be a difference in suspension of disbelief vs verisimilitude. The former is the audience's willingness to accept a premise, while verisimilitude is the work's ability to uphold said premise. Let's take an example in, "this story is about dragons". Some people just can't suspend their disbelief on premise alone, which is fine, not everything is for everyone, but it's everything else that matters.
There are two types of ways verisimilitude is re-enforced, and that's from internal rules and external rules. Internal rules would be something like, "dragons need to ingest a steady supply of metal to keep their scales hale and hearty," so if the writer is inconsistent in how long it takes for the scales to become brittle from a metal deficit (two weeks for one, four months for another, and a year for yet another) with no plausible argument within the text itself, that's a failure to maintain internal verisimilitude.
External verisimilitude would be taking real-world knowledge and applying it to the story. Clearly dragons are not real, and we've already established this is part of the premise, so no rupturing of verisimilitude over the dragons just existing. But how are these dragons structured? If they're not purely magical beings like an elemental would be, then they're more like a beast. Enhancing verisimilitude would be extending the wing webbing down the length of their bodies to their tail for better lift when flying instead of having the webbing end at the hip like most depictions show. Rupturing verisimilitude would be having a dragon the size of a freight truck have its hunger satiated by a single mouse or squirrel. That thing's gonna need at least two sheep.
And then there's the tottering moments, where it just kinda makes sense in hindsight. The girl aged wonky as a tree? Hm, trees do age slowly, don't they?
10:40 Also, it's weird that Hermione, of all people, likes the smell of parchment. I get that she loves schoolwork, but she's very much the kind of person who'd be against skinning animals.
Danny Phantom once had Danny transform where his classmate (Wes) would have obviously seen him, so the fandom made it Fanon that he KNEW Danny was Phantom and constantly tries to convince everyone, but no one ever believes him
Two characters that can't touch, hugging despite the fact one of them would melt as a result.
Hehehehe
My “favorite” movie
Huh?
Melt???
The biggest fandom inaccuracy in the biggest fandom: Jesus is middle-eastern, but most depictions of him in art make him white
Most arabs have a tan skin which is technically on the white spectrum but not full on white.
I do agree that many depictions make him as white as European nobility but the color change is as minor as all the 007 actors differences.
Nah, it's saying He told them to hate people
From what I remember, the current popular depiction of Jesus was cemented by a Renaissance artist taking inspiration from his twink boyfriend.
@@ayyymacaroniI remember this and honestly it's the only valid excuse anyone could give for it
People see what they expect to see when perceiving the Lord. He has to filter your perceptions because the human brain isn't equipped to comprehend things from the divine realm outside of 4 dimensional spacetime. The only people who can come close are extremely intelligent and disciplined mathematicians and theoretical physicists, or the violently insane.
I am a Hetalian, there is literally a whole part of the fandom that tries to decipher what is happening historically and how to make it make more sense when the characters are immortal beings that exist just to represent a human concept that itself is complicated. I was part of this for some months and decided to give up, it's too complicated.
Not even talking about things that don't make too much sense because Hima forgot about something and fucked up the whole timeline or we have to research it and correct it to write fanfics. But well Hetalia is a comedy, not a history book.
The Fandom I read for is set in the late 1800’s there’s a lot of modern AUs but there will still be fics tagged “Canon-Era” and then say a character is wearing a hoodie, has modern electricity and appliances or use modern slang when they talk :| some of it irl okay with but seriously? It’s not that hard to know modern clothes didn’t exist in the 1890’s
Jack McCoy from Law & Order is the only prosecutor in the common law world who gets to make the final speech in a criminal trial. I know that's only scratching the surface of the legal inaccuracy in those shows, but that was always the thing that got me.
The tangled ball of yarn that is the Winx Club timeline...
so. The strongest they can possibly reach is Enchantix. They reach that. Then apparently there’s another one? And various more? And then there’s the whole subplot of the nemeses? And then WHAT THE HELL IS BLOOMIX??
@@L-ghtlessSky Thomas Vacaro explains it better, but I feel what they were originally going for was different transformations for different locations and situations. For example, Sirenix so they could go to the Infinite Ocean, Mythix for the Legendarium, etc.
Unfortunately, the way it was executed makes it seem like they were more powerful than the supposed “ultimate transformation”, rather than their own thing
@@L-ghtlessSkyalso as for Bloomix, it’s supposed to be Bloom giving the other girls a bit of the Dragon Flame after they had the rest of their magic stolen away. This also had questionable executions
@@cureidolsmile9820 Yeah, I understand it was like, different situations and ‘everyone else has lost their magic!!1!1!1!’ but why name it BLOOMIX. It could’ve been DRAGONIX. It could’ve been executed SO MUCH BETTER.
it is my opinion that winx peaked at that one girl who poisoned flora and made the vampire things with the trix.
Remember how Bloom used to be able to see people's souls? What happened to that? It was an awesome power.
the actual hellscape that is the sims timeline.
