FREE AI Image Generator BEATS Midjourney + FLUX: Full Test + Prompt Battle

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 120

  • @sachindatt4045
    @sachindatt4045 Місяць тому +48

    The real test of any ai image generator should be consistent characters. While single image renderings are good test but ultimate test is only character consistency and that should define the value of any ainimage generator because that leads to the ultimate use of any visual medium as it's ability to be used in storytelling. So please help us know which one is best for creating consistent characters.

    • @thibaudherbert3144
      @thibaudherbert3144 Місяць тому +2

      simple it's flux since you can create loras.

    • @usmansiraj-g8n
      @usmansiraj-g8n Місяць тому

      ​@@thibaudherbert3144even if you use lora it's not 💯% so yeha we need an ai which can produce consistent character , poses and different expression

    • @Jebu911
      @Jebu911 Місяць тому +1

      Yeah its flux and considering flux can make videos out of still pictures too its more flexible than lets say midjourney even tho lot of people seem to like the style mj puts out for its pictures. MJ used to be the best but nowdays people want to have more so id say flux is the new king

    • @carlosnumbertwo
      @carlosnumbertwo Місяць тому

      Agreed.

    • @ToonTailsStudio-bn1rm
      @ToonTailsStudio-bn1rm 11 днів тому

      Completely agree. So far Flux is the only one doing this. I have have had some success with custom GPTs that I have trained on character sheets and detailed instructions but there are still big continuity errors and DALL-E’s art styles are way too limited. I would like to see more of these platforms focusing on consistent characters

  • @phadrus
    @phadrus Місяць тому +11

    I think you have to run each prompt 3 times and then look at the avg for each platform. You never know when one platform will give you a stinker of an image. Doesn’t mean the platform is more or less preferred. I think you’d have a more accurate assessment.

  • @analoressallano5613
    @analoressallano5613 Місяць тому +1

    "Wow, Recraft Version 3 really seems like a game-changer in the AI art space! The ability to handle detailed prompts, realistic styles, and even create SVG designs makes it a powerful tool for artists and designers alike. I love how you tested it against other AI generators, especially with famous figures and dynamic action scenes. Great breakdown and insights, can't wait to see how this tool evolves!"

  • @renascienza.bazarclub
    @renascienza.bazarclub 13 днів тому +3

    Impressed by Redraft, a lot. Every shoot feels more realistic. In Midourney best model, the skin ever looks like plastic to me.

  • @MarinaArrudaa
    @MarinaArrudaa Місяць тому +1

    Thank you so much for another very useful video. It’s wonderful to hear your opinion too; it’s very valuable. I loved how you developed this lesson. I’m so grateful for everything! I’m already part of your academy and newsletter.
    Loving this more elegant, black setup with your new hair!

  • @Marrro
    @Marrro Місяць тому +11

    I think the most important feature of Recraft is that it can generate vector images or vectorize loaded or created images and download them as SVG....

    • @Elwaves2925
      @Elwaves2925 Місяць тому +2

      Indeed. I tried photorealism last night and wasn't impressed at all. Being able to generate and save logos, or whatever, in SVG without the need to trace an image is a big time saver. That's what I'll use it for.

  • @marcduchamp5512
    @marcduchamp5512 13 днів тому

    Firstable where do you access the Recraft?

  • @RusulColee
    @RusulColee Місяць тому +38

    aitutorialmaker AI fixes this (AI driven Tutorials). AI art model beats Midjourney.

  • @Another-Layer
    @Another-Layer Місяць тому

    Great comparison test. I don’t think it’s about which one is better but more about the image style of the output from the same prompt. I like them all but are different. Thanks

  • @robertgarcia8500
    @robertgarcia8500 Місяць тому

    Great tutorial! as always ;-)
    Question: How can we make consistent characters for a children's picture book?

  • @sk1pp04
    @sk1pp04 23 дні тому

    I tested out Recraft V3 and found that it was impossible to get a character to look directly at the camera. I do like the the idea of it not generating that standard look by default, but it's disappointing that I can't specify it to do so. Even if I upload a reference image, it turns the head slightly smh. Maybe you can test things out and find a resolution to this issue.

  • @Randomica
    @Randomica Місяць тому

    is there option how to create consistence figure or character based on one image

  • @apatsa_basiteni
    @apatsa_basiteni Місяць тому +15

    Why is ideogram not among the comparison models? It's up there among the very best.

    • @Moctop
      @Moctop Місяць тому +3

      He checked the list and used the top 3. Ideogram was 4th.

