Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
Xinjiang, China: The Reality
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 сер 2024
- The West makes all kinds of horrendous claims about human rights in China -- but what evidence is there really? A new report out from Italian researchers gets at what is real and what is warmongering propaganda. KJ Noh, peace activist, scholar on the geopolitics of Asia & organizer with Pivot to Peace, breaks it down.
Link to the report here: www.cese-m.eu/cesem/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/EN-Xinjiang-2.pdf
» Become a patron: / breakthroughnews
--------------------------------
» Like us on Facebook: / btnewsroom
» Tweet us on Twitter: / btnewsroom
» Follow us on Instagram: / btnewsroom
At Breakthrough News we believe in the power of independent media. Five mega-corporations dominate the media landscape - controlling 90% of what we read, watch and listen to. They control the news cycle, to which social media and even most “alternative” media is forced to respond. We are breaking through that cycle.
We tell the untold stories of resistance from poor and working-class communities - because out of these stories we will construct a different narrative of the world, as it is and in real time.
People’s movements in every corner of the globe are changing history and shifting consciousness. But these movements barely receive any coverage from the corporate media. They need visibility. They need amplification. They need a media arm to break through.
We can be that media arm, but only with your help. Become a Patron and join us on the front lines in the battle of ideas.
Subscribe and follow us! / breakthroughnews @BTNewsroom
#China #Uyghurs #Xinjiang #BreakThroughNews #BTnews #socialistnews #socialist #raniakhalek #eugenepuryear
I have been in Canada for 50 years. I went a 18 days tour in Xinjiang 3 years ago. Here is my experience during the tour: I talked to couple of Taxi drivers. They said their business is getting better last 3 years because there is night market now. 3 years ago, no one walk on the street in the night because some bad guys fighting on the street with knife all the time.
Did you ask the taxi drivers where they were from?
@@CommunistBot I never made it to the far northwest…
"Don't be mad at the mirror if you are ugly." This is the most accurate expression to describe what the USA is like right now.
It’s America’s politicians and new media specifically. And these politicians and media outlets use and influence the American people to hate. In this case, to hate China.
thank you Putin
The MAIN reason why the USA western media falsely accuses CHINA of mistreating Uyghur Muslims is because they want to prevent the 1.6 Billion Chinese worldwide and 2.0 Billion Muslims from working together. Both these groups have been discriminated by USA and the WEST for decades and are more likely to work together. Chinese & Muslim nations working together will lead to US losing its dominance of the world. Plus this will gain Asia, Russia, Eastern Europe and African support too including the rest of the world such as Latin America. .
Putin's quote😊
Shining light on the hill is the big lie.
Facists who murder socialists describes US foreign policy better. The US is for 0.001% Wall st.. not 99.999% main st
Since I have began studying in Europe from China, I have read and watched too many fake news here about China. That is also why I love more China since I came Europe.
same here! watching BBC as a drama show now lol
you are a liar....lol
We all have the same experiences.
Malaysian in x i n j i a n g
Atiqah
ua-cam.com/video/CqiW1GrmMj0/v-deo.html
Same here too. I used to trust BBC and Other media but not anymore
The Western picture of China is false in general. Lived there for two years and I experienced it completely different.
Really? Who are the critics of the Chinese government within China? I’d just like to check their claims against these?
@@begshallots Probably mostly Chinese people who would rather live in the West and "want it all" and they want power. At least those are the people in Hong Kong. Can't really speak for whole Mainland China. The reasons are more diverse. Some just want out of poverty, which is a valid wish. Some might be mad at the government just because the want to and it's easier to push away the responsibility for your failure in life. If you want to have a good life in China that's perfectly possible. But who am I to paint a picture here? I never experienced the low end in China or anywhere else.
@@ImpeRiaLismus so, you’re saying there are NO critics of China, in China. There are no honest critics of policy. There are no legitimate critics of the government, in China. But EVERY country has critics. China is perfect? No Chinese have sincere problems? Explain this to me.
I lived in China for some months in late 2019 and early 2020. I, too, saw that China is very different to how capitalist media and govts in first world countries portray it. It’s much less politically oppressive and much more economically prosperous than we are told.
Also, the socialist govt restrictions make sense given the context of how many people died when China had uprisings in the past (e.g. the Taiping Rebellion and the Cultural Revolution), and how many people suffered and died when the USSR fell, and given the current US destabilisation campaign.
@@SimonAshworthWood did you meet any critics of the government there? Do you believe there SHOULD be criticism?
Xinjiang is the province where two railways to Europe departs from. One goes across Russia and the other goes through Iran. Both to Europe. China has in this year become the #1 trading partner of Europe.
No way US is happy about that...
@@1sanitat1 Let them cry me a river.
It also cuts through Afghanistan which taliban and the Afghanistan governments supports.
Then there's a third highway called Karakorum Highway which connects Xinjiang, China directly to Arabian sea through Pakistan. Now Pakistan and China are planning to build a new railway from Pakistani seaports in Arabian sea to Xinjiang and it will take some time.
Note : last week 8 Chinese engineers were killed in Pakistan by a US and Indian backed proxy group working on a mega dam near to both Xinjiang and Afghanistan
@@arminius6506 good info. Do you have link to your foot note.?
No such news coming out from NEWSX or WION and that is a surprise.
My support of China increase day by day with all the lies published by western media. These so called free press has no shame. I appreciate all of your effort to bring out the truth. Thank you.
