I’m convinced Colin doesn’t know who Fred Warner is because it’s no reason for him to not be on this list. Fred could arguably be between 2-5 on this list
Off-ball linebackers aren’t that impactful, in comparison to other positions. Star pass rushers, tackles, QBs, WRs are far more impactful generally speaking.
@@poststalone1496also, why do you think off-ball linebackers rarely get 2nd contracts from teams that drafted them? Certainly more valuable than RBs, but they are not a premium position by any means.
Pacheco and rice aren’t on here for the chiefs and neither is mcduffie or Bolton or karlaftis who has the same amount of sacks as Chris Jones. Not everybody can make the list man, it doesn’t mean they aren’t good. 10 is just a small number. And most people only think of that one big guy when it comes to defense anyways. Sneed has just had an insane season and shut down every wr 1
Colin cowherd does not watch the 49ers other than major televised games. Any Niners faithful knows that Fred Warner is the leader of that defense and easily in the top 10
Everyone knows that a good defense relies on having a strong d line and that line doing their job makes the entire defenses job easier so Bosa is definitely more important than Warner. If they pressure the qb then they either don’t throw the ball or they throw it badly and Warner can go catch it but warners roll is directly based off what they do so he can’t be the leader of your offense.
9/10 of the are correct but gotta have Warner in the list over Aiyuk. Outside of the top 10, guys like McDuffie, Humphrey, Greenlaw, Purdy, Pacheco, Rice, Ward, Bolton are all-pro/pro-bowl level players. Two very talented teams
Colin just doesn’t know who Fred Warner is because he’s literally the best linebacker in the league 2nd week he’s totally snubbed him. He’s way more valuable than deebo. He might not even be the best receiver on his team
warner has had some pretty abysmal effort plays in these playoffs so far. he also has one of the highest missed tackles totals in the entire league this season. i don't think he forgot about warner, he probably just sits around 12th-13th on this list to be completely honest.
There’s a lot of people who could’ve easily made this list and purdy is like 10th on that list dude. This isn’t like a ‘best on this team’ only list, it’s best player in general which he is not.
@@Zarab923 Purdy had a 70% completion percentage, 4,280 yards passing, 31 TD's, and 11 interceptions season this year. He had better stats than Lamar Jackson except for interceptions, and Lamar just won NFL MVP. And Purdy is in the SB.
@@marvinshenk stats are useless. If you throw for more yards with more completions does it matter at all if you lose the game? What if you get completions and get down to the red zone only to fumble the ball and score zero points. Congrats on the stats but you still lose. And players on good teams have the ability to pad their stats by blowing out the team when it’s smarter to manage the clock and not risk turning the ball over or getting injured. I’m not saying stats aren’t good and that they’re always wrong but football is a lot more complex than individual stats in a team sport especially when there’s not any context provided 🤷🏼♀️
Who are you putting him ahead of? Not saying you're wrong but Fred Warner isn't even on this list, so he honestly should get first dibs on replacing someone.
@@BangBangNinerMan Fred Warner was on a podcast a couple weeks ago, was asked to rank the 49ers top 5-10 players. And Fred Warner, the unanimous All Pro LB on the 49ers, didn’t even mention Brock Purdy when it came to ranking the best players on the 49ers. Brock’s OWN teammate didn’t even bring his name up. Brock is a solid QB, he’s good/solid. But he shouldn’t be mentioned with players like Trent, CMC, Kittle, Warner, Etc etc. Those are 1st team All Pros. Which means THE BEST at their position in the entire NFL. Brock ain’t close to that my guy.
1. Mahomes 2. CMC 3. Trent Williams 4. Chris Jones 5. Kelce 6. Warner 7. Bosa 8. Sneed 9. Kittle 10. Humphrey/Aiyuk/Deebo. These 11 players need to make up the top 10 and there is no negotiating
Didn't Trent Williams get bully shoved by jadeveon Clooney atleast twice where atleast once was a sack vs the ravens to where he had to be benched, cause the injury excuse lol
Mahomes is still better. Mcaffrey literally didn’t play for like half of two games and sat another one out and while Mahomes sat one out he’s definitely been there for the rest.
Stupid score passed niners bias at its finest though. If you uselessly run up the score on teams then you’ll have better stats… doesn’t make you better
Nope. Sorry guy but that's based on your bias. You say it's based on the season just so you can justify putting CMC over Mahomes. And then you've got C. Jones at #5 when he's been average. You've got a center on the list, not sure if you even know that, and you've got McDuffie on a top 10 list that doesn't have Sneed anywhere on it??? Nothing here makes actual sense.
