SHOULD JAMMU & KASHMIR BE GIVEN STATEHOOD ? PROS & CONS !

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 січ 2025
  • Join this channel to get access to perks:
    / @harshitdwivedivideos
    Laxmikanth Book 6th Edition - amzn.to/2TfTTtu
    Spectrum Modern History Book - amzn.to/3oiepb3

КОМЕНТАРІ • 63

  • @Raindropppppp
    @Raindropppppp 2 місяці тому +19

    We kashmiri want kashmir to become a district.😢

    • @Ishabhardwaj0
      @Ishabhardwaj0 2 місяці тому +5

      The whole Kashmir (which had 10districts) to be combined as 1 ...Are you out of your mind??🤨

    • @Raindropppppp
      @Raindropppppp 2 місяці тому +1

      @@Ishabhardwaj0 sarcasm ha

    • @Raindropppppp
      @Raindropppppp 2 місяці тому

      @Ishabhardwaj0 didn't u got my point 😒

    • @Shakes_Pear
      @Shakes_Pear 2 місяці тому

      I want pir panchal to become a single village in Kashmir district 😊

    • @Shakes_Pear
      @Shakes_Pear 2 місяці тому +1

      I want pir panchal to become a single village in Kashmir district 😊

  • @sunilrajput6941
    @sunilrajput6941 2 місяці тому +7

    Restoration of statehood would be a step to deliver the complete justice to j&k

  • @Sankalp2n7t
    @Sankalp2n7t 2 місяці тому +7

    We want jobs first , students are suffering here in kashmir , there aren't any private sector in kashmir Govt jobs are limited...😢😢😢😢??!!

  • @amitmeenia4504
    @amitmeenia4504 2 місяці тому

    it took so long 😢 thank you for video again😊

  • @satyabratapadhi9654
    @satyabratapadhi9654 2 місяці тому +1

    Happy Diwali Harshit sir and Vineet sir ❤❤

  • @ArjunSingh-pl4si
    @ArjunSingh-pl4si 2 місяці тому +17

    We reject abrogation of article 370 n 35a......5th of August 2019 is a black day for whole people of Jammu and Kashmir

    • @خان_جنيد
      @خان_جنيد 2 місяці тому

      +1

    • @huihui-jc1ef
      @huihui-jc1ef 2 місяці тому +1

      Cry more with fake id

    • @Ishabhardwaj0
      @Ishabhardwaj0 2 місяці тому +1

      Are u a representative of whole J&k?? We're also from j&k and we're happy with the removal of Article 370. Look at the ground level you will see many positive changes

    • @خان_جنيد
      @خان_جنيد 2 місяці тому

      @@Ishabhardwaj0 could you please elaborate 😒

    • @Ishabhardwaj0
      @Ishabhardwaj0 2 місяці тому

      @@خان_جنيد Please go and search about the reduction in militancy , health infrastructures, Educational institutions , Access to govt schemes like Right to information, right to education, foreign investments, tourism , etc etc.
      And to be honest , I am telling you from my personal experience, visit to Kashmir is no more scary as before.
      Let's see , how our j&k will grow up❤️

  • @Raindropppppp
    @Raindropppppp 2 місяці тому +2

    Love u harshit and vineet sir .❤ from kashmir.

  • @YouTubeCustomer-pt2ge
    @YouTubeCustomer-pt2ge 2 місяці тому +3

    Hamein bas State hood chahiye bas.. Lg government hatne chahiye. Aaj yahan par fake encounters ho rahe hai bjp ki wajah se 😢

  • @sudhirmeher1618
    @sudhirmeher1618 2 місяці тому +1

    Sir please upload daily editorial and news analysis... I m begging you please sir

  • @nayairhussain4634
    @nayairhussain4634 2 місяці тому +6

    Ohhh really, aaj tak integrity ko frak nhi pada since independence.. Ur tilt to incumbent govt. Is clearly looking so try to balance ur thought,,, and for ur information people like u who r at the higher authorities due to which we haven't deliver complete justice bcoz in the name of national security u always trying to hide ur mistakes.