Objective is to slow down China's growth from overtaking US's economy (forecast in 2028) and global dominance position. Xinjiang is the gateway into China via BRI (trade route via rail) as well as having oil reserve and a leading producer of solar panel and cotton.
After I saw a friend post about your analysis on Ethiopia, considering I was born in Ethiopia and grew up in the US, and have spent countless hours everyday following the news from a lot of local sources and the international news organizations, I was very impressed with how deep and accurate your analysis was. It made me believe if you can have such a deep understanding of what is happening in Ethiopia, I can trust you with any news coverage worldwide. I have been googling and Reddit searching for trusted and unbiased news source without result. I am glad to have run in to your site. I will be an avid listener. Way Better than NPR! Please keep up the good work in all fronts!
As an American who knows very little about the African continent generally, I very much was also grateful for this coverage, and feel a deep desire to learn more. I was recently looking at books by Maximilian Forte for more on Libya and he seems to be one of the better sources I've found so far, any recommendations would be much appreciated.
@@grahamaskey5721 nacheki is kinda biased, cherry picking out bad news about Europe, Russia, China, but leaving out most atrocities done by the US. Like Libya, Somalia, morroko, over 20 military bases in Afrika, how many were build in conflict and war?
@@talkfacts100 sure, it's not perfect but it helps give a sense of the variety of opinions in Africa. I only suggested these to help get a general picture of African news. I haven't found an African equivalent of Greyzone or Breakthrough. Have you got any recommendations?
@@grahamaskey5721 still looking, but I don't like a channel, I assume, deliberately skipping US atrocities on the African continent and condemn other countries. Doesn't show a balanced picture of the situation. I found they especially report on negative China news and I didn't notice any good news on that channel while other channels and media show those are the majority. Supposely positive cooperation and friendship > bad news in reality, like roads, ports, trains, malls, new job opportunities...
@@talkfacts100 I agree but because he said he didn't know much about Africa I thought it was worth giving some general sources which are at least African. I end up getting bits and pieces from all over the place so it is hard to recommend one particular site. Obviously he and others can read your criticisms and take that on board. Some kind of African equivalent of Breakthrough would be great, maybe there are things just not in English
There are slaves in Xinjiang. They are all named John Deere and each one was born in Illinois.
lol yeah, mechanical slaves.
Not sure but I think they're on the BDS list, will have to check. But fuck that brand, just in case.
Time for rise of the machines. Terminator unite!
But those are expensive slaves...😝
🤣Ha ha how true👍
The MAIN reason why the USA western media falsely accuses CHINA of mistreating Uyghur Muslims is because they want to prevent the 1.6 Billion Chinese worldwide and 2.0 Billion Muslims from working together. Both these groups have been discriminated by USA and the WEST for decades and are more likely to work together. Chinese & Muslim nations working together will lead to US losing its dominance of the world. Plus this will gain Asia, Russia, Eastern Europe and African support too including the rest of the world such as Latin America. .
This guest KJ Noh is highly impressive, makes great points and is highly researched and informed on the topic. This is the kind of expert MSM needs to have on their shows, but the fact that they get people like Gordon Chang and Adrian zens, ASPI etc just shows their intentions.
ua-cam.com/video/5xj25xKkjKI/v-deo.html 🤔
Hah. This kind of expert is what the MSM do not want you to see. Because it goes against their rhetoric.
All these groups and people are actual funded by the NED and US military weapons manufacturers
Adrian Zens, never lived in Xinjiang yet so called Xinjiang expert, paid by BBC. I believe Gordon Chang being paid by media too. They are just all paid clowns not experts or intellectuals.
Noble? This guy lied his ass off throughout the entire interview. These American anarchist who support this Chinese propaganda are traitors to their country.
What the US is doing is absolutely horrific and I am terrified that the strongest leaders could be so evil.
China is a peace loving country, I fully support and love the Chinese people ♥️🇨🇳
Well said
I am terrified also, God help us and pray to God justice will prevail.
whose god?
@@kwlwdp but there are so many god's and they can't all be right, however they can all be wrong so we must hope that good leadership will help us
Karma will descend upon the USA like a thunder bolt !!, ,how many Muslims have the evil , forked tongue US murdered in Iraq ?
This is how the US broke up my beloved Yugoslavia. Nobody should trust the US and its buddies.
No, instead your Serbian, Chetnik supremacists caused the break up of it. 100,000 strong Serb dominated federal army brutalized Bosnia and wanted to purge Muslims and Croats from the region. It was one of the most religious fanatical group, that also committed the Srebrenica genocide, where boys as youg as 12 were gunned down, and it's all in footage.
Once drunken with liquor and religious fanaticism, you can burn down whatever is your grasp.
@Dan2314 Wonderluck- Under him Serbs were good citizens then. Under the Ottomans too, they were so. They were the 1st platoon under Mehmet ll that attacked the walls of Constantinople. One of the most powerful Grand Viziers was of Serbian origin. They were It seems that under others they are much more productive than under leaderships like Milosevic or Karadic.
I understand you may not like their participation in the Ottoman wars, but many of them want to forget all that past and pretend that they were oppressed under the Ottoman rule. But they were part of that government, not against until the end days of the empire.
@@autumnicleaf there is a difference between normal Serbs and Četniks. Get it right. It was the US who caused alot of problems once Tito died. I am from Srebrenica and I know about the Genocide. Either way, if the US didn't get involved and tried to seperate us, Yugoslavia would have flourished.
