This is a very useful and informative video. Being a Index funds investor (not directly, but through Genius), this video definitely gave me extra confidence that my mutual funds investing is in right direction. Thanks much Shankar and ET Money team 👌👍🏻
Glad you enjoyed it, Sachin KN. Index funds (and ETFs) are picking up pace in India are we expect this trend to only pick up in the future. Happy to see you are using Genius
Hey Shankar .. 10/10 over presentation as usual. I like the diversity being provided by Midcap 150 but my worry is a huge tracking error due to impact cost seen in midcap stocks. With no history available as the passive midcap 150 is in nascent stage .. what kinda tracking error you anticipate?
Thank you very much. Personally, I don't bother with it But it's a good point you raise because very recently I was on a Zoom call and some young investors on the other side assumed that a tracking error means negative performance. It took me a while to explain that tracking error merely describes the size of the difference in relative returns and not whether it was positive or negative. On my part, my apathy towards tracking error is on account of the balancing out of positive and negative differences and maybe because all my index investments follow an SIP route. However if I any literature on this, I'll update to this message thread. Hope that works.
Nice information..As a ET money user, i would suggest to add separate category for index funds in ET money app along with research ratings and returns like in small cap ,large cap funds
The video is a good start. I wish the video emphasized Midcap in general and not one index of that space. For example very little was said about Nifty Midcap 50 and Nifty Midcap 100, Also I would have liked to see more about the methodology of index construction, frequency of it rebalance, turnover ratio, etc. Bottom line some wanting to learn/understand about midcap should come away with much more information.
Thank you. Everything need not be a replacement. If you are happy with Axis Midcap, then why not simply start your next midcap SIP in the index fund whenever you are comfortable doing it
@@ETMONEY Thanks for the reply. Also if you could please make a video on the recent allegations of front running in Axis Mutual Funds and how & if they will affect retail investors. Should they continue their SIPs in other axis funds such as Bluechip / Midcap etc
@@ETMONEY I have hdfc midcap opportunity fund Should i add a nifty 150 midcap in my portfolio as well ? Can we have both passive and active funds for midcap in our portfolio is it normal ?
Sir, Can you make a video on "Nifty Midcap 150 Momentum 50 Index Funds" - trying to understand if these funds are better than the "Nifty Midcap 150 Index Funds". There are also Insurance products linked with such funds ( Eg. Max Life New Mid Cap Fund). Are they better as we get the investing returns as per the index performance + insurance?
Hello Team etmoney.. How much percentage of nifty 50, next 50 & nifty midcap 150 should I keep in my portfolio for 20+ years sip ? Need maximum cagr return with high risk.. Please reply..
hello prakash sir, did you find the solution for ur query, as I'm also in the same strategy as you, investing in nifty 50, next 50, and nifty midcap 150 (direct, growth index funds). as i also want to keep it for more than 20 years, even longer than that as I'm in my early 20's and planning to sip. i also want a higher cagr maybe above 15+, even if it comes with higher risk. also share your exp and insights about index funds in long run. thanks in advance.
aum looks very low in all midcap 150 index funds and etfs . little better aum motilal mid 150 index fund around 500 cr, nippon mid150bees etf also 500 cr and nippon midcap 150 index funds aum only 300 cr. Kindly let me know what is the negative effect of low aum. Please explain
One thing I would like to see is to performance adjusted for inflation. In the video it talks about 15% annualized return. That sounds great but when considering inflation it will probably fall down to 7-8%. In this regard is there a phantom stock/index to track inflation. This way we can see the growth of the phantom stock in comparison to Nifty Midcap 150. Such a phantom stock/index will be very helpful and ideally this should be one that is defined and managed by orgs such as NSE, etc. Until such time ETMoney can construct its own ticker to do this job
Hii Sir ..Your videos provide great information ....... I have one query......Should i go for nifty next 50 index or should i go for midcap 150 index ...? ...i have horizon of 10 to 15 year.....I have started investing in Sensex index , parag pareikh , now I am searching for 2 3 funds for more diversification....Thanks
Thank you sir i am investing in motilal oswal nifty bank index fund of sip rs 1,000 from 2 years I am unable to know the fund performance sir i am very small investor please tell shall I continue my investment or not kindly advice your personal opinion
Sir have been doing SIP in followings , can you please evaluate these ? Any changes needed ? Parag perik flex cap -1000rs Axis bluechip- 1000rs Axis midcap -1000rs SBI - small cap fund-1000rs
Thanks for making a very good & an insightful video. Want to invest 3Lakhs Lum-sum & what should ideal percentage dip in the Nifty Midcap 150 Index to take 6 entries each of 50K. Plz suggest
i have moved from the same to Navi Midcap Index.. Jus due to their poor performance in 2023.. But think and decide.. i am a lot relieved now due to this switch though i may lose little Alpha
Hey Shankar..!! Thanks a lot for the video as always an excellent presentation.. ET money Genius is only available for the resident individuals and NRI not able to use it. Please give us some updates when we can available the service or there is no any hope for it ..?
