basic rights???? PR or work permit is a privlege not a damn right. gov can give or NOT. it is not indian persons right to demand. the audacity of you people to call it a right.
But for attracting students they show a work rights and when at the time of giving they change the law for international students who pay 6 times more fees than Canadian. May canada not want international students now and in initial ground there is disinterest of student with studying in canada but again to attract student will much more difficult for Canadian government. Canada not have achieve any extraordinary thing that can rank their universities so high but it was due to the students of different countries who select Canadian universities. I am seeing a deep fall in ranking of universities and interest of students to study in canada.
@@User15699”international STUDENT” yall came here to study. It would be a whole different conversation if yall actually have work skills that Canada needs and no, working at at Tim Hortons and gas stations doesnt count
@@User15699 no one invited students, what ever lies were told by your own indian immigration agents in india, who have no legal right to talk on behalf of Canadian gov. Trudea or nmark miller never gurenteed visa or work. few years back, students were not even allowed to work. 20 to 40 hour work was suppose to be temporary policy. Students were given permission for a temporary stay, not PR. you indians want to enter as students then never want to go back, which is a clear violation of return to home after study disclaimer that every student signs when applying for visa. again, PR is a privlege not anyones right. students pay 6 times fee because your parents never contributed to Canada with tax. Canadians get that advantage because our generations have been paying tax, it was our tax that built these universities.
@jodijaanify when I say invite students I say attract students canada government works very deeply with the agents to attract indian students so their is the big role of government in attracting india students. Another Canadian law allows students to apply for work after study visa not trudeau or mark Miller. Why students come to canada over other countries by observing that he or she can study 2 years and work 3 years. This after work was important reason behind students selection canada as country and canada government can also increase 1.5 years after this 3 years which Canadian government always do . But now students study for 2 years they not get work permit for which they select canada over many countries. If indian students are doing violation then why Canadian government is providing PR to students why they are even giving PR to students and violating their own rules. The reason is this is not a rule violation they apply legally and students never demand citizenship they demand for work visa or extension which is their rights as Canadian system promises them while selecting. Many Canadian thinks that we pay tax that why we pay less that is clearly not true even some German institutions provide free education to international students the reason behind high price for international students is that institutions runs on the international students money and that money build that University and give rank globally. If this students decrease institution funding will not cover by taxes in fews years you will see some public institution will suffer from expenses.
International students have been flocking to a loophole-to-immigration. Utilizing schooling as a backdoor ticket to Canada (instead of using the upfront immigration channels). Swarming a system that was NOT designed to be about EVERY student wanting PR. Now all Canadians have clued in that Canada's post secondary education system has (in 4 years time) turned into EDUGRATION. Something that the PUBLIC schools were NOT created for. Plus edugration (public or private) was NEVER approved by everyday Canadians. Plus what about Ghost Consulting that Canada told India to halt? What about the $ greedy foreign agents MARKETING & LYING to their own people about access to PR etc., being easy to get? What about IELTS spouses? Anchor babies? Fraud? False asylum claims? What about Canadian food banks & charity services being recklessly advertised on YT in Indian languages? What about Canadian housing being scooped up en-mass as investment vehicles by/for internationals? What about home rental/boarding signs stating "vegetarians only can apply"? Are all international students truly Scholars … or are most Economic Migrants (who BORROWED $ to buy their way to the head of the immigration line)? Yes Canada made some unfortunate mistakes especially by not pumping the immigration brakes sooner. But to say all the students (or their consultants back home) have not been at times 'gaming' Canada's EDUCATION programs to PRIMARILY gain western PR is ridiculous. Canadians want multi-culturism to succeed … and for all people (including immigrants) to be okay. Everyone I know is very happy with IRCC's recent changes (reductions & multifaceted investigations etc.). Including multi-generational long-term Asian-Canadians where many have been the MOST upset (by all of this). PS Canadians are aware that some great students are going through hell. And know Canada is partially to blame which hurts Canadian hearts. But bottom-line, Canada decides what needs to be done in Canada. Do you see Canadians protesting in other countries (that is not their own) making demands for themselves? No. Do Canadians see students from South Asia protesting in Canada, making demands since the world pandemic? Yes. If 36,000,000 Canadians travelled to India, since 2020, with the primary goal of being able to stay there permanently, that would raise India's population by 2.65%. Recent migrators (after PR) … especially the students... have raised Canada's population 2.65%. Changes are occurring in 2024, for HUGE reasons.
