'Imran Ko Ghabrana Hai': Tilak Devasher on How Pak Army has Struck Back and What Next I HT Podcast

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 кві 2024
  • Tilak Devasher, Former Spl Secy, Cabinet Secretariat and author of many acclaimed books on Pakistan, explains why Imran Khan is so popular among the masses in Pakistan. Analysing the reason behind his rise and also the reason behind his downfall, Devasher explains how Imran Khan has bitten off more than he can chew in taking on the Pak Army. Watch the video for more
    #pakistanarmy #pakistan #imrankhan #imrankhanpti
    TIME STAMPS
    00:00 - INTRO
    00:26 - WHY IS IMRAN KHAN SO POPULAR
    06:43 - IMRAN-ARMY FALLOUT
    09:10 - IMRAN HAS BITTEN OFF MORE THAN HE CAN CHEW
    11:25 - IMRAN'S POPULARITY UNJUSTIFIED
    15:15 - HOW PAK ARMY HAS STRUCK BACK
    18:14 - IMRAN KHAN KO GHABRANA HAI
    21:17 - NO COMPARISON B/W MUJIBUR RAHMAN AND IMRAN
    23:02 - PAK BREAK-UP IMMINENT?
    26:02 - PAK'S CHINESE DEBT TRAP
    28:41 - PAK'S NUCLEAR BLACKMAIL
    31:50 - INDIA MUST WATCH TOXIC PAK CAREFULLY
    33:28 - ARE PAK'S NUKES SAFE?
    34:46 - SHOULD INDIA HELP PAK?
    37:34 - ON KASHMIR AND BILAWAL
    39:40 - IMRAN KHAN WON'T SURVIVE JAIL
    Hindustan Times Videos bring you news, views and explainers about current issues in India and across the globe. We’re always excited to report the news as quickly as possible, use new technological tools to reach you better and tell stories with a 360 degree view to give you a better understanding of the world around you.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 314

  • @SN23031978
    @SN23031978 11 місяців тому +23

    Watching Tilak sahib from Islamabad. Have bought and read all his books on Pakistan and he surely knows this country deeply and much better than many Pakistanis.

    • @ramamurtipaluri2420
      @ramamurtipaluri2420 11 місяців тому

      Sadie Saheba I see you are one of the rare intellectuals of Pakistan who can assimilate information, be rational, have correct thought process, have intellectual properties and work for progress.

    • @youtubepromotion1818
      @youtubepromotion1818 11 місяців тому

      what a disappointment you are lady! Modi with popular hindu support in india is good for india while imran khan with popular pakistani support is bad for pakistan? No 1 Bulls**t. Btw how come indians like this one now support pak army against imran khan? Daal me bohot zada kaala hai! Secondly tell this uncle that no pakistani court has convicted imran khan or his wife in any corruption case in spite of all the pressure from the establishment! Fake cases from corrupt establishment does not make one guilty. Its the courts that decide whose guilty and whose innocent!
      Thirdly I can write a whole essay here on how well pakistan was performing in imran khan's tenure. One fine example was how he dealt with covid as one of the top leaders in the world who had it in control, while at the same time indians were dying like dogs and rats on streets of india from covid in modi's tenure.
      But what a shame indians still support that chayewala and you miss sadia doubt your learned oxford graduate ex prime minister imran khan. This is the dilemma of our nation. I knew this uncle was spreading bs just by going through highlights of this talk and you are all in awe of him for God knows what?

    • @youtubepromotion1818
      @youtubepromotion1818 11 місяців тому +1

      @@ramamurtipaluri2420 this dude is biased and knows nothing about pakistan just like this biased channel who always supports worst people for pakistan

    • @skysdhprm5067
      @skysdhprm5067 11 місяців тому +2

      Jehadi from Pakistan ...fan of tilak sir😢😢😢joke of the year😂😂

    • @infodaynightconv1445
      @infodaynightconv1445 10 місяців тому

      Also knows IK through and through.

  • @shahzilayub
    @shahzilayub 11 місяців тому +10

    Critical analysis by Tilak Devasher .Love from Pakistan.

    • @cleopatra7377
      @cleopatra7377 11 місяців тому

      It's obvious these Indian people support the Pakistan army 😈 they need to mind their own business

  • @powerpia2000
    @powerpia2000 11 місяців тому +5

    Oh My God! (Mashallah) What great content. I just by coincident saw this podcast. What a balanced analysis - both eye opening and inspiring. Im a pakistani, living in Denmark. Very much nuanced my view on Imran Khan. Thanks. Great content. Now I will order som of Mr Devashers books. What great command he has of pakistan knowledge.

    • @youtubepromotion1818
      @youtubepromotion1818 11 місяців тому

      He is spreading bs brother. Modi with popular hindu support in india is good for india while imran khan with popular pakistani support is bad for pakistan? No 1 Bulls**t. Btw how come indians like this one now support pak army against imran khan? Daal me bohot zada kaala hai! Secondly tell this uncle that no pakistani court has convicted imran khan or his wife in any corruption case in spite of all the pressure from the establishment! Fake cases from corrupt establishment does not make one guilty. Its the courts that decide whose guilty and whose innocent!
      Thirdly I can write a whole essay here on how well pakistan was performing in imran khan's tenure. One fine example was how he dealt with covid as one of the top leaders in the world who has it in control, while at the same time indians were dying like dogs and rats on streets of india from covid in modi's tenure. So keep bs to yourselves. Pakistani middle class who supports imran khan are not fools!!

