From now on when you do the mixer test, could you wipe it with a wet paper towel after you're done? That way we can easily see any coating that was scratched off.
Agreed, sometimes what you think is a scratch on the surface is actually the pan removing some material from the metal on the mixer, causing discoloration that can easily be wiped off.
Just watched this and if you look closely at the hexclad it did have scratches as well in the "corners". Harder to see because of the design. I think both are comparable and either will work very well. And yes, wipe with a wet paper towel for comparison.
I always stick (hah!) to cast iron, iron or stainless steel pans. That being said, if I WAS looking for a non-stick pan, I'd definitely want to pick one tested by, and approved by, Freakin' Reviews! Love the thoroughness and honesty of these tests!
Hearing Emeril's name brings back a lot of memories from when I was younger. Him saying "Bam!" always made me laugh but it did a good job at keeping me interested and watching. Between him and Graham Kerr, I was inspired constantly and loved to cook and tried lots of different recipes plus I'd constantly try to invent my own recipes and did a lot of experimenting with different ingredients and cooking styles. I'm willing to bet that you expected for me to become a chef, but I actually didn't go that route. Regardless of that, I've still always had a little bit of a passion for cooking that has stayed with me my whole life. I know this doesn't have anything to do with the pan, but just thought I'd share the memories that watching this brought back to me. Thanks for the video, James!
One of my friends growing up, her mom was from Thailand. She loved Emeril and his catchphrase. However…. instead of “BAM!” she would always yell “PAM!” We did tell her but she wasn’t phased and continued to say PAM. It always gave us a good laugh.
I'm very thankful of your honesty for it's the reason I watched your previous reviews. Thanks for getting into the nitty-gritty of it... Like the return or refund events.
That tomato sauce test did impress me. I have an older nonstick pan that is a cheaper version of the granite rock one, and their is definitely residual sauce that likes to stay behind. Also that first pancake impressed me, I never have a first cake that looks appetizing.
The first few month of most any good nonstick pan will make the pan look great. It's longer term where good separates from bad. Most, if not all, are bad. That is, don't count on more than a year or two from any nonstick pan before stuff WILL STICK.
@@2Truth4Liberty One to two years? You're abusing your pans, or you haven't bought non-stick in a decade. Modern non-stick should last at least five years. But that said, Teflon non-stick is 100x better than anything else, in terms of non-stick, even the most well seasoned pan will lose to Teflon.
The Emeril looks identical to the Blue Diamond with a different stamp on the bottom. I would like to have seen that comparison, considering the Blue Diamond is about 20 bucks. I suspect that these coatings are all about the same. At leat the Emeril came with a lid
Cookware manufacturers have done this on occasions in the past. They'll take an item and either re-sell it under a different brand or celebrity name. I had an anodized aluminum pan under the Emeril brand years ago that was identical to ones made for Costco under the Kirkland brand, among others.
I always love the "Unboxing!". Not sure why, nothing ever happens! Just once, I'd like to see the box defeat you! Hey, I'm 65, alone and unsupervised, and occasionally bored! Thoughts happen! 😉😄😂😂👵🇺🇸
I have a question. I heard of people filing claims against companies for false advertising of products. If a company claims that you can use a mixer on their pan and it won’t scratch, you do then it scratches wouldn’t that be considered false advertising?
For a return, they’d probably honor it. For a lawsuit, they may have a chance at an out by clarifying the instructions and usage in the product manual.
Yes, it would be false advertising. But if you take them to court the first thing a lawyer or judge is going to ask you is "How were you damaged?". If the damage is the cost of the pan and a ruined meal is it worth paying a lawyer? And if the company offered to replace the pan or refund your money you'd have no case at all.
Just finished a class in business law, but im no lawyer. Having not understood how this happens so bloody often, i had to read historical cases of whats called "Puffery". Apparently non truthful statements are acceptable in advertising to some extent unless they can be objectively verified. Seems this could be, but Im guessing this has happened so many times and the court decisions based on puffery precedent are simply going to continue to stand. Thats it in a nut shell.
Simple answer. NO. for a simple reason. When you buy a product, there is always a garantee that coming with it. And that garantee stupilate clearly that the garantee wont apply if you dont use the product the way it's supposed to be used. Using a mixer in the pan is probably against the garantee statement, and so, no garantee could apply and so the one doing the infraction is the user, not the creator. it's a shady thing, but it's like this sinze.. forever as far as i can tell. The other reason will simply be "mental", it's not because someone do something that mean you have to do the same. As exemple, it's not because they tested a car in a crash test that mean you had to crash you car in the nearest wall to test it.