  • @Moukrea
    @Moukrea Місяць тому +1

    Funny how Scarlet Johansson in Wonder Woman suit makes the suit looks like a Marvel one instead of a DC comics one for Midjourney (looking more like the suit of Captain Marvel than the one of Wonder Woman), the dataset of Midjourney influences that to the point it's no longer Wonder Woman at all (but got Scarlet Johansson almost right though...) guess Black Window (Johansson) is really tied to Marvel in their dataset.
    Other than that, feel like models generally struggle real hard with freckles and imperfections

  • @saundrasaumay9767
    @saundrasaumay9767 Місяць тому

    Thank you, I am going to check out Recraft!

  • @TorQueMoD
    @TorQueMoD Місяць тому +1

    I'd argue that Recraft did what you asked because you said the Sea Horse should be on the left of her, not the left of the screen. All 3 of the images show the character basically facing the sea horse, however, in Mid journey her right shoulder is more forward, but in the Recraft and Flux images her left shoulder is more forward. I'd give it to Flux, Recraft and then Midjourney, especially since Midjourney didn't really draw a sea horse.

  • @Treverlorn
    @Treverlorn Місяць тому

    A couple of months ago you did a video with a title that said Midjourney was "way too censored". Have you run into any censorship issues with Recraft?

  • @frankfurthe6282
    @frankfurthe6282 Місяць тому

    this is the best your hair has looked. thanks for the informative vid!

  • @hagardeviking9314
    @hagardeviking9314 Місяць тому

    Is there already a Ai app where i can import/feed the app with a collection of only one and the same full 3D figure/model, so after that I can use it in any form and poses?!

  • @thomalex8932
    @thomalex8932 Місяць тому

    Did you use the new version of Flux?

  • @Sayshasdad
    @Sayshasdad 16 днів тому

    A great and helpful analysis

  • @henridusasca8077
    @henridusasca8077 29 днів тому

    And in comparaison with Leonardo ?

  • @heartshinemusic
    @heartshinemusic Місяць тому

    What these comparison leaderboards forget to incorporate is how much control you can have over the outcome in the sense of creating consistent characters and various in-painting features. Especially for storytellers and as a pre-production for video generation, that is very important. I have a particular character created in MJ, but it's hard (or impossible) to re-create or adjust that character on other platforms.

  • @SystemsPlanet
    @SystemsPlanet Місяць тому

    Why can't I clip your latest video to share it?

  • @jViP70
    @jViP70 Місяць тому

    Thank you for your video, it was, as always, interesting! :) I looked at your figma and it seems that you put the same prompt for the fluffy animal as in the car prompt... ;)

  • @suzannecarter445
    @suzannecarter445 Місяць тому +2

    I've tried every one of the image generators and for photorealistic faces, nothing compared to CgDream. Now if I could just get Midjourney to accept these incredible images as a character reference I'd be on cloud 9.

  • @CarlosRodela
    @CarlosRodela Місяць тому +3

    ideogram missing from the testing? easily the best rn (imo)

    • @CarlosRodela
      @CarlosRodela Місяць тому

      maybe recraft vs ideogram video is in order

    • @turkeybuttsammich
      @turkeybuttsammich Місяць тому

      I tried ideogram with your prompt and was blown away. I used "Ornate signage in the spirit of a pirate ship that says "I am the master of my fate and the captain of my soul." It was perfect -- flawless!

    • @apatsa_basiteni
      @apatsa_basiteni Місяць тому

      For real.

    • @goliathonscave9834
      @goliathonscave9834 Місяць тому

      He discussed the top 3 rated. Ideogram is 4th so it is only "easily the best" by your own bias.

    • @CarlosRodela
      @CarlosRodela Місяць тому

      @@goliathonscave9834 ya i did say imo heh but that said a lot of us in the ai community are 2nd guessing the rankings..youll see some vids coming out discussing that. but either way, dig the breakdown of these 3

  • @NoFaithNoPain
    @NoFaithNoPain Місяць тому

    Loving the Fash-cut. But the moustache needs to be a little narrower :D

  • @simon_der_xxl_tomapfel9305
    @simon_der_xxl_tomapfel9305 Місяць тому +1

    The best image generator is flux 1.1 for real photorealism and midjourney is the best for consistent character

  • @rewindchroniclessforgenz
    @rewindchroniclessforgenz Місяць тому

    Bruh this AI technology is hitting different, fr fr it's giving main character energy and making other models look straight mid, no cap!🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @intermedia1906
    @intermedia1906 29 днів тому

    It's difficult to compare different models with a single image or a single prompt, because the optimum wording for one model is not always the best for another. Plus some models have parameters the others don't have that can improve a specific result.

