Former serfs tell the horrifying serfdom history in Tibet in this documentary
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
- Hey guys, just want to share with you a documentary that I watched these days.
This documentary interviewed several surviving serfs who were born as serfs to serve the "nobles" in Tibet. Not only they didn't have any freedom, suffered inhuman treatment, they weren't even considered human by the "upper class" before the peaceful liberation.
It also reveals the true archive history footage of Tibet. Through those black and white footage, you can also get a glimpse of what the life was like for the majority of the people in Tibet.
Hope this documentary will help you to understand the true history of Tibet too.
My great grandfather was a communist soldier and he would always share stories with us. Once he told us that while he was in Tibet, the Serfs would run to them and beg for food and also if they can join the army with them. Also another story was they found a young lady inside a wooden box in the middle of nowhere. Apparently they put her there as punishment to die out there. But they were able to save her and later she married one of his comrade. True story.
That’s a incredible historical event . I’m so glad Tibet was liberated from the vile serfdom Here in the west they applaud a CIA supported lama was has $150 million & is a fraud & they play the free Tibet card whilst living in luxury
@@EM-lz9kg 19th century Britain already wanted to occupy Tibet as its own territory, later the CIA joined the force intended to take over Tibet for their first front station serving the US/UK/West's geographical fronts. IF it is not due to the communist's rescue, that tibet today under the west's ruling will remain the same "Slavery System" to serve the foreigners.
Just watch what the US/UK/Europe did to Iraq, Syria, and the Middle East Bombed to Stone age, left in a hurry and cleaned up their treasury, banks and let those nations in hang.
ua-cam.com/video/Y4wvg9kTQPw/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/J-q1mO-fsW4/v-deo.html
Where is he now?
As of May 5, 2023, all replies are deleted/censored/shadow banned by Ytube. Sad. Guess why?
I was born in Nepal and grew up i HIndu culture and tradition. I was very much influenced by Tibetan Buddhist culture and religion. I left my Hindu religion and converted to buddhist at the age of 13. I had no idea about past history of Tibet. Now I am doing research on trauma and childhood of Dalit or marginalized people of India and Nepal. I was watching a video of Dalai Lama giving talk on buddhist psychology on youtube. I started reading comments on the video. There was one comment by Indian man saying the cruelty of serfdom culture of Tibet before the Chinese invention of Tibet in 1959. I was so shocked and suspicious how such thing could take place in peaceful land! I googled it. Yes it was true that people from poor background were forced to serve the upper class people without payment. Once born as a serf always a serf. The children were forcefully separated from the their parents as shown in the documentary. The invention of Chinese became bless to the serf which not only liberated them from the vicious cycle of serfdom but also gave freedom to live like a human being.
I really appreciate the producer of the documentary.
Not completely true. You'll find that the Dalai Lama never had that much power in the first place as the actual power went to the regional lords during the time who varied at times (when the Dalai Lama advised against attacking the Chinese, the Kham chieftains rejected this advice and went forward on a disastrous result; likewise, you'd find different treatment of the serfs from Lhasa lords being pretty cruel to Kham lords working together in the fields with their serfs). It's true that Tibet was never a spiritual utopia that the West advocates and there were lamas who complained about Tibet's degenerative ways but the stuff that the Indian commenter here said about the bones is misleading (I've already responded to him about that manner with some sources).
For the accounts of Tibet during the Chinese, I would recommend the book "Lord of the Dance" by Chagdud Tulku Rinpoche. It's a fascinating autobiography by a Tibetan lama and his experiences during the changing times of Tibet (he criticizes both the surrounding Tibetan system and Chinese system alongside placing humanity over politics).
@@DC-vn7kc the dalailama ,87years old ,will change into a boy and come back soon.I am sure his next life will love China ,actually his next life will love China than any Chinese can do .
@@DC-vn7kc Dalai Lama may not have that much power all the time, but he is the symbol and defender of the feudal system and he benefited a lot from that system. The reason he fled to India in 1959 was he refused to give up the system and the privileges.
Chinese communists try to pervert the depiction of other cultures to fit their false narrative of liberation. Chinese communism is one of the most overtly authoritarian and inegalitarian political systems in history. They're pointing fingers at a feudal society, telling you that they saved these people.. meanwhile, the CCP has concentration camps full of Uyghurs and a draconian social credit system to weed out political dissidents. It's a joke that China points accusing fingers at any society. They're the worst of all.
The Dalai Lama was a child, the CCP want y’all to believe that he was masterminding a slave country, meanwhile when he fled to India he was literally a child. Most of the slavery was because of older advisors.
Also they were in the works of joint the UN and drastically change the country and on its way of become like modern day Bhutan which was also very similar.
China likes to claim the “FREED” Tibet, how can they free a country that was already on its path of changing.
They like to claim the bad parts of Tibet, but what country on this earth was Void of evil like 60 years ago, I remember growing up in Nepal and they still had serfdom.
