Budget Creates Tremors in Indi Alliance Unity | Middle Class Happy or Sad with Modi | Vijay Sardana

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 вер 2024
  • Analyse the recent budget's impact on the unity of the India Alliance and how it has affected the middle class's sentiment towards Prime Minister Modi. Vijay Sardana delves into the key budget provisions, their implications for different sections of society, and the political repercussions for the India Alliance.
    Contribute to JD Annual Summit Hindu Ecosystem Fund:
    www.jddigital....
    💰Support Jaipur Dialogues:
    UPI: jaipurdialogues@icici
    GPay: 9829255606
    PayTM/PhonePe - 9829255606@okbizaxis
    PayPal: paypal.me/jddi...
    🛕Monthly Subscriptions (Domestic/International): [JOIN]
    Website: www.jddigital....
    👕Buy Jaipur Dialogues Merch:
    shop.thejaipur...
    💬Join WhatsApp Channel & Group:
    Channel - whatsapp.com/c...
    Group - chat.whatsapp....
    WhatsApp Us - wa.me/8619317791
    🌐JD Website:
    thejaipurdialo...
    Accounts Details for Direct Transfer:
    Bank Name: AXIS Bank
    A/C Name: JD Digital Private Limited
    A/C No.: 920020063880439
    IFSC Code: UTIB0001645
    Swift Code: AXISINBB010
    Type: Current Account
    Email: contact@jddigital.in
    #Budget2024 #NirmalaSitharaman #ModiGovt #IndiaAlliance
    #TheJaipurDialogues

КОМЕНТАРІ • 786

  • @THEJAIPURDIALOGUES
    @THEJAIPURDIALOGUES  Місяць тому +23

    Contribute to JD Annual Summit Hindu Ecosystem Fund:
    www.jddigital.in/jd-annual-summit-fund/

    • @meenasinha2965
      @meenasinha2965 Місяць тому +1

      Middle class happy nahi hai....khanye pinye kai daily use kai saman par itana mahgayi uspar Sarkar kaya ki kuch nahi .....tax mai aur chut diya jata.....mahgayi par kab niyentran hoga bataye sarkar

    • @shaktivaderdristi
      @shaktivaderdristi Місяць тому

      Nah, unsubscribe

  • @KaushikkSahu-hp9dp
    @KaushikkSahu-hp9dp Місяць тому +99

    Middle class hi hindu ecosystem ka main source hai aur sarkar usi se naajane kya dushmani nikal rahi hai.

    • @vithalbitla
      @vithalbitla Місяць тому +2

      sirji jara bathayenge kya chahthe ho govt. se..

    • @ram6030
      @ram6030 Місяць тому +1

      Abolish income tax that's the requirement

    • @KrishnaKumarBaranwal-qr3xr
      @KrishnaKumarBaranwal-qr3xr Місяць тому +2

      Bhai sahab aapke pass thok me VOTE jo nahin hai, isliye Sarkar aapki parvaah nahin karti hai

    • @ADITIYASHARMA007
      @ADITIYASHARMA007 Місяць тому +1

      Galti govt ki nhi hai tere jaise logo ki hai
      Jab tu free fund me bjp ko vote dega toh unko kya padi hai middle class kaa soche😂😂😂

    • @KaushikkSahu-hp9dp
      @KaushikkSahu-hp9dp Місяць тому

      @@ADITIYASHARMA007 haan bhai abse nota dunga. Waise bhi agli baar bjp jitne nai wali

  • @HinduWarriorForever
    @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому +106

    हम हिंदू करों का भुगतान करते हैं, जबकि 12 बच्चे पैदा करने वाले हमारी मेहनत की कमाई पर लाभ का आनंद लेते हैं।

    • @Human_soul_n_mind
      @Human_soul_n_mind Місяць тому

      Kaun hai jo 12 bacche poida karte?

    • @Shiva99333
      @Shiva99333 Місяць тому +12

      BJP MUST PAY ATTENTION to this charge.

    • @HinduWarriorForever
      @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому

      असुरों का सर्वनाश आवश्यक है.
      @@Shiva99333

    • @HinduWarriorForever
      @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому

      Yes.
      Jai Shree Ram 🙏
      @@Shiva99333

    • @user-cd3sy3gs6r
      @user-cd3sy3gs6r Місяць тому

      A day will come when Hindus will have to leave their country, either accept Islam 😢😢😢😢😢😢

  • @HinduWarriorForever
    @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому +185

    Among tax payers, 97% are Hindus...but what are we getting for running this economy. Burden is always on us without benefits.

    • @shreyasneerebailoor
      @shreyasneerebailoor Місяць тому +10

      Kuchh mat bolo, Secularism hai..

    • @HinduWarriorForever
      @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому +20

      @@shreyasneerebailoor
      We have right to speak because We literally own everything in subcontinent. If we start "No Tax" movement. Saare non-Hiindus bhukh se tadap kar narak jayenge.

    • @Shiva99333
      @Shiva99333 Місяць тому +5

      एकत्रित कर का उपयोग तदनुसार निर्देशित किया जाना चाहिए -
      अन्यथा भारत एक असफल कल्याणकारी राज्य बन जायेगा।

    • @HinduWarriorForever
      @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому

      Venezuela
      @@Shiva99333

    • @HinduWarriorForever
      @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому

      Venezuelan strategy fails.
      @@Shiva99333

  • @HinduWarriorForever
    @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому +133

    Don't divert. Accept truth. Budget has nothing for middle class citizens.