Guys, 49ers are going to win. Never mind the x's and o's... the 49ers haven't won a Super Bowl in 29 years. They've lost in their last two Super Bowl appearances, they're not about to lose a third straight. Kyle Shanhan is about to get redemption after the 28-3 heartbreak & squandering a 10 point in the Super Bowl vs the Chiefs. They are simply due. Sunday will see them win their sixth Lombardi
there's barely any connection left to the team that lost the Super Bowl 4 years ago, so if you're using logic that is based on stuff that happened 29 years ago then it literally means absolutely nothing in terms of what will happen this weekend lol "they are simply due" is not analysis and it doesn't mean anything
@@aneesabashir8496 well sure haha but that still doesn't necessarily mean your reasoning would prove to be accurate, it just means a game that could go either way happened to go that way regardless of what happened 29 years ago lol
McDuffie has definitely been awesome, and Snead has been absolutely elite all season long.......probably one of the most underrated guys in the game this year
They’re both awesome but sneed has let a wr 1 score on his all season and he saved the game vs the ravens by knocking the ball out at the goal line. Crazy play. Oh and jammed tf out of tyreek lol
Enough of the BS 🤔 3 elite teams played b4 super bowl, Dolphins, extreme cold conditions at Bills, unstoppable Ravens vs. Chiefs "compared to" non elite Rams, Packers, semi elite Lions vs. 49ers. Chiefs by far are the better team. 49ers will fall at Las Vegas
CMC should be the MVP. One if the most awesome RB no doubt!💪🏻49 will be disband after this season. Can’t keep all the top players! Got to do it this SB Sunday
Travis should be at 3, him and pat played mid throught but pat had his usual spot. dude was arguably the goat TE and then brock or fred should be in the top 10. Deb and brandon are awesome but i rank brock or fred higher than those two😁
Just way too much chiefs confidence simply because they’ve been there more often than the niners. I just don’t see the chiefs winning because the niners are gonna be hungrier. Brock Purdy gonna make a lot of people mad
Absolutely INSANE! TE Travis Kelce is the f'ing GOAT TE. ALL those Receiving Postseason recs hes had or close to & will EVENTUALLY BREAK! Not mention ALL his Reg Season domination the last decade. *1. Mahomes 2. KELCE! (TE Travis Kelce is ARGUABLY the best IMPACT PLAYER in the NFL since 2016-Prsnt.)
Check out The Carton Show on TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@thecartonshow
I’m convinced Colin doesn’t know who Fred Warner is because it’s no reason for him to not be on this list. Fred could arguably be between 2-5 on this list
Off-ball linebackers aren’t that impactful, in comparison to other positions. Star pass rushers, tackles, QBs, WRs are far more impactful generally speaking.
@@colecaine.If you'd played at the highschool level or beyond you'd understand how wrong you are.
Right, because high school football and NFL football are comparable hahahaha
@@poststalone1496also, why do you think off-ball linebackers rarely get 2nd contracts from teams that drafted them? Certainly more valuable than RBs, but they are not a premium position by any means.
@@colecaine.or beyond... Yes reading comprehension is beyond your capabilities. Good luck in life with that mentality friend.
I don’t think people understand just how crazy it is for a left tackle to not give up a single sack
Bosa over Kelce is crazy
Finally Sneed getting some credit
Nice list but someone needs to get pushed out for Fred Werner for sure!
You expect a Taylor Swift fan to understand anything about football? Cowturd is a clown.
San Francisco 49ers...🏈🏈🏈
To go the whole season and only give up one touchdown in coverage is crazy 😮
No Fred Warner is crazy lol
We're is Fred Warner?
somewhere around #11 i guess?
fred warner being off this list is a legit hate-crime
Pacheco and rice aren’t on here for the chiefs and neither is mcduffie or Bolton or karlaftis who has the same amount of sacks as Chris Jones. Not everybody can make the list man, it doesn’t mean they aren’t good. 10 is just a small number. And most people only think of that one big guy when it comes to defense anyways. Sneed has just had an insane season and shut down every wr 1
Colin cowherd does not watch the 49ers other than major televised games. Any Niners faithful knows that Fred Warner is the leader of that defense and easily in the top 10
Everyone knows that a good defense relies on having a strong d line and that line doing their job makes the entire defenses job easier so Bosa is definitely more important than Warner. If they pressure the qb then they either don’t throw the ball or they throw it badly and Warner can go catch it but warners roll is directly based off what they do so he can’t be the leader of your offense.
9/10 of the are correct but gotta have Warner in the list over Aiyuk. Outside of the top 10, guys like McDuffie, Humphrey, Greenlaw, Purdy, Pacheco, Rice, Ward, Bolton are all-pro/pro-bowl level players. Two very talented teams
Not at all Purdy impact is a top 3
Do not sleep on Sneed! 💯
This reliance on Pro Football Focus is laughable.