That being said, the Red Bull guy sued the crap out of them cause it didn’t actually give you wings… so I guess there’s always a way to swing it and win
It is a great frying pan! I have had no problems at all for 19 months. I love the Emeril forever pan. I'm not worried about the mixer test because I don't use any metal on my pans.
@@Malthan If you get a drop or 2 of oil on the bottom it's going to wick into those dots and stink from that moment on. I can't fry bacon and eggs without leaking a drop down the side. Good luck, I hope you stay perfect!
Terrific review... I was a professional reviewer for a few years. I have 4 Forever pans. Yes they worked fine for the first year, then they went south pretty fast. Years (10) ago I reviewed Rachel Rae pot set, it was $99.00 for a complete set. I still have them and they look almost as good now as they were then. I would never be ashamed to give that set as a gift. The Forever pans are wearing down fast: they lost the slide quickly and now I have to scrub them hard. They scratched easily and they look awful. I only cook for one so I am not beating them up. Pretty early on I had to use butter/oil to have them non stick. They are still better than the average pans but I am disappointed they did not live up to the promise. Rachel Rae are not as bad as the Forever pans after over 10 years. Thanks for all your reviews.
My biggest test interest is to see how well it works after 6 months of use. Silicone vs. metal utensils, dishwasher vs. hand washing. Great that it does what the commercial advertises, but does the coating last, does it need repeated oil seasoning over time, or is it disposable and useless after a few cooking tests.
Same. Unless they've invented some new non-stick coating technology that lasts forever (and they absolutely would be advertising that if they did) then it's going to stop being non-stop eventually. "Forever" Pan seems like false advertising
Ok now ya gotta do a video on how you rank all these pans and how they've all held up over the years. I'm always in the market for a good nonstick pan and would love a video where all the important info for all these pans is in one place.
Sorta unrelated, but it's nice to see you still using those Dreamfarm kitchen tools after all these years. Might consider some for myself because of that!
Ninja finally started selling their products in Europe and I bought bunch of their products because of your videos. I must say they really make great stuff I am happy with all my purchases.
I recently bought the 10” Ninja Never Stick skillet and really like it. One of the things I like about it is the weight. It isn’t as light weight as regular non-stick skillets, but not as heavy as a cast iron skillet. It didn’t come with a lid, but I have several that will fit it just fine. It can also be used in the oven to fairly high heat. I don’t recall the degree, but it’s up there around 450 degrees. I will likely get the 12”, too.
I have an Emeril pan that I bought several years ago. I use it often and it works just like the day I bought it. I spray it with a little bit of oil and go for it. I got rid of all the rest of my coated pans since I got this one. It’s an amazing pan!
I used to have one of those, I ended up not liking it because the bottom was too thin and it distributed heat unevenly, plus the non-stick wasn't great. It was OK though.
I looked at those…I have Elena Garcia ceramic, with white interior. I love the white! I was looking to replace my 11” diameter deep pan because I messed it up with over heating and I still want that white interior. The diameter and depth make it really useful for one pot dishes, too. Faster than a pot, since it has such a big surface area. I don’t use metal, don’t scrub with abrasives, and now I’ve learned my lesson on the very important heat limit…
I saw people talking about the blue diamond pan I’ve had my blue time and pan for about 3 1/2 years now I wanna say it works 93% as good as day one. In my opinion that’s amazing
It's rare and very useful to hear from people that have used a pan for multiple years, so thank you! Most Amazon reviews are useless as they are based only on initial impressions and almost any non-stick pan will perform well when new. One reason I like this channel is that it follows up on older products.
Wow that is good, I've got the graniterock pro, I've been using it everyday for the last couple years and I want to say it performs about 80% as well as the day I got it. It does require spraying if you don't want things like eggs to stick to it, but it still is otherwise much much less sticky/easier to clean than an ordinary pan.
