What Does 24 Members REALLY Mean? (tripleS Analysis)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 128

  • @ShinMinhoKPOP
    @ShinMinhoKPOP Місяць тому +248

    Seoyeon began this journey with "Isn't 24 too many?" I think by now we know, "No it isn't!" Everyday I find a little something (or a big something) that makes me fall in love with tripleS more, and I would bet many other WAVs do too. Of course, I'm here for the music and their performances, but the family and sisterhood aspect is what makes me enjoy knowing every single member. They are endlessly entertaining. I have my bias line, but I really do love each member. I hope more people will watch this and your "sorority" video, Ben, and fall in love with this group as much as we have. Great job, Ben!!

    • @Blaze72sH
      @Blaze72sH Місяць тому +8

      From "isn't 24 too many?" To "stage feels empty without 24."

    • @24Sonyeo
      @24Sonyeo Місяць тому +5

      I mean like it's more than just a big 24 girl group , it's very flexible and has high potential

    • @ava-rainehouston
      @ava-rainehouston 28 днів тому

      @@Blaze72sH this hits hard lmao

  • @CocoGen21
    @CocoGen21 Місяць тому +134

    additional point for aspect 1, I forgot the exact date but on the same day and the same hour, tripleS performed in 3 different schedules across the nation, they’re really everywhere all at once🤣

  • @moohan5398
    @moohan5398 Місяць тому +38

    Dahyun said that tripleS always dominate in numbers
    if tripleS bow at you, you have to bow back 24 times

  • @RudeMekanicals
    @RudeMekanicals Місяць тому +116

    One advantage is that no other group could have made the Badge Wars as entertaining as Triple S!!! Classics!

    • @samsaumaralikhan
      @samsaumaralikhan Місяць тому +5

      You can say that again

    • @RudeMekanicals
      @RudeMekanicals Місяць тому +6

      @@samsaumaralikhan One advantage is that no other group could have made the Badge Wars as entertaining as Triple S!!! Classics! lol!

    • @samsaumaralikhan
      @samsaumaralikhan Місяць тому +5

      @@RudeMekanicals LOUDERRRRR

    • @RudeMekanicals
      @RudeMekanicals Місяць тому +6

      @@samsaumaralikhan ONE ADVANTAGE IS THAT NO OTHER GROUP COULD HAVE MADE THE BADGE WARS AS ENTERTAINING AS TRIPLE S!!! CLASSICS!

    • @samsaumaralikhan
      @samsaumaralikhan Місяць тому +5

      @@RudeMekanicals 🤣🤣 AMEN

  • @yukimuraryuuto4839
    @yukimuraryuuto4839 Місяць тому +158

    World tours 24 countries at the same time?? You hear that Jaden Jeong 🤧

  • @RukaKikuchi
    @RukaKikuchi Місяць тому +120

    tripleS truly is a microcosm of what a typical AKB48 group is like, but on a much MUCH smaller scale. "Endless possibilities and infinite chaos" is the most perfect description for this group and I love it. 😂😂

  • @Burn143
    @Burn143 Місяць тому +50

    The great thing about TripleS is that the members are extremely charismatic/distinctive. Especially with having 24 members, I can always count on being entertained by them.😂Music is also great too.

  • @Valryx
    @Valryx Місяць тому +60

    Ohgod, any member could be put with any other member(s) for performances anywhere, and each member would have to learn different positions and choreo depending on who they are with.
    How can they dance so well having to constantly change things up, that's so impressive. 🤯

  • @Eljehani
    @Eljehani Місяць тому +44

    Maturing is realizing that 24 members is actually a good number for groups. Yeah it might be too big for some people and their names are hard to memorize and such but genuinely I've grown to love every single girl on tripleS more and more each day. It makes it fun to Stan them because there's 24 amazing and talented girls who make every single video ever made about them both entertaining and/or funny whether it's a fancam or a short compilation of their funniest moments! I love them so much

  • @lucaspena3267
    @lucaspena3267 Місяць тому +16

    Being a teacher and stanning TripleS actually makes so much sence

  • @jessietrollcat9215
    @jessietrollcat9215 Місяць тому +10

    I remember they once performed at 3 different festivals in the same day. 8 members on each stage

  • @jrvinwav
    @jrvinwav Місяць тому +10

    I freaking love tripleS, verty thankful to modhaus and Jaden for making tripleS. The biggest drawback for me having 24 members is that I miss my pairings so bad sometimes... specially my SeoYeon and YooYeon.

