Following a motorcycle accident at age 53 I had my right knee replaced with a Scorpio joint. Now, 20 years later, the joint needs replacement, so my initial estimate of the joint's life ("10 to 15 years") has been easily exceeded. Iam a 6ft tall heavily built guy (260 lbs) so I have been delighted with the knee's performance. Thanks for your excellent videos.
Very welcome Roy. 20 years - we would take that every time. Best of luck with your revision. Thanks for watching, subscribing and for sharing if you did.
@@TalkingWithDocs Still waiting for my revision following thr pandemic and now the Russian problem. Still able to walk (with a limp) but the wear is causing other nerve related problems with a groin strain feeling and aching hip. Have had all MRI'd and they have no mechanical damage, it's just referred nerve pain. Due for my revision op. 20th december (2022) and our nurses have just announced theri first strike on that date. Hmmmm......
I had my knee replacement 15 years ago. I am a lightweight woman, 116 lbs, age 72. I hike but stopped backpacking after I had this done. I snowshoe, walk, hike, do Yoga. I think my knee will work for the rest of my life.
Hey Docs my hips and knees are over 20 years old and look like new! My surgeon was surprised but pleased because I had my first hip done at 35 and I’m now 62. I love listening to you because it’s like I’m listening to my doctors (I was an Orthopedic Surgery Scheduler before retirement)
That gives some hope. My mum jusf had one knee done and i feel everyday as if im losing her,so afraid of losing her,that kind of pain is unbearable. Your message gives me lil tiny sparkle of hope...
I joined the double knee replacement club about 18 months ago. Walking is great no running. My favorite exersize is swimming. I turned 68 and am loving life. Just sharing and think you guys are great.
Hi Charles. We have put a bunch of patients into that club ourselves. So glad to hear you are enjoying your new knees. Yes running is usually off the table but who needs to run anyway? Thanks so much for sharing and for your kind words Charles. All the best to you. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
@@johncoll4456 I needed both done and could not imagine going thorugh it twice. Went through alot of knee problems for 30 years. But I,m a happy boy now!
Hi eva. Glad we could help in any small way. You will get through it once the time comes. The unknown is scary though and that's what the videos are for - to empower you. Good luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I had both of mine done the same day. They sent me home with a contraption that worked my knee joint that I could increase the angle as I got better. I have great flexion still to this day.
Don't worry, had both knees replaced, 21 and 4 years ago. No recovery aches and pains, normal walking resumed within a month on both occasions. An excellent result both times.Like the doc's say, early excercise and phsio worked a treat for me.
I had a partial replacement on one knee, for arthritis, 12 years ago, age 54. 18 months ago, my leg started collapsing under me and it turned out the polyethylene lining was slipping. Having a TKR on it next week. In fairness, my surgeon told me initially that the partial would last 10-15 years, so he was right! Hoping for 25-40 years for the new one! Thanks for all your great videos, they’re so helpful.💖
Good luck to you Shelagh. Yes 12 years is not too bad for a partial. Best of luck with the total and you are very welcome. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I am now 70. I have needed my left knee replaced for about 20 yrs. I had Synvisc injections for all of that time & it worked well for me. Jan 2020 I am getting my knee replaced as the pain is now getting to me.The other knee will also have to be replaced,but thats a few yrs down the road. Thank you Doc's for your video's I have enjoyed them.
My first knee was done in 2000, it lasted 18 years. I drive semi-local delivery, in and out of the truck 10-12 times a day. Had it replaced in 2108, retired in 2020. Still going strong.
I've had mine for 25 years now and it's still doing really well and I have no problem with it at all. I was told, at that time, it would last about 10 years.....lol.
Mine was done with a.10 to 15 yrs life time I am now coming up to 24 yrs on SEPT 28TH 2022 THE SURGEON TOLD ME.HE WAS SUCH A.GOOD SURGEON IT WOULD LAST 20YRS ITS NOW 24YRS
Four and a half years for my r knee . Done in the UK but using an American prosthetic. No post op pain which was what everyone promised :-) I enjoy working out and do kettlebell goblet squats no problem . It’s been a huge improvement for me
That's what happened to me too! Went in with nothing but pain and woke up after with no pain! Made them disconnect the morphine drip and switch to oral pain meds because morpine made me vomit so much. Still no pain in knee! Especially compared to opening the whole knee capsule when I was 18 which was indescribably painful!
Hey Docs, My partial knee replacement is 14 years old now and going well. I HAD a high BMI. But, still seem to be in good shape. I never run, but often walk and work hard in the garden. This has been a good health investment. The pain from surgery for three weeks was hell.
I had a total knee replacement, both but one at a time 20 years ago . They were Zimmers and have given me no problem. I needed them young because of the pain. I didn't run but I did clog. and I have almost full range of motion. I feel blessed. The only thing I don't do is run or get down on my knees. Great video. 👍💕😲
Hi Nancy. Yes is a very painful operation. Congrats though as you are through the hardest part! Thanks for sharing your story. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I gor my knee replaced at 39 years of age due to trauma. It is still going strong at 22 years. I had the non-metal parts replaced 3 years ago due to a massive infection that origininated from another part of my body. Don't give up on your knee!
Well, my own knee was crap. Injuries started at 17. Had arthritis in it by 30. TKR at 50...5.5 yrs. ago. Probably waited a year too long. It was the 8th surgery on that knee. I’m now able to hike for 5-8 miles. I am on ladders for work and walk on rooftops. My TKR gave me back my life joy. My other knee is coming in another year or two.
Glad it helped you so much CinkSVideo. Keep it up and good luck with your next knkee. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Hi Doc’s, I had my knee replaced Jan 16/20. It is now 3 weeks & so far so good. I had a spinal instead anesthesia which I would recommend as you are not full of gas. After surgery there is not much time for relaxing. Your up & walking a bit hours after surgery. Amazing! I was in hospital 2 days then home again. I’m going to physio twice a week & I’m finding it a bit tough at the moment. I think my bend is around 90 deg. Obviously I still have a ways to yet. Your videos are so informative.
Hi Ron. Sounds like you have the right approach. Lots of hard work and it will come. Make sure your pain is controlled and you have a strategy for swelling control. Best of luck to you and thanks so much for watching.
Did they send you home with the device that works your knee joint for you while in bed?? You can get up to I think 120 deg. I had both knees done and went back to work in 2.5 months with over 120 deg. I hope they still do that.
Great info! Hoping for 20 yrs for my btkr depue, titanium knees. I can accept being wheel chair bound better at 74 than at 54, when I had my surgery. My knee replacements were god-sent since I waited till I couldn't stand it anymore to have the surgery. Don't be fooled that the replacements are better than your real knees but they are much better than what you endured waiting for the knees to wear out enough to replace.
Hi Donna. We could not agree more. They are not normal knees but if you wait long enough you should love them. Best of luck going forward. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I had my first hips replaced with metal on metal and 5 years later I was poisoned with Chromium and Cobalt. My knees started squeeking and failing and I had metal poisoning. I had to have both knees taken out and replaced. It was a horrendous experience and lots of lost time. I just had a Bi-Lateral knee replacement at 74. I have no regrets and was glad to get it over with at once. I was not overweight and never smoked, so my surgeon and I decided to go for it. I just started to drive again and today is my 8th week after surgery and rehab has been great. I wouldn't recommend it to many people-you need lots of help the first two weeks almost full time. I had home therapy and now finishing up outside therapy this week with no regrets. Believe me, no pain, no gain. Exercise, exercise, and more exercise!