Divide and conquer good old colonial strategies
West always wanted to have a revenge on Yugoslavia because Ex president Tito supported Nasser when he took over Suez Canal.
I am deeply impressed by your courage to speak out the truth. Only truth can bring peace and cooperation to the world. Salute to KJ Noh for his deep insight on this topic.
Mike Pompeo is a fabulous fabricator.
Buckets of sonic shit flood the airwaves every time he speaks.
@Richard Fan Pompeo would be the spokesperson for Slim Fast by now if he is good at lying.
ah, this shit people
Look up the channel
The new atlas
Brian Berletic
Sorry some link frim his channel auto erase
The MAIN reason why the USA western media falsely accuses CHINA of mistreating Uyghur Muslims is because they want to prevent the 1.6 Billion Chinese worldwide and 2.0 Billion Muslims from working together. Both these groups have been discriminated by USA and the WEST for decades and are more likely to work together. Chinese & Muslim nations working together will lead to US losing its dominance of the world. Plus this will gain Asia, Russia, Eastern Europe and African support too including the rest of the world such as Latin America. .
I live in China and know the truth. Thank you so much for this report! Sharing it!
America is collapsing from within and is trying to sell "freedom" and lies to other countries, in order for American big businesses to exploit these nations they are trying to "liberate".
Brilliant discussion. Am very impressed with KJ Noh. Facts and truth - thank you to the BreakThrough News team!
I stumble on your video and I am surprised that this American Channel is discussing about Xinjiang and giving us a frank, open, unbiased and humble opinions which runs contrary to the Media such as CNN, CNBC, Fox, Skynews, etc. I am a Malaysian and I have visited China many times and I opined that China is a country that puts the people first above all else, ie, serve their citizens. China is a socialist country and probably the safest country to live in. One very important thing above China: there is no discrimination against the minorities; buy there is discrimination of the Han Chinese majority because China government provides privileges to the minorities such as university entrance for minorities, financial assistance to the minorities, etc. Thank you for your video and I plead for more of such honest and truthful videos.
This KJ Noh person is one of most eloquent, knowledgeable, and persuasive person I have had the opportunity to listen to. His use of the English language is impressive...the clarity and appropriate use of terms.
KJ Kno is an eloquent and meticulously well informed commentator on Xinjiang.
Unfortunately as he stated kinetic warfare is being employed by primarily the G7 countries and their poodle allies.
The truth is avoided at all costs when employing these tactics, it is called propaganda.
Thankyou BTN.
I agree with another BT commentator that all three of you should be supported by CGTN, allow you to "inject" your reports into CGTN's regular programming. China still is a poor second to the sophisticated, powerful, well funded US propaganda machine. She has to work many times harder and waste no time.
different mind set for the Chinese, we want to be a reliable trading partner not a warmongering empire with mass propaganda media outlets. but you are right Chine needs to defend itself better at info warfare.
Just go there and see it with your own eyes. If you think China is lying.
“You can fool some of the people all of the time, and all of the people some of the time, but you can not fool all of the people all of the time.” ― Abraham Lincoln
I have already seen this on the full show. But it is important to have as many view it as possible.
For more information on Xinjiang, follow the following foreign UA-camrs who gave been to Xinjiang.
Daniel Dumbrill (Canada)
Noel Lee (Singapore)
Barett (Lee Barett from UK)
Fermube (Fernando from Colombia)
Numuves (Canada)
There are a few others that I can't remember. Specially look out for Daniel Dumbrill who had a forum with few others.
"ua-cam.com/video/qUKMXeghO2Q/v-deo.html"
"www.quora.com/Is-there-any-hard-evidence-that-China-has-experienced-thousands-of-terrorist-attacks-in-just-the-last-3-or-so-decades-And-if-so-why-doesnt-the-Chinese-govt-just-come-out-with-said-evidence-and-or-timelines-rather/answer/Shouen-Li?ch=10&share=00882581&srid=92pv6"
"ua-cam.com/video/BPxZfqcKPF0/v-deo.html"
"ua-cam.com/video/vtZvxbp1iFc/v-deo.html"
"ua-cam.com/video/2tCuZu_U9rk/v-deo.html"
"ua-cam.com/video/aODKD5jaU94/v-deo.html"
I don’t understand if these three reporters are helping people understand the truth that China treat all minorities better than the big group of Han people!
In China there are fifty-six groups of nationalities, all 55 called minorities and they have their own tradition clothes and cultures got protected except Han group lost tradition clothes and only wearing same clothes as our Americans. If so thank you tell the truth!
If you can visit Xinjiang, you will be touched by the food and friendly people! They can dance showing their happiness🌸🌸😻😍🥰
@@kennyng2289 Have you heard of Nathan Rich ("hotpot king") He has some epic vids on the timeline of covid that are thorough & priceless. Also Gweilo (spelling?) He is Canadian.
@@auntijen3781
I've subscribed to Nathan Rich youtube channel and have followed him for quite some time. Very few videos from him nowadays. His latest video was on the extradiction of Ms Meng Wanzhou to the US few days ago.
@@kennyng2289 I know Rich mentioned moving over to a more patreon type format, creating content for paid subscribers. :(
The US really plays dirty here.
I've been to Beijing University for an exchange programme and my fellow classmate who is a minority in China mentioned her privileges in university admission.
