What was the most idiotic choice a characters’ made on this show? Let us know in the comments below. But please, don’t go all “Negan” on us about it. For more Walking Dead, check out our playlist: ua-cam.com/video/J1I_Q_T6_PU/v-deo.html
Andrea did try to kill the Governor, but Milton pushed her aside and stopped her. She thought about killing the Governor after returning from the prison and having sex with him, but she couldn't bring herself to kill someone in his sleep. It is pretty cowardly to murder someone in his/her sleep. Rick proceeded to do that, and it unleashed the Saviours' wrath upon him.
@@TheBob1901 there was a time before that, after she talked to Carol, when she could've killed him in his sleep, but she didn't. This was before the episode of her attempt and Milton's interference.
I think Andrea choosing The Governor over her friends was up there, which led to her death. Very disappointing when compared to her character in the Graphic Novels.
Andrea was treated like garbage at the prison, so no wonder she went back to Woodbury. I think Andrea's dumbest mistake was in incessantly talking to the mortally wounded Milton rather than focusing on using the pliers he pushed her way to free herself from her cuffs. If she'd shut up and just focused on freeing herself, she would have survived.
@@randalgraves6979 Maybe, but wouldn't it have been worse to leave Noah behind? After his previous escape attempts, he would have been made to suffer even more if he had stayed.
This!!! Especially when you compare how badass his comic counterpart was! He was trapped in a gym with a ton of zombies and he killed them all with only a hammer.
Asking Hershel to come along with the group to retrieve medical supplies when he was the groups only medic. And, of course, he got bit, had his leg amputated and almost died
@@BlackDiamond2718 Yes and no. Having a medic there to pick and choose what’s necessary for the group could save some heavy loading for supply runs but also it’s the apocalypse. Supplies are scarce.
A lot of people on here deciding for themselves that chandler Riggs wanted to leave the walking dead, where are you getting this information because that was not the case at all. Riggs wanted to go to college WHILE remaining on the show. He approached the producers about managing his time to do both. They broke his contract, that he still had 2 years left on, and they just killed him off rather than change his scheduling. They broke that poor kids heart and you can see that in every interview he had following his exit from the show. Even his dad took to Twitter to post an angry rant about how Gimple treated his son. The post was later deleted but it was made clear Riggs did not want to leave the show in any way. He was forced out and it was this treatment of Riggs that made Andrew Lincoln, Danai gurrera, and multiple other important cast members want to leave or reduce their time on the walking dead and start working on other projects. Killing off Carl and the treatment towards the actor, who had been on the show since the beginning, was the point of no return for twd. If you don’t believe me look it up for yourself. It was absolutely disgraceful the way they treated Riggs, considering he grew up on the show. Riggs main priority was acting and he had even taken a gap year to focus on acting in other shows or movies after being so heartlessly let go from twd.
I thought they killed him cause their ratings had failed really bad? Thts what I read . A lot of ppl were fed up with the 2 yr war and all of the people killing. Ik for me it seemed like it became more about them killing ppl and not the walking dead.
One mistake I see in almost every show or movie about survival is that when a group is lucky enough to find someone with medical training who can potentially save all their lives, they always fail to make protecting that person a high priority & I've never seen a show express that at least one other person should be trying to learn from them. Hershal should never have been put in a situation where he could be bitten or working outside the fence. Saddiq should have been guarded. Denise shouldn't have been out tromping on the railroad tracks. This group seems very adept at killing off their medics.
@@tavo7465 maybe not exactly because Glenn is the one picked by Negan instead of Abe but his death was meant to happen anyways As to Carl, yeah that was a blunder. He's a badass in the comics
The most dumb decisions that Andrea ever done was not shooting Daryl thinking of him as a walker is picking the governor over her friends Michonne to leave too.
Eugene joining the Saviors. Aaron crossing the Whisperers border. Andrea taking half and hour before trying to pick up the tool that would have freed her, knowing that Milton would turn and eat her, very soon.
The Dumbest or most stupid mistake was made by Lizzie. She thought that Walkers are still people inside and that she killed her sister Mika to prove her point.
Killing Beth and Andrea annoyed me because they were characters finally about to find their feet in not just the world but with the fans. Not to mention Beth’s death felt pointless because Noah just died like 6 episodes later. Carl’s the one that hits home tho. When Andrew left having Carl would’ve been the only thing keeping the majority of fans watching. It could’ve worked out with Carl being the face of the show. So many theories felt it could’ve ended with old man Carl but we were utterly robbed of that. Imo it was the worst decision in any hit TV show
It was never as good as it was before Negan. It was epic before Glenn died and ok after it was when Carl died it was on life support and when Rick died I pulled the plug....
The episode when Daryl and someone else went to get the girl a orange soda but found a food truck. The food truck eventually went rolling into the river and all was wasted
F in chat for Chandler Riggs. Man's moved closer to the set so it'd be easier for him to make it to the filming. And the directors killed him off because of money issues
@@cinxx_ Because legally they had to now pay him an adults wage. So they thought they could save money by killing him off, when it all reality they lost money because it because many fans were pissed and left. Can't make money off a show if no one's watching it, plenty of people still do including me, but the money they wanted to save by firing him completely negated and made the show worse and pissed everybody off.
The biggest mistake was following the comics formula of "find the dictator, fight the dictator, rinse and repeat". It's like the writers have blinders on.
I disagree Glenn was never that big of deal. Sure we liked him but no one was watching because of Glenn lol and that scene was sick. “Son are you still there? I just don’t know, It sounds like you’re trying to speak” lol
@@Spooky_515 if Rick is the soul of the show then Glenn was definitely the heart of the show. He had the heros journey more then any other character on that show. The nerdy funny guy who was a nobody before the Apocalypse steps up and lands the girl and becomes a hero?
It’s a show that’s adapted the entire comic series(after it ends this year I mean), there isn’t a lot of those anymore, and it just proves how much of a success it was. Count the spinoffs and you have a very successful franchise.
Killing Glenn off a popular character everytime I see somebody new watching Walking Dead on here they instantly love Glenn lol just to please people that read the comics idgaf it shouldn't has happened in the show.