    • @sstitta
      @sstitta Місяць тому +2

      Are you really Hindu warrior

    • @HinduWarriorForever
      @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому +11

      @@sstitta Suprabhat.
      Are you facing some issues in life from Green-Pests?

    • @muralidharsetlur2893
      @muralidharsetlur2893 Місяць тому +4

      🙏think about what we middle class are doing for the nation..We don't even vote.. Watching the TV. AND ENACT INTELLECTUALS involving in meaningless arguments and debate. We are directly responsible for the Jokers (opposition) occupying LS and RS seats🙏

    • @maxkak2149
      @maxkak2149 Місяць тому +2

      FDI from China is a master stroke, call for boycott the goods but increase trade and FDI

    • @HinduWarriorForever
      @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому

      @@maxkak2149 85 billion dollars(counting) trade deficit with Chiina is masterstroke??

  • @HinduWarriorForever
    @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому +59

    Nirmala is incapable. It seems she doesn't like middle class citizens.

    • @bhaswatimajumdar478
      @bhaswatimajumdar478 Місяць тому +12

      She is puppet

    • @HinduWarriorForever
      @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому +7

      @@bhaswatimajumdar478 puppet?

    • @HinduWarriorForever
      @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому +7

      @@bhaswatimajumdar478
      Puppet as in?
      Please elaborate.
      Thanks

    • @abhi1716
      @abhi1716 Місяць тому +13

      @@HinduWarriorForever In Modi cabinet, no one can take decisions. He needs chamchas or yes men. He is becoming so insecure about his position that he is willing to sacrifice whole party, Hindus, etc. He has become a megalomaniac who is not ready to realise ground reality.

    • @HinduWarriorForever
      @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому

      @@abhi1716
      I agree. Add to that, We all know modi' abides W.E.forum's diktats. Destroying native cultures and traditions to ashes is part of core agenda.

  • @gauravsabadra977
    @gauravsabadra977 Місяць тому +38

    Middle class extremely unhappy

  • @RN-vk6bn
    @RN-vk6bn Місяць тому +33

    It is shocking to know that FIR has been filed against Sanatani Sainik Gaurav Khattar in Congress ruled state of Karnataka. Each one must support him in whatever way possible.

    • @arvindpawar8585
      @arvindpawar8585 Місяць тому +1

      Yes, usko madad to karna chahiye lekin kaise ye pata hona jaroori he.

    • @reenatomar
      @reenatomar Місяць тому +1

      मोनू मानेसर, Maya kodnani to BJP ruled state me hi jail me hai. Unko to aapke Modi aur BJP valo ne hi JAIL me daala hai

    • @ADITIYASHARMA007
      @ADITIYASHARMA007 Місяць тому

      Agar kisi ne crime Kiya hai toh usse punishment milna chahiye

    • @kubrified1745
      @kubrified1745 Місяць тому

      @@RN-vk6bn Abe humein kya milega us se? BJP Karnataka Unit kya apni maa behen karwa rahi wahaan?

  • @biswadeep2010
    @biswadeep2010 Місяць тому +30

    Agar aur 5 Saal modiji Rahe aur aisa budget toh middle class saaf ho jayenge. Yeh na Hindu ka hai na middle class ka.

    • @VibhutiGaneshG
      @VibhutiGaneshG Місяць тому +2

      2012 में 2 lac तक टेक्स नहीं था .. अब ये 11 yrs मे 6.7% इंफलेशन जोड़ों तो आज 4.6 लाख तक आय कर नहीं होना चाहिए - मिडलकलास की ऐसी की तैसी हो चुकी हैं।

    • @RAHULSEN-og6mc
      @RAHULSEN-og6mc Місяць тому +3

      Sahi yeh sirf ambani and adani ke kiye hain no doubt , zara bhi sensitive nagi hain middle class + salaried logo ke liye jinhone isko 2024 me jitaya

    • @Chanakya831
      @Chanakya831 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@VibhutiGaneshG भाई आज के जमाने में जो आदमी महीने का 1 लाख कमा रहा है उसपर टैक्स नही होना चाहिए, पति पत्नी 2 बच्चे माँ बाप के लिए महीने का 1 लाख कुछ नही होता है, खर्चा निकल जाये वही बहुत है

  • @happyvolly
    @happyvolly Місяць тому +20

    विपक्ष का पता नही लेकिन मिडिल क्लास मे हडकंप. आने वाले चुनाव मे मिडिल क्लास इसका जवाब देगा फिर आप सब.मिलकर शोकसभा मनाना 😊😊

  • @gauravb777
    @gauravb777 Місяць тому +25

    Once upon a time, Narendra Modi asked people to give up their LPG subsidy. 1.13 crore people, mostly middle class, gave up that subsidy voluntarily. It is not that middle class does not want to help India's growth story. It is not that they don't want India's poor to benefit. It is just that they want to know why can't they get some relief? What have they gotten after 10 years of patience?
    And what relief do they want? They don't want the world from you. They just want to live honestly. Their children's school fee increases 10% every year. Their doctor's fees has doubled, even tripled, in last 10 years. Their house rent increases a minimum of 10% every year. Have their salaries increased in the same quantum? Heck, you have added insult to injury by increasing LTCG!
    This is a demoralising budget without any imagination. It will percolate through all the sections of society. If you think rural Bharat will be with you, this negativity will affect them too.
    I wonder if Modiji comes today and asks people to forego their subsidies voluntarily, would they?