They like to claim that Tibet was never gonna change , but in fact it was gonna change because joking the UN requires you to ban slavery altogether
I cried through this whole documentary, it was the best produced doc I have seen in years. I'm glad the former serfs are living good life and happy now. Tibet is so beautiful 🤩
Serfdom in Tibet is equal to the Dark Ages of Europe in the 11th century.
Eastern theocracy as it is based on their interpretation of Tibetan Tantric Buddhism by its elitist overlords.
The elites led by successive generations of the Dalai Lama, its advisers and the serfs made life miserable for the locals for generations.
Yeah, for Han Chinese invaders it's a beautiful land to pillage and ruin.
@@auggieniopetch3045stay mad slave owner
@@auggieniopetch3045you much be jealous to see Tibet profer.
@@auggieniopetch3045 Most Chinese don't want to be there. They prefer richer cities like Shanghai, Beijing, Chongqing where they can make more money. The Chinese teachers, medics, doctors, engineers are sent there to build roads, hospitals, and assist with medical services & education.
Thank you so much for sharing this my beautiful friend. These are the most beautiful and loving people. Their suffering was horrific but it never broke their loving spirits. 🌹♥️
People call out Dalia Lama to openly apologize to souls of slaves slayed by his serfdom.
Tibetans love China government as it destroyed his serfdom and brought human rights.
Dalai Lama was not happy with the reform so left China Tibet.
How brutal was Dalai Lama's serfdom?
They made Thangka or paintings on human skin, from LIVING slave girl's skin;
Skull drum of Tibetan Buddhism, made from skulls of LIVING slave boy and girl;
Skullcup, made from LIVING slave's skull;
Skin scripture of Tibetan Buddhism, made from LIVING slave girl;
Leg flute/trumpet/horn, made from legs of young LIVING slave girl;
Bone prayer wheel of Tibetan Buddhism, made from LIVING slave's bones.
Bone beads necklace or wrist lace, made from LIVING slave's bones;
Bone walking stick, made from LIVING slave's leg.
People need to realise that the current "Dalai Lama" is actually a fake Buddhist monk...a genuine Buddhist monk cannot be involved in any worldly affairs...It is utterly disgraceful that he is active in politics, promoting separatist movement, promoting slavery, promoting suicide by self-immolation etc...he is literally giving Buddhism a bad reputation.
@@rothschildjr4639 Pls search "Tibet human sacrifice" or "Tibet Serfdom", or the book "Use of Human Skulls and Bones in Tibet", by Berthold Laufer, Curator of Anthropology, Field Museum of Natural History, Chicago, 1923.
@@jagsingh6410 Thank you for sharing the information.
Evil Serf-owner of Dollar Lama..
Dollar lama luvs the best juicy beef steak……how? Hin dut va en dians must supply n feed him his royal taste n habit?
and do you guys know they are not speaking Mandarin. I, as a cantonese Chinese can't understand without subtitles. and yet the west media says CCP forced them to give up their culture and language. I am cantonese, and I can speak cantonese in daily life no problem, but true at school we need to use mandarin and pass exam in mandarin.
A unified language is a way to unify a country making everyone understand each other faster.
I think some of them were speaking highly accented mandarin which they were taught?? im not sure but some of the the older ones definetly did not
@@stevennotthe2997 Some of them were speaking Tibetan
@@stevennotthe2997 Tibetans are mostly bilingual now, the older ones did receive education in the past and depending on which region their education is received. Like, different parts of China have different accents. I still remember the old Tibetan man who carries a Tibetan dictionary all the time and learned to read tibetan after being freed from his oppressors.
We are talking about present generation and children born after 80s are forced in the boarding school .
In switzerland there are like 4 languages and it works. Language is only a tool, depending on the user what it will used for, if it is rather unifying or more conflicts
She is 66 y.o. I am 65.y.o. n definitely look physically younger by 20 years. She lives a hard life.
You can tell those granny was still horrified and sad by their past, it was painful memories her lips was shaken.
Indians are unhappy too see a moderately prosperous Tibet. The Indians would prefer to see the caste system applied to Tibetan Chinese.
The Hindutva far-right specifically, inspired by European far right political movements (read Nazi Germany or Fascist Italy)
McMahon Line is such a poorly demarcated border formed by British India.
You are correct. Even Alexander thd Great did not want to conquer India having reached Lahore ( Paskistan ). Good reason.
Later only Britain did !!!
@@thisiskevin1000 Everywhere the British went disaster followed. Just look at present day Palestine. Diego Garcia was given to the Americans and drove all the Natives out of the country.
As an Indian while I do admire the liberation of Tibetans from slavery and the abolition of the disgusting caste system I still love my nation
@@loggygaming2112 Then help change and make India better. I only see a bunch of Indian nationalists on UA-cam comments with anti-china bashing, but not really doing anything to improve their lives or their own country's standing.
Dalai Lama just showed his true face
as a gay?
His Holiness was in his teen at that time. Have you got brain?
