SLICK TRICK SS3 Broadhead Test
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 жов 2024
- This is a test of the Slick Trick SS3, 100 gr broadhead.
I'm using a Bowtech SR6 at 72# & 27" draw length and Bishop FOC King Arrows, 460 grs.
I have also picked up a new sponsor with my top recommendation for Broadhead Sharpening. staysharpguide... or @Innovative Outdoorsman The support I get for that has helped me improve my channel.
In case you're not familiar with my new test protocol, here is what I'm doing now:
1. Flight Test--1 field point & 2 broadheads out my by Bowtech SR6 at 40 yds, to see how well they group together.
2. Sharpness Test: I have a new test for edge sharpness and edge retention, using the Edge on Up Sharpness Tester. I test it out of the box and then again after Penetration Test 1, to see the edge retention.
What are some common scores for other edges? Here are some examples:
A butter knife takes 2000 grams of pressure to break the co polymer wire.
A new high end cutlery edge takes approx 375 grams of pressure to break the wire.
A utility razor blade takes approx 200 grams to break the wire.
Based on the many broadheads I have tested, here is my scoring scale:
Out of the Box Sharpness:
0-200 gr: 10
201-300 gr 9
301-400 gr: 8
401-500 gr: 7
501-600 gr: 6
601-700 gr: 5
701-800 gr: 4
801-900 gr: 3
901-1000 gr: 2
1001-1100 gr: 1
1101+ gr: 0
3. Edge Retention: Sharpness difference after Penetration Test 1:
10 minus 1 point for every 50 grams of sharpness difference. For example, if the initial sharpness was 400 gr of pressure and the sharpness after Penetration Test 1 was 450, the head would receive a 9 for Edge Retention Score.
4. Penetration Test 1: one shot into a combined medium of 2/3" of rubber mat, 1/2" MDF and Clear Ballistics FBI Grade Gel. This is to roughly simulate the tissue of an animal--hide, bone and muscle/fat.
5. Penetration Test 2: one shot into layers of cardboard.
6. Durability Test: For fixed blade heads, I take up to 5 shots into .22 ga steel plate and then evaluate the damage to the head. This is a good test to see the overall durability of the blades, as well as their connection to the ferrule. For mechanical heads, I take up to 5 shots into 1/2" MDF and then evaluate the damage to the head.
7. Concrete Test. This is a zero penetration test, which is a good test of the overall structural integrity of a head.
NOTE: Of course I understand we don't hunt steel plates and concrete, but all of these tests simply provide DATA POINTS for you to use in determining which broadhead is best for your hunting purposes. A well placed shot with pretty much any broadhead will get the job done most of the time. But why not prepare for the worst and buy the best you can?
If one head can hold up to multiple shots in steel & concrete-and another cannot--all other things equal, wouldn't you want to use the head that can withstand the steel and concrete? And after taking hundreds of animals with my bow, I've seen some bone shots cause more damage to a broadhead than even a cinder block.
The goal for all of us is to stack the odds in our favor as much as possible, and select a broadhead that is as lethal as possible for our bow/arrow set up and for the animal we are hunting.
At the end of each of my broadhead tests, you will find a score sheet listing all the results of the testing, so you can compare heads based on what factors matter to you the most. I also have an overall LUSK GRADE that is an evaluation of how the head performed in all the tests combined.
#Slick Trick
#Broadhead
#StaySharpGuide
Here are my Personal Discount Codes for other Broadheads that I'd like to share with you:
SEVR: LUSKFIVE
Tooth of the Arrow: LUSK19
Afflictor: LUSK10
Any financial support I get from my sponsor or from the discount codes is invested into my channel.
Man, you answered all my questions in this video before I asked.
Glad to hear that James.
Great visual on the "wound channel" with these heads using the sheet steel. You've got this testing protocol dialed.
Thank you Jared.
Love your broadhead tests man! Have you ever considered incorporating a deflection test in your broadhead reviews?
It might be too subjective to the weight & balance of your arrow build. Not many people shooting those Bishop arrows.
Thank you. I used to do an angle test, but almost every head did very well thru it...so I stopped doing it. I may add it back in in the future. I appreciate the comment and suggestion.
Waited long for this one!
Very good. Thanks Justin.
