RSS Chief’s Clear Message to Modi - Shed Arrogance, Rein in Your Frankenstein Monsters

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
  • RSS Chief's speech is a clear message to Mr. Modi - shed arrogance and rein in your Frankenstein monsters: Author, diplomat and former MP, Pavan Varma, to Karan Thapar for The Wire.
    .........................................
    One of India’s most perceptive political commentators says that the speech made by the RSS Sarsanghchalak in Nagpur last Monday was a clear message to Mr. Modi. Pavan Varma says it was a “pointed and relevant message” and of “seminal importance”. As Mr. Varma put it, it was “extremely important (because) Bhagwat speaks rarely but when he does so he has a purpose and a carefully thought-out message”.
    Mr. Varma says when Mohan Bhagwat spoke about the need to “respect diversity, live together and respect others … (and) embrace goodwill to all” he clearly had in mind the comments made by the BJP and Mr. Modi in particular during the recent election campaign. In one striking sentence Mr. Bhagwat said: “We must … treat the sons of our country as brothers”. Mr Varma said it is “explicitly clear” that Mr. Bhagwat was saying Muslims are brothers not infiltrators.
    Mr. Varma said although when the RSS Chief said a true sevak does not have arrogance he was speaking generically nonetheless “the inference was very clear” and it was obvious “at whom it was specifically directed”. Mr. Varma said that Mr. Modi’s claim that he is not of biological birth was probably “the final straw on the camel’s back”.
    In the interview, Mr. Varma spoke at length about what he called a “Frankenstein monster” by which he meant “lumpen elements” and the kind of unchecked lawlessness and violence that they have unleashed in alleged support of Mr. Modi and the BJP. At one point in this section of the interview Mr. Varma named the Bajrang Dal.
    Mr. Varma described the RSS Chief’s speech as “a cautionary voice”. In fact, it’s one of three critical comments made by RSS leaders in the same week. There was Indresh Kumar’s comment as well as Ratan Sharda’s article in the RSS magazine Organizer. All three were said in public not in private. Was that just a coincidence or is it a conscious deliberate message? Mr. Varma specifically answers this question. I will leave you to see the interview to hear his answer.
    I am only giving you the main big points made by Mr. Varma. I would encourage you to watch this interview to hear his rich, in-depth analysis of the RSS Chief’s speech in greater detail. Mr. Varma draws clear and explicit inferences to Mr. Modi, his government and his statements and attitude. Again, I would like you to see the interview to hear these for yourself.
    Join The Wire's UA-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews

КОМЕНТАРІ • 331

  • @zaphbrox8239
    @zaphbrox8239 3 місяці тому +139

    When the RSS is beginning to sound more sane than Modi and BJP ... we live in strange times.

    • @bikramsen9952
      @bikramsen9952 3 місяці тому +7

      😂😂😂
      So true
      Strange times

    • @johnyepthomi892
      @johnyepthomi892 3 місяці тому +8

      Also don’t take it as face value. It’s more likely attempt for BJP to take them seriously. They are sounding sane because their default is far from sane, which they probably can’t wait to go back to. They probably just want BJP to reconsider their value.

    • @nandakumar7938
      @nandakumar7938 3 місяці тому

      ​@@bikramsen9952❤ 6:54 q9😊
      L

    • @kausikgangopadhyay5589
      @kausikgangopadhyay5589 3 місяці тому +3

      It’s called compulsion!

    • @saisha8917
      @saisha8917 3 місяці тому +3

      Haa what times are we living in where this rss people sound more sensible that this silly government 😂😂😂😂

  • @alfiashaikh9228
    @alfiashaikh9228 3 місяці тому +10

    I would've been happier if this person had said these thing before the elections!

  • @nitishpatel1017
    @nitishpatel1017 3 місяці тому +26

    Since when did Mr Bagwat become the go-to person for pearls of wisdom? 🤔

    • @saliloltikar3958
      @saliloltikar3958 3 місяці тому +1

      You should listen to speeches then u would realise

    • @utubeissed
      @utubeissed 3 місяці тому

      You go for collecting oysters at Rahul Gandhi's meetings right? It rains pearls when rahul Gandhi speaks I guess!

    • @CosmicValkyrie
      @CosmicValkyrie Місяць тому

      You should listen to everyone. Otherwise you'll live in an echo chamber and cloak yourself in ignorance. It is especially important to listen to those who you do not like. There is not much point listening to those who you agree with because you already know the thoughts and opinions. But it is vital to know the position of your opponents to know the situation.

  • @kamleshprinters
    @kamleshprinters 3 місяці тому +76

    The message from RSS is for people. They pretended to show people that they are there and concerned about issues of our country. But infact they are not concerned or worried. It's a gesture to establish their goodwill (if any saved) after a span of 10 years. Nobody logically should believe in what RSS is saying now.