CGTN needs to hire KJ, they need hard hitting people like him on there. They need to hire all 3 in fact
Any people even cited by CGTN will be called shill, tankie, paid by CCP (CPC),
Have attack piece writing on them, straight up doxxing.
More channel reporting the better
No. BT should carry on without being seen as being aligned with anyone.
@Shnarfy McShmoombles good point
US is Using
ua-cam.com/video/522s__Q5aGI/v-deo.html
cgtn is pretty shi* with what they do tbh. if they were there to help advertising CCP or even just to tell the truth for their country they surely have failed. So why would a successful channel join a fail channel?
really hope momentum builds for this show, just watched the deep dive on ethiopia, great analysis and this as well!
There are 110 million Ethiopians behind the government's fight against a mafia group that milked the country for 27years. The entire western political machinery are on a crusade to resuscitate that same group. One huge prop in this effort is MSM who ran almost daily accusations againist the government.
The segment by BT on this issue was probably the only nuanced examination of the issue with much of the missing context.
The Uighurs are absolutely not being left behind and have no complaints. China has been spending money hand over fist building them hospitals and schools and a nice airport, roads, schools, houses, and a brand new high speed rail line. There is a huge trade centre going in for Russians and Kazakhs to come and buy Chinese vehicles, machines, and other goods. Everyone he saw saw was happy, well dressed, well fed and looking forward to the future. After all Pakistan have good relationships with China. Those you saw in those camps were of wahabis. Thank goodness no mirzais from Ahmadiyya, Nation of Islam, Mahdavia, Chrislam, Baha'i and Wahabis are in this country.
The US created the Uighur problem in Xīnjiāng by sponsoring terrorists there-the same tactics it used in Cuba, Venezuela, Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria and Libya. Faced with the grave challenge of terrorism and extremism, China has undertaken a series of counter-terrorism and deradicalisation measures in Xīnjiāng, including setting up vocational education and training centres and boarding schools.Uighurs, just like the other 9 Muslim ethnic groups in China, are entirely free to conduct their religion, with active state protection of their culture, and strong Affirmative Action measures which drastically benefits minorities. The vast majority of Uighurs are perfectly happy to be part of China, especially with recent drastic rises in standard of living, employment, and wages. It is only a tiny percentage of extremists in Xīnjiāng with ties to Daesh, funded by the CIA like the Mujahideen, and indoctrinated by Wahhabi extremism, who are agitating for independence and the establishment of “East Turkistan”.
ua-cam.com/video/DvFdonL0qZg/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/x99g4kua5s0/v-deo.html
unitedworldint.com/18208-Uighur-genocide-is-an-imperialist-lie/
ifmagazine.net/the-vocational-education-and-training-centers-in-Xīnjiāng-are-by-no-means-so-called-concentration-camps/
ua-cam.com/video/X2qSFIWrGRQ/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/DF02xWgkAJ0/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/4N385vKhXYQ/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/LLWD0EfPYaY/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/AaitXSdjFP8/v-deo.html
challenge-magazine.org/2021/04/05/foreign-diplomats-deny-lies-said-about-Xīnjiāng-by-the-west-after-trip/
www.helsinkitimes.fi/china-news/19019-witnessing-the-real-Xīnjiāng-foreign-diplomats-debunk-lies.html
www.curacaochronicle.com/post/main/beautiful-Xīnjiāng-should-not-be-smeared-by-lies/
uwidata.com/16769-us-lies-about-chinas-Xīnjiāng-debunked/
www.manilatimes.net/2021/04/04/opinion/columnists/another-big-lie-by-the-west-Xīnjiāng-genocide/859909
apnews.com/article/china-government-and-politics-religion-3d8fa6aee61268d105610ebc92ed1b55
medium.com/@leohezhao/Xīnjiāng-facts-vs-fiction-bdc2aa403c91
www.thestar.com.my/opinion/letters/2019/12/12/truths-about-Xīnjiāng-the-western-media-wont-tell
Gulf of Tonkin incident, WMDs in Iraq, Operation Northwoods, the lies of america never end. Taliban has seen that China and Russia are at peace with their Muslim citizens. There is much Afghanistan can gain after noting China's Poverty Alleviation efforts in Xīnjiāng. Mud in the eye for the US and Allies smearing China on Xīnjiāng.
USA is the godfather of ISIS . Japan Toyota is the pickup sponsor for ISIS .
You guys are courageous. Solidarity and best wishes.
I don’t understand if these three reporters are helping people understand the truth that China treat all minorities better than the big group of Han people!
In China there are fifty-six ethnic groups, all 55 called minorities and they have their own tradition clothes and cultures got protected except Han group lost tradition clothes and only wearing same clothes as our Americans. If so thank you tell the truth!
If you can visit Xinjiang, you will be touched by the food and friendly people! They can dance showing their happiness🌸🌸😻😍🥰
@@planwoods most of those 55 minorities are now Han with little connection to there native peoplr
@Glorious Hakka that's not nice
American politicians and westerner media are liers I found the truth from Ethiopian. The turn is Ethiopia to be demonized.
The westerners are believing that the world belongs to them. it was but not any more. The world belongs to all of us
Wasn't the USA bombing this exact same Uyghur group just last year? Look up US bombings in NE Afghanistan!
They have been for many years
www.nbcnews.com/news/world/u-s-targets-chinese-uighur-militants-well-taliban-fighters-afghanistan-n845876
@@obione69 Guess it's not about human rights for uncle sam! At least China isn't bombing them.
Ironically US has killed more Uighurs than China has.