  • @ghazanfarali2538
    @ghazanfarali2538 11 місяців тому +12

    Brilliant stuff, the insight, the analysis, on the dot, very well read and learned speaker

    • @vivekyadav1
      @vivekyadav1 11 місяців тому

      Except that he forgot to mention, that the pakistanis are converts to islam from hinduism, mostly from lower caste, that they are no arabs, turks or afghans or persians.
      None from the above categories consider pakistanis to be one of them.
      So the pakistani ego is based on falsified history, which is institutionalized in the pak studies textbooks.

    • @pashabaloch6029
      @pashabaloch6029 11 місяців тому

      Irman Khan is stupid Person like a Bawile Gand. 😂😄 Pakistan army take three years to understand that irman Khan is stupid Bawil Gand 😂😂😄both are same in there own way.

    • @cleopatra7377
      @cleopatra7377 11 місяців тому

      I totally disagree, these Indian people should mind their own business 😡 how DARE they tell us who should be our leader

    • @ghazanfarali2538
      @ghazanfarali2538 11 місяців тому +1

      They are only giving an analysis and in a free world anyone can do that, I think what we as a nation seriously need to work on is developing the ability to look at thins rationally and objectively instead of empty emotionality

  • @prakwandutta2861
    @prakwandutta2861 11 місяців тому +10

    Sir, you have not count the black economy of pakistan and the narcotics economy of pakistan Army..
    pakistan army is the biggest conglomerate of pakistan...

  • @Wanderer975
    @Wanderer975 11 місяців тому +4

    @11.47 Tilak says that Imran did not tackle Covid very well.
    You are so ignorant. Imran khan managed COVID in the best way possible. International experts praised him and Pakistan for managing covid in the best way.
    Please do a little research before saying things which are not true.

  • @abbasakhunzada4510
    @abbasakhunzada4510 11 місяців тому +4

    i think tilak failed to answer the reason behind imran khans popularity, the reason he is actually popular is not just because of mr clean or his cricket background but his social contributions, he has lived among the poor classes of pakistan seen them first hand before being the prime minister he was the first to open cancer hospitals in pakistan that provided absolutely free treatment to those who couldnt afford and apart from those big hospitals he used to open medical camps in less privileged areas for people who couldnt afford to travel to big cities ive seen such camps and met the peasants there and the way they talk about imran khan is as though they are talking about a messiah, imran khan brought in donations for earthquake victims in 2005 and after that whenever people needed aid. after becoming pm he quadrupled his social activities he brought in the health card program which allowed every citizen to free medical coverage upto 10 lakhs in a poverty stricken country such as pakistan this health card was like a divine gift to people who cant even afford basic medicines, there were people at the bottom of the social heirarchy who were now getting medical treatment for themselves and their families in the most elite hospitals next to families of the wealthiest classes of pakistan, khan also started many other programs such as "my labor will not sleep hungry" and "my people will not sleep on streets" which provided free quality diet for labors and their families and also living spaces for people who didnt have any place to sleep at night, and all this is just the tip of the iceberg, khan personally used to take part in these programs visiting these places siting with the labors and the peasants sharing meals with them, in one incident khan while travelling in lahore saw a couple people sleeping under a bridge while it was raining he immediately called his social workers told them about it they replied that our housing places are running at full occupancy and khan replied " i dont care i dont want to see these people sleeping under the bridge the next time i travel through here" and the social workers got some sleeping bags some tents went to those people brought them back to the housing places and set places for them on the roofs. khan was personally in touch with the people at the grassroot and thats where he draws his support from. now im not a blind supporter of imran khan he was made several terrible mistakes which i sometimes even call blunders forexample instead of promoting his own party workers and giving them tickets which wouldve been better because they were ideological members of the party he chose to bring in electables with the help of the establishment and that mistake is eating him up today because those electables were never khans people they were people of the military establishment. now many people think that imran khan is over but i think as long as he has got support from kpk he basically has a conscripted militia by his side because if there is anybody who will stand between the military firepower and imran khan it is the pashtuns because they love and cherish and they will not only stand between these two but also fire back at the military and if that happens military is doomed because every 13 year old pashtun knows how to use an ak 47 or atleast a shotgun, plus theres only 500 thousands soldiers in pakistan army pashtuns on the other hand are in millions. good luck to asim munir if khan decides to go wage a civil war and ill be pretty chill about it cause even in worse case scenario if we loose khan we will still the people of kpk retain independence from this military dictatorship known as pakistan.

    • @malikahmad8170
      @malikahmad8170 11 місяців тому +2

      Abbas sahib: “kuchh khudda ka khouf kurrain” this place is meant for small comments and not some dissertation. I did not read it because it is too long.

    • @krishSundar
      @krishSundar 11 місяців тому

      @@malikahmad8170 what the heck . He is elder to you . Address him with due respect.

    • @skysdhprm5067
      @skysdhprm5067 11 місяців тому

      ​@@malikahmad8170😂😂

  • @sujitsk
    @sujitsk 11 місяців тому +6

    Am surprised 'narco dollars' didn't come up in what was otherwise a riveting discussion

  • @chakrabortyengineers975
    @chakrabortyengineers975 11 місяців тому +2

    Absolutely fantastic. Deeply thoughtful

  • @ModiLaoxian2024
    @ModiLaoxian2024 11 місяців тому +16

    Pakistan now - Gareeb 20 😭😭😭🤣🤣🤣🥲🥲🥲
    Pakistan after it gets divided - Gayaab 20 😹😹😹

    • @sabrinakhan8217
      @sabrinakhan8217 11 місяців тому +1

      How is Manipur doing? Plz worry about 48 crore bhooka nunga of India. Per CNN, daily 30 indians commit hunger suicides. No pakistani has ever riksha khencha or died of hunger.