    • @suhitaraychaudhuri4591
      @suhitaraychaudhuri4591 3 місяці тому +9

      I agree. They are trying to save face.😂😂

    • @rajalanke5559
      @rajalanke5559 3 місяці тому +9

      Sorry, I must ask...
      Who is this Pawan Varma?
      Is he really an intellectual?
      Because he doesn't know the simple thing which even our road side vendors and beggars know!!!
      "MODI AND RSS ARE TWO SIDES OF SAME COIN!"
      Why are you people not inviting Mohanji Bhagwat for channel discussion? Let the viewers ask him questions

    • @whoru7257
      @whoru7257 3 місяці тому +1

      Says a man with the name Printers.Mr.Printers thinks he knows more than everyone😅😅😅

    • @rohitghoshal
      @rohitghoshal 3 місяці тому

      @@suhitaraychaudhuri4591 Save face from what? They don't fight elections. Their followers don't want secularism.

    • @manchikantimurty7375
      @manchikantimurty7375 3 місяці тому +3

      Modi is unable to Digest that Ram Lalla and Kedareswar of Kedarnath did not help at all.
      Modi was foolish to underestimate the Power of 63 Nayanars, 13 Alwars , more than 18 Immortal Siddha Yogis of South India. Annamalai could not explain to them what is Hindutva of bulldozer jhumla party headed by a PM who very frequently uses Modi washing machine with modi washing powder.
      .....
      Modi during his campaign March 16 to May 30 had uttered the following words so many times
      Hindu Muslim 762
      Poor 1094
      Ram 1200
      Farmer 879
      Congress 5133
      Modi 4320
      Constitution 762
      Alliance 966
      BJP 1359
      Development 834.
      ....
      Such worthless Guy. How can he become a Stateman like Pundit Jawaharlal Nehru son of illustrious Motilal Nehru. And both the father and son might have been born again to continue their work of protecting Indian Democracy. It is not fragile like that of Russia

  • @saumyaadhikari8078
    @saumyaadhikari8078 3 місяці тому +51

    Don't see too much in the message. It's only eyewash and pretence.

  • @ceva7727
    @ceva7727 3 місяці тому +162

    I seriously hope Modi faces criticism and difficulties from within and outside his party.
    This moronic situation of having a PM who is a very flawed personality and some idiots thinking he is God like is extremely harmful to our nation.
    Forget BJP, no political party or organization should encourage such figures.

    • @VimalRaju-m7u
      @VimalRaju-m7u 3 місяці тому +12

      Completely agree with you....Sincerely wish many in our country have your standpoint......a fellow patriot from down south...

    • @ramaswamikc9111
      @ramaswamikc9111 3 місяці тому +3

      good

    • @raxas7378
      @raxas7378 3 місяці тому

      And who replaces Modi, and how? Modi rose through the ranks - not by way of a coup. The same process will bring in his successor. Why should the successor be significantly different from Modi? Shah? Rajnath? Singh? Adityanath?

    • @krisgopi_8
      @krisgopi_8 3 місяці тому +4

      ​@@raxas7378Nitin gadkari is better option..
      Yogi is only for up.

    • @krisgopi_8
      @krisgopi_8 3 місяці тому +3

      ​@@raxas7378Shah is very bad for pm post, once his master leaves he will be packed off
      Rajnath Singh is ok under circumstances if modi reigns

  • @mokshajetley9244
    @mokshajetley9244 3 місяці тому +4

    If RSS knows everything why don't they come openly and save our democracy?

  • @KMVenugoalan-et2qg
    @KMVenugoalan-et2qg 3 місяці тому +45

    RSS and BJP are sides of the same coin. Both are politically and ideologically trained to speak with forked tongues

    • @chenithungjami140
      @chenithungjami140 3 місяці тому

      I wonder why they are speaking now.. It's too late... Pathetic

  • @kartheekvijay2250
    @kartheekvijay2250 3 місяці тому +6

    Mr Verma should understand that RSS/ BJP is same

  • @smiritigoswamiclass-5.398
    @smiritigoswamiclass-5.398 3 місяці тому +8

    We are always with neutral and intellectual media and Karan Thapar.❤😂🎉.

  • @K.B.Ravindra
    @K.B.Ravindra 3 місяці тому +8

    Adding to the comments already made by so many people, I would like to add that as Modi and his party have failed to secure a absolute majority, it will be really Human if Modi stops using Central Agencies like CBI, ED, IT etc to target and jail opposition party leaders.

  • @gdmufti5914
    @gdmufti5914 3 місяці тому +4

    Pleasure to listen to an impartial saner voice (Pawan Verma) after a pretty long time, on political scenario that's emerging vis a vis RSS n BJP.

  • @lawanwar3977
    @lawanwar3977 3 місяці тому +12

    As a person from northeast, I hugely respect their concern for diversity. It gives new hope for new India where we all can live in peace. The Modi machinery have really polarised and made hate its core politics.

    • @chenithungjami140
      @chenithungjami140 3 місяці тому

      It's too late.. Talking about diversity now that Modi did get majority is utterly nonsense.. Where was Rss when Modi was ruling the country with iron hand.. 😂😂

  • @anjansen8072
    @anjansen8072 3 місяці тому +10

    Nothing but on behalf of RSS--- try to damage control especially observing the Parliamentary election result.

