Ningning has so much ambition and cutthroat energy in her eyes it's craaaaazy. Not surprised though because she has been slaying every day since debut.
@@AlgricTWK I get what you implying but in this case its def the make-up. Thick eyeliner makes the white of the eye look smaller, in turn making the iris look bigger. Also contacts with wider pupil.
Makeup makes lots of difference, but you can see she had some procedure done by looking at her face shape. Not to much, I guess, since she also lost a lot of weight. No judgment tho @MadcookieBG
@@AlgricTWKthe eyeliner is very different But she change a lot her aura on stage too, she is VERY confident nowadays compared to the old days, she is in ber best era
Her stage presence was never low. Y’all are just too blind to realize that even not showing an expression is showing an expression and she showed it very well. She was serving Cunt always have, serving face always will 💅 She’s just that girl and I know she was just waiting for a comeback like this
@@vafelnaavafelkathey may have put NingNing alone for her birthday, then added the rest of the members since it’s the first broadcast for this comeback
@@vafelnaavafelka Because she's not Korean and SMent usually don't want the foreign members to get too much attention. Foreign members most likely will not renew their contract after 7 years, which means the more they invest on them, the more they will lose when the foreign members leave and go back to their home country.
@@feixu9792do you work for SM? Stop with this nonsense. Lol! Sick minded. That ain't true even with NCT, some korean members gets shaded like they did with taeil, jisung etc
That kiss at the end was so sweet. Ningning was like OMG OMG how do I react to this, I’m on camera hahaha our maknae’s strong aura for the performance turned into bubbles instantly after that kiss
Idk. Why Ningning eyes are catchy and beautiful. She has that Chinese almond round big eyes, similarly with Fan Bing-bing, anglelababy, and dilraba dilmurat. That kind of eyes are catchy and expressive!!!! With right eyeliner and makeup!! Make that eye pop and bigger!!!! 👀👁️👀👁️👀👁️👀👁️
Ningning is a rapper, dancer, visual, ace, an all rounder. Her face expression is so good and natural in stage ❤i just love her seeing on the stage!! M countdown should've shown ningning's full catwalk though
거기서 탄탄한 실력, 노래 안무 소화력이 기본으로 전제되어서 가능. 아무리 회사에서 좋은노래 뽑아줘도 그걸 받는 멤버들 실력이 안따라주면, 노래 안무 따로 노는 느낌 돌아서 대중들이 돌아서는건 시간문제..에스파는 멤버들이 곡의 느낌을 제대로 소화해내는 아우라가 있음. 그래서 연차가 쌓일수록 식상해지지않고 계속 신선해지는 느낌.
ㄹㅇ 일단 멤버들 비주얼이랑 역량이 너무 좋고 스엠도 일을 너무 잘함 멤버들 스타일, 곡, 뮤비 퀄리티랑 트렌디함, 미감 등등 모든 아이돌 통틀어 원탑임.. 아무리 1티어 아이돌이어도 가끔 미감 떨어지거나 b급 느낌 나는 구린 노래 나오기도 하는데 에스파는 그런게 없는듯
니네가 자꾸 성형한 게 잘못된 것처럼 성괴성괴 거리면서 욕하니까 아이돌들이 성형한 걸 숨기는거 아님;; 나도 성형해놓고 안 했다고 거짓말 치는 걸 좋게 보진 않지만 성형한 걸 숨기는게 도덕적으로 어긋나는 거지 니네한테 실질적으로 피해주는 것도 없잖음 굳이 외모 칭찬하는 댓에서 성형 얘기 끄집어내면서까지 까내리는게 추하다는 걸 좀 알아라
Ningning being the thumbnail of whiplash 1st promotion stage and the last ep of m countdown in 2024. We win 🎉 happy birthday ningning🎉 GIVE US BACK NINGNING THUMBNAIL!!!
Ningning's beauty is amazing! She is a true Princess Versace. Although she has been making her debut for four years, her strength is still improving. Who would have thought that a lead singer can dance so well! Crazy love you!
