If Shane was still alive by the end of the show, he'd be an absolute beast, even stronger than that. He could probably give a hard time to the likes of Beta and Carver
@@Aritingzlol Yeah he just kept getting more and more insane over time, by the time season 5 rolls around assuming he didn’t already get everyone killed he would probably be too insane for even the whisperers.
@cexar2591 you shouldn't compare between Maggie, Negan,Elijah And Shane Shane Was A cop Maggie Not A skilled fighter Negan Even His BadAssns He Still an old man Elijah I don't know But Shane skills and his experience would make him beat carver
@@khaledeljmal7132 he's not beating carver Shane was a cop carver was a special ops military soilder there are levels to this stuff carver would absolutely dogwalk shane
W edit and I agree with most except The Governor, strength goes to The Governor for several feats that I can endlessly list that far exceed Shane's capabilities
I agree with this, if Shane was still alive then he would of probably learned a few things and then he would be stronger then all the characters in Twd
Wow ! Brother this is an absolute Masterpiece congrats 🎉 But also, I think that Shane would be able to beat Beta and Carver mid-high diff and could you do Shane vs TWD characters please
I absolutely love this edit of course there might be some faulty mistakes, but very little for how many characters and how many points that have to be equally given to everyone if Shane would’ve lived on a bit longer I believe he might’ve been able to take out beta and some kind kind of the same way asDaryl did almost.
Man, Shane was already a monster in the second season and very strong, if he had lasted until the last season he would have been much stronger and could have beaten Beta and Brandon Carver at the Mid - Diff level
Typical Shane fanboy!! Clouded the brain so much that one can't even see the reality of most of the characters from the edit beating that crappy Shane's arse.
With Lori's death Shane will become much better. He will start to think rationally and will be same level of Rick if not better. There was a scene in s2 when Shane was fixing on building in the farm and he was completly done with Lori but she came to him and started with "oh Shane everything was real for me" and blah blah blah.
Bro didn't watch the series, and if he did, it was very bad. Shane did not live even six months in the apocalypse. Shane didn't show much strength, the only one he fought with was Rick from season 2...
@@МемнаяОпера shane dragged Ed, and Otis who are both fat as fuck. He held with only one hand to a window while punching a walker. Also got Daryl on the ground in a second. And he overpowered Rick at the begging of the fight, lifted him on a car and pushing him on the ground..
@@787lud ok Yes, I’m talking about experience in general. Shane simply lacks experience. Almost all the characters in this video have many times more survival experience, combat experience, and tactics than Shane.
Negan takes a few more and mid to highs or high, governor high to extreme, and shane mid to high or high diffs Simon, beta low diffs and easily takes combat
no. Negan could win but with high diff at least. Shane was a strong guy with good combat skills in season 2. If he made it to season 6-7, he would be very strong imo, like Rick and Daryl
What? Shut up, just shut up. Pathetic old Negan, who only has combat IQ and the people who always save him, will not defeat anyone alone. Shane negative difference
Well he knocked rick down with 2 hits while holding back and almost beat ed to death making his face bleed with 2 hits and easily put daryl in a chokehold so yes he solos most characters on top of that having combat experience prior to the apocalypse as a cop
He was a trained sheriff so yeah in the start of the apocalypse he has the gun training the stamina abilities to track and can read ppl do to his previous job. If you don’t think that’s useful then idk what to tell you
@@treythegreatwhite if it was in the same time line, of season 2, then sure but if we are talking about season 5-11 of shane then he would have a 50/50 on all of these guys or less %
it's actually pathetic if you think a strong officer trained in shooting/aiming loses to some random hobos in a fight except people that have the physical advantage (beta) or more trained (carver)
Explain how fodder-gan beats Shane in 1vs1…..😂 I mean in HTH and Gun Duell Shane solos no-low Diff. So I‘d gladly wanna hear an explanation from u how foddergan wins…😂😂😂
shane >>> rick (season 4) rick lost against governor because he was injured before the fight starts, shane beats governor mid - high diff. rick season 5 >>>> shane i dont need to explain the character development rick had in season 5 is insane, he started to act like what Shane became (crazy), Shane adapted to this world so fast, Rick took until season 5 to do this. If Shane had survived alongside Rick and Daryl they would dominate everything (governor lost against michonne) he is over rated
@@kalebcappeletti2985s5 rick didn't get better h2h idk why yall say he can beat everyone when he can't gov still beats him and michonne only won due to plot armor just like rick had plot armor against fighting the govenor and still lost after getting the drop, while gov has one eye , and took a bullet to the arm and was malnourished...gov> s5 rick
beta ain stronger than shane lowk. beta js a powerhouse cuz he tall and a pain soaker. he not really as strong as everyone says especially for his size. hes an old man whos js tall and relentless. shane has pure physical strength
@@evanmil0minefly Took 3 people to beat him and Negan even had to surprise attack him to actually knock him out if it's a gunfight Shane probably wins but if it's h2h Shane loses
@@000Veron That's fine. It doesn't rly matter tho since we know Daryl was able to fight in a stalemait with Carver who Rick's above ATP and Shane's scales above Rick Shane > Rick > Daryl ~ Carver
@@evanmil0mineflyIt wasn’t quite a stalemate. Firstly, that was Daryl and Dog vs Carver, and secondly, the fight only finished because the other Reapers turned up. I’m absolutely certain Carver would’ve killed Daryl if not for that.
