Massey Ferguson 5S VS John Deere 6M
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 січ 2022
- #MF5S #JD6M #MASSEYFERGUSON #JOHNDEERE
Two tractors tested by a farmer and compared in detail. See the remarkable differences* between the brand new Massey Ferguson 5S Exclusive edition and the legendary John Deere 6M Premium edition. Test report in English.
Zwei Traktoren, die von einem Landwirt getestet und im Detail verglichen wurden. Sehen Sie die bemerkenswerten Unterschiede zwischen dem brandneuen Massey Ferguson 5S Exclusive und dem legendären John Deere 6M Premium. Prüfbericht auf Englisch.
Deux tracteurs testés par un agriculteur et comparés en détail. Découvrez les différences remarquables entre le tout nouveau Massey Ferguson 5S Exclusive et le légendaire John Deere 6M Premium. Rapport d'essai en anglais.
Twee tractoren door een veehouder getest en met elkaar vergeleken tot in detail. Zie hier de opmerkelijke verschillen tussen de gloednieuwe Massey Ferguson 5S Exclusive en de legendarische John Deere 6M Premium. Testbericht in Engels.
*)If differences are not mentioned, it means that both brands offer the same functionality.
Supplement for MF benefits:
88. Automatic battery ground switch included.
89. Wider range (up to 500 rpm) of maximum torque.
90. Better air flow under bonnet, no fingers burned on side panels
91. Weight distribution between front and rear axle is more appropriate.
92. Agco Power has longer experience with SCR (Ad Blue) after-treatment system.
93. Power reverser on transmission lever.
94. PTO start adjustable (slow - normal - quick start).
95. Additional digital display of engine temperature, transmission temperature and battery voltage.
96. Automatic field detection in Auto-Guide.
97. Luxury seat upholstery and no boring colour.
98. Available with Grammer Dualmotion headrest
99. Better rockerswitch for rear linkage with up/neutral/down position
100.Diesel and AdBlue meters have much larger scales, easier to read.
101.Larger cab glass surface.
102.Higher seating position in the cab.
103.Red Dot product design award winner 2022.
Update MF (07-2022)
Temporarily available in special 175th anniversary colours limited edition.
Supplement for JD benefits:
22. Side windows have more solid lock mechanism.
23. Exhaust is more stable with less vibration.
24. Mirrors stay better in position.
25. Quick respond on power reverser.
26. Available with parklock if you choose Autopowr (IVT).
27. Cab suspension adjustable.
28. Less engine oil.
29. More choice in gearboxes.
30. Higher maximum permissible weight in option.
Update JD AutoTrac (07-2022):
John Deere now offers a new way to use AutoTrac guidance on machines from other manufacturers. To get AutoTrac onto a non-John Deere machine, John Deere cleverly uses an ISOBUS feature: AutoTrac TIM activation for Universal Generation 4 Displays, allows farmers to use the AutoTrac guidance system on other manufacturers' tractors. To use John Deere's AutoTrac TIM track guidance, users need the following items:
- ISOBUS display John Deere Gen4 Universal 4240 or 4640
- Satellite receiver John Deere StarFire 6000 or 7000
- Tractor with AEF-TIM certification
Rectification: The MF5S uses more engine oil when replacing: 16 l. vs 11,6 l. for the JD6M. - Авто та транспорт
Interesting comparison- thanks! For me, the 5S is by far the more modern tractor. Really sleek looks, too.
Vielen dank für die netten Worte. Freut mich sehr. Viele Grüsse.
I really like these two brands.
I prefer the 6120 because it has a simple interior design and is a very solid machine.
Sure, JD solid as rock🤘
De MF 5S serie heeft sinds enkele maanden een fabrieksupdate gekregen op motorsoftware. Daarmee zouden alle modellen de beschikking hebben gekregen over ongeveer 5 pk transportboost, beschikbaar vanaf versnelling 2E tot 4F. Bijvoorbeeld een MF 5S.125 gaat van 125 pk naar 130 pk met boost. Het maximaal koppel gaat van 520 Nm naar 540 Nm. Het maximale toerental is verhoogd van 2100 naar 2200 t/min. Het stationair toerental bij gebruik van de handrem is verlaagd van 750 t/min. naar 700 t/min. De boost is niet beschikbaar voor hydraulisch vermogen of aftakaswerk.