If you want to see something weird, watch "In Cold Blood" a movie made in the late '60s with Robert Blake...you get to see Scott as a young psycho killer.
but siddiq played a big role, carl dying was, i admit, the worst decision by writers but it wasn’t pointless, siddiq helped build up alexandria with water and such
Just about every character in TWD has made at least one dumb mistake or other. and it's even dumber but also made more sense that some of the mistakes of those character either lead to their deaths or to the deaths of others.
Well that’s the point of the show. The idea is that the human mistakes is the mean dead factor. We can also see that in the comics . For example, in the comics one the prisoners in the prison who’s name’s is Dexter tried to chase Rick’s group away after they accused him for killing two of Hershel’s daughters ( these young ones doesn’t appear in the tv show). As a result, during a attack of walkers inside the prison’s walls Dexter is shot from behind by Rick ( who break his moral code at this point of the story) .
What about completely forgetting that applying walker's inside over some suit or keeping two walkers with you (breaking their teeth and jaw off) makes one invisible to walkers.
That first season always hits so different. I wonder what the early seasons of the show would have been like if Darabont was still around. Or at least, anyone not Gimple
I wouldn’t see Daryl being alive If Frank was still in charge he was supposed to die in season 2 and I heard some death for Daryl in season 3 or 4 but yea a lot would be different
Honestly speaking from Negan’s perspective, killing Abraham made a lot of sense. He was the biggest (physically) member of the group and was an ex soldier. He had experience in war and Negan saw the coming war with Alexandria. Taking him out early in his mind probably would have made the war a lot easier.
Killing off Carl was by far the stupidest thing they did. He friggin grew up around walkers. Him getting bit was the laziest writing I have ever seen in a friggin show. It was like whoever wrote that script never even watch the show. The producers screwed him over just because he turned 18 and they did not want to pay him an adult wage.
@@Zalwalloo no he actually talked about that on a talk show. He said he never saw that coming because he'd just signed a new contract and bought a house. He didn't seem to happy about it either! The writers screwed him big time!
@@Zalwalloo Wrong. Gimple and spoken to Chandler's dad, advised they would need him for "at least 3 more seasons". Chandler Riggs then bought a home in Atlanta. That very same Season (1 of the "at least 3 more"), they (Simple Gimple) then killed him off.
There are many things that made Carl’s death so insulting one of them was how grimy they did Chandler Riggs They barely gave him any story despite being a main character alive in the comics and a respected major character in the comics (especially during the Negan storyline) and dubbed as The John Connor of The Walking Dead Andrew Lincoln years ago said that if Rick were to be killed off the way he’d want it is for it to be Carl that put him down He can never get that wish of what he felt was best for the character Then by Season 8 they performed a whole character switch as if Season 7 Carl didn’t want All the smoke Like he wasn’t the one who was like y’all got me fucked up and popped off the battle at Alexandria Now don’t get me wrong Carl was also a sympathetic person he was always trying to help people even if it meant going against his father so the Siddiq storyline doesn’t bother me as it’s in character of him But to change him from Mr Knuck If You Buck at the end of Season 7 to We Are The World during Season 8 without any form of transition or development is absolutely ludicrous and absolutely poor storytelling It made no sense And to kill him off the way they did it was disrespectful I get they wanted to do the Anyone can get bit at anytime all it takes is a second shit but it was still trash if you were going to kill don’t give him that basic ass death. Now onto the controversy of this whole fuckery Now most fans were upset by the killing of Carl Now Chandler was now 18 years old He has just graduated from high school so most fans assumed that he wanted to leave especially since we knew he was headed for college (he was also doing producing music for fun) with the idocity of Carl’s death instead of sending him away for a possible return despite were hurt fans respected Chandlers decision They did a whole big thing on The Talking Dead on his final episode and everything he’s on there talking about him going to college and everything Makes sense He grew up on the show Maybe he wanted his future to be something different Skip to the next day Chandlers pissed off father spills the tea that Chandler didn’t quit he was FIRED Scott Gimple had told Chandler before the new Season that he wanted him for at least 3 more years He agreed to stay on the show chose to attend college in Georgia and even brought a house between the show and and his school so he could be able to do both Scott Gimple knew this and said nothing Chandler had no warning about his death In fact the reason he found out only two episodes before was because Gimple came to the set and told him while they were filming the unknown bite scene and needed him to give off the right expressions for when they showed the flashback reveal So imagine finding out you’re being killed off as you’re filming the scene Imagine after being told you’re being kept made your college decision and noise based on it so you can continue your job only to be fired From my understanding Chandler decided to take a year off before starting college afterwards (I don’t know if he ever went) When fans found out they were pissed Casual viewers probably still don’t know this information So not only did they unnecessarily kill off Carl for (spoilers) it wasn’t even Chandlers decision He wanted to stay on the show planned his whole around it so he was able to do so only to get screwed over A major theory about why was because had now turned 18 and with that and being a main cast member his contract was to be done with a pay increase as he was no longer a minor They simply didn’t want to pay him especially what he deserved so they got rid of him Because they didn’t pay up And honestly you can tell his departure left a mark on not only the show but definitely the actors. Scott Gimple almost go a diss track from my ass because of this fuckery lol.
In season three when Rick didn’t make sure Andrew was dead when he chased him into that courtyard. He got away, then came back for revenge then that led to the deaths of Lori and T dog.
@@annafowdy but she would have had a better chance of surviving if Hershel had been there to help with the delivery. Also it was the stress of that situation that Andrew caused that made her go into labor in the first place.
andrew left BECAUSE carl got fired, he said the show writers were unjust and that it got him thinking of his own family, so he quit to spend time with them
I'd say the dumbest mistake was Rick and his group attacking the satellite outpost that ended up sparking the Saviour war. If Rick had gone with Morgan's more peaceful approach then I honestly think that Negan would have backed down a bit from almost bleeding Hilltop and the Kingdom dry as he would have wanted to keep his people safe by not allowing conflict to occur.
Dale didn't get bit by the walker, it tore his stomach/chest area open with it's hands. Rick was hoping to save him but Hershal made him realize that he couldn't be saved so Rick shot him to end his suffering
i dont mind Carl getting killed, but him getting bitten (for saving a total stranger)... common, of all things, he haven't learn anything from his father. dumb writing. that's the last episode i seen that makes me rage quit.
@@bigdaddygru They all die "anyway" at some point. Keep in mind that given Judith's age, there is at least a good 10+ year time jump from Carl's death to Siddiq's death so it's not like he died for nothing as Siddiq did a lot for the community.
