When Chorong is crying, it kind of remind me when Taemin meet Timoteo in The UNIT and then rain ask him about his best friend performance and then Taemin begin to cry.
Back in 2012, for a few months, I was lucky to work with CHI-CHI at a very cute building in Sinsa, Seoul which was Trophy Entertainment's HQ. While the girls were practising hard on the first floor, we were busy writing songs at the basement studio, for them and Andamiro (the other artist of the company, now Anda under YGX/Amoeba). I remember Azi (Bae Seo Yul here) and the rest of the girls (CHI-CHI was a 5 member girl group by then) and how hard working and cheerful they were. Except many original songs that didn't get to be released since they disbanded, I created an official remix for Love Is Energy where me and CHI-CHI appear at the beginning of the video. They have also signed 50 CDs that were sent to some of my subscribers from back then. Although they had to disband some time later, they remain a beautiful memory to many of us, and they have been a great inspiration.
It must’ve been quite hard for Apink too, when most of their colleagues have disbanded or in hiatus. Apink made great bonding with most of them while promoting together and finding some of them alone now while they’re still active as a group must be very emotional. I really admire Apink for recognizing her. That just means that they truly respect their colleagues. 💖
Yes, it was hard for Apink too..but I don't think they get emotional because they see a former colleagues. It was simply because the story was sad, if not heartbreaking. Even viewers who is not by anymeans related to CHI CHI teared up..becauss of emphaty. Chorong miight have felt the melancholy of a failed dream that's why she get's emotional. It could have been Apink who are in her shoes if fate played differently.
when they chose her because they wanted to give her chance to sing again on stage just like what they did before makes me sad and happy. I'm so lucky to stan these six fairies 😭❤️
Apink never change and still humble [at how they still remember their colleagues, respect their sunbae and hoobae groups] we stan that. All of them have good personality. That is one of the reasons Apink still slay .They overcomes 7years jinx. APINK X PANDA. APINK COMEBACK....... PLAY M PLEASE
I'm happy that they recognized her. It must've felt great for her to not be forgotten, even the music. A man is only truly dead when forgotten. Also, for anyone upset about my usage of "man" here, it can refer to a person regardless of gender. It feels wrong that I even feel the need to preemptively edit this comment and add this because there are idiots in the world who don't understand language.
@@nodamekira8580 “When does a man die? When he is hit by a bullet? No! When he suffers a disease? No! When he ate a soup made out of a poisonous mushroom? No! A man dies when he is forgotten!” Although variations of the quote have been said in various places.
Ever since I watched ICSYV I imagine that there will be a time that the guest recognized one of the singers and chose them to perform with them to the end, and now Apink did it and I'm happy for them.
The genuineness, compassion, and sympathy that Chorong has for others is just beautiful, and precisely the reason I've come to love Apink more and more since their debut days. I love each and every one of Apink members and I can't wait for their comeback this year! (Play M, I'm serious, like get on it, we need a comeback....PLEASE. Thanks for the concert though 😆)
The reason why Apink decided to sing the final stage with this member from ChiChi is because , if she really debuted as an idol before, they wanted to give her another chance to sing on stage.
Apink is awesome, first Eunji tones down her voice to let the contestant shine and then Chorong is brought to years thinking about other’s struggles. Love them!
Am I the only one who kept replaying Apink's live singing at the start? One thing that I am always proud of them is their stable vocals 😍 Apink, it's been 9 years but let's stay together forever ❤️
Awww i expect another silly n funny moments from our grannies. This is pretty sad actually n the fact Apink remembered her shows they never forget their rookies life trying to survive the harsh industry.
