To overcome this, problem, then there should be All India Judicial Service Commission for recruitment of judges of Supreme Court and High court and give opportunity to everyone. This will give transparent and equal chance to the deserving.
Collegium must be abolished. Commission for recruitment be established consisting of academics. High court judge and supreme court judge should be totally excluded. Member from Bar should face examination. Member of Bench should be based on quantity and quality of cases disposed and other activities since first appointment ie civil judge jr division. Those appointed directly to higher judiciary ie district judge, must put on 15 to 20 years in service.
Best solution is National judicial academy wherein qualifications must be set for candidates for eligibility like at least 15 years of active practice at bar At least 40 judgments wherein candidate has argued At least 40 written synopsis filed in courts to see his drafting skill Written exam and Interview The committee must comprise of three Supreme Court senior judges, two top law professors , two top psychological experts Then only candidates can be fair and selection can be fair
Best solution is National judicial academy wherein qualifications must be set for candidates for eligibility like at least 15 years of active practice at bar At least 40 judgments wherein candidate has argued At least 40 written synopsis filed in courts to see his drafting skill Written exam and Interview
In my opinion, the collegium system should be abolished, instead written examination should be conducted in which whosoever obtains 80 percent marks, should be interviewed by the Supreme Court judges for 20 percent marks and the top scorers should be appointed.
To overcome this, problem, then there should be All India Judicial Service Commission for recruitment of judges of Supreme Court and High court and give opportunity to everyone. This will give transparent and equal chance to the deserving.
Paper valuation not by judges And politicians
Collegium must be abolished. Commission for recruitment be established consisting of academics. High court judge and supreme court judge should be totally excluded. Member from Bar should face examination. Member of Bench should be based on quantity and quality of cases disposed and other activities since first appointment ie civil judge jr division. Those appointed directly to higher judiciary ie district judge, must put on 15 to 20 years in service.
No person having qualification, ability to become High court or supreme। Court jugde be discarded on the basis of being a member of judges family
Best solution is National judicial academy wherein qualifications must be set for candidates for eligibility like
at least 15 years of active practice at bar
At least 40 judgments wherein candidate has argued
At least 40 written synopsis filed in courts to see his drafting skill
Written exam and Interview
The committee must comprise of three Supreme Court senior judges, two top law professors , two top psychological experts
Then only candidates can be fair and selection can be fair
Abolish re command first
Best solution is National judicial academy wherein qualifications must be set for candidates for eligibility like
at least 15 years of active practice at bar
At least 40 judgments wherein candidate has argued
At least 40 written synopsis filed in courts to see his drafting skill
Written exam and Interview
In my opinion, the collegium system should be abolished, instead written examination should be conducted in which whosoever obtains 80 percent marks, should be interviewed by the Supreme Court judges for 20 percent marks and the top scorers should be appointed.
I J S* exam need