To be totally fair to MAL, a show with a single 10/10 review could top the chart since it would be rated 10/10 since it doesn't control for the number of votes. Their 'top list' is mostly ignored, but the site is still fulfilling its primary purpose of cataloging and indexing the anime history of its users.
your main complaints are people using the site how it’s intended?? 😭😭 it’s not supposed to be an efficient way to determine the best anime, it’s like the primitive alternative to anitwt. if it released in the 80s, dragon ball would be the top anime, if it released in the 90s it’d probably be evangelion or sailor moon, if it released any time after it’d never be one piece 😭😭😭😭
@@DC1_ it’s at like a 9/10 juts drop to a 7, for short form content it’s fine but for 8 mins a less intense voice is nicer to listen to. The loud aggressive style is a lot like mr beast but for just talking a slower pace isn’t a bad thing. Regardless keep up the good work bro ❤
Frieren is really really good, But what do you mean its not top 50? what metric are you using to say its not top 50? it does everything it wants to do with the highest level of quality, story, pacing and music, if thats the case then what really makes it not even in top 50? favorism or nostalgic reasons? we can say MAL is exploited for hype but frieren picking up more ratings, 3 weeks ago it was top 1 with 300k now I believe more than 450k. So whats the reasoning objectively that it isnt top 50? Mind you its not my favorite anime or even top 5 for me because of nostalgic reasons but objectively speaking its there beside that its not finished because I really dont think it matters much atp to know the quality of the anime, elaborate. also I have reasons to think of why FMA is all time best its not mine but I can see the reasoning for example its easier to get into, better paced than one piece, shorter which means its acessable to more people and many other reasons, even the story itself and holes in it etc. BTW I dont even have MAL account lol.
bro should of watched the show before making this vid its definitely one of the best animes I've watch and I've watched a lot but soo far its up there with fmabh we will have too see
Nah fr. I watch One Piece (I'm not very far tho lol) but I hate saying I'm a fan of One Piece because of "those" kinds of fans. A lot of the worst takes I've ever heard have come from the mouths of One Piece fans. Like yes, it's a good anime, but I wouldn't say it's the best media ever made, lol.
I mean, literally all the shows you listed deserve to be top anime. Maybe the order is incorrect but seriously? one piece over steins gate or fmab or even "whatever the hell this is" which is gina eiyuu densetsu, one of the (if not the most) praised sci fi anime in history. I'm not trying to hate, but stop over exaggerating. also, why not watch the shows before you trash on them? one piece and attack on titan are entertaining, yes, but objectively, they are not the best of all time. Legacy/impact you can argue for, but pure objective quality, neither is top 5 for me. AOT probably makes top 10 for me, but one piece doesnt
Your voice isn't that bad or too sharp, in fact I am using earphones and it doesnt hurt my ears. But I dont like reddit as a reliable source because of its manipulative voting to make a context. Your own opinion and personal experience should be enough for me to be listened to.
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion I suppose. But you definitely have a more new school take on what you qualify as great anime. *Shakes fist in OG anime fan*
Your favourite manga included Berserk so you might like Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu. To describe it loosely t''s kind of like an R rated Star Trek. Lots of politics, plenty of gory scenes, a good amount of exposition about the world's history. It's a 90s anime so it goes from limited animation when characters are yapping to the occasional absurdly well animated action scene.
Honestly, I like MAL and to me these aren’t problems. Though, I am a 00s fan so, of course I prefer the 00s design. I really don’t care for Anilist. Also, all of the sites function that way. Having season 1 and 2 as separate things in the database. Not much of a problem when all the sites do that. I’ve heard it reflects how anime comes out in Japan. It did bother me in the past, but it’s really not something I care much about anymore. Especially after knowing the why.
I just don’t understand why people don’t just read the English title if it matters so much to them. MAL has both titles. Ignore the one you don’t care to see. What’s wrong with having both titles present? I’ve just learned both titles, but even if I only cared for one, I’d just read the one I cared about. I wouldn’t complain about the site offering both titles. I’ve never struggled with this. MAL has the English titles there, too. Just read those if that’s your preference.
The best anime of all time would be an anime that doesn't have a plausible negative point, One Piece does, it's simply too long, AOT has a terrible ending, and FMAB doesn't have such obvious negative points, it's the best anime of all time not because you or I like it, but because everyone likes it.🤔
Mal only represents minority of the nime community. Not all would use it nor have I known anyone that uses it. FMAB doesn't hold a candle to AOT or one piece worldwide.
To be totally fair to MAL, a show with a single 10/10 review could top the chart since it would be rated 10/10 since it doesn't control for the number of votes. Their 'top list' is mostly ignored, but the site is still fulfilling its primary purpose of cataloging and indexing the anime history of its users.
well spoken
The one piece meat riding is craazzzzyyyy 💀
your main complaints are people using the site how it’s intended?? 😭😭 it’s not supposed to be an efficient way to determine the best anime, it’s like the primitive alternative to anitwt. if it released in the 80s, dragon ball would be the top anime, if it released in the 90s it’d probably be evangelion or sailor moon, if it released any time after it’d never be one piece 😭😭😭😭
the riding is wild
bro has Boku no Pico and Steins;Gatea and FMAB as the same rating on MAL, ion know if I can trust ur opinion
your voice is really pleasant to listen too
your voice is overly sharp and energetic so it comes off as a bit annoying, just drop the intesity a tad.
I just hate when UA-camrs have no energy when they record lines, trying to take a page out of MatPats book but sometimes might over due it lol
@@DC1_ it’s at like a 9/10 juts drop to a 7, for short form content it’s fine but for 8 mins a less intense voice is nicer to listen to. The loud aggressive style is a lot like mr beast but for just talking a slower pace isn’t a bad thing. Regardless keep up the good work bro ❤
I see no problem with the voice.