Awww I didn’t know about this until today when I felt like rewatching their old love is energy mv and saw people talk about this. I’m glad they were able to recognize her cause it’s gotta be sad to have been forgotten and I’m also glad she’s able to make money being a realtor
still can remember her, and choose her because they wanted to give another chance to perform on stage again.. that's why i keep stand for them. Apink Being Apink ❤
After ICSYV, you'll understand why Apink can receive love for such a long time even if you are not stanning them / they are not even close to your favourite group. I'm a happy pink panda by watching this whole episode of I Can See Your Voice. You can see their sincere & good personality. Let's hope the group goes on for a long time~ 💕
Every people have their own life... disband not a reason to give up... disband is just way to open new chapters in their life... so sad to see chorong crying... it make me feel sad to... We will always support Apink no matter what happens
Apink, please don't disband. After seeing chorong crying, I just couldn't shake my bad feeling off my chest. and then I heard Eunji's acrostic poem about 4-1-9. Please don't disband. 😢
Ah, I remember chi chi has 1 member looking like gyuri of kara. Also I remember their song 'love is energy' that has hand blender dance. That song is so nice. Also their song 'longer' is my fav.
Aawwee 🥺💖 Almost cried watching this. I still remember when they were all rookies, and how iconic the hand blender dance of CHI CHI is. I feel you Chorong.
I am so proud with my girls.. they recognized her😢 and imagine Bomi the pabo and always to forget things but was able to remember her.. so cute ~~ I love you Apink 💕
Probably the best episode in ICSYV because not only the viewers, audiences learned something, so is the performers & APink. Life is so fragile & unpredictable but it comes around one day.
I AM FAN OF CHICHI 😭😭 TOO HARD TO FINDING THE OTHER MEMBERS SINCE CHICHI DISBANDED EXCEPT SHINE(LEE SIA) WHO BECOME AN ACTRESS NOW. AZI! I MISS YOU SO MUCHH
You can see that hayoung is really apink's maknae in this video. Her cute voice when she said "it's really chi chi!", her shining and confused eyes before they sing omg💔💔💔
I'm so glad I found this! I was a huge fan of CHI CHI and was so sad they disbanded - seeing Azi perform onstage again was really really cool. And it's awesome that her song is on Spotify so I can hang onto it! Thanks Mnet, this totally made my day.
I love when the put the unnie vs Dongsaeng line. Apink make my day. Oh my when they say chi chi it totally remind me of one the song that I like which their signature of the hand dance really amazing and the song too but suddenly disappeared from kpop. She is the one of the member and I understand Chorong feeling's towards her. Oh my.. Tq Apink for recognizing them.
I have this feeling for their comeback this year... Hope my feeling for their comeback will true.. Missing Apink.. Apink is one the respected GG in kpop Era.. And their songs travel thru time it never gets old.. 😊 😊 😊 😊
![[ENG sub] I can see your voice 7 [2회] 너목보를 나오고 싶어했던 '오빠'를 위해 무대에 선 동생(남민정) '그 자리에 그 시간에' 200124 EP.2](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ezjg9y9OtDk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG sub] I can see your voice 7 [2회] 너목보를 나오고 싶어했던 '오빠'를 위해 무대에 선 동생(남민정) '그 자리에 그 시간에' 200124 EP.2](/img/tr.png)
![[ENG sub] I can see your voice 6 [3회] 군입대 앞둔 로꼬를 위한 여군 하사 ver '데칼코마니' 190201 EP.3](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BbftGIVwHNU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] 고려대학교 축제 에이핑크 (Apink) Mr. Chu | 240521 석탑대동제 KUTOPIA 1일차](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/b9OpZZ95QAc/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ ENG SUB ] MC Haewon @ 20th Century Hit Song (240223)](/img/n.gif)
To think that they can recognize her after many years have passed....Apink really pay attention to others.
I really appreciate how apink recognized her after how many years since debut of chichi
Apink and chichi debuted 2011
An bomi remeber also the song of chichi
Apink really gives the stage to their fellow girl group who not able to perform for a very ling time.