Bro didn't watch the series, and if he did, it was very bad. Shane did not live even six months in the apocalypse. Shane didn't show much strength, the only one he fought with was Rick from season 2...
@@МемнаяОпера I watched the series a lot of times, I watched Daryl's spin off, and Negan and Maggie's spin off, I'm waiting for Rick and Michonne spin off, I read the comics so if I watched the show
@@finn7747 I also watched the series. I watched the spin-offs. I just don’t understand why everyone overestimates a policeman who killed a small number of walkers, who did not complete the only fight with Rick, who did not live in the apocalypse for a year, who showed himself to be a bad leader. Shane has no experience. Why do you think Shane will beat an Afghan War Veteran, a former Special Forces soldier who was a hitman in the old world, who has one of the best fighting skills, who lived in the apocalypse for about 10 years, who is part of one of the most dangerous factions in TWD?
What the fuck is wrong with you guys? Negan, Governor and Leah and Alpha are definitely better villains than Shane. You don't always have to fist fight or have a duel, u know? The battlefield settings can vary from clean plane ground to a woods filled with one's army and weaponry. L Shane.
Carver isnot even that strong he is overrated AF shane loses to governor high diff he loses to negan high diff also other is fax but beta mid diffs and carver mid high diffs
@@Battle-Edits660 "Simon is featless" You saw my debate with one of your viewers. you know thats a false premise. Negan and Governor are overwhelmingly stronger than Shane.
@@shadowmomochiuchiha6839 I don’t think Negan is stronger than Shane, but I think the Governor is stronger than Shane now. But false premise I disagree, yes Shane doesn’t have good feats but at least Shane have more feats than Simon.
![Shane Walsh | Choices [ The Walking Dead ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/t76IoCJvm00/mqdefault.jpg)
Of course Shane Walsh wins, he's The Punished after all.
If Shane was still alive by the end of the show, he'd be an absolute beast, even stronger than that. He could probably give a hard time to the likes of Beta and Carver
Y Governor
He would have become the punisher
If shane was alive ricks group would literally have it so much easier
hee would’ve got them killed in s5
Assuming, of course, rick is still with them.
He’d get them killed in szn 3 or 4 because of his inability to work with people
@@Aritingzlol Yeah he just kept getting more and more insane over time, by the time season 5 rolls around assuming he didn’t already get everyone killed he would probably be too insane for even the whisperers.
Shane Walsh is the complete Character to survive in TWD Universe
And If He Survived Until s11 he would've take out carver eseily
He was a season 8 level character whilst he was in season 2
I don't think so. Carver, beat Maggie, Negan and Elijah (who was hurt tho) at the same time for a moment. Also, his combat skills were incredible
@cexar2591 you shouldn't compare between Maggie, Negan,Elijah And Shane
Shane Was A cop
Maggie Not A skilled fighter
Negan Even His BadAssns He Still an old man
Elijah I don't know
But Shane skills and his experience would make him beat carver
@@khaledeljmal7132 he's not beating carver Shane was a cop carver was a special ops military soilder there are levels to this stuff carver would absolutely dogwalk shane
@@Revy856 Shane's Personality With 16 Years Of Experience In This Univers
Would've Make Him The Punisher Literally
W edit and I agree with most except The Governor, strength goes to The Governor for several feats that I can endlessly list that far exceed Shane's capabilities
Bro loved it at last someone shows what Shane can do. But if Shane last till the 10th season Shane would be a monster.