His tongue
@@hendrasaputra8545 As a pedo. You complete the word as YT might censore me
@@i_love_tibet7001 his "holiness" kisses little boys and is quite silent in the current genocide.
Espeluznante, tenebroso y asombrosa la vida dolorosa de los siervos en el Tibet antiguo .
It’s not ancient Tibet. It’s living memory Tibet.
This is even worse than a dystopian fiction you would read about in a fiction book, and I'm only 10 minutes in. The idea that there are people who have the nerve to go on the web and defend the regime of Tibet and the Dalai Lama seems so sad and even a bit surreal. I am so glad this documentary exists to highlight the voices of real Tibetans and not the CIA pro-slavery narrative.
Years back, when I read news that D. Lama exiled in India, and that USA supported him. He became popular as he travelled. Henceforth, USA and its allies demonise China 🇨🇳 till this day. From this account, I can foresee the hardship and oppression of normal Tibet people. All the time I thought the Buddhist leaders would treat their own people well. They were only liberated in 1959...Now they live peacefully and harmoniously, with good education, and their family never be separated again. God bless Tibet.
Thanks for telling the world about the real Tibet before liberation!
sorry but Buthan has managed to liberate itself from serfdom like many other countries. and also what makes you think, that chinese can decide what tibetans need? why chinese determine the future of Tibet and not Tibetans themselves? do you say that we are not capable enough to do so, right? we are stupid and don't understand anything. so we needed the help from you big and glorious china. that's called colonialism.
@@tenzin5841china owned tibet in the Qing dynasty lol, why can’t they have it back after they won the civil war?
@@youtefhyofc do as you like and possess a whole country just as you wish, you egomaniac.
@@youtefhyofc congrats thaths a grown up right there. compare peoples dignity and identity with something you can posses like a toddler possess its toy. Egomaniac, try to respect others dignity and self determination.
I wish this documentary could be seen by everyone in the western world and, in particular, by every American in order to dispel the nonsense about “freeing” Tibet. It would also be nice to end the idolization of the the Dalai Lama as some sort of benevolent person when it seems from this documentary that whomever was Dalai Lama was a part of the oppressive ruling class.
May be we should free the native indians in America ! America too practiced slavery !
I thought that some German buddhist association have come out against this and trying to spread the truth.
Yes, learning about the actual history of Tibetan serfs completely changed my perspective. It's mind blowing that the Dalai Lama has been venerated in western society when they were the serf-owners that subjugated the lower classes who were essentially treated like slaves. The Tibetans have already been freed - from serfdom, not via "liberal democracy".
Dollar Lama!
Learn Tibet history and enlighten your self first , write don’t write when you don’t even know who HH Dalaï Lama is , you can’t tell whom we should idolize or not . Free Tibet long live HH Dalai lama
This is an excellent documentary, thank you, JingJing.
Japan should also make same video on MAO and other Chinese slave society and they have come to liberate Chinese.
.
@@gyadre Thank you Ms. Li Jingjing for revealing the other side of Dalai Lama who is claimed to be a Monk/Saint in the Western World (who never was and is in my judgment). How could the promoter of SLAVERY be a Saint. He is rather the cleverest and devilest Politician. Period.
I am so looking forward to her video on Cheng Lei, your former friend and colleague at CGTN who was disappeared by the CCP..imprisoned, no charges - kept from her small children for 12 months. I hope you can talk about how her friends abandoned her and dont mention her because they are scared it will happen to them.
I also look forward to your video on Zheng Zhou - another journalist imprisoned for 4 years simply for talking about the coronavirus.
Journalism is not a crime.
Perhaps she can do a video about Zhao Wei, she too has disappeared from chinese social media.,.and all of her movies/videos have been taken down. Its scary how a government can simply make people disappear isnt it - perhaps codepink can chat about how women in China are vanished by the government.
Apparently Zhao Wei was made invisible by the CCP because her presence was to strong, too well known, she was active across multiple platforms and that is seen as a threat to the complete power & control of the overwhelmingly male dominated CCP - i probably wouldnt want to be a woman across multiple social media platforms trying to become well know - the CCP do not like people drawing attention to themselves these days under Xi Jingpings term for life as self imposed president.
I look forward to her reply Li, shall we assume another blocking because ive mentioned your former friend Cheng Lei?
Do you remeber Cheng? First they came for Zheng, then they came for Cheng..who will they come for next?
@@BCAIlisons
She stole state secrets. You know nothing.
@@hokumai8782 ua-cam.com/video/Gq3TzIxctQE/v-deo.html
Thank you Ms. Li Jingjing for revealing the other side of Dalai Lama who is claimed to be a Monk/Saint. The truth is, he never was and is a Saint. How could the promoter of SLAVERY be a Saint. He is rather the cleverest and devilest Politician.
More like a snake !!! Dalai Lama's younger brother held a recent news conference & said he regretted working with CIA.