    • @ravikiran4512
      @ravikiran4512 Місяць тому +1

      What subsidy, govt depositing approximately Rs10 to my account nowdays

    • @hooman6080
      @hooman6080 Місяць тому +1

      they'll not care about us now they thinks how can they make mistake even god can't convince them please don't waste your energy on these people just partway from them they're already start falling a apart it is just beginning.

    • @kubrified1745
      @kubrified1745 Місяць тому +2

      @@ravikiran4512 2 packets of Parle G is your subsidy, bro 💀

    • @kubrified1745
      @kubrified1745 Місяць тому

      @@hooman6080 How can God convince them? He himself is God as he said earlier... 💀💀😺😺

  • @pkgty
    @pkgty Місяць тому +27

    Media may speak whatever suits whomsoever. But remember middle class will never forget this treachery of last ten years.

  • @kumarashish9954
    @kumarashish9954 Місяць тому +32

    विपक्ष को chodiye सर हम जितना खुल के मोदी का समर्थन किए ह 2014 से आज का बजट एकदम पिछवाड़े मे घुस गया मैं भी मिडिल क्लास हूं बहुत संघर्ष करना पड़ता ह पर हिन्दुत्व और सनातन के लिए ऐसे लाखो करोड़ों badget कुर्बान ह

    • @statsbelgaum
      @statsbelgaum Місяць тому +4

      Sir, Har Hindu aap pe garv karta hai 🙏

    • @abhi1716
      @abhi1716 Місяць тому +3

      Could you enlighten us by highlighting few points which Modi has done for hindutva? Is it giving Padam Vibhushan to mulla Mulayam? Is it related to inducting maximum IAS, PCS, other civil services from gajwa e hind community? Is it related to giving free coaching to a special community so that abbas ka yaar can daydream about noble prize? Is it related to termination of Nupur Sharma, T. Raja Singh, etc. from the party to appease Muslims? Name few. Stop living in la la land. Abbas ka yaar has gone crazy. His timidness is taking a toll on Hindus with each passing day. He can only raise hope but he doesn’t have courage to take risks any further. He will stick to chair. Soon he will be forced to resign by his own party men,

    • @ADITIYASHARMA007
      @ADITIYASHARMA007 Місяць тому +1

      Isi liye tujhe anbhakt kehte hai😂😂😂

    • @statsbelgaum
      @statsbelgaum Місяць тому

      @@ADITIYASHARMA007 aur tu gaddar hai... Dharam ka aur desh ka

    • @kumarashish9954
      @kumarashish9954 Місяць тому +3

      @@ADITIYASHARMA007 भक्ति अंधी ही होती है, 7 वी फेल तुझे क्या पता भक्ति के बारे मे दो मुट्ठी चावल के लिए बिक जाते हैं तेरे जैसे लोग 🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @deepaksachdeva6605
    @deepaksachdeva6605 Місяць тому +19

    इतना अच्छा तो बजट है ही नहीं, आप से संतुलित वीडियो की उम्मीद रखते हैं, माध्यम वर्ग को बहुत उम्मीद थी, बहुत निराश किया निर्मला जी ने। विदेशी कंपनी के लिए tax कम, indexation हटा दिया क्यों??, इतने छोटे tax slab 10 ke baad 12 fir 15 । Koi capital expenditure nahee badaya?? Why not make in India for mobile and solar panels, aisa lagta hai। सरकार ने foreign companies aur deep state ke agey surrender kar diya hai। Kam se kam ईमानदार middle class ko totally ignore Kiya gaya

    • @jaspreetsingh-xg7if
      @jaspreetsingh-xg7if Місяць тому +1

      Sirf Maha-murakh, Darpok, Corrupt, Mansik gulam Lok leaders hi deep state western countries ke Sath agree hote hai aur en ke agay juk kar desh ki exploitation karvate hai.

    • @VibhutiGaneshG
      @VibhutiGaneshG Місяць тому +1

      2012 में 2 lac तक टेक्स नहीं था .. अब ये 11 yrs मे 6.7% इंफलेशन जोड़ों तो आज 4.6 लाख तक आय कर नहीं होना चाहिए - मिडलकलास की ऐसी की तैसी हो चुकी हैं।

    • @heavenlypot
      @heavenlypot Місяць тому +1

      Poora video dekh.

  • @aviral5124
    @aviral5124 Місяць тому +64

    अगर भारत में पैदा होना है तो या तो अमीर घर में पैदा हो या एकदम गरीब घर में, मिडिल क्लास और वो भी जनरल कैटेगरी में मत पैदा करना भगवान 🙏🙏

    • @snehamehta6413
      @snehamehta6413 Місяць тому +2

      You can try to get poor or wealthy. Most people get rich by hard work.

    • @sandeepgupta-jf6xb
      @sandeepgupta-jf6xb Місяць тому

      Tax terrorism by BJP .Middle class most sufferer.
      BJP should be voted out from all states

    • @aviral5124
      @aviral5124 Місяць тому +7

      @@snehamehta6413 obviously we are working hard but one can't get rich overnight until then "happy middle class".