제 채널에 합 4만원받을수 있는 이벤트 올려놨어요~ 294
제 채널에 합 4만원받을수 있는 이벤트 올려놨어요~ 897
11년도에 걸그룹만해도 약200팀이 데뷔했었는데 데뷔동기팀명이라도 잊지않고 기억하고 있는것도 대단한데 심지어 얼굴까지 잊지않고 기억하는건 진짜 대단한거고 상대방에대한 예의가 들어남
그리고 11년도에 섹시 걸그룹이 넘치듯 데뷔할때 청순 걸그룹으로 데뷔해서 지금까지 살아남은거도 너무 대견하고 보기좋음
찾아보니 에이핑크만 살아남 다망함 그 년도에 데뷔한 그룹 ㄷㄷ
들어남 ....소름이다
멍청함이 드러나네
When Chorong is crying, it kind of remind me when Taemin meet Timoteo in The UNIT and then rain ask him about his best friend performance and then Taemin begin to cry.
It have same feeling there...
에이핑크가 데뷔한 2011년도 역대급으로 많은신인들 데뷔한년도였음 지금까지 활동하는 에이핑크도 대단한거고 치치라는 그룹 기억하고있던 맴버들의 마음도 참 여러가지 생각들었을것같다
Back in 2012, for a few months, I was lucky to work with CHI-CHI at a very cute building in Sinsa, Seoul which was Trophy Entertainment's HQ. While the girls were practising hard on the first floor, we were busy writing songs at the basement studio, for them and Andamiro (the other artist of the company, now Anda under YGX/Amoeba). I remember Azi (Bae Seo Yul here) and the rest of the girls (CHI-CHI was a 5 member girl group by then) and how hard working and cheerful they were. Except many original songs that didn't get to be released since they disbanded, I created an official remix for Love Is Energy where me and CHI-CHI appear at the beginning of the video. They have also signed 50 CDs that were sent to some of my subscribers from back then. Although they had to disband some time later, they remain a beautiful memory to many of us, and they have been a great inspiration.
I've always wanted "Longer" to be remixed by you. You other two remixes for them were good!
🥺❤️
저분 울컥했을 것 같다 .. 내 눈에만 울기 직전으로 보이는지는 모르겠는데 .. 해체 후 사람들의 기억속에서 사라지고 어쩔 수 없이 가수의 꿈을 아예 접은 상태인데 저들로 인하여 자신을 기억해주는 사람이 있다는것을 알게된거잖아 진짜 고마웠을듯 ㅜㅜ
Chichi already disbanded eventho in the past they are debut in the same year. Chorong felt so emotional bcs of that 😢
Lies...
Chorong was crying bcuz she misses me...😟
Steve LOL😂😂
@@Steve-ls3lr what the 😂😂😂
Hahahhahaa
@@Steve-ls3lr lol
에이핑크가 4번 미스터리 싱어 고른이유가 만약에 걸그룹출신이 맞다면 다시 한 번 무대 같이 하고싶어서라고 그랬음 에이핑크 마음씨가 너무예뻐ㅜ
초롱이 마음씨가 진짜..
에이핑크 사랑해요ㅜㅜ
It must’ve been quite hard for Apink too, when most of their colleagues have disbanded or in hiatus. Apink made great bonding with most of them while promoting together and finding some of them alone now while they’re still active as a group must be very emotional. I really admire Apink for recognizing her. That just means that they truly respect their colleagues. 💖
Yes, it was hard for Apink too..but I don't think they get emotional because they see a former colleagues. It was simply because the story was sad, if not heartbreaking. Even viewers who is not by anymeans related to CHI CHI teared up..becauss of emphaty. Chorong miight have felt the melancholy of a failed dream that's why she get's emotional. It could have been Apink who are in her shoes if fate played differently.
Even apink now have upcoming new reality show for them this month, queen indeed😘
@@pleasesubscribetomychannel2446 what's their new reality show?
Especially since Chi Chi disbanded so harshly.