Gautama Buddha-Shakyamuni born as Prince in Royal Family but he leaving all, then teach the Monk Sangha to leave materialistic and practice in Dhamma Spirituality
So if you see the Monks or self claim as Living Buddha but living in Rich Materialistic and have Feudalistic Power thats the fake one
Good one
I'm surprised that after 1year, this comment only got 21 likes.. I thought this is common sense.. 😮💨 😢
Don't forget about Dalai lama claimed himself as "Bodhisattva of kind" but have slave
Great documentary, Jingjing!! Applause
Great documentary, it is always good to see both sides of the story, not just the western side.
It's always good to know the both sides of history, the western side and the truth!
Fantastic Documentary, I had absolutely no idea about any of this. The history I was told was fiction and this documentary highlights the evils of propaganda. Thank you for this report, it was fantastic, and very enlightening.
I enjoy watching your work but this is the highlight so far. All the best for the future from Australia.
We chinese knw the true history of the old tibet, so every time comment like "free tibet", I was like 🙃 They knw nothing abt the old tibet,
It’s sad when the child asked the grandma “what did you want to be”…she didn’t even know how to answer
@@junqiwang4600 you should say wtf they know about Tibet.
JJ, excellent oral history and documentary on a world that has been kept hidden from people in the west. Few westerners ever knew the extent of slavery under the theocracy of Dalai Lama.
Feedback: The superimposition of contextual briefs is great but needs to be left on screen much longer for viewers to read. I have to constantly pause the video to read. Depending on the length of the briefs, you should allow at least double, if not, triple the amount of time to accommodate both fast and slow readers. Otherwise, missing those briefs will significantly reduce the understanding of its underlying history.
All history books were censored in the west. But in the 1950 to 1960 the Chinese in SEA countries had these books. That was before these SEA countries became independent !
Tibet had a caste system, and not only that was a theocratic dictatorship. 😂 To deny this as Chinese propaganda is denying Tibetan history. The insane level of coping only comes from members of cults.
They still believe in religion even after the lamas and elites treated them horribly. The lamas aren't worthy of your devotion.
They believe in the religion, not the Lamas per se. Same to any religion, for example, should a Christian the believe in the religion or the priest?
I kindly disagree with you .. please don’t be so easy to judge without proper knowledge of Tibetan history!
Whatever it is. We believe equally in Lama & religion
It’s all about Faith in religion & devotion in lama and that’s how it works!
When I was going to university back in the last 1990s, my professor who was from China said Tibet was a slavery society. This video confirms that.
Thank you very much we really Happy, and appreciate upload
never again they will experience it
Absolutely fantastic documentary 🇨🇳🚩✊
Most all the nobels escape to India and Western countries. Massive immigrants also located in US. They want their serfs back!!!!!
The masters left Tibet and now they want to go back to Tibet. Do you think the former serfs want them ?
Total 2017, they escaped to the US and wait for the US to put them back into Tibet so that they could round their former serfs up and force them to work for free again so that they could live a rich, carefree life again! One of these former noblemen was the current Dalai Lama, he has made an agreement with the US government that if he is able to generate enough support to get Tibet to secede from China then the US government would make him the king of Tibet. Then all he has to do is do whatever the US tells him to do and he would live a rich, carefree life just like his noble ancestors have done in Tibet for hundreds of years!
Long Live the Red East! Glory to Mao Zedong the Liberator!
This is not about taking sides, just have some honest questions.
1. If 95% of the population were serfs, and 5% clergy/upper classes, where do nomads fit into this equation?
2. Many people interviewed mentioned life improved after 1959, yet don't get into the details, despite big events taking place, such as the Great Leap Forward and Cultural Revolution, shortly after. How did life as a serf compare to freedom during the Great Chinese Famine and Struggle Sessions? The older lady towards the end mentions she got together with her husband during the democratic reforms, although she had worked with him as a serf. If democratic reforms refers to the time of Deng Xiaoping, this is quite a while after the peaceful liberation, leaving room for questions as to what happened in-between. Also in this conversation, she speaks about doing well in an afterlife, if there is an afterlife, and if policies are as good there as in present-day China. As a Buddhist, wouldn't she believe in rebirth? What did I miss here?
3. Over 150,000 Tibetans live in exile. If the quality of life for Tibetans in China is so great, why would such a large number of people risk their lives, crossing the Himalayas to start over in India, a country with a lower standard of living, where becoming a citizen for them is not possible? In addition, since the peaceful liberation, why do so many who permanently live in Tibet visit the Dalai Lama and/or attend his teachings in India if he is a symbol of their feudal past?
If you feel affronted by this, this isn't my attention.
1. Nomads aren't counted as population as they have no nationality. They probably could just pass through as long as they don't interacted in an unwanted way.
2. Either you interview a lot of people or you focus on one person because their span of attention isn't that great (they just decided to not do a single interview). Comparing being a serf for life with hungering because of basicly an unknown cause for a few years isn't comparable. The first is far worse. Africa has famines too, is the whole of africa now bad people (because they're unable to change it)? You have to recognize that they suffered under "buddhism", like "christianity" waged holy wars. Under the pretence of religion people have suffered, so they stop believing in it although buddhism is very altruistic.
