Will German conservatives' tough migration plans play into the far right's hands? | DW News

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @AnantVemuri
    @AnantVemuri 16 днів тому +91

    The governments need to stop allowing people to come and enjoy the social security support. And stop thinking about cheap labour but focus on quality. Ease labour laws and streamline investment for startups and innovation.

    • @dorjeelangchu3122
      @dorjeelangchu3122 15 днів тому +1

      It easy to cultivate argiculture by instagram but it hard to act upon ..! We know that

    • @MBJ2323
      @MBJ2323 15 днів тому +3

      Says an immigrant …

    • @PratikMukerjee
      @PratikMukerjee 15 днів тому

      @@MBJ2323 he is right though german economy's biggest problem is it's excessive labour laws other than the governemnt services or the age old companeis of germany liek bmw mercedes bayer adidas sap and all more and more businesses will move out/not consider germany for investment because asian countries particularly as wlel as the US have much more favourable busienss climates these days

    • @AnantVemuri
      @AnantVemuri 14 днів тому +4

      @@MBJ2323 An Tax paying immigrant :). Not sapping the economy of social security benefits.😏

  • @happiness5432
    @happiness5432 15 днів тому +31

    Anything that helps Germans.
    DW: Far right is here! Far right! Far Right!

    • @MrTEA2
      @MrTEA2 11 днів тому +1

      bots working overtime, ...

    • @franzsigel7166
      @franzsigel7166 11 днів тому

      Idk how Merz is helping by making lives worse for the average German.

    • @MrTEA2
      @MrTEA2 10 днів тому

      @@franzsigel7166 nice account ! Does the CCP pay you well ?

  • @jabba2454
    @jabba2454 15 днів тому +34

    Only let people in who benefit Germany

  • @PeterJordansonn
    @PeterJordansonn 16 днів тому +111

    Instead of being obsessed with mass immigration European leaders should try to improve birth rate among the native Europeans.

    • @kianlakchi7182
      @kianlakchi7182 16 днів тому +12

      Both are important but you are right (so indeed this comment is useless, that's 3 seconds you won't get back)

    • @ruiferreira6578
      @ruiferreira6578 16 днів тому +3

      Having more kids to increase youth unemployment?
      Having emigration is cheaper.
      You don't have to rase kids until they start working....

    • @bartelgrant
      @bartelgrant 15 днів тому +3

      As nice as that may sound in your head, growing a new generation of adults would take at least two decades. Two decades of tax burden (investing in kindergardens, schools, hospitals, paid parental leave) without direct return on investment. The question is what do you do in the meantime?

    • @khanhtrinh8008
      @khanhtrinh8008 15 днів тому

      They dont care, at least i know that for sure in Germany. Anyone with the right mind who leaves in Germany know better not to have more than 2 children because the childcare system here is sooooo bad that one of the parents quite ofzen is forced to either quit their job or do part time. They dont invest enough in producing more childcare personnel. Now parents are left to pretty much elbowing each other, begging for a childcare place so they can go to work. Our family decided to have 1 child and this bad system is definitely one of the main reasons we decided so. It's a very horrendous situation here

    • @mrraam2151
      @mrraam2151 15 днів тому +16

      ​@@bartelgrantthis is exactly the kind of mind set why Europe is declining, trying to find quick fixes

  • @Benjamin-hg018
    @Benjamin-hg018 15 днів тому +30

    He's no better than Olaf. This will bring even more problems.

    • @MovieRiotHD
      @MovieRiotHD 15 днів тому

      As a curious outsider: why do you think so? What are for both the ups and downs?

    • @micaeloliveira2727
      @micaeloliveira2727 15 днів тому +4

      Olaf unfortunately is the best for Germany 🤦‍♂️ what's wrong with world nowadays

    • @kraiker9651
      @kraiker9651 15 днів тому

      ​@@micaeloliveira2727 considering he chose to go to Ukraine and sign another agreement instead of saving his country when German government collapsed, that's highly doubtful

    • @micaeloliveira2727
      @micaeloliveira2727 15 днів тому +1

      @@kraiker9651 he supports higher debt limit and investment in public infrastructure

    • @kraiker9651
      @kraiker9651 15 днів тому +1

      @@micaeloliveira2727 there is a difference between what he supports and what he does. In my opinion he commited a treason (he's a GERMAN chancellor, not Ukrainian), no promises or opinions matter in this situation. It's not like anyone else is good, but waiting for something positive from Olaf is not possible for me

  • @geo322242
    @geo322242 15 днів тому +9

    Hard for some to accept but Europe needs to invest in defence and reduce illegal immigration, especially those of hugely different cultural background who are not willing to adjust. No diplomacy is respected if there is not a decent army backing it.