The first 3 sims games are all set around 25 years apart from each other, the order being Sims 3 --> Sims 1 --> Sims 2. With some characters appearing in multiple games, however the ages don't match up AT ALL especially not in comparison with each other. To make things worse every world in the sims 3 is on a slightly different timeline than the rest of them, ranging from 25 years before sims 1 to hundreds of years in the future with some being out only a couple years from each other (why 😭) If you can still get through all of that (including the xbox and extra sims 3 games which all also have timelines). U have the sims 4, which is on a COMPLETELY DIFFERENT TIMELINE AGAIN. And messes completely with the families of sims and their ages. (why is don lothario dating the caliente sisters' mum??)
I tried making my own sims savefile which continued on the stories of some of the characters from the older games for FUN but honestly the amount of maths and confusion was way too stressful to me cuz wtf 😭 (Ik the sims team definitely weren't thinking of a complex canon timeline when putting these sims into random situations but I couldn't help trying to make sense of it 😔)
Edit: I didn't even MENTION the random graves everywhere in the sims 3 and their weird connections to already existing characters.
6:56 In the games, Tails (who's canonical age fluctuates between 8 and 12 I believe) owns and flies several aeroplanes and owns property. I'd call the comics better about this, but thanks to Ken Penders, that would mean that several canonically grown adults were hitting on these teenagers (and he wanted one of said grown adults to be confirmed to have had sex with one of said teens), so personally I just headcanon that anthropomorphic characters in the games hit adulthood much sooner than humans.
When it comes to fantasy or anthropromorphic creatures or objects, I THINK you can afford to be unrealistic on some things unless that’s your goal. If a main focus of your story is to present something in a way that’s as scientifically-accurate as possible (saying you’re going to write a dog’s perspective as accurate as possible and then have him see his toy ball is red), that’s not good. You don’t have to break your back over getting every single detail right, though adding some of those details (like the moon actually changing phases in different scenes) will give it more believability. What you DO need is to make sure you’re not throwing every scrap of logic out the window and turning your story into a word version of an abstract painting.
Not everyone knows cats restrict meowing to communicate to mother and kitten. What everyone DOES know is that a cat meows. Having a cat just hooting like an owl for no reason or explanation, especially if they can’t talk, is going to put a lot of readers off very quickly.
2:25 this is why I only consider the original show canon and completely block everything else out of my mind.
I've also heard people say her mental problems come out of nowhere and aren't done well in the original show, but I disagree and I could tell she was crazy from when she first clapped and smiled when Zuko was burned. I'd say her losing it as soon as her best friends, who she's known her entire life, left her for the biggest threat to her empire makes a lot of sense. Especially since she just got the power she's been training her entire life for just to lose it to a child and her dishonored brother.
I think it was the change in the way her crazy showed itself. Manic smiles, high physical violence, grasping for control of others and situations vs sobbing and gibbering, losing control of self. Personally, I like to imagine that someone poisoned her and it was effecting the brain.
Even so, it doesn't really mean the mental illness was portrayed correctly or in a good way. (I've never actually watched atla though so take this with a grain of salt)
In Wings of Fire, Wren and Sky can speak both the dragon and human language fluently, it’s believable for them to know the human language since Wren was 7 and could already speak well enough when she found Sky, but how the hell did they learn to speak dragon?? Sky was a hatchling when Wren found him so there’s no way he would be able to speak well enough for Wren to learn from him and they both had very little contact with any other dragons.
ikr? like that's not how language works, you have to learn it?? especially with a spoken language like dragon is stated to be. if it was a nonverbal "language", like how irl cats communicate, that'd be one thing, but this is on a whole different level.
As somebody who loves a good timeline because it helps me understand lore better, doctor who has DESTROYED me
Fnaf has some crazy timeline shenanigans. Got even crazier when they briefly included timetravel.
In wings of fire, one of the side characters, Deathbringer, is assumed/implied to be the age as the main characters in the book he is introduced in. Yet, in a later off-shoot book that details his backstory, the year the story takes place in would mean he is muuuuch older in the present day.
Which wouldnt be too bad if it werent for the fact that when he meets the main characters, they are all 6 years old (late teens for dragons), and one of the main characters, Glory, is his love interest. Meanwhile the the book about his backstory would set him as being 13 years old (around like 30s maybe?).
However most people (including me) just ignore this as Tui (author) not being the best at keeping timelines in check.
Also, side note; dragon aging isnt the most consistent in the books, with dragons seeming to age very quickly from ages 1-7 and then just slowing down the aging from there, as its normal for dragons to live past 100.
Its odd that headcanoning him as a child soldier lines up better. Like, its horrifying, but i can see the faction he works for doing it, and it makes shipping line up better.
his age in his ministory is a retcon now tui made a mistake
slightly old comment but just wanna clear things up
In the Wings of Fire fandom, tribe evolution is a mess. Before book 15 (where the author introduced a few ancient dragons from millennia before the events of the books via flash blacks) I had a well constructed, scientifically-viable theory on how all the tribes could have evolved, and half an explanation for hybrids. With book 15 however, I've had to work around a lot of stuff, and frankly it's extremely frustrating.