    • @sushant3701k
      @sushant3701k 11 місяців тому +4

      ​@@sabrinakhan8217😂😂aate ki line me lag jao ,cnn didn't cover pakistan because whole nation is in line of aata 😂

    • @shobhitdagur1086
      @shobhitdagur1086 11 місяців тому +2

      ​@@sabrinakhan8217 India can feed all its people for 2 years if any thing doesn't grow. We are feeling 24 countries also 😂😂

    • @vivekyadav1
      @vivekyadav1 11 місяців тому +1

      @@sabrinakhan8217 Manipur is doing better than balochistan and khyber pakhtunkhwa.

    • @pashabaloch6029
      @pashabaloch6029 11 місяців тому

      Irman Khan is stupid Person like a Bawile Gand. 😂😄 Pakistan army take three years to understand that irman Khan is stupid Bawil Gand 😂😂😄both are same in there own way.

  • @tejamysore3699
    @tejamysore3699 11 місяців тому +3

    This is a good series! Please keep it up

  • @FinestaGang
    @FinestaGang 11 місяців тому +17

    Pakistan army never loses against its own civilians

    • @madandu
      @madandu 11 місяців тому +2

      Except in the east-Pakistan.

    • @FinestaGang
      @FinestaGang 11 місяців тому

      @@madandu Touché

    • @sabrinakhan8217
      @sabrinakhan8217 11 місяців тому

      @@madandu They didn't want to keep East Pakistan. Bahadur fauj planned the exclusion of communist Mujeeb and his bengali followers with USA. It was beginning of the cold war against communist USSR. It was 4 years of civil war with bengalis and then Americans stepped in with the idea of breaking Russia. To avoid public backlash and to keep 80% of share in annual budget, bahadur fauj dragged India in the war. PAF started airstrike on IAF. After few days of dishm doosham, army was ordered by ISI to surrender next door instead of surrendering to Bengalis 1000's of miles apart.

    • @pashabaloch6029
      @pashabaloch6029 11 місяців тому

      Irman Khan is stupid Person like a Bawile Gand. 😂😄 Pakistan army take three years to understand that irman Khan is stupid Bawil Gand 😂😂😄both are same in there own way.

    • @abbasakhunzada4510
      @abbasakhunzada4510 11 місяців тому

      just wait till the kp people revolt

  • @shimmy332
    @shimmy332 11 місяців тому +5

    How skewed is your information about the Tosha Khana 😅.Way before Imran was on the scene,gifts that were given to the Heads of State were placed in the Tosha khana and bought at a certain percentage of the price.Most of the previous Heads simply took away luxury cars, jewellery etc without paying anything .Imran did pay the reqd percentage for the watch which is on record.

    • @sna2409
      @sna2409 11 місяців тому

      This fool is idiot like other Hindustanis. He has no knowledge of ground realities.

    • @infodaynightconv1445
      @infodaynightconv1445 10 місяців тому

      But you are conveniently ignorning that Ik sold himself consistently as a clean skin (while denigrating others) and did not pay the Tosha Khana price even did not pay a low price first. He first sold at an exorbitant price then paid the low cost "price". IK has been scandalising other Pak leaders for almost 22 years. Now Firdaus tells us that his personal discussions with cabinet always stated "Repeat, repeat, repeat" and he didn't care how he defamed others with lies but knew the effect of "Repeat, repeat, repeat" to his fawning followers - repeating ad nauseum his version knowing it stretched the truth greatly.

  • @Unni4912
    @Unni4912 11 місяців тому +1

    Always a pleasure listening to Mr. Deveshar.

  • @shimmy332
    @shimmy332 11 місяців тому +3

    Also watch the interview w French journalist Daniel Bustard about the army disunity on this topic ,so Imran is not the voice crying in the wilderness that you are projecting.His party has been brutally disbanded by arresting and torturing elders,women, including being disrobed and forced to sign papers saying they will leave PT I.Most of them have cried when they had the pressers announcing it .

  • @drindrajeetasija5218
    @drindrajeetasija5218 11 місяців тому +1

    Great analysis .....comprehensive and factual .!

  • @hshs4051
    @hshs4051 11 місяців тому +11

    Wonderful to hear Tilak Sir 🙏🏼
    He brings in non speculative mature analysis which comes from his long experience studying Pakistan. Together with Sushant Sareen one gets a real picture of what's going on in Pakistan.
    Pakistan, I feel cannot be settled on its own feet without the begging or assistance because of its reason for creation. It just cannot prosper without losing obsession to Kashmir, trade and terrorism.... if you remove these there is no separate identity of 🇵🇰

    • @pashabaloch6029
      @pashabaloch6029 11 місяців тому

      Irman Khan is stupid Person like a Bawile Gand. 😂😄 Pakistan army take three years to understand that irman Khan is stupid Bawil Gand 😂😂😄both are same in there own way.

    • @cleopatra7377
      @cleopatra7377 11 місяців тому

      Lol it's biased, these Indian people love PAK army 😈 how DARE they tell Pakistan who should be their leader

    • @induchopra3014
      @induchopra3014 11 місяців тому

      Exactly.This is the reality.