Die Baureihe MF 5S hat in den letzten Monaten ein werkseitiges Update der Motorsoftware erhalten. Damit hätten alle Modelle etwa 5 PS an Transportleistung gewonnen, die von Gang 2E bis 4F verfügbar sind. Ein MF 5S.125 zum Beispiel steigert seine Leistung von 125 PS auf 130 PS mit Boost. Das maximale Drehmoment wird von 520 Nm auf 540 Nm erhöht. Die Höchstgeschwindigkeit wird von 2100 auf 2200 U/min erhöht. Die Leerlaufdrehzahl bei angezogener Handbremse wird von 750 U/min auf 700 U/min reduziert. Der Boost ist nicht für hydraulische Leistung oder Zapfwellenarbeiten verfügbar.
Ik heb van de MF importeur of MF Beauvais (fabriek) niets vernomen van een update op motorsoftware. Het is in ieder geval niet gecommuniceerd met de buitenwereld. Mocht het wel waar zijn, dan is de toch al pittige MF 5S, door zijn gunstige vermogens - gewichts verhouding nog sneller in transportwerk dan de JD 6M. Dank je wel voor het delen.
Fergusson front design is 10/10
I agree 😊 Especially this one🤩: photos.app.goo.gl/JeRabUzbTpnPLwAu7
made by a huge massey fan
Still a good relationship with my JD dealer😉😃
A tratar de um dinheiro é mais bonito de trator da Case e da Massey Ferguson
Due belle macchine ma MF e superiore
I like both brands which is why I'm checking out both. I'm also checking both out. I'm also checking Case IH and New Holland along with fendt.
Case IH and New Holland are pretty much the same, as are MF 5S and Valtra G series. The advantage of NHC tractors is the large choice of gearboxes. Some parts at Fendt and MF are identical (Agco), but the price difference is big. Try a demo tractor and you will experience the differences. Good luck.👍
@@maayenshof
Thanks I'll see what I can do. About demoing those tractors. With tractor availability being scarce on new models it might be hard right now.
Can you compare 6s and 6r?
Unfortunately not. The 6R would be a much better approximation to the MF 5S, but it comes at a higher price tag.
Some points of the 6R: larger turning circle, larger cabin, more luxurious command arm, available with 50 km/h, larger lifting capacity, optional 225-litre diesel tank, higher own weight, more extensive headland management, boost also with hydraulic power, dynamic weighing with front loader, hydraulic pneumatic cabin suspension, speedsteer, panorama doors, A-pillar display. Find out more at your JD dealer.
John Deere looks like it’s stuck in the 90’s
Massey Ferguson’s 5S Series tractor has received the Red Dot Award for product design 2022. But tastes differ. I personally think the John Deere is a beautiful tractor.
Its not regarding only John deer but some us cars stuck in time too
Winner MASSEY FERGUSON 😎
For you the winner, but there are always wishes left over.
My advice to MF is to get a perfect tractor:
Stop reversing the gearshift pattern when driving in reverse. Pushing the lever away from you is always accelerating.
Use the same hydraulic multi-lever in all S Series.
Introduce a double-clutch gearbox. It's already there in the 8S.
Mirrors that can also be extended electrically.
Widen the back of the command arm a little, to get more space for the elbow.
Develop a 4-pillar cab.
Develop a roof, where with and without visio roof, the roof always looks the same.
Cab suspension can be set more flexible.
The steering wheel should be able to be turned with a flat hand without feeling the spokes.
Remove the crossbar in front of the windscreen.
Create more storage space in the cabin.
Modify the cable entry hatch in the rear window.
Move the rear window wiper motor into the roof edge.
Give the front window wiper a larger stroke.
A style corner display.
Electric parklock under steering wheel.
Reversing camera in the rear roof.
Handrails at entry door further forward, for better access to cab.
Boost on PTO power.
LED rear lights, LED headlights and LED beacons.
Economy mode on front PTO, available by Zuidberg not by MF.
Black rims from factory.
Leather steering wheel.
Upholstered cab posts.
Improved braking.
Separate oil circuit for transmission and hydraulics.
Mobile phone attachment on command arm.
50 km/h
Anyone want to finish this list? So MF can learn from it.
5s segmenti 6 segmenti mi
Still Deere for us.
Great choice, enjoy it!!
Mf the best
John deere for sure
@@erichamilton5932 I agree on paper mf win. but I use john deere on field the last 20 years and they work perfect and zero damages
@@leo2090 Fair enough buddy. All the best.
Αδελφέ δουλεύω και εγώ τα τελευταία 15 χρόνια mf και δεν έχω την παραμικρή ζημιά! Όλα είναι στον χειριστη και στην σωστή συντήρηση του ελκυστηρα ασχέτως μαρκας
@@apokour3114 συμφωνώ μαζί σου απλά εγώ προτιμώ john deere.
MF