Name the feats
Governor is Michonne victim 😂😂😂😂
@@josuekilleryt6299cap
Nah governor is way poweful than michonne
I can imagine Shane and Andrea leaving mid s2 and we see him as Negan’s right hand man at the line up
Both of them got goosebumps. They were both crazy people.
if rick,shane,morgan,daryl formed a squad earlier then they would rule the TWD universe
I agree with this, if Shane was still alive then he would of probably learned a few things and then he would be stronger then all the characters in Twd
debate goes hardd. nice work dude
God Dayum! That's one BASED edit you got there!
Shane and Rick Grimes (Season 5) vs Carver. I believe it would be medium difficulty for Shane and Rick to take him down.
Wow ! Brother this is an absolute Masterpiece congrats 🎉 But also, I think that Shane would be able to beat Beta and Carver mid-high diff and could you do Shane vs TWD characters please
There is no way Shane beats Beta
Beta beats him low diff, Beta is the strongest character in the show
Exactly
@@MT_22-u7y Negan Low diff, Governor Mid diff and Carver Low-mid diff
Shane takes feats over Simon, Simon is a fodder
Shane has a lot of feats
Yeah, looking back on it Shane does have more feats than Simon
Guys at AMC we need a spinoff where Shane lives and I needs to be in that old style not this new unrealistic shit but proper good old TV.
I absolutely love this edit of course there might be some faulty mistakes, but very little for how many characters and how many points that have to be equally given to everyone if Shane would’ve lived on a bit longer I believe he might’ve been able to take out beta and some kind kind of the same way asDaryl did almost.
Battle edits, you are great at this stuff, keep doing what you do best
shane >>>all
Amazing! But i think Gareth wins in Experience, Iq and Weapons! Good Video!
Shane turns into the punisher negs all 😂
Underrated character imagine he lives ending he will win all 2:56 real
Man, Shane was already a monster in the second season and very strong, if he had lasted until the last season he would have been much stronger and could have beaten Beta and Brandon Carver at the Mid - Diff level
Thing is he wouldn't last, he was very aggressive and wasn't smart, he'd make rash decisions and get the whole group killed
Pope slams
Fax
Shane es uno de mis personajes favoritos de todo TWD
W edit W music W editor
Imagine only live till s2 but still stronger than 90% in twd verse
Goat edit
But if shane turns into the punisher mode he would smoke beta and brandon carver too
Shane is murking ALL of these mfs lol 🫵🏻
Typical Shane fanboy!! Clouded the brain so much that one can't even see the reality of most of the characters from the edit beating that crappy Shane's arse.
With Lori's death Shane will become much better. He will start to think rationally and will be same level of Rick if not better.
There was a scene in s2 when Shane was fixing on building in the farm and he was completly done with Lori but she came to him and started with "oh Shane everything was real for me" and blah blah blah.
God edit bro😎
Bro didn't watch the series, and if he did, it was very bad. Shane did not live even six months in the apocalypse. Shane didn't show much strength, the only one he fought with was Rick from season 2...
Shane fase final (Cuando mata a Randall) es la mera potencia
@@MC-tf5us 😱
@@МемнаяОпера 👺👺👺🔥
@@МемнаяОпера shane dragged Ed, and Otis who are both fat as fuck. He held with only one hand to a window while punching a walker. Also got Daryl on the ground in a second. And he overpowered Rick at the begging of the fight, lifted him on a car and pushing him on the ground..
@@787lud ok
Yes, I’m talking about experience in general. Shane simply lacks experience. Almost all the characters in this video have many times more survival experience, combat experience, and tactics than Shane.
The governor wins
The correct name is punisher vs twd villians😊
Die as a hero or live that long to see yourself become the villain
Negan takes a few more and mid to highs or high, governor high to extreme, and shane mid to high or high diffs Simon, beta low diffs and easily takes combat
Nah negan skinny ah ain't beating shane😂😂😂
@Rollsroyce7580 both governor and negan are skinny
@@dbdistrash gov lost weight in s4 but in s3 he was a little bulkier
I want a "what if?" series of TWD like what if shane didn't die?
No way you're saying Dawn is on the same level was Leah 💀💀💀💀💀
Damn, I hate seeing characters who are so bad ass like Shane die wayy too early and then seeing characters like Lance still alive in season 11.