@@randomname931
They actually don't even suggest that China killed any Uighurs. They instead try to invoke the memory of the holocaust in describing them as concentration camps. Which is more insulting, because people that saw these places described them as tertiary education centers teaching trade skills. And they went home on the weekends.
The MAIN reason why the USA western media falsely accuses CHINA of mistreating Uyghur Muslims is because they want to prevent the 1.6 Billion Chinese worldwide and 2.0 Billion Muslims from working together. Both these groups have been discriminated by USA and the WEST for decades and are more likely to work together. Chinese & Muslim nations working together will lead to US losing its dominance of the world. Plus this will gain Asia, Russia, Eastern Europe and African support too including the rest of the world such as Latin America. .
This gentleman is wonderful, thank you for removing the fog of BS.
The world needs people with integrity like you guys to step forward to defend the truth so that those greedy and selfish people (corrupt politicians and insatiable capitalists) cannot get away with their crimes and sins.
I don’t understand if these three reporters are helping people understand the truth that China treat all minorities better than the big group of Han people!
In China there are fifty-six groups of nationalities, all 55 called minorities and they have their own tradition clothes and cultures got protected except Han group lost tradition clothes and only wearing same clothes as our Americans. If so thank you tell the truth!
If you can visit Xinjiang, you will be touched by the food and friendly people! They can dance showing their happiness🌸🌸😻😍🥰
One mistake to point out: 56 ethnicities including Han to be precise instead of 56 groups of nationalities. There is only one nationality in mainland: Chinese.
@@Deandzzzzzz thank you, apologize my poor English
The MAIN reason why the USA western media falsely accuses CHINA of mistreating Uyghur Muslims is because they want to prevent the 1.6 Billion Chinese worldwide and 2.0 Billion Muslims from working together. Both these groups have been discriminated by USA and the WEST for decades and are more likely to work together. Chinese & Muslim nations working together will lead to US losing its dominance of the world. Plus this will gain Asia, Russia, Eastern Europe and African support too including the rest of the world such as Latin America. .
Xinjiang has been in administration by Han Dynasty more than 2000 years before, even far before Uyghurs formed for the first time as a nation in 13th century AD in Tang Dynasty.
Even after 2000 years with Han Chinese, the Uyghurs still have their own culture, traditional clothing, and language. The same goes for more than fifty other ethnic groups. This shows that the Han Chinese are not culturally invasive, unlike how some western media try to make it sound.
@@cliz305 they're really good dancers too aye
That is completely misleading. It is a region that has been conquered and ruled by China for a few periods in history when China has expanded westwards at its greatest territorial extents. That has been far from the norm throughout history.
This kind of statement reindforces the extremely imperialistic attituide that the current Chinese government promotes where everything that has once been under Chinese rule at any time must be part of China (you frequently see this in attitudes towards Tibet -and of course every island and stretch of water sout and east of China).
I'm British so should we therefore assume that anything and everything that Britain has ruled at any time in history must be British and accept British rule now? I'm sure that'll go down well...
Challenging the narrative is one thing but questioning the propaganda on one side only to swallow it wholesale on the other is something else entirely.
@@sirperybLakeney You may not trust my words, but you should believe the large amount of historical documents and evidence that have been discovered over years because unlike what you Westerners have always done, they never lie. If you have studied Chinese history, you should have heard of the Western Regions Duhufu “西域都护府” which was the administrative institution established in the western region(now Xinjiang) by Han Dynasty more than 2000 years ago.
@@sirperybLakeney If you are interested in Chinese culture, you should have heard of LI Bai (李白) , a very famous ancient Han poet, who was born in Sui Ye city (碎叶城) where was located in the western region under the administration of Tang Dynasty 1300 years ago, and then 500 years later, Uyghurs formed for the first time as a nation.
Professor K. S. Tay - Singapore: The so called Xinjiang genocide. Yes there was a violent crackdown on terrorism in the early 20s perpetrated by the extremist East Turkistan Independence Movement the ETIM since de-classified a terrorist movement by the USA. Yes there were detention centres and summary arrests. People died both innocent and guilty. It was bad but things came under control. Unlike other countries, China went further. Moved many Han Chinese in. Started economic development. Trained the Uygurs Chinese language, taught skills. Sent in the army, made them farm to kick start agriculture. Grow cotton. Cant fight terror with only terror. Educate, create jobs. Block foreign manipulation. Develop soft power. Allow religion but watchout for radicalisation. China is winning. USA is losing..
Professor Tay @ Singapore
The MAIN reason why the USA western media falsely accuses CHINA of mistreating Uyghur Muslims is because they want to prevent the 1.6 Billion Chinese worldwide and 2.0 Billion Muslims from working together. Both these groups have been discriminated by USA and the WEST for decades and are more likely to work together. Chinese & Muslim nations working together will lead to US losing its dominance of the world. Plus this will gain Asia, Russia, Eastern Europe and African support too including the rest of the world such as Latin America. .
The explanations are so clear. This is illuminating.