I STILL don't understand Lori "Cowboying Up" and driving off like she did in season 2 - it absolutely made ZERO sense at all. She was never more capable then being the den mother for the group and clearly couldn't handle herself, what the hell was she thinking driving off by herself?
There is wayy too many dumb mistakes characters make in the show. Like how Andrea just decides to trust the governor immediately and too many decisions Rick made. Their decisions are so irritating at times
Killing Shane, Carl, and Glenn were the biggest mistake in the whole series. Shane could have died tho, but not after 2 season's. He carried the show for 2 seasons and was by far one of the best characters in the series.
I feel like I’m alone but the show got even better when those happened. Season 9 is my second favorite season and it has barely any rick and no Carl. They did great with the story after writing them off
I think their dumbest mistakes is that the zombies can turn invisible, I mean you look around there are no walkers then you look back BOOM, a walker jumpscares you
Andrea didn't know it was Daryl when she shot him. She thought it was a Walker. The way Carl died and how Scott Gimple did Chandler Briggs dirty was definitely a stupid decision
3:12 Well Eugene once told negan, what his profession was before the outbreak (working for a pharmacist producing/breeding Diseases, curing other diseases with them "fighting fire with fire"), so the makers could have used that to twist the plot in the entire series... Like he could be involved in the origins of the virus...
Another thing, is the huge shootouts they would have, when hardly anybody is getting hit...they all just empty their guns wildly, shooting the shit out of everything. I mean, with a limited supply of ammo, you would think they would be more careful what they shot at.
Please apologise for insulting Carol, she's an absolute badass and has such a great character development, all up until season 9. After that she is still an interesting, but it get's weird, because they try to make her and Daryl the Main Characters, which doesn't really work with them, as they both are "lone wolf"-type of characters. It just takes from them...
Although a number of people think it was a smart move to lead the walkers out of town, I thought it was the dumbest mistake of the show and ultimately cost a lot of lives. The walkers were contained in a quarry. In a later episode it shows that the group had a gasoline truck. I would have closed the gap, gathered up as much flammable material as possible and saturated the pit with gasoline. They could have also found barrels, bales of hay, etc. to roll into the quarry, then light it all on fire 🔥 The End!
Beth's death was so dumb. What TF was she thinking?! Andrea not killing the governor but tv Andrea just did a lot of stupid crap. Something that's always bugged me is the Sophia thing. As a mom I would have kicked Lori, hard, because I AM going after my baby and I will die with her or for her, I'm not leaving it up to chance. Sophia would have lived. Carol could have quietly gone along with Rick.
I still think that the plan to lead the dead out of the quarry to be someone else’s problem was a terrible decision. They were nicely contained. How about rolling down barrels of oil dumping rubbish and other flammable items into the quarry, and setting it all on fire?
what about when rick tried to lure away 2 walkers and left sophia alone? that part always makes me frustrated, i understand everyone was beginning to deal with the walkers but that was pretty dumb to leave her alone scared and vulnerable
Eugene revealing Alexandria was a good thing because they were dealing with walkers and starvation. Eugene left before the whisperers were finished, the whole idea was to get help in dealing with them
#11 the fake out death of Glen. "realistically" he wouldn't have survived that. Having a dead body on top of yours getting ripped apart and not your own with how fast/brutual they rip apart people...lol glenn wouldn't be able to escape.
Well actually the zombie didn't bite Dale it only ripped his stomach open with its hands when he tried to hold it back but yeah that was a pretty dumb mistake on Carl's part
Oh, yeah, Rick leads the Anderson family right through the pack of zombies in Alexandrea(which were there because of his failed attempt to lead them out of town.) How about sneaking around the back, thru the backyards?
@@macbook802Rick was going out to kill it and tells Andrea "we will handle it" or something like that so i think Rick and Shane were okay with killing walkers with melee weapons...but also in season 1 T-Dog and Morales had baseball bats when they met Rick.
A dumb mistake was Daryl crashing a truck into the Sanctuary when it was surrounded by walkers and starving out the Saviors. All he had to do was wait half a day and they would have won.
I thought killing off Carl was a dumb mistake at the time, but that actor couldn't act worth shit. Ricks daughter that basically takes on what his comics role was, was a muuuuuch better actor!
Henry's movements got a lot of people killed, he was so mad at Enid he try force himself into something with Lydia, he was annoying for a while but that took the biscuit
Dragging things out is the dumbest mistake. They lost their audience with dragging season 7 on and on with fans believing it was all build up to an epic showdown and then we got season 8 and it was even more boring than season 7 lol
2 More Mistakes: Lizzie thinking Walkers were People and Killing her Sister to make a Point and Tyreese going into Noah's House and not Paying Attention to the Walker.
Honestly Andrea shooting him should have been #1 by a mile. She's not a skilled enough shot to be shooting between two living people at that range. IF I were Rick or Shane and had got back I would have smacked her as hard as I possibly could for that, then barred her from having guns. Andrea is the type of character you'd get if you got some left leaning New York type feminist in your group. "I can do everything the big boys can" with the whole mindset of having something to prove, that combined results in painfully foolish behavior like almost blowing 3 different guy's heads off trying to prove to them she can do it. THAT scene and that character proves why women shouldn't be cops.
I stopped watching the show back in S6. When I heard they actually killed off Carl I was baffled, since the entire last third of the comics were all about Carl.
be became pretty boring and even annoying in his later seasons the only and biggest problem with his death was, that the shows point of Rick building a safe world for him disappeared into nothing - which is... sad but actually realistic in such scenario.
one of the dumbest to me is when Eastman got bit, dude seemed like he was always on his toes only to get bit by one right in front of him and could've easily pushed Morgan away or grabbed him or something lmao
What was the most idiotic choice a characters’ made on this show? Let us know in the comments below. But please, don’t go all “Negan” on us about it.
For more Walking Dead, check out our playlist: ua-cam.com/video/J1I_Q_T6_PU/v-deo.html
The dumbest mistake was the writers deciding to kill off Carl
Renewimg the show for another season.
When Rick kicked carol out of the group. Luckily Carol put her feelings aside and save the group from being steak ums.
Great watchmojo ✨️video ⭐️
Probably the worst decision was to not quit after 6 seasons.
Surprised y'all didn't mention Andrea's mistake of not killing The Governor, when she had the chance.