Need a xl version, , not enough big cut fixed heads , g5 striker magnum that sort of thing ,
Yep...there are not many larger cut single piece heads...but Tooth of the Arrow XL does make one.
Wow 👏!! Very impressive.. I'm definitely a fan of this style of broadheads. I love the annihilators. I. Definitely interested in these. Thank you to who ever sent them in. Great video John! Thank you sir
Thank you Mikey. Much appreciated brother.
If it came in a 125 or a 150 I'd be all over that!
Yeah, I wish they did.
Great review Mr. John!!!!
Thank you Mike
Are these available in 125 grain? If not, they should be.
Nope, at least not yet. I agree.
Very impressive!!!!
Agreed. Thank you sir.
Will the head still be “effective” without using the Stay Sharp? I have a standard stone and was going to sharpen 60 degrees
Yes it will...plenty effective. Just not as sharp.
Thanks for putting out this amazing content! I looked but didn’t see a review for the Strickland Helix Broadhead. Have you ever tested or shot that one?
I've shot them in the past, but not tested them. I'd sure like to, but they won't respond to my requests to send me heads to test.
I don’t know if I’m the only one but I would like to see one more edge retention test after the cardboard penetration. These are great videos regardless though!
Thanks for the comment. I have considered that. However, it wouldn't be a fair test, because there is a significant difference in how many layers of cardboard the heads penetrate thru. Some have done as many as 65 and others 45--almost 50% difference. Those that don't penetrate thru as many layers would "retain" their edge much more than those that penetrate deeply. The penetration in MDF/Rubber Mat & Gel also vary, but no where near as much, and the difference is all in Gel, so it doesn't make a quantifiable difference in edge retention.
Great review! Slick Trick looks like a good broadhead. I might try this broadhead this deer season. BTW, steel products are mostly black oxide finish. Anodizing is a coating/finishing process done on aluminum products.
Oh thank you.
Nice tutorial on how to do the sandpaper sharpening. I’ve used that technique many times as a professional woodworker especially when restoring a tool that has been abused. Be sure to put a very flat backing behind the sandpaper such as glass or flat polished granite.
Thanks Nick. In this case the backing is curved, but also very smooth; it changes the bevel angle from 60 degrees to 44.
I have been waiting for this 🙌
Very good. Thank you.
New heat treated version of Tuffhead Evo single bevels are available now. We would love to see you test those heads again.
I'd sure like to test them. They told me they would send me the new ones to test, but have not done so yet.
SlickTrick SS3 vs. Tooth of The Arrow!?!
Yep, this needs to happe
Good comparison. I post the score sheets at the end of each vid so you can see how they compare in the same tests. I am also planning to do a new test of the Tooth of the Arrow, including the XL Solid, thru my 2021 protocol.
How long does it take to change the bevel angle?
That's a good question. To get them really sharp with the 344 Guide takes about 20 mins or so. I do it while I'm watching TV or listening to a podcast.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures ok thanks!
Thanks for your time on all these videos. I've been a fan of ST for sometime.
Thank you John; much appreciated, brother.
Tip looked better after the concrete test.
Amazing. Thanks!
Haha. I thought the same thing.
Are slicks tricks made in China now
I've heard that.
My new broadhead for Deer season !
It's a solid choice. Thanks Craig.
What would your preference be between these or the g5 m3?
The Slick Trick. I prefer the shorter design.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures thank you!
Good stuff 👍, Cool t-shirt 😎
Thanks David.
I think you need to quantify the accuracy during the field test by measuring the distance between the broadhead and the field tip arrows.
Naw, There’s way too much human error to make that effective. If I used a Hooter Shooter, I’d do it. But it wouldn’t be fare with my free hand shooting. I’m just seeing if they basically have the same point Of impact.
I’ve been waiting for this test !
Very good. Thank you Craig.
Looks like they borrowed a little engineering from the annihilator camp
What is it you think is similar to the Annihilator?
Love your video. Been a slick trick fan since they came out. Definitely using these this year. Thanks
Thanks Jeff. Good luck!
Not going to lie I’d really like to know what would happened if you should shot a deer with it in the shoulder would it go In deep Enough to kill or would it blow through? Or would it stop dead
I think it would penetrate better than most heads. But it depends on where in the shoulder. Scapula would be a non issue, but the ball joint itself could be for sure. Largely depends on the bow/arrow set up and specs. The head should hold up and do its part.