3. Like the million uighurs in concentration camp? It's just a made up number why else shouldn't they use or tell the accurate numbers of people which are confirmed? Nonetheless that several sources take numbers like 100,000 or 120,000 as well, the question is how much are there now and if you calculate the proportions with around a million people, you get around 50,000 slave owners. Besides that people from different nationalities live abroad (which is totally normal).
On the topic of “democratic reforms” I believe it refers to 26:33, as that’s when Tibet had them, so they’ve probably been together since the collapse of feudalism, late ‘50s - early 60’s, how Deng reforms would affect a couple so specifically that they are meaning those reforms is absurd
This seems a doctored documentary.
别的我不想回答，关于藏族逃亡的事情（不知道你的数据是否真实）即使在遭受那么严重的农奴制后，现在还是有大量的藏人信佛教，我只能说这是宗教的力量。对于我这个无神论者，这是愚昧的，但是对于信教的人这就是前世今生。
The Tibetans in exile were the rich enslavers of the population. They were the ones funded and armed by the CIA. The CIA works around the world to destabilise a nation. It's the strategic tactic of divide and conquer. But the problem with Tibetan ruling class was that the serfs outnumbered them and they supported the Communist party of China.
Excepcional , brillante y muy bien documentado el vídeo .
there's always two sides of a story, always. tibet was indeed had an oppressive rule over its people, but i strongly believe china had no business in deciding what was "best" for tibet.
two things can be true at the same time, even if them seem contradictory.
Lol, even prior to the CCP “invasion” Tibet had been under the jurisdiction of China for centuries, historically having no legitimate claim to sovereignty. Regardless, it’s an undeniable fact that Tibet’s human life index is at the greatest it’s ever historically been. Critical infrastructure, life expectancy, population, literacy, education attainment, have all flourished. Forfeiting control now would mean a massive gamble on the liveliness of millions, opening up Tibet to foreign military occupation, and the marked return of the repressive, “now reformed” religious sect. And to address the other side, people would find it curious to know they come directly and exclusively from the overthrown ruling class and no other than his touchiness the Dalai Lama himself who have comfortably taken up asylum in our western countries. They do not speak for the other +90%. Regardless, here’s to the continued prosperity of the Tibetan PEOPLE.
Thank you for sharing stories of Tibetans, every voice has a right to be heard! I'm sorry for their suffering! Good to see, that their life seem better now. However, don't use their personal and emotional stories for your political intentions. That's sad man! Kind of disrespecting their voice!
Smashed the LIKE button
You jealous. You cannot change history.
Wow this a beautiful documental and my blessings for all survivors, they are strong . Thank you for sharing this with us . Hello from California.
Really enjoyed this film. Am ignorant of western narrative of Tibet...this is the only one I know.
The truths I heard and seen here is irrefutable from the mouths of the lives lived. Am glad for knowing true history as it was lived and not a narration put out to keep a good face only.👍🏽
Here I'm a Napalese, speaking about Tibetan people's misery in the past, we've a very close acquaintance with Tibetan people historically and culturally_Before Tibet was liberated and reunited with China, the dalai lamas, predecessors of current dalai lama even persuaded the serfs (Tibetan people) to eat 'herbal medicine' that was made from his dehydrated feces turned into pills look alike. The serfs then were made to believe it in a true sense that they were indeed medicines. That is how horrible was the situation of Tibetan people in those days.
谢谢您作为外国人发出真实的声音，我为这个纪录片落泪，那些被西方媒体洗脑的人还说视频里的奶奶是演员。这个世界怎么了😢😢😢😢。真实存在的农奴制服的都可以说不存在。今天还看了一个1952年的新疆贵族视频，满身绿松石之类的首饰光线靓丽。和这个奶奶行程鲜明的对比。
watching this and i am amazed that what i would best describe as cowboy hats are quite popular in tibet.
Beautiful documentary
38:50 wow, it's even more messed up then my phone, lol. Thanks for posting this doc, it's really great!
I shall visit Tibet some day...
Tibet is connected by high speed train from Beijing
Evil Serf-owner of Dollar Lama..
When he was in India, he was too young to know this.
@Amos xu chines puppet everywhere
Outstanding!!! 👏👏👏
Or because background and subtitle are both black and white. Might be subtitles with different colours help.
guy 1: guys, wanna western democracy?
guy 2: back become serf to the greedy capitalist?
US & allies double standard
In the West, true Tibetan culture was colored as if people were living in free and democratic paradise. It us pretty ironic whenever i heard Dalai Luma talked about freedom and democracy here.
Maybe Tibet IS better off under China. The serf system looks similar to slavery in the USA during the 1800s.
Tibet is part of China .it is like the southern part of America should be in USA .if those southern American want to be independent from USA ,what will you Yankees do to them ?
