“A BIG Shift” JK Rowling Backs Labour’s Ban On Puberty Blockers For Under-18s

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 238

  • @lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559
    @lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559 Місяць тому +104

    If Labour really care about evidence, then they need to stop talking about 'gender identity' as though it's scientific fact. It's not; it's entirely ideological.

    • @madmelwood3778
      @madmelwood3778 Місяць тому +14

      100% correct

    • @olgapavlova585
      @olgapavlova585 Місяць тому

      Our media which is mainly owned by types who want to keep the British economy closely linked to USA banks, encouraging people to live in greed and debt, manages to get people to chant the word lefty as an insult, so they support USA capitalism and blame lefties for what USA capitalism causes. Then they keep voting for political parties who cause what they say they dislike, such as melting pot societies and trans children. It's only the USA that has a TV show for the child trans Jazz Jennings, only a USA magazine that made Caitlyn Jenner woman of the year, and now Dylan for the USA sports brand Nike.
      While the USA promotes diversity and melting pot societies to left wing countries, and all actual left wing countries such as most in north Europe and Scandinavia promote, are free health care, not being in debt with credit cards, houses are homes than for a few greedy people to buy up to make money off others and child environmental activists.

    • @LucyOLastic
      @LucyOLastic Місяць тому

      Based on what ideology?

    • @LucyOLastic
      @LucyOLastic Місяць тому

      Trans people are not gay by and large. So there is no existential threat to the gay community.... whatsoever. Not from them anyway.

    • @lynnm6413
      @lynnm6413 Місяць тому

      @@LucyOLastic Queer Theory combined with the TQ+ gender ideological cult

  • @susiegreaves7283
    @susiegreaves7283 Місяць тому +60

    The debate was only toxic because certain trans activists behaved disgracefully. Neither JK Rowling, nor Kathleen Stock, nor Maya Forstater ever behaved with anything less than clarity and calm conviction. They patiently waited for common sense to prevail. Now it has. We are still not there but it is thanks to a host of patient brilliant women that we are returning to sanity.

    • @TerryHall-nm8gt
      @TerryHall-nm8gt Місяць тому +3

      No it's because both men & women have stood up against this. You seem to forget about all the men standing up for women & girl's rights. Many of us stand up for our mother's, sister's, daughters & granddaughter's & every other natural female!!! It's not men against women it's sensible people against crazy & perverts !!!!!!

    • @susiegreaves7283
      @susiegreaves7283 Місяць тому +6

      Can't you give credit to these women who suffered persecution and abuse for their views? I was one of the people who saw how idiotic the whole thing was from the start but have the modesty to admit that what I went through was nothing in comparison to what these brave women did. Do you understand what these three women went through at all? Did you suffer for your views? I do know one man who did and that's Graham Lineham and I give him credit too.

    • @alasshewasthehighwaywoman8886
      @alasshewasthehighwaywoman8886 Місяць тому

      @@TerryHall-nm8gt I wish you were the real Terry Hall 😢

  • @user-sz5bb6bz5w
    @user-sz5bb6bz5w Місяць тому +72

    It's common sense.
    Please protect our children.

    • @stequality
      @stequality Місяць тому +5

      They should be protected but no one seems to care

    • @ExpendableRedshirt
      @ExpendableRedshirt Місяць тому

      I find that when people say "It's common sense" they are avoiding presenting actual evidence for their claims.

    • @stequality
      @stequality Місяць тому +2

      @@ExpendableRedshirt what evidence do you need

  • @srodgars1560
    @srodgars1560 Місяць тому +65

    It's not difficult, should not have let activist interfere with medicine. It's like having aneroxics appointed as nutritionist-

    • @robertcreighton4635
      @robertcreighton4635 Місяць тому +3

      Ha, good point.

    • @user-cn1zc6jx8n
      @user-cn1zc6jx8n Місяць тому +4

      Brilliant! Well said.

    • @james970027
      @james970027 Місяць тому +5

      Yep exactly - why the f were any of them listening to the views of activists and using that as a basis for medical intervention to begin with is the bigger question we need answers to considering there are numerous qualified doctors they should have been referring to.
      They need to stop taking in the opinions of groups such as stonewall who don't give a damn about anything but what they want for themselves - it's not the same organisation that it was, it's just clinging to any semblance of relevance at this point.