  • @adamsaustria2005
    @adamsaustria2005 Місяць тому +31

    idk why i have personally seen some people complain about members getting short breaks in the full group dances, because that is a weird ass thing to complain about

  • @Briarpatchlogic
    @Briarpatchlogic Місяць тому +37

    The ONLY analysis of SSS I need is that every dang one of them is a talent monster and drop dead gorgeous ❤

    • @everysongforME
      @everysongforME Місяць тому +2

      im thinking about this everyday...how can Jaden jeong picked 24 girls put in a group and all of them acutally are pretty 😭even from a non fan perspective.
      i know there was LOONA but damn jaden is something else on concept wise.

    • @Briarpatchlogic
      @Briarpatchlogic Місяць тому

      @@everysongforME excellent point...I'm sure there is some kind of conspiracy at work

  • @HyperAB
    @HyperAB Місяць тому +17

    im still shocked Ben doesnt have a bigger channel, you are by far and away one of, if not my favorite kpop channel. Your deep dives and analysis videos are top tier.

  • @PotetoEcho
    @PotetoEcho Місяць тому +57

    It's VV day and we also get a Ben Atmos tripleS video? Wavs are blessed

    • @audiboy6670
      @audiboy6670 Місяць тому +1

      what is vv day?

    • @V_OmegA
      @V_OmegA Місяць тому

      @@audiboy6670 come on...

    • @BinSensei94
      @BinSensei94 Місяць тому

      @@audiboy6670 tripleS’ new subunit “Visionary Vision (VV)” is releasing their MV/album later today.

    • @clvh2289
      @clvh2289 Місяць тому

      @@audiboy6670tripleS is coming back with new subunit Visionary Vision (VV)! :D

    • @irealisticc
      @irealisticc Місяць тому

      ​@@audiboy6670 their subunit visionary vision is abt to debut today!

  • @gumi030
    @gumi030 Місяць тому +13

    thank you for this video! i know a lot of people aren’t too interested because of the amount of members, but stanning tripleS is the best experience you could ever have. aside from the amount of members, their music is beyond anything you’ve heard from kpop recently. i love being wav and hope your video reaches new audiences!!

  • @resturamadani7
    @resturamadani7 Місяць тому +3

    TripleS member combination is a permutation of 24! , for example in pairings, you can attach each of any 24 member with the other 23, and that gives you 24 x 23 = 552 combinations!! And the multiplies goes on the more member put in a slots, like you probably will always see new chemistry in between them.
    For the dancemoves, in a jaechingu shows yuyeon said that they match the dance like D -1 before the stage performances, so they probably learnt all the basic dancemoves while adapting on the positions it the dance.
    Yuyeon also said that they have 8 - 9 managers, well, it made sense considering the chaos that might comes with that many members, yuyeon and tone doesn't even know how their stylists go with them during events.
    I'm happy to know about this group, and they surprises me in every comeback

  • @antinapay
    @antinapay Місяць тому +11

    Ben Atmos has delivered another masterpiece

  • @R4YTheGamer
    @R4YTheGamer Місяць тому +25

    WERE SO BACK! 🗣 Yk its a SPECIAL day when Ben posts + tripleS cb 😎
    Awesome vid as always~

    • @benatmos
      @benatmos  Місяць тому +4

      Thanks! VV hype!! 🥳

  • @Dreamcatchinggahyun
    @Dreamcatchinggahyun Місяць тому +6

    It remembers me when we were waiting for Girls Never Die release: every hour they would release a message from a different members each time starting from Jiyeon to Seoyeon ( Seoyeonz lol) so s24 to s1 wich is soooo smart
    btw when Seoyeon said "Isn't 24 too many?" I would definitely say yes if I was a baby WAV wich is not the case anymore but when were WAVs since a long time (let's say from the Assemble 24) you realize that you cannot imagine TripleS with less members only for units

