"NATION Building on CRACK," Trump's Plan To Relocate GAZANS to Jordan and Egypt: Trita Parsi
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 лют 2025
- Trita parsi of the Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft talks about the Israel-Hamas ceasefire and President Trump asking Jordan to take 2 million Gazans. #Trump #Gaza #MiddleEsat
About Rising:
Rising is a weekday morning show with bipartisan hosts that breaks the mold of morning TV by taking viewers inside the halls of Washington power like never before. The show leans into the day's political cycle with cutting edge analysis from DC insiders who can predict what is going to happen. It also sets the day's political agenda by breaking exclusive news with a team of scoop-driven reporters and demanding answers during interviews with the country's most important political newsmakers.
Follow Rising on social media:
Website: Hill.TV
Facebook: HillTVLive/
Instagram: @HillTVLive
Twitter: @HillTVLive
This seems crazy but if actually done, it could be a based move that would make the area stable for the first time in almost a century.
Based? It's Kaynesian lunacy
niall _"i love palestinians but just not in my neighborhood"_ stanage
TBF that's the attitude of all Arab nations.
7:45 It actually is Israel's choice. The palestenian people started something they cannot win. You have already lost this, and you have no position of strength left. You lost, and you are being conquered, and you will suffer the consequences of this.
And what goes around comes around, even for the US!
And Biden Harris didn't do one single thing to get back one single hostage.
I love how President Trump wastes no time making deals and negotiations to get the hostages back, but like President Trump said a long time ago, l don't think there are many hostages still alive.😢
Biden will have blood on his hands forever.
Well, it won’t come around from the Palestinians.
Gaza would be a great location for a U. S. military/naval base: very close to the Arab countries, lots of ocean access, next door to a trusted ally. Maybe that's what's really going on here.
Not our ally.
Yes. It belongs to the US now!!!🇮🇱🇺🇸🇮🇱🇺🇸🇮🇱🇺🇸
I don't think you can get more neo-con than that, even if you changed your name to George W.
I think Robbie owes Brianna an apology .. cause she was right the whole time.
I do think you're right that he should apologize for not giving her points any legitimacy.
I also think this issue is more nuanced than just one side is right and one is wrong though. Both sides presented truths and lies. Two things can be true and legitimate at the same time.
What about?
i think she owes all the guests she treated horribly an apology, not just the one that got her fired
@@nickfinney2598apologize to a goofy? No way! You only apologize when you agree on the problem. Patriots understand Israel has to do what it has to do to maintain peace in that in peaceful region.
You mean like the peace going on in Syria and Lebanon?
Palestinans elected Hamas started a war and lost. Now they will lose any autonomy or sovereignty they ever had. The hostages being held and treated poorly was a really idiotic strategem.
!!!!!!!!! , MADE. UR. BED. , WITH. FLEAS. --- DONT. COMPLAIN. ABOUT. THEM. STUCK. ON. U. !!! .
@@richardnorton9394 the u.s and Israel meddled in the Palestinian election, leading to Hamas's victory, and Netanyahu has done everything possible since to antagonize the Palestinians and end any chance of a two state solution, a point he is very proud of, but yes, your statement is not false if we ignore every piece of context.
Israel was formed on stolen Palestinian land to begin with.
Israel has slaughtered thousands of Palestinians since the 1948 Nakba, pushed them out of their villages, and stolen their homes.
Palestinians have the right to defend themselves.
Israel was formed on stolen Palestinian land to begin with.
Israel has slaughtered thousands of Palestinians since the 1948 Nakba, pushed them out of their villages, and stolen their homes.
Palestinians have the right to defend themselves.
@@dustinbaker8272 moving out of Gaza in 2005 and leaving them to their own devices is antagonizing? No one told them to abuse the billions of dollars in donations and spend it on missiles and rockets instead of improving their infrastructure or commerce.
So when they've been told they are going to be removed from their homeland and not allowed to return so Trump can build a resort explain the motivation to return the hostages????
Where do you get your info?? No one is making them leave. Clearly changes need to be made, or the terrorists will just take control of Gaza again and again.
