But I agreee with this review in a lot of ways, the Aspire is the oldest car her and thats why it lost, Ford does have the advantage of time as of now, just make the new Aspire with more features on offer and bigger tires and issue solved, and its already on the way, so the Dzires dominance wont hold long
hunted hey! we will call a product what it it is. Good or bad. You can choose to believe or not. We know where we would put our money. Where you choose to put yours is your decision. Thank you for watching.
hunted hey! At the end of the day people have different needs and they put their money according to what they feel is right. We can recommend based on our tests. We are sure about what we would do. Thanks again.
I will agree with this review man, See the Ford is the oldest car here and yet it finished 3rd, shows how much of a smart fighter the Ford is The Tigor and Ameo are failures, true they are built well have good features but back seat needs a lot more attention and the engine in Tigor is way too lackluster for being in top 3
Sooraj Ak sir ji woh to personal choice Hai, Baki sedan me muje Tigor behtar lagti Hai Design ke point se,sir aap new Dzire or old dzire side view or back view are same lagta hai
Aspire is more fun to drive How can it be on 3rd no Ford is always betfer in build but u did not consider that point. Yes it lacks in some new features.
Not sure what's with the hate on this video. Just because your favorite brand or car didn't win the comparo doesn't mean the review is biased. They've simply listed the pros and cons of each car and picked the winner that ticked the most boxes across all categories. The Tigor is a good looking car and has oodles of luggage space, a great sound system, but a terribly underpowered engine. The Ameo has a great engine, but you cannot ignore the lack of rear seat space. The Aspire is a fantastic jack of all trades, ticks the most boxes right and if it were for me, I'd place it at #2, but that is subjective. Yes, Ford seriously needs to revise the equipment list on offer in this car. This is 2017 and not 2013 for crying out loud. Redo the dash and give us a touchscreen. And the bad city mileage does take away a few points from it. I'd have put the Xcent at #3 for that 3 cylinder engine and inadequate space for 3 at the back. I won't exactly call that 3 cylinder engine 'refined'. That's the only point I'd disagree with the comparo. And even though I hate Maruti for adamantly refusing to bring the 90PS version of the engine to the Dzire and Baleno for sake of 'mileage', I cannot fault Zigwheels for picking the Dzire as the winner of this comparo. It indeed ticks the most boxes to pick the #1 spot. P.s. I'm not brand loyal,and I'd still pick the Aspire for that engine, but I'm a buyer. It's a subjective decision for me. They are reviewers. They gotta be objective. People need to understand the difference.
I know im asking randomly but does anyone know of a way to get back into an instagram account..? I stupidly forgot my password. I would love any tricks you can give me!
@Wells Jeremias thanks so much for your reply. I found the site through google and Im in the hacking process now. Takes a while so I will get back to you later with my results.
Laxman Varun bhai plz admit in hosp ur mental situation is not good..i think u r suffering from hallucination ...scihzophernia...dezire is no 1 selling car in india...from last decades nd now nee dezire has blown awal all..nd tata tigor wht is this...bhai yeh to competetion mei bhi naho hai...hyundai ya ford ka naam lqete to chlo maan v laete...pe rakhi hai kya
Diesel compact sedans.. the zigwheels review. The very fact that they say dezire is great for Highway with its puny engine right after admitting that it does not have that punch in city traffic and you have to shift down to move... Like seriously, how rigged can it be? So here is the truth. Ameo Best power, quality and driver feedback, nothing touches the ameo. but you have to pay that much price and also suffer as a rear passenger with the cramped up rear leg room. Tigor I don't understand why you included the tigor in this segment, with its price & specs one can clearly see its aimed at a class down. The only similarity is its a compact sedan. Dezire and xcent is overpriced as hell with no driver enthusiasm whatsoever. And the dezire lacks any concern of safety and build quality. The door panels feels like that of the old Maruti 800, one can damage it with a strong kick. Aspire Mix of both worlds. Well balanced in terms of power, quality, safety and pricing. The driver feedback is great at the same time enough room for the passengers and practicality. Conclusion: 1) If all you care about is mileage and doesn't give two shits about your family in case there is an accident, go for the dezire. 2) If you have concern for the safety of your family, but is planning to use the car in the city only, buy the xcent, the steering is super light and easy to drive. 3) if you're a car enthusiast and love driving one. Loves the quality and safety a car offers, but at the same time doesn't have to carry much people in the rear and also doesn't bother much about the higher service costs, buy the Ameo. 4) if you really want a compact sedan, just to have a sedan, with a lot of space at the price of the hatchbacks of other manufacturers, buy the tigor. 5) If you're a family guy who's looking for a relatively safer car with lot of power and decent built quality, at the same time doesn't want it to burn a hole in your pocket go for the Aspire diesel.
tigor is in 5th...!! are u kidding me... are u high. on weed...!!😂 its the best one when you look at overall package that it offers... and overpriced dzire... one can buy ciaz /honda city for its top end model...
Sir nice comparison but I m confused in the case of rear seat space at one place you said Aspire is second best and onther place it seems you are saying Xcent is No.2 for rear seat. Please give ranks of all these in case of rear seat space and comfort. Why honda amaze is out if campro Thanks sir
Karthik was really having high expectations from the comparo. U really know the difference between a Maruti and a VW. I mean I own a Ciaz as well as an Ameo. Surprisingly, the Ameo weighs more than even the Ciaz. U being such an expert, was not expecting a miss on the quality, fit n finish. Anyways, Suzuki owners will never know wat the Germans mades actually are.
nikhil Kadam hey Nikhil! I know this is hard to digest, but the Dzire is great. And again - we can't take weight to be the only measure of safety. If that were the case - what about F1 cars? Trust us, we were surprised by the result too. The Dzire isn't the most peppy, but it is the compact sedan that has the most to offer now. Thanks again for the faith and the time. Take care.