4:12 can we talk about the amount of detail ningning put into that pop and roll... she continues to amaze me even after all these years of watching her perform
Karina really even more flawless - 100% Giselle powerful in pink hair - 100% Winter with such confidence on stage - 100% Ning Ning and that mesmerizing expression - 100% AESPA IS THE MOMENT, 4 Goddess, 4 Voices, 4 All-rounders, 4 Expressions
WINTER HIT THE FUCK OUT THAT MOVE AT 4:08 YOU CAN TELL SHE WAS REALLY FEELING THE MUSIC!!! THIS IS THE TYPE OF PERFORMANCE YOU GET WHEN AN IDOL ACTUALLY LIKES THE MUSIC THE COMPANY MADE FOR THEM AND ARE HAVING FUN PERFORMING IT!!!!!
i think its a rerecording, because the braid is back in a clip after that. i wonder how they do it with the live audience, maybe one version with no one there
@@rima2956 I don’t think they are, honestly with the way SM is with them it wouldn’t be surprising if they aren’t. But also just because a performance is pre-recorded instead of performed in front of the audience doesn’t automatically mean there’s no live singing (I say this because it seemed like you thinking that since it’s not live in front of the audience that meant they weren’t live singing, if this is not what you meant then you can just ignore this). Also sorry if any of that sounded rude, that wasn’t my intention
wdym underrated? she got a lot of spotlight💀 just look at this comment section and other aespa's videos, most of people literally always talking about her
@@hdbfhjbadj I wouldn't call her underrated, but her fancams generally have the lowest views, and her solo has by far the lowest streams outside of China, so she's definitely not as popular, I guess in Korea in particular.
@@FrozenAlacrity it's because her fandom is not that big compared to the other members, but the general public likes her. she is popular in Korea tho, you can see the majority of korean comments here talking about her (also in other aespa's videos too)
Woahhhh, Karina's dance, WInter's vocals, Ningning's makeup and Giselle's Sp. This comeback everyone just ate so bad, but Giselle just shone so much this era🔥🔥🔥🔥
![[#MMA2024] aespa - Whiplash + Supernova + Armageddon (MMA ver.) | #aespa #에스파](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oQanvSArIh4/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#MMA2024] aespa - Whiplash + Supernova + Armageddon (MMA ver.) | #aespa #에스파](/img/tr.png)
![[단독샷캠4K] 에스파 'Whiplash' 단독샷 별도녹화│aespa ONE TAKE STAGE│@SBS Inkigayo 241027](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/OZytLLasceA/mqdefault.jpg)
the way Giselle gave Ningning a kiss on the cheek was so sweet. Nini our birthday girl
Yessssss, Ning was like 😊😊😊😊🤗😍😍😳😳 and Giselle was like 😙😙😘. It was iconic!
When?
💋
@@playtimewithirsa At the ending
@@ZeissWorldI’ve seen this so many times it’s not gonna happen
Winter looks like a badass futuristic video game protagonist
Fr that walk was amazing
@@galexydimond yeah
YEAAAAH
She looks like asuka kazama and reina from tekken, she looks so gorgeous!!!
agree
straight out of cyberpunk 2077
Ningning has so much ambition and cutthroat energy in her eyes it's craaaaazy. Not surprised though because she has been slaying every day since debut.
exactly
She is the boss queen
is she the one with the silver top?
@@GaGaObessionone in the thumbnail
@@GaGaObessionyeah silver top (and thumbnail)
2:32 여기 닝닝 무슨 코딩된거 같음 너무 잘한다
한국멤버2명 외모가 너무 트랜스젠더같음
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㄱ글 에서 벳프리 모솨서 잼민이 발정났누?
NingNing's makeup is insane. It's very different that you sometimes can't recognize her. That eyeliner is crazy
i think it's more than just make up hahahah
@@AlgricTWK look at her without make up and with make up. We talk about make up here
@@AlgricTWK I get what you implying but in this case its def the make-up. Thick eyeliner makes the white of the eye look smaller, in turn making the iris look bigger. Also contacts with wider pupil.
Makeup makes lots of difference, but you can see she had some procedure done by looking at her face shape. Not to much, I guess, since she also lost a lot of weight. No judgment tho @MadcookieBG
@@AlgricTWKthe eyeliner is very different
But she change a lot her aura on stage too, she is VERY confident nowadays compared to the old days, she is in ber best era
Winter and NingNing have the best stage presence like it’s not even up for debate
I agree!❤❤
Yayyy
Winter improved a lot omg!! Before she was a little bit low for me in stage presence but it seems she really improved 💅
@@rennrenn.3SSSin this comeback her sp is better than ningning. Watch her fancam, she like assasin ready to fight.