    • @kubrified1745
      @kubrified1745 Місяць тому

      @@snehamehta6413 Hardwork, Morality, diligence, it's all bullshit when you're in India.
      Only way to become rich in this C grade country is by unfair means. Look at the Home Minister of the country 😺

  • @VikasAptePune
    @VikasAptePune Місяць тому +2

    Sardana ji is a renowned Advocate! Surprised to hear him that don't know how many old and defunct laws scrapped! They are all available on Ministry of Law & Justice website as well as on LokSabha Bills portal.🙏

  • @ashishsinha2570
    @ashishsinha2570 Місяць тому +17

    Worst budget! Feeling betrayed by this budget.

  • @HinduWarriorForever
    @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому +63

    करदाताओं में 97% हिंदू हैं...लेकिन इस अर्थव्यवस्था को चलाने के लिए हमें क्या मिल रहा है?
    लाभ मिलता नहीं पर बोझ सदैव हम पर रहता है।

    • @abhi1716
      @abhi1716 Місяць тому +13

      Abbas ke yaar ko noble peace prize chahiye. We are paying taxes for Abdul to facilitate his community goal of gajwa e hind.

    • @HinduWarriorForever
      @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому

      Very disappointing ​@@abhi1716

    • @HinduWarriorForever
      @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому +14

      ​@@abhi1716 abhi bhi minority ke liye special budget. Votes hum de aur facilities muIo' ko. Ghazwa toh govt kar rahi hai hamare sath.

    • @HinduWarriorForever
      @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому +12

      ​@abhi1716 ghazwa will happen by 2034 it seems so. Because now even in remote areas of Uttarakhand we see MousaImaans.

    • @heavenlypot
      @heavenlypot Місяць тому +1

      Spam kyu karra tu?

  • @souravagasty1441
    @souravagasty1441 Місяць тому +15

    middle class will make sure bjp is kicked out in 2029. i have been a vocal bjp supporter but i cant fathom the intention of this government when it comes to taxation. they are hell bent on looting middle class and have been taking them for granted for the last 10 years. what is the need of increasing ltcg? my hand won't allow me to press congress button in evm but i have no interest in queing up in scorching heat to vote for this monsterous party in 2029. RIP BJP

    • @lalitsharma1801
      @lalitsharma1801 Місяць тому

      Yes agree. Peale long term capital gain me tax nhi Tha if invested for more than 1 year. Ab uspe tax thok reehe hai bloody hell

    • @sunildattakulkarni2754
      @sunildattakulkarni2754 Місяць тому +1

      Let us not forget that alternative will be more harmful. Medicine will be dangerous than the disease.

    • @lalitsharma1801
      @lalitsharma1801 Місяць тому +1

      @@sunildattakulkarni2754 we fully agree Sirjee that part. As of now, there is no alternative. But than, One shouldn't play monopolistic games.
      Why can't freebies to peaceful and other people are scrapped? Money saved will be in lakh crores.

    • @souravagasty1441
      @souravagasty1441 Місяць тому +1

      @@sunildattakulkarni2754 i agree and thats why middle class still voted for bjp in 2024 but they need to bloody understand that they can't continue to ignore middle class and expect them to vote. and after all these taxation what are we getting in return? i think if the government doesn't change its attitude towards middle class then they are up for a hammering in 2029.

    • @lalitsharma1801
      @lalitsharma1801 Місяць тому

      @@sunildattakulkarni2754 there should be a census community wise on the tax payers in India. I am a salaried employee and I have paid 60 lakhs as income tax in last six years. Though with God's grace, I have decent salary but that doesn't mean that I can't dream big to have good bank balance for my family.
      We take risk in investing in stock market and the reward that we get is again taxable. Got should understand that we are not investing in market with some free money. That money has already been taxed at 30 % rate and then being invested.

  • @photomadan9282
    @photomadan9282 Місяць тому +30

    But jo tax de rahe hai unka koi bhala nahi ho raha . Har jagaha par tax hai fee hai and corruption hai

  • @deepaksachdeva6605
    @deepaksachdeva6605 Місяць тому +10

    This is my laat view of your video, you are a retired IAS ,, you ahould have guts to say truth and criticize the Govt, this budget has broken the dreams n ezpectations of middle class

  • @kolyarus8405
    @kolyarus8405 Місяць тому +19

    नीतीश, नायडू तो नही छोड़ेंगे (3 बिलियन डॉलर मिले हैं) पर मिडिल क्लास जरूर बीजेपी को छोड़ देगा

    • @vjwshyamks
      @vjwshyamks Місяць тому +2

      They are not giving from thier budget. they are helping AP to get loans from banks. media not highlighinting this point.

    • @kolyarus8405
      @kolyarus8405 Місяць тому +1

      @@vjwshyamks then suggest Naidu to leave the govt.
      Again election and then we will tell this government the implications to not caring their core voters (voiceless middleclass Hindu)

    • @बबह-ड1ख
      @बबह-ड1ख Місяць тому

      मिडिस क्लास यदि बीजेपी को छोड भी देगा तो क्या उन गिध्दो के शरणम् गच्छामि हो जायेंगे ये गिध्द नोचकर खा जायेंगे।

    • @vaijeet
      @vaijeet Місяць тому

      ​@@kolyarus8405ऑर फिर कांग्रेस युक्त विपक्ष आकार हिंदू ओ की ऐसी band बजायेगा की मोदी मोदी करना पडेगा. भूल गये वो भ्रष्टाचार के दिन, पर अब खांगरेस केवल भ्रष्टाचार ही नहीं पर हिंदू ओ का कत्लेआम करेगी, देश को बेच देगी।

  • @hooman6080
    @hooman6080 Місяць тому +7

    Today BJP lost atleast 20% of middle class voter because since last 11year Budget and we middle class get nothing i will never vote for BJP again if they even announce the exemption on 20 lakh income you'll see pattan of BJP in 3 state elections.