    • @skysdhprm5067
      @skysdhprm5067 11 місяців тому

      Intellect Pakistani is more dangerous than madrsa jehadi..
      Let them in islamic rediclised ideology...

  • @user-dk6zx3gw2t
    @user-dk6zx3gw2t 5 місяців тому +1

    Tilak Sir🙏

  • @ihameed73
    @ihameed73 11 місяців тому +3

    IK did not handle COVID very well? This is coming from an Indian analyst? Really?

    • @anilkrmost
      @anilkrmost 10 місяців тому

      How did IK handled Covid?

  • @drtariqwahab
    @drtariqwahab 11 місяців тому

    Tilak saab nice to hear to your prospective.

  • @adambutt3738
    @adambutt3738 11 місяців тому +2

    It looks like i am watching a pdm politician interview. So many things said about khan were one-sided

  • @mohsinafzaal7159
    @mohsinafzaal7159 11 місяців тому +1

    Excellent program 👏

  • @aftabzaidi8610
    @aftabzaidi8610 11 місяців тому +7

    Brilliant analysis. Spot on. The Pakistani government certainly needs to get off the arrogance pedestal specially in these dire economic times. The least the government can do is open up with trade with India so food prices can get reduced

    • @induchopra3014
      @induchopra3014 11 місяців тому +2

      Apt. Pakistan is learning the hard way,whats China. This crackdown is because of a Chinese ministers visit.

  • @mng3389
    @mng3389 10 місяців тому +1

    Imran khan will be back very soon becouse pakistaníes stands with graet khan soon khan will bring nightmares to modi on world stage love imran love pak army

  • @abdulkhalid2254
    @abdulkhalid2254 11 місяців тому +1

    Imran khan is great leader , ppl of Pakistan stand with IK

  • @abdulkhalid2254
    @abdulkhalid2254 11 місяців тому +1

    Pakistan needs Imran Khan

  • @subrotomitra
    @subrotomitra 11 місяців тому

    Excellent ! a pleasure to listen to an erudite dissertation..

  • @debajyotinath5021
    @debajyotinath5021 10 місяців тому +1

    IK won't survive in jail, so he will be in exile and live a peaceful life in London/US/Dubai along with his children who all are settled abroad. Good luck to all supporters of IK and his 'naya pakistan'.

  • @javedfazal59
    @javedfazal59 11 місяців тому +2

    Mr Tilak is 100 percent correct! He is a megalomaniac!

  • @adesaia
    @adesaia 11 місяців тому

    Thanks. Buy try to give more analysis and detail if possible . Much of this is known . Thanks nevertheless for your sincere efforts

  • @aligzaidi
    @aligzaidi 11 місяців тому +3

    Real problem with Pakistan is not its economic, or other pity things that can be solved by hiring experts in related fields. Imran Khan goal is to rebuild a nation which lost its track and sleeping for last 70 years. Also please elaborate which “evening shots’ you’re referring to? To my knowledge he is a sportsman free from drug nor a consumer of alcohol unlike few Ex Pakistani generals.

    • @XYz-xf2bq
      @XYz-xf2bq 11 місяців тому

      Pakistan was never sleeping instead it was in hyper state mode

    • @aligzaidi
      @aligzaidi 10 місяців тому

      @@infodaynightconv1445 M.A Jinnah, Mandela, Erdugan and Mao were not messiah nor IK. This struggle is not about IK but for all Pakistani. People already decided to be with IK not with those Individuals who are in control of Pakistan which still live in colonial mindset and that needs to change in Pakistan.

    • @aligzaidi
      @aligzaidi 10 місяців тому

      @@infodaynightconv1445 You are right Pak Army Zindabad but few high jackers murdabad.
      Who are you BTW? Must be a Pakistan hater or a defeated soul who never seen Up/Down in life whois legs must be shaken by what is about to come next.

  • @neenachandra7968
    @neenachandra7968 11 місяців тому +1

    Imran khan May be an honest person.. But he don't have any Vision or Roadmap for his country.. Which is very important for any countries Leader..

  • @vivekyadav1
    @vivekyadav1 11 місяців тому +2

    Why is the anchor eating into so much of Devasher's time ? I thought the expert was Devasher ? 😁

  • @aneeshgk9757
    @aneeshgk9757 11 місяців тому +1

    Ma'am the podcast was good but you need to change the background

  • @HIMALAIIASCLASSES
    @HIMALAIIASCLASSES 11 місяців тому +1

    Good analysis

  • @pawanmahale3319
    @pawanmahale3319 11 місяців тому

    Nice podcast

  • @manojkumarsahoo3119
    @manojkumarsahoo3119 11 місяців тому +1

    The Pakistan army never loses a war against his own people.

  • @cricuts1
    @cricuts1 11 місяців тому +2

    No other nation will be more happy than Indians of our plight. They have an inherent disdain for us. This podcast seems to be for the moral support of N league.

  • @zulqarnainnaqvi9395
    @zulqarnainnaqvi9395 11 місяців тому

    This time people of Pakistan will not let him down. Mark my words.

  • @malikahmad8170
    @malikahmad8170 11 місяців тому +3

    As a Pakistani, I am totally in accord with Mr. Tilak. It is also my own consensus. Despite the title of Oxford education, he is not really educated in the sophisticated sense. He does not read or write. Both him and Nawaz are the products of the army. More later.

    • @XYz-xf2bq
      @XYz-xf2bq 11 місяців тому

      He remind me of sonia gandhi of india an ex oxford alumni and classmate of rajiv gandhi or her son rahul gandhi again an oxford graduate but far from being called educated. Both mediocre in politics and performance!
      Thanks!

