The 13th doctor is the first doctor I've watched who at least for me doesn't have a definitive personality, every other doctor I've seen had a moment that established them and you got a sense of who they were, Jodie Whittakers doctor just seems to change personality depending on whatever is required for the episode
Yeah especially in series 11 and 12, I think during Flux and Villa Diodati the writers got what she is, but by that point her era was basically over :(
No! I think the Gatwa version is the worst ever. At least Jodie was written a little bit more like the Doctor than Gatwa who’s breaking down crying nearly every episode and hitting on someone within minutes of meeting them! New Who never quite gets the characterisation of the Doctor right. I do like Jo Martin’s take on the fugitive Doctor. She’s stern and has a commanding screen presence. Her Tardis interior looks gorgeous and the police box design is very Classic. The Sea Devils look like the Classic ones which I like but the episode was rushed and they shouldn’t be flying around. I agree with most of your points.
Honestly I quite like Ncutis version a lot more than Jodie’s, she got better with her third and final series but overall she never felt very doctory :(
Rosa is such a bad episode, I think everything that can be said about why has been already but I'll just add that the episode should have been a pure historical, it did not need an alien villain in it whatsoever. The time period and setting alone with Ryan would be more than enough to bring tension and danger to the TARDIS team. I don't give 0/10s but if I did it would deserve it. The episode could have been really good which makes it hurt even more with the direction they took with it
Tbh I don’t despise it but yeah should have been a pure historical, the time racist thing is just so stupid. It’s a very serious and sensitive topic that ended up being funny instead which really should not happen
To hear Jodie say "The system is not the problem" in "Kleblam!" is a betrayal of what the Doctor stands for.
100% that episode started so strongly but the last 15 mins just fell apart :( it was like they wanted a twist but didn’t know how to achieve it
The 13th doctor is the first doctor I've watched who at least for me doesn't have a definitive personality, every other doctor I've seen had a moment that established them and you got a sense of who they were, Jodie Whittakers doctor just seems to change personality depending on whatever is required for the episode
Yeah especially in series 11 and 12, I think during Flux and Villa Diodati the writers got what she is, but by that point her era was basically over :(
Yes
😂😂😂
In comparison to the latest Doctor (Ncuti Gatwa) and his stories Whittaker's Doctor suddenly looks great.
Awww I quite like Series 14 haha, my level of cheesy fun
No! I think the Gatwa version is the worst ever. At least Jodie was written a little bit more like the Doctor than Gatwa who’s breaking down crying nearly every episode and hitting on someone within minutes of meeting them! New Who never quite gets the characterisation of the Doctor right. I do like Jo Martin’s take on the fugitive Doctor. She’s stern and has a commanding screen presence. Her Tardis interior looks gorgeous and the police box design is very Classic. The Sea Devils look like the Classic ones which I like but the episode was rushed and they shouldn’t be flying around. I agree with most of your points.
Honestly I quite like Ncutis version a lot more than Jodie’s, she got better with her third and final series but overall she never felt very doctory :(
Rosa is such a bad episode, I think everything that can be said about why has been already but I'll just add that the episode should have been a pure historical, it did not need an alien villain in it whatsoever. The time period and setting alone with Ryan would be more than enough to bring tension and danger to the TARDIS team. I don't give 0/10s but if I did it would deserve it. The episode could have been really good which makes it hurt even more with the direction they took with it
Tbh I don’t despise it but yeah should have been a pure historical, the time racist thing is just so stupid. It’s a very serious and sensitive topic that ended up being funny instead which really should not happen