Kartikeya Singhee can't agree more Karthik. End of the day, it is a personal choice. Indeed Dzire is doing great but have grown from the passe interiors and fit finish offered by MS. Anyways, ur doing a great job. Miss u on the Autocar reviews though. Keep Smiling:-)
Ye sab ek Vw owner Hi samaj sakta kyonki India me japani kachre ko pasand karne wale jyada h I own ameo tdi and I love the car isko chalane ke bad m guarantee leta hu ki koi b aadmi dezire nahi chalayega jab tak ki uski preference mileage na ho tdi engines r best m ciaz se race kar chuka hu 3 km ki race me Hi 300_400 metar ka difference ho gaya tha
Still now the reviewers haven't learnt that TIGOR is totally a different segment called Notchback, which can be placed between a Hatchback and a Compact Sedan, hence it would be less power and not that generous back seat space, but great value for money.. If U want, you could've compared Tata ZEST among the others which is the rival to all those cars here. I thought Zigwheels would never do this foolishness, or if done, they would mention that TIGOR is a different segment, but I was totally disappointed.
sammit velankar maybe.. I haven't seen AUTOCAR's Renuka telling anything good about TATA cars...But I didn't expect Zigwheels the same because their reviews about TATA cars where impressive..
Manu B Sorry. Notchback would actually be super appropriate for the Ameo. Tigor I would call as a fastback. See the terminology can vary but what these cars are supposed to do for their owners won't. We just kept that in mind. Thank you for watching.
Tigor offers the best, spending a little more than 9 lakhs can get you a full sedan.. boys you forgot to say the driving experience at speeds above 100..your favorite dzire will be the last. Tigor,Ford,vw are smooth and can feel the touch with ground...u guys just promoting Suzuki... You should have taken amaze, freaking u missed it..Tigor value for money if someone looking for a good drive in highways, seriously you won't race wen u ride with family...
Why does no one care about volkswagen? It is the second biggest car brand and also german. It has the highest build quality and has the highest performance. So volkswagen should get the first position
ZW - Why NCAP details are not being shared while comparing along with gauge? It would be good if you share these details, because safety comes first :) Please share your thoughts.
Vineeth They are enthusiasts, they won't. But most people who just want a perfect family car which Wont make a hole in their pocket in terms of reliability, ownership and fuel efficiency and is also nice to drive around. The only reason I wong buy a Dzire is due to its lightweight. No other issues.
bhai log agar everyone knows at the end you guys are going to rank Dezire and xent in the top slot... What's the use of doing this comparison..and also where is Amaze and zest.. clearly shows I are just trying here to trash Tata.. even top model of Tigor is almost 2 lakhs cheaper than rest.. comes with heavy features.. grow up people try to change looking after other brands they are trying to give their best.. it's like only Maruti and Hyundai what ever they bring in market u guys are going to praise them.. talk about the worst quality of marutis sheet metal which can not stay in the competition and what about crash test.. think about these points Also
Vishal Kale No it isn't. We look at products not brands. What brand it is only comes after you have evaluated the product. The Tigor is their newest and best and yes just an incredible package. But when it comes to the engine the Tigor is very disappointing. Like we said in he verdict - the Tigor fits a very narrow use case. And if it had the 1.3 diesel Quadrajet - like in the Maruti - boy, it would have been a very different story. Thanks for watching.
Kartikeya Singhee thanks for replying.. anyways love watching your review.. so in this case then make the comparison of petrol versions car in this category and surely Tigor will find the position in top 3..! Thanks
Disagree with that, see Tigor in my opinion is a lost product , it dosent reach both sides ie the compact sedan or the micr hatch segment ie the celerio,Kwid,Alto segment Maybe Tata wanted a sub 4m compact compact sedan, but its a let down, true its good value for money but compared to competition the big miss are the lack of space and the PATHETIC diesel engine, both big ailments in a segment where almost all are being perfected by global brands like Hyundai, Suzuki,Ford etc
I m planning to buy NEW Dzire ZXI Petrol MT. I have seen your review and liked Dzire a lot . I have gone through some other reviews following concerns come into my mind. 1- Plastic quality, Fit and finish is not up to the mark 2- It has vague steering I like cars with light steering feel for easy driving in low speed in city and gain some weight as speed increases on highway for confidence and good feedback. Is 2017 Dzire or Aspire handles in above said manner ? Please provide your expert guidance over above two concerns . Is these two concerns are serious and can be Deal breakers. My second short listed car is Ford Aspire Titanium MT how is Aspire in above two Concerns(Handling and plastic Quality Fit and Finnish) when compared with Dzire ?
Seriously guys after doing shiny camera shots, having a good English and knowledge this is how you review the cars. The first thing which should be priority is safety and as far as safety is concern Japanese cars are tincan. In every other department Tata tigor was at 3rd position except a few. But for the rear seat space it was head-on with Suzuki. If we talk about money tagor is the cheapest also. My choice would be 1. Tata 2. Dezire 3. Is equally distributed bw accent/amio/ford.
Very well shot & explained. Thanks reviewers for your hard work that makes it easy for us to decide at the comfort of our homes. Keep up the good work.
No U cant increase space inside a car even if U spend more or less, so is the pathetic 1.05l engine in Tigor, at least tata could have used the 1.3 DDis in Tigor, not this super sluggish 1.05 diesel
Alex Farooq thanks for watching And, yes we do get paid - by our employers - to test and write what we find out so that others don't have to. I'll put it this way, if someone in my family was to buy one of these - they'd get the same recommendation. Again, thanks for sharing your thoughts.
kartikeya singhee if you recommend the same to your family then please think about it again because for you the safety of your family is more important than space,engine etc etc
Im i20 petrol user n looking for upgrade. Test rided city 2017 petrol vx few days back, noticed play in gear n also gears stuck few time also noted huge noises when tested braking... is it usual with Honda city or just happened with me or the test drive vehicle not maintained well?? Help me to understand
Y are U test driving the over priced over hyped Honda City, go drive the new Verna 1.6 and buy that, costs less, and much better car as well , as long as U dont use back seats on a regular basis
I have used Tigor's Infotainment System and it is not laggy and in India even 4 people comfortably sit at the back of i10 or Alto. It's better that buying a Hyundai Verna, Honda City, etc. or Ecosport, Nexon, etc. than the Fragile Dzire that gets a dent with a small accident and costs more.