Exactly
Andrea did try to kill the Governor, but Milton pushed her aside and stopped her. She thought about killing the Governor after returning from the prison and having sex with him, but she couldn't bring herself to kill someone in his sleep. It is pretty cowardly to murder someone in his/her sleep. Rick proceeded to do that, and it unleashed the Saviours' wrath upon him.
@@TheBob1901 there was a time before that, after she talked to Carol, when she could've killed him in his sleep, but she didn't. This was before the episode of her attempt and Milton's interference.
fr
@@TheBob1901 That's the silliest connection I've ever seen drawn man. Whether Rick and the group killed them awake or asleep wouldn't have mattered.
I think Andrea choosing The Governor over her friends was up there, which led to her death. Very disappointing when compared to her character in the Graphic Novels.
Yeah I'm surprised they didn't bring up her basically sleeping with the enemy. That's why I wasn't really heartbroken when she died
Andrea was treated like garbage at the prison, so no wonder she went back to Woodbury. I think Andrea's dumbest mistake was in incessantly talking to the mortally wounded Milton rather than focusing on using the pliers he pushed her way to free herself from her cuffs. If she'd shut up and just focused on freeing herself, she would have survived.
Andrea made every single wrong choice at every moment she can in the show lmao
Andrea is the dumbest choice!
It is clearly the writers fault who didn’t seems to know how to treat that character or rev-invented it correctly.
I think by far the dumbest mistake on this list was when Beth decided to attack Dawn with a pair of scissors while Dawn was carrying a loaded gun.
🤐
Yes
I was so angry!!
she did it so she can sacrifice. she knew dawn wasn’t gonna let her out and she knew she wasn’t gonna make it. she did for noah.
@@katisthebestt exactly. She knew too much for them to just let her go.
Beth's mistake is pretty much one of the most dumbest moments, we ever seen in the show...As for me, it was one of the first drop outs.
If Rick didn’t take Noah back to trade for Beth & Carol. That wouldn’t have happened. 🤔
@@randalgraves6979
Hmmm... Maybe. Maybe. 🤔🤔
@@randalgraves6979 Maybe, but wouldn't it have been worse to leave Noah behind? After his previous escape attempts, he would have been made to suffer even more if he had stayed.
@@GrandmasterDevo what?? Why would he escape Ricks group?
@@randalgraves6979 I meant he tried to escape from the hospital. Dawn would have been more of a dick to him for trying to leave.
Tyrese going into Noah's house and not paying attention to his surroundings
That was EXTREMELY dumb!!! How did that not make the list??
@@bigdaddygru probably irl it wouldn't happen but the directors wanted to make it surprising so they killed tyrese
This!!! Especially when you compare how badass his comic counterpart was! He was trapped in a gym with a ton of zombies and he killed them all with only a hammer.
Comic Tyrese got the saddest legs no wonder the nfl got rid of his ass
@aveteranplayer6403Shane’s death was perfect. Many other characters shouldn’t have died or at least should’ve lived longer
Its amazing how often walkers manage to shuffle up and get people from behind like they are completely silent until they attack. Come on Dale.
For real. Its so unrealistic. How do they not hear them?
Dale can be excused more due to his age
Tyrese too lol
And one season later Daryl says "You'll smell em before you see em."
The dumbest mistake was the writers deciding to kill off Carl
100% completely fucked the show and the whole whisperer arc
and it was so lame how they did it...like he's survived nearly all these other attempts at his life ands THAT's how you decide to kill him off?
No doubt the dumbest decision made by the writer's
@@calzone3843 How did it fuck up the whisperers arc ?
@@leoc.7514 in the comics hes the one that takes the forefront after rick.
Asking Hershel to come along with the group to retrieve medical supplies when he was the groups only medic. And, of course, he got bit, had his leg amputated and almost died
But he never lost his head. He was always calm in every situation
@@randalgraves6979 I see what you did there 😭
@@randalgraves6979 until he did lose his head seriously
Tbh shouldn’t they just take all the medical supplies instead of just selecting them?
@@BlackDiamond2718 Yes and no. Having a medic there to pick and choose what’s necessary for the group could save some heavy loading for supply runs but also it’s the apocalypse. Supplies are scarce.
A lot of people on here deciding for themselves that chandler Riggs wanted to leave the walking dead, where are you getting this information because that was not the case at all. Riggs wanted to go to college WHILE remaining on the show. He approached the producers about managing his time to do both. They broke his contract, that he still had 2 years left on, and they just killed him off rather than change his scheduling. They broke that poor kids heart and you can see that in every interview he had following his exit from the show. Even his dad took to Twitter to post an angry rant about how Gimple treated his son. The post was later deleted but it was made clear Riggs did not want to leave the show in any way. He was forced out and it was this treatment of Riggs that made Andrew Lincoln, Danai gurrera, and multiple other important cast members want to leave or reduce their time on the walking dead and start working on other projects. Killing off Carl and the treatment towards the actor, who had been on the show since the beginning, was the point of no return for twd. If you don’t believe me look it up for yourself. It was absolutely disgraceful the way they treated Riggs, considering he grew up on the show. Riggs main priority was acting and he had even taken a gap year to focus on acting in other shows or movies after being so heartlessly let go from twd.
Fuck em (not riggs, the assholes that screwed him)
Wtf Gimple!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Riggs made a cameo in season 11 as a farmer.
Not to mention Andrew Jeffrey and Norman pleaded to keep him on
I thought they killed him cause their ratings had failed really bad? Thts what I read . A lot of ppl were fed up with the 2 yr war and all of the people killing. Ik for me it seemed like it became more about them killing ppl and not the walking dead.
One mistake I see in almost every show or movie about survival is that when a group is lucky enough to find someone with medical training who can potentially save all their lives, they always fail to make protecting that person a high priority & I've never seen a show express that at least one other person should be trying to learn from them. Hershal should never have been put in a situation where he could be bitten or working outside the fence. Saddiq should have been guarded. Denise shouldn't have been out tromping on the railroad tracks. This group seems very adept at killing off their medics.
Good point. I was always upset about the prison being so well mowed all the time, lol its stupid but it bothered me
They did train others on TWD - carol learned from hershel, Enid from Siddiq....
Never got over Glen and Carl dying 😭 The show lost its magic when they left.