Her stage presence was never low. Y’all are just too blind to realize that even not showing an expression is showing an expression and she showed it very well. She was serving Cunt always have, serving face always will 💅 She’s just that girl and I know she was just waiting for a comeback like this
지젤 헤어 미친거 아니냐? 저 색이 저 다크한곡에 어떻게 저리 찰떡이지 미쳤어
所謂的粉切黑？
이번 컨셉 지젤한테 찰떡
ㄹㅇ 다 어두우면 무거워질뻔 했는데 중화시켜주는 듯
She looks amazing
it’s because of the futuristic concept
닝닝이랑 카리나 여기서 데뷔초처럼 아이라인 꽉꽉 채워 그린 게 오히려 더 로봇 같고 좋은 느낌을 줌 ..
닝닝은 괜찮은데
카리나는 너무 성괴느낌
@@user-uc6df7jd2댓글목록 개한심ㅉ
닝닝아 ;;;;; 왜이렇게 이뻐지는거야 이젠무섭게 ;;;;
루키즈에서 혼자 데뷔한 이유가 있음....
ㄹㅇ 매번 레전드찍네
ㄹㅇ 카리나랑 이번에 투톱인데?
😭😭
애리도 윈터도 넘 이쁘고 에스파진짜 외모탑찍은
Even though they changed the thumbnail, that Ningning thumbnail is forever engraved in my mind. Ningning was that gorgeous and iconic.
why they changed
@@vafelnaavafelkathey may have put NingNing alone for her birthday, then added the rest of the members since it’s the first broadcast for this comeback
@@Djenitalk oh yeah may be) thank you
@@vafelnaavafelka Because she's not Korean and SMent usually don't want the foreign members to get too much attention. Foreign members most likely will not renew their contract after 7 years, which means the more they invest on them, the more they will lose when the foreign members leave and go back to their home country.
@@feixu9792do you work for SM? Stop with this nonsense. Lol! Sick minded. That ain't true even with NCT, some korean members gets shaded like they did with taeil, jisung etc
That kiss at the end was so sweet. Ningning was like OMG OMG how do I react to this, I’m on camera hahaha our maknae’s strong aura for the performance turned into bubbles instantly after that kiss
지젤 이번 컨셉 완전 찰떡이다..왤케 예뻐..이번 다크 컨셉에서 핑머를 했는데 너무 잘 어울림..my 신 김애리..
Holy shit ningning is so fucking beautiful
Keep well. God bless your soul👼🙌✨💫
Yup... she's lowkey become the main visual of the group.
*TELL ME ABOUT IT. SHE LOOKS STUNNING*
Exactly!!! I'm so enthralled by her this era 😍✨
@@MyHandle4455she is the most gorgeous ❤
00:57 ???????????진짜임????????????????ㄹㅇAI 그래픽인줄 몇번을 돌려봣네.....와ㅏㅏㅏㅏ.......닝닝아........WOOOW...
진짜 게임캐릭 합성인쥴;;
내사랑 닝닝아 진짜 사람이아니다 너무이쁘다제발
?? Ai 아니였나
카리나를 잇는 에스파의 AI….
Woooo… 절로감탄나옴
아니 윈터 왜 잘생김…? 설렌다 어떤 컨셉을 해도 다 잘 어울림
잘생쁨 미춌다 에스파사랑햐❤❤❤
윈터는 ㄱ 잘생김 닝닝은 ㄱ예쁨 카리나 할말도 없이 이쁨 지젤 핫걸 미침;;아 짜증나게 이쁘노
Real
진짜 신기한게 분명 몸도 엄청 여리여리하고 얼굴도 오목조목 얇은 선인데 이상하게 잘생김;;;
ㅇㅈ 저 헤어 너무 잘 어울림
근데 진짜 지젤이 이번에 레전드를 찍은건 반박 불가 맞는 듯 ... 음방 멤버들 개인 직캠 중에 몇 개는 지젤이 조회수 젤 높던데 이렇게 화제성 높았던거 진짜 처음 봄 ;;;;; 이번에 지젤력 리즈 찍는다 진짜
Ningning stole the show with those visuals, she really embodied the fashion runway concept.