Mr lusky have you tried to sharpen the shuttle t lock blades
Yeah, but just with a pull thru sharpener. You can also use a Stay Sharp Guide "C" sharpener, as it's designed for curved blades.
Actually interested in these as I hope to be hunting a 3 blade minimum area later in the year 😁
Very good.
How can I have a set sent to you?
Thanks Timothy. Send them to me at: John Lusk, 6159 Nottingham Dr, Johnston, Iowa, 50131.
@@dsmchristianchurch ok I've placed the order sorry they didn't have right bevel only left but I'd like to see how they perform before hunting season begins. I chose this head this year same weight but in right bevel. Can't wait to see the outcome of your video.
Very good. Thank you Timothy. What head is it?
Great review. John, do you have any experience whit this big angle(60-44degree) blade broadhead in hunting? What about bloody capacity?
I have used it in hunting. It definitely makes them a lot sharper. How that translates into blood trails would depend on where you hit, more than anything. But all things equal, it should increase blood trails, but making the wound channel more difficult to clot.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures thanks
Super impressed with this one! Especially after using the sharpener. A really tough well made broadhead for a reasonable amount of $. Now let's see the same thing in a 1 1/4'' - 1 3/8'' Lets also add a small set of cuts in the rear to attach a 3 blade insert like the Kudu Plus has its 2 blade insert. Just maybe the same 5/8'' size of the Kudu to get the additional bleeder effect.
Yep, I prefer a larger cut as well, unless I'm hunting a really big animal--like Tooth of the Arrow XL or Exodus.
This broadhead looks legit.
Oh yeah. It is.
just bought some of these! gonna try them on muley in sept!
Nice broadheads.
Can u redo the crimson talon g2s like this
Yeah, I should do that. I did many of the tests but not all of this new format. They are one of the best heads for the price on the market.
Excellent video! I LOVE the addition of the spin tester & love the demonstration of the stay sharp. Great job!
Thank you sir.
Mate, the tests/videos are coming fast now 😎
Haha. Fall is almost upon us. I typically post one/week, but need to start trying for 2/week or at least 5/month.
This may be the best you’ve tested. Between penetration and the way it held together . For the price this is a tough competitor for the price compared to some of these expensive single bevels. Wish i had held off on the aliens and got these
They are really good--one of the best. I prefer a wider cut, personally. And the Exodus performed extremely well--posting that in a few days. Also, for the price, the Deepower all steel head did very well also.
Great review 👍👍 you definitely made my selection easier on what I'm shooting this year for sure!
Very good. Thank you
Seems like one piece heads do much better than replaceable blades ... 😎🏹 Good stuff ... 😎👍
Well, in most cases yes...but wait till you see the Exodus. That's coming soon.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures with velocities over 300 fps and especially velocities over 375 fps many broadheads have less predictable flight and wind resistance. I've found the short profile helps minimize this. The Exodus works well out of my crossbows (Shoulders wont handle the compound bows anymore) at over 400 fps.
Blatant copy of tooth of the arrow heads. Wow
Well, except it's 3 blades. Pretty big difference there.
Could you sharpen this by placing it flat on a stone?
Yes, I mentioned that in the video.
what would you recommend for white tail 40yards and in?
Yes, they will certainly get the job done. Personally, I prefer a larger cut for whitetail...like a good mech (Sevr is my favorite) or a larger cut fixed blade (Exodus & Tooth of the Arrow XL are two of my favorites). But any good head, like this one, will get the job done with a good shot--shot placement is 90% of the issue. These are great for lighter set ups or animals larger than deer.
I would go Sevr 1.5 or Exodus. Those heads are reliable, cut great, and Afordable. White tails are not too tough to get penetration on so focus on getting good flight, having your overall setup dialed in right and being well practiced.
Reminds me of a single piece exodus.
Thanks for watching & commenting. I find it a bit more like a 3 blade Tooth of the Arrow.
I used a Nicholson pipeliner file its curved did some monotech broadheads they were super sharp
Also buy the pre-season heads monotech has and save money
Very good. I haven't tested those.
How do these compare to the annihilators?