Personally, I think the show got even better. Carl was annoying. Glenn’s death furthered Maggie’s character arc so it was needed
I agree. After Glen was killed the show wasn't the same. I still watched it tho lol
Tbf they killed him exactly like he is in the comics
@@lewiswatson5799 I don't think that's true
@@tavo7465 maybe not exactly because Glenn is the one picked by Negan instead of Abe but his death was meant to happen anyways
As to Carl, yeah that was a blunder. He's a badass in the comics
Henry was essentially the wish version of Carl. Pretty sure the only reason they killed him was because of how much the fans absolutely hated him.
i hope thats not true because i hate this fandom now 😭😭 i love henry
Well I guess he has another thing in common with Carl a wasted death 😂😂
All the trash decisions they made you know they don’t give into fan service
they only hated him bc he went back for a girl that he had feelings for outta of "doing the right thing"😢
@@hafahuntei8559 carl did the samw in the comics
I was convinced Laurie was gonna make up this whole list
I did not like Lori one bit.
😂
Lori*
I mean it could be an entire Andrea/Lori list 🤣🤣
@@jordantickell99 ngl completely forgot how to spell it 😂😂😂
The most dumb decisions that Andrea ever done was not shooting Daryl thinking of him as a walker is picking the governor over her friends Michonne to leave too.
The actress even was pissed at how they wrote her
Not shooting Daryl??? This comment is confusing my brain
What they're saying is that shooting Daryl was not the stupidest thing they did it was the other thing they just worded it differently
Eugene joining the Saviors. Aaron crossing the Whisperers border. Andrea taking half and hour before trying to pick up the tool that would have freed her, knowing that Milton would turn and eat her, very soon.
@@DanielGonzalez-vo5ni disagree tho cuz she was protecting the group from a walker. It just happened to be a half dead Daryl.
The Dumbest or most stupid mistake was made by Lizzie. She thought that Walkers are still people inside and that she killed her sister Mika to prove her point.
Stupid? No, I think the point was She was Insane.
@@earlleeruhf3130 Good point.
Traumatized girl
Mistake? Nah, poor kid was batshit crazy!
I think she has mental illness
Killing Beth and Andrea annoyed me because they were characters finally about to find their feet in not just the world but with the fans. Not to mention Beth’s death felt pointless because Noah just died like 6 episodes later.
Carl’s the one that hits home tho. When Andrew left having Carl would’ve been the only thing keeping the majority of fans watching. It could’ve worked out with Carl being the face of the show. So many theories felt it could’ve ended with old man Carl but we were utterly robbed of that. Imo it was the worst decision in any hit TV show
Andrew left because of Carl's death
Carl was annoying but the way they killed him off was very stupid
I love when an adaptation changes parts of the story but Carl dying wasn't it
Facts. Daryl was a great move, but taking out Carl, and doing Andrea's whole character dirty felt wrong.
@@wulaeofthetengu8336 Andrea could’ve been redeemed too.
@@wulaeofthetengu8336 I still think about it till this day
Andria not killing The Governor in his sleep was by far one of the dumbest decisions in the show
I think she was still riding the high a bit of the governor
Glens death will haunt me forever. That entire scene just lives in my head and I can’t get rid of it, I could never watch it again 💔
Well, getting out of the series give his career a boost, in an award winning movie and a great role in Nope.
Feel that
That's how he died in the comics
That was def the most traumatizing episode for me
It was never as good as it was before Negan. It was epic before Glenn died and ok after it was when Carl died it was on life support and when Rick died I pulled the plug....
The episode when Daryl and someone else went to get the girl a orange soda but found a food truck. The food truck eventually went rolling into the river and all was wasted
Those are two different episodes. The orange soda incident happened with Denise. The truck in the water happened with Rick
@@istayjammin2589 it was the same episode. That was on Jesus debut
I laughed my ass off with all the memes regarding this episode 😆
Rick: "Today Still is The Day😆👍"
Yea, if you say so, Pal🙄
Couple ppl here need to rewatch the show or just never talk about the show again
"someone"?? Lol Rick the main character?
F in chat for Chandler Riggs. Man's moved closer to the set so it'd be easier for him to make it to the filming. And the directors killed him off because of money issues
Yeah cos of his age or something
@@cinxx_ Because legally they had to now pay him an adults wage. So they thought they could save money by killing him off, when it all reality they lost money because it because many fans were pissed and left. Can't make money off a show if no one's watching it, plenty of people still do including me, but the money they wanted to save by firing him completely negated and made the show worse and pissed everybody off.
@@PublishedLeaf yeah that’s right , worst mistake they made
Lori leaving Carl unattended & unsupervised only to ask everyone in the group if they saw her son.
The biggest mistake was following the comics formula of "find the dictator, fight the dictator, rinse and repeat". It's like the writers have blinders on.
No show has ever made me sooooo angry for soooo many dumb decisions!
I just gave you your 69th like 😉
Killing Carl was 100% the dumbest, worst decision ever in a tv show
no. he was boring and even annoying in his later seasons.
@@Blei1986they didn’t develop him enough at this point
Honestly Glenn's death definitely Daryl's fault for attacking Negan from the beginning, that were truly an big mistake ever.
I disagree Glenn was never that big of deal. Sure we liked him but no one was watching because of Glenn lol and that scene was sick.
“Son are you still there? I just don’t know, It sounds like you’re trying to speak” lol
@@Spooky_515 if Rick is the soul of the show then Glenn was definitely the heart of the show. He had the heros journey more then any other character on that show. The nerdy funny guy who was a nobody before the Apocalypse steps up and lands the girl and becomes a hero?
Glenn died from negan in the comic... Daryl is not a comic character. An big mistake u made there
@@weelzneal4768 What's your point? We're talking about the show.
@@IAmMightyMike original poster's comment "its Daryl's fault Glenn died" it wasn't his fault, he was written to die there
The dumbest mistake was letting it continue for so many seasons, and killing what used to be a good show
It’s a show that’s adapted the entire comic series(after it ends this year I mean), there isn’t a lot of those anymore, and it just proves how much of a success it was. Count the spinoffs and you have a very successful franchise.
@@KoltVEVO I like this reply it wasn’t aggressive but got to the point and proved him wrong
Killing Glenn off a popular character everytime I see somebody new watching Walking Dead on here they instantly love Glenn lol just to please people that read the comics idgaf it shouldn't has happened in the show.