  • @Nory86
    @Nory86 Місяць тому +13

    I’m been trying to get into triple s and IM OVERWHELMED

    • @hellencristinamarcelino5697
      @hellencristinamarcelino5697 Місяць тому +3

      watch the signals in the right order, I'm doing this and I already know the first 16 members in less then 2 months (because I'm an university student so... I don't have so much time) and I'm planning in watching the badge war season 1 with this 16 members I already know bc every wav says that it really helps to know them better, and then after I know the last 8 girls, I'll watch the second season yay

    • @gumi030
      @gumi030 Місяць тому +2

      i recommend watching badge war season 1 and 2 here on youtube!!

    • @Blaze72sH
      @Blaze72sH Місяць тому +1

      Triples channel -> set the video filter to "oldest" -> enjoy.

    • @Pandaxo_143
      @Pandaxo_143 Місяць тому +3

      I’m literally watching the signals from beginning to end. It’s better to do it now that later! And it’s totally worth it 😊

    • @triplesgalaxies
      @triplesgalaxies Місяць тому +2

      i started with badge war it was a disaster but i knew the members names and order. i watched a few signals and boom all of them were really easy to distinguish

  • @trevajct
    @trevajct Місяць тому +5

    Great video Ben, your answer to the question around how they decide roles is interestingly answered in the latest VV variety show video with Jaefriends. As it's noted by YooYeon they choose themselves the day before depending on the combinations and they need to learn up to something like 20 different combinations at any time. Seems likes of Naky and Kae are the leaders from dance coordination. It's a testament to just how talented they all are and despite some WAV and fans dislike, it's why it makes sense choreography styles are very similar across the board.

  • @Little3888
    @Little3888 Місяць тому +17

    Ben, who are your TripleS biases now that you've had time to digest the last 4 members?

    • @benatmos
      @benatmos  Місяць тому +21

      It’s always shifting a little bit but I would say Hyerin, Yeonji, Kotone, and Chaewon make a solid top four right now!
      Chaewon was SO FUNNY in all the ASSEMBLE24 behinds I watched preparing for this video, so she’s a recent addition. Every member in Glow has climbed my bias list a lot though! 👍

    • @Diyel
      @Diyel Місяць тому +4

      ​@@benatmos are you gonna update the sorority vid, now that we have more info about the last 8?

    • @Little3888
      @Little3888 Місяць тому +1

      @@benatmos Yes I always thought Acid Angels would be my fave, but then Glow shocked me... Chaewon immediately became my top bias too, and lately I've been intrigued by Hyerin and Joobin. Nakyoung gives a bit of Kim Lip vibe so she'll always be special...she first drew me to TripleS the same way Kim Lip drew me to OEC (and Kpop in general). Jaden has a good eye.

    • @benatmos
      @benatmos  Місяць тому

      @@Diyel I do have plans to! I'm thinking early 2025, but we will see.

  • @iiiHyejun
    @iiiHyejun Місяць тому +5

    i love that triples is 24 members!! because it makes them really unic in kpop and in music. im glad we got to see this big of a kpop group in our time and if we think about it 24 isnt that many members to be fair. Also did you know triples is 1 of the fastest growing fandoms that exist rn!!

  • @elijahlopez324
    @elijahlopez324 Місяць тому +5

    I'm loving more of the TripleS content you've been making. Because of you, they have become one of my ult groups. Please continue to make more! You're my favorite youtuber when it comes to TripleS content and maybe even kpop content in general. TY BEN!

  • @t.dsmith8619
    @t.dsmith8619 Місяць тому +2

    I'm pretty sure Yooyeon said in the recent Jaejoong interview with her and Kotone that they pretty much handle all the unit switching themselves when it comes to performances

  • @Erik_Emer
    @Erik_Emer Місяць тому +4

    It's reported their monthly food expense is 30,000,000 won, which means their yearly enpense is 360,000,000, meaning about 216,000 USD, the yearly wage of a general physician, pilot, or construction safety director...
    So, I hope people are buying them cosmos to fund their overall expenses for the members to earn (at least a near Korean) average living salary.