Colin just doesn’t know who Fred Warner is because he’s literally the best linebacker in the league 2nd week he’s totally snubbed him. He’s way more valuable than deebo. He might not even be the best receiver on his team
warner has had some pretty abysmal effort plays in these playoffs so far. he also has one of the highest missed tackles totals in the entire league this season. i don't think he forgot about warner, he probably just sits around 12th-13th on this list to be completely honest.
McDuffie was all Pro but he doesn't make the list i swear people don't know football at all but act like they do. SMH
Brock Purdy should be on the list. He was the last player drafted last season and he's in the Super Bowl!!! Show some respect!!!
There’s a lot of people who could’ve easily made this list and purdy is like 10th on that list dude. This isn’t like a ‘best on this team’ only list, it’s best player in general which he is not.
@@Zarab923you sound silly being a good QB put you at 2 before of impact
His play is better than his teammates even though I am a niners fan Purdy is the best niners player
@@Zarab923 Purdy had a 70% completion percentage, 4,280 yards passing, 31 TD's, and 11 interceptions season this year. He had better stats than Lamar Jackson except for interceptions, and Lamar just won NFL MVP. And Purdy is in the SB.
@@marvinshenk stats are useless. If you throw for more yards with more completions does it matter at all if you lose the game? What if you get completions and get down to the red zone only to fumble the ball and score zero points. Congrats on the stats but you still lose. And players on good teams have the ability to pad their stats by blowing out the team when it’s smarter to manage the clock and not risk turning the ball over or getting injured. I’m not saying stats aren’t good and that they’re always wrong but football is a lot more complex than individual stats in a team sport especially when there’s not any context provided 🤷🏼♀️
The Brock Purdy disrespect is real smh
Who are you putting him ahead of? Not saying you're wrong but Fred Warner isn't even on this list, so he honestly should get first dibs on replacing someone.
@@williamamsbary5226 Brock the best player on the 49ers
@@BangBangNinerManthat’s a joke
@@connorsmith6517 how?
@@BangBangNinerMan Fred Warner was on a podcast a couple weeks ago, was asked to rank the 49ers top 5-10 players.
And Fred Warner, the unanimous All Pro LB on the 49ers, didn’t even mention Brock Purdy when it came to ranking the best players on the 49ers. Brock’s OWN teammate didn’t even bring his name up.
Brock is a solid QB, he’s good/solid. But he shouldn’t be mentioned with players like Trent, CMC, Kittle, Warner, Etc etc. Those are 1st team All Pros. Which means THE BEST at their position in the entire NFL. Brock ain’t close to that my guy.
1. Mahomes 2. CMC 3. Trent Williams 4. Chris Jones 5. Kelce 6. Warner 7. Bosa 8. Sneed 9. Kittle 10. Humphrey/Aiyuk/Deebo. These 11 players need to make up the top 10 and there is no negotiating
Your list is what he should have used for the show, wayyy more accurate
Bruh Mcduffie made 1 team all pro. SMH
@@thronesofgaming5240 yeah mcduffie also has an argument for the 10 spot
Congratulations, you just made a top-12 list (13 if you include McDuffie).
Now try again and actually FOLLOW THE RULES this time!!
cry more@@Vic-Vega
Good list but I’d swap out Aiyuk for Warner.
Didn't Trent Williams get bully shoved by jadeveon Clooney atleast twice where atleast once was a sack vs the ravens to where he had to be benched, cause the injury excuse lol
An injury is an injury not an excuse.
Don’t know why he hates Fred Warner
My top 10 (based on this season):
1. McCaffrey
2. Mahomes
3. Trent
4. Kittle
5. Chris Jones
6. Warner
7. Kelce
8. Bosa
9. McDuffie
10. Creed Humphrey
Mahomes is still better. Mcaffrey literally didn’t play for like half of two games and sat another one out and while Mahomes sat one out he’s definitely been there for the rest.
Stupid score passed niners bias at its finest though. If you uselessly run up the score on teams then you’ll have better stats… doesn’t make you better
Nope. Sorry guy but that's based on your bias. You say it's based on the season just so you can justify putting CMC over Mahomes. And then you've got C. Jones at #5 when he's been average. You've got a center on the list, not sure if you even know that, and you've got McDuffie on a top 10 list that doesn't have Sneed anywhere on it??? Nothing here makes actual sense.
@@Mik3yLowMcDuffie over Sneed is actually defensible.
No Brock is not, especially if you're basing this on 2023. Purdy was better than Mahomes!!
That’s a good list.