    • @malikahmad8170
      @malikahmad8170 11 місяців тому

      @@XYz-xf2bq yes, Here “educated’ IS EQUIVALENT to the word LITERATE which makes one able to read and write. For instance, our partition leaders are really educated. At that time, educated means getting a law degree bar-at-law from UK. Gandhi, Nehru, Liaqat and Jinnah, all had law degrees from USA. However, the only person who was really well read and wrote books also, was Nehru. Bhutto (original one) was a very well read and highly educated person. He had an excellent library and most of the books were in history. Our General Zia had perhaps read only one book I.e. Holy Quran. As a mostly broke student in Lahore, I bought the first book. “the glimpses of history” written by Nehru which I still have it. Our cricket hero and Kuptaan also went to Oxford and got some bare one education including our Foreign Minister Bilawal Bhutto. I read the Indian FM is well read. I doubt if Putin have the habit of reading and writing other than reading secret reports about his enemies. PS. I remember a Pakistani friend who went to Ajmer Sharif and upon return brought truckload of new and used books instead of the traditional items like paan and alachis (cardamom)

    • @XYz-xf2bq
      @XYz-xf2bq 11 місяців тому

      @@malikahmad8170 Yes!
      Another masterpiece by pt.jee is his autobiography. As far as i have gathered except subhas chandra bose none of our ICS of undivided indian origin had active participation in our freedom struggle so it naturally gave space to lawyers to fill this vaccum in our struggle for freedom. Rest i doubt capacity of Lala jee, Tilak or Vipin chandra. They too had no vision of independent india. Mahatma had amazing capacity of mass mobilization. Ultimately pt.jee modernity triumphed all
      Remember it took many years of efforts persuasion of pt.jee to pass hindu code bill in both houses before it became law. So i consider him social reformer apart from great freedom fighter,writer, thinker
      and visionary. He spend his 22 yrs in jail.
      Thanks!

    • @mohammadkhizarrehman7158
      @mohammadkhizarrehman7158 11 місяців тому

      You are biased. He reads and has authored and co-authored 6 Books.

    • @malikahmad8170
      @malikahmad8170 11 місяців тому

      @@mohammadkhizarrehman7158 the easiest thing is to allege bias without any counter arguments.

  • @tehsinahmed9065
    @tehsinahmed9065 11 місяців тому

    We understand your worries very well.

    • @XYz-xf2bq
      @XYz-xf2bq 11 місяців тому

      What worry?
      If india would have in worry it is the best time to invade pakistan for indian army. I want you to remain forever as buffer state between india and Afghanistan and iran and central asia. And if i am in worry i will prepare myself for any mis adventure pakistan. An economically broken pakistan, politically divided which has trouble at her home and from western border is ideal for indian army and present political dispensation of india for any war.. If you are so much confident try to flex your muscle!
      Thanks!

  • @kaushaljariwala5468
    @kaushaljariwala5468 11 місяців тому

    This lady is much better than the one at ANI. Much respectful and un-interrupting.

    • @michaelmyers2826
      @michaelmyers2826 11 місяців тому +3

      Because she has absolutely zero knowledge about Pak politics and has nothing to add up.
      Whereas Smita Prakash is having decades long Experience of Journalism, she even went to Pakistan tens of times to interview the senior political and military leadership. Please have some knowledge before barking.

    • @kaushaljariwala5468
      @kaushaljariwala5468 11 місяців тому

      Why don't you eat your own shit and keep quite, perhaps that suits you more, than farting from your mouth...
      If she is so knowledgeable then keep doing podcast on he own. Why to invite other guests, inturpt them and waste viewrs/listeners time..

    • @kaushaljariwala5468
      @kaushaljariwala5468 11 місяців тому

      I just checked your other comments, go shit somewhere on some other channel you little crying narcissist bitch

  • @subro3439
    @subro3439 11 місяців тому +3

    Imran Khan should be worried as Pak army will not leave him.

  • @rajendrajasathy4356
    @rajendrajasathy4356 11 місяців тому +1

    HT needs to lean something from Palaki or Smita Prakash on how to set podcast env....kya dull scene hai...

  • @SalimKhan-dm2oq
    @SalimKhan-dm2oq 10 місяців тому

    Love and support IK unconditionally

  • @babahanuman83
    @babahanuman83 11 місяців тому +2

    fine and interesting. only one point: pak is more in imf and worldbank debttrap than in chinese debttrap. see the numbers. 20% china, 60 percent imf and worldbank, rest other governments.

    • @michaelmyers2826
      @michaelmyers2826 11 місяців тому

      Wrong data. 27% IMF, 25% China, 21% Private foreign banks

  • @AliKhan-oh9ks
    @AliKhan-oh9ks 11 місяців тому

    💚❤ BAHRIA TOWN LAHORE
    💚❤ BAHRIA TOWN KARACHI
    💚❤ BAHRIA TOWN ISLAMABAD
    💚❤ BAHRIA TOWN RAWALPINDI

  • @AB-jw3mz
    @AB-jw3mz 11 місяців тому +1

    What is missing in breaking up of Pakistan, is Indian commitment. Without India, East Pakistan would have never become Bangladesh. now the Baloch, Sindhi, Hazara and the Patan are crying for our help, but Modi is sitting on his hands. Sad but true to say that Indra Gandhi was the only PM with balls in India.