    • @freeyaw29
      @freeyaw29 Місяць тому

      more likely goes into their crypto investor and the girls only got a small cut from those objekt revenue

    • @Erik_Emer
      @Erik_Emer Місяць тому +1

      @@freeyaw29
      True, but it seems like the girls still get a good cut from that remaining percentile. Someone on Reddit did the math for (a recent at the time) 7 day sales for an all member objekt sale where it was revealed ~90000 objekts were bought, meaning the revenue for those 7 days was ~269,100 usd at a 2.99 usd price point. If we take a range for the split between company:members as 90:10 to 50:50, that’s somewhere 1,125.25 to 5,606,25 usd per member. So, that on top of album sales, the multiple appearances they make per day thanks to the the group splitting up for promotions in different locations on the same day, and probably merch sale, they make pretty good wages.
      For the investors, I don’t know how true that is.

  • @freeyaw29
    @freeyaw29 Місяць тому +4

    1:53 Yooyeon and Seoyeon last interaction. funny they got separated until now 😂

  • @eternally_01
    @eternally_01 Місяць тому +5

    tripleS comeback!!!

  • @pokiedokie24
    @pokiedokie24 Місяць тому +2

    Ben Atmos recruiting more WAVs again ❤️

  • @MadaraxUchiha
    @MadaraxUchiha Місяць тому +1

    Thanks for this video, you're a true WAV too lol
    tripleS is my second favorite girl group in K-pop, I stanned them during Generation, I just love all 24 members, their music, sub-units and their concept! They truly are an Idol of all Possibilities.
    My bias is Jiyeon

  • @HoaPhan-ge1bf
    @HoaPhan-ge1bf Місяць тому +1

    Absolutely love your stuff, Ben; it's the most unique, yet entertaining on the platform. Keep it up!

  • @SUGARCUBE.playlists
    @SUGARCUBE.playlists Місяць тому +1

    Yes, I believe managing 24 members can be challenging for the company, but it also enhances the experience for fans and WAVs who enjoy their content even more. Each member has their own unique charm, abilities, personality, and position, which makes it hard for WAVs to choose just one bias. That’s what’s great about big groups. I've been a WAV since their first subunit, and with time, I got to know all the members by name and personality. For new WAVs or those interested in stanning the group, it might seem overwhelming at first, but I assure you, it's worth it. This video by Ben Atmos really shows why this group is so special, and whether you're already a fan or just curious, you'll appreciate them even more, I know I did. 😁❤

  • @GaSz-h6k
    @GaSz-h6k 12 днів тому

    Im addicted to your triples contents, pls make more~

  • @Foxziewolf
    @Foxziewolf Місяць тому +1

    The section where you were talking about keeping track of all 24 girls, the fact that you DIDNT insert the clip from S2 of their reality show where the group themselves didnt notice Yubin and Chaewon go missing, is a crime. XD

  • @justwavvv
    @justwavvv Місяць тому +1

    TODAY IS VV DAY WE ARE SO BACK!!!

  • @soul_reaper1611
    @soul_reaper1611 Місяць тому +2

    Strength in Numbers 😂

  • @V_OmegA
    @V_OmegA Місяць тому +29

    Jaden recipe works... kudos to all the JJ haters from 2019... ;)

  • @Marcondirondirondello
    @Marcondirondirondello Місяць тому +1

    I literally can't wait for their world tour!

  • @TsChryssa
    @TsChryssa Місяць тому +1

    It's not that hard to stan a classroom guyyyyyys ! Love those girls, great vid!

  • @KapowGamer
    @KapowGamer Місяць тому +1

    My mind is thinking about Jaden being Gru & triples their minions, then i laugh a lot 😭

  • @louisxD
    @louisxD Місяць тому +1

    Great content as always

  • @lXpe0
    @lXpe0 Місяць тому

    Adoro tus videos de tripleS. ¡Gracias!