Dezire vs ameo . I m confused between two.. which one is best. Ur review is ok for me. But my friends opt for Volkswagen because of its name and transmission.. moreover dezire zxi+ is costlier than ameo top end petrol . Both manual..?? Just give me a decision
Arun Shenoy what about the weight loss in dezire . They ve reduced the weight loss by reducing the exterior body material .. whether this reduces the safety.. if I go beyond 100 , it ll oscillate ??
missed karthikeya sinhee ...and reguarding the lag mentioned in ameo ...which diesel turbo doesn't have a lag, 250 nm from 1500 rpm and turbo kicking in at that range makes very minimal lag, anyway aspire has better accelaration figures than ameo ryr??
So much bitter in here. The Dzire truley deserves the rank one. It's good in terms of performance, comfort, and safety. Although it's kind of overpriced BUT you get all the safety features, the amazing performance and comfort.
Just one thing ... Ford for fun loving guys. Don't compare with Dzire Xcent taxi cars. Volkswagen 10+ horses for nothing ... but Tigor for its hot looks ... Nothing else matters I have Figo Titanium tdci with wider rubber 😈😈😈
S 555 that concern is with lower Trims of Xcent....I have SX(O) trim...no problem in any department at all....just drive Hyundai Xcent or Grand i10 just once...then you will surely impressed....So much easy & effortless to drive... just try it once...soft suspensions, best in segment interior,most silent cabin in the class, most feature rich car in the segment..easy to eye.. easy to use👍
I drove it and I didnt feel impressed at all, the ride was superb in city speeds but post 100 kmph it felt like its going to take off from ground and too much vertical moveemnt Then the steering, it has no feel, almost like a TOY, scares me when making fast lane changes etc at speeds excess of 100 kmph Rest all felt fine
ford aspires must introduce some features like push button start, rear view parking camera, some sporty looks, fog lights , led lights, sensor for wipers, increse head room and leg space
Its coming, Aspire will get a facelift by July 2018, it will include, new 6 " infotainment touch screen with SYNC 3, reverse parking sensors and camera in top 2 variants and base variants will also have touch screen but wont get SYNC 3 Also Ford will introduce a new 1.2l i3 Dragon petrol motor with 94 HP and 116 Nm torque replacing the current 1.2l i4 TiVCT
Zigwheels didn't tell about decreased weight of Maruti Dzire about 100 kg...so that's why Dzire gives more avarage ...but also gives least amount of safety when car gets hit....And most importantly Zigwheels didn't tell about servicing cost of these cars for 60k or 100k....Think about it Zigwheels & viewers...
when they compare cars, they should also take into consideration the price aspect.. tigor is more than 2lakhs cheaper than dzire.. and cheaper than the rest 3 cars too..
They already told in the last section it is value for money car, still you can bark only, you Tata bhakt will never improve and can listen against Tata, pathetic people, appreciate them for their work rather than getting offender for not promoting your so called fav car, Tigor is good car but if you compare it with others it is not in the segment, know the difference first then point out your finger on them, idiot Tata lovers 👎
Good review.. now dzire leads the segment by this version.. aspire looks slightly dated now,needs to improve on door closing sound,meter console,music layout on dash.Hope they will bring facelift in early 2018
really? you guys lost the trust of viewers, ford is clearly the winner here, any person with common sense will prefer safety (and build quality) to touch screen or fancy gadgets,
Why does no body talk about how kerb wait makes a difference in safety. Just saw a dzire getting totalled when hit from behind. Tata nexon which is in front barely has its fender dented. I personally dont like paper light cars even though that gives more fuel efficiency. I love to drive on my own and I would pick German built ameo over others any day if I had to pick. I used to have polo before most fun hatchback I had ever driven...
Ameo is 110 bhp and Dzire is 75 bhp.. and they say Dzire doesn't lose punch over 100 kmph.. paid review. Didnt speak about the german build quality and fit n finish. If you just lean on Dzire door it will bend and it is the best car .. lol
Nice review. But can u do this same review with petrol cars. I know its awkward coz no one buys petrol car these days. But like me many more out there r confused between xcent/aspire petrol war.
Can you explain is safety only matters with ABS and Airbags, what about weight, material and metals grading. You should think once again for ranking. Xcent has better build quality than dzire. So even if it is narrower but still all better than dzire
Please compare the petrol varients of these car. Every channel is comparing the diesel. I'm thinking to but Tata Tigor petrol and the petrol engine is far better than it's diesel.
You’ve done a lot of new car reviews. Request you to do a detailed best used suv car you can be today for city and highway use. I’m sure a lot of people will thank you please.
Arun Shenoy thanks. A buying guide won’t be interesting rather than that best available used suv car in the market today would help. Considering out road conditions, floods, potholes throughout the country I’m sure most of the buyer now are moving towards suv. New car sales confirm this as well. Considering a budget of under 10L what would be ideal for mainly city and long highway trips
Dzire is no doubt a formidable package from Maruti. However, there are a couple of points to consider before making the purchase decision. Maruti, like Tata and Hyundai will sell the current dzire model to cab operators in India. Thats a big issue for me. You can see the current Dzire, the Dzire Tour before it. It affects the image of the car and the image of the brand in a big way. After buying it, you can't help but notice that every other car on the streets is a dzire or a xcent or a zest or a tigor..etc..Suzuki should change the models before selling it to the cab operators. My personal choice would definitely be the Ameo or the Amaze. Ameo is the best car when it comes to quality, performance, sheer build quality, brand value. Amaze is also a good car, just the diesel motor is a bit unrefined. Thanks
really good comparison... but I don't think the Tigor was worth the fifth position... it is not that bad... I feel the aspire should be at last and Tigor in forth making the ameo third
review by English speaking self proclaimed experts ?? guys didn't even discussed on SAFETY features and build quality. more preference given to FEATURES . give me a break. I think in case of engine performance only Aspire and Ameo stands tall . and in case of internal space again Aspire and Dzire wins the race. guys don't be stupid to discuss on how many bottle holders it has or how Is the touch screen infotainment system. peace !!