4 months since full left knee replacement. I worked my butt off at PT and feels great now, still a little tender but I’m good to go... and I ride a bike 3/4x a week and lots of squats too just keep it stretched I’m getting the right one done next week 😱 Perfect timing during this virus 🦠 BS
Docs.....I had a L TKR 3 1/2 yrs. ago at 65yo. I had a horrible recovery... pain and PT for 1 yr.!!!! Wish I had you guys doing my surgery...the Physical Therapist was excellent. Have been an RN for 30 yrs. and a co-worker at NYPH, whom I became friends with recommended one of the surgeons on the Rehabilitation floor we worked on. I only stayed on that unit 5 yrs. but she was sure this was the best and nicest guy. Well, the years changed him and not for the better. I did have 2 consults but I truly know I picked the wrong surgeon. It was bone on bone, but I wish I never had it done. No one suggested the hylauronic acid injections to me....I have been getting them now for 2 years in my R knee (bone on bone) and they are helping. One year ago was in a car accident and the prosthetic knee was smashed against the dash...when the EMT'S saw my knee, they thought I had a compound fracture, swelling was sticking up about 2 inches from under my slacks and they wanted to cut leg of pants up to knee. Orthopedist (not the same surgeon) said it was a hematoma and would go away in 6 to 8 weeks....its now 11mos.!!! Before the accident I was eventually able to go hiking without a problem, but the lump and discoloration are still there, though it has gotten somewhat smaller. I had other injuries and am going to PT for them, but not the knee. The last 3 weeks the pain in the replaced knee has gotten much worse...hard to go up & downstairs...hard to walk and feel a loud click sometimes even turning in bed. Nothing showed up on the x-ray, or the MRI, and am now scheduled to have a bone scan (12/12). Listening to your video, I'm really afraid that by now something has cracked or broken...maybe the plastic. I researched what can be done for a really painful replacement and all I found was, have another replacement. I can't continue with this pain, it seems worse than before I had it replaced. Please let me know if there is any other way I can have a normal life. Am on pain meds for back but can't take any NSAIDS because I ruined my stomach with Advil, despite taking them with milk and/or food. The pain meds are not helping the knee pain. Replaced knee is swollen, hot, and painful. I never want to go through another replacement again....can you Docs think of anything at all? You both are so nice...how far away are you Docs from NYC or New Jersey? When people are nice, it makes one cry, which is what I'm doing now. 😢😪😥 Was never heavy till I couldn't hike, walk, or bike. Have lost 17 lbs. since June and would like to lose another 15 or 20lbs. That would put me at a good weight and if lost another 10lbs would be thin. I hope you will be able to respond to me. ( I loved working in the OR.) Thanks, Docs.
Hi Susan. It sounds like you have had a very difficult journey. Thanks for taking the time to share it with us. Certainly the car accident could have caused the implants to change position or possibly loosen. A bone scan will help with that. Sometimes in car accidents the patella can be injured especially if it has not been resurfaced. Best to wait for the scan and discuss with a different surgeon whether or not they feel there is something to revise to reduce your pain. Please keep us posted on what happens and good luck. Thanks for watching
Thank you - very interesting! I had mine done at quite suddenly at 73 after smashing my tibial plateau in a fall. I’m trying ro be careful and hoping not to have to do it again. Have resigned myself to being a walker and a retired runner.
Hi Kathleen. You are very welcome. Sorry to hear about the accident. Good idea about retiring the running shoes for walkers. Best of luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
65-year-old male here, with a 11-year-old TKR (right knee). I'm a skinny Minny (65 kg), so that's not a factor. I'm very active, primarily walking/hiking (2 years ago, I completed the Nijmegen 120-mile forced march in 4 days) and cycling (last year I completed 1,100 mile Land's End to John O'Groats in 16 days). Because these are low-impact activities, I think my knee is holding up pretty well. But just recently, I'm noticing higher volumes of activity causes some knee swelling. I foster dogs and so I dog-walk from 6-8 miles each day and ride a bike trainer about 5 hours per week. I'm monitoring it carefully, but am aware I probably need to back off if I want my TKR to last.
I had mine in 2013 & 2015 by Dr Douglas Dennis in Denver Colorado. I am a professional ski instructor and ski over 100 days per year. I am 69 and all is well and everything so far is great. I also ski and teach Telemark skiing and the knees are fine. My knees were injured while waiting in my car at a red light and being hit by a semi truck who did not stop. I survived. He did not.
When I was in the Air Force in 1983 I went to doctor with knee pain, popping, etc. he sent me to therapy for strengthening exercises but told me I would eventually need knee replacement. He said to put it off as long as I could as the technology was evolving and there would be better replacements in the future. I’ve done lots of therapy over the years, plus bicycling as my main exercise. But now the time has come and the knees are toast. Still got a tiny bit of cartilage in left knee, but right is bone on bone. I guess that doctor would be shocked that I took him this seriously and took measures to make the knees last as long as I have. I plan to live well past 100 years, so hope the knees last more than 20 years.
I had both mine done. One year apart in 2015 -L, 2016-R, 2018- Revision Right due to Knee Instability/Loose Implant. BMI is very high. Battling with prolonged use and effects of steroids for three decades (for pain and severe asthma attacks)- Morbid obesity is the byproduct. I am 47(2021). I was working full time whilst being bone on bone for the span of 10 years- every three month knee injections with Supartz/Hyaluronic membrane/Corticosteroids to tolerate pain while working until I cannot do it anymore. Thanks for the beautiful video, doctors.
I am 62 and have had both knees replaced- got osteo on both sides of my family..... My first one was at 51 and my 2nd at 55. You said the main reason to replace the TKR is because it becomes loose? Are there common symptoms when that happens? Pain, slipping, catches in the joint? Thanks for all your information!! I've learned a lot from you all. Greetings from the US.
You guys add to my ..getting to be...daily enjoyment. This particular video very appreciated- am considering a knee replacement. Have had 2 hips replaced. The 2nd one is a little wonky when I do knee bends with that knee forward...it kind of 'wavers out to the side'. Have one more follow up with my surgeon so I'll ask him, but it does preoccupy me a bit. Back to main point of this note- much appreciated information-thank you
Mine (2) are 24 years old. I had a minor revision to replace the liner between top and bottom at 22 years. All is well and doctor said the implants look great. Mine were done at 50. I’ve never missed a beat at doing whatever I like to do. Staying a healthy weight is very helpful.
Hi Doc's Fantastic series of videos. My knee replacement is 10 years old and starting to become painful again, my surgeon says that the joint has become loose and needs to be replaced again!!! please can I have your thoughts on the implications of a second replacement replacement, thanks
Hi Steve. Glad you are liking the videos. Loosening is probably the number one cause of pain after 10 years of success. Revision surgery is often successful. It is harder than the first procedure but with lots of hard work hopefully you can get back to your regular lifestyle. Best of luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I’m 54 years old and seven weeks postop as of today for a right total knee replacement. The left one needs it too, but it wasn’t as bad. I was 100% bone on bone in the medial and middle part of my knee and had a lot of scar tissue. Anyway, my goal is this December, I can ski again, because I am still having issues with soreness and stiffness. I’ve heard it could take up to a year to recover from. I just hope skiing does not wear out the parts. I always stick to groomed runs, unless there’s been a huge downpour of snow.
9 months ago @73 I had 1st TKR, Started walking right away, out of hospital 7 hours after. Still waiting for all to be quiet, I can't bend it backwards 100% but close. Hearing this , glad I waited since I was told to do it 8 years ago. Next knee needs at least a partial, now I know I will only do TKR and a full pad will be better than a partial. I will wait until it screams at me before I go back and keep nursing it til then.
Had a “complex” knee replacement that failed within a few months due to some form of contamination of the metal!. Had several ops to clean out/debrief the abscess that formed. Ultimately the whole prosthesis was removed & the knee area replaced by cement. Result was a stiff leg for 12 months. All the time there was an underlying risk of above knee amputation! Ultimately, I had a second stage complete knee prosthetic inserted with the loss of some tib & fib bone. The operation was a complete success, but my leg is now at least two inches shorter than previously - hence a pronounced limp! The prosthetic is working well - only minus is the knee jerks forward occasionally, causing me to stumble. I use crutches continuously for added support.
Well my 3rd day out,Had some pain this morning, no family living close, sorta on my own feeling good & stronger, i can see how a guy might over do it,thats in the front of my mind too,, but for me just at this short time, soo glad i did it, and with Talking With Docs was a big helper thanks Leland
Interesting information. I had my right knee replaced May of 2019. I was not told not to run. I did my first dog show 6 weeks post op. I guess my knee will wear out sooner since I have to run to show the dogs. Much less pain now though. Thanks for the info.
You are very welcome Heidi. Running short distances for the dog shows are probably not the culprit. We are more talking about long and middle distance runners. Hope that clarifies. Glad you got back to something you love. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I am 73 and generally I jog, not too fast a quarter of a mile then walk about 3/4 of a mile and then jog another quarter of a mile and then walk the last half mile. Is this Considered not too strenuous? I have ADHD with an emphasis on the H. If I don’t jog for a day or two I really am antsy. Not being able to do this was really bumming me out. Do you think it would be OK two or three times a week. Love love love your videos
I’m a 64 yr old man. Moderately active, good bmi. I’ve had my left knee total replacement 22 yrs and the right knee total replacement 21 yrs. No significant problems. My original doctor said they could last 20 yrs, or maybe the rest of my life. Am I an exception?
OMG I know this is truth but I’m hoping mine will last 40-50yrs lol. This has been such a pain in the butt recovery. I need my right one done and absolutely don’t want to even go there.
Hi San D. Yes it is a painful procedure for sure. Keep working hard. Do your exercises on both sides and maybe you can avoid surgery for awhile on the right. Good luck and thanks for watching.
Love the information on all of your videos! Wish I could get one of you to do my tkr. Too long a wait time so it looks like I will have to go to to the US orAlberta.