Clean a carbon steel shovel, then oil shovel, hold shovel inside fire in your firepit n heat it up....then get ur steak and cook in shovel above fire. The shovel has no holes, which in return keeps tons more juices towards better eatting. Hope ya give this a gander as well 👍
I had enough of my gotham steel copper pans that once again failed me and bacon/eggs stuck horribly bad. Lasted maybe 2 years and all of them are garbage. Have a chef grade nonstick pan that sticks now and a ceramic pan that also sticks terribly bad. I was searching for a quality nonstick pan and then after reading some reviews i asked myself why waste money on another pan thats just going to fail? So i looked up carbon steel pans that should last a lifetime and with a proper seasoning should always last and can be redone if needed. So im looking and trying to decide between two pans: Mauviel M Steel and BK Cookware. Im leaning the BK as its cheaper for a bigger pan. Update: I bought a 2pk on amazon of the viking pans and they are so so. I heavily seasoned them as recommended and at first they worked quite well. Remember to never use more than medium heat and if anything less because these pans get hot. I think this is half the reason why im loosing my non stick seasoning on them now. I always use olive oil but i think its low heat tolerance is getting burnt off and now eggs/bacon stick again. Im gonna have to use a propane burner outside to smoke them and re-season. Maybe i should find/use a different oil thats more heat tolerant? Regardless they are easy to clean and still work better tham my nonsticks.
I had a set of the Emeril pans... they didn't hold up well after about a year. Switched those out to a set from Ninja, same deal, didn't hold up well after about a year. Now trying out a hexclad set, we'll see how they do. I like the idea of more durability with the stainless steel layers coupled with the (likely not *as* good) nonstick of Teflon. Time will tell.
With non-stick pans, long-term durability is the #1 criteria. Most of them are great day 1. Hex Clad has, by now, stood the test of time. Yes, it may not be quite as good as a day 1 non-stick, but it is way more reliable in the long run.
@@lazulin you really shouldn’t be buying long-term durability non stick cookware. just buy cast iron and stainless pans that will last forever, keep them seasoned, and buy a cheap little restaurant supply non stick pan for $8 and use it until the Teflon wears. Way less hassle
Seems that way, but that hexclad was $130 and an extra $50 for a lid. I pulled the trigger on the Ninja never stick premium 12.5" from Bed Bath, with 20% online discount just this last week for 40+ but a lid would have been another $30! I went to the local thrift shop today and dug through a box of glass pan lid covers. got one that seriously was never used. $1.50. Even had the small vent in it, the $30 ninja lid doesnt have any vent holes...
James your videos are so good i been waiting all day to watch a 26 minute video for a pan ill prolly never buy .i unironically look forward to the shrimp and chicken tests
I pretty much abandoned the whole nonstick pan thing years ago. Eggs are the only thing I can see having a sticking problem. I almost always use stainless steel (I also have a cast iron pan). It's durable (should last a lifetime) cleans up well with hot soapy water, and cooks well. I like the idea of it not wearing out.
I just bought a 40$ matte enameled cast iron pan slow baked some chicken wings in bbq sauce yesterday for 3.5 hours and everything washed out perfectly chicken fell off the bone. Washing that pan was as tough as washing the plate I used. Amazing. LOVE IT!!!
In my experience, when it comes to pans that need to be seasoned, like cast iron, I find that there is a "break-in" period. After a few uses and seasonings, it begins to perform at its best. Some sooner over others.
Honestly, I'm impressed by the pan... if I was buying it for me. However, I'm looking for a pan for my mother who is of the opinion that metal tools are the best tools, no matter what the pan manufacturers say. She can, will, and has, scratched up non-stick pans less than 30 minutes after receiving them. So I had hoped that this Emeril pan might work for her, as it is light and is advertised as being able to stand up to her. I'm sad that the reality is otherwise. But the Hexclad is my other choice, so I'm glad to see that you have had good luck with that one for so long.
I've NEVER had a non stick pan last longer than 6 months. I think I tried them all at one time other. I use SS or cast iron now, they work. Get back with me in 6 months of daily use and see if it works as good as new.
I've had nonstick pans last me for years, if they are only lasting 6 months then one must be doing something wrong. I have cast iron, stainless and non stick that I treat each with care. But I reach for the nonstick the most because it's easier.
I love your videos. I always use a hand mixer to mash potatoes or turnip in the pot. Not a ”pan” so to speak, but same difference. I use stainless steel pots for this.
My husband got me "The Rock" set from Starfrit and my oh my ---are they the best pans I've ever owned. After heavy usage "As a chef" and dishwashers ---metals tools, everything! They are still nonstick and pretty amazing. I had them for now 5 years! No scratch! Just some decoloration.
@@Phynastor oh yeah no, its not called graniterock. Its Starfrit TheRock set. It have an engraved logo on the handle. I've seen lots of chef using those pans before, and they are 100% oven proof depending if you get the ones with the metal handles. They also have a coper version, which have a more "kitchen" style? I bought one and its older than my 5 year set. Its still nonstick and I never seasoned it, and I put it in the dishwasher too. A lot more heavy duty than the regular The Rock set.