If they can do that, there are plenty of opportunity in India to lead lavish life. Even a poor apprentice from little known but genuine Hotel management degree and little five star hotel experience in India who was on short term US visa is now facilities manager in Amazon USA, married to daughter of his senior in company, and US citizen leading comfortable life with 2,00,000 family income in USA, at age 28. There is nothing special for such people in Canada
@@saurabhade1079why do you speak of isolated cases of peoples lives as though it’s a possibility for the collective just because it’s the US. You have no idea what you’re talking about about my friend.
Not only that, Canadian citizens are being denied jobs anywhere the vast majority of workers are Indian because they refuse to hire anyone not of their culture?
Stop saying Indian students and start saying as it is. Say sikh permanent resident aspirants from Punjab. Almost 100% of these “students “ are sikhs from Punjab. They come to Canada NOT to study. They come to get PR status by hook or crook.
Truth - Their work permit is denied because they are not working in the area of their graduation or in specialization they have completed their degree. These people are working in Tim Hortons, and Walmart and Canadian teens can't find work so these peoplea are aked to return home or find work in the area of their specialization/in which they have obtained the canadian degree.
Policy change doesn't happen overnight, even if it does its not your right to protest it. You're a guest here trying to be PR. This does not look good on you.
Why do you have to go to Canada to live in a small space and work tirelessly to meet the ends when you are educated and qualified? Stay back in Bharath, Come back to India..you will live in Peace and happiness It's a myth that you'll be happy there .. Vande Mataram!
I am indian living in canada. I want to say this : It's not anyone right to protest for PR . Work hard and apply for it just like we done earlier..canadians are best ppl i ever seen thats y still they living in canada😊
If it was only just school then back to your country, that would be great, but that's not what happens . I personally think that's the plan from applying to a Canadian school to getting here on a campus . You should stop applying and go home and let everyone know Canada is not going to accept you once you are out of school. It's not racism as i used no countries name but Canada . It's fed up with other countries taking advantage of Canadian kindness.
Did these students take an undertaking that they'll return to their home country once they completed their studies? PR is not a right, it's a privilege!!
They should have mention that earlier , First they took high fres from Oversee students and then deny to give work permit, it is simply loot.They didn't go just for your education, It is because of your Currency strength. They want to give back the money to their Parents by working there.
@@Subhash-oy9mf They are not citizens that why they pay higher fees. It's the same situation in all others countries by the way.They were ready to pay these tuition fees thinking that will give them PR.Solution very simple: stay and study in your country!!!
Construction or Health Care....what's the issue? Oh wait, you don't want those jobs, easy and high paying. I get it. I see most of them as bullies and I'm not liking it
So much misinformation here. None of the 5 people in the panel understood the issue correctly. 0 basic research and understanding of what a work permit is.
No, they're not being denied work permits. There are work permits available but all the Indian people want to do is work in retail in coffee shops. None of them want to take the jobs that are offering work opportunities which would allow them to stay
I went to highschool with a girl from China. Only one Chinese student. I asked her how she got to come to Canada. She had to write a test and make a high mark and be sponsored by someone in Canada.
I am a resident of PEI, and I support the protestors. I hope that they are allowed to stay here. They want to be here, and they've started building lives here. It's unfair to suddenly change the rules, and it would be very unfair to force them to leave.
They changed the rules on getting PR. They're allowing them to stay until their permit expires.... they didn't say "well, you can work here for 2 years" and then kick them out 6 months later. Some of the people protesting were interviewed and said they have less than 50 points toward immigration and are demanding to be allowed to stay as long as necessary to get the points. What's the point of even having an immigration point system unless it matters. I'm old enough to remember when my province just started to bring in Indian immigrants and I hadn't met one who wasn't friendly and kind. They loved to share food and culture with neighbours; they integrated into the general society while keeping their personal customs. They studied hard, they worked hard, and they earned the types of education that made them a net positive to society. I've had to check the local court docket daily for 2 decades (stalker reasons) and I can't remember ever seeing a name usually associated with India. The recent wave of students are not like that. They're trying to jump the queue over other immigrants (including those from India) who are more than qualified to stay here and are working their way through the process the right way. The biggest group of people who want them to go home are other people from South Asia, because of the crime and housing issues. We're not allowed to discriminate in Canada when it comes to renting, but over 80% of apartment rentals in the GTA say "Punjabi (Or Gujarati) only". Now there are more India-associated names on the court docket than anyone else. Stats Can just released a report showing that of the people inadequately housed (homeless, living in overcrowded conditions), over 60% of them are Indian students crowded into homes, with up to 25 people living together.
