This was a genuinely inspiring experience. I've just re-watched it and even though 99% of it still went over my head it's made me go back to some of my old books to try and delve back into this stuff. Many thanks.
@@ZaneCarney thank you so much . I am a guitar teacher and this was awesome ! I will use some of this information with my students . Cheers from Italy !
Crazy respect Zane! I know zero theory but your enthusiasm and way you speak really gets across your love and understanding and draws me in as a viewer . New sub for you sir
This is my first experience with Zane Carney. He is the best kind of out of control, off the wall or whatever expression you want to use. He is an amazing music teacher. He makes it fun and digestible at the same time as extremely informative.
I love that he mentions Wes Montgomery. Wes is one of my biggest influences, tied at first with SRV. The grand psychedelia of Wes' album "A Day In The Life," or the smoothness of the album "Tequila," or the pure sexiness of the album "Bumpin'" caressing your soul. -Wes Montgomery with Jimmy Smith. -Stevie Ray Vaughan with Reese Wynans. Same matching, driving energies. The highest levels of musicality achieved by these pairings. My favourite piano/organ piece ever is Reese's work on "Riviera Paradise." Between the tone, and the touch from the opening to the piano solo, his use of octaves at one point, which is, for me, reminiscent of Wes' guitar work, all the way to the upward "cascading" outro of the piano solo? I've got tears now just thinking about it.
Great use of examples to color in the pictures that go with the paragraph. Hope this format has some legs allowing more episodes the fans can vote in for your show. Josh et al name everything. ✌
The analogy you used for not knowing theory -feeling around in a dark room - so perfect. I know that feeling so well when I get kind of lost in a jam. Wish learning theory and ear training was as easy as turning a switch though!
Josh is one dope ass player and these jams are pure crack. If he wasn't making dope ass pedals he would be releasing dope ass joints on wax. In fact, he needs to do that with this trio and feature the JHS Three on Record Time real soon!
My first time seeing Zane, and between him and Rick Beato I feel like it’s my first day of kindergarten and I’m not going to make it. Good news is once I retire one day I’ll have more time to let this fly over my head.
Nice Lucifer reference. When it comes to music theory, I’m still struggling with the man who draws the elephant pictures. edit, it's 12tone that draws to cute pictures.
Love the comment by Mark Knece" " Zane is the musical Bob Ross". Just started following Zane based on this amazing video. And I do NOT believe that Zane does not have perfect pitch
This inspired me a bit. I woke up with Saturday in the Park in my head, and I thought, "I can figure out the chords to this!" Then I did, pretty close. Am7 D7 FM7 C...
Yes, isolated you would call it a b7 or minor 7 (as opposed to a natural or major 7). But since it's part of a Dominant chord, it is common to refer to it as a dominant 7th.
Definitely interesting, and with a frenetic energy not typically seen on a JHS episode, however I felt like the entire show was overdubbed in a foreign language, and not even one whose origins I could guess at. Like when you’re riding the subway in NYC and 2 people next to you are having an animated conversation in a language which you’d swear came from an alien world, or another dimension. Every once in while you pick out a word or phrase only to find yourself a few seconds later going ‘wait.. what the hell language is that?!’ Good stuff tho. I think.
Wes Montgomery never heard of him!!! Went to iTunes down loaded every album they had of him. At first when I started listening it didn’t sound to great, and I started I started hating, and then I realized what he was doing. It’s great if you do more episodes like this it would be a great help for those that don’t want music theory I am sorry I love learning. Even if it’s dry I will force myself to learn this stuff it’s good. Knowledge is power regardless what it is. Thanks Josh!
@@ZaneCarney he is awesome I down loaded his acid Jazz stuff too omg 😱 great stuff. Thanks for the lesson today it was phenomenal. I have a question I’ve been playing seriously for exactly one year next week religiously everyday. Practicing learning songs I know some scales where should I realistically be at, and how do I measure if I am any good or not. Also where would you tell someone like me where to focus there learning towards. Should it be learning to read music and learn music theory and all scale modes. I talked to my wife about this earlier she told me to make a lesson plan and actually stick to it but I am not sure where to even begin.
I cant believe that of all topics in the video, the first comment will be this. 13:44 all those things are great on eggs (hot sauce on the side, rest mixed in to the scramble)
*rolls up blazer sleeves* can you imagine if Robin Williams went into music education instead of comedy????? I think....it might sound.... a little.....like this
Hahahaha! I do these much slower over on my Twitch if you wanna hear some half speed versions haha. You ain’t wrong though, I sometimes go highhhhh gear
Please don't misunderstand me I'm almost 60 years old and just started playing 6 months ago. I could die happy if I could play half as good as Josh when I'm done.