Lucky! Both of mine are no longer nonstick. Also, when I've removed them from the dishwasher and wipe down any leftover drops of water, a black residue from the bottom of the pan is left on my towel.
@@LC.1990 ive saw some ppl talk about that in their reviews. Strangely mines never did that so I cant speak for that experience. I mean fabrication defaults are a thing, as I bought some of the stuff on this channell to be totally not working like his did! Might be similar in these cases.
Many years ago I bought an Emeril stainless cook set and was always very happy with it. I later found out it was actually made by Allclad. I don't know who produces this though.
I'll stay with my All-Clads ... a nonstick pan I use 3-5 times a week is just starting to stick a little after 2 1/2 years. Its big brother, which gets used once every couple of weeks, is still perfect.
Good review and love the extra reality check on the end where you expose the difference in what they advertise vs what they actually give you. In this one I see that advertising getting pulled once they suffer some false advertising suits.
Yeah, like some of those claims are ridiculous sure, but the dishwasher thing is just a pure bruh moment. And the ad should definitely be pulled and the POS who thought of some of those claims should be jailed. I should also mention from what i've heard from video games, apparently in the US it's not false advertising if it's not mentioned on the package. So if it's the same case for this, then I think our false advertising laws are way too forgiving.
@@thequadrupleagent4130 I'm not a lawyer but it does seem to meet the broad definition of false advertising in the United states. Which is defined as... False advertising is defined as the act of publishing, transmitting, or otherwise publicly circulating an advertisement containing a false, misleading, or deceptive statement, made intentionally or recklessly to promote the sale of property, goods, or services.
Have you seen the OXO Mira Tri-ply stainless nonstick pans? Supposed to heat more evenly than anodized nonstick pans and more efficiently on induction. Would love to see how that pan lives up to your standards. Awesome channel!
As someone who's done some fairly serious cooking over the last 20 years and owned every pot, pan, knife and kitchen gadget under the sun, here's the one observation that I can make consistently - no matter the advancements in cookware technology, all coated / non-stick, and even most stainless steel cookware, will fail eventually, no matter how much you follow the usage and care instructions. The only cookware that truly stands the test of time is cast iron. Clean it properly after every use, with a non-abrasive scrubber, elbow grease and water (no soap after the very first wash - EVER!), immediately dry thoroughly and wipe the inside with a thin layer of oil. Do that, and you'll have the best, non-stick and longest lasting piece of cookware in your arsenal. I bought my first cast iron skillet some 20 years ago, and to this day, it performs just as good, if not better than the early days of when I bought it. All I did was follow the method mentioned above and it's served me well. Yes, cast iron is heavy, and maybe not practical for some... but performance wise, it'll never let you down :)
I've been using cast iron my whole life and I agree with most of what you say, however if you properly season your cast iron you can use a mild dish soap and warm water to clean it and it will not remove the seasoning. Just wipe it down with oil before you store it and bring it to temp before you start cooking the next time. Oh, and it never hurts to cook bacon on it a few times a month.
Also, something I didn’t know for years; you get a microscopic amount of iron every time you eat something cooked in your cast iron. Good to prevent anemia.
@@3rdpig A fair point, and some cast iron manufactures do say you can do that. But best to avoid it IMO :) Couldn't agree more on the bacon point either. And whenever I have it on hand, I like to also rub the inside of my skillet with a knob of duck fat. Not only great for developing the seasoning, but flavor too!
I've had my Emeril set for almost a year. I'm a cook by trade and am CONSTANTLY impressed by these pans. I wish the restaurant I work at had them! Aside from a few scratches where my parents put knives in them to soak🤦 They STILL work flawlessly. And are the go to pan EVERY MEAL. EVERY DAY!
I bought the Legasse Forever pan three years ago. I am very hard on my pans, I use knives forks and I even used scouring pads. Now the pan has scratches on it. But the scratches hardly show up. The pan is still worn but nothing sticks. I have always used fat/oil since I do not like the flavor of my dishes without it. It amazes me often how well this pan holds up. I have the set but I only use the 8" pan every day. I want a 10" pan but they only sell sets. I will review your other pans to see who has single 10" pans. I don't really want to give him business because he screwed me with his rotisserie unit. But I am not one to cut off my nose the spite my face. Love your videos. Thank you
There are plenty of reviews of the Hex Clad where they look at it magnified after these tests and it shows a lot of break down of the materials, which is going directly into your food.