  • @robertcreighton4635
    @robertcreighton4635 Місяць тому +70

    Men are from Mars
    Women are from Venus
    Any other gender is from Uranus

    • @cindyspowart555
      @cindyspowart555 Місяць тому

      I did something I tend not to do and advise others not to. I Googled a health issue from a reputable medical website. I was Googling about a post-menopausal women's issue. I don't know why but I was shocked to read on this particular website in the article, "person w/ a vagina". We have already seen the erasure of the straight white male (or, heaven forbid if you are one nowadays). We are now witnessing the erasure of women. I'm happy to see the push back against the trans agenda.

    • @joeblogs-vx4ep
      @joeblogs-vx4ep Місяць тому +5

      Very well said 👏👍

    • @robertcreighton4635
      @robertcreighton4635 Місяць тому +1

      @joeblogs-vx4ep I'm a cis gender male, but I use ladies' toilets cos I identify as a pervert....

    • @Anita1984isuponus
      @Anita1984isuponus Місяць тому +2

      Excellent!

    • @captainbigos9267
      @captainbigos9267 Місяць тому

      Yep, they pull it straight out of their asses.

  • @technoverse101
    @technoverse101 Місяць тому +35

    kids are off limits, and this is non negotiable

    • @unowen-nh9ov
      @unowen-nh9ov Місяць тому

      Unfortunately no, it became an industry, a surgically mutilating chemically castrating lifetime mentally & physically scarring for profit industry.

  • @michellevalois8412
    @michellevalois8412 Місяць тому +15

    If they want to be liable for all the medical malpractice lawsuits, many of which are already in the world, be NY guest. But we all know who is going to pay for all the damage this will cause, the NHS and the tax payer, the vast majority of which don't agree with these policies..

  • @suitwo
    @suitwo Місяць тому +23

    If you want to know just how low and depressing a time we are at right now just remember we are seriously having to remind people there are 2 genders and not to give children drugs that will permanently destroy their body. And if anyone dares say the children chose it I would remind people that children won't know any better, they will just follow whatever adults tell them.

    • @50madam
      @50madam Місяць тому +3

      So true

    • @user-jy8bt9uz7f
      @user-jy8bt9uz7f Місяць тому +3

      Well said ❤

    • @rachelwelsh8254
      @rachelwelsh8254 Місяць тому

      2 sexes. There are 0 genders. 'Gender' is just sex stereotypes and expectations put upon males and females.

  • @executivecars7695
    @executivecars7695 Місяць тому +51

    Dame JK this woman is a real feminist hero ❤

    • @ExpendableRedshirt
      @ExpendableRedshirt Місяць тому +1

      She is just another hate preacher who could care less about the pain and suffering she is causing.

    • @Abi-kk4nl
      @Abi-kk4nl Місяць тому +3

      ​@@ExpendableRedshirtshe is a fighter for gay youth and traumatized youth in speaking out against puberty blockers

    • @executivecars7695
      @executivecars7695 Місяць тому +3

      @@ExpendableRedshirt keep your knickers on sweetheart she’s speaking facts

  • @joeblogs-vx4ep
    @joeblogs-vx4ep Місяць тому +8

    The government are supposed to speak for the people but they just speak for themselves
    This is just one reason why people feel disenchanted with politics and politicians

  • @aodhanofailain
    @aodhanofailain Місяць тому +16

    Lisa Nandy (1:48) thinks the debate over gender identity ideology has become polarised and toxic? Who was it who signed a pledge in 2020 calling women’s rights group Women’s Place UK a ‘trans-exclusionist hate group’ without providing any evidence of hate speech or actions from this group? Errr, it was Lisa Nandy. Maybe the first step to de-toxifying the debate would be for Ms Nandy to apologise to WPUK, not for her to lecture others?

    • @TerryHall-nm8gt
      @TerryHall-nm8gt Місяць тому +1

      🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌 well said 🙌👍

  • @ipohtennischannel5482
    @ipohtennischannel5482 Місяць тому +32

    A chance for Labour to do something important at the the beginning of their term in office.
    JK Rowling should be Culture Secretary.

