What do you think of P1Harmony's comeback ? Song : SAD SONG Artist : P1Harmony (피원하모니) Album : SAD SONG Outro : It's Alright #P1Harmony #Sadsong #linedistribution
@@nikolashakos_ Yes but Soul is half Japanese, half Korean, was raised in Japan and learned Korean at an older age. It’s not that he doesn’t want to sing but he wasn’t that comfortable with the language. Over the years he’s learned more hence why he has more lines than he used to.
@@_harley_1288 If language was the problem, why didn't the company debut another trainee who was fluent in Korean instead? If an idol who has debuted in a group is treated as a backup dancer every comeback because they can't sing or aren't confident in the language, why bother debuting them in the first place? This is the K-Pop industry, the "K" stands for "Korean" and the "Pop" for "Pop MUSIC". If a trainee can't speak Korean or can't sing, then they shouldn't debut because they don't fill the requirements. It's like a job, if someone isn't capable enough for a job, the employer chooses another one who is more capable.
@_harley_1288 Well, if y'all don't atleast mention it, he's never gonna sing. And it's not just about his Korean anymore, he doesn't feel very good about his voice. That's why Jiung wrote a few more lines for him this comeback and pushed him to sing more. He needs that push.
piwon literally chooses their line distribution themselves why are you guys complaining?? also regardless of group, having only a 20 second difference between the main vocal and everyone else (minus soul) is really fair. he's the main for a reason
their distribution is always weird but it's because they all take time on deciding who does which line so they quite literally pick stuff for themselves and only occasionally do they write for someone specififcally (only intak and jongseob really write for themselves cause they're rappers and jiung and keeho because they do most of their lyrics but also jiung does write for other members if he wants them to shine from what the members have said)
the most insufferable ppl will always be found complaining on a p1h line distribution video 😭 it’s fine to want certain members to have more lines, but it’s not mistreatment if they don’t get as much compared to other members they all distribute lines amongst themselves for jongseob, keeho has said they usually save him for the second verse because they know his talent will wow ppl (meaning other basic rap sections would go to the two other rappers) for soul, js a few days ago, he was talking abt his parts jiung wrote for him to sing and how speaking in korean is hard and he was nervous for theo, i can’t really say ik the reason for that, maybe because singing would require him to be in the center for longer and he doesn’t like dancing, but idk either way, acting like they’re being mistreated for less lines is crazy (suspecting some mistreatment based off other things is valid tho, dont get me wrong)
Can people just be happy without complaining about the line distribution bruh, y'all should be thankful that Soul at least has a real lines here rather than an ad libs
such a strange distribution. half of the group doesn't sing anything until the second verse while three other members have more than 20 seconds...? okay. soul lines are short as always, at least he had some kind of a verse here.
cuatro años ya de debut y todavía soul no puede tener líneas verdaderas como los demás miembros la verdad que no entiendo que pasa del otro lado si es el quien no quiere líneas o su empresa literalmente lo ve como un bailan solamente
En un behind the scenes de Killin' It Theo dice que ellos son quienes deciden la distribución de líneas. Si hay dos miembros que quieren la misma línea cada quien hace su impresión y los miembros dan retroalimentación y votan con respecto a quién lo hace mejor. En el vídeo que insertaron Soul está callado mientras los demás discuten, él dijo que siempre está de acuerdo con lo que dicen los demás.
this group has such a weird way of distributing their lines, i guess its because they all collectively work together to split it... but i just wanna hear soul more.. i KNOW this boy has such a beautiful vocal tone
Theo said they vote for whoever embodies the lines the best. So if they're getting greedy they do their impression and the members give feedback on who does it better. Soul tends to stay silent when they're discussing that. But yeah Soul lines are a need 😭😭
Why do y’all always complain that soul doesn’t have lines when YOU KNOW he doesn’t want to have that many lines. It’s his choice, please respect it.
Then why is he in the group in the first place if he is there just to dance? Aren't the requirements to be an idol both singing and dancing?
@@nikolashakos_ Yes but Soul is half Japanese, half Korean, was raised in Japan and learned Korean at an older age. It’s not that he doesn’t want to sing but he wasn’t that comfortable with the language. Over the years he’s learned more hence why he has more lines than he used to.
@@_harley_1288 If language was the problem, why didn't the company debut another trainee who was fluent in Korean instead? If an idol who has debuted in a group is treated as a backup dancer every comeback because they can't sing or aren't confident in the language, why bother debuting them in the first place? This is the K-Pop industry, the "K" stands for "Korean" and the "Pop" for "Pop MUSIC". If a trainee can't speak Korean or can't sing, then they shouldn't debut because they don't fill the requirements. It's like a job, if someone isn't capable enough for a job, the employer chooses another one who is more capable.