I bought the Blue Diamond pans based on your pan reviews. I found it to be the best price so gave it a chance. I love these pans. They are the ones I reach for and I used them just about every day.
And he’s only gotten more freakin’ awesome! My first was an ice cream scoop years ago. It was notable because of Breyer’s ice cream left out retained it’s shape and James joked about what could it be made of that would cause that!
I just want to say, I really enjoy your reviews. I have come to your channel about 3 times now to search and see if you have done a review on something I have thought about getting. I thought about getting this pan but, for me, the "life time" being 7 years and not actual life time was the deal breaker.
I've been really happy with my granite stone pans. Bought a few different sizes and been generally happy with them. Totally agree with you. If your pan is not gonna hold up, leave those claims out of the infomercial. And that 7 year "lifetime guarantee" is laughable. Again, something you shouldn't say in the commercial if it isn't true. Easy fix, don't say it and people won't be disappointed lol. Great review as always. Even was the first in again to hit that like button. Got it at 10 seconds in 😜
Bought my granitestone pans based on James review and they are great. Unfortunately, my wife is not a great cook and uses high heat and aerosol spray to cook eggs in them! This is why we can't have nice things.
I love my new Ninja Never Stick. It is not as light as a regular nonstick skillet, nor is it as heavy as a cast iron skillet. At 73, and with the onslaught of arthritis, cast iron and the lovely enameled cast iron Dutch ovens are way too heavy for me. But the Ninja can be used in the oven whereas many regular nonstick skillets can’t be. It could be the weight and thickness difference that made the Ninja heat up more slowly than the Emeril pan. Thank you for this excellent review, James!
One way that you can measure how evenly a pan heats up (which would have answered some questions about the Ninja vs the Emeril) is by spreading a thin, even layer of flour on the bottom of it when cold and then watching it brown/burn as it comes up to temperature. Usually thinner, faster-heating pans suffer from having very uneven heating.
I bought a pair of Granitestone Diamond Pro pans at Costco. It suggested not using a spray on oil so I don't. No DW cleaning either but that's fine since I don't have one. It scratches easily even though I don't use metal. I do like it even with the shortcomings. I love these reviews because only time will tell. I like oil with pancakes because of the crispy edges.
They will all scratch, especially if you don't treat them well and don't use non-metal utensils. Get cast iron if you don't want scratches. Every pan with a "non-stick coating" will wear and scratch, it's science.
Great video as always! I have an 8" WMF non-stick pan, I don't know if they are available in the US, and have been cooking with it for about 3 years now, and it is as good as the day I first got it. My other non-stick is a T-Fal Titanium, which I have had for almost 2 years, and it is also as good as the day I got it. Of course, I would never think of allowing any metal utensils near either of them, and they are always hand washed. I would bet they will last the rest of my life, along with my 100-year-old, or so, cast iron skillets - which I will have to leave to someone in my will. 😁
When I moved into my condo the previous owners left an old scratched-up T-fal pan behind. Though I've never used it without oil, I can see it performing these tests just about as well.
One note on the pancakes: If you use those "just add water" mixes, take a look at the ingredients. Almost all of them have "butter powder" in them, so pretty much regardless of pan used, it's not likely to stick since you're basically adding butter anyway. I know these pans are pretty solid on the non-stick so it doesn't matter much, but something to keep in mind for the future of testing ;-)
Another great review!!! I have been watching your for years now and have purchased many products based on your videos. I have never once been disappointed!!! Just curious...do you keep the apartment just for videos? Thanks for great content!
Did you ever do a follow up on the Hexclad pan ? Would be interesting to see how it's holding up if you're still using it. From this video it still looks pretty good.
Bought some Hexclad a few months ago. It's not as nonstick as an out of the box nonstick pan, but it's decent, and you can treat it like cast iron. Even use steel wool on it. Bullet proof pans imo.
Man!! You are the best! This is the best video out there for testing stuff! It is complete, accurate & informative. New subscriber!! Thanks a million. Btw, I just got the 8'' & 9½'' pans as a gift. I wonder if I will change the ones I have already ( got 1 Gotham Orange one + a The Rock one which does the job ) or if should I switch to the Emeril ones. In the end, you said it perfectly, no matter if advertised as the best pan out there, you still need to use common sense!! I never use a mixer in a pan!! It's just stupid even if the ad shows that!