    • @Raja-pr1ex
      @Raja-pr1ex 11 місяців тому

      Good to know that she was a transgender

    • @AB-jw3mz
      @AB-jw3mz 11 місяців тому

      @@Raja-pr1ex would you prefer a man / woman / transgender who will cut Pak into pieces? or a bullshitter who only talks about it in political rallies-

  • @sna2409
    @sna2409 11 місяців тому +2

    I closed this interview after 8 mins. The old goat is fool.

  • @hshs4051
    @hshs4051 11 місяців тому +1

    Anyways Imran Khan any day was the best bet for India. I feel the current political dispensation did disservice for themselves by picking up power last year when Imran Khan was kicked out. If he was allowed to continue he would have made matters worse.

  • @shimmy332
    @shimmy332 11 місяців тому +1

    All I will say is 'do your research'.

  • @bhargavrm
    @bhargavrm 11 місяців тому +1

    Shezaad Poonawala is a young upcoming gem in the BJP cadre...!!! ❤

  • @monjourhossain7955
    @monjourhossain7955 11 місяців тому

    IK is a brand personality

  • @pashabaloch6029
    @pashabaloch6029 11 місяців тому +2

    Tell me one pathan who left irman Khan PTI 😂😂😄😄😄

  • @justiceweneed8007
    @justiceweneed8007 11 місяців тому +1

    Asif munir will run for life if all Pakistani awam will come outs once

  • @jamilmalik6296
    @jamilmalik6296 11 місяців тому

    Very interesting and an informative show. A well informed guest.

  • @Haris802
    @Haris802 11 місяців тому +2

    If the Indian people and their government focus on the welfare of their own people instead of Pakistan, maybe their poverty can be reduced.

    • @nousername1587
      @nousername1587 11 місяців тому +4

      Look who is talking 🤣🤣

    • @Haris802
      @Haris802 11 місяців тому

      @@nousername1587 Whoever is speaking, we have no interest in them, but they are concerned about Pakistan, they should speak for the welfare of the poor people of their own country instead of Pakistan which is not their rights to comment on.

    • @prakwandutta2861
      @prakwandutta2861 11 місяців тому +1

      @@Haris802 we are focusing...
      But intelectual and security official of india must watch on indian neighborhood including pakistan.

    • @narujohn6984
      @narujohn6984 11 місяців тому

      Only pukes think that Indian govt. focuses on Pukestan. Lol, pukestan doesn't occupy even 1% of Indian foreign policy. Indians though watch pukestan, who doesn't want to see comedy club.

    • @madmax-bu6wt
      @madmax-bu6wt 11 місяців тому +1

      Go stand in atta queue. poverty is increasing as speed of light in pakistan

  • @Kanan180
    @Kanan180 11 місяців тому +3

    But why are they discussing him we should focus on our issues and forget them 😂

    • @Mr_ST_720
      @Mr_ST_720 11 місяців тому

      America and china indirectly encourage Pakistan to use funds against India. Pakistan creates in india sleeper cells, madrasa funds, secret political funding to local muslim goons n areas n khalistan through hawala, it keeps india muslim population interest not to align for matters of uniform civil code, population control , waff board n other minority rebellion to pull down economic progress of India . Core issue of uttar Pradesh, Kashmir, Kerala and Assam is muslim population creating dangerous anti india areas n localities all encouraged by Pakistan.. dawood is big example n china uae America n other nations wants India's progress not to exceed theirs..so takes help of Pakistan.. just check why Pakistani generals salary is equivalent to software Engineer n software architects salaries of Bangalore..how many anti india tasks each one handles so that they are paid in dollars like software engineer

    • @amjadsk.2469
      @amjadsk.2469 11 місяців тому +6

      Dumb statement. Everyone must know about geo politics because it affects our lives directly or indirectly.

    • @firstsparkle5378
      @firstsparkle5378 11 місяців тому +7

      Not only policy makers, but even conscious Indian citizens must have a close eye on what is going in Pakistan.... It is a country, which initiated 4 wars against India & continue to use proxy wars & terrorist activities against India which costed India almost 2 lakhs deaths & billion of dollars.... It's extremely important to have an understanding & analysis regarding what is going in Pakistan bec their situation translates into their actions & those actions impact India.... In the words of Shekhar Gupta(the print) - "Pakistan's politics should be treated as internal politics of India".

    • @firstsparkle5378
      @firstsparkle5378 11 місяців тому +4

      Information converts into analysis which provide "clarity of thought".... & in today's world- Information, analysis & clarity of thought is the key to success.

    • @banatireang8161
      @banatireang8161 11 місяців тому

      They are discussing content hi content for the view

  • @irshadhasnain7156
    @irshadhasnain7156 10 місяців тому +1

    The speaker knows everything but does not know why he is popular?

  • @vinodhaboloor7181
    @vinodhaboloor7181 11 місяців тому

    Excellent podcast 👏

  • @justiceweneed8007
    @justiceweneed8007 11 місяців тому +1

    If imran khan doesn't know how to run pakistan then no one knows

  • @niteshkapoor1276
    @niteshkapoor1276 11 місяців тому

    how do u explain the billions of the ex- general ? .......................Tilak Devasher

  • @YouTubeofnaveenvyas
    @YouTubeofnaveenvyas 11 місяців тому

    Who’s so naive and illiterate to have suggested and added background music during highlights for a podcast 🤷🏻‍♂️- Reallyyyyyyyyyy!!!!!!