    • @e13kid
      @e13kid Місяць тому

      That would be insane 🤣

    • @jujutrini8412
      @jujutrini8412 Місяць тому +4

      I doubt she wants to hold a position in the cabinet.

    • @ipohtennischannel5482
      @ipohtennischannel5482 Місяць тому

      @@jujutrini8412 You never know, she may end up as Culture Secretary in Reform's first government.

    • @olgapavlova585
      @olgapavlova585 Місяць тому

      The media gets people to chant lefty as an insult so they support USA capitalism and blame lefties for what USA capitalism causes, so they keep voting for political parties who cause what they say they dislike, as Tories want Britain to be like the USA. It's only the USA that has a TV show for the child trans Jazz Jennings, only a USA magazine that made Caitlyn Jenner woman of the year, and now Dylan for the USA sports brand Nike. While the USA say they won't make female gen ital mutilation illegal and many USA women tell men they prefer them to not have a foreskin, so their penis end becomes calloused and less sensitive. The men then spend all day online trying to take out their issues from having less sensitivity on women and spread their sick culture to other countries. It's why the USA has so many men banned from other countries for making websites encouraging men abuse women while travelling. USA shouldn't be allowed to call itself a western nation while they make mutilating children preferable.
      While all actual left wing countries such as most in Scandinavia promote, are free health care, not being in debt with credit cards, houses are homes than for a few greedy people to buy up to make money off others and child environmental activists.

  • @juicylouisey
    @juicylouisey Місяць тому +4

    We DO know about the side effects of puberty blocker from their use in precocious puberty.
    They are marginally less awful than the condition they are used for.

    • @ExpendableRedshirt
      @ExpendableRedshirt Місяць тому

      Evidence?

    • @juicylouisey
      @juicylouisey Місяць тому +1

      @@ExpendableRedshirt yes there is evidence which is why the NHS in England changed its practice on how long they are willing to prescribe it for in regard to precocious puberty.
      If you wish you can search for the NICE guidelines.

    • @alasshewasthehighwaywoman8886
      @alasshewasthehighwaywoman8886 Місяць тому +2

      @@juicylouisey he's a bot in human form, he ain't gonna be looking up anything

    • @juicylouisey
      @juicylouisey Місяць тому +2

      @@alasshewasthehighwaywoman8886 Well, I am not doing it for him.
      As the woke say “Educate yourself. Do the homework.”

    • @alasshewasthehighwaywoman8886
      @alasshewasthehighwaywoman8886 Місяць тому

      @@juicylouisey they do!

  • @user-fe9nv9lw9f
    @user-fe9nv9lw9f Місяць тому +8

    How do most of you guys still make profit, even with the downturn of the economy and ever increasing life standards

    • @ann-ie4hc
      @ann-ie4hc Місяць тому

      Well, I picked the challenge to put my finances in order. Then I invested in cryptocurrency, stocks, through the assistance of my discretionary fund manager

    • @ann-ie4hc
      @ann-ie4hc Місяць тому

      Stephanie Aaron Trentham

    • @Ethangray-cr5nd
      @Ethangray-cr5nd Місяць тому

      This is correct, Stephanie strategy has normalized winning trades for me also, and it's a huge milestone for me looking back to how it all started..

    • @Honorato-vrp
      @Honorato-vrp Місяць тому

      The first step to successful investment is figuring your goals and risk tolerance either on your own or with the help of a financial professional but it's very advisable you make use of professional

    • @gaspardfigueroa
      @gaspardfigueroa Місяць тому

      Yes, I agree with you. Her platform is wonderful, and her strategies are exceptional

  • @OKR1982A
    @OKR1982A Місяць тому +2

    They will follow the science, unless it doesn't say what they want when they will re interpret or change the science to fit their ideology. The BMA are already trying to U turn on it.

  • @elkpaz560
    @elkpaz560 Місяць тому +6

    Always interesting to note the YT banners that appear at the top of these items.