  • @Johnnywalnuts1
    @Johnnywalnuts1 12 днів тому +4

    AFD is not far enough to the right

  • @samwise6444
    @samwise6444 15 днів тому +13

    YOU CAN'T REGULATE PEOPLE'S REALITY!!!

    • @nareshwildbones
      @nareshwildbones 15 днів тому +5

      But you can definitely regulate which people get to come here and influence the reality of people living here

    • @PPfilmemacher
      @PPfilmemacher 11 днів тому

      Right, You can't, but unfortunately that doesn't stop politicians from trying again and again

  • @Zockopa
    @Zockopa 14 днів тому +4

    The german economy is bleeding out and he will regulate Meta. What a joke.
    But he is also the person who wants more german action in the Ukraine war.
    I wonder if he is living in the same universe.

  • @MattyG96
    @MattyG96 15 днів тому +20

    Very 1984. You should be proud Europe

  • @driasalta4834
    @driasalta4834 16 днів тому +31

    Demographics is destiny.

    • @nuqwestr
      @nuqwestr 16 днів тому +7

      I'm in Southern California. I watched that truth unfold over the last 30 years.

  • @SyedWadud-j2c
    @SyedWadud-j2c 15 днів тому +4

    Regulate? It was used by USSR. Where is freedom of speech?

  • @kobra6335
    @kobra6335 15 днів тому +38

    With regards to free speech, Europe is becoming more like Russia and China.

    • @CrackCocaKolaine
      @CrackCocaKolaine 15 днів тому +8

      True. Freedom of speech is essential to democracy.

    • @CrackCocaKolaine
      @CrackCocaKolaine 15 днів тому +7

      @@kobra6335 Google censors right talking points while favoring left talking points..

    • @CrackCocaKolaine
      @CrackCocaKolaine 15 днів тому

      @@kobra6335 Google has committed crimes

    • @dort-s9g
      @dort-s9g 15 днів тому +5

      You guys are censoring tik tok, where's the free speech?

    • @PotatoSchrank
      @PotatoSchrank 15 днів тому +8

      Brother, you can't even say bad words on television in the US, what are you on...

  • @WoJackHorseman24
    @WoJackHorseman24 15 днів тому +7

    Unless citizenship is obtained through fraud, how could it ever be revoked? If citizenship can be revoked, it is essentially reduced to residency. Citizenship should be permanent

    • @PratikMukerjee
      @PratikMukerjee 15 днів тому

      but very extreme cases though like shamima begum was revoked of her citizenship becasue she joined ISIS so unless you get caught in somehtign like that i'ts safe.Also there will eb a legal procedure they can't revoke it jsut liek that

  • @alexandru5369
    @alexandru5369 11 днів тому

    "Far right" just means normal and not wanting the state in your business at this point

  • @slanginandbangingtactical1829
    @slanginandbangingtactical1829 15 днів тому +14

    Let the people decide what is true and not. More regulation is what is destroying freedom

    • @johnreigebendijo5469
      @johnreigebendijo5469 15 днів тому +8

      Let the people decide what is true and not?? Really?

    • @slanginandbangingtactical1829
      @slanginandbangingtactical1829 15 днів тому

      @ really

    • @rouz0
      @rouz0 15 днів тому

      It was told for years by non western countries that they are tired of West interference in their elections and west didn't care . Now it caught you, so suck it up. 😄!It is called democracy! And now you understand the only reason you could be proud owners of democracy was lack of interference in your internal affairs.

    • @nymuelovan
      @nymuelovan 15 днів тому +4

      Fact checking is not censure

    • @slanginandbangingtactical1829
      @slanginandbangingtactical1829 15 днів тому

      @ HONEST QUESTION.
      WHO FACT CHECKS THE FACT CHECKER

  • @giovannituber2827
    @giovannituber2827 15 днів тому +2

    Of course in Europe we simply cannot have a Free speech, here people need to be controlled by our betters.

  • @sebbvell3426
    @sebbvell3426 16 днів тому +7

    Friedrich Merz vs Alice Weidel

  • @SiriusAlien
    @SiriusAlien 15 днів тому +1

    So now Germany is finally seeing Syria, only after the nation is occupied by Islam.
    How advanced and peaceful!

  • @tedalfred9516
    @tedalfred9516 11 днів тому

    The EU and especially Germany are becoming truly pathetic

  • @JG-xi4tu
    @JG-xi4tu 14 днів тому +1

    Merz is my next Chancellor! 😃

  • @thedarkslide
    @thedarkslide 15 днів тому +3

    Regulation. Europe’s answer to everything. Pathetic.

  • @Csu2024
    @Csu2024 15 днів тому +1

    Doing what EU does best, regulation.