Not being removed from the realm of the living would be the motivation.
I don't think Gaza would make a good resort, but it would be a great location for a U. S. military/naval base: very close to the Arab countries, lots of ocean access, next door to a trusted ally. I think that may be the real reason Trump wants Gaza.
WHO said they are NOT allowed to return?
Whoever told you that is lying to you, President Trump has repeatedly said, they are going to build a beautiful place for the people of Gaza to return and live in PEACE.
PRESIDENT TRUMP BRINGS PEACE. 🇺🇸
Just how many hostages did Biden Harris bring back?
Zero zilch nada. NONE.
ARE YOU NOT HAPPY THAT FINALLY HOSTAGES ARE BEING RETURNED?
This perpetual refuge status is a problem. The Palestinians are going to have to learn to live in peace wherever they are.
Hehehehe....good one. Next, vegetarian sharks.
The big ask. It tends to break people's brains.
You must admire people who cant take a fictional tale that doesnt include them, flip it on itd head and make the world carry their water. This is an amazing occurrence
Wait - why does this guy only talk about the Arab states paying to rebuild Gaza? He’s an unofficial Iranian spokesman. Shouldn’t he be talking about how much Iran is willing to contribute? I thought Iran loved the Palestinians? I guess they’re more into destruction than building.
I'm going to presume your thoughts about Iran are sarcasm. 🤞
Why is an Iranian regime shill the head of an American institution?
So they're not releasing the remaining hostages because what Trump said that sounds like a bunch of b******* to me
There was a Palestinian state in gaza from 20007 to 2023. Then they invaded their neighbor and started a war.
When Robbie asked if the Palestinians are a monolith and this guy answered “it’s simple” he lost all credibility.
The fact that Trumps proposals is making everyone angry is actually a good thing. It's clear that a one or two state solution is not an option. Time for some fresh thinking that gets people to the negotiating table.
It shows a complete lack of respect for the Palestinian people. Treating people without dignity will backfire over the long term. Haven't the lessons of the middle east shown that? Trump has no historical sense.
PARSI: these people can’t move. They love Gaza.
ALSO PARSI: these people should be living in Israel.
PARSI: Jordan can’t take in a million Palestinians. It would destroy the country.
ALSO PARSI: Israel should take in seven million Palestinians.
AYATOLLAHS: I like this Parsi guy.
57 countries with Islamic members should endorse the Palestinians to a better life in their countries
LOL
💯
Yeah, I wonder how he can't see the flaw in this line of argument. I think President Trump has a dumb idea here, but you can't argue that sending Palestinians to Jordan would destabilize Jordan and then argue that the Palestinians should be allowed to move back to Israel while ignoring the destabilizing aspects of this.
Do something different… Thats the key and the remedy to break the insanity.
Don't start a war if you can't handle retaliation
The refugees who left Israel in 1947 refused to live with jews. They were all welcome to stay but couldn't stomach the jews as fellow countrymen.
Get out of here with that BS.
Great gest. I like this guy, seems like an objective observer
STARTING AND LOSING A WAR HAS CONSEQUENCES
One of the biggest impediments when it came to nation building and building a liberal democracy was the culture and religion of inhabitants.
Trump wants to circumvent that issue by kicking out the Palestinians.
Palestinians ceded any claims on oct.7
This is not a surprise. This is out of the Christian Nationalist playbook.
So what is the answer? Everyone is tired of the fighting that has gone on for decades. At the point, it is silly and so silly solutions should be discussed. They had opportunities to be adults.
Stop finding Israel, Le the lm settle it on their own
Everyone is tired of the fighting ? Really???? I have seen no proof that anyone is tired of this mess.
Here’s a solution for you that hasn’t been tried, stop giving away billions and billions of dollars to Israel and stop covering for them diplomatically. They will then have to actually act in good faith for the first time in their criminal history and grant Palestinians equal human rights. 😮
Isn't this amazing, President Trump certainly gets things done.
He got the hostages back, l Don't think there's any more, tho.
Biden is still causing chaos sheet he's gone. Biden Harris did nothing to get them back, he is all about GREED, killing, death, and destruction.