Hi Bruce. Thanks so much and we are so glad you like the videos. Sorry about the wait times. They will be long for awhile due to the pandemic backlog. Best of luck to you. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Hi mat. Yes sometimes that is possible. It depends if the metal parts are loose from the bone or not. They usually do not wear out though. Great question. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I had mine at age 40. I’m now 63 and mine is doing great. I’ve got an older replacement and they cut everything and now they don’t. I had to literally learn how to walk again due to them cutting everything. And the pain was excruciating..
@ Connie Thank you so much for commenting because I have been worried about how long they last. I am 43 and have been nervous since I had my partial knee replacement 7 weeks ago and thinking about having to revise it every 10 years is stressing me out😞. Its painful. Did you have cemented or cement-less implant?
You guys are great and wish I had seen these before my surgery. I had my TKR 7 years ago at Mayo Clinic and fortunately my surgeon gave almost the same advice you recommended in the Top 5 Things Not to Do and the running part. Due to injuries from my early days of ski racing and bad luck, I had to have mine done at 45. Knowing these are only going to last for a period of time, what happens if I have to have it replaced again and how many times can it be replaced?
Hi Paul. Revising them is possible and sometimes can be done more than once. There are a lot of factors. Just try and take care of them so they last as long as possible. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
I think a real challenge for suppliers/designers of TKR is to figure out a way to allow patients to get back to at least moderate running. For me this is huge.
I had both knees done at the same time Dec 17, 1997. My 79th birthday is Thursday. My biggest problem is stooping down and climbing stairs. The knee joint seems fine and solid. I walk a lot and that is not a problem. I'm probably 30 pounds overweight but do not have any real health issues at this time.
Hi Bobby A. The same principles are true for hip replacements. The main difference is that many of the hip replacements today are uncemented so it removes one of the causes of wear - the cement. So they will often last longer than the knees. But still advised to avoid high impact activity but remain active. Thanks for watching.
I had mine at age 57, I'm now 76 and mine is doing great too even though they used Titanium and cement. I had it done in Dubai due to an accident. Fortunately, I never experienced any pain after the op and it's still fine. No running or jogging and it's just like new, touch wood!
Oil, Dr. Zalzal. When trying to remove those pesky stickers, any oil rubbed into the tag will allow you to instantly scrap it off. I use a drop of canola or any other cooking oil. Notice I said canola, super export for Canada!🥰
Hi lolalola7779. No we do not but that is a very good question and very good topic. There are pros and cons to both. There is a recent trend towards more cementless knees. We will try to get that topic covered. Best to discuss with your surgeon in advance. All the best. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
My knee replacement has lasted for 14 years and it is still going strong. I have lost 30 pounds since having my KN but still walk, nor run, 25 mikes a week!
Hi Mara. We did look at their promotional website after your comment. It is currently in the very early stages. Time will tell if it works long term and has an acceptable complication/side effect rate. Thanks for watching
Hey fellas, Just had my right knee replaced (41yrs old, due to trauma 20yrs ago and three failed ACL surgeries). Question. I love to golf and am curious if walking the golf course vs riding in a cart will speed up (potentail) TKA revision?
Is a 4 mile bike ride every day too much? My TKR is now 4 years old. I downhill ski 10-15 times a year. So far everything seems fine. Which would you recommend: walking or cycling? I really enjoy your videos.
Thanks Robert. We would say no - keep on cycling! Both cycling and walking are fine. Sounds like you are doing very well - congrats. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
Will wearing a high quality knee brace possibly extend the life of a knee replacement? Are mountain biking and road biking acceptable forms of working out post knee replacement?
Hi Chinaskin if you knee is stable a brace should not be necessary. Keep the knee strong, your weight down and avoid high impact. Best of luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
A good friend of mine had his knee replaced thirteen years ago. He is at least seventy pounds overnight, skies 70 to 100 days a years and he skies really hard, lots of moguls and steeps. He also mountain bikes and golfs a few times a week in good weather. He has it done when he was 50. He has had no issues. He knows he is more than likely going to need to have it replaced but he burns hot to resting is not and option.
Hi CORRIGEEN71. So IM nails will often last your entire life. The main reason is that once the bone heals they are no longer doing any work. They are put there to hold the bone in place while it heals. If the bone did not heal, the nail would certainly break. Once it has healed, the nail is just there doing nothing really. Hope that answers your question. Thanks for watching.
I am 70 years old. My total knee was put in 1993. Thats 28 years ago and I have beat the snot out of it. I have a custom made implant known as the NJ knee.
It all points to the incredible genius of design of the human knee. Imagine the cumulative shock loading to the joint over a lifetime of continuous use. Any possibility of organ donation type of replacement. I imagine it would very complex in implementation. It really is amazing what can be accomplished in Knee reconstruction surgery. I wonder if any particular Nutrition is conducive to maintaining the lubricant surface and well being of knee joint and all articulated surfaces of the body.
Hi Bill. We agree. Yes nutrition does play a role but the specifics we do not understand. Transplant is a problem because of the way synovial fluid feeds the cartilage. Maybe some day. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Hi Patrick. It will really depend but it could be either. Each case is a little different. Hope that helps. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Hi Philippa. If you are a severe pronator it can lead to a valgus deformity but this should be dealt with at the time of your total knee. Sometimes orthotics can help. It should not severely affect the wear of the prosthesis. Thanks for watching.
After my wife had a total knee replacement, one leg was about 8cm longer than prior to the surgery. It’s not clear if the prior damage created the offset, but regardless, she now must wear a lift in all shoes, has lower back pain, and other challenges that didn’t exist prior to her procedure. Perhaps you could address this in a episode… what happens when a knee replacement goes wrong?
Hi David. We are very sorry to hear that. We are also unsure how a knee replacement would be more than 3 inches longer after surgery. When a crooked leg is made straight it does get longer but that is the original length of the leg. Lengthening of the leg is more common with hip replacements but to be honest is not an issue with knee replacements. We suspect there must be something else that could explain this. At any rate, a video on complications is a great idea. All the best. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Great video I had a ankle replacement nine years ago and it is still going strong, unfortunately my bones have decided to make spurs not hurting yet but will need to have them cleaned out and while that is happening they will change my plastic piece. I had the Star ankle replacement. And running or jumping is a no no.
I got one 32 years ago still working great and it was even recalled because the plastic incert was over sterileized and the little peg part broke off a little bit after a year never had it fixed.I was told then it would last about 10 years never took it easy on it have done lots of tree work.
I heard what you said about running. BUT, how about jogging on a high quality treadmill and not going very fast? What about snowboarding? txs for you highly informative videos
You are very welcome mcdavid57. So we still advise against jogging. Power walking. Any time both feet are in the air the impact on your knee increases. Snowboarding is more about wiping out. You have to decide how important it is to you for sure. Best of luck. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Can you talk about a knee revision? I had a knee replacement at 53. Not overweight or anything, just bad luck with severe osteoarthritis. Now at 60, the other knee is really bad. I would go ahead and have it replaced, but I'm terrified of having them both fail.
I have had total knee replacement on both knees 6 yrs ago. For some unknown reason after a short walk n drive to the store I couldn’t bend my knee more than 90 degrees n couldn’t stand on it with a slight bend. I had to totally straighten my leg to walk. When driving my knee rests against the door. Not sure what’s happening. I am 56yrs n 295lbs. My right knee is fine no issues
Booking my surgery for knee replacement tomorrow. I'm 51yrs old and no other choice. I had a second scope this past May. Unsuccessful. Wanted to know which is preferred? Plastic or the titanium? I am scared to death to have this surgery. Your thoughts are very much welcomed. Thanks so much.
Hi Aileen. All knees nowadays have metal and plastic. The spacer between the metal parts is always plastic. Hope that helps. Good luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
@@TalkingWithDocs thank you for replying. And yes I did subscribe. You two are extremely informative. Met with my surgeon today. And now I wait..🤞 😬. Thank you for doing these videos. Everyone who sees them will be very appreciative. Thank you.
I had a total knee replacement 17 years ago. Now the plastic part has worn thin and it needs to be replaced. My doctor says it can be done as an out-patient.
I was just told by my doc that the clicking in my knee is a good sign that the prosthetic will last longer! This particular prosthetic has a prong on it that causes the clicking but increases the durability. I'm due for another TKR on the other knee next week. I don't want to be walking around on two clicking knees! So do certain prosthetics click more than others?
Hi Clicky . . . we mean Jay! Just kidding. Lots of total knees click. It is usually not a big deal and will often decrease with time. Good luck with your next procedure.
I am a 60 yr old military retired vet in pretty good shape but have one hip and one knee replacement. 2 questions: should strength training increase the life of those fake joints? What do you recommend for cardio workouts if I want the joints to last as long as possible.