  • @TheFeedRocket
    @TheFeedRocket Місяць тому +3

    I think you will agree, MidJourney is clearly the best for pure artistic style, if you want to create art, MidJourney is the leader. Like I have said before I really hope MidJourney never tries to be like the others. I have no connection to MidJourney but nothing even comes close to the aesthetics and artist stylized outputs you can get. Now MidJourney is not even close when it comes to real life normal photos, or cartoons, text, etc... MidJourney is like an artist, more creative, more ways to be abstract, with unlimited diverse styles you can generate over many models. But I will certainly add recraft to my growing toolkit.
    Art and style MidJourney is the leader. but poor on text and realism or normal photos.
    Text and realism 1. Ideogram, 2. Flux 1.1 pro, 3. FreePik, now looking at Recraft.
    others I use much less lately Dell-E, and Leonardo

  • @AllGames-InternationalGamers
    @AllGames-InternationalGamers 15 днів тому

    Good video. Thx 🎉

  • @gert-janvs5708
    @gert-janvs5708 13 днів тому

    The woman with the colourful seahorse, from her point of view because of the seahorse being slightly further away (as for being out of focus a little), the seahorse is actually and literally ¨to the left of her¨. If the seahorse should have been on the left side of the picture, next to her, that would need other wording. Otherwise I like the video very much!

  • @earncrypto24-ud3ne
    @earncrypto24-ud3ne Місяць тому

    where is the consistent character feature? how it beats midjourney ??

  • @arimcbrown
    @arimcbrown Місяць тому +1

    I believe Scarlett Johansson might not be a good example, after OpenAI included her voice, they got sued. So I can imagine certain projects being wary of her in particular.

  • @sagarsriva
    @sagarsriva Місяць тому

    great video, thanks

  • @benzyn
    @benzyn Місяць тому

    Recraft has many models from which you can create different styles. You need to do a "real" comparison though with these different models in order to make a true comparison!

  • @ianmatthews9219
    @ianmatthews9219 Місяць тому

    Recraft has a new text mode for long text witch is not just a normal prompt...

  • @ian2593
    @ian2593 Місяць тому

    You said that the sea horse should be to '...her left.' It was to our right but to her left.

  • @Jebu911
    @Jebu911 Місяць тому

    Id give a big minus points for MJ on that scarlet johansson because shes clearly not wearing the prompt you asked for. Id say flux wins that round just for costume accuracy and its the most cinematic anyway.

  • @bonce8022
    @bonce8022 Місяць тому

    It is quite unfair to compare these products using them as is, with default out of box settings. Midjourney has lot of finetuning keys like sref, personalization, chaos, stylize and what not. Same applies to Flux Dev model, it is quite versatile, though also limited in many ways (camera controls, artistic styles, stereotype characters, etc.), but you can greatly expand it's potential with custom workflows and Loras.

  • @davidhalliday7776
    @davidhalliday7776 16 днів тому +1

    Recraft is much more realistic. Midjourny creates images that are very much AI. The image of the Asian person in a vest was a great example. It was also the only one that actually had a vest on.

  • @kroanosm617
    @kroanosm617 Місяць тому

    I think some of these models avoid exact replicas of celebrities to avoid lawsuits.

  • @amicuscrypto1942
    @amicuscrypto1942 Місяць тому

    nice new hair style

  • @RadicalModeration
    @RadicalModeration Місяць тому +6

    TBH, I liked the Midjourny images in most comparisons.

    • @DivinityInTheHouse
      @DivinityInTheHouse Місяць тому

      tell me one, that accepts image references, upscale with variations, variations in specific areas, character ref, using an image as a complete reference, and more.​@detective2221

    • @ygdamien826
      @ygdamien826 Місяць тому +1

      @detective2221like what

    • @milo-qh7cv
      @milo-qh7cv Місяць тому

      cartoonish more like it

  • @adalberthoma7554
    @adalberthoma7554 Місяць тому

    its model hidden behind a paywall, trial period available
    at least sd models are freeware

  • @pafcaf
    @pafcaf 15 днів тому

    On the contrary (sorry) but the interface isn't very user friendly, and it produces some of the strangest results. Such as when prompting a simple male or female portrait they're always staring up into the sky like they're looking at a passing helicopter, or posed strangely like they're peering around a corner. Weird. Midjourney still seems like the best, now that Playground no longer has canvas and "fix faces" :(

  • @InfoRanker
    @InfoRanker Місяць тому

    Recraft doesn't let you use image references (that I know of) so it automatically loses.