Negan demolishes Neg diff
no. Negan could win but with high diff at least. Shane was a strong guy with good combat skills in season 2. If he made it to season 6-7, he would be very strong imo, like Rick and Daryl
@@787lud he would've gotten killed at the lineup and Shane has very overrated combat skills. Negan negs
What? Shut up, just shut up. Pathetic old Negan, who only has combat IQ and the people who always save him, will not defeat anyone alone. Shane negative difference
@@DoofenCrack_YT yea i mean it isnt an argument to say that he would have gotten killed at the lineup bro
Fax
I hope they bring back shane in twd universe
The governor would mess up Shane... REALLY bad. Rick beat Shane in a fight and Philip obliterated Rick in a fight. Governor megastomps Shane
Shane was destroying Rick in a fight. The second fight Rick got a cheap shot and stabbed him, doesn't really count
@@MicahParker849 The Governor fucked Rick up at the prison battle and if Michonne didn't stab The Governor from behind he would have killed him
Bro literally 💀👻
Beta is a fucking unit. It would be a great fight
How do I post vídeos without getting copyright?
the governor and negan >>
Every Reaper would solo Shane. People that say Shane can beat Carver are actually delusional.
Strength goes to governor, he is much taller, he beat Rick easily
Shane Walsh wins because he is the punisher
Bro I think the governor would destroy shane
ngl we see shane for 2 seasons and you say hes stronger then everyone, Beta somehow wins but ight. Shane fan fr
Well he knocked rick down with 2 hits while holding back and almost beat ed to death making his face bleed with 2 hits and easily put daryl in a chokehold so yes he solos most characters on top of that having combat experience prior to the apocalypse as a cop
@@Iloveyourmom360 exactly, and he also had that militaristic way of living and mindset even before the apocalypse
He was a trained sheriff so yeah in the start of the apocalypse he has the gun training the stamina abilities to track and can read ppl do to his previous job. If you don’t think that’s useful then idk what to tell you
@@treythegreatwhite right and you realise the world has practiced while he was dead, its been like many years after his death
@@treythegreatwhite if it was in the same time line, of season 2, then sure but if we are talking about season 5-11 of shane then he would have a 50/50 on all of these guys or less %
Negan and Gov slams
is this a template? could i use it? (With credit)
Song?
My Ordinary Life-The Living Tombstone
Who tf is Brandon he ain't beating Shane in a man to man fight 😤
(He definitely would)
Did bro even watch the last season? Shane's a beast, but Brandon basically soloed Maggie, Negan and that one guy in 3v1 melee.
Governor had more strength and durability and iq combat, shane extreme high diff
Shane Walsh vs The Walking Dead TWD ll My Ordinary Life ll Rick Grimes ll Negan Smith ll Glenn Rhee ll Daryl Dixon Edit 👍🏻😈😈😈😈🔥
😭😭😭Wtf is this meatriding tribute😭😭😭😭🙏
Fr
it's actually pathetic if you think a strong officer trained in shooting/aiming loses to some random hobos in a fight except people that have the physical advantage (beta) or more trained (carver)
Dw shane is still alive in marvel !
The governor slams maybe negan aswell but w overall
Shane is goat
Bro pope,simon,governor,negan>>>
He's not beating governor
😂
Beta and Negan>>>>>>Shane No Diff
Explain how fodder-gan beats Shane in 1vs1…..😂
I mean in HTH and Gun Duell Shane solos no-low Diff. So I‘d gladly wanna hear an explanation from u how foddergan wins…😂😂😂
Governor beats Shane imo
But good vid
No
shane >>> rick (season 4)
rick lost against governor because he was injured before the fight starts, shane beats governor mid - high diff.
rick season 5 >>>> shane
i dont need to explain
the character development rick had in season 5 is insane, he started to act like what Shane became (crazy), Shane adapted to this world so fast, Rick took until season 5 to do this.