  • @phywem
    @phywem Місяць тому +1

    The second aspect is absolutely true

  • @Diyel
    @Diyel Місяць тому +1

    Hey, guys, wake up! Ben Atmos is baaaaack! When are you gonna update the explaining triple S like a Sorority?

  • @Jeilatin143
    @Jeilatin143 Місяць тому

    8:25 I dare you Ben...😂😂😂😂😂

  • @jayem5541
    @jayem5541 Місяць тому

    I like everything you said about aspect 4 that all them have different personalities and unique traits and they benefit each with those traits ❤❤❤

  • @dano_col9347
    @dano_col9347 Місяць тому +1

    Omg! I have enough chairs in my home for all of them!!! 🙋🏻‍♂️🙃

  • @Remmusnus
    @Remmusnus Місяць тому +2

    We don't need full squad to complete tripleS..24 is tripleS 8 is tripleS 6 is tripleS 😊

  • @Hal-uq5qv
    @Hal-uq5qv Місяць тому +1

    28 Parter? Do IT Ben 😎

  • @Diameansday
    @Diameansday Місяць тому

    This is making me wanna stan! i've been listening to them since 2022 november anyways

  • @Sakane.01
    @Sakane.01 Місяць тому +1

    6:55 Genuine question, has NCT even promoted and performed with all the members all at once?

    • @ngoctanpham.
      @ngoctanpham. Місяць тому +2

      Yes.. NCT 2018 Black on black, NCT 2020 Resonance, NCT 2021 Beautiful,...

    • @Sakane.01
      @Sakane.01 Місяць тому

      @@ngoctanpham. Yeah, but I meant like all 25/26 members

  • @triplesgalaxies
    @triplesgalaxies Місяць тому

    i just wanna say you're the only fanboy i like i respect you

  • @lunaris7342
    @lunaris7342 Місяць тому +1

    I have spend to much time in Jpop I dont even understand anymore what the Problem with many Members it. I love Groups with many Members. TripleS seems to work like some Jpop Groups in many ways

  • @TheBlbeemer
    @TheBlbeemer Місяць тому

    When you dive into triples, it's worth it though.

  • @kinrateia
    @kinrateia Місяць тому +1

    Your sona looks like adrian agreste i cant unsee it

  • @dabinshiii
    @dabinshiii Місяць тому +1

    8:00 Jiwoo 100%

  • @okumuraaa
    @okumuraaa Місяць тому

    i love your videos SO MUCH, you are my favorite kpop blogger

  • @ava-rainehouston
    @ava-rainehouston 28 днів тому

    like, yeah, 24 members in the one group might SEEM too big, but its actually not!! plus, when you get to know all of the members, you can't ever imagine tripleS without them

  • @jeffreyknutson
    @jeffreyknutson Місяць тому +1

    My BIAS is ... ALL OF THEM!!!

  • @tickymeister883
    @tickymeister883 Місяць тому +1

    i love tripleS

  • @YohanesRobby
    @YohanesRobby Місяць тому

    i can say that Jaden Jeong is genius

  • @HamburgersS5
    @HamburgersS5 Місяць тому

    9:10 I’m sorry what now I didn’t notice till now OMG YeonJi is a human robot 😱 that’s crazy I never see ppl do that b4

  • @w-illo
    @w-illo Місяць тому

    i hear yooyeon and nien at 7:58..?? also soomin i think idk 😢

  • @ava-rainehouston
    @ava-rainehouston 28 днів тому

    9:06 OH MY GOD... YEONJI... ????????

  • @orbitingaroundannie
    @orbitingaroundannie Місяць тому

    8:57 mayu did NOT want to be there (please correct me if it's not mayu, I'm a new WAV)

  • @crudojoshuaricofort8795
    @crudojoshuaricofort8795 Місяць тому

    4:53 is 99% gonna happen in the future or maybe it already did...

  • @dessu8967
    @dessu8967 Місяць тому +2

    9:32 hey ben, love your videos and I'm not trying to start anything but unless you've seen a clip of Nien herself explicitly self-identify as Chinese, I don't think you should put her in the "Chinese" line with Xinyu. Nien's nationality is Taiwanese and that is different. As a Taiwanese-American myself, I wouldn't identify as Chinese. I know it takes a lot of work to make your videos so it's too late now but a friendly suggestion, in future videos you could just say Nien is the Taiwanese member just like how you say Sullin is the Thai member.