Exactly, sir.
After crying, I found myself laughing at 40:21 seeing the boy hide his face "inside" the bowl when the topic of "how good is your school grade?" was brought up 😂😂😂😅😅😅 #asiankidlife
With cattle and plows as the mean of agriculture, it shouldn’t surprise anyone that Tibet was much alike medieval Europe
Thank you Jing Jing for well documented life stories of the PEOPLES... you are a GEM ❤
"you will own nothing and you will be happy"
Well Europe is trying to make their citizens poorer then round them up when homeless.
China was Hero. 😮
I always thought the Dali Lama was a fraud. His family were part of the Tibetan oligarchy.
the dalai lama was born to a poor farming family you fool.
When you watch this documentary, consider the Chinese, European, and even American civilizations of that era. Poor farmers were often employed by wealthy farmers, and they received unfair treatment. In contrast, Tibetans were far better off than the wealthy Chinese who employed them. However, just when reform for the common people in Tibet was about to occur, the CCP nearly completely destroyed the region and forcibly took the land and peaceful people.
All Tibetans or the 5% of the ruling class that you’re descended from?
U never see this reality in Brat Pitt's movie.
I used to wonder why the Chinese didn't have a Taliban situation on their hands when they invaded as Tibet would be the PERFECT place for a guerrilla insurgency. But it turns out most of the country had good reason to collaborate with China.
When I traveled to Tibet, a Tibetan told me an interesting thing. In Tibetan, Mao Zedong’s troops are called Jinzhu Mami, which means people who break chains.
@@王安澜-m1u Thank you for telling me that :)
The poor, the weak and the unfortunates are always the victims.
My whole life was a life
🇲🇫👏👏👏⭐💯
Thanks to Li Jingjing for producing an unbiased and true documentaries on Tibet serfs populations in the past decades. They had suffered tremendously on their treatments n hardship by the lordships in their country. I am happy and delighted for their freedoms and dignities. Wishes them all the best for the futures.
Everyone is aware that this is Chinese propaganda, right? Even the comments are part of the propaganda show. Congratulations, your mind has been zombified!
yeah no shit that it's propaganda, however it doesn't change the fact that tibet was a serfdom.
We are ware that you are spreading US propaganda, yes.
@@noa9125Exactly this
@@noa9125 so was china in their feudal years, its just that china got modernized earlier and Tibet never got the chance
Hey it's no different than how the Americans justify their conquests.
From an Chinese American POV, Tibetan in China still respect Mao…because his atrocities were insulted from Tibet…I been to Tibet, I was shocked when I saw Tibetan families with Maos portrait in their home. From a Chinese POV…Maos accomplishments were canceled by his atrocities.
you mean insulated?
Mao is just one person in the CCP. He made mistakes. But the mistakes he made were small in comparison to the atrocities committed by the West around the world for centuries. At least the CCP continues to lift its people out of extreme poverty. Meanwhile in 2023, the West continues its wars and covert coups, sanctions, and a widening gap between rich and poor.
Actually Mao Zedong liberated Tibet from Slavary and has been deemed as a real god, he has been deemed as the reincarnation of Manjusri Bodhisattva.
Next time make a video about China’s serfdom and in others part of world too during feudal system.
What is the name of the song that starts playing at 16:11?
In early century every country had serfs .so it’s not big deal .so after that it’s changed.
Hope people can now understand why the tibetan people wants the help from China
Painful real life story during 1945 to 1955 year in Tibet in China . Now still going on Western
Countries . Life is far better in Tibet now with high speed railways now .
western defends serfdom society in tibet. they have no shame.
Which area of Tibet is this … the way speak from southern of Tibet ?
The accent should be from Shannan
"Charlie don't serf"
Free Tibet!!!
You cannot hide the truth....
give also panchen lama a voice!
The sexual abuse was
Li Jingjing you're so beautiful ❤
always filled with doubt and fear, or why else do you only post one side of the story? if you feel you are right that why you fear different perspectives? scary cat.
When empire falls slaves get liberated and elite suffers.
I was wondering if the they were all monks how they were getting things done 🤔.Now I know, sadly 😔.
I see these images of people just living in the streets, ... see what's happening to Imperialist USA? They are paying for what they have done.