Yes, that’s absolutely what he’s doing. One has to take music theory analysis as descriptive rather than prescriptive. That is to say, it’s a language to describe what happened rather than a method for playing. Josh is finding notes that he finds interesting in patterns he’s encountered before, Zane is fitting that into a framework that he understands. These are not the only analyses that one could apply.
Check out Anton Petrov, Sabine Hossenfelder, Veritasium and Mark Rober. YOutueb decided that I wanted to learn astrophysics and then tried to steal in some particle physics too and I got sucked right in.
@@ZaneCarney You just went off on too many tangents for me personally. Don't take it too personally, and thats before you add on the usual guitarists active indifference to music theory. Send me your paypal deets and ill shout you a waffle :)
@@adrianmiller1971 you my friend are NOT wrong haha! I love me some tangents, I do I do…no need to send me a waffle, but I love the gesture :) Maybe I’ll see ya on a Twitch stream soon where we can get to know one another!
@@ZaneCarney Youre really doubling down on the alienation factor lol, im 50, i only just know what Twitch is, and only because i have 30+ years in IT (aspie born in the 80's, the most glorious time in human history...mostly because no one had invented a fucking millennial yet. I had 2 mice, 1 named JFK and 1 named Ronald Reagan (because his pelt was the same colour as Ronnies and i reasoned it was okay as they both had been democrats) - but still strange for an Aussie kid). See i can tangent (plus my spirit animal is Hunter S Thompson). I most definitely won't be seeing you on twitch sadly :) Keep up the good work, and long may your neckerchief rein :)
@@ZaneCarney Actually talking about my 80's upbringing, SRV was and is my God. I blame him for instilling in me an active disinterest in musical theory, though i have garnered the odd bit over the years since - i can just about write out a chromatic scale :). But it struck me that you might find it galling to watch footage of him playing and have a guest onstage, where you can clearly see said guest trying to ask Stevie what key the song is in and Stevie just points to where he starts out on the neck, mere moments before he launches into whatever it is and the guest just tries to figure out where he's going and catch up :) Would that be like a trigger point for you? The unknown knowns...seems fitting to give Rumsfeld a nod, given his recent demise. This is the kind of gold you could expect on that suggested Twitch catch up :)
I'm sorry, this is the FIRST JHS video I couldn't get through, about 3 mins in, I watch this show for gear and history. This turned it into a musical Math assignment. 32 years of shredding and I have no desire to learn theory
Sorry, just me, anyone else turned off by this one? I have seen every JHS show like 10 times, I couldn't do this. I even watched the 2 hours of spring reverb drip. This wasn't fun for me. Please get the HM2W Waza and have a Metalhead come in and help out with a demo
@@KelticKabukiGirl see that's the problem. Shredding is terrible, you can always learn theory and go play something interesting. Write a solo that actually carries some emption that isn't muscle memory
@@ileutur6863 Dude, I play Jazz Metal Fusion with Dark Ambient psychedelic madness. Not getting into theory gave me my own style, I phrase things like a Jazz guitarist who was really into Dimebag Darrell and Marty Friedman. I am also a songwriter. It all comes naturally to me. All taught be ear. I am also a Dramatic Tenor Operatic Metal singer
@@ileutur6863 IE, I can shred, but its not all I do. I play Thrash, I play Stoner DoomGazeMetal, I play Old School Death Metal, I play Jazz and Blues Rock. I play ambient, I play psychedelic, I play nylon classical guitar, I play bass, drums, Bohdran, Tinwhistle, Hurdy Gurdy etc. Western theory is racist anyway. I take a lot of influence from Asia and Slavic cultures as well. Like I said, I sat through 2 hours of seeing if reverb pedals drip, and I don't do that. However, I liked hearing how it sounds and as a producer It might come in handy. Shredding isn't terrible, you think what Paul Gilbert and Marty Friedman does is terrible?
Well this was just way too much fun. Thank you @JHS for turning me on to Zane Carney, what a fascinating person.
❤️❤️❤️
You are very welcome.
This was a genuinely inspiring experience. I've just re-watched it and even though 99% of it still went over my head it's made me go back to some of my old books to try and delve back into this stuff. Many thanks.
Love it!
I think this is one of the moments In my life that made me realized how lost I was … I enjoyed every moment
Fellow lost boy over here (in most areas of life!)
Good grief! I love this dude! I'm going to wear his music out this July. Thanks!!!!