  • @prashantaguha-cesc-pcbl-he3638
    @prashantaguha-cesc-pcbl-he3638 3 місяці тому +1

    We look forward to the time when the "Power of Love" will replace the "Love of Power".
    William Ewart Gladstone

  • @sanjeevnair9005
    @sanjeevnair9005 3 місяці тому +6

    Bingo. Spot on. Wonder why our other fellow person did not analyse it the moment it came out..

  • @prakashpimparkar489
    @prakashpimparkar489 3 місяці тому +10

    What a correct analysis

    • @rajalanke5559
      @rajalanke5559 3 місяці тому

      Sorry, I must ask...
      Who is this Pawan Varma?
      Is he really an intellectual?
      Because he doesn't know the simple thing which even our road side vendors and beggars know!!!
      "MODI AND RSS ARE TWO SIDES OF SAME COIN!"
      Why are you people not inviting Mohanji Bhagwat for channel discussion? Let the viewers ask him questions

    • @floriststamp5021
      @floriststamp5021 3 місяці тому

      Why do you repeat the same thing. Have you nothing else to say

  • @shamspuri2493
    @shamspuri2493 3 місяці тому +2

    It's so good to hear discourses on this channel which are intelligent, discerning and all sides of the arguments are explored, evidenced by facts and when there is a lack of factual info, the speakers are quick to admit that and are humble. Although initially, I thought the Print had some credibility, Shekhar Gupta was found to be trying so hard to hide the fact that his leanings were with the BJP and he is prone to give opinions, pass judgements, based on his own opinions but make them sound like a 'news worthy bulletin' but ends up being a softer voice for Godi media that he tries very hard to hide. The Wire is a more superior channel and is not afraid to debate and call out the wrongdoings of the ruling party or the ruler's rhetoric without fear or favour.

  • @kareemkhan-hv1yp
    @kareemkhan-hv1yp 3 місяці тому +20

    RSS would never want equal minorities participation/representation in parliament...... This speech is just to make sure that they are not seen as anti minorities in India and internationally

  • @kaushal9566
    @kaushal9566 3 місяці тому +4

    Common...when Modi was ralling with the motton, muslim, machali, mangalsutra, Mohan bhagawat did not comment why big Modi is like. At that time he wanted Modi to get 400 paar. Tested, When Modi didn't get ..that failed. He spoke last Monday. Mindless man. The RSS mind will not understand that,what India and her soil made of people are. Better make their bones straight .

  • @mayansab
    @mayansab 3 місяці тому +1

    Thanks

  • @praboobas
    @praboobas 3 місяці тому +3

    Thanks!

  • @khaliqjawadkhaliqjawad2466
    @khaliqjawadkhaliqjawad2466 3 місяці тому +2

    This Is We Called True Journalism 👍

    • @dileep6021
      @dileep6021 3 місяці тому

      when it is against bjp it is true journalism right???
      Its really a f**king conclusion
      can u point out one news that seems favouring the BJP?
      one section of media bat for BJP and another bats for Indi Alliance
      If one is called Godi media, then the later can be called Kindi media or Thukade thukade media.
      each and every media has their own agenda and political party likeness....

  • @akashagarwal5183
    @akashagarwal5183 3 місяці тому +7

    Interview dr. Ramchandra Guha on these election results..

    • @swastik1nm
      @swastik1nm 3 місяці тому

      Oh please i want this

  • @anilevarghese
    @anilevarghese 3 місяці тому +6

    Are these parties interested in the real issues?
    Just power hungry?

  • @khumiburton3211
    @khumiburton3211 3 місяці тому +3

    Manipur Manipur Manipur 🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐 😢😢😢

  • @giridhark9889
    @giridhark9889 3 місяці тому +2

    Is Mohan Bhagwat or RSS speaking from the heart or is it just a ploy to regain Manipur and the rest of India from the Congress party? Also isn't the RSS's goal of making India as a Hindu Rashtra responsible for all this mess in India? RSS says it's a cultural organization but its goal is always political establishment of the BJP and its allies. I remember Ram Madhav of RSS going to NE and doing some work there. There after BJP rose to power in NE States. Arambai Tengol also is a cultural organization in Manipur but we know how big a role it played in Manipur violence. Thus,RSS is an organization with political motives in the garb of a cultural organization. Their aim is establishment of Hindu Rashtra.
    Will RSS give up its goal of making India a Hindu Rashtra and support Secularism? As long as RSS supports Hindu Rashtra concept of Golwalkar it is still active for communal politics in India.

  • @scifai8024
    @scifai8024 3 місяці тому

    Great conversation between Mr. Karan Thapar and Mr. Pavan Verma 🎉

  • @vinaygupta5831
    @vinaygupta5831 3 місяці тому +3

    To my mind RSS itself is to be blamed to allow too much rope to ' One Person' equating himself to be the Country ; Vishwaguru, Non- biological, Indestructible( Avinaashi)??And what not ...!