확실히 카리나, 윈터 독보적이네 ㄷㄷ 에스파 투탑
Ningning has a such a strong aura she's so captivating with her dancing style.
윈터 ㄹㅇ 만년돌인 이유: 윈터보다 머리스타일 자주 바뀌는 연예인 못 봤는데 바뀌는 족족 찰떡으로 받아먹음 진심 이렇게 모든 스타일이 다 어울리는 연예인 처음 봄 이 정도면 헤어쌤도 신나서 다 도전해 볼 듯 ㅋㅋㅋ
진짜 걍 컨셉 안어색하게 소화하는걸 넘어서 하는 것마다 ㄹㅇ 윈터한테 너무 찰떡임... 어떻게 이렇게 하는것마다 찰떡같이 잘 받는지...
팜하니 머리 오마쥬
@@josammosa98비슷한 헤어긴 한데 느낌이 아예 다른듯
@@josammosa98니 온갖곳에 팜하니 표절 이러고 다니는거 보니까 ㄷㅇㄷ 하이브발 분탕충인가본데 조용히해라;;
Ning Ning is soooo pretty my gosh!! Her stage presence is legendary
NINGNING LOOKED SO STUNNING WALKING OUT. that was one of the coolest song intros…
닝닝 진짜 미친거아님? 존나이쁘다
에스파 역바하려해서 죄송합니다 저희는kpop암덩어리HYBE입니다.
@@도게좌박는아일릿수장 님ㅋㅋㅋ 싸패토끼단임??
하이브가 역바이럴 돌린거 맞구만 싸패토끼단이러네
응 시진닝~
닝닝 진짜 이번에 다이어트 얼마나 했길래 인형같은 얼굴이 됐어
03:49 진심 미친거아님? 사람이 어떻게 저렇게 매혹적임? 이 파트 쾌감 개미침
멤버들이 옆으로 싸악 퍼지면서 애리가 샤약 나오는데 그냥 사람 호로ㄹ로 홀려버림;;
애리 핑머하니까 너무 잘 어울리는거 같아요 ㅠㅠ 찰떡임.. 마이 아닌데도 홀려버려..
@@user-be5wt6ou1n그니까요ㅜㅜ
진짜 사람 미치게함…
이파트가 진짜 킬링인대 애리가 이번 노래 찢엇다…
저기 원래 함성없는걸로아는데 갑자기 너무이쁘게나와서 본인도모르게 마이분 함성나오신듯 ㅋㅋ
Yes 👍
ニンニンこのメイク似合いすぎて過去一好きなビジュ
ジゼルも今回のビジュが一番好き
ほんそれ
さいこー！
수퍼노바는 무대보다는 무비가 더 재밌었는데 위플래시는 생각외로 무대가 더 재밌네ㅋㄱㅋㅋ 에스파 너무 좋아ㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋ
진짜 ㅇㅈ
ㄹㅇ
위플래시 뮤비는 걍 예술작품같음…개간지나
댄서 활용해서 구성을 정말 알차게 채운 것 같음
안무 영상보면 ㄹㅇ 헉 소리나옴…
안무가 지림
Ningning thumbnail, its what she deserves. We cheered!!! 🎉🎉
they changed 😤
They changed it when everybody praised ningning for her beauty. I think they don't like ningning to be the center of attention 😢😢😢
They all ate but Ningning and winter ATE!!! 🛐
Idk. Why Ningning eyes are catchy and beautiful. She has that Chinese almond round big eyes, similarly with Fan Bing-bing, anglelababy, and dilraba dilmurat. That kind of eyes are catchy and expressive!!!! With right eyeliner and makeup!! Make that eye pop and bigger!!!! 👀👁️👀👁️👀👁️👀👁️
If you have seen Ningning's direct shot, I swear you will be immersed in Ningning's world.
확실히 아마겟돈 때보단 힘을 뺀 거 같은데 덜어냄의 미학이라고 절제된 것도 미침
ㅇㄱㄹㅇ
ㄹㅇ 너무 깨끗하고 청순하게 이쁨.... 조명도 안 탐.....ㄹㅇ 자연미인인 듯....
