Sabaton - Father (Music Video)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 жов 2022
- / ascotter (후원)
Supporters will be mentioned in Description and Special Thanks List(End Card)
Special thanks to (Patrons)
* DR.Rhee BA, History MA, Urban Planning Ethnopher
* BlueLamp
* Domdonald
* 춘갈농장
My 56th MV. Father
Thank for watching.
Song: Father
Author: Sabaton
Movie/Clips:
1. Schindler's List (1993/Film)
2. Hitler: The Rise of Evil (2003/Film)
3. Haber(2008/Film)
4. The Boy in the Striped Pajamas (2008/Film)
5. War Horse (2011/Film)
6. Sarajevo (2013/Film)
7. Tolkien (2019/Film)
8. Clara Immerwahr (2014/Doku)
9. Osowiec. Attack of the Dead Men - War Gaming
10. Sabaton History series
11. The chemical reaction that feeds the world Daniel D Dulek
12. The Great war series
13. The Scientist Who Killed Millions and Saved Billions
Lyrics
A long ago in eastern Prussia
Young men with great ambitions rise
So who can tell me who can say for sure
Which one will win the Nobel Prize?
It was a golden age for science
The kaiserreich would hold the key
And as the conflict came and tensions rose
The manifest of the 93
Haber-Bosch, the great alliance
Where’s the contradiction?
Fed the world by ways of science
Sinner or a saint?
Father of toxic gas, and chemical warfare
His dark creation has been revealed
Flow over no man’s land, a poisonous nightmare
A deadly mist on the battlefield
“Perversions of ideals of science”
Lost words of alienated wife
And in the trenches of the western front
Unknowing soldiers pay the price
And on the battlefield they’re dying
And on the fields the crops are grown
So who can tell us what is right or wrong
Maths or morality alone?
Haber-Bosch, the great alliance
Where’s the contradiction?
Fed the world by ways of science
Sinner or a saint?
Father of toxic gas, and chemical warfare
His dark creation has been revealed
Flow over no man’s land, a poisonous nightmare
A deadly mist on the battlefield
Father of toxic gas, and chemical warfare
His dark creation has been revealed
Flow over no man’s land, a poisonous nightmare
A deadly mist on the battlefield
During times when there’s peace he belonged to the world
During times when there’s war he belonged to his place of birth
Where, will this lead? What’s coming next?
From your inventions?
We wonder where, where does it end?
Who can foresee, see what will be?
Haber-Bosch, the great alliance
Where’s the contradiction?
Fed the world by ways of science
Sinner or a saint?
Father of toxic gas, and chemical warfare
His dark creation has been revealed
Flow over no man’s land, a poisonous nightmare
A deadly mist on the battlefield
Father of toxic gas, and chemical warfare
His dark creation has been revealed
Flow over no man’s land, a poisonous nightmare
A deadly mist on the battlefield
Idk if anyone noticed but the German soldier struggling to breathe at the end is supposedly suppose to be the future dictator of Germany
Some people say his experience getting gassed is why he himself didn't use any(despite having a decent supply and at the suggestion of his advisors)
@@connorhilchie2779 well if he used nerve gas in stalingrad before the 6th army invaded, it would have eliminated most of the russians defending there. Blanket all of stalingrad with gas.
@@russjiao-long5387 kinda, the gas blows with the wind, if the wind is coming to you, you will only gas yourself
@@russjiao-long5387 yeah but i think a scenario like the attack of the dead men would happen again
@@M4A3E8_Sherman for real. despite what der fuhrer said about the slavs, they really were a different breed- almost like cast iron beasts. they deserve respect for their combat skills
The Haber-Bosch process produces ammonia, important for fertilizer, hence the wheat, if anyone was wondering.
And it didn't require any particularly expensive equipment, either.