Then you take 10 of them into your home and live for few years with them. Then you go with them to India and stay there for few years. Then give us your opinion again.
Which rights he is talking about. Did they not declare that they will return after they study is finished. There is no right for an International Students.
Immigration agents & students from Canada shoudl provide right informaiton. Indian student sin canada posting all hifi picures, car, vacation, luxurious road trip, etc giving impression that Canada is lan of opportunity , u can make future there. This needs to be stopped. reality is totally different
Is there somewhere they were given any papers that gave them right to Job. Once they study they should get back home. So did you apply from Immigration or to Study. Please get out. International Students are not Welcome in Canada. specifically Indian Students.
They are about to learn what born canadians learn everyday, that they do not really have a say in the rules in this country. So if they dont get grandfathered in and get sent back to India, the'll just have to cope, par for the course, as Canadians didnt have a say in whether or not they could come here and get residency.
What a smart bunch... Getting into over $40,000 worth of debt that will take a lifetime to pay off back in their home country. And now they want PR to work in a prosperous country to get out of this self-inflicted debt trap.
I was an international students too. These students are from poor family. 25 induan students living in one room. If you dont have money and skill stay away from Canada.
They should study and then go back to India and then apply for Immigration as a skilled Entry. not jumping the line Student > Work Permit > becoming PR. Get out the International Students have not been cheated but the Students are trying to Cheat the Immigration System.
The students have no right to stay here, they were given a certain amount of time as students. Now it's time to go home. That's how it works. They don't have the right to demand things of the Canadian government. They are not citizens
There are lots of students from china, Vietnam they are not protesting why just Indians. Because they don’t like in India,they want to live life on luxury
Yes please dont study in Canada. Stay home and save your money
I second this!!
Don't save Money, sell your land and give to Canada colleges and come back India and pay loan 😂😂😂😂
basic rights???? PR or work permit is a privlege not a damn right. gov can give or NOT. it is not indian persons right to demand. the audacity of you people to call it a right.
Yep
But for attracting students they show a work rights and when at the time of giving they change the law for international students who pay 6 times more fees than Canadian. May canada not want international students now and in initial ground there is disinterest of student with studying in canada but again to attract student will much more difficult for Canadian government. Canada not have achieve any extraordinary thing that can rank their universities so high but it was due to the students of different countries who select Canadian universities. I am seeing a deep fall in ranking of universities and interest of students to study in canada.
@@User15699”international STUDENT” yall came here to study. It would be a whole different conversation if yall actually have work skills that Canada needs and no, working at at Tim Hortons and gas stations doesnt count
@@User15699 no one invited students, what ever lies were told by your own indian immigration agents in india, who have no legal right to talk on behalf of Canadian gov. Trudea or nmark miller never gurenteed visa or work. few years back, students were not even allowed to work. 20 to 40 hour work was suppose to be temporary policy. Students were given permission for a temporary stay, not PR. you indians want to enter as students then never want to go back, which is a clear violation of return to home after study disclaimer that every student signs when applying for visa. again, PR is a privlege not anyones right. students pay 6 times fee because your parents never contributed to Canada with tax. Canadians get that advantage because our generations have been paying tax, it was our tax that built these universities.