Hi John. Yes strength training is good for your general health and bone strength. As for best activity, anything that is low impact that raises your heart rate is good. Best of luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I had 2 arthroscopic surgeries. I had a very good surgeon. I have no problems now. First one done for L inside tear. It was bad! Then I tore it again! He fixed it with significant arthritis. He told me, I can clean it up, but cannot stop the arthritis. Next time is a TKR! Thanx for video fellas!
Hi Michele. For sure its hard and younger people have the hardest time it seems. It will get better. Pain control. Control the swelling. Do your physio. Repeat. Best of luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
My awesome Orthopedic Surgeon did a great job. Very smart, caring, knows his job doctor. Dr. Ronald Jones, just retired, Saint Joseph's in Eureka, and Fortuna, hospitals. Dr. Feely in San Francisco did my total reversal shoulder replacement, almost three years ago now. Great job, considering my osteogenesis imperfecta. Some docs seer clear of me. Don't blame them. Rather have that, then go ahead with a doctor that's unsure!
Hey Doc’s I had a total knee replacement 7 weeks ago doing well my physical therapist told recovering very well, told him I watched you guys and did the Pre surgery exercises he told me that helped a lot, so I’m 65 years old how about riding a bike 🚲 is that ok on the new knee Thanks Rob
Greetings gentlemen! I am just about to have a Scheker Distal Radio Ulnar Joint Implant installed in my right arm in less than two (2) weeks, and I have been watching some of your videos because they were recommended by UA-cam, and because I thought that there would be some similarities between both the artificial joints and the preparation for the surgeries, and what to expect following the surgery. One thing that I have learned specifically is to take the pain medication as prescribed like clockwork to avoid being in pain, thereby making the healing process go more smoothly, and thus returning to normal activities as soon as possible. However, I have not considered until now, how many years I could expect to use the joint without needing a replacement. I had originally planned to have the Ulna shortened, since it is 1.5 centimeters too long 25 years following a major snowboarding accident which resulted in a monteggia fracture of the right Ulna and the disintegration of the end of the Radius at the elbow end, and resulted in the installation of a silastic implant on the end of the Radius and many surgeries and two bone grafts on the Ulna. The wrist was also broken in three (3) different locations. After 25 years, it has been found that the Ulna is too long and the distal end of it is in really bad shape, so shortening the Ulna would not provide favorable results, hence the surgery that has been scheduled. Since the implant is a relatively new procedure, I have absolutely no idea how long it will last, but since it will not be under the amount of pressure that a knee wound normally be, I would expect it to last at least 25-30 years or more, but I will ask my surgeon to provide me an estimate, now that has been brought to my attention. I have gathered a great deal of knowledge about artificial knees from watching your videos, and from reading through the comments. Thank you for posting this and other videos! Please have an excellent and awesome day! 🙂👍
Thanks so much Mike. Glad we could help in any small way. Best of luck with your procedure and please keep us posted. Stay safe. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
@@TalkingWithDocs Thank you Doctors! I have learned a lot about artificial joints, and about how to best prepare for such a surgical procedure. I have been working with my physical and occupational therapists to help prepare me for the surgery with exercises to do prior to the operation, and also with ways to help manage doing things that normally require the use of two (2) hands. I have found your UA-cam channel so resourceful, that I had subscribed several videos ago. It would be awesome to find videos similar to yours, that featured information specifically for the procedure that I am scheduled for next week. Thank you for posting these videos! Please have an excellent and awesome New Year! 🙂🎉
Its weird 3 years ago I had both knees replaced, 3 years later my left knee is buckling again when I had that replaced even after surgery in physical therapy it buckled i.m 52 years old it took 3 months to recover! My knee doctor did a new surgical technique on my right knee took only 2 months to recover no buckling after surgery and no buckling now
So usually by X-ray. This can assess the plastic to a certain degree as well as the cement mantle. As well as your symptoms. Thanks for watching and subscribing
I seem to recall my Dr. Telling me I would probably need a revision (?) in roughly 12 - 15 years. Basically going in and replacing the plastic ( ?) pads ( 12 years in now on a Smith & Nephew). Is this a more/less invasive a surgery and how does the pain compare?
Hi J Elmo. So yes you could argue it is slightly less invasive but you need to go through the same incision which is the main cause of the pain so usually comparable. Hope that helps. Thank you for watching, subscribing and sharing if you did.
Following a motorcycle accident at age 53 I had my right knee replaced with a Scorpio joint. Now, 20 years later, the joint needs replacement, so my initial estimate of the joint's life ("10 to 15 years") has been easily exceeded. Iam a 6ft tall heavily built guy (260 lbs) so I have been delighted with the knee's performance. Thanks for your excellent videos.
Very welcome Roy. 20 years - we would take that every time. Best of luck with your revision. Thanks for watching, subscribing and for sharing if you did.
Can you run or if not at least jog???
@@kleven2270 Joggin was OK until abouta year ago.
@@TalkingWithDocs Still waiting for my revision following thr pandemic and now the Russian problem. Still able to walk (with a limp) but the wear is causing other nerve related problems with a groin strain feeling and aching hip. Have had all MRI'd and they have no mechanical damage, it's just referred nerve pain. Due for my revision op. 20th december (2022) and our nurses have just announced theri first strike on that date. Hmmmm......
Sir can U tell for how many years an operated person able to walk without any support??
I had my knee replacement 15 years ago. I am a lightweight woman, 116 lbs, age 72. I hike but stopped backpacking after I had this done. I snowshoe, walk, hike, do Yoga. I think my knee will work for the rest of my life.
Awesome Marlene. Thanks for watching and subscribing
You are my hero. I'm scared but now I feel better
Hey Docs my hips and knees are over 20 years old and look like new! My surgeon was surprised but pleased because I had my first hip done at 35 and I’m now 62. I love listening to you because it’s like I’m listening to my doctors (I was an Orthopedic Surgery Scheduler before retirement)
Hi Pamela. Good for you! Glad you are enjoying the videos. All the best. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
Which knee implant did you go with?
That gives some hope. My mum jusf had one knee done and i feel everyday as if im losing her,so afraid of losing her,that kind of pain is unbearable. Your message gives me lil tiny sparkle of hope...
I joined the double knee replacement club about 18 months ago. Walking is great no running. My favorite exersize is swimming. I turned 68 and am loving life. Just sharing and think you guys are great.
Hi Charles. We have put a bunch of patients into that club ourselves. So glad to hear you are enjoying your new knees. Yes running is usually off the table but who needs to run anyway? Thanks so much for sharing and for your kind words Charles. All the best to you. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I had a knee replacement twelve years ago. Serious operation. I can't imagine doing both knees at the same time.
@@johncoll4456 I needed both done and could not imagine going thorugh it twice. Went through alot of knee problems for 30 years. But I,m a happy boy now!
Don't retire too soon Docs, keep those videos coming. Thanks again.
Hi Darlene. No imminent retirement plans just yet. Thanks for watching.
Loved to hear all these things. I’m terrified having this done because of unknown. Glad to hear you both! I haven’t heard this.
Hi eva. Glad we could help in any small way. You will get through it once the time comes. The unknown is scary though and that's what the videos are for - to empower you. Good luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I had both of mine done the same day. They sent me home with a contraption that worked my knee joint that I could increase the angle as I got better. I have great flexion still to this day.
Don't worry, had both knees replaced, 21 and 4 years ago. No recovery aches and pains, normal walking resumed within a month on both occasions. An excellent result both times.Like the doc's say, early excercise and phsio worked a treat for me.
I had a partial replacement on one knee, for arthritis, 12 years ago, age 54.
18 months ago, my leg started collapsing under me and it turned out the polyethylene lining was slipping.
Having a TKR on it next week.
In fairness, my surgeon told me initially that the partial would last 10-15 years, so he was right!
Hoping for 25-40 years for the new one!
Thanks for all your great videos, they’re so helpful.💖
Good luck to you Shelagh. Yes 12 years is not too bad for a partial. Best of luck with the total and you are very welcome. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
@@TalkingWithDocs : Thanks!💖
I love these two doctors. Great information and nicely presented!
Thanks so much John for the kind words. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
I am now 70. I have needed my left knee replaced for about 20 yrs. I had Synvisc injections for all of that time & it worked well for me. Jan 2020 I am getting my knee replaced as the pain is now getting to me.The other knee will also have to be replaced,but thats a few yrs down the road. Thank you Doc's for your video's I have enjoyed them.
Hey Ron. So glad we could help in any way. Good luck in January. Keep us posted on your progress. And thanks for watching
My first knee was done in 2000, it lasted 18 years. I drive semi-local delivery, in and out of the truck 10-12 times a day. Had it replaced in 2108, retired in 2020. Still going strong.
Very nice Randy! Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Which implant did you go with?
The question needed clarification because the answers are all over the place. Nice job.
Glad we could help Willow. Thanks for watching
I've had mine for 25 years now and it's still doing really well and I have no problem with it at all. I was told, at that time, it would last about 10 years.....lol.