Just how many hostages did Biden Harris bring back?
Zero zilch nada. NONE.
ARE YOU NOT HAPPY THAT FINALLY HOSTAGES ARE BEING RETURNED?
anybody still remember when robby slammed the table and screamed at briahna joy gray in his unwavering defense of israel?
More accurately because she couldn't even fain sympathy for a kidnapped and tortured Israeli woman in a conversation with her sister.
@@josephclements2145 what? robby did the screaming like 2 days after the attack lol
Lol, she was pro hamas, he was just reasonable
@@vietimports Yeah, he had an outburst once. BJG was doing almost daily.
@@deadgolfer6345debating with people who can’t seem to comprehend the context of historical events and distort that context to dehumanize the group that has been backed into a corner due to those events will do that to someone. Cool heads are ideal, but a callous disregard for the humanity and history of another group, a disregard that has gone mainstream, would make any person objectively looking at the situation bothered
This is an out of box solution to a situation that has yet to be solved by the normal approaches. Will it work?
That’s well said
Sometimes when I can’t find something, and have looked in all the “normal” places it’s *supposed* to be and I still can’t find it, I then begin looking in the strange places it shouldn’t be. That’s sort of like this- the normal solutions didn’t work, guess it’s time to start trying unorthodox methods.
So is moving all of the jews out if the region and giving Israel to Palestine.
Why not offer to take in all of the jews of Israel and give Israel to Palestine?
@@college54114use tax payer money to rebuild a country destroyed with tax payer money is not an out box idea lol. It's the Hallmark of our military the last 3 decades.
This is the craziest idea any american president has ever had
Lol
😂😂what would've done if you were the Pres? allow them to stay and continue the war? If Palestianian continue to allow Hamas... then it is the result of their choices...
You got any better suggestions?
No, it is the most sane idea.
Just crazy enough to work
People forget that the Israelites were there thousands of years before the "Palestinians."
Lies
That doesnt matter. Lines were drawn to give a land specifically to the Jews. Just because Palestinians refuse to accept that doesn't change anything. Also land won in war goes to the victor. Israel has won wars since 1948.
If you believe the biblical narrative, they committed genocide to take the land in the first place.
So says my Magic book. The white people from New York and other places in America are actually middle eastern 😂
Robbie, THE PEOPLE WANT TO STAY IN THEUR LAND! AN NOT BE GENOCIDE BY ISRAEL
They voted for terrorists to rule them they don’t want peace would you want them for a neighbour?
Your just as guilty of genocide if you want them to stay. You know EXACTLY what is about to happen.
They could have stayed in their land. They didn't
With Netanyahu in charge israel don't need enemy,
They hove not been there 1000s of years lies
Palestinians elected Hamas ' they brought this on themselves' let them stay in their rumble
I heard a comment about Trump's Gaza proposal possibly is just him putting out something ridiculous on the negotiating table in hopes of getting Saudi Arabia and other Arab nations to step up to the plate to manage Gaza, removing the US and Israel from the conflict of interest in regards to the Palestinians.
If not, I'm out of support for Trump. US controlling Gaza would be bonkers.
*"I'm out of support for Trump."*
You never supported Trump.
what trump said in Ukraine need back the money 😂😂😂
Jordan king puppet needs follow your master 😂😂😂
Just how many hostages did Biden Harris bring back?
Zero zilch nada. NONE.
ARE YOU NOT HAPPY THAT FINALLY HOSTAGES ARE BEING RETURNED?
Isn't this amazing, President Trump certainly gets things done.
He got the hostages back, l Don't think there's any more, tho.
Biden is still causing chaos sheet he's gone. Biden Harris did nothing to get them back, he is all about GREED, killing, death, and destruction.
Best idea! As a RFK Jr. supporter who voted for Trump, I would vote for a 3rd term! God bless Israel 🇮🇱
I hope his pager doesn't go off.
Parsi represents the country that is trying to unalive Donald Trump and I don't think it's in good taste to bring him on to make veiled threats to our country. It's really time you stopped bringing Iran into discussions and pretending they are something else.
💯 have him come on but make it completely clear he’s giving the Iranian perspective.