  • @rassel9663
    @rassel9663 15 днів тому +5

    They should consider the length of naturalization based on skilled workers. If they increase the length for skilled workers also then i dont think skilled workers will be interested to come. Already language is the biggest problem and now if they increase the length then skilled workers will say bye bye to Germany

    • @ireminmon
      @ireminmon 15 днів тому +1

      When you're relying on outsiders to come in and run your state for you you've already lost.

    • @rassel9663
      @rassel9663 15 днів тому +1

      @@ireminmon Not really, there is a difference between skilled immigrant and illegal immigrant. Look at USA, you will know why EU is so much behind USA. EU is no more capable to sustain by itself. If you want to remain poor german then that is a different case.

    • @drwho9437
      @drwho9437 15 днів тому +1

      You are correct, there is a huge brain drain into the US because wages are higher and if they get an H1B the path to naturalization and dual citizenship is not debated. Even France has long allowed dual nationality. Germany was super behind in this. When people have families in other countries they find it hard to just cut all ties and become German, look at the Turkish population for decades... It is unfortunate how obsessed people have become with migration across the entire west its impacting all the democracies: UK, Germany, US, Netherlands and more. The reality of the impact in all these places it actually marginal objectively but it "feels" significant so people place more blame here. For skilled labor Germany has to remember they are competing globally for that talent. A great engineer can work anywhere in the world they want.

  • @Valentina.Montano
    @Valentina.Montano 15 днів тому +2

    Far right? No, just conservatives but, not far-right.

  • @TraumaBondi
    @TraumaBondi 16 днів тому +14

    Trying to appeal to the AfD voters.

    • @RodrigoGonzalez-gf6cm
      @RodrigoGonzalez-gf6cm 15 днів тому +5

      Appeal to common sense voters

    • @DummyUseless-er3dn
      @DummyUseless-er3dn 15 днів тому +1

      Nope. It’s not common sense to strip citizens of their citizenship. That’s a nonsense proposition

  • @davidnorth6541
    @davidnorth6541 15 днів тому

    Yes it will play into the hands of the far right. It will be impossible to outdo the far right to the right.

  • @mattermax
    @mattermax 15 днів тому +4

    appointed chancellor, no one Will vote for this warmonger

  • @PierreForsberg-y2z
    @PierreForsberg-y2z 15 днів тому +2

    Of course, do NOT let people talk about the links between Merz and BlackRock or Ukraine and Burisma.
    Stop anything which could in any way benefit Russia, including the truth.

  • @jeffdockery7877
    @jeffdockery7877 15 днів тому +4

    The EU needs to have the strongest military in the world. The US shouldn’t have to provide defense for countries in another hemisphere. As far as immigration, probably best to only allow those that can provide a service not available in the EU.

    • @Kennon959
      @Kennon959 15 днів тому +3

      You need to learn what hemisphere means.......... (Hint the US and the EU are both in the Northern hemisphere)

    • @Curryking32000
      @Curryking32000 15 днів тому

      No, the EU is a dangerous dictatorship and needs to be dismantled

  • @maneshipocrates
    @maneshipocrates 15 днів тому

    Why are we not shown the speech?

  • @Левица_архив
    @Левица_архив 15 днів тому +1

    Oh please.

  • @maisumthiago8615
    @maisumthiago8615 14 днів тому

    The far right in Germany should be oppose the breathing so maybe most of this liberals and so call journalist will oppose to that given thinking people more room in the world to be in peace.

  • @RogerPerera-q3k
    @RogerPerera-q3k 15 днів тому +6

    Present CDU or CSU leaders are not strong enough to steer Germany through the trouble waters.
    Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg, Former Federal Minister of Defense of Germany from CSU could be an idealist to form an alliance with AfD & BSW

    • @bekken971
      @bekken971 15 днів тому

      You're out of touch. Weidel will shock you in the new elections

    • @jabba2454
      @jabba2454 15 днів тому

      Well no German Leaders are strong enough to lead

    • @Julia-Richter
      @Julia-Richter 15 днів тому

      Nice try Ivan

    • @bekken971
      @bekken971 15 днів тому +1

      @@jabba2454 Weidel is.

    • @RogerPerera-q3k
      @RogerPerera-q3k 15 днів тому

      @@bekken971 Weidel party will. But I can guarantee next German Chancellor will definitely be a strong man and not a strong woman in the face of Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin.
      Woman's time is over !!!

  • @tomhenry897
    @tomhenry897 15 днів тому

    Liked Facebook when they deleted Republicans

  • @bekken971
    @bekken971 15 днів тому +12

    Germany should leave the EU and start a European free trade zone only. Britain would sign on to that in a heartbeat. The EU is not democratic.

    • @Curryking32000
      @Curryking32000 15 днів тому +2

      Totally correct and I'm a Brit

    • @Daxter250
      @Daxter250 15 днів тому

      cute, an AFD sympathisant in disguise.