@jodijaanify when I say invite students I say attract students canada government works very deeply with the agents to attract indian students so their is the big role of government in attracting india students. Another Canadian law allows students to apply for work after study visa not trudeau or mark Miller. Why students come to canada over other countries by observing that he or she can study 2 years and work 3 years. This after work was important reason behind students selection canada as country and canada government can also increase 1.5 years after this 3 years which Canadian government always do . But now students study for 2 years they not get work permit for which they select canada over many countries. If indian students are doing violation then why Canadian government is providing PR to students why they are even giving PR to students and violating their own rules. The reason is this is not a rule violation they apply legally and students never demand citizenship they demand for work visa or extension which is their rights as Canadian system promises them while selecting. Many Canadian thinks that we pay tax that why we pay less that is clearly not true even some German institutions provide free education to international students the reason behind high price for international students is that institutions runs on the international students money and that money build that University and give rank globally. If this students decrease institution funding will not cover by taxes in fews years you will see some public institution will suffer from expenses.
International students have been flocking to a loophole-to-immigration. Utilizing schooling as a backdoor ticket to Canada (instead of using the upfront immigration channels). Swarming a system that was NOT designed to be about EVERY student wanting PR.
Now all Canadians have clued in that Canada's post secondary education system has (in 4 years time) turned into EDUGRATION. Something that the PUBLIC schools were NOT created for. Plus edugration (public or private) was NEVER approved by everyday Canadians.
Plus what about Ghost Consulting that Canada told India to halt? What about the $ greedy foreign agents MARKETING & LYING to their own people about access to PR etc., being easy to get? What about IELTS spouses? Anchor babies? Fraud? False asylum claims?
What about Canadian food banks & charity services being recklessly advertised on YT in Indian languages?
What about Canadian housing being scooped up en-mass as investment vehicles by/for internationals? What about home rental/boarding signs stating "vegetarians only can apply"?
Are all international students truly Scholars … or are most Economic Migrants (who BORROWED $ to buy their way to the head of the immigration line)? Yes Canada made some unfortunate mistakes especially by not pumping the immigration brakes sooner. But to say all the students (or their consultants back home) have not been at times 'gaming' Canada's EDUCATION programs to PRIMARILY gain western PR is ridiculous.
Canadians want multi-culturism to succeed … and for all people (including immigrants) to be okay. Everyone I know is very happy with IRCC's recent changes (reductions & multifaceted investigations etc.). Including multi-generational long-term Asian-Canadians where many have been the MOST upset (by all of this).
PS Canadians are aware that some great students are going through hell. And know Canada is partially to blame which hurts Canadian hearts. But bottom-line, Canada decides what needs to be done in Canada. Do you see Canadians protesting in other countries (that is not their own) making demands for themselves? No. Do Canadians see students from South Asia protesting in Canada, making demands since the world pandemic? Yes.
If 36,000,000 Canadians travelled to India, since 2020, with the primary goal of being able to stay there permanently, that would raise India's population by 2.65%. Recent migrators (after PR) … especially the students... have raised Canada's population 2.65%.
Changes are occurring in 2024, for HUGE reasons.
Well said. Take your country back before trudeau destroys it and burns it to the ground
To all Indians looking to immigrate to Canada: Study a useful degree at a reputable university. Do NOT go to a diploma mill college
If they can do that, there are plenty of opportunity in India to lead lavish life. Even a poor apprentice from little known but genuine Hotel management degree and little five star hotel experience in India who was on short term US visa is now facilities manager in Amazon USA, married to daughter of his senior in company, and US citizen leading comfortable life with 2,00,000 family income in USA, at age 28. There is nothing special for such people in Canada
@@saurabhade1079why do you speak of isolated cases of peoples lives as though it’s a possibility for the collective just because it’s the US.
You have no idea what you’re talking about about my friend.
many students don't even study at all
I live in Canada and these students come here to become permanent residents and then citizens. They use schools as a tool for their goal.
There was no shortage of Tim Horton workers before you came.
Many Canadians were denied work at tim hortons
They did not pay too much so tim,s was out of the question
Pay Yas tool low sorry ,
Not only that, Canadian citizens are being denied jobs anywhere the vast majority of workers are Indian because they refuse to hire anyone not of their culture?
Stop saying Indian students and start saying as it is. Say sikh permanent resident aspirants from Punjab. Almost 100% of these “students “ are sikhs from Punjab. They come to Canada NOT to study. They come to get PR status by hook or crook.
Some solid points being made by the panelists. You don’t need to spend $10k to go abroad and learn how to bake or cut hair. It’s ridiculous.
Please don’t cry because it’s Canada not India so let them apply their own rules for their own people benefit as Indian government do.