Chorong lead them pretty well
when they chose her because they wanted to give her chance to sing again on stage just like what they did before makes me sad and happy. I'm so lucky to stan these six fairies 😭❤️
They are truly fairies #panda #apinkforever 💞❤💕🐼
Apink never change and still humble [at how they still remember their colleagues, respect their sunbae and hoobae groups] we stan that. All of them have good personality. That is one of the reasons Apink still slay .They overcomes 7years jinx. APINK X PANDA. APINK COMEBACK....... PLAY M PLEASE
True
Dont disband apink pleaseeeee
Play M
We are panda always support APINK for ever
GUESS WHAT THEY REALLY DID CAME BACK AHHH
Even their agency changes name in muliple times but Apink still same
초롱이 눈물의 의미가 참 예쁘다.. 무대가 얼마나 값지고 간절한지 에이핑크도 공백기를 겪고, 컴백을 기다리며 팬들이 떠나지는 않을지 불안한 마음으로 지낸 나날도 있기에 누구보다 잘 알텐데, 무대가 그리워서 나온 10년 전 데뷔 동기의 마음에 얼마나 이입됐을까..
1:14 미스터츄 시작. 춤추며 노래하는 것만 듣다가 저렇게 부르는 걸 들으니 너무 예쁘게 들려서 몇 번을 보고 또 봤는지 모르겠네요
10년전 동료가수까지 기억하는 에이핑크...
초롱언니 목소리 너무 부드럽고 듣기좋다ㅜㅜㅜ
I'm happy that they recognized her. It must've felt great for her to not be forgotten, even the music.
A man is only truly dead when forgotten.
Also, for anyone upset about my usage of "man" here, it can refer to a person regardless of gender. It feels wrong that I even feel the need to preemptively edit this comment and add this because there are idiots in the world who don't understand language.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 wen u said idiots
Man here is human being, it's okay just ignore them
Cottidae One Piece's reference yo
@@nodamekira8580
“When does a man die? When he is hit by a bullet? No! When he suffers a disease? No! When he ate a soup made out of a poisonous mushroom? No! A man dies when he is forgotten!”
Although variations of the quote have been said in various places.
Those stupid feminists are driving me crazy anyway ur right she got a beautiful voice :)
대박 걸그룹 치치 멤버가 맞다니...!
엄청 긴장을 많이했었는데 다시 한번 방송에
출연해서 에이핑크 멤버들이랑 듀엣을 하게되니 다행이에요 서율 씨
우아 치치의 장난치지마 진짜 잘 들었었는데 ㅜㅜ 머하시는지 궁금했었는데 이렇게 알아가네요 !
메인래퍼였는데 저정도 보컬이면 선방하신거죠
That moment chorong start to cry. I'm crying along..
Ever since I watched ICSYV I imagine that there will be a time that the guest recognized one of the singers and chose them to perform with them to the end, and now Apink did it and I'm happy for them.
크 정은지 화음 보소
I'm addicted to Hayoung, Naeun and Chorong, Namjoo raw voices singing here 😍
This is such a touching moment its been almost 10 years and they still remembers their debut trainee members.. chorong pls dont cry 😭
The genuineness, compassion, and sympathy that Chorong has for others is just beautiful, and precisely the reason I've come to love Apink more and more since their debut days. I love each and every one of Apink members and I can't wait for their comeback this year! (Play M, I'm serious, like get on it, we need a comeback....PLEASE. Thanks for the concert though 😆)
And they just comeback last month, and I thing it so successful🏆💪
Wah, Apink's voice when singing Mr. Chu is so soft in his ears
Ofcourse they can recognize her, queens reigning for almost 9 years this year, they know many idol groups, old and new.
Apink comeback!!!!
when chorong start to cry, yeaah it's chorong with the softness heart
Our Rong-leader is just so precious. Chorong loves Apink so much that the thought of them disbanding brought tears to her eyes
I still love Chorong's voice. No one has a similar voice to her.
always smiling when I hear her voice... cute voice😍
The reason why Apink decided to sing the final stage with this member from ChiChi is because , if she really debuted as an idol before, they wanted to give her another chance to sing on stage.
Apink is awesome, first Eunji tones down her voice to let the contestant shine and then Chorong is brought to years thinking about other’s struggles. Love them!