They really should've stuck to the source material.
@@KoltVEVO successful yes, but still garbage… just like the transformers.
Rest in peace Scott Wilson
He was perfect on the show. His characters death was the saddest to me.
R.I.P
If you want to see something weird, watch "In Cold Blood" a movie made in the late '60s with Robert Blake...you get to see Scott as a young psycho killer.
Them killing off siddiq made carl dying seem pointless.
but siddiq played a big role, carl dying was, i admit, the worst decision by writers but it wasn’t pointless, siddiq helped build up alexandria with water and such
Just about every character in TWD has made at least one dumb mistake or other. and it's even dumber but also made more sense that some of the mistakes of those character either lead to their deaths or to the deaths of others.
Well that’s the point of the show. The idea is that the human mistakes is the mean dead factor. We can also see that in the comics . For example, in the comics one the prisoners in the prison who’s name’s is Dexter tried to chase Rick’s group away after they accused him for killing two of Hershel’s daughters ( these young ones doesn’t appear in the tv show). As a result, during a attack of walkers inside the prison’s walls Dexter is shot from behind by Rick ( who break his moral code at this point of the story) .
What about completely forgetting that applying walker's inside over some suit or keeping two walkers with you (breaking their teeth and jaw off) makes one invisible to walkers.
How is that the show's problem as a "stupid mistake" when it's clearly from the comics.
they’ve used the guts method throughout the show tbo
@@markjones5672 Read the post again. It's like for most of the series they forgot all about it
There was more than ten mistakes this show made over the years. 😂 Like Firing Frank Darabont and putting Scott Gimple in charge.
That first season always hits so different. I wonder what the early seasons of the show would have been like if Darabont was still around. Or at least, anyone not Gimple
I wouldn’t see Daryl being alive If Frank was still in charge he was supposed to die in season 2 and I heard some death for Daryl in season 3 or 4 but yea a lot would be different
Frank being fired was pure BS. He could have made that show so much better.
@@Eclipses915 Frank wouldn't have killed him off since he's a fan favorite
The dumbest was killing off Abraham AND Glenn in one episode. Completely did Abraham dirty..
Ok even though Glenn’s death perfectly matched the comics I don’t really agree with Abraham’s death on the show
Not dumb at all..
Honestly speaking from Negan’s perspective, killing Abraham made a lot of sense. He was the biggest (physically) member of the group and was an ex soldier. He had experience in war and Negan saw the coming war with Alexandria. Taking him out early in his mind probably would have made the war a lot easier.
True but it seems before his death, Abraham was clumsy & unfocused since his mistakes made the guard alert the entire outpost
Killing off Carl was by far the stupidest thing they did. He friggin grew up around walkers. Him getting bit was the laziest writing I have ever seen in a friggin show. It was like whoever wrote that script never even watch the show. The producers screwed him over just because he turned 18 and they did not want to pay him an adult wage.
No, he wanted off the show to go school
@@Zalwalloo No. He bought a house in Georgia and applied for college in Georgia. So that he could continue on the show.
@@Zalwalloo no he actually talked about that on a talk show. He said he never saw that coming because he'd just signed a new contract and bought a house. He didn't seem to happy about it either! The writers screwed him big time!
@@Zalwalloo Wrong. Gimple and spoken to Chandler's dad, advised they would need him for "at least 3 more seasons". Chandler Riggs then bought a home in Atlanta. That very same Season (1 of the "at least 3 more"), they (Simple Gimple) then killed him off.
Carl's death was the saddest one.
"Your sense of duty gets your group into some deep doodie, always getting saved by some samurai booty."
-Walter White.
I remember that 😭😭😭
There are many things that made Carl’s death so insulting one of them was how grimy they did Chandler Riggs They barely gave him any story despite being a main character alive in the comics and a respected major character in the comics (especially during the Negan storyline) and dubbed as The John Connor of The Walking Dead Andrew Lincoln years ago said that if Rick were to be killed off the way he’d want it is for it to be Carl that put him down He can never get that wish of what he felt was best for the character Then by Season 8 they performed a whole character switch as if Season 7 Carl didn’t want All the smoke Like he wasn’t the one who was like y’all got me fucked up and popped off the battle at Alexandria Now don’t get me wrong Carl was also a sympathetic person he was always trying to help people even if it meant going against his father so the Siddiq storyline doesn’t bother me as it’s in character of him But to change him from Mr Knuck If You Buck at the end of Season 7 to We Are The World during Season 8 without any form of transition or development is absolutely ludicrous and absolutely poor storytelling It made no sense And to kill him off the way they did it was disrespectful I get they wanted to do the Anyone can get bit at anytime all it takes is a second shit but it was still trash if you were going to kill don’t give him that basic ass death.
Now onto the controversy of this whole fuckery Now most fans were upset by the killing of Carl Now Chandler was now 18 years old He has just graduated from high school so most fans assumed that he wanted to leave especially since we knew he was headed for college (he was also doing producing music for fun) with the idocity of Carl’s death instead of sending him away for a possible return despite were hurt fans respected Chandlers decision They did a whole big thing on The Talking Dead on his final episode and everything he’s on there talking about him going to college and everything Makes sense He grew up on the show Maybe he wanted his future to be something different Skip to the next day Chandlers pissed off father spills the tea that Chandler didn’t quit he was FIRED Scott Gimple had told Chandler before the new Season that he wanted him for at least 3 more years He agreed to stay on the show chose to attend college in Georgia and even brought a house between the show and and his school so he could be able to do both Scott Gimple knew this and said nothing Chandler had no warning about his death In fact the reason he found out only two episodes before was because Gimple came to the set and told him while they were filming the unknown bite scene and needed him to give off the right expressions for when they showed the flashback reveal So imagine finding out you’re being killed off as you’re filming the scene Imagine after being told you’re being kept made your college decision and noise based on it so you can continue your job only to be fired From my understanding Chandler decided to take a year off before starting college afterwards (I don’t know if he ever went) When fans found out they were pissed Casual viewers probably still don’t know this information So not only did they unnecessarily kill off Carl for (spoilers) it wasn’t even Chandlers decision He wanted to stay on the show planned his whole around it so he was able to do so only to get screwed over A major theory about why was because had now turned 18 and with that and being a main cast member his contract was to be done with a pay increase as he was no longer a minor They simply didn’t want to pay him especially what he deserved so they got rid of him Because they didn’t pay up And honestly you can tell his departure left a mark on not only the show but definitely the actors.