I am a Tibetan living India . I have heard stories from my older generations about how families have to serve monasteries and how imposing and terrifying it was. I have heard of aristocrats misusing their powers to suppress the poor and more. This documentary is something which makes me more aware of how Tibet was back then. The story of this lady is very sad and heart wrenching. It’s not like we Tibetans in exile are not aware of these things. We have been told stories of the livelihoods of our grandparents from childhood. But this doesn’t justify the communist government’s action. Tibet has never been a part of China and we will surely get freedom. Every country have its own dark side and history. Every country had a patriarchal system similar to this one in the past . I suggest everyone to dig more into the history of Tibet and then comment. I also feel that the Tibet before 1950s was a very backward place . His holiness himself has said that the occupations seems like a blessing in disguise sometimes. Without that Tibet would not have been so modernized and developed . But what the situations of Tibetans living in tibet nowadays. It’s not any not better. Those who obeys the communist laws lives an easy life. But what about the people who were denied to study andpractice Tibetan culture and Buddhism. What about the young monks forced out of monasteries and treated like dogs. What about the people who were sent to prison just because they said FREE TIBET. What about Panchen Lama who went missing under the actions of the communist government. What about the people who self immolated themselves because they could no longer live under the oppression. The lives of Tibetans in tibet are no better than before. The tibet you see on UA-cam are all just what the communist party wants you to see. Search about the lives of political prisoners and how they are inhumanely treated after being arrested asking for their rights.
Do search on the recent actions of the communist government on the Tibetan people before glorifying the communist party.
I don’t specialise in Tibetan history but I do know that the communist party did not free us from suffering. They just change the way to make Tibetans suffer and glorify their actions by hiding the wrong doings under the sheets. Why else would thousands of people flee tibet? Why would parents send away their kids to cross the Himalayas on their feets to flee tibet , if the situation was soo goos after occupation.
#Freetibet #longlivehisholiness
❤❤❤
The West: "Free Tibet!"
Mao: "We did.'"
Really fantastic documentary, I had absolutely no idea. I've been so propagandized in the US into thinking that the Tibetans were victims of imperialism, I legitimately didn't know they'd actually been freed from the yoke of oppression when China moved in. What they experienced under the prior feudal system sounds positively horrific. What they lived through was functionally slavery. I will be showing this documentary to everyone who will listen. We've been lied to about Tibet in America, it's time to spread the truth.
Please do that. Tibet was liberated during Mao era. We read this in China history ( books not available outside China. Western countries banned ).
Tibet has been a part of China at various times for thousands of years. The British even made China pay reparations for the damages caused by the Tibetan people when they killed 202 British soldiers as well as horses during a rebellion against the British rule. The British said that since Tibet was a part of China, China must pay for all of the lost lives and damages caused by the Tibetan people. I'm so glad China has freed the long-suffering Tibetan serfs who had suffered so much by members of the clergy, government, and feudal land owners.
Focusing on history, the Southwest China was plagued with slavery and feudalism. I am ethnic Miao/Hmong and growing up, I sat like a Japanese on my knees and my mother hit me and said, don't sit like a slave. I realized it was because of history, when the Nosu Yi or Black Yi enslaved many Hmong/Miao, White Yi and other ethnic groups in Southwest China.
Does this include Dalai Lama as a slave owner? Obviously so me thinks.
@@btiger9495 Actually a former national sozialist of germany wrote a book (title: "Seven Years in Tibet") about how he adores what the dalai lama did. People just don't read books or think for themselves, so they deem everything as possible which is exactly the reason you can fall for misinformation.
Indian logic : China is evil to abolish the caste and slavery systems in Tibet...lets support those slave owners who fled to India for Tibet independence to re-establish the caste and slavery systems in Tibet...Jai Hind!!
Evil Serf-owner of Dollar Lama..
Now you know India always dislike China.
For hindu cow is more worthy than people.
Indian doesn't give a shit about its own people let alone tibetans. They will support "free tibet" yet suppress Sikh and kashmir separatists. What hypocrisy.
They only support "free tibet" and dalai lama to be a thorn in china's side. Also they dream that a so called 'free" Tibet could be a buffer state between them and the chinese.
As a 🇺🇸, I haven’t heard about Tibet on over 10 years. But if someone goes off with the “free Tibet” crap, I’ll just respond with “let the Confrderacy rise again!” Also found it so sus that the Free Tibet org is based out of Britain and headed by two White guys.
when I saw the Dalai lama kissing that kid in the mouth, it sent me down a rabbit hole.
The powerful do as they want.
It led you to this propaganda. Good job.
@@foarfield Read "Magic and Mystery in Tibet" by Alexandra David-Néel, a British lady Lama who explored Tibet or "Three Years in Tibet" by the Japanese Zen monk Ekai Kawaguchi. Both spent time in Tibet before the Chinese invasion, and spoke in detail about the abuse of children by Tibetan monks. It was commonplace.
@@jimzorn3853 Those are real sources. This video is by an employee of the propaganda department of the CCP pushing an agenda.
Good Job and Support ! Tell the world the truth of the old Tibet before the liberation ! ! Bravo to China Rise Peacefully and be Strong ! ! !
I am a Tibetan from Tibet. The content in the video is similar to what my grandma told me. She also lived a good life after Tibet was liberated by China.