그 땐 ㄹㅇ 첫 정규여서 힘 엄청 준 것 같고 지금은 미니여서 그런 듯
근데 지젤도 확실히 이뻐짐 원래 차이 많이났는데 이제 좀 따라가는 수준
@@motiki297지젤 최근영상들 미모랑 비율 미쳤음 다이어트+카메라마사지 빡세게 받은듯
1:17 음악 시작하자마자 진심 소름돋았다.. 지난 4년동안 수많은 시행착오를 겪고 드디어 에스파가 추구하던 유니크한 컨셉성이 제대로 대중들에게 각인된것같아서 뭉클해짐ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅠㅠ 올해는 정말 에스파의 해였고 앞으로도 그럴꺼임ㅇㅇ
수만리 유영진 있었을 때 에스파도 좋지만 갠적으로 광야컨셉 버린게 더 좋음…수만리 떠나니까 애들 컨셉이 더 고급져짐…아직 계셨다면 드라마 아마겟돈 위플 같은 곡 나올 수 있었을까…
@@하치-d4c드라마가 원래 이수만 나무심기 곡이었으니 이런 비트 곡은 나왔을거임 근데 이런 가사와 컨셉으로는 못나왔겠죠..
@@undine_ 헐 드라마가 그 나무심기 곡이었어요..? 그 노래에 나무심기 가사 매치가 전혀 안되는데…🧐
그놈의 ㄱ글 에서 벳프리 댓글 ㅈ 나많네 그렇게죠 좋은가보지 보러갈까??
最後可愛過ぎてリピ止まらない！！！ジゼルと寧寧最高すぎる！！❤
Ningning is a rapper, dancer, visual, ace, an all rounder. Her face expression is so good and natural in stage ❤i just love her seeing on the stage!! M countdown should've shown ningning's full catwalk though
Yes, her facial expressions have improved beyond expectation. She use to look a little worried and nervous.
@@lynnj85 Beyond expectations!? She always had good stage presence. She was my favourite member since debut
대상 에스파 줘라 진짜;;; 개미쳤다
이래서 가수는 노래를 잘 만나야 하는거같음.
솔직히 걸그룹 1등까지는 아니였는데 넥스트레벨, 슈퍼노바 중독적인 노래로 제대로 눈도장찍고 틱톡으로 대박나서 이제는 걸그룹에서 독보적이다.
맞말.. 아무리 예뻐도 소속사 자본부터 노래 퀄리티 다 받춰줘야 가수가 빛나는거지.. 대형대형 하는 이유가 있음
게다가 요즘 유행이랑 반대되는 컨셉 계속 밀고가니까 대체할 그룹이 없어져서 탑 고정 찍은 듯
거기서 탄탄한 실력, 노래 안무 소화력이 기본으로 전제되어서 가능. 아무리 회사에서 좋은노래 뽑아줘도 그걸 받는 멤버들 실력이 안따라주면, 노래 안무 따로 노는 느낌 돌아서 대중들이 돌아서는건 시간문제..에스파는 멤버들이 곡의 느낌을 제대로 소화해내는 아우라가 있음. 그래서 연차가 쌓일수록 식상해지지않고 계속 신선해지는 느낌.
@@heyyou2834이런 노래는 끼없으면 오글거릴듯 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I hope they continue unique concepts like this!
ㄹㅇ 일단 멤버들 비주얼이랑 역량이 너무 좋고
스엠도 일을 너무 잘함 멤버들 스타일, 곡, 뮤비 퀄리티랑 트렌디함, 미감 등등 모든 아이돌 통틀어 원탑임..
아무리 1티어 아이돌이어도 가끔 미감 떨어지거나 b급 느낌 나는 구린 노래 나오기도 하는데 에스파는 그런게 없는듯
ニンニン照れてるの可愛いすぎ！この曲はジゼルの魅力を最高にだす曲！
윈닝 진짜 고점 터진듯 너무이쁘고 무엇보다 표정 연기를 너무 잘함 진짜 그냥 아이돌임 지젤도 미친 것 같음 카리나야 머 항상 이쁘고
에스파 역바하려해서 죄송합니다 저희는kpop암덩어리HYBE입니다.