Scott Gimple almost go a diss track from my ass because of this fuckery lol.
The 2nd mistake was killing off Henry after giving him Carl's storyline.
If you are going to write a book, use punctuation marks. Your comment is just nonsensical gibberish.
In season three when Rick didn’t make sure Andrew was dead when he chased him into that courtyard. He got away, then came back for revenge then that led to the deaths of Lori and T dog.
Actually, I think Lori would've died either way.
Who is Andrew?
@@debmorton3310 he was one of the five prisoners that they found at the beginning of season three.
@@annafowdy but she would have had a better chance of surviving if Hershel had been there to help with the delivery. Also it was the stress of that situation that Andrew caused that made her go into labor in the first place.
Killing off Carl then Rick leaving the next season was so bad I bet they didn’t know Andrew Lincoln was planning on leaving during season 10
He left during the first half of season 9
andrew left BECAUSE carl got fired, he said the show writers were unjust and that it got him thinking of his own family, so he quit to spend time with them
I'd say the dumbest mistake was Rick and his group attacking the satellite outpost that ended up sparking the Saviour war. If Rick had gone with Morgan's more peaceful approach then I honestly think that Negan would have backed down a bit from almost bleeding Hilltop and the Kingdom dry as he would have wanted to keep his people safe by not allowing conflict to occur.
I agree
Negan back down.... 🧐??? Doubtful
That’s why I didn’t care when Glenn died. They invaded territory and killed people in their sleep.
Rememeber the photographs on the wall.
The mistake was faulty intelligence. Starting a fight with an enemy of undetermined strength. Crucial mistake in any war.
Dale didn't get bit by the walker, it tore his stomach/chest area open with it's hands. Rick was hoping to save him but Hershal made him realize that he couldn't be saved so Rick shot him to end his suffering
Daryl shot him btw
@@itsrk3063 oh right he was about to and then Daryl did it
Darryl shot him
@@jaevargas5625 yes I know I remember that now
I never like curl
i dont mind Carl getting killed, but him getting bitten (for saving a total stranger)... common, of all things, he haven't learn anything from his father. dumb writing. that's the last episode i seen that makes me rage quit.
And then the fact the guy eventually died anyway!! So he gave up his life for NOTHING!! At least have him get bit saving his dad's (Rick) life!!!!
@@bigdaddygru They all die "anyway" at some point. Keep in mind that given Judith's age, there is at least a good 10+ year time jump from Carl's death to Siddiq's death so it's not like he died for nothing as Siddiq did a lot for the community.
@@markjones5672 pretty sure it was about six years but the point still stands
Dubbest mistake Negan said it himself. Not killing all of Ricks group instead of just 2 of them.
I STILL don't understand Lori "Cowboying Up" and driving off like she did in season 2 - it absolutely made ZERO sense at all. She was never more capable then being the den mother for the group and clearly couldn't handle herself, what the hell was she thinking driving off by herself?
There is wayy too many dumb mistakes characters make in the show. Like how Andrea just decides to trust the governor immediately and too many decisions Rick made. Their decisions are so irritating at times
Killing Shane, Carl, and Glenn were the biggest mistake in the whole series.
Shane could have died tho, but not after 2 season's. He carried the show for 2 seasons and was by far one of the best characters in the series.
When Carl died, the show lost its heart. When Rick left, the show lost its soul.
Whatever remained is just someone's fanfic.
I feel like I’m alone but the show got even better when those happened. Season 9 is my second favorite season and it has barely any rick and no Carl. They did great with the story after writing them off
@@BoogSReviews I agree completely 👍
I think their dumbest mistakes is that the zombies can turn invisible, I mean you look around there are no walkers then you look back BOOM, a walker jumpscares you
Andrea didn't know it was Daryl when she shot him. She thought it was a Walker. The way Carl died and how Scott Gimple did Chandler Briggs dirty was definitely a stupid decision
Man.. the camera man is just built different….. he survived the whole show!
3:12 Well Eugene once told negan, what his profession was before the outbreak (working for a pharmacist producing/breeding Diseases, curing other diseases with them "fighting fire with fire"), so the makers could have used that to twist the plot in the entire series...
Like he could be involved in the origins of the virus...
Now THIS is a video ive been waiting for, so many easily avoidable mistakes on the characters parts.
Not shooting Negan when ppl had sooooooo many chances while he was dialoguing out in the open. Like that's just plot armor to the max
Show left out his insurance policy he had for that. There were actually more ppl waiting to invade if they started trouble
Another thing, is the huge shootouts they would have, when hardly anybody is getting hit...they all just empty their guns wildly, shooting the shit out of everything. I mean, with a limited supply of ammo, you would think they would be more careful what they shot at.
Dumbest mistake - killing off Karl just as he became likeable but keeping Carol in the show for soooooo long
They should have killed Andrea off in the first season and let her sister live. The one playing her sister was a better actress.
@@brianporter9430 they ruined andrea in the show, shes so cool in the comics
Please apologise for insulting Carol, she's an absolute badass and has such a great character development, all up until season 9. After that she is still an interesting, but it get's weird, because they try to make her and Daryl the Main Characters, which doesn't really work with them, as they both are "lone wolf"-type of characters. It just takes from them...
Although a number of people think it was a smart move to lead the walkers out of town, I thought it was the dumbest mistake of the show and ultimately cost a lot of lives. The walkers were contained in a quarry. In a later episode it shows that the group had a gasoline truck. I would have closed the gap, gathered up as much flammable material as possible and saturated the pit with gasoline. They could have also found barrels, bales of hay, etc. to roll into the quarry, then light it all on fire 🔥 The End!
I thought the same thing…
Yes! That’s what I said too!!
They didn't wanna give the actor that played Carl a raise in pay so that's why they killed him off.
Don't do it 2fallon it's A SCAM
I thought they did it so they could do a time skip
It is true. AMC didn’t want to give a salary raise since he was turning 18. I believe that is a major reason why Andrew Lincoln left the series.
Which was stupid when they didn't have to add new characters and pay those actors
Time after time Rick made terrible decisions to put them in danger and move the story along.
How did you manage to forget Tyrese death ?