Say Suzuki, Maruti is nothing without Suzuki and one thing to note is its not just Suzukis merit that they are making ground, its more of the Indian car buyer who supports them most unlike all other brands that has to fight against false prophecies and perceptions to make their cars sell
Tigors engine is not that underpowered... I 've seen people attching CNG in honda city ... so stop complaining...Well I'd rather buy a tigor and save my 3 year petrol cost rather buying a Hyundai or a Suzuki ...
U guys are making a mockery of the cars which seriously deserve to be on 1&2 nos. I feel like laughing that u placed vw ameo at 4th no. Which is the safest car among all of them.. & it has all the features in comparison to others.. yes there’s a leg space problem at rear but u can’t ignore ameo just bcoz of this reason.. I own vw ameo diesel highline & believe me this car has the power to white wash all those toys.. ford aspire is the another good car but u get least features in it
@Arun how come u miss build quality of car Ameo is tight on legroom but its power and build quality no one can match even small scooter broken Dzire and swift which got NCAP rating of 2 u r asking viewers to just put their life on air by buying extremely unsafe Marutis and as a reviewer u should know that high speeds it’s the cars outer structure that saves the people inside by absorbing shock not airbags which by the way nobody knows when they open in Maruti s😀
Not satisfied with tigor rank....and please compare petrol varient too...and it's a notch back.... And. A simple review of a car take 10-15 min and you compare within 11 min...great...
zigwheels honda is still there with Amaze , its has good engine , better interiors and moderatly good boot space , atleast consider it for comparison...,😌
Dzire is over priced.aspire is the sensible pick. It is Better to have 6 air bags than large touch screens.
But I agreee with this review in a lot of ways, the Aspire is the oldest car her and thats why it lost, Ford does have the advantage of time as of now, just make the new Aspire with more features on offer and bigger tires and issue solved, and its already on the way, so the Dzires dominance wont hold long
mr. Sparrow if u hav sensible driving then no need of airbag 😂😂
M4M - Made for malayali if u r that much scared means no one can help u
@Akshaypacheni when truck or bus will hit, airbags can do nothing if they were at speed of 70-80..cars will destroyed in seconds and driver too
Zigwheels really really hates Tata. They will always put Tata cars as last.
Kalpak Kar yes you are right
Up
most of the reviewers have became sales man for suzuki and hyundai. not so good
hunted hey! we will call a product what it it is. Good or bad. You can choose to believe or not. We know where we would put our money. Where you choose to put yours is your decision. Thank you for watching.
Kartikeya Singhee not only you. every car reviews says suzuki and hyundai are way to go. Ameo and Tigor are the best in this category
hunted hey! At the end of the day people have different needs and they put their money according to what they feel is right. We can recommend based on our tests. We are sure about what we would do. Thanks again.
hunted coz dzire and xcent are tuned!!
I will agree with this review man,
See the Ford is the oldest car here and yet it finished 3rd, shows how much of a smart fighter the Ford is
The Tigor and Ameo are failures, true they are built well have good features but back seat needs a lot more attention and the engine in Tigor is way too lackluster for being in top 3
Tata Tigor value for money,best music system,best suspension in car,Tata is Indian company reasons by Tata tigor
petrol or desil sir
Chauhan Jaydeep but a booring design
Sooraj Ak sir ji woh to personal choice Hai, Baki sedan me muje Tigor behtar lagti Hai Design ke point se,sir aap new Dzire or old dzire side view or back view are same lagta hai
Chauhan Jaydeep first of all don't call me sir.
In this segment frankly the tigor is value for money. But I prefer the ameo.
Bakwass music system he tigor ka
Aspire is more fun to drive
How can it be on 3rd no
Ford is always betfer in build but u did not consider that point.
Yes it lacks in some new features.
Tata best
rajeshwar salunke haha kya joke hai
Ghanta
rajeshwar salunke .... Very true far better than caruti fuzuki..... TIN CANS ..... Crap shit
Lol
Tigor is best choice for compact sedan
Not sure what's with the hate on this video. Just because your favorite brand or car didn't win the comparo doesn't mean the review is biased. They've simply listed the pros and cons of each car and picked the winner that ticked the most boxes across all categories. The Tigor is a good looking car and has oodles of luggage space, a great sound system, but a terribly underpowered engine. The Ameo has a great engine, but you cannot ignore the lack of rear seat space. The Aspire is a fantastic jack of all trades, ticks the most boxes right and if it were for me, I'd place it at #2, but that is subjective. Yes, Ford seriously needs to revise the equipment list on offer in this car. This is 2017 and not 2013 for crying out loud. Redo the dash and give us a touchscreen. And the bad city mileage does take away a few points from it. I'd have put the Xcent at #3 for that 3 cylinder engine and inadequate space for 3 at the back. I won't exactly call that 3 cylinder engine 'refined'. That's the only point I'd disagree with the comparo. And even though I hate Maruti for adamantly refusing to bring the 90PS version of the engine to the Dzire and Baleno for sake of 'mileage', I cannot fault Zigwheels for picking the Dzire as the winner of this comparo. It indeed ticks the most boxes to pick the #1 spot.
P.s. I'm not brand loyal,and I'd still pick the Aspire for that engine, but I'm a buyer. It's a subjective decision for me. They are reviewers. They gotta be objective. People need to understand the difference.
I know im asking randomly but does anyone know of a way to get back into an instagram account..?
I stupidly forgot my password. I would love any tricks you can give me!
@Hugh Denver Instablaster ;)
@Wells Jeremias thanks so much for your reply. I found the site through google and Im in the hacking process now.
Takes a while so I will get back to you later with my results.
@Wells Jeremias It did the trick and I now got access to my account again. I'm so happy:D
Thank you so much you saved my ass :D
@Hugh Denver you are welcome :)
What about Tigor Petrol?