@DemiCape it's incredibly grating and falls into the overhyped youtuber pitfall
W critique
Frieren is really really good, But what do you mean its not top 50? what metric are you using to say its not top 50? it does everything it wants to do with the highest level of quality, story, pacing and music, if thats the case then what really makes it not even in top 50? favorism or nostalgic reasons? we can say MAL is exploited for hype but frieren picking up more ratings, 3 weeks ago it was top 1 with 300k now I believe more than 450k. So whats the reasoning objectively that it isnt top 50? Mind you its not my favorite anime or even top 5 for me because of nostalgic reasons but objectively speaking its there beside that its not finished because I really dont think it matters much atp to know the quality of the anime, elaborate.
also I have reasons to think of why FMA is all time best its not mine but I can see the reasoning for example its easier to get into, better paced than one piece, shorter which means its acessable to more people and many other reasons, even the story itself and holes in it etc.
BTW I dont even have MAL account lol.
alr bro
@@Xerbat. i.imgflip.com/42cgdw.jpg
I don’t think it’s dead and Friren deserves to be the top rated anime of MAL, and thankfully it still is.
4:07
"Whatever this anime is"
Bro really showed no respect to LOTGH
But FMA is normally top of the chart. Most of the time it’s accurate.
bro should of watched the show before making this vid its definitely one of the best animes I've watch and I've watched a lot but soo far its up there with fmabh we will have too see
I only ever used mal for looking up the current and upcoming season/schedule
one piece fan detected, opinion rejected
Nah fr. I watch One Piece (I'm not very far tho lol) but I hate saying I'm a fan of One Piece because of "those" kinds of fans. A lot of the worst takes I've ever heard have come from the mouths of One Piece fans. Like yes, it's a good anime, but I wouldn't say it's the best media ever made, lol.
I mean, literally all the shows you listed deserve to be top anime. Maybe the order is incorrect but seriously? one piece over steins gate or fmab or even "whatever the hell this is" which is gina eiyuu densetsu, one of the (if not the most) praised sci fi anime in history. I'm not trying to hate, but stop over exaggerating. also, why not watch the shows before you trash on them? one piece and attack on titan are entertaining, yes, but objectively, they are not the best of all time. Legacy/impact you can argue for, but pure objective quality, neither is top 5 for me. AOT probably makes top 10 for me, but one piece doesnt
Steins Gate is great.
Ratings? I do'nt care about what people think, if I like it I like it.
Your voice isn't that bad or too sharp, in fact I am using earphones and it doesnt hurt my ears.
But I dont like reddit as a reliable source because of its manipulative voting to make a context. Your own opinion and personal experience should be enough for me to be listened to.
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion I suppose. But you definitely have a more new school take on what you qualify as great anime. *Shakes fist in OG anime fan*
I prefer Anilist personally
I like his energy have you heard youtuber chills many commented that they dislike his voice.
Nah man you just didn't point at freaking Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu and called it "whatever the hell this anime is" 🗿.
What is your problem with Frieren???😭😭😭
Great vid, id just suggest watching out for peaking your mic
Your favourite manga included Berserk so you might like Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu. To describe it loosely t''s kind of like an R rated Star Trek. Lots of politics, plenty of gory scenes, a good amount of exposition about the world's history. It's a 90s anime so it goes from limited animation when characters are yapping to the occasional absurdly well animated action scene.
Honestly, I like MAL and to me these aren’t problems. Though, I am a 00s fan so, of course I prefer the 00s design. I really don’t care for Anilist. Also, all of the sites function that way. Having season 1 and 2 as separate things in the database. Not much of a problem when all the sites do that. I’ve heard it reflects how anime comes out in Japan. It did bother me in the past, but it’s really not something I care much about anymore. Especially after knowing the why.
maybe you are just jelous or envy
nah, Code Geass tramples all.
Fun fact: Lelouch is #1 at the top of the Favourite character in MAL
I never liked Code Geass. Lelouches stupid intelligence and the fanservice made it stupid.
Thankfully many people think the same.
I swear ive seen your profile picture from a death grips video
What software do you use to edit your videos?
Anime shows need to be in japanese. Worldwide people know by the japanese title. Americans thinks they are the center of the world.
I just don’t understand why people don’t just read the English title if it matters so much to them. MAL has both titles. Ignore the one you don’t care to see. What’s wrong with having both titles present? I’ve just learned both titles, but even if I only cared for one, I’d just read the one I cared about. I wouldn’t complain about the site offering both titles. I’ve never struggled with this. MAL has the English titles there, too. Just read those if that’s your preference.
The best anime of all time would be an anime that doesn't have a plausible negative point, One Piece does, it's simply too long, AOT has a terrible ending, and FMAB doesn't have such obvious negative points, it's the best anime of all time not because you or I like it, but because everyone likes it.🤔
Mal only represents minority of the nime community. Not all would use it nor have I known anyone that uses it. FMAB doesn't hold a candle to AOT or one piece worldwide.
Please don’t listen to the gripes about your voice bro just be yourself :)
Very high quality video.
Parody?
love the video
yap
ok zoomer
Anyone have better sites?
real ones know about anilist !!!! you can very easily transport MAL lists to anilist
MY DISCORD ACCOUNT GOT DISABLED SO I CANT TALK TO YOU
bro one piece anime sucks wth are u on
I agree with the frieren and oshi no ko takes but everything else nahhhh
cry more fma fans, your anime is literally boring and cringe
You know nothing about #frieren 🫵🏻🚮