The actual durability test is how the pan performs after 50 or 100 uses and being cleaned carelessly. My cast iron frying pan has been used hundreds of times and is indestructible.
Think we will buy one. I love my cast iron skillet, but it would be nice to have a good skillet without having to pull out the heavy cast iron each evening. Great review, as always. Thank you!
So far my mom has totally destroyed every as seen on tv pan. Just from her cooking alone. The only one that seems to hold up and keep coming back. Is the old school cast iron skillet. In fact shes destroyed a couple electric and gas stoves with that thing 😂
@@bipbop3121 I know she won't even listen to me. It's where she likes to use metal cooking utensils that destroy any protective coating on the skillet or pots and pans. I've even gone as far as replacing all her cooking utensils with wooden ones. But she still uses metal forks and knives on some meals. You don't want to know how much teflon coating I've eaten over the decades thinking it was black pepper 😂
They're probably fine when new. The coatings are designed to be stable at normal cooking temperatures. They shouldn't leach anything out. Teflon for sure is bad for you if fumes are inhaled during manufacturing but it's safe to touch and even ingest in small quantities in solid form (hence why it's used on pans). I'm not sure if any of these brands use a different material or blend of materials though.
@@Briaaanz Do you have a source? AFAIK PTFE on its own is inert unless it get extremely hot and PFOA was phased out of the production process a decade ago. Edit: I should say I'm not a Teflon/PTFE fanboy or anything trying to defend it, I'm just genuinely curious. Personally, I cook mainly on a cast iron skillet.
@@NiSE_Rafter google says that PTFE produces some dangerous fumes when heated above 300°C (572°F). Otherwise, it's not toxic. I don't think anyone would cook at this temperatures.
At Costco they had some guy pushing Hexclad pans and he did the mixer thing. Sure enough, the eggs that followed came right out. I was tempted but they were pricier than I wanted. Good review.
Yes, I'm gonna spend 25 minutes watching somebody talk about a cooking pan. If I could go back in time 30 years and tell my high school self that this would be the highlight of my day, what would he say? I guess he'd be happy that Pearl Jam still exists and we have tickets for MSG on September, 11. But then he'd be confused as to why I mentioned that date as if it has some type of importance.
You missed that side-1,steak-2 picked up its own juice char when you slid it around. That's a veeery nice bonus. Downside, like any thin-wall pan you're getting bottom-dome.
I have wasted my money on those "Coated Pans" . Everyone one of them has failed regardless of manufacture .I have had my Hexclad pans for 2.5 years. They still perform like new!
Those pancakes 🥞 look great. I’m impressed, course I don’t review pans like you do. I bought my wife pioneer women and one of the pans was complete trash. We had to throw it away because we cooked eggs in it and it burned and stuck to the pan. I couldn’t get it out and it then was stained permanently. Thanks for the informative videos.
Try using All Clads latest pans. I have recently purchased 5 individual pans and have been very satisfied. They have done everything that you have shown in your video comparisons
The packaging on the 8" skillet I purchased at a store stated it worked will all type cooktops including INDUCTION but it DOES NOT WORK ON INDUCTION COOKTOP.
Just get any t-fal or calphalon or any other decent teflon non-stick pan and try to take care of it until finish wears down. If you don't use metal silverware in it and be careful you'll probably get 2-3 years out of them. I got three tramontina from costco that are fine enough.
Even if it's a good pan if somebody standing up there telling me that you'll never have to buy another set of pans for the rest of your life and they're talking about a non-stick I'm sorry those do not last forever I doubt it will even last 7 years. I don't see how people get by with that kind of stuff false advertisement they tell you that it can take one thing but then the instructions tell you not to do that guarantee it for life but they don't let you know that life in their term is 7 years. Just that simple fact alone with weird warranty discrepancies and things makes me not want to buy a product so I'll just buy a T-Fal 👍🏻
I'm curious about Ikea's copper pan called the Oumbarlig for $19.99. It has really great reviews and I'd like to know if it could hold up to some of these recent non stick pans. thanks.
@@richardbottom9843 I'm pretty sure it's not, but then again, when the FTC investigated No Man's Sky, they only cared about what was on the box and not any of the interviews or trailers. So, if they act the same for this, then they could get away with it despite the tv ad being a complete lie.