@@ETMONEY Yes, I have gone through that video. I was bit confused if we could invest in the smallcap 250 index. Since there are a lot of companies in the smallcap index and all of them could not be a top performer. We have seen actively managing funds where they have delivered excellent returns upto 25% CAGR. So does it really make any sense to invest in actively managing funds or smallcap passive funds. If I have this question, I am sure most of the viewers should also have the same question. This can save our money any time if you help us with the same. I tried to search this topic on UA-cam but I couldn't find any detailed video, pls think about it if you could be the one to solve this issue.
I want to invest in the bear market in sip format and want to sell it when market recovers , which one should i choose from between active fund or an index fund?
if one is investing in Index Funds of any given fund house: What happens to the Dividend Recieved by the Fund House for holding the Stocks.. Does the received dividend get added as part of the NAV?
Very insightful indeed! Shankar, please do advise if we should go the lump-sum way or the SIP way if we had about 10 lakhs to invest during this market corrections? As you mentioned about the nifty Axis mid cap, can i invest 10 lakhs as a lump-sum or go the SIP route? An early reply will be highly appreciated... Thank you :)
Wondering if ETMoney has similar videos on other NSE indices e.g. Nifty Smallcap, Nifty Microcap, etc. What about Bond indices, an area that seems to be completely ignored in discussions.
Not much to rank. Afterall, all index funds within a category needs to have the same stocks and the same weightage. Only expense ratio and tracking error differs which tend to change very frequently (every month)
@@ETMONEY Should I invest in OPTION 1: Nifty 50 (UTI), Nifty next 50 (UTI) & midcap 150 quality 50 (UTI) index mutual funds or OPTION 2: Nifty 50 (UTI), alpha low volatility 30 (ICICI) & midcap 150 quality 50 (UTI) index mutual funds? The issue I see with Option 1 is all are from the same fund house. I am planning on a monthly SIP rather than lumpsum. I will invest in parag Parik Flexicap & Axis Small Cap after from the index funds.
I love the oration you bring in, very stately and detailed style.
Thank you
As usual. The presentation and kind of information is always amazing.. Thank you sir
Our pleasure! Thank you for the appreciation
This is a very useful and informative video. Being a Index funds investor (not directly, but through Genius), this video definitely gave me extra confidence that my mutual funds investing is in right direction. Thanks much Shankar and ET Money team 👌👍🏻
Glad you enjoyed it, Sachin KN. Index funds (and ETFs) are picking up pace in India are we expect this trend to only pick up in the future. Happy to see you are using Genius
Hello Sachin i am also going to invest via genius is it really worth it?
2) how it is saving the money compare to it's peers?
Bro can u answer… where will be my index fund sip if conpany closed or runaway bcz we dont need demate for index or mutual fund
Perfect presentation in a very simple language.Thank you.
Glad you liked it! Thanks for the appreciation
Hello Et Money Team
Superb presentation
Keep such high quality videos coming
Thank you
Good Video, as always. Please can you provide comparison (similar at time 8.32 in your video) between Nifty Midcap 150 and Nifty Next 50 Index. Thanks
Hey Shankar .. 10/10 over presentation as usual. I like the diversity being provided by Midcap 150 but my worry is a huge tracking error due to impact cost seen in midcap stocks. With no history available as the passive midcap 150 is in nascent stage .. what kinda tracking error you anticipate?