  • @iainrae6159
    @iainrae6159 Місяць тому +3

    Nice to see Lisa making an effort, though a natural smile occasionally would be welcome. Hats off to J.K. Rowling, a beacon of light and critical thinking.

  • @ThePepperford
    @ThePepperford Місяць тому +12

    Even Xbox is promoting transgender games WTF 😒

  • @deborahm3622
    @deborahm3622 Місяць тому +6

    Nandy shows her bias though by calling these children 'trans children'. A child with dysphoria or a confusion regarding their sexed bodies has always real underlying psychiatric causes, Cass pointed to pornography as being a big issue in why girls are developing dysphoric feelings, and the part of social media. In addition there has been mass marketing since the GRA came in.

  • @mycatspethooman5590
    @mycatspethooman5590 Місяць тому +4

    Could thier decision be based on not wanting to lose one of thier biggest doners?

  • @RachelDavies-wn7ir
    @RachelDavies-wn7ir Місяць тому +2

    LGB needs to be separated from T.

    • @AidanC850
      @AidanC850 Місяць тому

      LGB Alliance

    • @ExpendableRedshirt
      @ExpendableRedshirt Місяць тому

      They have tried but it didn't work. The majority of the LGBT community rejected the bigotry of the LGB alliance.

  • @MackerelCat
    @MackerelCat Місяць тому +3

    Sorry. I can’t respect Nandys opinion on this when she has spent literally years not bothering to investigate this topic, and has in fact parrotted the TRA line. Now she wants to speak about the Cass review and Streeting’s decision as though the pair of them haven’t spent the last few years denouncing gender critical concerns.

  • @madmelwood3778
    @madmelwood3778 Місяць тому +15

    The conversion therpay is exaclty what has been happening..when the medical professionals are taking children through a non exploratory verbal therapy and just supporting their views and then allowing them to access medical invasive operations is the WORST form of conversation therapy.
    How to make a gay kid straight?

    • @lynnm6413
      @lynnm6413 Місяць тому +2

      I never understood what transition has to do with not being gay anymore? You are born with your sexuality, just as you are born with your sex.
      If anyone has plastic surgery to look different, doesn‘t change their gayness….right?!

    • @Abi-kk4nl
      @Abi-kk4nl Місяць тому +1

      ​@@lynnm6413because if a young lesbian transitions to male, she can call herself a straight man. She can live in that denial and people will support it and even call it self love and being yourself.

    • @lynnm6413
      @lynnm6413 Місяць тому +1

      @@Abi-kk4nl I know, it‘s ridiculous….!
      Talk about being homophobic to the 9th degree…neither accepting your biology nor your sexuality!
      And these folks want ME to believe THEY are living ‘their TRUTH’! 🫣🤔

    • @Abi-kk4nl
      @Abi-kk4nl Місяць тому +2

      @@lynnm6413 that bugs me as a lesbian. So you are tagging on transgender people and them trying to escape into another identity into " loving and ACCEPTING YOURSELF, and being your true self" ugh no, that's for gay people, what they are doing is the opposite of that...

    • @lynnm6413
      @lynnm6413 Місяць тому

      @@Abi-kk4nl exactly…and the TRA’s are ruining all the acceptance the LGB had to fight for the last 50+ years to establish.
      LGB 🪓 T

  • @Spyrit2011
    @Spyrit2011 Місяць тому +6

    The problem with that is puberty blockers are used for children who go into puberty too early at too young an age, but they are not used over long term.

    • @stumccabe
      @stumccabe Місяць тому +3

      I think I read or heard that the ban on puberty blockers is not absolute and that in very limited situations they could be used.

    • @lynnm6413
      @lynnm6413 Місяць тому +1

      It‘s called precocious puberty, and even in this instance it is being used less and only in severe cases because of the damage these blockers cause.
      Originally, GnRH analogs were used in prostate cancer treatment, a cancer where long term consequences of drugs are negligible because most patients die rather quickly.

  • @madmelwood3778
    @madmelwood3778 Місяць тому +2

    I am not waiting with bated breath for this to happen as they all talk out the side of their mouths...its not just puberty blockers, the therapies are still ongoing..they only closed the bloody clinic.
    As for lisa nandy she needs to be educated in biology.
    Slightly disappointed at JK to back them this early on.