This is how he achieved the Nobel peace prize as this was a revolutionary breakthrough not just for chemistry but for agricultural development which in turn forced massive cultural and societal changes
My great grandfather told my father when he was old when he fought in WW1 when he first saw the gas “was like a fog unlike I ever seen, I breathed some of that in and I never healed to this day I still smell it and it burns. Fuck that shit”
My greatgrandpa lost a lung during a gas attack. It led up to him dying after being in a house fire years later. He was in the hospital on the brink of death for a while.
@@Niroc98 👌
You'd be hard-pressed to find a more potent representation of the double-edged sword of science
Nuclear fission.
The visuals you put together gave me chills again. This story of Haber is a reminder that it is sometimes futile to sort certain figures into morally good or bad, making it difficult to treat their legacy and memory. A lot of times they may be both. Haber is probably the finest example of this.
In time Peace I belong to world. In time of War I belong to my Homeland. -Fritz Haubert
Would He not invent poisonus gasses used in war houndred of thausends may would live. Would He not work with Bosh, bilions would starve to death.
Fritz Harber, the man who killed millions to save billions.
Agreed it's hard witch one he is because he invented a faster way to make fertilizer but at the same time he invented a weapon as deadly as a nukeclear bomb if not as devistating it could be worse I hate to say it but both world wars used the most devistating weapons on earth to ever to be made
In my opinion there truly is no morally good nor bad.
Some of the most "evil" people (say Adolf for example) had the best intentions "to help their country"
@@rougestorm1038 agreed there people in his government that did like Werner von baurn who invented the v2 rocket and then invented the Saturn 5 rocket for NASA that we used to go to the moon.
3:17 I love that one detail where when he says "Where will this lead?" we actually see where this leads! Well executed
"well executed" poor poor choice of words
@@soupfork6357 💀
@@I_Am_Scp_049 Accurate with the prisoners on Auschwitz
@@I_Am_Scp_049 mista white
This is what I'm missing in the official release. They should have added at least a silhouette of the famous Auschwitz gate in the clip.
Haber is a fascinating man cause i truly feel he quite well embodies the human condition
I agree, the human condition both seeks to help and harm itself.
Pretty much humanity it sums it well
Can someone please explain to me what is meant my "human condition"?
I heard it a few times
@@Boone69 Our ability to subsume all humanity in order to ensure victory for our tribe.
@@huginnmuninn2155 Thank you
4:27 adolf nearly dying from mustard gas
Not the first time he almost died during the war, he had a few close calls including a friendly fire accident that wiped out everyone in his unit but him
its amazing that in the final moments of the video we see a certain dictator facing the wrath of a creation meant for his side.
The same creation used to kill millions by said dictator...
"Father of toxic gas, a chemical nightmare" such a hard hitting banger of a line
Imagine being called "The Father of Artillery", or "Father of Air Possession", or something like that.
@@altier1119there was a person known as the father of artillery. It was general Henry Knox
@@mustang-vj1ih I would rather give this title to Napoleon, but apparently Henry Knox would be a talented logistician, expert in artillery and in logistics and transport (I did not know him at first.)
"Father of toxic gas and chemical warfare" not "Father of toxic gas, a chemical nightmare"
@@Gondaldin sure buddy
Amazing video. I especially love the inclusion of the scene from The Rise of Evil at the very end, as well as the auschwitz scenes showing that even after the 1st war it would still be used but rather than military targets it was used for a more nefarious purpose than ever thought of.
Haber was definitely rolling in his grave when a descendant of his creation was on innocent civilians. That is something that stands out about this particular video, showing the eventual regression of using gas, going from targeting troops in battle to non-combatants and people who have no chance; at least the Allied armies of the West developed and used gas masks to have a chance at surviving.
Allied Troops: why do I smell mustard gas?
Fritz Haber: 😈
Plants: Mm, this gas smells good, lets check it out
Someone get a condenser and some hotdogs.
There is no debate. Haber and Bosch are saints by feeding the world and did what they could to defend their nation. Saints are never perfect. Great video to go with a great Sabaton song.
They're not saints, nor devils
They're scientists
Very interesting composition
The bodies of your generation will feed the land by composting.