Thank you very much. Personally, I don't bother with it
But it's a good point you raise because very recently I was on a Zoom call and some young investors on the other side assumed that a tracking error means negative performance. It took me a while to explain that tracking error merely describes the size of the difference in relative returns and not whether it was positive or negative.
On my part, my apathy towards tracking error is on account of the balancing out of positive and negative differences and maybe because all my index investments follow an SIP route. However if I any literature on this, I'll update to this message thread. Hope that works.
@@ETMONEY l
Tracking error may lead to positive better returns as well.
Motilal Oswal midcap 150 index fund tracking error is low
I recently invest in UTI Nifty 150 Quality 50 Index Fund , Direct(G). I will hold it for long-term. Is it good.
Is Midcap 150 quality 50 index better than normal Midcap 150? If so then on what basis?
Shankar nath.. Is my fav 👍
Nice information..As a ET money user, i would suggest to add separate category for index funds in ET money app along with research ratings and returns like in small cap ,large cap funds
The video is a good start. I wish the video emphasized Midcap in general and not one index of that space. For example very little was said about Nifty Midcap 50 and Nifty Midcap 100, Also I would have liked to see more about the methodology of index construction, frequency of it rebalance, turnover ratio, etc. Bottom line some wanting to learn/understand about midcap should come away with much more information.
Thankyou for the useful information Sankar sir.
Always welcome. Thanks for the kind words
Fantastic analysis, presentation and information....
Glad you liked it! Thanks for watching
Good Video
Make a video on
midcap 150 index Fund vs midcap 50 index fund
And
Smallcap 250 index Fund vs smallcap 50 index fund
Thanks in advance
Good video. If someone has Axis Midcap running SIP, should he shift to Passive Nifty 150 Midcap Index fund ?
Thank you. Everything need not be a replacement. If you are happy with Axis Midcap, then why not simply start your next midcap SIP in the index fund whenever you are comfortable doing it
@@ETMONEY Thanks for the reply. Also if you could please make a video on the recent allegations of front running in Axis Mutual Funds and how & if they will affect retail investors. Should they continue their SIPs in other axis funds such as Bluechip / Midcap etc
@@ETMONEY I have hdfc midcap opportunity fund
Should i add a nifty 150 midcap in my portfolio as well ?
Can we have both passive and active funds for midcap in our portfolio is it normal ?
Thanks for midcap details and informative video..
Most welcome. Glad you liked it!
So in 150 companies atleast 15 company need to outperform to give good returns 😐
Very good video
I have hdfc midcap opportunity fund
Should i add nifty 150 midcap in my portfolio as well ?
Can we have both passive and active fund for midcap?
Midcap 150 or midcap quality 50
Same question
Super clarity!!
Thanks
बहुत बढ़िया जानकारी। धन्यवाद आपका।
nifty midcap 150 quality 50 . how this index?
Brilliant research and analysis. Kudos 👍👌
Excellent presentation and explanation.
Thanks
Sir, Can you make a video on "Nifty Midcap 150 Momentum 50 Index Funds" - trying to understand if these funds are better than the "Nifty Midcap 150 Index Funds". There are also Insurance products linked with such funds ( Eg. Max Life New Mid Cap Fund). Are they better as we get the investing returns as per the index performance + insurance?
Very well explained
Thanks for liking
Could you do an analysis btw Nifty midcap 150, midcap 50 & nifty next 50 index, please
?
Fantastic as always 👍
Thank you! Cheers!
Interesting presentation.. Kudos to the team.
Thanks a lot
About NIFTY Midcap 150 Index Fund
I admire the communication and delivery of the gentleman presenter.
KKAGRAWAL
Very informative
Glad you liked it
Excellent Information👍
Glad it was helpful!
Good presentation
Thanks
super presentation...
Thank you 🙂
Excellent presentation 👍👍👏👏
Thanks a lot
Perfect analysis
Thank you Shankar for educating us about the index.
Please share your thoughts on Nifty midcap 150 quality 50.
Sir which one is better to invest nifty midcap 150 or midcap momentum 50?
gr8 👍 video
Thanks 😀
I am not able to find the 'Subscribe' button.