In China, these 55 ethnic minorities groups can get better benefits: such as less score getting in good colleges; can have as many as kids when the main group got birth controlled in 1980 to 2010 about. Everyone of Han wish is a minority😍😻🥰
I am Tujiazu. I did get an extra 10 score in the entrance exam. My colleague roommates, two are Uyghurs and one from Mongolia. My Uyghur roommates told me they got extra 100 scores in the exam(which I envy so much). However, it is a good policy. Because my hometown is in the middle part of China and less developed than the east coast province. Education standard is lower. Xinjiang is less developed and due to their religion, it is correct to give them more extra scores to encourage more young people to have high standard education. My Mongolian roommate, however, is damn tall and strong...yet rich.....The first day we met, he told me his family sold a cow to pay for his Tuition，I feel sad for him at that moment because I thought he was in a poor family...yet he told me his family has more than 1000 cows. Damn it! There are good sides and bad sides, but the policy is abusolutely reasonable and try to give everybody equal access to education asap.
And I'm Han. And I received no extra core in the Entrance exam. It's good to be minority in China
This is both racist AND untruthful. Well done, sir.
The MAIN reason why the USA western media falsely accuses CHINA of mistreating Uyghur Muslims is because they want to prevent the 1.6 Billion Chinese worldwide and 2.0 Billion Muslims from working together. Both these groups have been discriminated by USA and the WEST for decades and are more likely to work together. Chinese & Muslim nations working together will lead to US losing its dominance of the world. Plus this will gain Asia, Russia, Eastern Europe and African support too including the rest of the world such as Latin America. .
Watching this after your video on current situation in Ethiopia, which was phenomenally accurate after heap of dis/misinformation by almost all MSM. What can I say? There really are people who care to do their homework before opening their mouth.
Much respect 🙏🙏🙏🇪🇹
An excellent show. KJ Noh incredibly impressive in his knowledge and clarity of his commentary.
lol - all party propaganda talking points read basically word for word - exactly the same as any other CH shill (find 4 and you will see they all say the same ish), the people on this comment section are so touched by their hatred of the US. Im not from there, agree there is plenty to dislike.but seriously this BS is all still centered on the US being the only actor with any agency - after learning the language, spending 10 years in Beijing and dating a Uighur for a couple of years - i can tell you - China has agency.
Its ridiculous how the mainstream media twist every report. We really need to question all these mainstream media journalism
It is not ridiculous. John Kerry, former Secretary of State said "Americans have the right to be stupid." You-tube will delete this message b4 you can even read it. Or they let it stand to pretend they don't censor and control comments they don't like.😁
I don't read any western MSM anymore, the bias is unbelievable
China is committing Uighur Genocide in Xinjiang. There is no doubt about it.
When the Commissioner of United Nations High Office for Human Rights, Bachelet, visited Xinjiang to investigate the allegations of genocide, she was not allowed to go to any unrestricted areas in Xinjiang. She was not allowed to interview any Uighurs she may encounter during the visit.
When Bachelet visited and investigated Xinjiang, she was only able to visit places permitted by the China Gov., and was able to only interview Uighurs permitted by the China Gov. When she interviewed the Uighurs , China officials must be present to monitor the interview.
China is trying to cover up the crime of genocide against Uighurs that is being carried out in Xinjiang.
Thank you for this break down of what is reality. The news in Australia is none stop propaganda, and unfortunately, so many are duped. Keep up your good work.
Absolutely agree, but I what can we expect when our media is owned by the US, or controlled from the US, and those that aren’t try to keep up by being like US media.
I’ve noticed a couple of ABC China experts, give a perspective that is critical, yet they look like they’re ashamed of what they’re saying, ashamed for having to lie
As an Australian I totally agree with your comment and look forward to a multi polar world. Most Australians are kept in the dark about what is happening in the world. We have no source of real information .
Australia should look at the treatment of her own Indigenous Australians, stops following the US by pointing the finger at others.
The MSM in Australia peddled so much propaganda to soften the public to prepare aggression with big brother is disgusting.
I also know most of us Australians are very disturbed by what sections of our government are doing with locking up asylum seekers in detention centers on Christmas Island, etc. Most of us not only do not identify with those actions, but seriously disagree with them. We've had the UN officially call out our government for this on multiple occasions.
The US / Australian propaganda that suggests that the Chinese government also somehow mind-controls all of its people, and that many Chinese immigrants are secretly "agents of the state" is absolutely appalling, and can only lead to escalations of violence locally and internationally.
Thank you BreakThrough News and other Western sources being brave enough to call bullshit on these alienating propaganda machines.
Please keep telling the truth we and the world desperately need it so all could live in peace , dignity and Justice ! Thank you!
It’s quite simple. What kind of ethnic genocide regime improves the lives of the ethnic group? What does any country do to counter any extremist group? Since when did you care about muslim lives? Why do you try to force your way of life on China under the name of your definition of democracy when Chinese people are living just fine or even better than you? Just leave China alone. If there is any serious problem, Chinese people will take care of it. And I am okay as long as we can prosper together by cooperating together. BTW I am not Chinese.
No hatred of minorities in China.............they are all brothers.
After over 5000 years history, China still have over 120millions of Ethnic Minorities including 12.7millions Xinjiang Uyghurs, 1.8millions Muslim Kazakhs, 13.0millions Muslim Hui & over one-half million other minority Muslims. The Tibetan population is over 6 million also.
In comparison to USA together with Canada and Australia short histories, how many "millions" of Native American in North America and Native Australian left??
Not even one million because Australia & USA and Canada have literally exterminated over 95% of Native Australian and North American Native Red Indians. THIS IS WHAT WE CALLED THIS REAL GENOCIDE.
Where are the MASS GRAVES in Xinjiang? Unlike the North America Red Indian children whose Mass Graves can be physically located in Roman Catholic Church ground and Residential School ground.
