maybe less bloom strength in the parts that uses it, a more original font, theres a clear discrepancy of the editing of the intro and the actual video, and maybe less jump cuts in the fighting scenes
I would say the edits are good but too much, I appreciate the effort and finding a balance, but I’d say my biggest problem was the abrupt cuts it just really changes up your commentary style I’m used to. But if that was the goal then go ahead and keep it cause it was still an amazing video!
I feel like it is less chill than your normal edits and it caters to those with low attention spans, but imo it just makes the pacing feel rushed and hyper. Personally, I’m not a fan of it, and the reason I watch you in the first place is for your chill videos that don’t follow what everyone else is doing and it’s a breath of fresh air from all the shorts type editing we see in the average video nowadays.
criticism: - there's too many edits, a. 0:29, I don't need to see the items in the form of a edit if I just saw you loot them from the chest, same for 0:53. b. 0:47, I'm not sure if this is for anyone else but I've been accustomed to looking at twitch chat starting from the bottom, and I didn't get enough time to look at the chat before it zoomed out, same for 12:24. c. 5:29, the time-lapse for fishing made sense because we got to see the collection of items that you got, it would've been better just to have a straight cut just cause you're mining blocks. - editing lacks personality, a. the edit for items smoothly going up, chat smoothly going in and out, villager moving in the intro, etc. they all look the same, and they look generic. Keyframe tweens are good for polish, but they should be used sparingly. b. tv cut is straight up dated c. non copyrightable music, pls no, there's options other than Kevin Macleod pls... - music, a. I actually really liked the chill vibe for most of the video, but if there's action going on in the video, I need music to reciprocate that feeling, it makes it feel more full and polished. Although ironically, the ending music was doing too much, so make sure to feel it out and see what fit. ok sorry for the text dump hopefully some of these things are helpful ok bye
i love the text lol, I have edited all the videos on my channel for the last couple years and I liked the minimal editing and stuff and I was wondering if others did too. I get emails all the time from editors saying that they can make my videos better and that my editing is lacking. This editor emailed me and offered to edit this video for free so I let him. It's personally not my editing style either in terms of watching enjoyment and most things you said I agree with
I like the editing with a lot more montage feel and cutting out waiting especially in bow fights, but a lot of cuts are too quick and either cut off your talking (even if the content is boring, it seems wrong when you’re interrupted mid sentence) or cut off actual combat/context within a fight. And the transitions with noise got a bit overdone imo. A bit less cuts during close quarters stuff and this style is real good!!
at 6:00 and probly other times in the video didnt finish yet, i really really do not like not being able to see like any of the fight. pls dont do the cuts between hits or shots, also whole vid is just kind of weird
i dont like it much either but editors keep emailing me saying my content is bad and they can fix it so I let one of them edit a vid to see how they would make it better
i honestly really love that you say that lol. I uploaded this to gauge what my audience liked more, and most people like how I normally edit so that makes me very happy
I didn't edit this myself, some guy emailed me saying that my editing could use an upgrade and he'd edit it for free. I've had a lot of emails like that recently so I wanted to see what it would be like and get my viewers feedback. I agree with most of it
Hey guys! This video has different editing than normal. Very interested to hear your thoughts on it :)
I quite liked the editing style but if i was too give a bit of criticism, i think it could have been slowed down a tiny bit.
maybe less bloom strength in the parts that uses it, a more original font, theres a clear discrepancy of the editing of the intro and the actual video, and maybe less jump cuts in the fighting scenes
way too much editing, its trying to get better attention span for the audience but not everyone has a terrible attention span
I would say the edits are good but too much, I appreciate the effort and finding a balance, but I’d say my biggest problem was the abrupt cuts it just really changes up your commentary style I’m used to. But if that was the goal then go ahead and keep it cause it was still an amazing video!
I feel like it is less chill than your normal edits and it caters to those with low attention spans, but imo it just makes the pacing feel rushed and hyper. Personally, I’m not a fan of it, and the reason I watch you in the first place is for your chill videos that don’t follow what everyone else is doing and it’s a breath of fresh air from all the shorts type editing we see in the average video nowadays.
criticism:
- there's too many edits,
a. 0:29, I don't need to see the items in the form of a edit if I just saw you loot them from the chest, same for 0:53.
b. 0:47, I'm not sure if this is for anyone else but I've been accustomed to looking at twitch chat starting from the bottom, and I didn't get enough time to look at the chat before it zoomed out, same for 12:24.
c. 5:29, the time-lapse for fishing made sense because we got to see the collection of items that you got, it would've been better just to have a straight cut just cause you're mining blocks.