Thankyou
Most welcome
@EtMoney It would be better if this index compared with nifty next 50 also. Thanks
Hello@ETMoney can you pls make a video on nifty next 50 vs nifty midcap 150
"ICICI PRUDENTIAL MIDCAP FUND DIRECT GROWTH"
I want to start a SIP in it for 10-12 years for wealth creation purposes? Will it be a good choice?
very well explained
Excellent!! Which fund house performing good in nifty mid cap funds. Pls confirm
Hello Team etmoney.. How much percentage of nifty 50, next 50 & nifty midcap 150 should I keep in my portfolio for 20+ years sip ? Need maximum cagr return with high risk..
Please reply..
Hi. Please check out ETMoney Genius. It works on this very concept.
hello prakash sir, did you find the solution for ur query, as I'm also in the same strategy as you, investing in nifty 50, next 50, and nifty midcap 150 (direct, growth index funds). as i also want to keep it for more than 20 years, even longer than that as I'm in my early 20's and planning to sip. i also want a higher cagr maybe above 15+, even if it comes with higher risk. also share your exp and insights about index funds in long run. thanks in advance.
How the U T I INDEX MIDCAP 150 QUALITY 50 IS ? IS IT A GOOD FUND FOR INVDSTMENT
aum looks very low in all midcap 150 index funds and etfs . little better aum motilal mid 150 index fund around 500 cr, nippon mid150bees etf also 500 cr and nippon midcap 150 index funds aum only 300 cr. Kindly let me know what is the negative effect of low aum. Please explain
Sensex index fund vs nifty 100 index fund....which is best
Great. ...please make a video on the junior bees etf
I think very soon nifty midcap 150 quality 50 index will outperform nifty midcap 150 index
Why you think so, can you elaborate more?
lol
One thing I would like to see is to performance adjusted for inflation. In the video it talks about 15% annualized return. That sounds great but when considering inflation it will probably fall down to 7-8%. In this regard is there a phantom stock/index to track inflation. This way we can see the growth of the phantom stock in comparison to Nifty Midcap 150. Such a phantom stock/index will be very helpful and ideally this should be one that is defined and managed by orgs such as NSE, etc. Until such time ETMoney can construct its own ticker to do this job
No index/fund in the world gives you inflation adjusted return numbers. It's an absurd thing to ask for in the first place.
@@tathagatasinharoy3332 Could you elaborate on why it is not relevant?
Hii Sir ..Your videos provide great information ....... I have one query......Should i go for nifty next 50 index or should i go for midcap 150 index ...? ...i have horizon of 10 to 15 year.....I have started investing in Sensex index , parag pareikh , now I am searching for 2 3 funds for more diversification....Thanks
Thank you sir i am investing in motilal oswal nifty bank index fund of sip rs 1,000 from 2 years I am unable to know the fund performance sir i am very small investor please tell shall I continue my investment or not kindly advice your personal opinion
Sir I am new to this field can you please tell me do we have to pay any extra amount to this et money app if we invest through this app
Why ET Genius want PAN details?
Thanks for making a great video.
Which is a better performing index b/w Nifty Next 50 & Nifty Midcap 150?
Plz make a comparison video Sir
Thanks. The values keep changing everyday so video based updation is not possible. You can check this yourself on the NSE website - that's what I do.
Thanks Sir
Go for NIFTY 100 index fund
Sir have been doing SIP in followings , can you please evaluate these ? Any changes needed ?
Parag perik flex cap -1000rs
Axis bluechip- 1000rs
Axis midcap -1000rs
SBI - small cap fund-1000rs
Don't invest in an active large cap fund. Instead put it on a large cap index like nifty 50 or sensex.
Which one is more preferable?
NIFTY Midcap 150 Index fund Vs Smallcap 250 index fund?
You can find answer at 9:00 in video👍
Thanks for making a very good & an insightful video.
Want to invest 3Lakhs Lum-sum & what should ideal percentage dip in the Nifty Midcap 150 Index to take 6 entries each of 50K. Plz suggest
Always do SIP. No lumpsum
I have PGIM india midcap opportunity fund, ranked quite well on ET money score card, any advice if one should move to the passive index
i have moved from the same to Navi Midcap Index.. Jus due to their poor performance in 2023.. But think and decide.. i am a lot relieved now due to this switch though i may lose little Alpha
Hey Shankar..!! Thanks a lot for the video as always an excellent presentation..