@@lunavixen015 Yes I know they did have one of the best redemption arcs in video game history.... I don't think the shady company selling as seen on tv pans is going to do the same.
i still like my granitestone pan, only issue i've had is food does stick to the rivets that connect the handle because they are inside the pan but are bare metal with no nonstick coating. i guess they didn't plan for food to get up that high but when you stir it around it does get on them
The bottom line is that with non-stick pans, you ALWAYS have to replace them after 3-4 years because the Teflon WILL wear out and degrade. So don't spend a lot of money on a non-stick pan. With the steaks, I have stainless steel All Clad and steaks and other meats naturally release after the surface has browned. Finally, I would suggest you test cookware with "thermal shock" for warping. The average user won't let a pan cool down before shocking with cold water to clean. Cheaper, thinner pans will warp which renders them useless on a ceramic cooktop because they will no longer heat evenly. These advertisers are promising the world to make a buck, but the reality is that there is NO non-stick cookware that will last a "lifetime" unless they are using the lifespan of a hamster.
Man, your Americans have it rough. In Australia, that scratch test would be considered false advertising, and the company would instantly need to refund. Secondly, that whole "customer needs to pay return shipping"vis completely illegal in Australia. If there's an issue with an item under the terms of the warranty, it's the companies responsibility to handle all incidental costs. Americans sure enjoy getting themselves reemed by big business! Edit: yeah you can't buy this pan in Australia, a scam like this would be destroyed by the ACCC and they'd be laughed out of the country. I'm honestly shocked you let advertisers just outright lie to you in the US. Have you got no cosumer protection laws at all?
From now on when you do the mixer test, could you wipe it with a wet paper towel after you're done? That way we can easily see any coating that was scratched off.
Agreed, sometimes what you think is a scratch on the surface is actually the pan removing some material from the metal on the mixer, causing discoloration that can easily be wiped off.
Yes i agree.this would show true result
also do it while it's hot for a better test
I was thinking similar with a dry paper towel at first or even half then with a wet paper towel.
Just watched this and if you look closely at the hexclad it did have scratches as well in the "corners". Harder to see because of the design. I think both are comparable and either will work very well. And yes, wipe with a wet paper towel for comparison.
I always stick (hah!) to cast iron, iron or stainless steel pans. That being said, if I WAS looking for a non-stick pan, I'd definitely want to pick one tested by, and approved by, Freakin' Reviews! Love the thoroughness and honesty of these tests!
I agree non-stick is the worst for cooking but best for cleaning so pick your poison 😂
@@seffbones5655 cast iron cleans really well, so long as you season it well and never wash it and mess it up lol
He does a good review so I agree. I love stainless, but I'd take cast iron or carbon steel over nonstick..
@@priestesslucy yea it just takes a year to get to that point… bought a lodge last year and it’s just now completely non stick
Cast iron is a learning curve ... It is the true forever pan...
Hearing Emeril's name brings back a lot of memories from when I was younger. Him saying "Bam!" always made me laugh but it did a good job at keeping me interested and watching. Between him and Graham Kerr, I was inspired constantly and loved to cook and tried lots of different recipes plus I'd constantly try to invent my own recipes and did a lot of experimenting with different ingredients and cooking styles. I'm willing to bet that you expected for me to become a chef, but I actually didn't go that route. Regardless of that, I've still always had a little bit of a passion for cooking that has stayed with me my whole life. I know this doesn't have anything to do with the pan, but just thought I'd share the memories that watching this brought back to me. Thanks for the video, James!
One of my friends growing up, her mom was from Thailand. She loved Emeril and his catchphrase. However…. instead of “BAM!” she would always yell “PAM!” We did tell her but she wasn’t phased and continued to say PAM. It always gave us a good laugh.
So, after all the pan reviews, which is your best pan?
I'm very thankful of your honesty for it's the reason I watched your previous reviews. Thanks for getting into the nitty-gritty of it... Like the return or refund events.
Between the Ninja & Emeril pans, which one do you like the best & why? A very great review! Thanks.
That tomato sauce test did impress me. I have an older nonstick pan that is a cheaper version of the granite rock one, and their is definitely residual sauce that likes to stay behind. Also that first pancake impressed me, I never have a first cake that looks appetizing.
Ya the first pancake or french toast is almost always the worst one for me in my experience.
I don't think it's really impressive, as he had the lid on the entire time, which trapped in the moisture, possibly allowing it to release easier.
YESSS ! 1st pancake , grilled cheese , quesadilla ....
The first few month of most any good nonstick pan will make the pan look great.
It's longer term where good separates from bad.
Most, if not all, are bad. That is, don't count on more than a year or two from any nonstick pan before stuff WILL STICK.