- editing lacks personality,
a. the edit for items smoothly going up, chat smoothly going in and out, villager moving in the intro, etc. they all look the same, and they look generic. Keyframe tweens are good for polish, but they should be used sparingly.
b. tv cut is straight up dated
c. non copyrightable music, pls no, there's options other than Kevin Macleod pls...
- music,
a. I actually really liked the chill vibe for most of the video, but if there's action going on in the video, I need music to reciprocate that feeling, it makes it feel more full and polished. Although ironically, the ending music was doing too much, so make sure to feel it out and see what fit.
ok sorry for the text dump hopefully some of these things are helpful ok bye
exactly, though i feel like the music should stay like how he usually does it, and i also think the text has way too high of a glow effect as well
i love the text lol, I have edited all the videos on my channel for the last couple years and I liked the minimal editing and stuff and I was wondering if others did too.
I get emails all the time from editors saying that they can make my videos better and that my editing is lacking.
This editor emailed me and offered to edit this video for free so I let him. It's personally not my editing style either in terms of watching enjoyment and most things you said I agree with
I agree with this dude. I would have liked to see more of the pvp/ fights
I like the editing with a lot more montage feel and cutting out waiting especially in bow fights, but a lot of cuts are too quick and either cut off your talking (even if the content is boring, it seems wrong when you’re interrupted mid sentence) or cut off actual combat/context within a fight. And the transitions with noise got a bit overdone imo. A bit less cuts during close quarters stuff and this style is real good!!
6:00 dam u cut out all the pvp man 😭
Love the vid although tbh I don’t care for the adhd editing
Love the editing but im already in love with raw gameplay
looks cool, feels too distracting with the pop ups and pvp cuts but
Idk i feel like its too much editing
He tried a new editor
@@OnlySteve391 no shit i was giving him feedback like he asked
And I’m telling you why the editing is different
at 6:00 and probly other times in the video didnt finish yet, i really really do not like not being able to see like any of the fight. pls dont do the cuts between hits or shots, also whole vid is just kind of weird
New Editing definitely will help bring new viewers, but the classic style is more you.
Awesome editing man, I mean I could be your video editor if this is difficult?
i feel like mixing fast paced edits w chill gameplay is not it IMO! but still an entertaining vid regardless from my goat.
i dont like it much either but editors keep emailing me saying my content is bad and they can fix it so I let one of them edit a vid to see how they would make it better
W editing style idk if you're hiring help for this editing stuff but it shows in the video
I find the editing very exhausting, with all the special effects and everything… I’ve got hearing, I’ve got eyes. I don’t like it
i honestly really love that you say that lol. I uploaded this to gauge what my audience liked more, and most people like how I normally edit so that makes me very happy
Why, so videos can take even longer to release lol
I think the music is too less of a vibe
average annoying bow spammer
it’s alright but I dislike cutting up fights.
yea i feel like most fights were kinda cut up like that lmao, i also prefer just letting fights play out
Like the editing but it needs way more sound effects cuz the zooms and stuff look super awkward without it
New editing is cool and all but I miss those one or two videos that Zane edited for you
You literally cut out all the pvp, i have no idea how you won the last fight.
I didn't edit this myself, some guy emailed me saying that my editing could use an upgrade and he'd edit it for free. I've had a lot of emails like that recently so I wanted to see what it would be like and get my viewers feedback. I agree with most of it
I don't think the guy who edited this plays Minecraft @@scottehLive
this old
eggs milk bread pepsi
I love the fiserman class (0:16)
goat
W vid from big man as always
nvm
First
Like the editing style ngl it’s more captivating
W video editing I would say it was a little excessive with the pop up items and loud outbursts in the beginning while looting structures
gotta give it to scotteh, the editing is pure perfect. The music fits in, the edits are on place. Huge congrats!!!