    • @ADITIYASHARMA007
      @ADITIYASHARMA007 Місяць тому +1

      Kuch nhi khoya hum anbhakt hai 😂😂😂
      Ye mat bhuloo
      Hum fir bhi vote denge modi ko kyuki hum gulaam hai 😂😂😂

  • @Orca_techie
    @Orca_techie Місяць тому +14

    This is the last time I or anyone on my family or friends voting for mr Modi, the government has made sure we never progress by taking our money away

    • @dreamingaboutjungkook3930
      @dreamingaboutjungkook3930 Місяць тому

      Bye bye congress ke rule mai dekhte hain aapke kitne moj hori hai.

    • @dreamingaboutjungkook3930
      @dreamingaboutjungkook3930 Місяць тому

      Aap un hindus mai hain jinka hum itihaas nai padhte hain ki apne choote choose laalach ke liye woh virodhiyo se mil jayega

    • @Orca_techie
      @Orca_techie Місяць тому

      Abe lallu, kamana Sikh pehle, kese pay pay jodte he middle-class taki ham maa baap ki seva kar sake, aur bacho ko education se paye, BJP ko islia vote nahi dia tha ki wo b congress ke jese hame loote. Agar vote dia he toh Kam karna padega hamare lia. Toh ye faltu bakvas apne pass rakhia. Thike seth ji

  • @subhamdelhi4630
    @subhamdelhi4630 Місяць тому +3

    Vijay Sardana raises valid points. Intellectual debate!

  • @danchaitanya
    @danchaitanya Місяць тому +2

    Brilliant analysis Sardhana ji!!!

  • @Robolearning
    @Robolearning Місяць тому +18

    Unfortunately this will cost BJP a lot. People are not liking this. They have made joke at salary class.

    • @VibhutiGaneshG
      @VibhutiGaneshG Місяць тому

      2012 में 2 lac तक टेक्स नहीं था .. अब ये 11 yrs मे 6.7% इंफलेशन जोड़ों तो आज 4.6 लाख तक आय कर नहीं होना चाहिए - मिडलकलास की ऐसी की तैसी हो चुकी हैं।

  • @dhiraj.parwani
    @dhiraj.parwani Місяць тому +45

    What tremors?! It is a lifeless budget just like previous budgets under NDA rule. The government has forgotten that middle class also votes!
    Shamlessly emphasising on 17500 benefit!

    • @nishakamath5287
      @nishakamath5287 Місяць тому +2

      17500/- benefit😅😅 and on the side she has forced STCG along with removal of CII.. only to burden the middle class with more tax

    • @ADITIYASHARMA007
      @ADITIYASHARMA007 Місяць тому

      Anbhakt par koi dhyaan nhi deta 😂😂😂

  • @HinduWarriorForever
    @HinduWarriorForever Місяць тому +53

    मत भटकाओ. सत्य को स्वीकार करो. बजट में मध्यम वर्ग के नागरिकों के लिए कुछ भी नहीं है।

  • @chetanhatadia4176
    @chetanhatadia4176 Місяць тому +1

    Mr Vijayji nicely highlighted & analysis budget with SD sir.
    Thank you JD team🙏

  • @gauravb777
    @gauravb777 Місяць тому +8

    Sir apse godi media wali umid nahi rakhta, vipaksh chodo yaha hamare hosh ude hai, Na government Hindu ki baat krti hai aur na hi middle class toh fir ese government ka kya matlab 😢😮😢😮😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

  • @SunilkumarSrivastava-cy5yg
    @SunilkumarSrivastava-cy5yg Місяць тому +1

    Sardana ji ke budget analysis se ye lagta hai hum karz leke ghee kha rahe hain ya ghee khane ka natak kar rahehai. Phir bhi sardana ji ka analysis logical aur factual hai.very nice 👍.

  • @kamaljyotimedhi
    @kamaljyotimedhi Місяць тому +19

    As bjp voter, I am unhappy for this budget no matter how much you praise Modi 3.0..Modi 3.0 will be regarded as last nail in the coffin... Thank you..

    • @rajneesh1977
      @rajneesh1977 Місяць тому

      Modi Ji 3.0 will end in 2029....New BjP PM will come...

  • @SkillRaptor-ie6bt
    @SkillRaptor-ie6bt Місяць тому

    The fund support to middle class to become entrepreneurs is major point in this budget. I am an IITian, I said no to jobs and started my business and employ 12 people. I am living example of how this strategy will give fruits in near future.
    The budget ks truly middle class oriented, which empowers people to become self employed.

  • @royaltiger79
    @royaltiger79 Місяць тому +1

    Very healthy discussion today. Govt must stop free bee & focus on economic growth. Middle class specially Income tax walo ko rehem Karo.🙏

  • @pkgty
    @pkgty Місяць тому +9

    Aap sab log kuch bhi kah lo. Bure ko achha bana do. Middle class sab yaad rakhega.

  • @maxkak2149
    @maxkak2149 Місяць тому +1

    How calmly is dixit listening and not giving his universal smile and making a very hard grin.