  • @patricialittle2406
    @patricialittle2406 Місяць тому

    Puberty is a time of self discovery, experimentation, uncertainty and hormone chaos, it is not a time to be medically altering a child's adolescence. Mental health support until they are of legal age is the way to go. Protect children from themselves and social media pressure.

  • @fashionbemeUK
    @fashionbemeUK Місяць тому

    They need to stop talking about this Because let Kids be Kids For Once, They Have Enough to deal With our Crazy Government, 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧 Get Our Country Back 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧👮‍♂️👮‍♂️👮‍♂️Hopefully we Can Get this Crazy Government Out ASP

    • @ExpendableRedshirt
      @ExpendableRedshirt Місяць тому

      Puberty blockers do just that. Most kids who start puberty blockers will eventually decide not to continue with their transition. The treatment is stopped and for the vast majority, they will go through puberty and live their lives as the sex they were at birth. A few though do decide that transition is the right thing for them. Puberty blockers give the children, their doctors and parents time to assess how they really feel and make an informed decision. This is a good thing.

  • @fashionbemeUK
    @fashionbemeUK Місяць тому

    There not small boats, They are Large Boats, Lets Get this Right😢

  • @MichaelBall1979
    @MichaelBall1979 Місяць тому

    It’s probably one of the only things I will support Labour on. Plus it’s funny seeing the Labour MPs losing their minds over it but then that reaction shows which ones support child abuse.

    • @ExpendableRedshirt
      @ExpendableRedshirt Місяць тому

      Do you have any evidence of child abuse or is it just another thoughtless slogan?

  • @AndyJarman
    @AndyJarman Місяць тому +3

    I was very dismissive of Hillary Cass adopting the trans activist vocabulary in her report. I have to admit though she appears to have succeeded walking quite a tightrope on this.

    • @ExpendableRedshirt
      @ExpendableRedshirt Місяць тому

      She shows no evidence of harm from Puberty blockers and does not even assess the harm of restricting trans-affirming treatment. Your first assessment was right she hit every single one of the anti-trans lobbies talking points with not one shred of evidence to support them.

    • @alasshewasthehighwaywoman8886
      @alasshewasthehighwaywoman8886 Місяць тому

      She had to so they didn't take to the streets to defend their much-cherished sexual rights. Cass is watertight and she treats them courteously. That's why they've got no recourse but dishonesty and boring people to tears. They can't even legitimately call her a terf without lying cos a real terf calls them what they really are (I daresay she does at home tho)

    • @alasshewasthehighwaywoman8886
      @alasshewasthehighwaywoman8886 Місяць тому

      @@ExpendableRedshirt dude you made a fool of yourself again there 🥱

  • @paulharvey439
    @paulharvey439 Місяць тому

    She's been gasping to say something nice about her friends.

  • @adrianwhyatt594
    @adrianwhyatt594 Місяць тому +2

    Trans communities claim not to have been consulted at all. Autism is not a mental illness. It is a pervasive developmental difference. It is essential that trans people and their organizations are consulted, and that those who have reversed their transition are consulted in Labour's consultation process.

  • @madmelwood3778
    @madmelwood3778 Місяць тому

    Yes david yes..more layers of bureaucracy making a big problem far bigger and more expensive

  • @MrCarol666
    @MrCarol666 Місяць тому

    Kids need reasured no drugs or surgeries or blockers .they are kids...adults need to realise that kids just dont do dangerous life changing indoctering ...they need not over think there develooement into a normal adult ..not wotk of feeling work on facts

    • @ExpendableRedshirt
      @ExpendableRedshirt Місяць тому

      I would rather leave such decisions to doctors. Children who show signs of dysphoria have always had access to counselling.

  • @AndyJarman
    @AndyJarman Місяць тому

    There goes Labour's voter base.

  • @STEVEBINNION1
    @STEVEBINNION1 Місяць тому +1

    Are they any use over 18

    • @cindyspowart555
      @cindyspowart555 Місяць тому

      A good question. Unfortunately, I don't know the answer. If not puberty blockers, hormones after 18? I actually agree w/ 18+. I know that my late step-Son didn't want his daughter, who, at 11 changed her name to a male specific name and started to dress as a boy, thought that 18 was the age for his daughter to make such a serious decision.