😂😂fake account 😂
Bro tf? Learn to lie. 😂
A Muslim from Somalia introduced me to this on his podcast. It's insane! He said the Tibetan monks used to charge people for breathing air. He also said Hinduism as a unified religion was an invention of the West, and basically he said many things that really undermine the Western narrative about China being some inauthentic oppressor in the region, actually China seems like the most authentic, and LEAST oppressive.. But the Western propaganda tool is powerful
Yes, Hinduism was standardised and organised with the help of British. Back then, they didn't have any single unified religion in India. It's all politics
@@__Man__ Sad how politics mascurades as spirituality it shows you how easy we are to control as humans
@@M53478 What? Did you understand my comment? Hinduism as a UNIFIED institutionalized religion did not exist. The Cannon of Hinduism contains many books which have nothing to do with eachother, Hinduism was not one unified religion it was many different ones that ossified into One mythological theatre after a while.
@@M53478 And are you not aware India was called the British Raj for a century?
@@nadjiguemarful it's politic and scams. No wonder why India is the biggest scammers on earth because their identity themselves was founded on many scams based on mythological record instead of archeological record
The documentary film in a way let modern day people imagine the lives of the black slaves in North America, Carribean islands in the 17-19th century.
That was America darkest history.
Hi, I'm from Brazil and I didn't know almost anything about Tibet besides the lies told by the great western media, I was happy to discover things I would never know if it wasn't for this documentary.
It's sad to know that the liberation of the Tibetan people is treated in such a distorted and negative way here, our elites fear that one day we will also free ourselves just like the Tibetan people.
Congratulations Tibetan brothers, may the revolution reach the whole world someday.
Good now you know. This was in the Chinese histroy books in China & not outside ( suppressed by US & Britain ). Sad.
UA-cam is an American company, so what you see is basically what the United States wants you to see. What kind of country is the United States? The whole world knows, hypocrisy, lying, aggressive
@@btiger9495 How do you know to trust the Chinese history books in the first place if you have a skeptical eye for one side and a blind eye for another?
@@DC-vn7kc It's called critical thinking. Hopefully one day you will be able to tell.
@DC777 , it is called Due Diligence. Most brainwashed people rely on Western mainstream media for info. And, always radicalize not to believe non-western sources. No surprise there. No difference from fanatic radicalized Muslims. Very sad.
Thank you so much for uploading this docu. I had no idea and have been touched to tears by the statements of the survivors and their unspeakable suffering.
I have only recently woken up to the lies I have been told for 40 years now by the western system. Since I have started doubting and questioning everything and am reviewing my beliefs. I have now subscribed to your channel and will continue following your videos. So again thank you for reaching out, providing the truth and spreading the love.
Come to me... Why blame west for our true stories. You want truth! Come to Dharamsala, India. Not USA, OR ANY OTHER WESTERN WORLD OR CHINESE STATE RUN MEDIAS EITHER.
It is Good that you have finally wakened up from the western lies and cheat.
This dark side of Lama controlled Tibet is never spoken of in the Westerm media! Thanks very much. I would like to draw your attention to another interesting aspect of this story. The Cerf owners usually are been born as cerfs in their next life! This is how Karma functions. Colonizer is born as colonized! Universal law of Karma never does any injustice to anyone!
Very Lucky China came to rescue the Tibetian people
That's some powerful documentation! Great job! It's a good thing that they are still alive to tell their stories. That's priceless.
Nice, tons of historical documentary clips
Thank you very much for showing the truth about Tibet, and refute the western propaganda! 谢谢！
As of Apr 2023 today, only 23K viewers watched this video after 1 yr! That's less than 0.01% (1/100%) of US population. That means a very very small percentage of the people is actually aware of Serfdom in Tibet. This extreme slavery is deeply hidden away.
So, when the west or anti-China population advocated for Tibet's freedom, they actually wanted to force the Tibetans back to extreme slavery under the Dalai Lama, and feudal system (old Tibet govt officials and aristocrats). These were 3 classes of masters who owned the slaves outright.
Most likely 99% of the western population is ignorant of Serfdom practices. All they think is Communism is evil, brainwashed by the MSM and political ideology. Of cos'they don't know Serfdom was abolished by the Communist Party. Over 1 million extremely abused slaves were liberated since 1959!!! In US, blacks were still badly discriminated, mistreated and separated in 1959. They cannot vote until after the Voting Rights Bill was passed in 1965!! Took 6 yrs after Serfdom was abolished in Tibet, China. This is very sad indeed. 😢😢 When will the real Historians redress this misinformation? Or propaganda?
This is the same as the upper southern states of the United States wanting to continue to have black slaves. The Dalai Lama has never been the president of Tibet. Tibet is just an administrative region like a state in China, but its propaganda in some media has turned into a government-in-exile representing the people.
Many people forget a simple reality, since the CCP did not persecute Christians, Taoists and Muslims, why did it persecute Buddhists. Some people say that the CCP persecutes Tibetans and Uyghurs, so why don’t the remaining 53 ethnic minorities persecute them together.
So is it possible that the police are only arresting criminals, but they are considered to be arresting ordinary citizens? It's really infuriating that so much of the media is deceiving ordinary people these days.
你以为他们不知道吗？知道但是他们是白种人不允许黄种人比他们更出色。