Aaditya Kadam a waste
Laxman Varun bhai plz admit in hosp ur mental situation is not good..i think u r suffering from hallucination ...scihzophernia...dezire is no 1 selling car in india...from last decades nd now nee dezire has blown awal all..nd tata tigor wht is this...bhai yeh to competetion mei bhi naho hai...hyundai ya ford ka naam lqete to chlo maan v laete...pe rakhi hai kya
Aaditya Kadam amazing car
Is Honda Amaze out of India?????
Honda itself is cheating Indians with overpriced,Cityt,Jazz,WRV
Exactly they should have included Honda amaze as it's got best engine in terms of nvh levels also mileage
What the Amaze is no way as refined as Jazz, somehow the Amaze felt unrefined and mileage although was good still not as good as Suzukis
Ponygt 662 jazz is not overpriced dude.
for me it felt overpriced specially when compared with Elite i20
Diesel compact sedans.. the zigwheels review.
The very fact that they say dezire is great for Highway with its puny engine right after admitting that it does not have that punch in city traffic and you have to shift down to move... Like seriously, how rigged can it be?
So here is the truth.
Ameo
Best power, quality and driver feedback, nothing touches the ameo. but you have to pay that much price and also suffer as a rear passenger with the cramped up rear leg room.
Tigor
I don't understand why you included the tigor in this segment, with its price & specs one can clearly see its aimed at a class down. The only similarity is its a compact sedan.
Dezire and xcent is overpriced as hell with no driver enthusiasm whatsoever. And the dezire lacks any concern of safety and build quality. The door panels feels like that of the old Maruti 800, one can damage it with a strong kick.
Aspire
Mix of both worlds. Well balanced in terms of power, quality, safety and pricing. The driver feedback is great at the same time enough room for the passengers and practicality.
Conclusion:
1) If all you care about is mileage and doesn't give two shits about your family in case there is an accident, go for the dezire.
2) If you have concern for the safety of your family, but is planning to use the car in the city only, buy the xcent, the steering is super light and easy to drive.
3) if you're a car enthusiast and love driving one. Loves the quality and safety a car offers, but at the same time doesn't have to carry much people in the rear and also doesn't bother much about the higher service costs, buy the Ameo.
4) if you really want a compact sedan, just to have a sedan, with a lot of space at the price of the hatchbacks of other manufacturers, buy the tigor.
5) If you're a family guy who's looking for a relatively safer car with lot of power and decent built quality, at the same time doesn't want it to burn a hole in your pocket go for the Aspire diesel.
tigor is in 5th...!!
are u kidding me...
are u high. on weed...!!😂
its the best one when you look at overall package that it offers...
and overpriced dzire... one can buy ciaz /honda city for its top end model...
Aayush Wadia yeah ! Tigor diesel delivers 27.86 kpl and the petrol that I have delivers 22.6 kpl .it's better than DZire , Ameo , Xcent , aspire also
Arun Shenoy , 1.05 engine is for the diesel . It's a 1.2 for the petrol . Check your info before commenting .
@@pritikanague902 this comparison is between the diesel compact sedans. See the video properly before writing.
Sir nice comparison but I m confused in the case of rear seat space at one place you said Aspire is second best and onther place it seems you are saying Xcent is No.2 for rear seat. Please give ranks of all these in case of rear seat space and comfort. Why honda amaze is out if campro Thanks sir
Arun Shenoy Thanks sir. Very good explanation
Karthik was really having high expectations from the comparo. U really know the difference between a Maruti and a VW. I mean I own a Ciaz as well as an Ameo. Surprisingly, the Ameo weighs more than even the Ciaz. U being such an expert, was not expecting a miss on the quality, fit n finish. Anyways, Suzuki owners will never know wat the Germans mades actually are.
nikhil Kadam hey Nikhil! I know this is hard to digest, but the Dzire is great. And again - we can't take weight to be the only measure of safety. If that were the case - what about F1 cars? Trust us, we were surprised by the result too. The Dzire isn't the most peppy, but it is the compact sedan that has the most to offer now. Thanks again for the faith and the time. Take care.
Kartikeya Singhee can't agree more Karthik. End of the day, it is a personal choice. Indeed Dzire is doing great but have grown from the passe interiors and fit finish offered by MS. Anyways, ur doing a great job. Miss u on the Autocar reviews though. Keep Smiling:-)
nikhil Kadam i hav ciaz too..too don joke around dat giving 19+ average nd looks r grt too
Ye sab ek Vw owner Hi samaj sakta kyonki India me japani kachre ko pasand karne wale jyada h I own ameo tdi and I love the car isko chalane ke bad m guarantee leta hu ki koi b aadmi dezire nahi chalayega jab tak ki uski preference mileage na ho tdi engines r best m ciaz se race kar chuka hu 3 km ki race me Hi 300_400 metar ka difference ho gaya tha
@Arun Shenoywhat is your opinion regarding hyundai xcent petrol sx model
Still now the reviewers haven't learnt that TIGOR is totally a different segment called Notchback, which can be placed between a Hatchback and a Compact Sedan, hence it would be less power and not that generous back seat space, but great value for money.. If U want, you could've compared Tata ZEST among the others which is the rival to all those cars here. I thought Zigwheels would never do this foolishness, or if done, they would mention that TIGOR is a different segment, but I was totally disappointed.
Manu tata call it STYLEBACK
sammit velankar yeah... I didn't mention that, but I knew. But the folks who read this may not do the same.. that's Y :)
Manu B reviewers r just paid by maruti i guess
sammit velankar maybe.. I haven't seen AUTOCAR's Renuka telling anything good about TATA cars...But I didn't expect Zigwheels the same because their reviews about TATA cars where impressive..
Manu B Sorry. Notchback would actually be super appropriate for the Ameo. Tigor I would call as a fastback. See the terminology can vary but what these cars are supposed to do for their owners won't. We just kept that in mind. Thank you for watching.