  • @bloodgourd
    @bloodgourd Місяць тому +1

    Midjourney's censorship is unhinged.

  • @beanbox6724
    @beanbox6724 Місяць тому +2

    Самсону привет!

  • @danielchoritz1903
    @danielchoritz1903 Місяць тому

    0:25 the hand holding the baby looks real bad, not talking about it and scrolling fast by makes me to leave

  • @dascodraws6040
    @dascodraws6040 Місяць тому

    I have no desire to have a service for my generations. So flux is still king for me.

  • @iamdrdeath
    @iamdrdeath 11 днів тому

    Great video but there's one thing in relation to the female and the seahorse. Technically RECRAFT is the only correct image, the seahorse is to her left, as she standas the other 2 are to the left of the frame which is in fact a fail :) IMO that is!!!

  • @DJ369-Miami
    @DJ369-Miami Місяць тому

    Recraft is pretty bad at following my prompts. Ideogeam considerably better. I like the menu and canvas approach though

  • @happyraptor7986
    @happyraptor7986 Місяць тому

    Who actually even uses midjourney? Stable Diffusion XL and pony are so good

  • @bakablitz6591
    @bakablitz6591 Місяць тому

    i love these types of videos! keep it up

  • @hIIXu
    @hIIXu Місяць тому

    Clearly a MJ boi 😅

  • @marcus_ohreallyus
    @marcus_ohreallyus Місяць тому +4

    OMG...you just start messing around with it and trigger a moderation alert. Recraft can go to hell. I'm really tired of the censorship.

  • @StormlightStudiosOffical
    @StormlightStudiosOffical Місяць тому

    Recraft does the best celebrity faces ever seen at a close up to medium close-up range however it completely throws out the resemblance beyond that which is extremely annoying unfortunately

  • @szin
    @szin Місяць тому +1

    Its not really free, now is it, its limited to daily trails, not free endless.. Stop doing click bait.

  • @live--now
    @live--now Місяць тому

    Mid... what.... Never heard of her.. Does she have a great free tier and plans..?????

  • @tiberiubuta
    @tiberiubuta Місяць тому +1

    I find the midjourney images of people very unrealistic. The skin texture in particular always looks like plastic, nothing like a real person, even when within the parameters of "cinematic". They scream to me "AI generated". Nice on style, very weak on realism.

  • @Manimani-lq8tc
    @Manimani-lq8tc Місяць тому +1

    Hiii❤ watching👀.. Now

  • @TheMaindful
    @TheMaindful Місяць тому

    So Midjourney wins most but the title says it beats MJ? that's what we call clickbait.

  • @Halliday-o3c
    @Halliday-o3c 27 днів тому

    Recraft gladiator wins by default for no morphing

  • @generated.moment
    @generated.moment Місяць тому

    I found it to be garbage, for now no one will beat Midjourney in realism, and no one will beat Flux in accuracy

  • @jonmichaelgalindo
    @jonmichaelgalindo Місяць тому

    Title said "free" for a closed-source paid model. Clickbait? Isn't that a straight up lie? 🧐

  • @mikefiatx19
    @mikefiatx19 Місяць тому +2

    Video could have been made without being political but you had to throw trump into it. Well done pissing off half your followers for no reason.

    • @TPCDAZ
      @TPCDAZ Місяць тому +4

      People have different political opinions. Get over it

    • @Quix94
      @Quix94 Місяць тому +2

      Take care my sensitive little man

    • @brockhampton3078
      @brockhampton3078 Місяць тому +3

      IDK if he pissed off half of his followers, nobody else seems upset about this lol

    • @mikefiatx19
      @mikefiatx19 Місяць тому

      @@TPCDAZ Yeah, I get that. But I came here for AI and Tech info, not politics. But creators just can't do anything without making it political. It's the same reason no one watches MSM & he is bringing it to the channel for no reason.

    • @TPCDAZ
      @TPCDAZ Місяць тому +1

      @@mikefiatx19 Actually you made it political. He just chose a famous face to include, having watched the video he never once mentioned politics. Would you have been up in arms about this is it was Kamella Harris? I doubt it. SO you made it political, not everyone cares about politics enough to lose your head over. Who cares who wins, all changes again in four years anyway and the next liar can come in. Just enjoy the video and leave the politics to the politicians.