Am I the only one who kept replaying Apink's live singing at the start? One thing that I am always proud of them is their stable vocals 😍 Apink, it's been 9 years but let's stay together forever ❤️
The starting performance is always a lip sync one. It's the show's signature
@@GiangKero i think he mean at the start of this video
This shows why APINK is a legend, no matter how big you became, you cannot forget the people who dreamt with you and always with you. 😊
2011년에 데뷔한 걸그룹 중에는 에이핑크가 유일하게 살아남은 그룹이니 데뷔동기를 오랜만에 만나니 짠하네여.
와....공부해서 자격증까지 땄구나.
진짜 대단하고 멋지다.
노래 너무 잘하고 목소리도 다 너무 이쁘다
우우우아아아 롱 언니 울지마요
Awww i expect another silly n funny moments from our grannies. This is pretty sad actually n the fact Apink remembered her shows they never forget their rookies life trying to survive the harsh industry.
Azi used to my bias in ChiChi before they disband...I miss ChiChi so much...I'm glad that Apink recognised her...~
Chorong unnie don't cry 😭🤧🙂
Awww I didn’t know about this until today when I felt like rewatching their old love is energy mv and saw people talk about this. I’m glad they were able to recognize her cause it’s gotta be sad to have been forgotten and I’m also glad she’s able to make money being a realtor
still can remember her, and choose her because they wanted to give another chance to perform on stage again.. that's why i keep stand for them. Apink Being Apink ❤
chorong is a kind hearted person😍😍😍😍
After ICSYV, you'll understand why Apink can receive love for such a long time even if you are not stanning them / they are not even close to your favourite group. I'm a happy pink panda by watching this whole episode of I Can See Your Voice. You can see their sincere & good personality. Let's hope the group goes on for a long time~ 💕
Bomi was right.. she was from a gg called chichi that promoted with apink before
actually it was chorong who said it to bomi
Well, both of them look each other, remember that she was the member of chichi. Then bomi spill their reaction to the mc..
왠지 눈물 나올 것 같더라ㅜㅜ
에이핑크맴버들과 4번 히든싱어랑 같이 노래를 불렀는데 실력자였다는거
I WATCHED THIS SO MANY TIMES. BUT WHEN CHORONG UNNIE CRIED, I ALSO CRIED
Every people have their own life... disband not a reason to give up... disband is just way to open new chapters in their life... so sad to see chorong crying... it make me feel sad to... We will always support Apink no matter what happens
Chorong is so soft, i hope she'll get the best everyday in her life❤
another win....this season guest is so good
They had to make up for what happened in the first episode.😂😂😂
Qayyum Ahmad why? What happened to their first episode?
에이핑크 너무 좋앙
Naeun so pretty...her voice so lovely💕💕
Oh my. The fact that I used to obsess over Chi Chi’s Longer got me crying. 🥺🥺 Please do listen to Longer, it sounds so nice even after 8 years.
eunji's smile
Chorong ....don't cry 😣
The girl who cried is really amazing... She's very down to earth i love how she feel for her fellow artist♥️♥️♥️
Same 😭 She's Apink's leader Park Chorong ❤ she's so caring
Must be such an emotional moment for her coz they recognized her
When Mr. Chu started to play I don't know why i cried. I just missed apink. Please stay healty.
Apink, please don't disband. After seeing chorong crying, I just couldn't shake my bad feeling off my chest. and then I heard Eunji's acrostic poem about 4-1-9. Please don't disband. 😢
It's so emotional to see her still being recognized by the girls...I mean,they debuted at the same year and had the same dream
초롱이는 리더인 이유가 있네ㅋㅋ
이유가 뭘까요?
김기현 초롱이때문에 멤버들 재계약한 거에요~~
Ah, I remember chi chi has 1 member looking like gyuri of kara. Also I remember their song 'love is energy' that has hand blender dance. That song is so nice. Also their song 'longer' is my fav.
omggg yes yes same with me, I still remember :'(
@@amaninazakaria2935 I'm amazed that I can remember them. I wish they have a good life
I'm actually a little surprised that Love Is Energy didn't blow up, it was unique and so good.