Tigor offers the best, spending a little more than 9 lakhs can get you a full sedan.. boys you forgot to say the driving experience at speeds above 100..your favorite dzire will be the last. Tigor,Ford,vw are smooth and can feel the touch with ground...u guys just promoting Suzuki... You should have taken amaze, freaking u missed it..Tigor value for money if someone looking for a good drive in highways, seriously you won't race wen u ride with family...
Style - Subjective; Quality - Aspire>Dzire; Performance - Aspire>Dzire; NVH - Equal; Space - Dzire>Aspire slightly; Ride - Equal; Handling - Aspire>Dzire; Features - Dzire>Aspire; Value - Aspire>Dzire; Fuel efficiency - Dzire>Aspire slightly.. Overall easily Aspire>Dzire..
Why does no one care about volkswagen? It is the second biggest car brand and also german. It has the highest build quality and has the highest performance. So volkswagen should get the first position
paid review
Who paid them u..?
no maruti pay them
Polumu tech ..wat r u trying to say man?.. Its bcoz u hate dzire and xcent?
Go nd fuck ur self
After watching this channel, the very word PAID REVIEW has come to my mind as well ... when I see down I see it first.
ZW - Why NCAP details are not being shared while comparing along with gauge? It would be good if you share these details, because safety comes first :) Please share your thoughts.
No matter what they choose comments be like "100% rigged". 😂😂😂
Siddarth Joji bro! I owe you a hug for that. Sach main!
i dont think these reviewers will buy the so called no 1 or no 2 car listed above if they were asked to buy 1 of these.
Vineeth They are enthusiasts, they won't. But most people who just want a perfect family car which Wont make a hole in their pocket in terms of reliability, ownership and fuel efficiency and is also nice to drive around. The only reason I wong buy a Dzire is due to its lightweight. No other issues.
bhai log agar everyone knows at the end you guys are going to rank Dezire and xent in the top slot... What's the use of doing this comparison..and also where is Amaze and zest.. clearly shows I are just trying here to trash Tata.. even top model of Tigor is almost 2 lakhs cheaper than rest.. comes with heavy features.. grow up people try to change looking after other brands they are trying to give their best.. it's like only Maruti and Hyundai what ever they bring in market u guys are going to praise them.. talk about the worst quality of marutis sheet metal which can not stay in the competition and what about crash test.. think about these points Also
Vishal Kale No it isn't. We look at products not brands. What brand it is only comes after you have evaluated the product. The Tigor is their newest and best and yes just an incredible package. But when it comes to the engine the Tigor is very disappointing. Like we said in he verdict - the Tigor fits a very narrow use case. And if it had the 1.3 diesel Quadrajet - like in the Maruti - boy, it would have been a very different story. Thanks for watching.
Kartikeya Singhee thanks for replying.. anyways love watching your review.. so in this case then make the comparison of petrol versions car in this category and surely Tigor will find the position in top 3..! Thanks
Disagree with that, see Tigor in my opinion is a lost product , it dosent reach both sides ie the compact sedan or the micr hatch segment ie the celerio,Kwid,Alto segment
Maybe Tata wanted a sub 4m compact compact sedan, but its a let down, true its good value for money but compared to competition the big miss are the lack of space and the PATHETIC diesel engine, both big ailments in a segment where almost all are being perfected by global brands like Hyundai, Suzuki,Ford etc
Ponygt 662 hehe be Happy with then global brands..! And vehicles which u mentioned here there Tiago who is fighting with them strongly..!
Vishal Kale yes sir, we will try to do the petrol comparison soon. We hope to help. 🙏🏽
Safety should also be considered.. ABS EBD Abags??
Does the ameo dsl have more power punch on the highway or the aspire dsl which throws u back sudden when turbo kicks in plz let me know asap. Thanks
Wat about built quality?
hlo cardekho i want to know how is the stearing fell of dezire at high speed is it better than hyundai cars ???
I m planning to buy NEW Dzire ZXI Petrol MT. I have seen your review and liked Dzire a lot . I have gone through some other reviews following concerns come into my mind.
1- Plastic quality, Fit and finish is not up to the mark
2- It has vague steering
I like cars with light steering feel for easy driving in low speed in city and gain some weight as speed increases on highway for confidence and good feedback.
Is 2017 Dzire or Aspire handles in above said manner ?
Please provide your expert guidance over above two concerns . Is these two concerns are serious and can be Deal breakers. My second short listed car is Ford Aspire Titanium MT how is Aspire in above two Concerns(Handling and plastic Quality Fit and Finnish) when compared with Dzire ?
dzire is most beautiful looking car im segment, well price is high but that deserve too
Seriously guys after doing shiny camera shots, having a good English and knowledge this is how you review the cars. The first thing which should be priority is safety and as far as safety is concern Japanese cars are tincan. In every other department Tata tigor was at 3rd position except a few. But for the rear seat space it was head-on with Suzuki. If we talk about money tagor is the cheapest also. My choice would be 1. Tata 2. Dezire 3. Is equally distributed bw accent/amio/ford.
Very well shot & explained. Thanks reviewers for your hard work that makes it easy for us to decide at the comfort of our homes. Keep up the good work.
Price of the tigor should have been considered before giving that no 5 rank.
This comparison does not do any justice to the car. And amaze should have also been compared.
It's time to change the way people review cars these days. Even the best vfm car is ranked last.
No U cant increase space inside a car even if U spend more or less, so is the pathetic 1.05l engine in Tigor, at least tata could have used the 1.3 DDis in Tigor, not this super sluggish 1.05 diesel
Alex Farooq thanks for watching And, yes we do get paid - by our employers - to test and write what we find out so that others don't have to. I'll put it this way, if someone in my family was to buy one of these - they'd get the same recommendation. Again, thanks for sharing your thoughts.
kartikeya singhee if you recommend the same to your family then please think about it again because for you the safety of your family is more important than space,engine etc etc
how is the handling of dezire at high speeds is it better than the hyundai cars
Please tell us about the buil quality also.