Hi diana. Thanks for sharing. A quarter century? That is amazing. Keep it going. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
Mine going on 22 years, they told me 10-15 at least. So happy they were not correct in the estimate.
where you had your knee replace?
Mine was done with a.10 to 15 yrs life time I am now coming up to 24 yrs on SEPT 28TH 2022 THE SURGEON TOLD ME.HE WAS SUCH A.GOOD SURGEON IT WOULD LAST 20YRS ITS NOW 24YRS
So imagine how long these current modern technology knee replacement will last
Four and a half years for my r knee . Done in the UK but using an American prosthetic. No post op pain which was what everyone promised :-) I enjoy working out and do kettlebell goblet squats no problem . It’s been a huge improvement for me
That is awesome Stephen! Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
That's what happened to me too! Went in with nothing but pain and woke up after with no pain! Made them disconnect the morphine drip and switch to oral pain meds because morpine made me vomit so much. Still no pain in knee! Especially compared to opening the whole knee capsule when I was 18 which was indescribably painful!
Hey Docs, My partial knee replacement is 14 years old now and going well. I HAD a high BMI. But, still seem to be in good shape. I never run, but often walk and work hard in the garden. This has been a good health investment. The pain from surgery for three weeks was hell.
Very nice Mr Mockingbird. Thanks for watching and subscribing
I had a total knee replacement, both but one at a time 20 years ago . They were Zimmers and have given me no problem. I needed them young because of the pain. I didn't run but I did clog. and I have almost full range of motion. I feel blessed. The only thing I don't do is run or get down on my knees. Great video. 👍💕😲
I had bilateral replacements. (5 weeks from surgery) I hope to God above I never have to have another.
Hi Nancy. Yes is a very painful operation. Congrats though as you are through the hardest part! Thanks for sharing your story. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
Thank you for that info, my husband is having a total knee replacement this year, this is helpful.
Glad we could help Luwanna. Thanks for watching and for subscribing if you did.
I gor my knee replaced at 39 years of age due to trauma. It is still going strong at 22 years. I had the non-metal parts replaced 3 years ago due to a massive infection that origininated from another part of my body. Don't give up on your knee!
Hi Velma and Spez. Thanks for sharing Velma and good luck to you Spez! Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
Which implant did you go with
Well, my own knee was crap. Injuries started at 17. Had arthritis in it by 30. TKR at 50...5.5 yrs. ago. Probably waited a year too long. It was the 8th surgery on that knee. I’m now able to hike for 5-8 miles. I am on ladders for work and walk on rooftops. My TKR gave me back my life joy. My other knee is coming in another year or two.
Glad it helped you so much CinkSVideo. Keep it up and good luck with your next knkee. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Had t
Hi Doc’s, I had my knee replaced Jan 16/20. It is now 3 weeks & so far so good. I had a spinal instead anesthesia which I would recommend as you are not full of gas. After surgery there is not much time for relaxing. Your up & walking a bit hours after surgery. Amazing! I was in hospital 2 days then home again. I’m going to physio twice a week & I’m finding it a bit tough at the moment. I think my bend is around 90 deg. Obviously I still have a ways to yet.
Your videos are so informative.
Hi Ron. Sounds like you have the right approach. Lots of hard work and it will come. Make sure your pain is controlled and you have a strategy for swelling control. Best of luck to you and thanks so much for watching.
I hope your knees are doing well! I’ve heard therapy afterwards is the worst. I’ve had both hips replaced and one revised but that really wasn’t bad.
Did they send you home with the device that works your knee joint for you while in bed?? You can get up to I think 120 deg. I had both knees done and went back to work in 2.5 months with over 120 deg. I hope they still do that.
Great info! Hoping for 20 yrs for my btkr depue, titanium knees. I can accept being wheel chair bound better at 74 than at 54, when I had my surgery. My knee replacements were god-sent since I waited till I couldn't stand it anymore to have the surgery. Don't be fooled that the replacements are better than your real knees but they are much better than what you endured waiting for the knees to wear out enough to replace.
Hi Donna. We could not agree more. They are not normal knees but if you wait long enough you should love them. Best of luck going forward. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I had my first hips replaced with metal on metal and 5 years later I was poisoned with Chromium and Cobalt. My knees started squeeking and failing and I had metal poisoning.
I had to have both knees taken out and replaced. It was a horrendous experience and lots of lost time. I just had a Bi-Lateral knee replacement at 74. I have no regrets and was glad to get it over with at once. I was not overweight and never smoked, so my surgeon and I decided to go for it. I just started to drive again and today is my 8th week after surgery and rehab has been great. I wouldn't recommend it to many people-you need lots of help the first two weeks almost full time. I had home therapy and now finishing up outside therapy this week with no regrets. Believe me, no pain, no gain. Exercise, exercise, and more exercise!
Sorry, I said knees. I meant to type hips!
Congrats Janne. Quite the journey. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
4 months since full left knee replacement. I worked my butt off at PT and feels great now, still a little tender but I’m good to go... and I ride a bike 3/4x a week and lots of squats too just keep it stretched
I’m getting the right one done next week 😱 Perfect timing during this virus 🦠 BS
Good luck next week Las Vegas Valley! Thanks for watching, subscribing and for sharing if you did.
Docs.....I had a L TKR 3 1/2 yrs. ago at 65yo. I had a horrible recovery...
pain and PT for 1 yr.!!!! Wish I had you guys doing my surgery...the Physical Therapist was excellent. Have been an RN for 30 yrs. and a co-worker at NYPH, whom I became friends with recommended one of the surgeons on the Rehabilitation floor we worked on. I only stayed on that unit 5 yrs. but she was sure this was the best and nicest guy.
Well, the years changed him and not for the better. I did have 2 consults but I truly know I picked the wrong surgeon. It was bone on bone, but I wish I never had it done. No one suggested the hylauronic acid injections to me....I have been getting them now for 2 years in my R knee (bone on bone)
and they are helping. One year ago was in a car accident and the
prosthetic knee was smashed against the dash...when the EMT'S saw my knee, they thought I had a compound fracture, swelling was
sticking up about 2 inches from under my slacks and they wanted to cut leg of pants up to knee. Orthopedist (not the same surgeon) said it was a hematoma and would go away in 6 to 8 weeks....its now 11mos.!!!
Before the accident I was eventually able to go hiking without a problem, but the lump and discoloration are still there, though it has gotten somewhat
smaller. I had other injuries and am going to PT for them, but not the knee. The last 3 weeks the pain in the replaced knee has gotten much worse...hard to go up & downstairs...hard to walk and feel a loud click sometimes even turning in bed. Nothing showed up on the x-ray, or the MRI, and am now scheduled to have a bone scan (12/12). Listening to your video, I'm really afraid that by now something has cracked or broken...maybe the plastic. I researched what can be done for a really painful replacement and all I found was, have another
replacement. I can't continue with this pain, it seems worse than before I had it replaced. Please let me know if there is any other way
I can have a normal life. Am on pain meds for back but can't take
any NSAIDS because I ruined my stomach with Advil, despite taking them with milk and/or food. The pain meds are not helping the knee pain. Replaced knee is swollen, hot, and painful. I never want to go through another replacement again....can you Docs think of anything at all?
You both are so nice...how far away are you Docs from NYC or
New Jersey? When people are nice, it makes one cry, which is what I'm doing now. 😢😪😥
Was never heavy till I couldn't hike, walk, or bike. Have lost 17 lbs. since June and would like to lose another 15 or 20lbs. That would put me at a good weight and if lost another 10lbs would be thin. I hope you will be able to respond to me. ( I loved working in the OR.)
Thanks, Docs.
Hi Susan. It sounds like you have had a very difficult journey. Thanks for taking the time to share it with us. Certainly the car accident could have caused the implants to change position or possibly loosen. A bone scan will help with that. Sometimes in car accidents the patella can be injured especially if it has not been resurfaced. Best to wait for the scan and discuss with a different surgeon whether or not they feel there is something to revise to reduce your pain. Please keep us posted on what happens and good luck. Thanks for watching
Definitely the best channel!
Thanks so much Nan '59. And the best viewers and subscribers!
I had a total knee replacement aged 49 in 1980. I’ve now had it 21 years still going strong
Doesn't that make it 41 years david? 21 years is also amazing. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
@@TalkingWithDocs my mistake I’m confusing when I got married with the operation. I had the knee replacement in Jan 2000 so it’s now 21 years.
@@davidmccormick426congratulations! You can fast walk? How many kilometres able to walk daily?
Are u on your feet a lot
Thank you - very interesting! I had mine done at quite suddenly at 73 after smashing my tibial plateau in a fall. I’m trying ro be careful and hoping not to have to do it again. Have resigned myself to being a walker and a retired runner.