  • @maunder7083
    @maunder7083 Місяць тому +19

    Middle class not happy with this budget

  • @user-kx9jv5gu4u
    @user-kx9jv5gu4u Місяць тому +3

    डरे हुये फक्कीर की कुर्सी बचाव अभियान!
    बहुमत ना मिलने का असर।

  • @rajeshshrivastava240
    @rajeshshrivastava240 Місяць тому +19

    लेमनचूस बजट

  • @taposhisarker7680
    @taposhisarker7680 Місяць тому +3

    Hindus need to be alert only unity can save their next gen in Bharat

    • @ADITIYASHARMA007
      @ADITIYASHARMA007 Місяць тому +1

      Alag hi level hai anbhaktoo kaa 😂😂😂
      Bjp ko bachane ke liye kya kya kahani gadte hai😂😂😂
      70 saal me toh hindu ko kuch nhi huwa aur achanak modi govt me hinduoo ko khatra hai😂😂😂

  • @S.P.01
    @S.P.01 Місяць тому +1

    भारत का मध्यम वर्ग भी हड़कंप में है। लोग सोच रहे थे की इनकम टैक्स में कुछ छूट मिलेगी, कुछ नही मिला। ऊंट के मुंह में जीरा बस यही मिला है।

  • @Raj-ug7dz
    @Raj-ug7dz Місяць тому +7

    2024. Meri or poori family ka last time tha jab humne bjp ko vote diya...koi fayeda nahin Dene ka middle class service class admi kuch nahn milta

    • @varshakaurav
      @varshakaurav Місяць тому +1

      Kisko vote doge Rahul ko?

    • @rajneesh1977
      @rajneesh1977 Місяць тому

      sabvi ka yahi dard hai..kya kare dusra option nhin hai middle class ke paas...

  • @loveislove9211
    @loveislove9211 Місяць тому +5

    एकदम घटिया बजट है ।
    मध्य वर्गीय लोगों को सामूहिक आत्महत्या के लिए प्रेरित करने वाला ।
    एक तरफ 100 बीघा जमीन वाले गुंडे किसान बनकर हर चीज की मलाई चाट रहे है और इधर नौकरीपेशा एक 2 कमरे का मकान तक नहीं ले पा रहा ।
    गरीबों के तुष्टिकरण की सीमा होती है ।इनपर जितना मर्जी पैसा लगा दो ये ढेर सारे बच्चे पैदा करके फिर से गरीब के गरीब ही रहेंगे।

  • @Human_soul_n_mind
    @Human_soul_n_mind Місяць тому +2

    Few days later, we all will forget about budget and it's affects. And then we will start religious based mentality thought and comments.

    • @heheye461
      @heheye461 Місяць тому +1

      You guys leave your religion. Everything will be fine.
      Will you? Why asking others

  • @rambhupalreddygantla1549
    @rambhupalreddygantla1549 Місяць тому +1

    Correct Sir, ground level corruption is same as in UPA govt. In central secretariat same is corruption culture.

  • @puspanjalipatra7208
    @puspanjalipatra7208 Місяць тому

    many many thanks for public awarness regarding loan of country 🙏🙏🙏

  • @rajantiwari8456
    @rajantiwari8456 Місяць тому +3

    मध्यम वर्ग को ग्यारहवें झुन झुने के लिए शुभकामनाएँ

  • @reddysena
    @reddysena Місяць тому +4

    Why middle class has to pay double tax...tds from employer and indirect taxes on all the crap we buy and atlast we get nothing. Really disappointed with bjp govt and next election who ever gives tax benifits to middle class will vote them and we doesn't mind if it's a muslim party as well.

  • @speedbird109
    @speedbird109 Місяць тому

    Best discussion and very well articulated @ 39:24 regarding taxation vs middle class.

  • @lakhvirsingh8941
    @lakhvirsingh8941 Місяць тому +2

    It is good bihar is allocated fund from center for development. Now it is chance for nitish to do nothing but to maintain law n order in bihar so that some investment should come for industries.

  • @jagrutisharma907
    @jagrutisharma907 Місяць тому

    धन्यवाद वाद व आपका आभार

  • @Raj-oi4bq
    @Raj-oi4bq Місяць тому

    Excellent sardana ji spot on.

  • @shukladn
    @shukladn Місяць тому +6

    This govt introduced LTCG on investors, Dividend distribution tax on investors, new tax regine without exemption, buyback tax on investors, covid and now again increase in tax... You take income tax,GST Tax and more many taxes..tax on tax.. bhaiya FII ko 5% tax exemption kyon diya. India ka FM Americans ke liye budget bana raha hai.

    • @jaspreetsingh-xg7if
      @jaspreetsingh-xg7if Місяць тому +1

      Sirf Maha-murakh, Darpok, Corrupt, Mansik gulam Lok leaders hi western countries ke Sath agree hote hai aur en ke agay juk kar desh ki exploitation karvate hai. Finance minister ko toh Hindi bhi Nahi bolni aati properly. english mindset mein live Karne vali yeh lady ko desh ke common Loko ki problems ke bare mein samj Nahi ayegi kabhi bhi.
      Lootere western countries ke Neo-colonial ways of exploitation ko promote kar rahi hai yeh finance minister under leadership of Modi ji.
      west ki mansik gulami ko leave Nahi karte Darpok, Corrupt, Maha-murakh leaders

    • @RAHULSEN-og6mc
      @RAHULSEN-og6mc Місяць тому

      Jab tax payers 3% of population hain 5 trillion economy banne wali country mein they should be given the best treatment

  • @muralidharsetlur2893
    @muralidharsetlur2893 Місяць тому +2

    🙏सरदाना सर, wonderful explanation. 80%. But अंत में लग रहा है आप एक विपक्ष की भूमिका निभा रहें। देश में दूसरा ऑप्शन बताए मोदी के अलावा। केजरी, अखिलेश, राहुल पप्पू या, कर्नाटक, तमिल naad. Sab haramee, dagabaaj, lootne वाले, देश को बेचने वाले। This set up is the best we have in this timeline. सारे विश्व में एक देश बताईए who are better placed.🙏

    • @rajneesh1977
      @rajneesh1977 Місяць тому

      option nhin bata rahe hain.aayina dikha rahe hain Modi sarkar ko..kaam se jyada baatein jyada karte hain Modi ji....