Im i20 petrol user n looking for upgrade. Test rided city 2017 petrol vx few days back, noticed play in gear n also gears stuck few time also noted huge noises when tested braking... is it usual with Honda city or just happened with me or the test drive vehicle not maintained well?? Help me to understand
Y are U test driving the over priced over hyped Honda City, go drive the new Verna 1.6 and buy that, costs less, and much better car as well , as long as U dont use back seats on a regular basis
Good and exhaustive review. Will the rating change if built quality and warranty factors are included as parameters to rank these cars? Thanks.
Amaze ..?
Please do a comparison between amaze and dzire or suggest me one ( infotainment system ) is not priority
Go for dzire bro, I own it the best you can get
Sir uae ki dezire ma or India ki dezire ma difference hota ha kya please reply me
You sit scooped up in the Dzire. It has very less headroom when compared to the Ameo
I have used Tigor's Infotainment System and it is not laggy and in India even 4 people comfortably sit at the back of i10 or Alto. It's better that buying a Hyundai Verna, Honda City, etc. or Ecosport, Nexon, etc. than the Fragile Dzire that gets a dent with a small accident and costs more.
Is tigor worthy to buy? Confused
No vivek, it has many downside please buy either aspire or dzire
Dezire vs ameo . I m confused between two.. which one is best. Ur review is ok for me. But my friends opt for Volkswagen because of its name and transmission.. moreover dezire zxi+ is costlier than ameo top end petrol . Both manual..?? Just give me a decision
Arun Shenoy what about the weight loss in dezire . They ve reduced the weight loss by reducing the exterior body material .. whether this reduces the safety.. if I go beyond 100 , it ll oscillate ??
Arun Shenoy thank u . .
Arun Shenoy I m planning for dezire .. only doubt in body material . One guy from hyundai confused me
Can we get Maruti Dzire diesel AGS up hill review pls. How to drive (start/stop) it at steep slopes?
missed karthikeya sinhee ...and reguarding the lag mentioned in ameo ...which diesel turbo doesn't have a lag, 250 nm from 1500 rpm and turbo kicking in at that range makes very minimal lag, anyway aspire has better accelaration figures than ameo ryr??
Honda Amaze????
ROGER COUTINHO yeah
why did you left zest and amaze
Honda amaze missing?
Yes
Sir Dzire me megma gray colour kaise hote hai...ya...achhe nhi hai to change kar le...
why honda amaze is not considered for this comparo?
You didn't touch the Safety???
When did Honda Amaze missed the spot in Compact Sedan ?
Also consider the braking power in terms of time & distance to stop from 100KMPH
I find it amazing that you've left out the Honda Amaze.
No matter what d world throws at u, u all will always chose a Maruti or a Hyundai!
True bro, these pathetic people can only talk about Tata Tata, in real world they will still prefer Maruti or Hyundai
So much bitter in here. The Dzire truley deserves the rank one. It's good in terms of performance, comfort, and safety. Although it's kind of overpriced BUT you get all the safety features, the amazing performance and comfort.
Just one thing ... Ford for fun loving guys. Don't compare with Dzire Xcent taxi cars. Volkswagen 10+ horses for nothing ... but Tigor for its hot looks ... Nothing else matters I have Figo Titanium tdci with wider rubber 😈😈😈
Why isn’t anyone talking about the safety!!? Maruti has to go way long for that
Guys best comparative video😊👍
My choice... XCENT... Really easy to drive💖
NiTiN Dangade Try with Ford if safety is concern...xcent did not have abs in std ...Crap hyundau
S 555 that concern is with lower Trims of Xcent....I have SX(O) trim...no problem in any department at all....just drive Hyundai Xcent or Grand i10 just once...then you will surely impressed....So much easy & effortless to drive... just try it once...soft suspensions, best in segment interior,most silent cabin in the class, most feature rich car in the segment..easy to eye.. easy to use👍
I drove it and I didnt feel impressed at all, the ride was superb in city speeds but post 100 kmph it felt like its going to take off from ground and too much vertical moveemnt
Then the steering, it has no feel, almost like a TOY, scares me when making fast lane changes etc at speeds excess of 100 kmph
Rest all felt fine
ford aspires must introduce some features like push button start, rear view parking camera, some sporty looks, fog lights , led lights, sensor for wipers, increse head room and leg space
Its coming, Aspire will get a facelift by July 2018, it will include, new 6 " infotainment touch screen with SYNC 3, reverse parking sensors and camera in top 2 variants and base variants will also have touch screen but wont get SYNC 3
Also Ford will introduce a new 1.2l i3 Dragon petrol motor with 94 HP and 116 Nm torque replacing the current 1.2l i4 TiVCT
How about petrol?
Even though maruti come standard with airbags abs ebd it is still a tin can its sheet metal is so thin that u can press it with your fingers...
@Arun Shenoy Why dont you test review that aspect yourself. 😂 Shameless journalism to the core.👎
Why comparison is not made petrol to petrol vs disel to disel
when ever i drive polo diesel i only wish i could buy that car its such an amazing car with such a good performance and handling
Honda amaze??
Zigwheels didn't tell about decreased weight of Maruti Dzire about 100 kg...so that's why Dzire gives more avarage ...but also gives least amount of safety when car gets hit....And most importantly Zigwheels didn't tell about servicing cost of these cars for 60k or 100k....Think about it Zigwheels & viewers...
Aspire & tigor best in the world 👑👑
Make a video on compact SUVs please
when they compare cars, they should also take into consideration the price aspect.. tigor is more than 2lakhs cheaper than dzire.. and cheaper than the rest 3 cars too..
They already told in the last section it is value for money car, still you can bark only, you Tata bhakt will never improve and can listen against Tata, pathetic people, appreciate them for their work rather than getting offender for not promoting your so called fav car, Tigor is good car but if you compare it with others it is not in the segment, know the difference first then point out your finger on them, idiot Tata lovers 👎
Good review.. now dzire leads the segment by this version.. aspire looks slightly dated now,needs to improve on door closing sound,meter console,music layout on dash.Hope they will bring facelift in early 2018
really? you guys lost the trust of viewers, ford is clearly the winner here, any person with common sense will prefer safety (and build quality) to touch screen or fancy gadgets,
Why does no body talk about how kerb wait makes a difference in safety. Just saw a dzire getting totalled when hit from behind. Tata nexon which is in front barely has its fender dented. I personally dont like paper light cars even though that gives more fuel efficiency. I love to drive on my own and I would pick German built ameo over others any day if I had to pick. I used to have polo before most fun hatchback I had ever driven...