    • @tanmayjoshi4127
      @tanmayjoshi4127 3 місяці тому

      They are just doing double play. To assert themselves over BJP. They are very happy with what BJP is doing

  • @mittemari
    @mittemari 3 місяці тому +16

    Why do you all think that the Indian citizens are fools. Is that way all politicians think mr Pavan Verma? You can extoll the virtues of RSS all you want but we the citizens know that this is a power struggle amongst the biggest parivarvaad sanstha and they aint fooling anyone. The moment one became weeker the other one who was feeling oppressed speaks out. That says a lot about the character and moral strength of RSS. They can only confront the weak and never has the guts to take on the powerful. Thats because they just dont have the moral authority as they have enjoyed the fruits of power that Modi delivered. Now seizing the opportunity they have come out of closet.
    RSS always speaks with forked tongue. This is a purely internal fued and there is no love for either the Indian citizens or the general masses. Infact they are particularly in awe with the way the muslims and Dalits have endured the atrocities of the lumpen elements of RSS and BJP. They have done it with dignity and answered spectacularly at the hustings. This has infuriated the RSS as they would have been happy if the Muslims and Dalits had reacted violently which would have jave given them enough pretext to unleash violence with state power in these sections. Witness the ethnic violence of Manipur and thats a clear exmaple of how the RSS and BJP have left it fester as the Kuki-Zo has reacted violently against the Mieties backed by RSS. Let RSS come out in open about their relationships with Aramabai Tenggol. Mr Pavan Verma are you also afraid to say the truth?

    • @ramakumarnambiar7010
      @ramakumarnambiar7010 3 місяці тому +3

      👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 Couldn’t put it any better @mittemari.

    • @saisha8917
      @saisha8917 3 місяці тому

      Well said bjp is born from rss sanghis have always backed up bjp no way are they actually concerned about people of India and our constitution it's just that they can't digest the fact that people especially minorities and Dalits and normal sane people of this country united to save their rights and constitution they wanted violence so that they could sell their hindutva ideology futher but unfortunately they failed in this and modi was brought to his knees without even a majority vote all this is showoff and coverup thing nothing else woh hota hai jab ghar ka baacha shararat kare aur koi complaint le ke ajaye to Ghar Wale apne hi bacche ko chata laga ke mamla Rafa dafa karte hai wahi hal hai

    • @veenacrasto9259
      @veenacrasto9259 3 місяці тому +1

      Very well spelt out.

    • @mirzagsabur2516
      @mirzagsabur2516 3 місяці тому +1

      RSS and BJP are two sides of the same coin. There is no reason to trust either. Mohan Bhagat has smelt the change of wind and repositioned himself quicker than Modi. It's just a part of firefighting. RSS and BJP will dump Modi if their first game plan didn't work out. People of India should stay vigilant and stay the course which made it a great country. Otherwise there will be few more Adani but 100s of millions will languish in poverty.

    • @mittemari
      @mittemari 3 місяці тому +1

      To see the duplicity of RSS and so called Mohan Bhagwats sermons on social discord witness the event in the last week. A person who sat on dharna to ask for.relase of murderer of Graham Steines and his two minor kids was made CM of Odisha. Why is Bhagwat silent is he fine with this grapevine is that his choosing.
      During Bakrid and run up to the festival there has been disturbances from the Hindutva Lumpen elements the Frankenstein as Mr Pavan Verma puts it where as I call them states militia / mercenaries in MP, Telengana and Odisha. Bulldozer justice was meated out in MP oj the pretext of suspecting cow slaughter or storing beef in refrigerator cue Akhlaqs lynching. Where is mr Bhagwat and his sermons now.
      Finally the LG of Delhi who has a personal beef with Arundhati Roy has rakes up a 13 yr old case and sanctioned her prosecution/persecution for a speech she allegedly made under the dreaded UAPA. Will mr Mohan Bhagwat speak for the weak in all these cases. No never because he just doesn't have the moral courage. That's RSS and it's so called leader and his sermons. Don't be fooled it's a internal power struggle and not any love for the country or it's battered citizens. Shameless people and mR Pavan verma if you cannot speak truth then don't. Shame on you as well.

  • @knaizawlrealestate1114
    @knaizawlrealestate1114 3 місяці тому

    Thank you for your hard work sir, i salute you, you are a real Indian, i love India but the way it go it enrange me to fight to death

  • @muthuswamythirumurthy2340
    @muthuswamythirumurthy2340 3 місяці тому +2

    Wonder such a comment would have been forthcoming from Nagpur if BJP would have got majority seats.A leader must have a vision.I would believe the group if they had insisted on a course correction around 5 yrs ago..Suddenly everyone has become brothers n sisters..Personally I feel underestimated...

  • @audfrknaveen2256
    @audfrknaveen2256 3 місяці тому +1

    RSS is the basic breading ground for people like modi

  • @najeerbehna221
    @najeerbehna221 3 місяці тому +1

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @alokjaimen8833
    @alokjaimen8833 3 місяці тому +2

    What Osama was for U. S. and allies, Bhindrawale for Indira Gandhi ( their created and nurtured menace mongers ).
    Modi ji is for RSS - their educated and nurtured gentleman, who has gone out of their hands.
    Sorry Mr. Bhagwat - you woke very late.

  • @celsapinto2338
    @celsapinto2338 28 днів тому

    Verma over here you are right.