Guys, 49ers are going to win. Never mind the x's and o's... the 49ers haven't won a Super Bowl in 29 years. They've lost in their last two Super Bowl appearances, they're not about to lose a third straight. Kyle Shanhan is about to get redemption after the 28-3 heartbreak & squandering a 10 point in the Super Bowl vs the Chiefs. They are simply due. Sunday will see them win their sixth Lombardi
there's barely any connection left to the team that lost the Super Bowl 4 years ago, so if you're using logic that is based on stuff that happened 29 years ago then it literally means absolutely nothing in terms of what will happen this weekend lol
"they are simply due" is not analysis and it doesn't mean anything
Promise to come back here on Monday if I'm right??
@@aneesabashir8496 well sure haha but that still doesn't necessarily mean your reasoning would prove to be accurate, it just means a game that could go either way happened to go that way regardless of what happened 29 years ago lol
@@mattcarberry368Buddy, how does Shanahan, Deebo, Kyle J., Kittle, Greenlaw, Armstead, Warner, Bosa, Dwelley, Givens qualify as "barely any connection??"
That's 10 guys!
1. Fred Warner
2. I’m not sure Sneed is even the best corner on the Chiefs, Trent McDuffie has been awesome
McDuffie has definitely been awesome, and Snead has been absolutely elite all season long.......probably one of the most underrated guys in the game this year
They’re both awesome but sneed has let a wr 1 score on his all season and he saved the game vs the ravens by knocking the ball out at the goal line. Crazy play. Oh and jammed tf out of tyreek lol
Enough of the BS 🤔 3 elite teams played b4 super bowl, Dolphins, extreme cold conditions at Bills, unstoppable Ravens vs. Chiefs "compared to" non elite Rams, Packers, semi elite Lions vs. 49ers. Chiefs by far are the better team. 49ers will fall at Las Vegas
That's crazy you didn't have Fred Warner up there!
Mahomes "just recently"entered his prime?? His whole career has been his prime
CMC should be the MVP. One if the most awesome RB no doubt!💪🏻49 will be disband after this season. Can’t keep all the top players! Got to do it this SB Sunday
Top 3 i agree with. Chris Jones should be #4.
Chris jones has never had a sack in the Super Bowl
Most versatile running back us lamar,he can qb too
Kittle should he number 3 becuz hes the 2nd best lineman on his team and top 10 beat catchers in the league
Non Mahomes, he's the first to appear. Fire the intern ! 😂😂😂
Deb flopped, Kittle flopped, Bosa flopped, Aiyul flopped. Please with the benefit of the hindsight please come back with a better list 😊
And still til this day the Greatest QBs of all time
Brady and Joe Cool
Why would someone with Raider in their name comment this? 😲
Greatest TE of all time halfway down this list?
I'm taking fred warner, chris jones, brandon aiyuk, isaiah pacheco, and l'jarius sneed over deebo samuel... but thats just me
Travis should be at 3, him and pat played mid throught but pat had his usual spot. dude was arguably the goat TE and then brock or fred should be in the top 10. Deb and brandon are awesome but i rank brock or fred higher than those two😁
Sneed over warner is so comical 😂
Fred Warner???
"Top 10 non-Mahomes players in SBLVII" ... #1: Mahomes
No offence but George Kittle is not a first ballot HOFer Colin seriously
SF fans, is Warner better than Patrick Willis/Navarro Bowman?
nick bosa over chris jones is comical this list is so bad
Colin doesn’t talk facts, he just say 💩 that make people talk about it .
I dont not If Colin hace seen the Games, but Not putting Brock and Isaih in the list, its lame
Boss better than Kelce? Unreal…i can see the Trent and CMC pick, but Bosa is not better than Kelce.
Chris Jones > Bosa
100 on that 👍🏻 button
Quinnen Williams > Chris Jones
Just way too much chiefs confidence simply because they’ve been there more often than the niners. I just don’t see the chiefs winning because the niners are gonna be hungrier. Brock Purdy gonna make a lot of people mad
No Maholmes is soon going to pass Brady, don't bet against him!
Colin’s rule most top players wins SB. Gotta take niners right?
May look like that but chiefs have a better o line and defense and coaching
@@dylanallen5653Kansas City definitely doesn't have a better head coach than SF.
Defense is debatable.
Absolutely INSANE!
TE Travis Kelce is the f'ing GOAT TE.
ALL those Receiving Postseason recs hes had or close to & will EVENTUALLY BREAK!
Not mention ALL his Reg Season domination the last decade.
*1. Mahomes
2. KELCE!
(TE Travis Kelce is ARGUABLY the best IMPACT PLAYER in the NFL since 2016-Prsnt.)
Fred hasn’t been playing good
Mahomes so far in his own class that he can’t be on this list lol
sneed over warner is laughable. “Uncle Colin” is not invited to the cookout
Funny has Warner locked up all the top wr 1’s all year and not allowed them a single touchdown? Nope. Sneed did that