Well, both are great heads--in flight, durability, and penetration. Personally, I prefer the larger cut of the SS3 over the Annihilator for deer sized animals. But I also really prefer a larger cut than the SS3 for deer as well...like a Tooth of the Arrow XL or Exodus, for example.
They look like the oz cut heads , nice review John well done
Yes, similar to the Ozcut Elite 3 blade.
Love the content! I would love to see how bishop holy trinity does with your new tests...... I bought a set last season and unfortunately wasn't able to take an animal with them yet. I have not doubts about their durability but I do have concerns about the 60 degree bevel and it limiting the sharpness of the head. What are your thoughts on that?
That's a good question. a 60 degree bevel will only get "so sharp." However, that will not affect penetration at all. I did a test recently where I dulled the blades of one two blade head with a file--like super dull. And then had another of the same heads that was super sharp. In a penetration test, like I do for Penetration Test 1, the difference was less than 1/2". Edge integrity is much more of a factor in penetration than actual felt sharpness. With the Bishops, those edges just don't chatter. That being said, a sharper head will cut the tissue more effectively as it penetrates, at least in theory, which will result in cleaner cuts and greater bloodletting.
You can always use the Stay Sharp 344 on the Holy Trinity to make it even sharper than it is.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures Thank you so much for the response and wisdom!
Thanks John. Well done video and the head looks like a winner.
Thank you.
John, do you have a running score sheet for all your tests? If so, where? You refer to the score sheet in all your videos, but I can't find it!
Was wondering the same thing?
The score sheet is posted at the end of every video...right after I post the Lusk Grade. You can always take a screen shot of those and compare them. I also posted a Summary of all the scores of heads tested in 2020 in a video at the end of December 2020, called 2020 Scoring Summary or something like that. I posted a summary of all the scores in 2021 thru March on my Facebook Page--Lusk Archery Adventures. I am in the process of creating a website that I will keep updating the scores sheets on.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures thanks John!
No flight test
Yeah there is, it's at 2:56 minutes into the vid.
I watched your review of the annihilator broadhead and compared it to this one. I think the annihilator did better on the concrete test, no damage to the tip.
I forgot the stats, but the slick trick seemed sharper, is that true?
Yes on both parts, I believe. But both did very well...and the SS1 has a larger cut.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures I just bought the slick trick broadheads, I had purchased the annihilator's and killed one deer with it. Huge hole, but spotty blood trail. My guess is they need to be sharper, as you suggest.
would it do any good to spray the heads with silicone to prevent rusting and aid in penetration?
I just picked up a pack of these and was really underwhelmed with how dull they were (granted I know you are supposed to sharpen new broadheads out of the package) but you also should not be able to run your finger up and down the edge either.
Well, that's what happens with 60 degree bevels--30 on each side. They will only get "so" sharp. Now, it's plenty sharp enough to zip thru an animal that's for sure. But if you want them super sharp, get a Stay Sharp Guide 344, cause it changes the bevel to 44 degrees.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures that makes sense for machined heads. I did reach out to Slick Trick and talked to a customer service rep. He did say you “absolutely should not be able to run your fingers along the edge” and to send them back so they can review and send a new sharpened set out (which I appreciated).
@@LuskArcheryAdventuresI just ordered these as well. With heads like these, is the benefit more about blasting through an animal making a big hole vs slicing through with super sharp replaceable blades?
How does being short aide in penetration that goes against everything dr. Ashby found in his studies three-to-one ratio
Yeah, I'm not a believer in some of his research, honestly. But penetration does largely depend on the medium being shot into. These tests only measure that with the two Penetration Tests I do--the rubber mat/MDF/FBI Gel and then the layered cardboard. Both of those tend to "stick" to a broadhead, so the less the surface area, the better. More liquid/lubricated mediums can be a different story. But then again, bone and hide and tendon are not very "liquid" based either.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures ok. I get that
@@LuskArcheryAdventures this is why I believe his tests were Head and Shoulders above any other test that I've seen, because he used actual game animal carcasses to do his test on, it doesn't get any more realistic than that
How sharp were they out of the package? Thanks
I did that test in the vid--did you see it? That's one of the main tests I do--Initial or Out of the Box Sharpness. The score is always listed at the end of the vid as well.
Yes what does a 350 score mean! No clue?
@@ishotapig I know the lower the number the better. I think it measures how much force it takes to cut through a wire. Less force = sharper blade