윈닝 아닙니다. 닝닝! 입니다
@@-markshin-윈터 닝닝을 글케 말한듯요?
@@김민수-x9g 아.. 저도 닝닝 카리나 닝닝입니다! 패러디요
@@-markshin-그건 닝닝이름 잘못불렀을 때 하는거고 이거랑은 좀 안맞는거 같은데…
Ningning looks gorgeous 😮 Aespa delivered QUALITY entertainment ❤❤❤❤
진짜 닝닝은 무서울 정도로 예뻐진다는 말이 맞는듯....... 매번 컴백마다 리즈라고 생각하는데 그걸 자기가 깨고 계속 올라감...
성형한거 다 빼면 닝닝밖에 안남음
@@mukbus5935 걸그룹통틀어서 닝닝만 자연미인? 칭찬 감사
진짜 인형 그 자체네
시진닝ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
니네가 자꾸 성형한 게 잘못된 것처럼 성괴성괴 거리면서 욕하니까 아이돌들이 성형한 걸 숨기는거 아님;; 나도 성형해놓고 안 했다고 거짓말 치는 걸 좋게 보진 않지만 성형한 걸 숨기는게 도덕적으로 어긋나는 거지 니네한테 실질적으로 피해주는 것도 없잖음 굳이 외모 칭찬하는 댓에서 성형 얘기 끄집어내면서까지 까내리는게 추하다는 걸 좀 알아라
닝닝 신세경느낌 ㄹㅇ미쳤다 용안
미치셧어요?
닝닝 김사랑 닮은듯
@@user-ip1ny5dy7q갠적으로 신세경보다 이쁜거같음
ningning’s part is really good.. dance and rap everything
Winter's stage presence, giselle strong dance, Karina and Ningning shining as always omg they're THAT GROUP
Ningning being the thumbnail of whiplash 1st promotion stage and the last ep of m countdown in 2024. We win 🎉 happy birthday ningning🎉
GIVE US BACK NINGNING THUMBNAIL!!!
Well, it was fun for how long it lasted 😢
They change the thumbnail
they changed it 🙄🙄
@@happylifehh i know 😭
@@kenjijack7279 it suck 😿
닝닝 진짜 예쁘다.그 외모와 호랑이같은 눈으로 무대에서 더 끼 마음껏 부리면 베스트일듯. 아직은 약간 샤이하고 착한느낌이 있네ㅎ
닝닝 진짜 미친것같음
어찌 나올때마다 리즈 갱신하는것같지
닝닝 썸네일 보고 안 들어올 수가 없었다… 너무 예뻐
Ningning's beauty is amazing! She is a true Princess Versace. Although she has been making her debut for four years, her strength is still improving. Who would have thought that a lead singer can dance so well! Crazy love you!
Isn't she the main vocal of Aespa
@@miori4591 yes main vocal
4:12 can we talk about the amount of detail ningning put into that pop and roll... she continues to amaze me even after all these years of watching her perform
3:49 극락파트
Yes!
와 ㄷㄷ
ㄹㅇㄹㅇㄹㅇ ㅁ.쳤음
진짜 개쩌는거같움 소름 촥
지젤 폼미춋당
이번 퍼포는 닝닝윈터가 찢었다고 생각.. 음원에선 지젤윈터가 참 잘하더라 카리나는 수록곡에서 보컬이 진짜 너무 좋았음
지젤 피지컬이 레전드로 잘나옴 닝닝이랑 윈터는 춤선 기량 10000%를 뽑아낼 수 있는 노래를 만나버림ㄷㄷ
위플래쉬 카리나 보컬 쩌는데 먼 소리래ㅋㅋ
@@naann-lk3th네 카리나 노래 잘불러요
@@은실김-q5dㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
아 요즘 안타까운게 이딴식으로 카리나만 어케든 쏙 빼먹을라고 하더라 타팬인가 아니면 그냥 병ㅅ인가
3:48 이 무대는 에스파도 에스파지만 조명 연출로 빛내는거 미친 거 같음
와 ㄹㅇ
이번곡 지젤 킬링파트 부분 미쳐서 정신 나갈거 같고 닝닝이는 진짜 가면 갈수록 전성기 이번 위플래시 AI 모습이 보인다.... 지민정은 꾸준히 너무 잘해줘서 고맙고
썸네일 진짜 미쳤나봐 닝닝 너무너무너머너머무 예쁨
점점 카리나 찾기 힘들어질 듯.