Robbie letting his racism slip through on this one.
Also the comments are so obtuse.
Lack of empathy and lack of insight. Imagine you’re kicked out of your home by military, put in a camp, and the marched off out of your country by a foreign military and told: this is not your country anymore, you don’t live here, if you choose to live here and we let you you will be a second class citizen and we will treat you poorly-because that is what actually happened to the Palestinians (and documented proof exists). So for all the “I’m gonna defend my country against the liberals” out there, imagine if Trump had not won and none of your policies had come theough-then maximize it by 1000 on steroids and you might perhaps know what it feels like to be occupied by a foreign power just because you don’t have a military.
Yall need to learn more and educate yourselves.
If they acted like first class citizens rather than terrorists, there would be no conflict. Aid money was diverted towards war....unaccountable
All the Palestinians have birth certificates and their birth certificate say that they are Egyptian.
@thekentuckyan8088. I don't know about other P-people but Arafat was born in Egypt.
@ according to the son of the man that created Hamas, they all have birth certificates and they’re all Egyptians
They had control of their country and look what they did.
Lol literally false israel has been in total control of these people for decades.
I think Robby's mind had been completely hacked.
Why's that kid?
Gaza will be an absolute idea for US military base in the middle east.. this city is big enough for the American to be a great area to build the best Military base to protect Israel as well, our long time ally.. 🤔👍
The terrible low audio level makes this channel increasingly hard to take. Fix it soon, or I'm out.
Just go, Kirk. People are tired of your whining anyway.
Paid for by tariffs American companies will pay.
They created before civil wars on jordan and egyp lol search it up. Palestinians know peace as much as dogs are vegetarians
If it ain't broke, don't fix it, but it's been broken since day one let's interview some more bureaucrats I do like the hill, however, because they balanced their opinions that are informed and not pointed kudos
Weird way to say "genocide".
Isn't this amazing, President Trump certainly gets things done.
He got the hostages back, l Don't think there's any more, tho.
Biden is still causing chaos sheet he's gone. Biden Harris did nothing to get them back, he is all about GREED, killing, death, and destruction.
WHY NOT LOS ANGELES PEOPLE ARE SENT TO RUSSIA AND THE AREA B CONVERTED TO RIVIERA
Boosting it further lol. Who cares Niall? Whoever this middle east lover?
Those people have not been there for thousands of years. About 200,000 people were there prior to the Jews returning. Most of them arrived in the region at the same time as the Jews during the second Aliyah. Prior to the second Aliyah that entire region was an undeveloped backwater. Most of them were recent migrants from Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and Jordan regions. The Palestinians did not even exist as a distinct ethnic group from other Arabs until 1967.
@@zerphase in 1900, 600K people lived in palestine, with 94% being arab; 1800, it was 275K with 97% being arab. At the time of the Balfour declaration in 1916, which started this mess, 90% of the region was arab. Facts matter
😂😂😂😂 this is the headline i needed today
Awe the Muslims don't get anothet Lebanon and they upset. Just move to Lebanon.
I used to like this guest a lot but now he seems very biased and always coming to the show with an agenda
ye man . its called oct 7 !!!! f around and find out !
Germans were ethnically cleansed from Sudetenland and now there is peace between Germany and Czechia. Stop forcing nonsense ideas on people.
There's plenty of open land in Siberia the Palestinians could move too. Same with the Antarctic. Dress warm.
Is he a spokesman for Iran ?
I mean, given nothing else works - why not.
Well, that's a headline.
A convicted felon and a war criminal deciding the fate of Gaza.
Isn’t this what they claim Putin is doing?
So obvious that Robbie sees Palestinians as non people.
YES, ISRAEL WILL BE VICTORIOUS
Hmm 🤔🧐
The old Robbie we were accustomed to tried to come out but Parsi quickly shut him down 😂
These people have been fighting over that land since literally king David from from the bible who killed Goliath with a sling. Maybe separating them is the answer 🤷♂
Gaza is going to Jordan...
Their own fault, they should have accepted Trump's deal... pity
Robby got shut down fast!!!!😂😂