    • @Julia-Richter
      @Julia-Richter 15 днів тому +2

      Maybe in 50years. But now European countries need to get closer instead of drifting apart.

  • @storyextract7742
    @storyextract7742 15 днів тому +1

    Hi I'm an international student willing to move to Germany for Masters in molecular biology in upcoming winter intake. Will this hard migration policy hit us too? it's my dream to pursue my research in this field from Germany. Can anyone provide any information or ideas regarding this?😢

    • @hardtma
      @hardtma 14 днів тому +2

      You will be fine

    • @NoidoDev
      @NoidoDev 14 днів тому

      Don't be silly. This isn't about a few highly qualified researchers. Also don't ask that on UA-cam, ask the German embassy in your country.

    • @storyextract7742
      @storyextract7742 14 днів тому

      @@hardtma thanks.

  • @tesfoega
    @tesfoega 15 днів тому +4

    No, we really don't appreciate this clowns "insights". What a joke.

  • @desertportal353
    @desertportal353 7 днів тому

    Yes indeed! Regulate meta - at a MINIMUM.

  • @pevlez
    @pevlez 15 днів тому

    What mistakes?, complying with international law?

  • @CatsDiary2
    @CatsDiary2 15 днів тому +1

    They should send everyone home and don’t visit or live in other people country

  • @MBJ2323
    @MBJ2323 15 днів тому

    “Germany will look different in 10 years”
    Germany couldn’t build an airport in the last 10 years, how will that be different by taking labor force into the market? Ahaha
    Just racist politicians … that’s all

  • @goldencoast8896
    @goldencoast8896 15 днів тому

    Another regulation

  • @lindaSmith6588
    @lindaSmith6588 15 днів тому +7

    Yes, please regulate META!!! And yes, prepare for chaos from Trump!!

  • @2024Research
    @2024Research 15 днів тому +1

    Wetwillies said Olaf ay

  • @avaneesh-h1i
    @avaneesh-h1i 15 днів тому +3

    If far right is come economy will down

    • @alpharius_nox
      @alpharius_nox 15 днів тому +6

      Your economy is already down, lol. Who you blaming?

    • @nymuelovan
      @nymuelovan 15 днів тому

      Is not the economy that worries me the most under the hard right rule

  • @2024Research
    @2024Research 15 днів тому

    I dont know I got your kids by the time!!!

  • @BaumerPaulGefreiter
    @BaumerPaulGefreiter 15 днів тому +1

    👍

  • @LorDFireball1
    @LorDFireball1 14 днів тому

    Ein Kapital Demokrat. Och wie Süß. Da machste ma Tuck Tuck, die die ....🙃

  • @hemanshuambani9572
    @hemanshuambani9572 15 днів тому

    U spreaded democracy to other countries ex Georgia your recent democracy spreading project…so u have to taste your own medicine now 😂😂

  • @Samichou3
    @Samichou3 15 днів тому

    But tik tok is all good, go figure.

  • @ruiferreira6578
    @ruiferreira6578 16 днів тому +9

    Meta, X and so on must be heavily regulated:
    1. Strong fact checking
    2. Antitrust laws, can't have more than 30% of the industry.
    3. Foreign owners can't make national political comments. Only if they belong to a national party... which is impossible

    • @TraumaBondi
      @TraumaBondi 16 днів тому +18

      More government restrictions sounds like your keen on building a dystopia.

    • @alpharius_nox
      @alpharius_nox 15 днів тому

      Tell me again who’s the fascist? Look at all the ways you want to control people and information! 😂

    • @danix4883
      @danix4883 15 днів тому +7

      Yeah number 3 is a huge NO, this is the government interfering way too much

    • @kumart2668
      @kumart2668 15 днів тому +4

      First, start with German Media and its elected representatives making videos and expressing opinions on other nations internal politics.

    • @sillypuppy5940
      @sillypuppy5940 15 днів тому +5

      So, who checks the fact checkers?

  • @janekbrat6951
    @janekbrat6951 15 днів тому +1

    How on earth is Immigration a top election race matter? There are like twenty issues that are way more important.

    • @NicolasHaufe
      @NicolasHaufe 15 днів тому +14

      No there arent

    • @rouz0
      @rouz0 15 днів тому

      No matter! Economy and immigration are the only matters that ordinary people care about. The general public is not deep thinkers

    • @friedrichvonhoffmeister3343
      @friedrichvonhoffmeister3343 15 днів тому +10

      Have you read what happened in Magdeburg how is there anything more important than feeling safe during your holidays in your neighbourhoodm

    • @Julia-Richter
      @Julia-Richter 15 днів тому

      Because humans are humans.

    • @ireminmon
      @ireminmon 15 днів тому +2

      If migration is not important then we can easily all agree to just ban migration and stop talking about it?