Hi Kathleen. You are very welcome. Sorry to hear about the accident. Good idea about retiring the running shoes for walkers. Best of luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
Great info! Love the joy you guys have, keeps my interest when you throw in the comedy!
Thanks Pamela. We do our best! Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
65-year-old male here, with a 11-year-old TKR (right knee). I'm a skinny Minny (65 kg), so that's not a factor.
I'm very active, primarily walking/hiking (2 years ago, I completed the Nijmegen 120-mile forced march in 4 days) and cycling (last year I completed 1,100 mile Land's End to John O'Groats in 16 days). Because these are low-impact activities, I think my knee is holding up pretty well. But just recently, I'm noticing higher volumes of activity causes some knee swelling. I foster dogs and so I dog-walk from 6-8 miles each day and ride a bike trainer about 5 hours per week. I'm monitoring it carefully, but am aware I probably need to back off if I want my TKR to last.
Yes hard to say activity is good for it. If concerned get an X-ray to make sure everything looks ok. Keep moving!
You guys absolutely rule! It’s fun hearing you guys talk and laugh, you guys have a great sense of humour!
We do our best Alida. Thanks for watching and subscribing
I had mine in 2013 & 2015 by Dr Douglas Dennis in Denver Colorado.
I am a professional ski instructor and ski over 100 days per year. I am 69 and all is well and everything so far is great. I also ski and teach Telemark skiing and the knees are fine.
My knees were injured while waiting in my car at a red light and being hit by a semi truck who did not stop. I survived. He did not.
Wow GottaTele. That is a scary story. Glad you are ok and living your best life. Thanks for watching and subscribing
I love watching Talkimg with Docs. I’ve learned a great deal! Thanks for doing this!!!
When I was in the Air Force in 1983 I went to doctor with knee pain, popping, etc. he sent me to therapy for strengthening exercises but told me I would eventually need knee replacement. He said to put it off as long as I could as the technology was evolving and there would be better replacements in the future. I’ve done lots of therapy over the years, plus bicycling as my main exercise. But now the time has come and the knees are toast. Still got a tiny bit of cartilage in left knee, but right is bone on bone. I guess that doctor would be shocked that I took him this seriously and took measures to make the knees last as long as I have. I plan to live well past 100 years, so hope the knees last more than 20 years.
Good luck Tanya. You’ve got this! Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
I had both mine done. One year apart in 2015 -L, 2016-R, 2018- Revision Right due to Knee Instability/Loose Implant. BMI is very high. Battling with prolonged use and effects of steroids for three decades (for pain and severe asthma attacks)- Morbid obesity is the byproduct. I am 47(2021). I was working full time whilst being bone on bone for the span of 10 years- every three month knee injections with Supartz/Hyaluronic membrane/Corticosteroids to tolerate pain while working until I cannot do it anymore. Thanks for the beautiful video, doctors.
Best of luck to you bachok. Hang in there. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
I am 62 and have had both knees replaced- got osteo on both sides of my family..... My first one was at 51 and my 2nd at 55. You said the main reason to replace the TKR is because it becomes loose? Are there common symptoms when that happens? Pain, slipping, catches in the joint? Thanks for all your information!! I've learned a lot from you all. Greetings from the US.
Yes usually pain and swelling. Hope it’s far away for you! Thanks for watching and subscribing
You guys add to my ..getting to be...daily enjoyment. This particular video very appreciated- am considering a knee replacement. Have had 2 hips replaced. The 2nd one is a little wonky when I do knee bends with that knee forward...it kind of 'wavers out to the side'. Have one more follow up with my surgeon so I'll ask him, but it does preoccupy me a bit. Back to main point of this note- much appreciated information-thank you
Mine (2) are 24 years old. I had a minor revision to replace the liner between top and bottom at 22 years. All is well and doctor said the implants look great. Mine were done at 50. I’ve never missed a beat at doing whatever I like to do. Staying a healthy weight is very helpful.
Nice work Art. Thanks for watching and subscribing
Hi Doc's Fantastic series of videos. My knee replacement is 10 years old and starting to become painful again, my surgeon says that the joint has become loose and needs to be replaced again!!! please can I have your thoughts on the implications of a second replacement replacement, thanks
Hi Steve. Glad you are liking the videos. Loosening is probably the number one cause of pain after 10 years of success. Revision surgery is often successful. It is harder than the first procedure but with lots of hard work hopefully you can get back to your regular lifestyle. Best of luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I’m 54 years old and seven weeks postop as of today for a right total knee replacement. The left one needs it too, but it wasn’t as bad. I was 100% bone on bone in the medial and middle part of my knee and had a lot of scar tissue. Anyway, my goal is this December, I can ski again, because I am still having issues with soreness and stiffness. I’ve heard it could take up to a year to recover from. I just hope skiing does not wear out the parts. I always stick to groomed runs, unless there’s been a huge downpour of snow.
Keep pushing
I just love your information and presentation 😁
Thank you so much Juliette. That is very kind. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I really enjoy watching your videos! Thanks
Thanks Darlene.
Excellent...inspiring
I'm confident now of planning for the replacement of my damaged knees
Well that’s good news! Good luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing
9 months ago @73 I had 1st TKR, Started walking right away, out of hospital 7 hours after. Still waiting for all to be quiet, I can't bend it backwards 100% but close.
Hearing this , glad I waited since I was told to do it 8 years ago.
Next knee needs at least a partial, now I know I will only do TKR and a full pad will be better than a partial.
I will wait until it screams at me before I go back and keep nursing it til then.
Yes waiting is most often the best choice
Yet again another useful and informative video…thank you 👍🇬🇧
Glad you liked it Alan. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
Had a “complex” knee replacement that failed within a few months due to some form of contamination of the metal!.
Had several ops to clean out/debrief the abscess that formed.
Ultimately the whole prosthesis was removed & the knee area replaced by cement. Result was a stiff leg for 12 months. All the time there was an underlying risk of above knee amputation!
Ultimately, I had a second stage complete knee prosthetic inserted with the loss of some tib & fib bone.
The operation was a complete success, but my leg is now at least two inches shorter than previously - hence a pronounced limp!
The prosthetic is working well - only minus is the knee jerks forward occasionally, causing me to stumble. I use crutches continuously for added support.
Wow Roger that is a lot to deal with. Glad you are ok. Thanks for watching and subscribing
Well my 3rd day out,Had some pain this morning, no family living close, sorta on my own feeling good & stronger, i can see how a guy might over do it,thats in the front of my mind too,, but for me just at this short time, soo glad i did it, and with Talking With Docs was a big helper thanks Leland
Yay Leland! Congrats
Interesting information. I had my right knee replaced May of 2019. I was not told not to run. I did my first dog show 6 weeks post op. I guess my knee will wear out sooner since I have to run to show the dogs. Much less pain now though. Thanks for the info.
You are very welcome Heidi. Running short distances for the dog shows are probably not the culprit. We are more talking about long and middle distance runners. Hope that clarifies. Glad you got back to something you love. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I am 73 and generally I jog, not too fast a quarter of a mile then walk about 3/4 of a mile and then jog another quarter of a mile and then walk the last half mile. Is this Considered not too strenuous? I have ADHD with an emphasis on the H. If I don’t jog for a day or two I really am antsy. Not being able to do this was really bumming me out. Do you think it would be OK two or three times a week. Love love love your videos
I’m a 64 yr old man. Moderately active, good bmi. I’ve had my left knee total replacement 22 yrs and the right knee total replacement 21 yrs. No significant problems. My original doctor said they could last 20 yrs, or maybe the rest of my life. Am I an exception?
Hi Mark. No there are more and more stories like this. Congrats. Thanks for watching and subscribing
I had mine replaced 36 and 34 years ago. Still doing great.
That b is amazing Elizabeth! Thanks for sharing. Thanks for watching and subscribing
OMG I know this is truth but I’m hoping mine will last 40-50yrs lol. This has been such a pain in the butt recovery. I need my right one done and absolutely don’t want to even go there.
Hi San D. Yes it is a painful procedure for sure. Keep working hard. Do your exercises on both sides and maybe you can avoid surgery for awhile on the right. Good luck and thanks for watching.
Love the information on all of your videos! Wish I could get one of you to do my tkr. Too long a wait time so it looks like I will have to go to to the US orAlberta.
Hi Bruce. Thanks so much and we are so glad you like the videos. Sorry about the wait times. They will be long for awhile due to the pandemic backlog. Best of luck to you. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Hi, what happen when the plastic part wear off? Can it be replaced without changing the titanium parts? Thaanks... Enjoyed watching your videos...
Hi mat. Yes sometimes that is possible. It depends if the metal parts are loose from the bone or not. They usually do not wear out though. Great question. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
Yes, it can be done without replacing the other parts.
I had mine at age 40. I’m now 63 and mine is doing great. I’ve got an older replacement and they cut everything and now they don’t. I had to literally learn how to walk again due to them cutting everything. And the pain was excruciating..