Ameo is 110 bhp and Dzire is 75 bhp.. and they say Dzire doesn't lose punch over 100 kmph.. paid review.
Didnt speak about the german build quality and fit n finish. If you just lean on Dzire door it will bend and it is the best car .. lol
dizir.... biuld ....in body... pepsi tin
Exactly tin ka dabba
Nice review. But can u do this same review with petrol cars. I know its awkward coz no one buys petrol car these days. But like me many more out there r confused between xcent/aspire petrol war.
Can you explain is safety only matters with ABS and Airbags, what about weight, material and metals grading.
You should think once again for ranking. Xcent has better build quality than dzire. So even if it is narrower but still all better than dzire
Tata should offer a good Compact sedan...cause tigor is really small na narrow
Please compare the petrol varients of these car. Every channel is comparing the diesel. I'm thinking to but Tata Tigor petrol and the petrol engine is far better than it's diesel.
Ashish Nihalchandani noted sir. Will do.
Were is honda Amaze?
Amaze ?
Where is the amaze?
You’ve done a lot of new car reviews. Request you to do a detailed best used suv car you can be today for city and highway use. I’m sure a lot of people will thank you please.
Arun Shenoy thanks. A buying guide won’t be interesting rather than that best available used suv car in the market today would help. Considering out road conditions, floods, potholes throughout the country I’m sure most of the buyer now are moving towards suv. New car sales confirm this as well. Considering a budget of under 10L what would be ideal for mainly city and long highway trips
Wish a similar comparison is done for petrol including the Amaze
Y have u left Honda
great work keep it up!
Dzire is no doubt a formidable package from Maruti. However, there are a couple of points to consider before making the purchase decision. Maruti, like Tata and Hyundai will sell the current dzire model to cab operators in India. Thats a big issue for me. You can see the current Dzire, the Dzire Tour before it. It affects the image of the car and the image of the brand in a big way. After buying it, you can't help but notice that every other car on the streets is a dzire or a xcent or a zest or a tigor..etc..Suzuki should change the models before selling it to the cab operators. My personal choice would definitely be the Ameo or the Amaze. Ameo is the best car when it comes to quality, performance, sheer build quality, brand value. Amaze is also a good car, just the diesel motor is a bit unrefined. Thanks
really good comparison... but I don't think the Tigor was worth the fifth position... it is not that bad... I feel the aspire should be at last and Tigor in forth making the ameo third
Where is Honda Amaze ?
Fake Review! PAID !!!
Oooo..something's burning
Vishnu Prasad His bum is!
Smartphone Pedia paid comment
Yaa paid comment
Yeah
ye haathi ko betha kar check karoge rear seat space toh kahan bachegi
review by English speaking self proclaimed experts ?? guys didn't even discussed on SAFETY features and build quality. more preference given to FEATURES . give me a break. I think in case of engine performance only Aspire and Ameo stands tall . and in case of internal space again Aspire and Dzire wins the race. guys don't be stupid to discuss on how many bottle holders it has or how Is the touch screen infotainment system. peace !!
It's not going to be so long before Ford updates the interior as it did in the case of the Ecosport , after that its gonna do some spanking again
Maruti is ruling in every segment with their cars
Say Suzuki, Maruti is nothing without Suzuki and one thing to note is its not just Suzukis merit that they are making ground, its more of the Indian car buyer who supports them most unlike all other brands that has to fight against false prophecies and perceptions to make their cars sell
Price too....
Guys, U gave way too much weightage to Rear Seat comfort & fuel_efficiency it seems... Engine has No Value or What??
ford aspire [ winner ] , suzuki dzire [ 1st runner up ] , tata tigor [ 2nd runner up ] , hyundai xcent [ 3rd runner up ] , volkswagen [ 4th runner up ]
You add Reverse Parking Sensor / Camera and touchscreen infotainment system in Ford Aspire. You will get winner of this competition.
Its because of reviews like this maruti and Hyundai sell like they do.
Tigors engine is not that underpowered... I 've seen people attching CNG in honda city ... so stop complaining...Well I'd rather buy a tigor and save my 3 year petrol cost rather buying a Hyundai or a Suzuki ...
Go and buy na, you can bark here only for Tata, when in real world you will still buy Maruti car only for better fuel efficiency and low maintenance 👎
Tata tigor and ford aspire great vehichles
First of all there should be included Tata Zest rather than Tata tigor....then all of us may find thr real pick up of compact sedan car...
thanks guys.
U guys are making a mockery of the cars which seriously deserve to be on 1&2 nos.
I feel like laughing that u placed vw ameo at 4th no. Which is the safest car among all of them.. & it has all the features in comparison to others..
yes there’s a leg space problem at rear but u can’t ignore ameo just bcoz of this reason..
I own vw ameo diesel highline & believe me this car has the power to white wash all those toys..
ford aspire is the another good car but u get least features in it
@Arun how come u miss build quality of car Ameo is tight on legroom but its power and build quality no one can match even small scooter broken Dzire and swift which got NCAP rating of 2 u r asking viewers to just put their life on air by buying extremely unsafe Marutis and as a reviewer u should know that high speeds it’s the cars outer structure that saves the people inside by absorbing shock not airbags which by the way nobody knows when they open in Maruti s😀
Not satisfied with tigor rank....and please compare petrol varient too...and it's a notch back....
And. A simple review of a car take 10-15 min and you compare within 11 min...great...
Thanks i am looking for 5 seater comfortable car and u clearly told Dzire wins the battle
zigwheels honda is still there with Amaze , its has good engine , better interiors and moderatly good boot space , atleast consider it for comparison...,😌