It would be great to see Daniel Dumbrill on the show.
For real, I'm totally in for a 2-3 hours long Xinjiang episode ft. Daniel Dumbrill, Carl Zha, Timmpa Karjalai, and Scott Hu!😆
if you haven't heard of him,
I really like Nathan Rich,
his 'covid timeline' vids got me hooked!
Nathan Rich's Covid coverage;
Original COVID TIMELINE
[1+ year ago]
ua-cam.com/video/kO5EXjFKE7U/v-deo.html
What will happen if COVID hits the US?
[1+ year ago]
ua-cam.com/video/rJiKxV4rTCQ/v-deo.html
The "New Face" of Covid19;
[1+ year ago]
ua-cam.com/video/FLFH6WsZu8M/v-deo.html
UPDATE;
Part 1) USA COVID19 TIMELINE
[9 momths ago]
ua-cam.com/video/NlGusf4_1tc/v-deo.html
Part 2) USA COVID19 TIMELINE
[9 momths ago]
ua-cam.com/video/sTTm7QQ_Yww/v-deo.html
Part 3) USA COVID19 TIMELINE
[9 momths ago]
ua-cam.com/video/OohWio2BET4/v-deo.html
5 million cases of COVID19 IN US
by DECEMBER of 2019?!?!
(According to US CDC's own data)
[7 months ago]
ua-cam.com/video/TgPHvrfWr-U/v-deo.html
More Chinese propaganda, great
The MAIN reason why the USA western media falsely accuses CHINA of mistreating Uyghur Muslims is because they want to prevent the 1.6 Billion Chinese worldwide and 2.0 Billion Muslims from working together. Both these groups have been discriminated by USA and the WEST for decades and are more likely to work together. Chinese & Muslim nations working together will lead to US losing its dominance of the world. Plus this will gain Asia, Russia, Eastern Europe and African support too including the rest of the world such as Latin America. .
Brilliant discussion. Thank you.♥️
Glad to see people catching up. Slowly but surely.
i lost it when kj mentioned elizabeth warren 🤣🤣🤣🤣
came out of no where lol
That's the punchline of the talkshow 😁
And, the DNA test revealed she is less than 1% Red Indian. Just like the lying MSM is less than 1% truthful about Xinjiang genocide. That means the US population relies on 99% lies n fake news to get 1% truth.😁😁
The MAIN reason why the USA western media falsely accuses CHINA of mistreating Uyghur Muslims is because they want to prevent the 1.6 Billion Chinese worldwide and 2.0 Billion Muslims from working together. Both these groups have been discriminated by USA and the WEST for decades and are more likely to work together. Chinese & Muslim nations working together will lead to US losing its dominance of the world. Plus this will gain Asia, Russia, Eastern Europe and African support too including the rest of the world such as Latin America. .
1% counts according to Liz
Wow, KJ is super knowledgeable and nailed every single point.
Always respect people out there promoting truths and facts instead of propagandas.
Chinese believes and practices harmony.................
Great in depth interview on Xinjiang
I am glad I got different views of journalism on Xinjiang. We, the outsiders, have to learn from both sides about what is happening there.
Thank you.
Would absolutely love it if I could get the audio of BreakThrough News as a podcast. I'm not a big UA-cam user and prefer to listen to audio while I work
I realize this video is 2 years ago. But as of my posting, Xinjiang is looking better and better. Long live China!
Thanks so much for debunking disinformation on Xinjiang 👌👍👏👏👏so impressively articulated, very interesting & riveting narratives 👍👌👏👏👏🙏
China has stood alone for thousands of years without any friends. Great empires had came and gone with just ruins to marks their once existence. No one identifies now a days as descendants of the empires. But except China. It is the emotional tie to the ancestral land, the culture and customs and close emotional ties to their ancestors that allow the people to drift back together despite dynastic changes. PRC would not fall for a few hundred years not with the recent memory of hundred year of humiliation.
Just found your channel. Fully enjoying the content.
when i lose faith in journalism, then I see this.. well done people
It is so important to have journalists always confirm our own biases and to never challenge our preconceived notions!
@@kotaibushi940
Journalists (especially western/indian/israeli/australian) should be thrown in prison
The MAIN reason why the USA western media falsely accuses CHINA of mistreating Uyghur Muslims is because they want to prevent the 1.6 Billion Chinese worldwide and 2.0 Billion Muslims from working together. Both these groups have been discriminated by USA and the WEST for decades and are more likely to work together. Chinese & Muslim nations working together will lead to US losing its dominance of the world. Plus this will gain Asia, Russia, Eastern Europe and African support too including the rest of the world such as Latin America. .
People before know who is the demon and who is not . This video puts more proofs to what they know . Courageous talk. Let the US proves it's not the real villain.
After your balanced, unbiased and truthful analysis of the news in Ethiopia where I am from, I trust this media more than any other mainstreams Media aka state media.
This is a fantastic conversation, the guest KJ Noh is of great insight, though I believe many would have difficulties in accepting. BRAVO!
This is an excellent analysis by Mr. KJ Koh, a peace activist.
peace activist says muslim terrorists vs China bad, but US deserves them ?
That was an excellent analysis by KJ Noh. What i think people often overlook in their discussion is part of the reason America is trying to use atrocity propaganda and to blame China for covid-19 is they are looking for a justification to cancel the trillions in debt owed to China. They can't do that right now without ruining their economy and the bond market, so they use alleged atrocities as the starting off point to create a rationalisation.