Hi Connie. Thanks for sharing. 23 years that is amazing! Keep up the good work and thanks for watching.
@ Connie Thank you so much for commenting because I have been worried about how long they last. I am 43 and have been nervous since I had my partial knee replacement 7 weeks ago and thinking about having to revise it every 10 years is stressing me out😞. Its painful. Did you have cemented or cement-less implant?
Worst pain I’ve been through.
@@terryosowski8143 I hear you. I am going through it right now at 5 weeks.
Me too
You guys are great and wish I had seen these before my surgery. I had my TKR 7 years ago at Mayo Clinic and fortunately my surgeon gave almost the same advice you recommended in the Top 5 Things Not to Do and the running part. Due to injuries from my early days of ski racing and bad luck, I had to have mine done at 45. Knowing these are only going to last for a period of time, what happens if I have to have it replaced again and how many times can it be replaced?
Hi Paul. Revising them is possible and sometimes can be done more than once. There are a lot of factors. Just try and take care of them so they last as long as possible. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
My first has lasted 21 years, now awaiting revision (replacement), second one hardly run-in yet at 4 years old. No worries on replacement then.
I think a real challenge for suppliers/designers of TKR is to figure out a way to allow patients to get back to at least moderate running. For me this is huge.
Some would argue the evidence that says you shouldn’t run is weak at best. It seems to make sense but there isn’t a lot of data
I had both knees done at the same time Dec 17, 1997. My 79th birthday is Thursday. My biggest problem is stooping down and climbing stairs. The knee joint seems fine and solid. I walk a lot and that is not a problem. I'm probably 30 pounds overweight but do not have any real health issues at this time.
Nice work Glenn. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
How about a similar discussion on total hip replacement. Thanks, great and helpful videos.
There is many videos thry have made about hip replacement.
Hi Bobby A. The same principles are true for hip replacements. The main difference is that many of the hip replacements today are uncemented so it removes one of the causes of wear - the cement. So they will often last longer than the knees. But still advised to avoid high impact activity but remain active. Thanks for watching.
Thanks Eliska.
I had mine at age 57, I'm now 76 and mine is doing great too even though they used Titanium and cement. I had it done in Dubai due to an accident. Fortunately, I never experienced any pain after the op and it's still fine. No running or jogging and it's just like new, touch wood!
Very nice alan. Keep it up! Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
can you please tell me the name of hospital?
@@RG-tq4un The American Hospital In 2002. I expect the surgeon is retired now. Known as Dr 'Sammy'.
Oil, Dr. Zalzal. When trying to remove those pesky stickers, any oil rubbed into the tag will allow you to instantly scrap it off. I use a drop of canola or any other cooking oil. Notice I said canola, super export for Canada!🥰
Ha nice
Hi Docs! Do you have video on cementless vs cemented implants. Which is preferred?
Hi lolalola7779. No we do not but that is a very good question and very good topic. There are pros and cons to both. There is a recent trend towards more cementless knees. We will try to get that topic covered. Best to discuss with your surgeon in advance. All the best. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
@@TalkingWithDocs Thanks! I asked my doctor about cementless and he said he would prob go with that if I needed total knee conversion in the future.
I have had mine for almost 23 years and still going strong.
Amazing. Thanks for watching and subscribing
My knee replacement has lasted for 14 years and it is still going strong. I have lost 30 pounds since having my KN but still walk, nor run, 25 mikes a week!
Nice job Mark. Thanks for watching and subscribing
Would you consider doing an episode on the Calypso knee system and when it might be available?
Hi Mara. We did look at their promotional website after your comment. It is currently in the very early stages. Time will tell if it works long term and has an acceptable complication/side effect rate. Thanks for watching
@@TalkingWithDocs Thanks for looking into it. How long do clinical trials for this type of thing usually take?
Hey fellas,
Just had my right knee replaced (41yrs old, due to trauma 20yrs ago and three failed ACL surgeries).
Question. I love to golf and am curious if walking the golf course vs riding in a cart will speed up (potentail) TKA revision?
Hi Mitch. We would say walking the course is likely ok. Just stay out of the rough!! Thanks for watching and subscribing
Is a 4 mile bike ride every day too much? My TKR is now 4 years old. I downhill ski 10-15 times a year. So far everything seems fine. Which would you recommend: walking or cycling? I really enjoy your videos.
Thanks Robert. We would say no - keep on cycling! Both cycling and walking are fine. Sounds like you are doing very well - congrats. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
Will wearing a high quality knee brace possibly extend the life of a knee replacement? Are mountain biking and road biking acceptable forms of working out post knee replacement?
Hi Chinaskin if you knee is stable a brace should not be necessary. Keep the knee strong, your weight down and avoid high impact. Best of luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
A good friend of mine had his knee replaced thirteen years ago. He is at least seventy pounds overnight, skies 70
to 100 days a years and he skies really hard, lots of moguls and steeps. He also mountain bikes and golfs a few times a week in good weather. He has it done when he was 50. He has had no issues. He knows he is more than likely going to need to have it replaced but he burns hot to resting is not and option.
Hi Scott. Yes you may need one but he will enjoy life. Thanks for watching and subscribing
@@TalkingWithDocs To true, take care.
Intermedullary nail 8n my right leg how long will it last, and general lifr time of metal implants??
Hi CORRIGEEN71. So IM nails will often last your entire life. The main reason is that once the bone heals they are no longer doing any work. They are put there to hold the bone in place while it heals. If the bone did not heal, the nail would certainly break. Once it has healed, the nail is just there doing nothing really. Hope that answers your question. Thanks for watching.
What are your options if a TKR fails?
Depends on the cause of failure but often revision
Revision?
I am 70 years old. My total knee was put in 1993. Thats 28 years ago and I have beat the snot out of it. I have a custom made implant known as the NJ knee.
Very cool Fred. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
I’ve had both mine replaced about 6 years now and couldn’t be happier.
Thanks for sharing Sage'wmn. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing if you did.
How difficult was the recovery? What did you do for the pain?
@@cherylmcnutt9905 Same question I am 20 and have arthritis my knee is in bad condition Doctors have recommended TKR and i am scared.
@@TheSD75 Ha! I’m 63 and the doctor said I’d have to wait 5 to 10 years, because they wear out.
I got mine at 39 years old , best thing I ever did, my life sucks 95 percent less
Well that is awesome! Thanks for watching and subscribing
It all points to the incredible genius of design of the human knee. Imagine the cumulative shock loading to the joint over a lifetime of continuous use.
Any possibility of organ donation type of replacement. I imagine it would very complex in implementation.
It really is amazing what can be accomplished in Knee reconstruction surgery. I wonder if any particular
Nutrition is conducive to maintaining the lubricant surface and well being of knee joint and all articulated surfaces of the body.
Hi Bill. We agree. Yes nutrition does play a role but the specifics we do not understand. Transplant is a problem because of the way synovial fluid feeds the cartilage. Maybe some day. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Can the plastic component be replaced?
I just had a TKR at 60yo.
Let's say I wear it out in 15!years.
Will they replace the whole knee again or just the plastics.
Thanks
Patrick
Hi Patrick. It will really depend but it could be either. Each case is a little different. Hope that helps. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Is Dr Steadman a good Orthopaedic surgeon ,thanks
Hi Charlieboy Lol. We do not know Dr Steadman sorry. Good luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
If you have pronation/flat feet can this adversely affect how the wear on the prosthesis evolves and cause more wear in some areas over others?
Hi Philippa. If you are a severe pronator it can lead to a valgus deformity but this should be dealt with at the time of your total knee. Sometimes orthotics can help. It should not severely affect the wear of the prosthesis. Thanks for watching.
I am in my 16th year with mine and going great.
Just saw this. 16 years and counting. That's awesome. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
After my wife had a total knee replacement, one leg was about 8cm longer than prior to the surgery. It’s not clear if the prior damage created the offset, but regardless, she now must wear a lift in all shoes, has lower back pain, and other challenges that didn’t exist prior to her procedure. Perhaps you could address this in a episode… what happens when a knee replacement goes wrong?
Hi David. We are very sorry to hear that. We are also unsure how a knee replacement would be more than 3 inches longer after surgery. When a crooked leg is made straight it does get longer but that is the original length of the leg. Lengthening of the leg is more common with hip replacements but to be honest is not an issue with knee replacements. We suspect there must be something else that could explain this. At any rate, a video on complications is a great idea. All the best. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
8mm, not cm! Thanks for the reply.
Great video I had a ankle replacement nine years ago and it is still going strong, unfortunately my bones have decided to make spurs not hurting yet but will need to have them cleaned out and while that is happening they will change my plastic piece. I had the Star ankle replacement. And running or jumping is a no no.