T dog was already hit, he just gave up his life for Carol cause he knew he didn’t have long anyways.
@@owiebaloney7494 He means Tyrese, not T-Dog
@@owiebaloney7494 smh
"What horrible train of thought...?" Nice pun.
Beth's death was so dumb. What TF was she thinking?! Andrea not killing the governor but tv Andrea just did a lot of stupid crap. Something that's always bugged me is the Sophia thing. As a mom I would have kicked Lori, hard, because I AM going after my baby and I will die with her or for her, I'm not leaving it up to chance. Sophia would have lived. Carol could have quietly gone along with Rick.
I still think that the plan to lead the dead out of the quarry to be someone else’s problem was a terrible decision. They were nicely contained. How about rolling down barrels of oil dumping rubbish and other flammable items into the quarry, and setting it all on fire?
what about when rick tried to lure away 2 walkers and left sophia alone? that part always makes me frustrated, i understand everyone was beginning to deal with the walkers but that was pretty dumb to leave her alone scared and vulnerable
What abt putting sophia in a barn filled with walkers?
Letting the only doctor go out on a scavenging trip was dumb
killing Carl was the second dumbest thing the walking dead has ever done.
if I was Robert Kirkman I would have sued amc.
Eugene revealing Alexandria was a good thing because they were dealing with walkers and starvation. Eugene left before the whisperers were finished, the whole idea was to get help in dealing with them
#11 the fake out death of Glen. "realistically" he wouldn't have survived that. Having a dead body on top of yours getting ripped apart and not your own with how fast/brutual they rip apart people...lol glenn wouldn't be able to escape.
The still have organs flesh skin,etc to go through and the walkers aren’t smart im pretty sure he could’ve got out of that😂
@@korruptgamer5608 with how many was shown, and how fast they go through a body, glen wouldn't escape...but because he's a main they made it so.
Well actually the zombie didn't bite Dale it only ripped his stomach open with its hands when he tried to hold it back but yeah that was a pretty dumb mistake on Carl's part
#1 Screwing over Frank Darabont
And the fact that Saddiq dies anyways is like there was no point in Carl saving him
the thumbnail nailed it lol
Oh yeah
Camping in the woods when there are thousands of abandoned buildings to live in.
Oh, yeah, Rick leads the Anderson family right through the pack of zombies in Alexandrea(which were there because of his failed attempt to lead them out of town.) How about sneaking around the back, thru the backyards?
2:03 “After Rick fails to return from a venture into town” let’s just point out that from what we can see it was literally 5 minutes after Rick left.
Andrea didn't know it was Daryl, he came out of the Forrest looking like a zombie
True but Rick was going to handle the walker without wasting a bullet and possibly drawing more from the noise of the gunshot.
@@christineleatherwood7987 were they thinking like that in season 2? I thought they were still too scared for zombie combat
@@macbook802Rick was going out to kill it and tells Andrea "we will handle it" or something like that so i think Rick and Shane were okay with killing walkers with melee weapons...but also in season 1 T-Dog and Morales had baseball bats when they met Rick.
Basically everything Andrea did
A dumb mistake was Daryl crashing a truck into the Sanctuary when it was surrounded by walkers and starving out the Saviors. All he had to do was wait half a day and they would have won.
Andrea was the kind of person NOBODY wants in their survivor troop.
I thought killing off Carl was a dumb mistake at the time, but that actor couldn't act worth shit. Ricks daughter that basically takes on what his comics role was, was a muuuuuch better actor!
The dumbest mistake was dragging the show on 5 seasons longer than necessary while making unconscionable deviations from the source material.
Henry's movements got a lot of people killed, he was so mad at Enid he try force himself into something with Lydia, he was annoying for a while but that took the biscuit
Dragging things out is the dumbest mistake. They lost their audience with dragging season 7 on and on with fans believing it was all build up to an epic showdown and then we got season 8 and it was even more boring than season 7 lol
Dumbest mistakes is not learning enough and not going to school to have easier life my leg just hurts
Beth's death made me so angry. It was such a pointless death.
You’ve forgot when they went to find terminus, they were hoping to find a new home but then got captured by canibles
Biggest mistake was Rick and Michonnes exit that was weak and will be resolved with a spin off series
That spin off series, if it happens, is going to be so weak!! It's too late to bring Rick back now, they just need to end it!
2 More Mistakes: Lizzie thinking Walkers were People and Killing her Sister to make a Point and Tyreese going into Noah's House and not Paying Attention to the Walker.
Lizzie was a kid who went insane in that crazy world.
0:43. In other words, **DON'T** go batty. **wack!!**
The most dumbest mistake was killing carl to make people mad and sad
Honestly Andrea shooting him should have been #1 by a mile. She's not a skilled enough shot to be shooting between two living people at that range. IF I were Rick or Shane and had got back I would have smacked her as hard as I possibly could for that, then barred her from having guns. Andrea is the type of character you'd get if you got some left leaning New York type feminist in your group. "I can do everything the big boys can" with the whole mindset of having something to prove, that combined results in painfully foolish behavior like almost blowing 3 different guy's heads off trying to prove to them she can do it. THAT scene and that character proves why women shouldn't be cops.
I stopped watching the show back in S6. When I heard they actually killed off Carl I was baffled, since the entire last third of the comics were all about Carl.
Bro The dumbest thing they did is killing carl off.
The dumbest mistake was rick cutting his hand off
"Carl Grimes eventually becomes a professional walker slayer" - Did you forget it was a walker that killed him? lol
That was exactly the point they were trying to make.
Lorie driving with the map is how we did it back in the olden times before google maps
Andrea was the queen of poor decisions.
Absolute dumbest mistake: Daryl killing glenn by attacking Negan. Because of you, Maggie is pissed, Negan is alive and the show only got 11 seasons
I knew that Carl's death was going to be number 1.
Same
be became pretty boring and even annoying in his later seasons
the only and biggest problem with his death was, that the shows point of Rick building a safe world for him disappeared into nothing - which is... sad but actually realistic in such scenario.
one of the dumbest to me is when Eastman got bit, dude seemed like he was always on his toes only to get bit by one right in front of him and could've easily pushed Morgan away or grabbed him or something lmao
imagine ending the show without showing rick grimes. that would be the dumbest.
Or, him being gone for so long but magically pops up in the final scene in the series finale!! Now THAT would be dumb!!!