  • @mitalfuria6212
    @mitalfuria6212 3 місяці тому +4

    Brilliant journalism 👏🏼

  • @cyrilabraham1776
    @cyrilabraham1776 3 місяці тому +5

    Modi and his government/party have brought India down to the most grotesque level of comical irrelevance. And Indians, who scramble to other countries for survival/decent livelihood bear the brunt of the shameful conduct of these goons in power.

  • @ashwinimehta
    @ashwinimehta 3 місяці тому +3

    And today a minister from MP has the audacity to say he won't serve Yadav s and Muslims as they didn't vote fir him!! How does he know? And how dare he whe. He was elected to serve the people.. not who he chooses to.. outrageous

  • @JoeDsouza-s4g
    @JoeDsouza-s4g 3 місяці тому +1

    Super

  • @vinaybhatnagar4998
    @vinaybhatnagar4998 3 місяці тому

    I agree with the thread of this interview. Well done..

  • @ritabiswal9623
    @ritabiswal9623 3 місяці тому

    Pawanji is very correct Karanji. And your questions Karanji, are the ones asked by all simple people of this country, ie., people who are not intellectuals but are living a difficult life

  • @kumarnarayana5105
    @kumarnarayana5105 3 місяці тому +5

    "डरा हुआ नागरिक एक नपुंसक समाज पैदा करता है" !

  • @rajmundary1401
    @rajmundary1401 3 місяці тому

    With the ongoing report about Naidu’s request as NDA partners it looks like ND Modi care less & is bulldozing Naidu & Nitish. Despite in the past 10 years the world has witnessed how the corrupt Speaker Birla has violated the constitutional post & dismissed MP & passed Bills without any discussion in Parliament. If Naidu & Nitish play low for any bribe they will face consequences of their own MP crossing to BJP & adding the needed number of 273 & TDP, JDU will be finished forever - God Save India / Bharat.

  • @PadmanabhanAnanth
    @PadmanabhanAnanth 3 місяці тому

    Par excellence (despite the audio issues).

  • @bipenderjindal8388
    @bipenderjindal8388 3 місяці тому

    Excellent discussion. Please do another show by bringing patriotic muslims and to list their efforts to earn the trust and respect of this nation and to foil the efforts of terrorists. Thank you.

  • @humptydumpty4773
    @humptydumpty4773 3 місяці тому +1

    No Prime Minister worth the salt would have ever done nor would do in the future , what Modi did.

    • @chenithungjami140
      @chenithungjami140 3 місяці тому

      Please elaborate ??.. I wonder what Modi did for the country.. Changing names of government schemes, places,establishments etc etc.. ??? What else??

  • @SivaPothuluru
    @SivaPothuluru 3 місяці тому

    There is no problem with India's future as long as we follow Sanathana Dharma. Even today, Hindus can not live in Muslim majority areas. The whole world is worried about Islamic violence. Thanks to our liberal life. Every minority is more than safe in India.

  • @sitaramaraonandamuri4241
    @sitaramaraonandamuri4241 3 місяці тому +1

    Bhagawat should have cautioned Yogi also for his bulldozer raj and Muslim hatred actions along with Modi. He is the biggest culprit in the this matter

  • @stanalvares6888
    @stanalvares6888 3 місяці тому

    The apology was just a case of grandfather shedding crocodile PR tears on behalf of his grandchildren to give the public a 'feel good factor' when all know that his strategy has flopped.

  • @jaisonkunnel8569
    @jaisonkunnel8569 3 місяці тому

    Fabulous

  • @Bhumish_LK
    @Bhumish_LK 3 місяці тому +4

    Mr. Pavan Varma is talking through his hat.
    He knows nothing about the prevailing dynamics between RSS and Narendra Modi as RSS is already beholden to Modi.

    • @prakashpimparkar489
      @prakashpimparkar489 3 місяці тому

      Ostriches

    • @prakashpimparkar489
      @prakashpimparkar489 3 місяці тому +2

      What about Bhagwat
      He retracted?
      If Headon RSS can not dare to or wish to speak about their own ordinary swayamsevak
      How will they dare to speak to oppressors

    • @PriyaK-cu1fz
      @PriyaK-cu1fz 3 місяці тому

      Correct bhumish. It would be too rich of RSS to not be licking boots of modi 😂😂

    • @Bhumish_LK
      @Bhumish_LK 3 місяці тому

      @@prakashpimparkar489 Mohan Bhagwat is a mediocre man. He isn't as impactful as his predecessors Rajendra Singh and Madhukar Dattatreya Deoras were.
      He should have spoken long time ago. His recent comments are duplicitous as RSS as an organisation is always prone to.

  • @madhubalasharma2822
    @madhubalasharma2822 3 місяці тому +1

    Whenever BJP is in trouble,Mr.Bhagwat suddenly appears on the screen with some solution.They are one not two.We support coalition government in centre as well as states.

  • @ruthmangalwadi
    @ruthmangalwadi 3 місяці тому +1

    Karan I am so proud of your clarity and courage.
    But PLEASE speak up for Christians in UP, Odisha and Chhatisgarh being tormented every single day. We have documentation of these horrible happenings where Christians are being falsely accused and put in jail. Thankfully this is not happening to the Muslims as yet. Christians remain a quiet minority - but absolutely ignored by the Press and the administration who side with the perpetrators.