Truth - Their work permit is denied because they are not working in the area of their graduation or in specialization they have completed their degree. These people are working in Tim Hortons, and Walmart and Canadian teens can't find work so these peoplea are aked to return home or find work in the area of their specialization/in which they have obtained the canadian degree.
Policy change doesn't happen overnight, even if it does its not your right to protest it. You're a guest here trying to be PR. This does not look good on you.
If you don’t like it, go home
This is what happens when someone uses loopholes to abuse the systems
You are a student came in as a student that does not give the right to work and stay here, pack your stuff and go!! and no you have no rights
BYE!
Good, don't let the door hit you on the way out.
Yep! Their attitude stinks and they feel entitled and boss people around.
Tim hortons has fired many Canadians
Why do you have to go to Canada to live in a small space and work tirelessly to meet the ends when you are educated and qualified? Stay back in Bharath, Come back to India..you will live in Peace and happiness
It's a myth that you'll be happy there ..
Vande Mataram!
Sadly rent has doubled in the past two years in many cities. You need to leave and it does not make me happy to say that 😞
They should come back we are already vishwa guru with 5 trillion dollars economy
In Canada tim Hortons is a life time job. Many Canadians over age 60 are working for Tim Hortons because it is the only job.
I am indian living in canada. I want to say this : It's not anyone right to protest for PR . Work hard and apply for it just like we done earlier..canadians are best ppl i ever seen thats y still they living in canada😊
If it was only just school then back to your country, that would be great, but that's not what happens . I personally think that's the plan from applying to a Canadian school to getting here on a campus . You should stop applying and go home and let everyone know Canada is not going to accept you once you are out of school. It's not racism as i used no countries name but Canada . It's fed up with other countries taking advantage of Canadian kindness.
Lot of students workers return from US and no one complains about so why students complaining about Canada??
Indians are paying students fee to buy the Canadians Citizenship 😂
Did these students take an undertaking that they'll return to their home country once they completed their studies? PR is not a right, it's a privilege!!
They should have mention that earlier , First they took high fres from Oversee students and then deny to give work permit, it is simply loot.They didn't go just for your education, It is because of your Currency strength. They want to give back the money to their Parents by working there.
@@Subhash-oy9mfIndians who studied useful degrees are welcome in Canada.
@@Subhash-oy9mf They are not citizens that why they pay higher fees. It's the same situation in all others countries by the way.They were ready to pay these tuition fees thinking that will give them PR.Solution very simple: stay and study in your country!!!
Construction or Health Care....what's the issue? Oh wait, you don't want those jobs, easy and high paying. I get it. I see most of them as bullies and I'm not liking it
So much misinformation here. None of the 5 people in the panel understood the issue correctly. 0 basic research and understanding of what a work permit is.
How would you explain the issue?
No, they're not being denied work permits. There are work permits available but all the Indian people want to do is work in retail in coffee shops. None of them want to take the jobs that are offering work opportunities which would allow them to stay
I went to highschool with a girl from China. Only one Chinese student. I asked her how she got to come to Canada. She had to write a test and make a high mark and be sponsored by someone in Canada.
Editor : NewsX - If they are talking about rights go back to India and file a case against the Imiigration Consultants who sold you the dreams.
I am a resident of PEI, and I support the protestors. I hope that they are allowed to stay here. They want to be here, and they've started building lives here. It's unfair to suddenly change the rules, and it would be very unfair to force them to leave.
They changed the rules on getting PR. They're allowing them to stay until their permit expires.... they didn't say "well, you can work here for 2 years" and then kick them out 6 months later.
Some of the people protesting were interviewed and said they have less than 50 points toward immigration and are demanding to be allowed to stay as long as necessary to get the points. What's the point of even having an immigration point system unless it matters.
I'm old enough to remember when my province just started to bring in Indian immigrants and I hadn't met one who wasn't friendly and kind. They loved to share food and culture with neighbours; they integrated into the general society while keeping their personal customs. They studied hard, they worked hard, and they earned the types of education that made them a net positive to society. I've had to check the local court docket daily for 2 decades (stalker reasons) and I can't remember ever seeing a name usually associated with India.