Just don't get me started on canon biology in general (for reference, dragons are considered adults at 7; 8-year-olds founded a school where a 20-year-old is going, and no one questions it. Dragons _keep growing_, albeit slowly, after they turn 7. She should be at least a third bigger than all the others, especially since the school was intended for dragonets (think 2-5 year-olds). ) I've also worked a hopefully scientifically-viable theory for that.
Oh and the worst part in the languages. Someone help me.
I personally handwave the languages with an animus dragon who didn't know about pantala, and the pantalan dragons just assuming its a result of the now-deified clearsight. So maybe everyone's been speaking icewing for the past 1500 years.
Army size in Star Wars. In Episode 2, Obi-Wan is informed on Kamino regarding the clone army that 200,000 units are ready, with a million more well on the way. So the clone army is 1.2 million men strong. And they are the main Republic force in a galaxy wide conflict.
Considering Germany invaded the Soviet Union in 1941 with an army more than twice that size, it makes absolutely no sense. The clone army would be way to small to fight in a war that spans the entire galaxy.
I took it as "we've got a million currently being made" and not "we're stopping after a million more"
A unit is Star Wars is a group of soldiers, not individual soldiers. I don’t remember how many soldiers there were per unit, but I know there are billions of clones total
@@wapple4240 They should be in the quadrillions of soldiers. More if SW used even a tiny fraction of the bounty of space they have access to. A single K2 Dyson Swarm would be home to more living space than every planet in our galaxy many times over, even building multi km high buildings to the limit of the planets ability to radiate away waste heat.
But it's not a science fiction story or setting, it's a fantasy adventure in a stolen space suit.
@@wapple4240 And they were STILL always outnumbered by the droids.
@@bmobmo6438tbf droids we're cheap and easy to make so it's probably not that much of a stretch to think they would be outnumbering the clones 9/10 times, especially since in the e.u they had factories all across the outer rim that even the empire had to deal with, what I want to know is how in the hell is one planet with one cloning facility supplying a galactic army? Surly there must have been billions of offworld cloning facilities across republic owned territories in order to keep up with the droid army and yet I can only vaguely remember seeing only like one cloning station in space from the the show that never gets brought back up again after one or two episodes and kamino getting most of the attention.
Playtime Co. toys. Just. Playtime Co. toys.
I have no idea how some of them are even alive with the anatomy twists they have going on...
If you’re gonna get into Ace Attorney, you’re gonna have to accept that the games abide by their own court system and therefore allows SO MUCH insane shit to occur.
in a birthday letter from kaeya, just after the TCG came out in genshjn, he started the letter with “yo” which. he would NEVER. and the entire letter just felt like an ad for the tcg…. like, cyno is already the biggest ad for it ever, because he’s canonically obsessed with the game and we were already in sumeru so we got to see cyno often. it was perfect. we didnt NEED kaeya to advertise the game. i swear hoyo just uses kaeya as a way to advertise things. first his demo barely even being about him, then this?? how much more are they gonna disrespect him like this……
in fnaf William and Henry never got drafted for the war, this opens up a new type of trope: fake dating to dodge the draft.
I’m not sure if this fits but I have to say. The Worldbuilding in Steven Universe is kinda iffy. Earth was the first planet to have intelligent, sapient beings on it. So why were there already diplomats and armies? Who were they negotiating and fighting with? It doesn’t seem like each other, at least until Pink’s rebellion. What did the zoo amethysts do all day? What does anyone do all day? They only consume resources when they make more gems, and I guess their building materials.
Yeah, the show being Steven's perspective only really hurt the worldbuilding, we never saw how Homeworld operated on a larger scale before it got turned into a democracy after the timeskip. There also was this whole thing about a resource shortage creating smaller Era 2 Gems with diminished powers that just… never comes up again. I think the handwave is supposed to be that they ran out of Pink Diamond's essence when making more Gems, but Rubies that would need mostly red coloring essence from Pink are still considered common throwaway soldiers while Peridots which would mostly need blue and yellow coloring essence have diminished capacities? Doesn't really make a lot of sense. We also never see any Era 1 Peridots that are the "correct" size or any diminished Era 2 versions of other Gems for that matter. It feels like there was a whole arc there that got aborted.
Earth isn't the first planet with intelligent life. And all the gems perform their assigned duties
@@rainpooper7088The show being in Steven's perspective is what makes the show work. It would actually be restrictive and take away from the story otherwise. All of these are pretty small details tbh that likely we would have learned if Cartoon Network actually let the series play out to full completion.
@@natalimoina I’ve brought that up on fan communities before, apparently it’s Word of God(dess) that the humans were the first intelligent life.
I feel like there was supposed to be some sort of "Galactic War" the Diamonds, and thus all of gemkind, had been fighting for hundreds of thousands of years, hence the need for more and more gems- a war so large that they'd need the Cluster, and that they were willing to wait thousands of years for the Cluster to emerge so they could use it.