    • @ashishalexander8040
      @ashishalexander8040 3 місяці тому +1

      Innocent people are falsely accused and are unfairly treated by the administration. This should worry everyone who is concerned about democracy in India.

  • @sudhirpillai3108
    @sudhirpillai3108 3 місяці тому +1

    HAAAAAAA.... IT TOOK TEN YEARS AND A DIMINISHED MANDATE TO REALISE .....THIS..

  • @vivekra
    @vivekra 3 місяці тому +1

    How naive to believe RSS is concerned about lumpen elements. Then they would have sent a message to Bajrang Dal not BJP. This seems to be a power struggle between Bhagwat and Modi and Bhagwat does not stand a chance unless he manages to launch a rival political party. Modi has huge money power due to the Gujarati lobby.

  • @monicabanerjee71
    @monicabanerjee71 3 місяці тому

    Questions were more pointed and sharp than the answers. Mr Verma needed to prepare better

  • @jamesdavis9438
    @jamesdavis9438 3 місяці тому +1

    Mr. Bhagwat is too late!

  • @sourabasu6122
    @sourabasu6122 3 місяці тому

    Do you think if BJP secured absolute majority, Mr Mohan Bhagwat would have uttered the similar words as he has said now.

  • @vinayakrao2881
    @vinayakrao2881 3 місяці тому

    Hope the opposition also follows!

  • @jimmybindra
    @jimmybindra 3 місяці тому +1

    very well put & understood ..it's pretty clear, RSS isn't happy as the least they would like to see India broken in the name of religion. Of course they want a kind of soft Hindu supremacy in India as being the majority population, but surely they aren't happy how Modi's & Modi's BJP is trying things upside down just to reap PM & Power benefits. It's a very interesting case study how things have panned out. I being from a Minority community, see this very interesting & trust me 'am not in Khatre mein' as we never have been -- LOL

  • @SANJAYKUMAR-jb1gt
    @SANJAYKUMAR-jb1gt 3 місяці тому

    👌👌

  • @tinbemhaokip6272
    @tinbemhaokip6272 3 місяці тому

    God bless karan

  • @ansuman2007
    @ansuman2007 3 місяці тому

    I was of the opinion that Pawan verma has a good understanding of RSS designs and BJP implementing the same. No more....RSS is not chastising Modi he is only calibrating the RSS position which remains unchanged

  • @puredistraction415
    @puredistraction415 3 місяці тому +6

    RSS Chief seems like a good sober man. Modi has been a terrible influence on India, he brings out the worst in us.

  • @thomasthomasphilp4393
    @thomasthomasphilp4393 3 місяці тому +2

    Our Syrian Christian community proudly says we are Hindu by culture and Christian by faith. For me, a Hindu from Kerala is nearer to me than a White Christian from Europe. My dad's first cousin has been in RSS Kerala since 18. This organization's goddess is Bharat. There are even atheist RSS workers. India can only develop if we all move together with the aspiration for a developed Bharat. Yes of course,. Islamism is a threat to any democracy, be it the West or India. It has to be addressed. Yes, Christian missionary activity has to be cut off. I find it morally incorrect to convert Non-Christians by exploiting poverty. Faith has to stem from your heart!

  • @jhabadrinamemjmkkkok6362
    @jhabadrinamemjmkkkok6362 3 місяці тому

    Very sad that Modi is not loosing.But still you are employed so thanks to Modi.

  • @vjaysan
    @vjaysan 3 місяці тому

    Given the progress India has made the last decade, arrogance seems like a good thing as it has delivered an upwards trajectory to her prosperity and development. Prior to that it has only been a lot of hot air and poverty. Get real India, PM Modi has opened the gates to a Ten Trillion economy, a critical mass for India's spread of wealth.

  • @maryjemyfreeman7639
    @maryjemyfreeman7639 3 місяці тому

    PM the broken💔 vessel of varanasi, the common man of hindi patti, more down to earth than the polished and sauv intellectuals

  • @sultanshaikh9742
    @sultanshaikh9742 3 місяці тому +1

    Modiji's Politics is of Hindutava and against Muslims is since he has become the Priminister. Why after this politics did not play well, RSS has come out to criticise this policy ?

  • @viswaghosh1
    @viswaghosh1 3 місяці тому

    If RSS remains true to Golwalkar's policies, then RSS will soon jettison Mohan Bhagwat.

  • @prosenjitsengupta3743
    @prosenjitsengupta3743 3 місяці тому

    Please request Mr. Pawan Verma to use earbuds for better audibility.

  • @sultanshaikh9742
    @sultanshaikh9742 3 місяці тому +1

    RSS Cadres didn't help BJP during this election . Wich shows that there were some differences between them. Does these differences are due to the Modiji 's more closeness with big industry and avoiding RSS ?