@@kweenyuri ikr. People start to notice them with that hand blender dance. If only the company promote them better
They were the first group that I stanned just to see 5 minutes later that they already disbanded :(
I still listen to Chichi's "Love is energy" and "Longer", I love these 2 songs♡
BOPS
Because of Azi,now i replaying chi chi old song like,love is energy(the helicopter hand),longer,I really miss all the early 2010's gg
와 ㅋㅋ 에이핑크 역시 존나예쁘다 ㅈㄴ잘부르고
아이즈원 원래 순위알려져있다고 말하시는분이시네요
Eunji❤❤
Aawwee 🥺💖 Almost cried watching this. I still remember when they were all rookies, and how iconic the hand blender dance of CHI CHI is. I feel you Chorong.
I am so proud with my girls.. they recognized her😢 and imagine Bomi the pabo and always to forget things but was able to remember her.. so cute ~~ I love you Apink 💕
its chorong who said to bomi about chi chi
This QUEEN never failed to amaze me.
it's so precious.. bomi still recognized her even tho it has been several years since they debuted.
10년전 일을 기억하네 ㄷㄷ
4:28 너무 많은 의미를 담은 눈물
Probably the best episode in ICSYV because not only the viewers, audiences learned something, so is the performers & APink. Life is so fragile & unpredictable but it comes around one day.
Chorong, the best leader💓
I AM FAN OF CHICHI 😭😭 TOO HARD TO FINDING THE OTHER MEMBERS SINCE CHICHI DISBANDED EXCEPT SHINE(LEE SIA) WHO BECOME AN ACTRESS NOW. AZI! I MISS YOU SO MUCHH
Do you know their Instagram?
They have come so far.. so proud of them...
Apink singin 1000% same as original song... Only legend can do
Queen with humble warm heart..so proud with Apink..❤❤❤❤❤🥰🥰😍😍
Love is energy & Longer is the best song of CHI-CHI. I think everyone like them.
I like when this show bring previous idols onto the show. I think it's interesting to see an update and see what former idols are up to now.
Like you
You can see that hayoung is really apink's maknae in this video. Her cute voice when she said "it's really chi chi!", her shining and confused eyes before they sing omg💔💔💔
A pink live so awesome
Shy person with amazing talent
Chorong really cares apink and dedicated to apink
they are 10years-girlgroup for a reason 😭❤️❤️❤️
Chorong leader please be strong even 2 members are gone
Who's the other one??i know naeun left apink but the other one I don't know
@@eurrrhea Yookyung, she left before nonono era
@@schaeisha1039 ahhhhh i know now she quit because she pursue her fashion designer passion hehwhehwh i search in google but thanks anyway
No one talk about how good Azi sang this song....I really continuously keep repeating it N times to listen it! (So good) I am Panda by the way
I'm so glad I found this! I was a huge fan of CHI CHI and was so sad they disbanded - seeing Azi perform onstage again was really really cool. And it's awesome that her song is on Spotify so I can hang onto it! Thanks Mnet, this totally made my day.
I'm gonna miss you longer....
My fav song, Chi Chi
I never regret stanning this girlgroup.
I am proud to be a Pink Panda.
그래도 공인중개사 멋있다ㅎㅎㅎㅎ진짜 어려운데
I really love chichi, their song ‘love is energy’ is great❤️❤️❤️ happy to see her come to the show
Apink you did well chosing the right contestant, and please do more tv show together
I love when the put the unnie vs Dongsaeng line. Apink make my day. Oh my when they say chi chi it totally remind me of one the song that I like which their signature of the hand dance really amazing and the song too but suddenly disappeared from kpop. She is the one of the member and I understand Chorong feeling's towards her. Oh my.. Tq Apink for recognizing them.
I have this feeling for their comeback this year... Hope my feeling for their comeback will true.. Missing Apink.. Apink is one the respected GG in kpop Era.. And their songs travel thru time it never gets old.. 😊 😊 😊 😊
I cry when chorong cry
Chorong don't cry ㅠㅠ
에이핑크 사랑해요~ ♡
Apink
Visual ✔️
Live vocal ✔️
Such a queen