3:18 gives me the chills
Your not wrong but he did not know it will be used that way it's kinda sad
@@Strongnurgling he truly did not deserve the blame for it
@@Strongnurgling but fritz defended the use of poison gas in war? unless you're talking about someone else
edit: ok
@@captain_noo in ww1 yea but did he know it will be killing jews on a mass level
@@captain_noo
He intended it ONLY for enemy combatants! Certainly not for helpless civilians. He spent his whole career, alongside Einstein, fighting against blood superstitions and similar nonsense. A big part of why he did what he did was that he thought it would solidify in most German’s views that ethnic Jews were as patriotic as everyone else, helping to end that superstition. Alas, it did not, in the end.
the story behind this song, shows a great truth, of scientific breakthroughs, meaning a great power when created can be used for both good and evil! Who uses it must know and be aware of it!
Though the audio quality sucks
You truly know how to embed the music with the perfect video sequences! Keep up your great works!
Adolf Hitler is the guy at the end with the Iron Cross
Yep, he got it on in time, unfortunately.
@@eldermillennial8330 Exactly, if only he didn't
the begining of the song feels so powerful with the visuals of waves of poison gas flowing forward, so mighty great work
The path to hell is paved with good intentions and the cobblestones are the skulls of the fallen.
번역
A long ago in eastern Prussia
(먼 옛날 동프로이센엔)
Young men with great ambitions rise
(큰 야망을 품은 사내가 자랐네)
So who can tell me who can say for sure
(그러니 어떤 이가 확실하게 내게 말할 수 있을까)
Which one will win the Nobel Prize?
(누가 노벨상을 수상할지?)
It was a golden age for science
(때는 과학의 황금기였고)
The kaiserreich would hold the key
(카이저라이히(독일제국)가 답을 알고 있었네)
And as the conflict came and tension rose
(그리고 갈등이 시작되고 긴장이 고조되며)
The manifest of the 93
(93인의 성명서(93명의 과학자,예술가,철학가,작가들이 제 1차 세계대전 참전에 찬성한다는 성명서))
Haber-Bosch, the great alliance
(하버와 보슈, 위대한 연합)
Where's the contradiction?
(모순은 어디에 있던가?)
Fed the world by ways of science
(과학의 길로 세계를 먹여살린 그는)
Sinner or a saint?
(죄인인가 성자인가?)
Father of toxic gas, and chemical warfare
(독성가스와 생화학무기의 아버지)
His dark creation has been revealed
(그의 어두운 발명이 깨어나고)
Flow over no man's land, a poisonous nightmare
(무인지대로 흘러가는 그 맹독의 악몽은)
A deadly mist on the battlefield
(전장의 치명적인 안개라네)
"Perversion of ideals of science"
("과학의 이상적인 도착")
Lost words of alienated wife
(소외된 아내는 말을 잃었고)
And in the trenches of the western front
(서부전선의 참호속에서는)
Unknowing soldiers pay the price
(모르는 병사들이 목숨을 치뤘네)
And on the battlefield they're dying
(그들이 죽어가는 전장에서)
And on the fields the crops are grown
(작물이 자라가는 들판에서)
So who can tell us what is right or wrong
(누가 우리에게 옳고 그름을 말해주겠나?)
Maths or morality alone?
(수학인가 도덕성인가?)
Haber-Bosch, the great alliance
(하버와 보슈, 위대한 연합)
Where's the contradiction?
(모순은 어디에 있던가?)
Fed the world by ways of science
(과학의 길로 세계를 먹여살린 그는)
Sinner or a saint?
(죄인인가 성자인가?)