Ningning's straight shot is even crazier
@@AaaA-km2yuDon't worry, because you care about her
@@AaaA-km2yu어때요? 외국인한테 직구맞는 느낌??
@@AaaA-km2yu뭐래 카리나랑 완전 다른데
Ningning is seriously so beautiful
올해의 아티스트는 에스파에 돌아갔습니다.
artis of the year
대상
로제,,,,
@@dennislee5629로제 노래가 5일전에 나왔는데 받겠냐고 ㅋㅋㅋ
@@dennislee5629에스파가 수퍼노바 아마겟돈까지 기록이 미쳐서 올해는 확정 수준임
에스파는 진짜 감탄이 아니라 비명이 나오게 만들어.. 컨셉, 곡, 멤버들 개개인까지 내취향이 아닌게 없다..
썸넬 닝닝이 미쳤고 스튜디오 돈맛난다 이런건 제발 더 고화질로 볼 수 있게 해주세요ㅠ
ㅇㅏ니 윈터 머리가 잘어울리려면 도대체 얼마나 예뻐야됨,,?머리도 개작아야될듯..저런 머리가 잘 어울린다는게 ㄹㅇ 개천재 아이돌같음ㅜ어떻게 전원이 다 이렇게 초절정 미녀지..?
NINGNING'S BEAUTY, STAGE PRESENCE, DANCE MOVES IS DRIVING ME CRAZY 🫣🫣🫣🫣
Ning Ning grew up and became more and more beautiful.
썸네일 닝닝 진짜 미쳣네 홀린듯 들어옴
왜 조이 닮았다고 하는지 알겠네 레드벨벳 조이인줄
목소리는 ses 바다
닝닝 썸네일 완전 여신인데 이걸 어떻게 안들어 올 수가 있겠어..
닝닝 미모 미쳤…? 보자마자 홀린듯이 들어옴
닝닝 AI미 미쳤음 무표정이 너무 예쁘다
Karina really even more flawless - 100%
Giselle powerful in pink hair - 100%
Winter with such confidence on stage - 100%
Ning Ning and that mesmerizing expression - 100%
AESPA IS THE MOMENT, 4 Goddess, 4 Voices, 4 All-rounders, 4 Expressions
아니 썸네일… 이걸 어떻게 지나쳐요…………. 닝이줘 미쳤다 진짜
2:29 ning slays this part so hard like god I love her
에스엠 레전드로 남을 걸그룹
에스파가 에스엠 새 역사를 쓰고있다
NINGNING VISUAL'S ARE NO JOKE! Our maknae is the prettiest this comeback and always
They upgrade, and NingNing is gorgeous!!!!!! STAGE QUEEN!!!!
WINTER HIT THE FUCK OUT THAT MOVE AT 4:08 YOU CAN TELL SHE WAS REALLY FEELING THE MUSIC!!! THIS IS THE TYPE OF PERFORMANCE YOU GET WHEN AN IDOL ACTUALLY LIKES THE MUSIC THE COMPANY MADE FOR THEM AND ARE HAVING FUN PERFORMING IT!!!!!
And 4:17 sheessh
에스파 진짜 미친듯 모든 부분에서
Gigi's face card is INSANE ♡♡♡
런웨이 워크도 화끈하고 안무도 좋고, 배디 스타일링도 매력있고, 우리 퀸들의 퍼포먼스도 완벽해요. 이번 퍼포먼스는 너무 완벽해서 속상했어요ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Finally pruit bish is gone 😂😂😂😂
런웨이
@@lily-fl1yg 감사해요 😅👍
속상..?