  • @mintdel333
    @mintdel333 11 місяців тому +1

    Ht studio team 3rd class

  • @shimmy332
    @shimmy332 11 місяців тому +1

    Not sure what the agenda is here,or just misinformation 🤔

  • @dddd-xh7km
    @dddd-xh7km 11 місяців тому +2

    यदि पाकिस्तान आर्मी को इमरान खान के साथ वही करना है जो जिया उल हक ने भुट्टो के साथ किया था तो इसमें देर क्यों हो रही है ?

    • @sumitnimawat7408
      @sumitnimawat7408 11 місяців тому

      Because Bhutto was sindhi and imran khan is a Punjabi

  • @malikahmad8170
    @malikahmad8170 11 місяців тому

    We don’t even have enough grass now.

  • @LordGNome1000
    @LordGNome1000 11 місяців тому

    Ab ANI ki smita ne shuru Kiya hai; toh sabko podcast karna hai ab!!!

  • @I0-_-0I
    @I0-_-0I 11 місяців тому

    Riyasat e Madina 😅 He did take Pakistan back to 1400 years ago...😂

  • @Wanderer975
    @Wanderer975 11 місяців тому +5

    @0:10 Tilak, you are very ignorant about Imran khan's government tenure.
    Pakistan economy was growing at 6% (Now 0.3).
    Exports increased from 20 to 30 billion dollars.
    IK took welfare initiatives like Sehat Card which allowed any citizen to get free treatment of diseases upto 10 lakh rupees in a year.
    He created Shelters that give free Food and place to sleep for poor workers in major cities.
    He started making Dams to preserve Water.
    He started building IT sector and during his government IT exports hot a big boost.
    He started reforms to create a better environment for investments.
    And so much more...
    Who gave you any right to judge if he is good for Pakistan or not.
    That's our decision.
    People of Pakistan know what he has achieved and what he can do more if allowed into power.
    Over 70% people in Pakistan supports him.
    That's why this Corrupt government has violated Constitution to stop elections.
    That's why Army chief asim munir is kidnapping his party members and torturing them until they agree to leave PTI.
    But people in Pakistan would still support him.
    I know the reason why india is confused.

    • @zulqarnainnaqvi9395
      @zulqarnainnaqvi9395 11 місяців тому

      Very correct analysis

    • @malikahmad8170
      @malikahmad8170 11 місяців тому +2

      Wanderer: this gentleman’s has a pulse on Pakistan-as a Pakistani, I must admit an excellent analysis. The Kuptaan has given us nothing but disappointment, frustration, and hopelessness. He is as corrupt as Sharifs and Zardari’s, if not more. It is bs to call him Mr, Clean. Had wasted our time and a golden opportunity was given to him and he did not know what to do by hiring and appointing mediocre people like Buzdar and then becoming stubborn on it. Since he was ousted, he mostly had nothing agitating politics. This parliamentary system is based on alliances, cooperation and dialogues

    • @neenachandra7968
      @neenachandra7968 11 місяців тому

      True Imran khan wil only make a century and Pakistan will become free of troubles😂😂😂

  • @noorahmed5649
    @noorahmed5649 11 місяців тому +1

    khan is coming back .....

  • @adesaia
    @adesaia 11 місяців тому

    If the people and army can somehow get off this bus where they need to sort out kashmir which only they think they need to do they will suddenly prosper . I cant believe the Pakistani Punjabi or Sindhi somehow like Chinese government and people and willing to let them just take control of key infrastructure.. maybe so but hard to believe . They will gave more danger from this loss than from India which frankly doesn't want anything anymore from Pakistan or it's people . Just draw the line keep what u have and move on

    • @shimmy332
      @shimmy332 11 місяців тому

      Of course India doesnt want want Pakistan.Too many problems.
      Just stop negative propaganda and behave like a superpower w dignity

  • @asadabbasmirza9519
    @asadabbasmirza9519 11 місяців тому

    So what ,if it breks up
    We t oppressed got azaadee but got another rule

  • @asadabbasmirza9519
    @asadabbasmirza9519 11 місяців тому +1

    Just repeating pakistani media,
    Had he been ..

  • @shimmy332
    @shimmy332 11 місяців тому +1

    His books are misleading and devoid of facts

  • @shairali2962
    @shairali2962 11 місяців тому

    Should be otherwise around .
    ....

  • @rakeshkoul92
    @rakeshkoul92 11 місяців тому

    Amazing analysis , the moderator is amazing and so is Mr Tilak,
    My two cents is that if India wants to be hawkish then forget everything and wait and watch what is happening in Pakistan,
    But if India is not hawkish , then India has to tame Pakistan Army , if Pakistan is not playing then all cards are on the table and India has to protect its borders whether the enemy country is thirsty or hungry..
    The expert is hung on a imaginary situation, I am requesting the expert to watch online videos where commom people of Pakistan have AR 15 automatic guns waiting to cross border with China's help , the expert wants to provide water to these people ,,, it is a time to rethink all of these things, Jai Hind.