I really appreciate KJ's clear, precise, & factual presentation.
i laughed when i heard the slavery accusation lol slaves picking cottons in 21st century? have they ever heard of the term agri-machines? its not 18th century north america ffs
10:05 - And I'm not talking about Elizabeth Warren.
That just cracks me up.... ROTFLMAO 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
US government: The truth always requires fixing my interest, when the truth is not fixed to my interest, then that truth is not the truth, at least not my truth.
Thank you for this excellent informative video. I am very much impressed by KJ Noh for his analysis.
Wow, so glad I stumbled on this channel, very eloquent speaker.
Xinjiang is the national hub for oil, gas and coal. China is investing more than ever in the vast, resource-rich Xinjiang region with the aim of bolstering oil extraction and refining, coal production, power generation, and natural gas production and transport. Xinjiang has an estimated 21 billion tons of oil reserves and major new deposits are still being found. Xinjiang also has the country’s largest coal reserves. Beijing said that $300 billion dollars (685 projects) are invested in Xinjiang. $130 billion are for infrastructure such as roads, highways and railways (NYT. Dec 2014).
Again I can say this enough to the BN super team
Don't change your approach. I'm not yet able to offer financial support but when I can, I will. You treat Global South analysts,experts, activists and journalists like valuable people
You have an objective "eyes open" mature approach to your news and analysis.
Build your own niche this way and as tough as things go in this field,we should try to support you in other ways if views are suppressed.
Thank you again,for treating us,esp for me as an African,like equals. You're almost totally unique in the anti-imperialist Western media.
Also,again please we need the links to follow some of these exceptional guests you invite
I just discovered your channel a few fays ago and instantly subbed due to your highness quality research/discussion and quality informed guests.
You guys will probably blow up and double or triple your subs in he next few weeks or months, you will have hundred thousand subs in no time.. Keep up the good work.
Also think about getting Chinese translator and doing Chinese subs and uploading on Chinese social media, you will get a much bigger audience and also more funding from Patreon and the like.
Very good point on Chinese translation
French as well to engage the Central and West Africa region
Brilliant guest brilliant discussion. You've earned a new sub
Xinjinag is the starting point of the Chna BRI project and major goods are shiping out to the west startng from Xinjiang. By causing havoc in Xinjiang, US is trying to sow down BRI progress if not stopping it.
Obviously not a peep in mainstream western media about the newly released Italian research paper...
Thanks for the discussion. Please continue to bringing more light on the truth in China
really want some mainstream media to show this video on TV.
There’s no way. Not how MSM works. Only independent news outlets or studios can give us this.
@@caomilo1031 Maybe worth sending a few copies to some of our politicians though with a cover letter, even if it’s just to remind them some of us don’t buy into their bs
Ppl wanna talk about slave labor...look no further than Frito Lay... it's right in our own backyard ppl.
Really effective and important talk, I am so happy to see this. I did not even hear about the Italian or Swedish reports debunking the genocide, I wonder why...warmongers are steering the ship!!
Exactly! You don't hear about the reports that show no evidence in Western MSM
6:00 Pascal's wager
Throw as much against the wall as you can
And see what sticks
.... Leave people with the impression that something terrible is going on.
So
if you give them that, then the rational decision is that we believe it despite our doubts
because not believing it might leave terrible consequences
An abuse of people's empathy
China has never persecuted any minority since CPC took power. On the contrary, when the Hans was allowed only one child per married couple (for example, Xi Jinping himself has only one child), the minorities were never put under such a policy. As a result, the population in most minority communities have been increasing since CPC took power.
Wow this is actually very informative, good job guys
United Nation keep quite. They should investigate and clarify this situation rather allowing unfound statements been in circulation. Culprit to let the world gussing and in confusion.
What a great interview! So many facts were unpacked here. KJ Noh lays out the facts so succinctly. The Elizabeth Warren remark was hilarious! Both hosts were amazing too. Love BTN. 👍❤️
Thank you for tell the truth the world ! You guys have great social responsibility!
That jab at Elizabeth Warren was great
Very informative. I hope 6ou guys can put your sources in the description in the future, if possible.
10:17 that warren bits killed me😂😂😂😂
so good. thank you all very much for such a strong discussion, which shows us what the Western campaign against China is really about.
Thank you Mr. KJ Noh! Thank you BreakThrough News! May your tribe increase!
You guys make me feel good about future of America and future of our planet. Thank you!
Thanks to the BreakThrough News. Finally I found a English channel that speaks truth that I would watch in its entirety. KJ brings in a very objective observation of Xinjiang. Her point that we are in the war is so accurate and shocking. Great work.
Well said, KJ .Hat off .You have a real deep knowledge about Xinjiang and totally agree with you about it.
Thanks very much for sharing! I do hope all Americans and westerners can open their eyes and ears to righteous media (if there still any left…)
i feel sorry to say this. why is the USA keep accuse china on slavery of the xinjiang people.
where they have millions of african american descendent who are the living evidence of the USA slavery.
did the USA gov pay all the african american compensation and do a formal apology to them?
did the USA gov admit they are wrong on this?
She's so good, K J, the best guest on this topic!
Remember CIA operation mockingbird?
You're one of the fews who deeply understand CIA covert operations. Most just get manipulated n live under a rock.😁
KJ Noh is an excellent analyst. He sums up the relevant issues very succinctly and thoroughly.