  • @rdpant6761
    @rdpant6761 Місяць тому +6

    नमस्कार
    मैं मोदी समर्थक हूं पर मुझे लगने लगा है कि अब पुनर्विचार करने का समय आ गया है।
    बीजेपी अपने समर्थकों को ही निचोड़कर विश्व गुरु बनने की राह पर है ।अभी तक मिडिल क्लास को जो भी मिला कांग्रेस के समय में ही मिला बीजेपी अब वसूल रही है ।
    अब महसूस होता है कि मिडिल क्लास ठगा जा रहा है और मेरी यह सोच कि बीजेपी हर जगह सही है पुनर्विचार की आवश्यकता है ।

  • @LOL-tz5kt
    @LOL-tz5kt Місяць тому +1

    हर हर महादेव🙏🙏

  • @peeyushvasistha
    @peeyushvasistha Місяць тому +3

    They didn't do anything for middle class in 11 years.
    Pathetic mindset of Modi.

  • @sukeshchandersharma2832
    @sukeshchandersharma2832 Місяць тому

    Great and words of wisdom to Nation!

  • @sunilrathod4839
    @sunilrathod4839 Місяць тому +7

    Iss baar Maharashtra main hone wale November election main bjp haregi - middle class tax bhaar ke maar gaya

  • @jesalkapadia
    @jesalkapadia Місяць тому +4

    I am a fan of JD so please do not take it otherwise. Finance and journalism should be separate topics.

  • @vinaygarud8110
    @vinaygarud8110 Місяць тому +4

    मध्यम वर्ग को बम्बू मिला हैं. गरीब को कितनाही दो आखिर हिंदू गरीब जात और मुस्लिम धर्म के लिये ही मत देता हैं ये सिद्ध हुआ हैं.

  • @sunderbhati344
    @sunderbhati344 Місяць тому +1

    जय भारत जय श्री राम।।

  • @Sanjeev-te8tj
    @Sanjeev-te8tj Місяць тому +1

    बजट पोप जी के समझ आ जाए तो यह आश्चर्यजनक घटना होगी।

  • @radhikakarmarkar9464
    @radhikakarmarkar9464 Місяць тому

    Vijay Sardana Sir is on point about the middle class... and the Tax

  • @MyPlanetMyDuty
    @MyPlanetMyDuty Місяць тому +2

    The government should give some benefits to those who pay tax honestly.. like free education to their kids up to 12th and healthcare also....

  • @kjo5280
    @kjo5280 Місяць тому

    Excellent analysis Mr Sardana.

  • @faceITnow
    @faceITnow Місяць тому +1

    Sardana Ji is right !!

  • @user-yd1sx8xf6w
    @user-yd1sx8xf6w Місяць тому

    Excellent and true analysis 🎉🎉🎉

  • @manubhaishah1632
    @manubhaishah1632 Місяць тому

    Explained very well to understand budget in detail.

  • @omprakashsinghthakursaha-my4io
    @omprakashsinghthakursaha-my4io Місяць тому +1

    भारत सरकार करप्शन और लीकेज सुधारे ! सब ठीक होगा केवल न्यायपालिका को सुधारे ???

  • @rajendranathanmnair4122
    @rajendranathanmnair4122 Місяць тому +1

    Budget should be a simple document that makes our life easy and aspirational. We never had such a budget ever. It was a terror tool at hands of babus who called it socialism. This budget is more of the same but riding on technology. No control will go away, manufacturing will happen only with babus blessing. Middle class shown middle finger by the most entitled FM who have never worked with people and hence have no idea of our daily difficulties. We will continue to be victims of more socialism if sarkari type.Existing vacancies won't be filled to reduce expenses, but more money will be spent placating youth in short term. As a BJP core voter since 1980 what are my options? Nothing but continue to support as alternative is anarchy.

  • @grgrgrjjjjjj
    @grgrgrjjjjjj Місяць тому

    you are right. Debt trap is dangerous. hope opposition raise this issue!

  • @MsKaiga
    @MsKaiga Місяць тому

    it was an eye opening discussion.

  • @shambhusharma3256
    @shambhusharma3256 Місяць тому

    Vijay Sardana is absolutely correct.

  • @ksbuggal
    @ksbuggal Місяць тому +1

    Sardana ji ur vishleshan is great

  • @PremSingh-fy8uc
    @PremSingh-fy8uc Місяць тому +1

    निर्मला ताई ने मध्यम वर्ग को चूरन चटा दिया।
    इनको तो चुनाव लड़ना नही है -- नही तो इनकी जमानत जब्त होना तय है।संजय जी बजट पर विष्लेषण के लिये कृपया इनके पतिदेव को आमन्त्रित करें।

  • @shukladn
    @shukladn Місяць тому +5

    This budget is disastrous for retail investors. Govt will loose their permanent votes now. The govt will get a huge defeat now in future election. Public ka mohbhang ho gaya hai ...