  • @nousername1587
    @nousername1587 11 місяців тому +1

    Change the host please

  • @Mayank-wq9yc
    @Mayank-wq9yc 11 місяців тому

    Imran himself criticising the head of army

  • @Rayanmiah6940
    @Rayanmiah6940 11 місяців тому

    Torturing an innocent person sadly Army is forgetting that what goes around it comes around

  • @Oddly_Fascinting
    @Oddly_Fascinting 11 місяців тому +5

    This guy is clewless about alot of stuff😂😂 khan is the only hope

  • @GamingStarslegends01
    @GamingStarslegends01 11 місяців тому +1

    Imran is not scared of death

    • @Gr8putin
      @Gr8putin 11 місяців тому +3

      But his pti lieutants are scared . a single man can’t run the show for party

    • @shobhitdagur1086
      @shobhitdagur1086 11 місяців тому +2

      He will remain the last scared man if he lives

    • @GamingStarslegends01
      @GamingStarslegends01 11 місяців тому

      @@shobhitdagur1086 he have already options to leave pakistan but he is staying of he is scared he will leave pakostan

    • @banatireang8161
      @banatireang8161 11 місяців тому +2

      Every1 is afraid of dying its100%true,and if not they are the only gorkha regiment but imran is not a gorkha he is a dhokaa

    • @madmax-bu6wt
      @madmax-bu6wt 11 місяців тому

      He will fight till last youthia and then run away. He is coward who does not own up his illegitimate daughter. Perhaps in islam that ic called bravery 😂

  • @atifmanzoor63
    @atifmanzoor63 11 місяців тому

    You’re missing one major point the army tried to assassinate him

  • @arsalanmirza3411
    @arsalanmirza3411 11 місяців тому

    Arey Dikra 🧐 Don’t worry 😉 Be happy 😂 and Think Positive 👍 Civil “war” in Pakistan 🇵🇰 means BHARAT “MATA” will become “AKHAND” BHARAT once again 👏 🎉

    • @Aashu299
      @Aashu299 11 місяців тому +1

      No, thank you! Pakistan can disintegrate into 4 different nations. We want nothing except POK.

    • @arsalanmirza3411
      @arsalanmirza3411 11 місяців тому

      @@Aashu299 Yeah in your dreams 🛌 😴 Wake up ⬆️ CHINA 🇨🇳 is on your door step 😂🤣

    • @Aashu299
      @Aashu299 11 місяців тому

      @@arsalanmirza3411 you guys were saying that in 2017 when Doklam happened, before that you were threatening us in 2013 about 2014 once Americans leave Afghanistan, you will come to Kashmir, then 2020 Galwan and now again. 🤣 Marrying your cousin and then producing babies has weakened your mind. You can’t simply understand we are way above your league. We are not like you. Don’t worry about us! Your Abbu China knows it.

    • @pashabaloch6029
      @pashabaloch6029 11 місяців тому

      Irman Khan is stupid Person like a Bawile Gand. 😂😄 Pakistan army take three years to understand that irman Khan is stupid Bawil Gand 😂😂😄both are same in there own way.

  • @thenationalist4772
    @thenationalist4772 11 місяців тому

    Anything about Pak is black comedy, parody, and spoof for Indians. Popcorn entertainment.

  • @jasjitgrewal8680
    @jasjitgrewal8680 11 місяців тому

    Imran flew too close to sun, he’s going to go down from heat now

  • @mohamedfarookaziz9290
    @mohamedfarookaziz9290 10 місяців тому +1

    ASIM TUJAY SARI DUNIA GALIA DA RAHI HA. APNI IZZAT KA THORA SI TOH SHARAM KERO

  • @abidjabbar358
    @abidjabbar358 11 місяців тому +2

    Ab ik ko ghabrana hey

  • @asadabbasmirza9519
    @asadabbasmirza9519 11 місяців тому +1

    He is clean

  • @khurramali452
    @khurramali452 10 місяців тому

    Imran Khan ghabrata nhe hai usne saare choro or pore GHQ ko ghabraht men dala hoa hai

  • @shahabtangwani2858
    @shahabtangwani2858 11 місяців тому +1

    useless analysis.this guy dont ground reality.he is biased about imran khan.

  • @Wayseller
    @Wayseller 11 місяців тому

    Deveshar. Devasher?

    • @shimmy332
      @shimmy332 11 місяців тому

      Dishwasher???😅

  • @manzoorelahi5132
    @manzoorelahi5132 11 місяців тому

    Sorry Sir but you are not aware of ground reality here in Pakistan

  • @erjamaludeen
    @erjamaludeen 10 місяців тому +1

    Poor analysis of Imran Khan.

  • @malikahmad8170
    @malikahmad8170 11 місяців тому

    Okay, here, is my question, if you are so democratic, champion of human rights blah, blah, why had you not condemned the blanket Russian aggression against Ukraine? You should know that Russia would come of this war as a second rate power even if they win this war.

  • @cleopatra7377
    @cleopatra7377 11 місяців тому +1

    MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS 😡 WE LOVE KHAN

  • @Ashfaq_saab
    @Ashfaq_saab 11 місяців тому

    Uncle baqwaas na karou imran khan is fighting for us

  • @zunairakashif47
    @zunairakashif47 11 місяців тому

    Sounds like Tilak has run many successful campaigns like the one Iman is running. You guys should do your homework otherwise what is the point of having this stupid talk.

  • @becooldontfreez
    @becooldontfreez 11 місяців тому +1

    36:48 what's so funny about that... Afghan have ruled you Indians while you guys can't handle a country a quarter of your size... as an Afghan I sometimes believe Pakistani claim that one Pakistani is equal to 10 Hindus true.

  • @asadabbasmirza9519
    @asadabbasmirza9519 11 місяців тому +2

    What a nonsense
    Speak to genuine people in media.
    He has become another Major Agarval.
    Read the statistics on economy before ths Govt.
    Now ...
    Punjab humaraa sindh tumhaara.