Father of toxic gas, and chemical warfare
(독성가스와 생화학무기의 아버지)
His dark creation has been revealed
(그의 어두운 발명이 깨어나고)
Flow over no man's land, a poisonous nightmare
(무인지대로 흘러가는 그 맹독의 악몽은)
A deadly mist on the battlefield
(전장의 치명적인 안개라네)
Father of toxic gas, and chemical warfare
(독성가스와 생화학무기의 아버지)
His dark creation has been revealed
(그의 어두운 발명이 깨어나고)
Flow over no man's land, a poisonous nightmare
(무인지대로 흘러가는 그 맹독의 악몽은)
A deadly mist on the battlefield
(전장의 치명적인 안개라네)
During times when there's peace he belonged to the world
(평화의 시절엔 세계를 위했고)
During times when there's war he belonged to his place of birth
(전쟁의 순간엔 그의 조국을 위했네)
Where, will this lead?
(이것이 무엇을 야기할 것인가?)
What's coming next from your inventions?
(너의 발명이 다음엔 무엇을 불러올 것인가?)
We wonder where, where does it end?
(우리는 이것이 어디서 끝나는지 알까?)
Who can foresee, see what will be?
(누가 예측하고, 무슨 일이 일어날지 알 수 있을까?)
Haber-Bosch, the great alliance
(하버와 보슈, 위대한 연합)
Where's the contradiction?
(모순은 어디에 있던가?)
Fed the world by ways of science
(과학의 길로 세계를 먹여살린 그는)
Sinner or a saint?
(죄인인가 성자인가?)
Father of toxic gas, and chemical warfare
(독성가스와 생화학무기의 아버지)
His dark creation has been revealed
(그의 어두운 발명이 깨어나고)
Flow over no man's land, a poisonous nightmare
(무인지대로 흘러가는 그 맹독의 악몽은)
A deadly mist on the battlefield
(전장의 치명적인 안개라네)
Father of toxic gas, and chemical warfare
(독성가스와 생화학무기의 아버지)
His dark creation has been revealed
(그의 어두운 발명이 깨어나고)
Flow over no man's land, a poisonous nightmare
(무인지대로 흘러가는 그 맹독의 악몽은)
A deadly mist on the battlefield
(전장의 치명적인 안개라네)
반박 환영
고맙소 동무
This is even better than I thought it would be. Excellent work!
What I like is in the instrumental, you showcased the benefits of ammonia, in contrast to the intro.
1:28 WOW that powerful ! He said "Help me !"
Sorry to spoil your bubble, but that was actually "Albie" in reference to his friend before he was consumed by the gas.
Very haunting video👍👍great work as always 👍👍
Amazing work on this ascotter! i'm glad your other videos are getting recognized!!
YT videos rarely leave me breathless.
But you've definitely managed to do just that.
Thank you!
💀
He's contributions are still a significant net positive to humanity.
A Germain Medic once said:
"ze healing is not as rewarding as ze hurting"
Coincidence? I think not 🧐
Thanks for making this alternative clip. It's really amazing
This is one of your best. Very well done
And just like that, he disappeared with a banger.
This channel is a gem of History material
Great work putting these together
Your videos are so awesome every time
this song is so sad and beautifull at the same time becouse of how it feels while listening to it and knowing the story behind the history of it,
Always great work cotter!
Awesome
You are right, Herr von Richthofen.
I- I thought you were kaputt??!!!??
@@JD-jn3eu Nein he wasnt Kaputt thats a lie from ur germans the truth is we froze him so we can revive him later
You're also awesome
@@floriankanzaki2085 I'm a zombie
Incredible video! Well done!
Great job
Great work.
This song took me half a year for it to grow on me but now I love it. It's strange isn't it? Hope you're doing well Otter!
Excellent video my man
I was excited for this. Worth watching, innit
unlike some videos
Amazing work
Good work on the video
Great job mate
This is really good tbh
Meno male che c'è questo gruppo che sensibilizza e racconta questi fatti realmente accaduti......😢😢😢😢😢GRANDI.....
Wonderful
Great Work!, though I don't prescribe to the Zyklon-B shower hype I did enjoy this endeavor, you earned a sub, Prosit!
perfection :)
this video gives me the chills
Was wondering for your next Sabaton video if you could do one about Screaming Eagles as I always wanted to see a scene of the Germans receiving the reply of NUTS! while Sabaton played in the background.