    • @dreamingaboutjungkook3930
      @dreamingaboutjungkook3930 Місяць тому

      Koi nahi congress aayegi phir kitni moj hori hai aap logo ki pata chal jayega. Minority ke majority bante hi waise bhi aapko koi nahi puchane wala . Na democracy bachegi na reservation. Go on BJP ka kya bigedaga kisi political party ka kuch nahi bigdta isliye ehsaan mat dikhaye. Mat do vote BJP ko ap dete the kyonki woh aapko best option laga koi ehsaan nahi kiya aapne

  • @shyamkishorkumar6685
    @shyamkishorkumar6685 Місяць тому

    अच्छा विश्लेषण.

  • @rightchoice7719
    @rightchoice7719 Місяць тому +12

    आज ऐसा लग रहा।है मोदी सरकार को वोट करके हमने कोई गुनाह कर दी है।

  • @mala8367
    @mala8367 Місяць тому +9

    There is nothing beneficial for middle class say most of the people. That is why Chidambaram is praising because he knows the effect of this bad budget

  • @rajaindustries855
    @rajaindustries855 Місяць тому

    Agreed. Corruption has not come down at 90% levels. 10%may have come down at higher levels which cannot b felt/ seeen by majority.

  • @balaravirala2361
    @balaravirala2361 Місяць тому

    Right Analysis. very good and honest.. BJP should think about what he said..

  • @ganeshnayak656
    @ganeshnayak656 Місяць тому

    Perfect 👍👍👍👍👍

  • @shantarammandlik2589
    @shantarammandlik2589 Місяць тому +5

    नवनिर्वाचित लोकसभा 2024 सांसद राहुल गांधी लोकसभा मे "लिडर ऑफ लायर = झुटो का सरदार " है ।

  • @VedaSay
    @VedaSay Місяць тому

    Its always refreshing to hear Sardana ji.

  • @Bfuyg
    @Bfuyg Місяць тому

    VANDE MAATRAM
    🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

  • @gits19love
    @gits19love Місяць тому

    No one should be above the nation Mr. Narendra Modi, please see if you are eligible and capable to deliver as PM of India. We need big decisions in reforms in police, judiciary and ias/ips to counter common man issues we need good governance and corruption free governance

  • @AR-jl2qc
    @AR-jl2qc Місяць тому

    Itna sach bol diya Vijay sir ki Sanjay ji ka face hi utar gaya 😂😂😂

  • @Shan56566
    @Shan56566 Місяць тому

    Very good analysis sirs

  • @chaturbhujpatel196
    @chaturbhujpatel196 Місяць тому +15

    न खाउगां न खाने दूँगा सिर्फ मोदी जी तक रह गया है आम आदमी के लिए करप्सन बढता जा रहा है। संगठित करप्सन को रोकने के लिए पार्टी व सरकार की कोई मानिटरिंग नहीं है।

    • @kubrified1745
      @kubrified1745 Місяць тому +1

      @@chaturbhujpatel196 गलत लाइन लिखी भाई, सही लाइन है, "सिर्फ मैं और अमित शाह खाएंगे, बाकी सब अपनी अपनी मरवाएंगे..." 😺😺😺😺😺

    • @Gokul_kanpuriya
      @Gokul_kanpuriya Місяць тому

      और ये व्यूज लाओ पत्रकार लोग सिर्फ हिंदुओं को गुमराह करने वाली आत्म मुग्ध पत्रकारिता करेंगे

    • @dreamingaboutjungkook3930
      @dreamingaboutjungkook3930 Місяць тому +1

      Achha gandhi family mai karnataka mai jo ghotala hua woh andekha kiya jayega AAP ke baare mai comment veer kuch nahi bolenge.

  • @abhi1716
    @abhi1716 Місяць тому +2

    Abbas ka yaar has become more dangerous for Bharat than Pappu.

  • @debashishghosh8184
    @debashishghosh8184 Місяць тому +2

    Excellent analysis by Vijay Sardanaji👍

  • @kilovictor777
    @kilovictor777 Місяць тому

    Sir itna bada fan hoon Modiji ka ki manta nahi tha corruption abhi bhi hai, but it is a fact that all my business friends have been telling me there is tremendous corruption at the lower level. Infact some say it has increased.

  • @bhaswatimajumdar478
    @bhaswatimajumdar478 Місяць тому +8

    Freebies Freebies Freebies
    Middle Class Tax payers suffering 😢

    • @Fhjkkkkgfddffgh
      @Fhjkkkkgfddffgh Місяць тому

      Centre Govt kya free deti hai ?
      Govt business man ke isharo par chalti hai isliye aise tax lagaa rhe hain

  • @vayuice
    @vayuice Місяць тому

    Its time for middle class hindus to be unite.

  • @ramanujamthatta1346
    @ramanujamthatta1346 Місяць тому

    Is this Sardana Saab's voice is an honest unbiased voice at all?
    I wonder!

  • @kumarbhai09
    @kumarbhai09 Місяць тому +1

    Sir 400 se 800 ₹ masik ki bahut badi badi chooth de diya hai FM ne so middle class ko unke charan sparsh karna chahiye.

  • @1000petabytes
    @1000petabytes Місяць тому +1

    Dharmo Rakshati Rakshitaah
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    Khali jeb se nahi hota

  • @singhbhai3538
    @singhbhai3538 Місяць тому

    You are right sir