You rock! Had SUCH a blast!!!
This scared the heck out of me and made me laugh and taught me.
All of my goals
Appropriate.
Love every minute of this . Theory made easy and fun. That’s the way to go .
My man!
@@ZaneCarney thank you so much . I am a guitar teacher and this was awesome ! I will use some of this information with my students . Cheers from Italy !
That was amazing! And look!!! We didn't see ANY PEDAL in this episode! And din't miss it at all! Wow!! Cool!!!
Crazy respect Zane! I know zero theory but your enthusiasm and way you speak really gets across your love and understanding and draws me in as a viewer . New sub for you sir
I love that, aww thank you!
This is my first experience with Zane Carney. He is the best kind of out of control, off the wall or whatever expression you want to use. He is an amazing music teacher. He makes it fun and digestible at the same time as extremely informative.
I love that he mentions Wes Montgomery. Wes is one of my biggest influences, tied at first with SRV. The grand psychedelia of Wes' album "A Day In The Life," or the smoothness of the album "Tequila," or the pure sexiness of the album "Bumpin'" caressing your soul.
-Wes Montgomery with Jimmy Smith.
-Stevie Ray Vaughan with Reese Wynans.
Same matching, driving energies. The highest levels of musicality achieved by these pairings. My favourite piano/organ piece ever is Reese's work on "Riviera Paradise." Between the tone, and the touch from the opening to the piano solo, his use of octaves at one point, which is, for me, reminiscent of Wes' guitar work, all the way to the upward "cascading" outro of the piano solo? I've got tears now just thinking about it.
How crazy would it have been if there were a Wes/SRV duo album?! Never thought of it until your comment…daydreaming, commence
@@ZaneCarney yeah, I've dreamt about that before. It sounds amazing.
Zane Carney, you’re a mad philosophatician. I love this whole thing so much
Aww thank you!!!
This was hugely inspirational, thank you
Thank YOU :)
Great use of examples to color in the pictures that go with the paragraph. Hope this format has some legs allowing more episodes the fans can vote in for your show. Josh et al name everything. ✌
Ooooh, fan voted ones would be so fun!
First time seeing Zane - what a legend! Mate, you’re amazing 🤩 what a brain 🧠
THat's what it takes to get a gig touring with John Mayer.
The analogy you used for not knowing theory -feeling around in a dark room - so perfect. I know that feeling so well when I get kind of lost in a jam. Wish learning theory and ear training was as easy as turning a switch though!
He kind of reminds me of Aziz Ansari (Tom Haverford) from Parks and Rec.
Yesssssss
Josh and band make some seriously wonderful music. I am anxiously awaiting a cd or some kind of collection.
For REAL
thoroughly enjoying this
Zane, where you been? You're f'n brilliant! Instant subscribe man!
P.S. You got perfect pitch, don't you? Don't lie.
I wishhhh! Just very developed relative pitch!
Vacation on Arrakis reminds me of Traffic's Rock And Roll Stew🎸
This was great - Thanks Zane
Thank YOU!
Fantastic episode. My brain is blissfully overwhelmed.
Loved this! More please sir…
Thanks :)))) Maybe see you over on Twitch soon!
Omg omg omg this watch will be amazing
Great video! I'm impressed and educated. I gotta re-remember all that stuff.
The energy Zane has is unbelievable 😂🎉
Was wondering what that intro was. Sounded awesome
Aww, thanks!
Josh is one dope ass player and these jams are pure crack. If he wasn't making dope ass pedals he would be releasing dope ass joints on wax. In fact, he needs to do that with this trio and feature the JHS Three on Record Time real soon!
That first one made me think of The Jesus Lizard.
This was awesome thanks!
Guitar, theory AND gaming. I'm in..👍
I need more of this!
That Phrygian Dom made it a cool Django thing that did not get too "jazzer" or "prog" (but I love both of those, of course).
Preachhhhh
My first time seeing Zane, and between him and Rick Beato I feel like it’s my first day of kindergarten and I’m not going to make it. Good news is once I retire one day I’ll have more time to let this fly over my head.
Nice Lucifer reference. When it comes to music theory, I’m still struggling with the man who draws the elephant pictures. edit, it's 12tone that draws to cute pictures.
Yesssss
He goes overboard with his mnemonics!
Still waiting for the TruckerSpeed first release
Great show!
Love the comment by Mark Knece" " Zane is the musical Bob Ross". Just started following Zane based on this amazing video. And I do NOT believe that Zane does not have perfect pitch
If the definition of insane has a picture of Zane next to it… I wanna be insane.