Good video.
I bet even today theirs people who look upon this man with loathing in their hearts.
Great video! Gives me the ambition to make it again.
이젠.. 한국어 자막을 볼 수 없는것인가..
Well put together!
全人類の未来を救い、一方で何千万人も殺すことになった悲劇の科学者…
I wouldn't say he saved mankind, we got on just fine for tens of thousands of years without him. If even the likes of the black death couldn't stop us, having to wait a while for another chemist to create a better fertilizer wouldn't either.
An invention that would improve lives and take lives. Where's the evil in this invention and where's the good? There's no difference anyway more.
The video gives me chills, "Where will this lead"?
My guys really made a Veritasium Video into a Sabaton Song lmao
This is a key example of a good man being twisted to turn something good into a weapon. I'm just glad he didn't live to see the extension of his invention past his life-time.
You might want to read more about him. He personally went to the trenches to check the equipment and had no feelings about it after the war.
@@Dave-ks9fi Your talking about someone building a weapon to save his own from death by killing the other at that moment in time . Just like the Nuke. How would he had reacted if he knew what was to happen after the first world war and onwards.
@@insainetrooper7489 Oppenheimer felt really bad for example
Good job love how you match the music with video
good videos 👍
Da best
If you ever do Cliffs of Gallipoli, you should show the HMHS _Britannic_ at least once.
I as an Orthodox Christian like to ponder what could have happened had the Gallipoli offensive been a success. Churchill blamed the Admiralty for ruining their opportunity to surprise the Turks, but no, they were SO well prepared, that they knew they were coming. I lean to the theory that Saint Czar Nicholas had a German spy leak in his intelligence network, who then shared it with the Turks.
What if that spy had been stopped?
Part of the plan had been to liberate and arm the Armenians against their oppressors, which would have massively turned the tide. The Australians and Russians would have marched into Constantinople and taken back the Hagia Sophia for Christendom! Then, they’d have turned a blind eye as the surviving Armenians sought revenge after seeing the killing fields of Armenian corpses.
Love this
Без работ учёных.Без новых технологических прорывов существование человечества бессмысленно.Будут ли новые технологии использованны на благо человечества или уничтожат миллионы это ответственность военных и политиков.
Конкретно тут - это полностью его ответственность. Именно он пришёл с предложением превратить его изобретение в оружие, и он командовал первым применением газа на Ипре за что был удостоен звания капитана (хотя он не служил). Инициатива хим оружия в первой мировой полностью за ним: модификация огнемётной смеси, иприт, хлор и даже приложил руку к зарину, хотя там в основе стоял Шрадер) - все хим оружие первой мировой стоит за его предложениями. А вот во второй его как раз использовали. Под угрозой смерти (из-за того что он был евреем) он разработал Циклон А, а после смерти с его нароботок сделали Циклон Б. Вот почему в песне звучит вопрос: Грешник или святой ?. Он создавал аммиак исключительно из мирных целей (удобрение и пестициды которыми пользуются до сих пор, что позволило прокормить миллионы), но он так же предложил и реализовал это в оружие.
Me amd the boys after finding bleach and ammonia under the sink
I can't imagine how he would've felt had he'd live to see what the nazis did with his invention...
they did not use any toxic gas
@lancechua9743
How so? Wasn't the gas chambers using toxic gas?
@@lancechua9743they use to Jewish people but not in war
@@lancechua9743actually they did, in gas chambers, they used a more potent version of mustard gas
And the fact that Haber is Jewish... Wow
@@lancechua9743Yes, Germany during WW2 used zyklon-B. A gas that was able to be made only because of the toxic gas created by Haber and Bosch.
Edit: Spelling.