    • @ajaja112
      @ajaja112 2 місяці тому

      Jese apne Yogiji kahte h
      Jab tak Hindu ko kata jata rahe kisiko koi integrity, secularism, terrorism nahi dikhai deta. Jab J&K me terrorism kam ho gya tab tum jese librandu logo ko problem ho Rahi h
      I don't care whose govt it is, I believe what's important and absolutely necessary must be done, no matter how much people like you and lkfc cry over it

  • @kiara2718
    @kiara2718 2 місяці тому

    Thank you so much sir😊

  • @PriyankaSharma-1
    @PriyankaSharma-1 2 місяці тому

    Thanks Sir😊

  • @haseebacademy8977
    @haseebacademy8977 2 місяці тому

    Struggle of students is real, unemployment is a real problem in J&K, statehood must be granted back as assured by honorable ministers on the floor of parliament.

  • @preetamnaik9740
    @preetamnaik9740 2 місяці тому +1

    PROS
    1) DEMOCRATIC RIGHTS has got nothing to do with STATEHOOD because INDIA is a DEMOCRATIC COUNTRY (FLAW IN CONCEPT)
    2) THE UNION TERRITORIES are more STABLE than STATE GOVERNMENT. Pick up any EXAMPLE. (NO REAL LIFE EXAMPLE)
    CONS
    1)WHY will local politics lead to tensions CONSIDERING THEY want STATEHOOD. (There's flaw in the LOGIC)
    2) HOW can there be exploitation is THEY want STATEHOOD. (Again a LOGICAL FLAW)
    3) ALL STATES are somewhat dependent on FINANCE from the CENTRE. IF its a CON, It's CON for all STATES ( AGAIN a LOGICAL FLAW)
    PLEASE ADDRESS THE ABOVE DOUBTS
    IT WILL HELP US THE STUDENT COMMUNITY
    THANK YOU
    HAPPY DEEWALI

    • @girishshandilya8205
      @girishshandilya8205 2 місяці тому

      @@preetamnaik9740 Let's give you another perspective.
      Pros
      1. Agree with your first assertion
      2. Centre has more power vis a vis , Union Territories, so any issue regarding internal security (J&K is a hotbed of Internal and external security issues) can be dealt with easily and speedily rather than getting into the hassles of State centre tussles .(As we see every other day in case of West Bengal.)
      Cons
      1. Local politics has led to Kashmiri Pandit genocide and successive waves of exodus Kashmiri Hindus from the Valley of Kashmir, while the extremist forces had the tacit consent of the local political forces and community during that period. The majority community of the valley of Kashmir even got inspired by the extremists and played their part well in the Kashmiri Hindu exodus by showing community effervescence aginst the Hindu fold , many still holding and earning from the lands owned by Kashmiri Pandits who left the valley.
      3. The exploitation is done as is being done in West Bengal by Muslim hooligans supported by TMC, as was done in Kashmir during early 1990. Minority Hindu faces hardship and gets threatened wherever it becomes minority. I being a resident of J&K have a first habd experience of this problem, when I heard a 8-9 yrs old Muslim Boy comparing a Hindu majority locality in the neighborhood of his locality to a flush hole(toilet seat) and branding Hindus Kafir. Think about the level of filth his parents and the people of his locality may have for Hindus when a boy at that tender age has so much hatred for Hindus.
      3. J&K was and still is highly dependent upon Centre for its finances. I agree with you on this one. Most Hilly states of India don't have much revenue except seasonal Tourism.

  • @girishshandilya8205
    @girishshandilya8205 2 місяці тому +5

    I'm from Udhampur district of Jammu, where Northern Command of Indian Army has its headquarters. We don't want Statehood. We need our safety ,which is first priority for us than having a statehood. Bookish Knowledge and inflated democratic values look very good on paper, but ground realities differ
    1. We have elections as Delhi has elections. It doesn't take our democratic rights.
    2.We don't have much resources, we are mostly dependent upon GoI for our resources.
    We don't feel safe in the hands of Government run by Kashmiri hegemons who have a voter base inspired by a world's most radical ideology.
    National Security, Integrity and safety of J&K's minority are more important than having statehood

    • @AjaySingh-fg3cb
      @AjaySingh-fg3cb 2 місяці тому +1

      And I am from district reasi where as unemployment is at peak in jk

    • @girishshandilya8205
      @girishshandilya8205 2 місяці тому

      @AjaySingh-fg3cb Unemployment is a problem all over the world. But Unemployment is better than STSJ

    • @IlyasWani-l3h
      @IlyasWani-l3h 2 місяці тому +1

      Lundbakhth here ....go ask modi he has been running govt here frm 9 yrss go

    • @girishshandilya8205
      @girishshandilya8205 2 місяці тому

      @@sirisaacnewton____________5018 Thanks for showing your true colours, That's what your fundamentalist community wants , that's what it does to idol worshippers anywhere and everywhere they get the chance. Jammu Kashmir tumhare baap ka nhin hai jo Gujarat chale jaaun.