Is it a substructure?
Ummm I'm literally watching on a Friday morning in June 2024.... it's too early for this level of freaky coinkydinks
This inspired me a bit. I woke up with Saturday in the Park in my head, and I thought, "I can figure out the chords to this!" Then I did, pretty close.
Am7 D7 FM7 C...
Yesssss!!!!
More of this please.
In the first jam explanation with the chords of C major, shouldn’t the G7 chord be 1-3-5-b7?
Yes, isolated you would call it a b7 or minor 7 (as opposed to a natural or major 7). But since it's part of a Dominant chord, it is common to refer to it as a dominant 7th.
I guess we could say, Josh uses a WAY HUGE number of modes.
I feel like I just moved to town and the teacher introduced me as the new kid and I'm already WAY behind.
Zane just brought quantum physics and philosophy into this lesson 🤯😃
Tryinnnnnnn’
Definitely interesting, and with a frenetic energy not typically seen on a JHS episode, however I felt like the entire show was overdubbed in a foreign language, and not even one whose origins I could guess at. Like when you’re riding the subway in NYC and 2 people next to you are having an animated conversation in a language which you’d swear came from an alien world, or another dimension. Every once in while you pick out a word or phrase only to find yourself a few seconds later going ‘wait.. what the hell language is that?!’ Good stuff tho. I think.
Opening jam . This guy is doing the heel tap thing in.... what’s this timing? ?
"You like eggs n bacon." Great band name
dude's treble clefs are out of control
This was great :) #inanebutsincere
My next album title
Wes Montgomery never heard of him!!! Went to iTunes down loaded every album they had of him. At first when I started listening it didn’t sound to great, and I started I started hating, and then I realized what he was doing. It’s great if you do more episodes like this it would be a great help for those that don’t want music theory I am sorry I love learning. Even if it’s dry I will force myself to learn this stuff it’s good. Knowledge is power regardless what it is. Thanks Josh!
So glad you’re starting to dig Wes!
@@ZaneCarney he is awesome I down loaded his acid Jazz stuff too omg 😱 great stuff. Thanks for the lesson today it was phenomenal. I have a question I’ve been playing seriously for exactly one year next week religiously everyday. Practicing learning songs I know some scales where should I realistically be at, and how do I measure if I am any good or not. Also where would you tell someone like me where to focus there learning towards. Should it be learning to read music and learn music theory and all scale modes. I talked to my wife about this earlier she told me to make a lesson plan and actually stick to it but I am not sure where to even begin.
@@ZaneCarney Love to hear if you have done any analysis like this of Jesus Christ Superstar. Mad Respect!
Wes or Django?
Toughhhhhh call…I’d still choose Wes, though!
mind blowing funking good
Zannnnnneeeeeeee!!!!! Dude inspired me to buy a rumble mod. It got stolen. I will buy another 😭
Son of!
@@ZaneCarney rumble mod…more like FUMBLE MOD #roasted 🤦🤦🤦
“Garbage jazz notes”
Check Sparrow
Nice 206 in the background
I cant believe that of all topics in the video, the first comment will be this. 13:44 all those things are great on eggs (hot sauce on the side, rest mixed in to the scramble)
Allllll the toppings
@@ZaneCarney that should've been the name of one of those jams.
*rolls up blazer sleeves* can you imagine if Robin Williams went into music education instead of comedy????? I think....it might sound.... a little.....like this
God BLESS
👏🏻Bravo!!
it's called a pick slide.....
Totally incredible !!! ADHD might not be required to follow Zane C -- but it helps. (ssshhh... adhd is a super power.)
Name for the Josh, Nick and Addison band should be.... "No Mode Left Behind"
Can Zerb smoke something to slow h I m D O W N a bit?
Hahahaha! I do these much slower over on my Twitch if you wanna hear some half speed versions haha. You ain’t wrong though, I sometimes go highhhhh gear
I want the drugs that he's on...but only sometimes.
Only. On. Thursdays.
There is no way Josh is intentionally making those mode switches on purpose is there? He's just Jamming and stuff is coming out. Right?
Please don't misunderstand me I'm almost 60 years old and just started playing 6 months ago. I could die happy if I could play half as good as Josh when I'm done.
Yes, that’s absolutely what he’s doing. One has to take music theory analysis as descriptive rather than prescriptive. That is to say, it’s a language to describe what happened rather than a method for playing. Josh is finding notes that he finds interesting in patterns he’s encountered before, Zane is fitting that into a framework that he understands. These are not the only analyses that one could apply.