    • @user-jy8bt9uz7f
      @user-jy8bt9uz7f Місяць тому

      You
      Just leave it to Hilary Cass

  • @amazinggrace5692
    @amazinggrace5692 Місяць тому +2

    You can’t block puberty if puberty has already happened.

    • @bernieb5233
      @bernieb5233 Місяць тому

      Then they use a different hormone drug.....if needed once they go through natural puberty....

    • @Hector-bj3ls
      @Hector-bj3ls Місяць тому +5

      No you can't. And you shouldn't. Because it's not a switch you can just turn off and on whenever you want.

    • @JadeLeaf1980
      @JadeLeaf1980 Місяць тому

      @@Hector-bj3lshowever the left keep spreading misinformation claiming they CAN switch puberty on and off when they want and there’s no side effects from blockers and long term hormone use, and they threaten any detransitioner who tries to speak up and say they’re now SEEING the side effects.

  • @user-jy8bt9uz7f
    @user-jy8bt9uz7f Місяць тому +2

    Not difficult actually to conclude that sex is binary

  • @hevchip741
    @hevchip741 Місяць тому

    Great news.

  • @janholding5206
    @janholding5206 Місяць тому

    It's NOT difficult!

  • @kerryryan5116
    @kerryryan5116 Місяць тому

    My little prediction......if Labour does not improve its policies on indigenous British women JK will stop donating and look at other parties who enshrine the rights of Britsh indigenous women.

  • @cindyspowart555
    @cindyspowart555 Місяць тому +1

    I agree w/ 18+. Even Blaire White agrees w/ 18+ and I do value her opinion on this issue.

  • @adamnbayley
    @adamnbayley Місяць тому

    Puberty blockers should be compulsory...

  • @ExpendableRedshirt
    @ExpendableRedshirt Місяць тому +2

    So let's get this straight; There is no evidence that puberty blockers cause harm, Streeting admits this and not even Cass shows evidence for that. And we know that, when trans-affirming care was restricted in the U.K. in 2020, suicides among trans children jumped from one in the previous seven years, to sixteen in the three years since.
    So Streeting decides to ignore the lack of evidence of harm from the use of puberty blockers and the clear evidence of harm caused by restricting trans affirming care?
    In other words he has chosen the path that will guarantee more children will die.
    How is this decision rational in any way? As deaths mount up this will come back to bite Labour hard.

    • @pacmangotdmunch
      @pacmangotdmunch Місяць тому +9

      There are a lot more children than 16 a year regretting their irreversible transition

    • @user-jy8bt9uz7f
      @user-jy8bt9uz7f Місяць тому +1

      You don't have anything straight you are advocating child abuse .

    • @user-jy8bt9uz7f
      @user-jy8bt9uz7f Місяць тому +1

      You are delusional

    • @shelleyphilcox4743
      @shelleyphilcox4743 Місяць тому +4

      Unfortunately there is evidence that puberty blockers are not fully reversible and do cause damage. The majority of our bone density is laid down during puberty. Block puberty and it inhibits bone density development leading to weak bones. Current evidence is showing that this does not recover to levels when natural puberty occurs. The Head of WPATH Marcie Bowers is on video footage sharing that no child administered puberty blockers before Tanner Stage 2 of puberty ever experiences orgasm, yet this was omitted from their latest guidance. It is unknown the full extent of the effects on brain development. Further evidence is the fact that children who have their puberty blocked to not develop adult sized genitalia. This has meant later surgeries to create replica external genitalia of the opposite sex is very complicated and the techniques are highly experimental with even higher levels of serious complication and lifelong implications for adult sexual function. I would urge you to research this information.

    • @alasshewasthehighwaywoman8886
      @alasshewasthehighwaywoman8886 Місяць тому +1

      Keep coming back to edit this....still heavily fictional

  • @technohow6494
    @technohow6494 Місяць тому +2

    God made Adam & Eve not Adam & Steve

  • @pigsymagic4741
    @pigsymagic4741 Місяць тому

    So do I