Interesting L. A pioneer. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
I got one 32 years ago still working great and it was even recalled because the plastic incert was over sterileized and the little peg part broke off a little bit after a year never had it fixed.I was told then it would last about 10 years never took it easy on it have done lots of tree work.
Hi Michael Stem. Glad it is going well. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
I heard what you said about running. BUT, how about jogging on a high quality treadmill and not going very fast? What about snowboarding? txs for you highly informative videos
You are very welcome mcdavid57. So we still advise against jogging. Power walking. Any time both feet are in the air the impact on your knee increases. Snowboarding is more about wiping out. You have to decide how important it is to you for sure. Best of luck. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Will be overweight make a difference in the longevity of the implant?
Yes it can Sharon. Hard to know exactly how much of a difference. Thanks for watching and subscribing
Can you talk about a knee revision? I had a knee replacement at 53. Not overweight or anything, just bad luck with severe osteoarthritis. Now at 60, the other knee is really bad. I would go ahead and have it replaced, but I'm terrified of having them both fail.
Hi Jill. We will definitely add it to our list of topics to cover in the future. Best of luck to you. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I have had total knee replacement on both knees 6 yrs ago. For some unknown reason after a short walk n drive to the store I couldn’t bend my knee more than 90 degrees n couldn’t stand on it with a slight bend. I had to totally straighten my leg to walk. When driving my knee rests against the door. Not sure what’s happening. I am 56yrs n 295lbs. My right knee is fine no issues
Hi Pauline. Hard to say. Best to see your doc and get an X-ray to check things out. Thanks for watching and subscribing
Booking my surgery for knee replacement tomorrow. I'm 51yrs old and no other choice. I had a second scope this past May. Unsuccessful. Wanted to know which is preferred? Plastic or the titanium? I am scared to death to have this surgery. Your thoughts are very much welcomed. Thanks so much.
Hi Aileen. All knees nowadays have metal and plastic. The spacer between the metal parts is always plastic. Hope that helps. Good luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
@@TalkingWithDocs thank you for replying. And yes I did subscribe. You two are extremely informative. Met with my surgeon today. And now I wait..🤞 😬. Thank you for doing these videos. Everyone who sees them will be very appreciative. Thank you.
I had a total knee replacement 17 years ago. Now the plastic part has worn thin and it needs to be replaced. My doctor says it can be done as an out-patient.
That sounds pretty good Hella Tomczak. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
I was just told by my doc that the clicking in my knee is a good sign that the prosthetic will last longer! This particular prosthetic has a prong on it that causes the clicking but increases the durability. I'm due for another TKR on the other knee next week. I don't want to be walking around on two clicking knees! So do certain prosthetics click more than others?
Hi Clicky . . . we mean Jay! Just kidding. Lots of total knees click. It is usually not a big deal and will often decrease with time. Good luck with your next procedure.
I second that about the knee clicking going away after a few years😂 Eight years titanium and cement
Got my TKR at 14 years old due to osteogenic sarcoma. I’m 42 now with the same knee! Yearly scans still show it going strong.
Awesome Marci. What a champ! Thanks for watching and subscribing
I am a 60 yr old military retired vet in pretty good shape but have one hip and one knee replacement. 2 questions: should strength training increase the life of those fake joints? What do you recommend for cardio workouts if I want the joints to last as long as possible.
Hi John. Yes strength training is good for your general health and bone strength. As for best activity, anything that is low impact that raises your heart rate is good. Best of luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
I had 2 arthroscopic surgeries. I had a very good surgeon. I have no problems now. First one done for L inside tear. It was bad! Then I tore it again!
He fixed it with significant arthritis. He told me, I can clean it up, but cannot stop the arthritis. Next time is a TKR! Thanx for video fellas!
You are very welcome Jean. Good luck once you are ready to pull the trigger on the TKR! Thanks for watching.
Hi, I am on my 7th week PO, not a fan yet, still pain and stiffness, hope it gets better, had mine done as outpatient on 10/22, not recommended.
Hi Michele. For sure its hard and younger people have the hardest time it seems. It will get better. Pain control. Control the swelling. Do your physio. Repeat. Best of luck. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
Worst pain I’ve been through. It ruined me.
@@TalkingWithDocs How is the pain controlled? How is swelling controlled?
My awesome Orthopedic Surgeon did a great job. Very smart, caring, knows his job doctor. Dr. Ronald Jones, just retired, Saint Joseph's in Eureka, and Fortuna, hospitals. Dr. Feely in San Francisco did my total reversal shoulder replacement, almost three years ago now. Great job, considering my osteogenesis imperfecta. Some docs seer clear of me. Don't blame them. Rather have that, then go ahead with a doctor that's unsure!
Yes Rose - you want an expert. OI is complicated for sure. Glad you are ok. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Awesome...you guys are very interesting.
Thanks so much Robert. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing with someone if you did.
Hey Doc’s I had a total knee replacement 7 weeks ago doing well my physical therapist told recovering very well, told him I watched you guys and did the Pre surgery exercises he told me that helped a lot, so I’m 65 years old how about riding a bike 🚲 is that ok on the new knee Thanks Rob
Hi RMK22 SR. Congrats on doing so well. 7 weeks and biking sounds perfect. Keep it going. Thanks for watching, subscribing and sharing if you did.
Yes you can. Important to be able to bend your knee to more than 90 degrees.
Greetings gentlemen!
I am just about to have a Scheker Distal Radio Ulnar Joint Implant installed in my right arm in less than two (2) weeks, and I have been watching some of your videos because they were recommended by UA-cam, and because I thought that there would be some similarities between both the artificial joints and the preparation for the surgeries, and what to expect following the surgery. One thing that I have learned specifically is to take the pain medication as prescribed like clockwork to avoid being in pain, thereby making the healing process go more smoothly, and thus returning to normal activities as soon as possible. However, I have not considered until now, how many years I could expect to use the joint without needing a replacement. I had originally planned to have the Ulna shortened, since it is 1.5 centimeters too long 25 years following a major snowboarding accident which resulted in a monteggia fracture of the right Ulna and the disintegration of the end of the Radius at the elbow end, and resulted in the installation of a silastic implant on the end of the Radius and many surgeries and two bone grafts on the Ulna. The wrist was also broken in three (3) different locations. After 25 years, it has been found that the Ulna is too long and the distal end of it is in really bad shape, so shortening the Ulna would not provide favorable results, hence the surgery that has been scheduled. Since the implant is a relatively new procedure, I have absolutely no idea how long it will last, but since it will not be under the amount of pressure that a knee wound normally be, I would expect it to last at least 25-30 years or more, but I will ask my surgeon to provide me an estimate, now that has been brought to my attention. I have gathered a great deal of knowledge about artificial knees from watching your videos, and from reading through the comments.
Thank you for posting this and other videos! Please have an excellent and awesome day! 🙂👍
Thanks so much Mike. Glad we could help in any small way. Best of luck with your procedure and please keep us posted. Stay safe.
Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did.
@@TalkingWithDocs
Thank you Doctors!
I have learned a lot about artificial joints, and about how to best prepare for such a surgical procedure. I have been working with my physical and occupational therapists to help prepare me for the surgery with exercises to do prior to the operation, and also with ways to help manage doing things that normally require the use of two (2) hands.
I have found your UA-cam channel so resourceful, that I had subscribed several videos ago. It would be awesome to find videos similar to yours, that featured information specifically for the procedure that I am scheduled for next week.
Thank you for posting these videos! Please have an excellent and awesome New Year! 🙂🎉
What are the symptoms that your artificial knee is failing? I had a bilateral TKR at the age of 53, which was 16 years ago.
Hi ANN. usually increasing pain and swelling and less likely clunking or a change in alignment. Thanks for watching and subscribing if you did
Its weird 3 years ago I had both knees replaced, 3 years later my left knee is buckling again when I had that replaced even after surgery in physical therapy it buckled i.m 52 years old it took 3 months to recover! My knee doctor did a new surgical technique on my right knee took only 2 months to recover no buckling after surgery and no buckling now
Is there any way to measure the health of the implant? Is there any research to figure how to repair tkr ?
So usually by X-ray. This can assess the plastic to a certain degree as well as the cement mantle. As well as your symptoms. Thanks for watching and subscribing
Does the “brand” of the TKR matter?
Not really Roberta. They are all similar and most have good results. Subtle differences between brands. Thanks for watching and subscribing
I seem to recall my Dr. Telling me I would probably need a revision (?) in roughly 12 - 15 years. Basically going in and replacing the plastic ( ?) pads ( 12 years in now on a Smith & Nephew). Is this a more/less invasive a surgery and how does the pain compare?
Hi J Elmo. So yes you could argue it is slightly less invasive but you need to go through the same incision which is the main cause of the pain so usually comparable. Hope that helps. Thank you for watching, subscribing and sharing if you did.