@_harley_1288 Well, if y'all don't atleast mention it, he's never gonna sing. And it's not just about his Korean anymore, he doesn't feel very good about his voice. That's why Jiung wrote a few more lines for him this comeback and pushed him to sing more. He needs that push.
piwon literally chooses their line distribution themselves why are you guys complaining?? also regardless of group, having only a 20 second difference between the main vocal and everyone else (minus soul) is really fair. he's the main for a reason
their distribution is always weird but it's because they all take time on deciding who does which line so they quite literally pick stuff for themselves and only occasionally do they write for someone specififcally (only intak and jongseob really write for themselves cause they're rappers and jiung and keeho because they do most of their lyrics but also jiung does write for other members if he wants them to shine from what the members have said)
Why do yall complain 😂 You know p1 mostly distribute lines among themselves so what’s the problem
i know soul just wanna dance but im sick and tired of his lack of lines😭😭😭 he has my favourite vocal tone
i like his vocals too but I think we can't do anything if having lesser lines is his choice
Doesn’t he choose the lines he wants?
@@NijiAkuma yes!! but as i said i adore his vocals and tone i would love if he chooses to have a atleast a little more in the future 🥹🥹
the most insufferable ppl will always be found complaining on a p1h line distribution video 😭
it’s fine to want certain members to have more lines, but it’s not mistreatment if they don’t get as much compared to other members
they all distribute lines amongst themselves
for jongseob, keeho has said they usually save him for the second verse because they know his talent will wow ppl (meaning other basic rap sections would go to the two other rappers)
for soul, js a few days ago, he was talking abt his parts jiung wrote for him to sing and how speaking in korean is hard and he was nervous
for theo, i can’t really say ik the reason for that, maybe because singing would require him to be in the center for longer and he doesn’t like dancing, but idk
either way, acting like they’re being mistreated for less lines is crazy (suspecting some mistreatment based off other things is valid tho, dont get me wrong)
Ijbol do the people complaining even know that piwon themselves decide the line distribution for most songs...
i know they pick their lines but i’d love to hear more of soul in their songs. he has such a good voice
Soul voice is so addicting
Can people just be happy without complaining about the line distribution bruh, y'all should be thankful that Soul at least has a real lines here rather than an ad libs
such a strange distribution. half of the group doesn't sing anything until the second verse while three other members have more than 20 seconds...? okay. soul lines are short as always, at least he had some kind of a verse here.
and yes i will complain i don't care🤗🤗🤗
frrr, while watching the mv i was thinking "when the hell theo is going to sing?"
Honestly P1 always have weird line distributions but it's still a banger nonetheless
why does soul have such short lines?
@@pinoccio69
Keeho and Theo vocals are crazy!
But i think you missed some of their ad-libs
I think the members harmonizing themself
@@k_linedistribution625 oh okay!
I really love this song and all the parts suit the members so much! Thanks for the video ❤
As i believe in human rights i dont have a _______
soul
soul
soul
soul
soul
Please do p1harmony its alright next.
Шота сказал, что он не уверен в своем пении и ему не нужно много партий. Уважайте его выбор
Such a good line distribution for P1Harmony! Are you going to distribute the album?
I should 👀♥️
cuatro años ya de debut y todavía soul no puede tener líneas verdaderas como los demás miembros la verdad que no entiendo que pasa del otro lado si es el quien no quiere líneas o su empresa literalmente lo ve como un bailan solamente
el propio soul ya dijo que el solo quiere bailar y por eso pide pocas lineas
En un behind the scenes de Killin' It Theo dice que ellos son quienes deciden la distribución de líneas. Si hay dos miembros que quieren la misma línea cada quien hace su impresión y los miembros dan retroalimentación y votan con respecto a quién lo hace mejor. En el vídeo que insertaron Soul está callado mientras los demás discuten, él dijo que siempre está de acuerdo con lo que dicen los demás.
Por ahí dicen q al propio soul no le gusta tener tantas líneas pues se dedica más al baile x_x
this group has such a weird way of distributing their lines, i guess its because they all collectively work together to split it... but i just wanna hear soul more.. i KNOW this boy has such a beautiful vocal tone
Theo said they vote for whoever embodies the lines the best. So if they're getting greedy they do their impression and the members give feedback on who does it better. Soul tends to stay silent when they're discussing that. But yeah Soul lines are a need 😭😭
thei
poor soul
he said himself that he doesn’t want many lines
Devorar = Jiung