  • @vijaykrishnaseth6441
    @vijaykrishnaseth6441 3 місяці тому +1

    Modi is the creation of RSS. It ever and ever stood with Modi for last 20 odd year. Bhagwat is only diplomatically cover for Modi. Both are in deeper league with each other. Shri Bhagwat even now is in total support of Modi. RSS today controld each and every organ of entire administrative machinary. So please do not give any different colors.

  • @satishkumarl4999
    @satishkumarl4999 3 місяці тому

    Just because PM modi has occupied every space unlike other PM 's in the past he looks like dominating everything,it is also because he is involved personally in every major projects of development he is always seen,moreover he has a 10 hr lead in working hours over others he has extra time to be present everywhere for media to capture.

  • @kirmaniamjad9300
    @kirmaniamjad9300 3 місяці тому +2

    MODI SHAH BJP KHATAM

  • @SadiquaParvin-u2r
    @SadiquaParvin-u2r 3 місяці тому

    I had respect for this PV but RSS man by calling it a cultural organisation. It’s more political than all our political parties put together. They love power without accountability and wealth without accounts and members without membership. For both Modi & RSS, like any secretive organisation nobody is indispensable.

  • @enjaydad
    @enjaydad 3 місяці тому +2

    Disagree with Pavan Varma that Modi is the most popular leader as he has been dumped by the masses. Rahul Gandhi has emerged as the most popular in UP polls

    • @sarbanimitra8145
      @sarbanimitra8145 3 місяці тому

      So congress got 99 seats?😂

    • @enjaydad
      @enjaydad 3 місяці тому +1

      @@sarbanimitra8145 Popularity vote in UP Modi 32% Rahul 36% .
      BJP accomplices ECI and Tons of money and rigging by officials.
      Congress's accounts frozen,,,. no official machinery cooperating,...not being bank rolled
      Most importantly Harvard Educated and carries the masses with love , not hate.
      Hope you appreciate these facts too

  • @h79guf
    @h79guf 3 місяці тому +1

    Nitish and Nadu waiting for BJP to act against the duo first > BJP challengers waiting for RSS for the nudge > RSS leaders can’t do more than a murmur as the duo might have files on them 😂

  • @ahamedchowdhury6106
    @ahamedchowdhury6106 3 місяці тому

    @0.16 sec, The dog barks when he says one-man rule on BJP... even dogs can smell the dictator hahaha

  • @criterion53
    @criterion53 3 місяці тому

    Was bhagwat sleeping for so long. His sudden concern for Manipur at this stage indicates his reaction to the people's mandate giving modi only 240 seats.

  • @brksk4309
    @brksk4309 3 місяці тому +1

    Why RSS waited so long to plug modi from farting. They should haved nipped it in the bud. But they are cribbing now when the sound has gone out of control.😢

  • @yeshwanthreginald4233
    @yeshwanthreginald4233 3 місяці тому +1

    If rss is so serious of bjp functioning why they are not addressing Modi and shah directly. Rss ego amd super ego of Modi is now clashing they are the face of same coin. Both are fascist and not good for democratic India.

  • @sohailstone
    @sohailstone 3 місяці тому

    Mohan Bhagat wants to give a message that Modi is not the head of Party 🙏🏼

  • @Oceansta
    @Oceansta 3 місяці тому

    Aahhh the old good cop-bad cop routine. oldest trick in the book.

  • @pmcm5536
    @pmcm5536 3 місяці тому

    How much clout RSS has on BJP needs to be seen???? My impression is absolutely NIL????

  • @jayaseelansubbaiah6509
    @jayaseelansubbaiah6509 3 місяці тому +1

    👌👌👌👌👌👍👍👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

  • @celestialspartan7977
    @celestialspartan7977 3 місяці тому

    You can talk till your tongues drop to the floor and also wipe it ....Modi will remain at helm of affairs.

  • @mariavaz9054
    @mariavaz9054 3 місяці тому

    Kama pays.congress jindabad Jai hind.

  • @royrand8521
    @royrand8521 3 місяці тому

    Too little, maybe too late for Mohan Bhagwat to even attempt a CYA operation.

  • @kasturiswami784
    @kasturiswami784 3 місяці тому +1

    Rss can not escape responsibility of encouraging this egoistic monster by calling them lumpen elements. Rss is full of they. Are they not dreaming of Hindu rajya. Now Modi has become too big for them to tame,they are saying this. The mother organisation is at fault by narrating false history. Rss should be banned but can we eradicate people's ideas?

    • @shriharikulkarni2305
      @shriharikulkarni2305 3 місяці тому

      Which false history ?
      If true history is being told to hindus there might me daily riots. Such is oppression of islamic invaders

  • @patrioticindian57
    @patrioticindian57 3 місяці тому

    Bhagwat je comes across as a learned man who also knows other religions and its basic tenents while remaining a steadfast hindu.. He is talking like a statesman while politicians are speaking like professors of whatsapp university and demagogic and illogical.

  • @manojitbose5570
    @manojitbose5570 3 місяці тому

    I was listening to this interview hoping to educate myself on the recent electoral developments. But disappointing to see how cleverly half truths and one sided views are being peddled. Both, by this journalist and his guest who I held in high respect.