    • @benatmos
      @benatmos  Місяць тому +2

      Got it 👌 Sorry about that and thanks for letting me know. I added a correction in the subtitles.

    • @ngoctanpham.
      @ngoctanpham. Місяць тому

      Nien is Taiwanese-Vietnamese

    • @dessu8967
      @dessu8967 Місяць тому

      @@benatmos no worries, thanks for having an open ear, we all learn something new every day

  • @estebandelgadotenorio6642
    @estebandelgadotenorio6642 Місяць тому

    I Watch es a freaking guide and I could get al ,ember like I forgot hoy they look like and who they are , inremember names but I forgot their looks is gonna be hard for me and I wanna know like who is who fr and dono get it wrong I looooove this group

    • @merci-tg4se
      @merci-tg4se Місяць тому

      watch badge war !! you'll end up remembering at least some of them

  • @JohanPark07
    @JohanPark07 Місяць тому

    Brooo what happened to Yeonji's eyes 😭

  • @SoraiaLMotta
    @SoraiaLMotta Місяць тому +2

    I guess it must work to like the group overall, but hard to an individual level. Its curious indeed.
    I can barley keep up with 17 and their 13 members x1,84 will be a challenge.

    • @geneglow8439
      @geneglow8439 Місяць тому +4

      I'd say it's only difficult if you're forcing yourself to learn them all at once. 24 members sounds overwhelming, yeah, but you'll naturally get to know each of them the more you see and read about them (basically by watching their content), so there's really no rush to remember everyone. It's okay to start small (maybe only keep up with a few members or subunits that stand out to you) and if you wish to learn more, you can.

  • @andreesteves2
    @andreesteves2 Місяць тому +1

    I'm Brazilian, and a group with 24 women here in my country wouldn't last 6 months. There would only be envy and fights.
    I find it surreal that this works.

  • @Fernanda-sg4on
    @Fernanda-sg4on Місяць тому

    Bro how long does any of you try to remember their names?, it took me a whole month to remember each member biography

    • @chrisssw_
      @chrisssw_ Місяць тому +1

      it just comes naturally by watching their content

  • @MEMORIESDREAMFUN
    @MEMORIESDREAMFUN Місяць тому

    But someone lost😢 rare item when she come.if you popular vote good very good screentime but if you not popular tranfer to invisibles

  • @KDawggs
    @KDawggs Місяць тому

    BEN IN HIS TRIPLES ERA 💯💯💯💯💢💢💢💢💢🙊🙊🙊🏳‍🌈🏳‍🌈🏳‍🌈

  • @doneace
    @doneace Місяць тому

    우리 트리플에스 홍보해주셔서 진심으로 감사드립니다❤
    오늘 트리플에스 Visionary Vision이란 새로운 트리플에스 유닛이 나와요
    많은 관심 부탁드립니다^^

  • @ahchoo6579
    @ahchoo6579 Місяць тому

    9:07 wait is that real?

  • @rissa_77
    @rissa_77 Місяць тому +1

    WHAT HAPPENED TO YEONJI HELP

  • @bullbae02
    @bullbae02 Місяць тому +1

    it means so little earnings

    • @gumi030
      @gumi030 Місяць тому

      actually, all the members have already received their paychecks. they make money from their objekts, which fans buy to support them. all of their food is paid for and they’re well compensated! they’re very open about it too!

    • @freeyaw29
      @freeyaw29 Місяць тому

      their idol salary and their objekt cut are different.

    • @9921-l4n
      @9921-l4n Місяць тому +1

      they already said it in national television program that their paycheck is equivalent to a section chief at a major company.

    • @Blaze72sH
      @Blaze72sH Місяць тому

      You'd be surprised.

  • @junyapa
    @junyapa Місяць тому

    When you say things about they are the big family I’m gonna crying..🥹

  • @itzpotatochips
    @itzpotatochips Місяць тому

    just in time for vision@ry vision !! thanks for making this