얘넨 너무 자주 나오니까 지겹다
닝닝 썸넬 뭔데.. 눈을 의심했다.. 미모 미쳤네
썸네일 닝닝 보고 들어왔습니다.. 진짜 미쳤네요 그냥
GISELLE has been performing and doing great movements❤
닝닝씨 진짜 콤퓨타 미녀?!!!! 나때는 ai아니고 컴퓨터미녀였다 미쳤다 비쥬얼 증맬루
NingNing's walking look like a pro model
最後ちゅってするジゼルもされるニンニンも可愛すぎる。
スタイリングも今までで1番100点満点だと思う。
3:49 giselle untying her braid for THAT part, she knows she’s that girl!
i think its a rerecording, because the braid is back in a clip after that. i wonder how they do it with the live audience, maybe one version with no one there
Did you notice that it goes back to being tied for a second again before being untied again 03:54 ? I wonder if this was recorded multiple times.
@@sakeinoyes they record these music shows usually more than once
@@xiaoxueewait so they’re not singing live?
@@rima2956 I don’t think they are, honestly with the way SM is with them it wouldn’t be surprising if they aren’t.
But also just because a performance is pre-recorded instead of performed in front of the audience doesn’t automatically mean there’s no live singing (I say this because it seemed like you thinking that since it’s not live in front of the audience that meant they weren’t live singing, if this is not what you meant then you can just ignore this). Also sorry if any of that sounded rude, that wasn’t my intention
보다보니 드는생각인데 에스파는 뭔가.... 연차가 아무리쌓여도 늘 신인같음 팀 컨셉이 미래지향적이라서그런가.... 가면갈수록 실력은 느는데 신인같이 늘 새로움.. 쇠맛에 길들여져버렸어....🔩🛠️
벌써 5년차 넘어가는데도 갓데뷔한것같아요
진짜 어떻게 매번 노래가 겹치지도 않고 잘 뽑아내지? 작곡가들 진짜 변태들만 모아놓은 듯 너무 환상적임 2024년은 에스파의 해가 맞다..
Ning ning is so pretty and underrated. She gives me goosebumps
wdym underrated? she got a lot of spotlight💀 just look at this comment section and other aespa's videos, most of people literally always talking about her
@@hdbfhjbadj I wouldn't call her underrated, but her fancams generally have the lowest views, and her solo has by far the lowest streams outside of China, so she's definitely not as popular, I guess in Korea in particular.
@@FrozenAlacrity it's because her fandom is not that big compared to the other members, but the general public likes her. she is popular in Korea tho, you can see the majority of korean comments here talking about her (also in other aespa's videos too)
Korea hates her because she’s Chinese
닝닝 썸네일만 잘 찍힌 건가 했는데
무대 등장부터 엔딩 요정까지 내내 ㄹㅈㄷ네
겁나 이쁨
OMG!! Aeri Kissed Ning Ning😭😭💗💗
지젤 핑머 미쳤음ㄹㅇ;; 닝닝 미모 댑악
NingNing looking so beautiful in this stage!!
Woahhhh, Karina's dance, WInter's vocals, Ningning's makeup and Giselle's Sp. This comeback everyone just ate so bad, but Giselle just shone so much this era🔥🔥🔥🔥
닝닝 저 고양이눈아이라인 찰떡...
지젤사마 핑머도 넘 예쁨
윈터 헤매코 진짜 ㄹㅇ 개이쁘고 좋다 ㅠㅠㅠ 근데 난 저 닝닝의 한쪽 팔토시? 볼레로? ㅋㅋ 장갑까지 한게 너무 개취임 ㅠㅠㅠ진짜 닝닝 머리카락 개길고 찰랑이는것도 대박....
Ningning looks like a doll
닝닝 2절 시작 파트 킬링파트다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 개지림
아니 …….. 좋아요왜이렇게많아짐…? 저는 마이가아니라그저타팬인데
4:07 여기 윈터 고개 쳐드는 거 미쳤네 진짜 디테일 뭐야
ㅅㅂ 그니까
아 쾌감 지린다 ㅋㅋㅋ
WINTER IS SO INSANE WITH THIS CHOREO OMYGOD
닝닝 너무 좋아...
Ningning thumbnail is insanely beautiful
4:11 와 닝닝 미모 미쳤다 긴생머리 너무너무너무 이쁜거 아니냐며…❤
4:07 윈터 어떻게 이렇게 관절을 잘쓰지
여기 진짜 레전드
춤 너무 깔끔하게 잘 춤
춤 진짜 잘춤
여기 진짜 미침
NingNing looks really pretty. I didn't make a mistake when I chose her as the most beautiful member of the group🔥😭