  • @sklux6147
    @sklux6147 3 місяці тому

    Mr Bhagwat, addressing the nation? Why media is discussing the fallouts of his speech?
    He is RSS chief. What is his legitimacy and authority to address the nation? How does he obtain the power and recognition?
    Is the ceremonial critique about the government, leadership/ achievements, election behaviours etc just a facade? Advices and quoting from the scriptures of great wisdom and their values in high sounding Sanskrit from the high podium are merely part of annual serman coming from the self appointed, self styled moral High Priest. Or not?
    What such an exercise, undertaken by the Mother Organisation, is meant to achieve? It gives an impression that it is - Less About The Message and More About Image. Enhancing and consolidating the image as the all powerful institution that has succeeded in becoming the defacto controller and governor of the country. Shadow Power at play. Accept or not.
    This ceremony sends a deceptive assessment to mislead the citizens. The goal is to place the Mother Organisation firmly on a lofty pedestal as an all superior in terms of wisdom, credibility, patriotic (nationalist) attributes, empowered and authentic body to oversee, guide and validate the government and the polity of the country. Clearly this is an extra constitutional projection of authority over the affairs of democracy. How far it is legitimate is questionable.
    Any organisation/ institution/ association etc bodies are free to operate in democracy. They may assume certain rights and responsibilities for themselves as provided and allowed in the Constitution.
    It matters when any one organisation by virtue of being in a position where it's views, assessments and decisions may have profound impact on the government. In doing so it has substantial influence over the kind of governance delivered to the people.
    If that is the case then does it have any accountability on the outcomes and implications vis -a- vis the Constitution of the country? Whether that matches with the expectations & aspirations of the citizens and whether conforms with the Constitution?
    If such an organisation has allowed a bad / incompetent leadership to take charge of the government with huge majority then who bears the responsibility for the consequences of violation of people's trust, misrule, violation of constitution, oppression of dissent, finish off of the political opposition, capture the mainstream media, control the democratic institutions like ECI, Lokpal, Human Rights Authority, Women's Commission etc, influence education system and it's institutions through policies and appointment processes?
    RSS seem to have taken upon themselves to critique their own party/govt and the polity of the country in public. What was the compulsion?
    Why RSS has allowed incompetency, corruption and blackmailing to persist to the third term without seeking to change the leadership for the betterment of the country? Political success above ideological preferences seem to have taken precedence. How can the future of the nation be entrusted to such self-interest groups?
    Can India realise the aspirations set out in our Democratic Constitution in equal, free and inclusive manner? Who will answer and who will ensure?

  • @jyotibhalerao6178
    @jyotibhalerao6178 3 місяці тому +3

    The rule is not of one man but two men Modi and Amit Shah.

  • @victoriajohn1024
    @victoriajohn1024 3 місяці тому

    RSS people should understand that we are temporarily living on this Earth so no need to discuss about Religion and there is nothing belongs to us, because God created everything and every human being so no need fighting Hindu and Muslims. We all know that our lives are very short so because kind and love one another unconditional. Don't hurt anyone.

  • @rakp4215
    @rakp4215 3 місяці тому

    All such interviews hardly matter to the arrogant Modi.
    Unfortunately, Honourable President of India is a rubber stamp otherwise things would have been quite different.
    Now the only hope lies with the Supreme Court or say the Chief Justice of India.(Mr Chadrachud).
    His affirmative action will make him "अमर" and our next-generation will remember him as a Saviour of this Nation.

  • @vijendernathaniel2488
    @vijendernathaniel2488 3 місяці тому

    RSS are Responsible for Shree Narendra Modiji's terms as Chief Minister of Gujarat and Prime Minister of India 🇮🇳.
    Unfortunately Modiji was a below average Chief Minister of Gujarat in February 2002.
    Modiji Overtook Shree Lal Kishan Advaniji as Prime Minister of India 🇮🇳 in 2014 which was totally Disastrous Period .
    Shree Lal Kishan Advaniji was a Great Statesman and Leader compared to Shree Narendra Modiji who was lacking Exposure on National Economic Level & National Integration in Unity and Diversity and living in Peace and Harmony.

  • @roshanlal1740
    @roshanlal1740 3 місяці тому

    RSS doesn’t mean what they say.

  • @adamsinghlealadhar6234
    @adamsinghlealadhar6234 3 місяці тому

    To be very honest RSS itself is feeling unsafe now from the fear of Modi and Shah. Nadda has already made it abundantly clear BJP does not need RSS any more. Look at it this way. RSS is a dogma creating agency but they do not have the power to execute or enforce its agenda in real terms in agencies, such as courts or institutions such as Universities and other similar organizations. However, BJP has all such means of enforcement as we have seen in decisions made by courts and how they deal with protests at Universities and against their agenda such as the farm laws and the CAA, perhaps others areas as well. So given this why would BJP want to have another head ache on its hands such as RSS. It would be a better idea to take over RSS and have a seamless transfer of power as head of RSS with a PM once the PM retires. Modi would be a good start where the incoming PM will be under the direct control of the RSS head. This the reason whey the RSS is so agitated as they can see the writing written on the wall of their death knell approaching.