It’s hard to imange this happens in real life 🤯in fact as you see he died in ww2 1938 it’s crazy to think about that it’s only 2022 that means-100 it means the year would be 1922they would be using the dangerous chemicals back then then in fact it has not even Ben 100 years since ww2 and all of this happing less then 100 years 😳dam I got goose bumps😳
If I remember correctly he didn't live long enough to see WW2 and the holocost. He did get kicked out of Nazi Germany for being a Jew though
@@connorhilchie2779 huh interesting 🤔also how did he get kick out in Germany if he died during the war ? 😐in 1938? The war ended in 1942 so was he REALLY kicked out ? Or is their more to the story?🧐
@@jettmthebluedragon you are off by 3 years 1945 was the end of the war
@@thebloodmoonwarrior I’m was not talking about the war I was referring to the death of well the father of this video 😐I don’t remember his name 😓
Слухаючи пісні Sanaton можна потрохи вивчати історію👍🏻
Грандіозне виконання, в найкращому дусі Сабатону.
Louco não? 👾👽
I love how they added the gas chamber scene from movie: " The boys in the striped pajams"....
When his country called him he answered, when science called him, he answered. There's no definitive answer to the moral question of Haber or any other scientist like him.
wow, incredible💯
0:40 did i see hecter salamanca?
yes, he is
@@TheIronWire lol mafia mexican in world war 1
Yep, that is Mark Margolis, the actor of Hector Salamanca and the attempted carbomber in Scarface.
I hate to say it, but the video is much better than the one sabaton made
Damm good Music video with perfect editing.
I truly see him as a monster but you also can call him a Hero
As it perfectly sums up humanity
In many ways of its own.
I also he was a nationalist and i don't that he made it for his country but of course it made the war last longer
Well, without him humanity would stagger and massive famine would claim billions of people and lead to wars for resources all over the world.
Pretty true now the question is IS HE A SAINT OR A SINNER!
And you see him as a sinner while I don't.
@@filipnassen9076
Several nasty naval wars for control of guano islands and major bat caves had been increasing throughout the 1890s-early 1900s, and only stopped when his discovery made international headlines. Without him, those would have only grown more and more deadly. We’d no longer be able to honor our dead with burials or ritual cremation, bone and fat nitrates would have HAD to be returned to the soil quickly, not slowed by embalming fluid or dumped into the air by fire. That would have been intolerable to most cultures, besides the Tibetans and Mongolians.
For the Grandfather
My favorite sabaton song, btw great scientist amd very smart and patriotic man, he deserved such a good song at least
Am i the only one who thinks the kaiser in the beginning looked kind of hot he had this leather Steampunk look an little bit thats hot
Was Haber's recipe for mustard gas ammonia and bleach or more complicated? Yes it is my King Of The Hill fan side talking.
He created the process for making ammonia before him even that recipe would be impossible
You get chloroamine by bleach and ammonia. Mustard gas is s(ch2ch2cl)2
😢
No matter how many lives you save, the thing he created was the reason for a entire new era of warfare, one of brutality, he should have been tried for his crimes not given a Nobel prize.
For every man he killed, he saved 10 children from starvation and hellish wars for dwindling resources. Imagine civil wars over the last few small caves full of bat crap, or naval wars for the very last guano islands.
FOR THE GLORY OF GRANDFATHER NURGLE!!!!!!!
실례가 안된다면 왜 자막이 없는지 알 수 있을까요?
No mans land
Every man grave
💀💀💀
sabaton nether disappoints
한국인들 소속을 밝히시오(중복선택 가능)
1. 사바톤팬
2. 밀덕
3. 역사덕후
다
Please do ghost division next
Which movie is the scenes where the gas in turned on into the battlefields from? In the beginning of the video
You gave me PTSD from a past life i had in WW1...... the memories..... the SCREAMING!
even how many dangerous weapon germany invent they cant win against spammers
Metal machine!!!!!pls❤
Kaiser William I scene from which movie plz tell me
I want to Watch full movie
Its kaiser willhellm II
(unrelated)
german soldier: hey look a dove maybe its a sign of peace
*it has arty cords*
how about doing one for talvisota or white death?
A long ago in Eastern Prussia...