ET money Genius is only available for the resident individuals and NRI not able to use it. Please give us some updates when we can available the service or there is no any hope for it ..?
Most welcome. We don't have any updates on the opening of the service for non-residents. I'll be sure to post an update if something comes up.
As usual an useful information, presented very nicely. One question whether we can start in the current situation when the market stared falling?
Thank you
Fantastic overview..what are your thoughts on 50 :50 weightage in nifty 100 and nifty midcap 150 index thru edelweiss large and midcap index fund??
Never examined it but looks like it covers all the bases.. the top 250 companies
Tracking error is huge and fund size is low.. instead go for motilal oswal midcap 150 index fund
Could you please make a video on Nifty smallcap 250. Does it make any sense to invest in the same ?
Will try! We do have a video on small caps where we show 2 techniques to see if it is the right time to invest or not. Have a look
@@ETMONEY Yes, I have gone through that video. I was bit confused if we could invest in the smallcap 250 index. Since there are a lot of companies in the smallcap index and all of them could not be a top performer. We have seen actively managing funds where they have delivered excellent returns upto 25% CAGR. So does it really make any sense to invest in actively managing funds or smallcap passive funds. If I have this question, I am sure most of the viewers should also have the same question. This can save our money any time if you help us with the same. I tried to search this topic on UA-cam but I couldn't find any detailed video, pls think about it if you could be the one to solve this issue.
@@ben10hindi71 go for active fund in small cap.............then midcap space go to nifty midcap 150 index fund
I want to invest in the bear market in sip format and want to sell it when market recovers , which one should i choose from between active fund or an index fund?
Pls watch the video on Active vs Index funds on our channel
Go for AXIS NIFTY 100 index fund
if one is investing in Index Funds of any given fund house: What happens to the Dividend Recieved by the Fund House for holding the Stocks.. Does the received dividend get added as part of the NAV?
Yes
If it's a growth fund dividend would be reinvested and added to NAV.
So that why we are comparing with TRI
1st like
Sidhi baat no bakwas
Very insightful indeed! Shankar, please do advise if we should go the lump-sum way or the SIP way if we had about 10 lakhs to invest during this market corrections?
As you mentioned about the nifty Axis mid cap, can i invest 10 lakhs as a lump-sum or go the SIP route? An early reply will be highly appreciated... Thank you :)
Wondering if ETMoney has similar videos on other NSE indices e.g. Nifty Smallcap, Nifty Microcap, etc. What about Bond indices, an area that seems to be completely ignored in discussions.
Is this a good time to invest in Small Cap Mutual Funds?
No
My etmoney account got accidentally deleted please implement something to get back or recover my old account
👌
👍
Didn’t mention anything about tracking errors. Disappointed. ☹️
सर ये video हिन्दी में होता तो ज्यादा लोगों तक पहुच पाता इस नाँलेज से फायदा उठा पाते ....
Yeah entire India doesn't speak Hindi only😂
Pl hindi translation
Why don't you rank Index funds in the application?
Not much to rank. Afterall, all index funds within a category needs to have the same stocks and the same weightage. Only expense ratio and tracking error differs which tend to change very frequently (every month)
@@ETMONEY Should I invest in
OPTION 1: Nifty 50 (UTI), Nifty next 50 (UTI) & midcap 150 quality 50 (UTI) index mutual funds or
OPTION 2: Nifty 50 (UTI), alpha low volatility 30 (ICICI) & midcap 150 quality 50 (UTI) index mutual funds?
The issue I see with Option 1 is all are from the same fund house. I am planning on a monthly SIP rather than lumpsum. I will invest in parag Parik Flexicap & Axis Small Cap after from the index funds.
@@nitmat14 Go for AXIS NIFTY 100 index fund (80%) and rest 20% in Motilal oswal midcap 150
हिंदी मे व्हिडिओ करो सब को समझ आएगा
Can we pledge it for collateral margin?
Bought 1500 quantities