  • @badbackbatch
    @badbackbatch Місяць тому

    tried it - no matter what I did it repeatedly put glasses on my character and apparently 30 is the new 60 or vice versa - whatever, my 30 year old character looked like a retiree - POS

  • @jamesc8517
    @jamesc8517 Місяць тому

    Tested this, useless for any serious creative work. Both enhancing and compositing, even in the setting "almost identical" creates absurd results, ignoring prompts, texture and composition. How can this mess possibly be ranked ahead of Flux Pro etc?

  • @p_p
    @p_p Місяць тому

    Meh.. Cloud services😒

  • @TRex-n2z
    @TRex-n2z Місяць тому

    Why even bother doing these tests if you keep pickign Midjourney even when its giving far worse result.

  • @kevrymell6636
    @kevrymell6636 Місяць тому

    To be honest I did not like it - after half a dozen tries I did not like anything it produced

  • @I-Dophler
    @I-Dophler Місяць тому

    As young girls navigate the vibrant and often intricate landscape of their formative years, they find themselves exploring a world filled with fascination and allure. This period is marked by a blossoming curiosity about relationships and the dynamics of attraction, where they begin to discover what captivates their interest and ignites their imagination.
    In this enchanting journey, discussions about physical attributes and personal preferences can take on a playful yet meaningful tone. Young girls may find themselves drawn to the idea of attraction in a way that sparks excitement and wonder, as they learn to express their feelings and desires. This exploration is not merely superficial; it lays the groundwork for understanding deeper connections and the importance of mutual respect.
    Embracing these topics with a sense of fun and openness allows for a rich dialogue that can empower young girls. By creating a safe space for these conversations, we encourage them to explore their identities and boundaries, helping them navigate the complexities of relationships with confidence and curiosity. This thoughtful approach nurtures their self-awareness and appreciation for both themselves and others, leading to fulfilling interactions in their journey ahead.

  • @nw9353
    @nw9353 Місяць тому

    Recraft is over censored garbage. It will not let me draw a simple political cartoon. When it does draw something it is the complete opposite of what I asked it to do.

  • @I-Dophler
    @I-Dophler Місяць тому

    As older women navigate this vibrant phase of life, their connection to the natural world often deepens, particularly with the fascinating array of birds that inhabit their surroundings. Among these, the larger bird species can evoke a sense of wonder and admiration, embodying strength and beauty that resonates with many.
    Big birds, such as majestic swans, regal peacocks, and striking roosters, play significant roles in both the ecosystem and human culture. For instance, swans glide gracefully across lakes, their elegant movements and striking white feathers captivating onlookers. These birds symbolize grace and tranquility, often inspiring those who encounter them to reflect on the beauty of nature and the serenity it brings.
    Peacocks, with their dazzling plumage and intricate feather patterns, represent the splendor of self-expression. Their vibrant colors and elaborate displays during courtship rituals can captivate the imagination, reminding us of the importance of embracing one's uniqueness and confidence. Older women may find themselves drawn to these birds not just for their beauty, but for the messages they convey about individuality and self-acceptance.
    In more pastoral settings, the presence of large cockerels can add a lively dynamic to the landscape. These birds are known for their vibrant colors and robust personalities, often serving as the spirited guardians of the flock. Their morning calls herald the dawn, marking the start of a new day and infusing the atmosphere with energy and vitality. Engaging with these big birds can foster a sense of connection to the rhythms of rural life and the cycles of nature, encouraging a deeper appreciation for the simple joys found in everyday experiences.
    As older women continue to explore their interests and passions, the world of big birds offers a rich tapestry of beauty, inspiration, and connection to nature. Whether through gardening, birdwatching, or simply enjoying the sights and sounds of their feathered friends, these experiences can enhance their sense of well-being and contribute to a fulfilling, enriched life.

  • @lifelessons7711
    @lifelessons7711 15 днів тому

    Thanks for this analysis, but it is irritating to have your face on top of the images that you compare. Next time make yourself smaller and leave the screen to what's important.

  • @marcduchamp5512
    @marcduchamp5512 13 днів тому

    Midjourney is a woke joke

  • @LethargyPike
    @LethargyPike 9 днів тому

    STOP USING AI ART LAMES

  • @kbrodeur
    @kbrodeur Місяць тому

    they all look the same. it's boring.