If Shane had survived alongside Rick and Daryl they would dominate everything
(governor lost against michonne) he is over rated
@@kalebcappeletti2985 agree
@@kalebcappeletti2985s5 rick didn't get better h2h idk why yall say he can beat everyone when he can't gov still beats him and michonne only won due to plot armor just like rick had plot armor against fighting the govenor and still lost after getting the drop, while gov has one eye , and took a bullet to the arm and was malnourished...gov> s5 rick
beta ain stronger than shane lowk. beta js a powerhouse cuz he tall and a pain soaker. he not really as strong as everyone says especially for his size. hes an old man whos js tall and relentless. shane has pure physical strength
W but Negan takes strength and wins high diff
Negan takes strenght? 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😂😂
@@Vaaaalen_137 yerrr
pls dont br saying dub sh** like that
I dont think shane beats the governor or negan but good vid
I respect your opinion.🤝
Bruh, Shane beats nearly everyone here. The only ones above is probably the Governor and Beta
And Carver IMHO
@@000Veron nah he beats Carver
@@evanmil0minefly Took 3 people to beat him and Negan even had to surprise attack him to actually knock him out if it's a gunfight Shane probably wins but if it's h2h Shane loses
@@000Veron That's fine. It doesn't rly matter tho since we know Daryl was able to fight in a stalemait with Carver who Rick's above ATP and Shane's scales above Rick
Shane > Rick > Daryl ~ Carver
@@evanmil0mineflyIt wasn’t quite a stalemate. Firstly, that was Daryl and Dog vs Carver, and secondly, the fight only finished because the other Reapers turned up. I’m absolutely certain Carver would’ve killed Daryl if not for that.
Brother Shane will beat B carver
He might win over everyone except the Governor and Negin
Not Shane’s chad face
Shane ain’t beating neagan
Governor wins
governor is over rated
@@kalebcappeletti2985 😂
@@kalebcappeletti2985 Shane is overrated
@@andrea.grimesno, cry, governor fan
@@Khalil00284 😂
Bruh don't even compare Shane to a women Lol😂
Simon>>>
Мерсер, Бета, Губернатор, Карвер, Рик убьют Шейна
Shane>Beta
Shane>Carver
Bro didn't watch the series, and if he did, it was very bad. Shane did not live even six months in the apocalypse. Shane didn't show much strength, the only one he fought with was Rick from season 2...
@@МемнаяОпера I watched the series a lot of times, I watched Daryl's spin off, and Negan and Maggie's spin off, I'm waiting for Rick and Michonne spin off, I read the comics so if I watched the show
@@finn7747 I also watched the series. I watched the spin-offs. I just don’t understand why everyone overestimates a policeman who killed a small number of walkers, who did not complete the only fight with Rick, who did not live in the apocalypse for a year, who showed himself to be a bad leader. Shane has no experience. Why do you think Shane will beat an Afghan War Veteran, a former Special Forces soldier who was a hitman in the old world, who has one of the best fighting skills, who lived in the apocalypse for about 10 years, who is part of one of the most dangerous factions in TWD?
I love Shane, everyone hates him for what he did in the second season, but later Rick became the same, but everyone loves him.
fr
What the fuck is wrong with you guys? Negan, Governor and Leah and Alpha are definitely better villains than Shane. You don't always have to fist fight or have a duel, u know? The battlefield settings can vary from clean plane ground to a woods filled with one's army and weaponry. L Shane.
Well, the VS videos are generally literally based on a duel scenario...
Shane solos
Shane Vs Negan
Quase deu empate
Holy cow
Carver isnot even that strong he is overrated AF shane loses to governor high diff he loses to negan high diff also other is fax but beta mid diffs and carver mid high diffs
Shane is overrated.
gov mid diffs shane
classic battle edits L
Simon
Negan
Governor
Negative difficulty
Cry about it
Negan and Governor is debatable and I might make a remake on it. But Simon doesn’t have any good feats at all, Simon is just featless.
@@Battle-Edits660 "Simon is featless"
You saw my debate with one of your viewers. you know thats a false premise.
Negan and Governor are overwhelmingly stronger than Shane.
@@shadowmomochiuchiha6839 I don’t think Negan is stronger than Shane, but I think the Governor is stronger than Shane now. But false premise I disagree, yes Shane doesn’t have good feats but at least Shane have more feats than Simon.
@@Battle-Edits660 He doesn't have more feats than Simon🤣
@@shadowmomochiuchiha6839Well if you so sure, what about you prove it.
Overall, Shane wins all of them except beta and the governor
Cap
Negan Wins Low-diff, Gov Wins Mid-diff,
@@Cocoa_de_mani w
@@Cocoa_de_maninegan really solos..
No diff.
But governor no, Shane solos
This video shows how overrated shane is.
Overrated af
👍🏻
Ok