    • @shahi1322
      @shahi1322 2 місяці тому +1

      Dfa jev jk say

  • @Infyo-d6f
    @Infyo-d6f 2 місяці тому

    Class 8 ncert science padha dijiye sir please

  • @koushikroy.2002
    @koushikroy.2002 2 місяці тому

    Thank you sir

  • @infintyvlogger5522
    @infintyvlogger5522 2 місяці тому

    Restore statehood is mandatory for democracy

  • @MohdIqbal-us9ft
    @MohdIqbal-us9ft 2 місяці тому

    Sir agar modi gujrat state main union territory banaye ge tab main Maan sakta hu ki modi ne jandk k saath insaaf kiya hai baki gujrat, rajasthan,Punjab , Maharashtra,sari states border main he ati hai na waha pay sensitive issue nhi hai yeh question Mera ap say hai

    • @PawanGaur-r8d
      @PawanGaur-r8d 2 місяці тому

      But waha koi army par pathar nahi marta na koi terrorist activities hoti hai.

  • @Kapil63
    @Kapil63 2 місяці тому

    Acha mic lelo sir,, sunne b ni ho rha ese.

  • @sanamrashidmohd838
    @sanamrashidmohd838 2 місяці тому

    Hlo sir i m your mentorship course students plzz update us and plz extend the couse duration with new update atleast 1 yrs

  • @PradyumnaKumarMohanty-b8p
    @PradyumnaKumarMohanty-b8p 2 місяці тому

    No, for some years let it be union territory.
    Yes but some certain conditions.
    ‘Police’ must be either with central list or with concurrent list.
    Most of them will not agree.
    Because they want stone pelters.

  • @amirrrrrrrrrrrr1997
    @amirrrrrrrrrrrr1997 2 місяці тому

    Lgao hisab iska ab yh decide krega jandk ko state milni chahie ya ni khud iska ek EXAM ni NIKLA UPSC KA😅😅😅😅😅😅😅

  • @vijeta--Madhav
    @vijeta--Madhav 2 місяці тому

    sirr plzz ek bar sanjeev verma cover kr dijiye plzz sirrr

  • @AmirBashir-pd5rq
    @AmirBashir-pd5rq 2 місяці тому

    Unemployment rate high in jammu and Kashmir

  • @My_Cents
    @My_Cents 2 місяці тому +2

    🤣🤣🤣🤣 NO ✋️ STOP just Like BJP Voilated Art 370 Treaty Conditions agreed by India STOP this one too

  • @vsbhutiyal3844
    @vsbhutiyal3844 2 місяці тому

    370 abrogate krne ka gift mil gya hai centre ko... Nhi dein... State to aayegi hi ayegi...

  • @Rudra_7_7_7
    @Rudra_7_7_7 2 місяці тому

    Noo,we don't want that.

  • @aachmanpandey5892
    @aachmanpandey5892 2 місяці тому +2

    Sir mike is disturbing rest video is good😊

  • @Godparticle11
    @Godparticle11 2 місяці тому

    Abay luday kashmiri economy is dependent on toursim only 😅😅😅😅.

    • @yasirfirdous4673
      @yasirfirdous4673 2 місяці тому +2

      Apple, saffron, bat making factory nd many other things

  • @heartplayer9147
    @heartplayer9147 2 місяці тому

    Central bias is clear

  • @ajaja112
    @ajaja112 2 місяці тому +1

    In my opinion, Jammu should be given statehood and Kashmir should be made a UT.
    We can't tolerate having anymore terror attacks in our country.

    • @yasirfirdous4673
      @yasirfirdous4673 2 місяці тому +6

      Put this idea in ur àss, u r no one who will tell what to do what not to do

    • @girishshandilya8205
      @girishshandilya8205 2 місяці тому

      @@yasirfirdous4673 Wow , You really are someone, You have a talent to put your Ideas into your ass, You are an amazing human , You should be a Museum artifact.

    • @girishshandilya8205
      @girishshandilya8205 2 місяці тому

      @@yasirfirdous4673 wow, 🤯 You put your ideas up your ass, You have a great talent. You should either be in a circus performing such an amazing feat or you should be in a Museum