I have to admit, I had to look up Zane Carney to see if this was a joke. Guess not.
Damn this guy is a nut... a very smart nut. Nice.
Also, I subscribed to this genius/nut
eek, always such a nightmare when there are other hosts.
You are 👉 a pirate
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏💛
Josh and Frank would of had good conversations.
🤣🤘🎸
SURFING WITH MY GIRLFRIEND
🐥
16:14 Forget music theory! Just need the explanation of how the universe works dude and I'm good 😂
You and me both!
Check out Anton Petrov, Sabine Hossenfelder, Veritasium and Mark Rober. YOutueb decided that I wanted to learn astrophysics and then tried to steal in some particle physics too and I got sucked right in.
This guy is a great example of what turns people off to learning theory
I didn't realize Henry Thomas plays guitar so well and knows so much about music theory.
Flattery will get you everywhere
Fripp
Too much waffle...and not the good kind you put syrup on
Pleaseeeeee explain haha
@@ZaneCarney You just went off on too many tangents for me personally. Don't take it too personally, and thats before you add on the usual guitarists active indifference to music theory. Send me your paypal deets and ill shout you a waffle :)
@@adrianmiller1971 you my friend are NOT wrong haha! I love me some tangents, I do I do…no need to send me a waffle, but I love the gesture :) Maybe I’ll see ya on a Twitch stream soon where we can get to know one another!
@@ZaneCarney Youre really doubling down on the alienation factor lol, im 50, i only just know what Twitch is, and only because i have 30+ years in IT (aspie born in the 80's, the most glorious time in human history...mostly because no one had invented a fucking millennial yet. I had 2 mice, 1 named JFK and 1 named Ronald Reagan (because his pelt was the same colour as Ronnies and i reasoned it was okay as they both had been democrats) - but still strange for an Aussie kid). See i can tangent (plus my spirit animal is Hunter S Thompson). I most definitely won't be seeing you on twitch sadly :) Keep up the good work, and long may your neckerchief rein :)
@@ZaneCarney Actually talking about my 80's upbringing, SRV was and is my God. I blame him for instilling in me an active disinterest in musical theory, though i have garnered the odd bit over the years since - i can just about write out a chromatic scale :). But it struck me that you might find it galling to watch footage of him playing and have a guest onstage, where you can clearly see said guest trying to ask Stevie what key the song is in and Stevie just points to where he starts out on the neck, mere moments before he launches into whatever it is and the guest just tries to figure out where he's going and catch up :) Would that be like a trigger point for you? The unknown knowns...seems fitting to give Rumsfeld a nod, given his recent demise. This is the kind of gold you could expect on that suggested Twitch catch up :)
I FUCKING LOVE THIS GUY!!
When did Athene get into music? 🤪
Since he stopped playing WoW jk
SUI-ESP 1-1
These are always way more simplistic that you realize. Kind of disappointing tbh. Lol
I'm sorry, this is the FIRST JHS video I couldn't get through, about 3 mins in, I watch this show for gear and history. This turned it into a musical Math assignment. 32 years of shredding and I have no desire to learn theory
Sorry, just me, anyone else turned off by this one? I have seen every JHS show like 10 times, I couldn't do this. I even watched the 2 hours of spring reverb drip. This wasn't fun for me. Please get the HM2W Waza and have a Metalhead come in and help out with a demo
@@KelticKabukiGirl see that's the problem. Shredding is terrible, you can always learn theory and go play something interesting. Write a solo that actually carries some emption that isn't muscle memory
@@ileutur6863 Dude, I play Jazz Metal Fusion with Dark Ambient psychedelic madness. Not getting into theory gave me my own style, I phrase things like a Jazz guitarist who was really into Dimebag Darrell and Marty Friedman. I am also a songwriter. It all comes naturally to me. All taught be ear. I am also a Dramatic Tenor Operatic Metal singer
@@ileutur6863 IE, I can shred, but its not all I do. I play Thrash, I play Stoner DoomGazeMetal, I play Old School Death Metal, I play Jazz and Blues Rock. I play ambient, I play psychedelic, I play nylon classical guitar, I play bass, drums, Bohdran, Tinwhistle, Hurdy Gurdy etc. Western theory is racist anyway. I take a lot of influence from Asia and Slavic cultures as well. Like I said, I sat through 2 hours of seeing if reverb pedals drip, and I don't do that. However, I liked hearing how it sounds and as a producer It might come in handy. Shredding isn't terrible, you think what Paul Gilbert and Marty Friedman does is terrible?
To each his own, but I find music theory fascinating.