The recent wave of students are not like that. They're trying to jump the queue over other immigrants (including those from India) who are more than qualified to stay here and are working their way through the process the right way. The biggest group of people who want them to go home are other people from South Asia, because of the crime and housing issues. We're not allowed to discriminate in Canada when it comes to renting, but over 80% of apartment rentals in the GTA say "Punjabi (Or Gujarati) only". Now there are more India-associated names on the court docket than anyone else.
Stats Can just released a report showing that of the people inadequately housed (homeless, living in overcrowded conditions), over 60% of them are Indian students crowded into homes, with up to 25 people living together.
Then you take 10 of them into your home and live for few years with them. Then you go with them to India and stay there for few years. Then give us your opinion again.
Which rights he is talking about. Did they not declare that they will return after they study is finished. There is no right for an International Students.
Immigration agents & students from Canada shoudl provide right informaiton. Indian student sin canada posting all hifi picures, car, vacation, luxurious road trip, etc giving impression that Canada is lan of opportunity , u can make future there. This needs to be stopped. reality is totally different
Why it’s only Indian that’s the real question
canadian gov should deport all student doing drama on the street sending bad impression of our country to others
Change in international students policy but only Indians are protesting lol.
Manitoba is over 211,000 square miles pei is just over 2000 square miles
Time to go home with subsidize education and build your own country.
Venkat sir is right....guys are coming to earn diploma and to get pr...there intention is to get out of india.. not to study..
Lol how is this "Anti-India"? These people came on temporary statuses and thus always knew they had to go back. Stop spreading lies.
Sent home
Is there somewhere they were given any papers that gave them right to Job. Once they study they should get back home. So did you apply from Immigration or to Study. Please get out. International Students are not Welcome in Canada. specifically Indian Students.
PEI number one export is it own people who must leave to find work elsewhere
Lots of jobs in India.. india is largest economy...plus go back lots of scope in india
You guys have no right. Go back. You have no right even to protest!
They are about to learn what born canadians learn everyday, that they do not really have a say in the rules in this country. So if they dont get grandfathered in and get sent back to India, the'll just have to cope, par for the course, as Canadians didnt have a say in whether or not they could come here and get residency.
A good idea not to study in Canada! Plz study in India and support your local
And why even this host and these guys who do not live in Canada talking about Canada and its rules? Hilarious
What a smart bunch...
Getting into over $40,000 worth of debt that will take a lifetime to pay off back in their home country.
And now they want PR to work in a prosperous country to get out of this self-inflicted debt trap.
Pm Modi need to expose them about modern slavery
So you would start new life protesting the country politics ? Would you like to use weapons as well ? I wouldn't be surprised.
Immigration is federal
Go home
Study 🤣 ya right Canada is a very bad country plz stay home or go study somewhere else
Time for India students to study in India ... the backdoor student immigration scam is over.
Gov can change the rule anytime,,it’s not your country just go back to
I just wan to clarify anchor ,,u r spending money for study,, there is no guarantee for return what you spend..
Why this anchor and other people try to find issue in their own country, why don’t don’t they research that why people of India want to leave
Time to go home
Go home
I was an international students too. These students are from poor family. 25 induan students living in one room. If you dont have money and skill stay away from Canada.
Sorry, but Canada is full.
I don’t know what rights there protesting for because they have non here
PEI is just over 2000 square miles. Canada is over 3 million sq miles. They are NOT demanding to stay in Canada. They are demanding to stay in PEI.
They should study and then go back to India and then apply for Immigration as a skilled Entry. not jumping the line Student > Work Permit > becoming PR. Get out the International Students have not been cheated but the Students are trying to Cheat the Immigration System.
They want a few more years to have babies 👶 👶 👶 👶 👶 and they will live 5-8 generations in a single home 🤯
The students have no right to stay here, they were given a certain amount of time as students. Now it's time to go home. That's how it works. They don't have the right to demand things of the Canadian government. They are not citizens
Exactly
CHINADA is done
They are not demanding to stay in Canada. They are demanding to stay in PEI
/ blank stare
But PEI is in Canada😂😂😂😂😂
PEI is in India?
PEI is in Canada 😂
They went for study, should come back home after study instead of begging
There are lots of students from china, Vietnam they are not protesting why just Indians. Because they don’t like in India,they want to live life on luxury