@@2Truth4Liberty One to two years? You're abusing your pans, or you haven't bought non-stick in a decade. Modern non-stick should last at least five years.
But that said, Teflon non-stick is 100x better than anything else, in terms of non-stick, even the most well seasoned pan will lose to Teflon.
Pan reviews are easily my favorite out of the content you make for whatever reason
The Emeril looks identical to the Blue Diamond with a different stamp on the bottom. I would like to have seen that comparison, considering the Blue Diamond is about 20 bucks. I suspect that these coatings are all about the same. At leat the Emeril came with a lid
Just like drop-shipped junk
1000 different names for the exact same item
Cookware manufacturers have done this on occasions in the past. They'll take an item and either re-sell it under a different brand or celebrity name. I had an anodized aluminum pan under the Emeril brand years ago that was identical to ones made for Costco under the Kirkland brand, among others.
I like a lid. Did he say the price?
Where do you get the drop ship brands?
I always love the "Unboxing!". Not sure why, nothing ever happens! Just once, I'd like to see the box defeat you! Hey, I'm 65, alone and unsupervised, and occasionally bored! Thoughts happen! 😉😄😂😂👵🇺🇸
Quick call 91? if only my alzheimers would allow me to call for help.
An unsupervised adult male????should not be allowed in this day and age 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Lol! I feel ya!
I have a question. I heard of people filing claims against companies for false advertising of products. If a company claims that you can use a mixer on their pan and it won’t scratch, you do then it scratches wouldn’t that be considered false advertising?
For a return, they’d probably honor it.
For a lawsuit, they may have a chance at an out by clarifying the instructions and usage in the product manual.
Yes, it would be false advertising. But if you take them to court the first thing a lawyer or judge is going to ask you is "How were you damaged?". If the damage is the cost of the pan and a ruined meal is it worth paying a lawyer? And if the company offered to replace the pan or refund your money you'd have no case at all.
Just finished a class in business law, but im no lawyer. Having not understood how this happens so bloody often, i had to read historical cases of whats called "Puffery". Apparently non truthful statements are acceptable in advertising to some extent unless they can be objectively verified. Seems this could be, but Im guessing this has happened so many times and the court decisions based on puffery precedent are simply going to continue to stand. Thats it in a nut shell.
Simple answer. NO.
for a simple reason. When you buy a product, there is always a garantee that coming with it. And that garantee stupilate clearly that the garantee wont apply if you dont use the product the way it's supposed to be used.
Using a mixer in the pan is probably against the garantee statement, and so, no garantee could apply and so the one doing the infraction is the user, not the creator.
it's a shady thing, but it's like this sinze.. forever as far as i can tell.
The other reason will simply be "mental", it's not because someone do something that mean you have to do the same. As exemple, it's not because they tested a car in a crash test that mean you had to crash you car in the nearest wall to test it.
That being said, the Red Bull guy sued the crap out of them cause it didn’t actually give you wings… so I guess there’s always a way to swing it and win
Thanks!
Look forward to seeing an update on whether you get a replacement pan.
This is the only UA-cam channel I get excited over when he posts. Love me so freaking reviews.
I love when he review kitchen products
It is a great frying pan! I have had no problems at all for 19 months. I love the Emeril forever pan. I'm not worried about the mixer test because I don't use any metal on my pans.
Warm it up good and smell the bottom. Those dots stink, and they stink up your whole kitchen.
@@Bob_Adkins You think someone wouldn't notice a stink when using something regularly for 19 months?
@@Malthan If you get a drop or 2 of oil on the bottom it's going to wick into those dots and stink from that moment on. I can't fry bacon and eggs without leaking a drop down the side. Good luck, I hope you stay perfect!
Terrific review... I was a professional reviewer for a few years. I have 4 Forever pans. Yes they worked fine for the first year, then they went south pretty fast. Years (10) ago I reviewed Rachel Rae pot set, it was $99.00 for a complete set. I still have them and they look almost as good now as they were then.
I would never be ashamed to give that set as a gift. The Forever pans are wearing down fast: they lost the slide quickly and now I have to scrub them hard. They scratched easily and they look awful. I only cook for one so I am not beating them up. Pretty early on I had to use butter/oil to have them non stick. They are still better than the average pans but I am disappointed they did not live up to the promise. Rachel Rae are not as bad as the Forever pans after over 10 years. Thanks for all your reviews.
Love how thorough your pan reviews are. Always fun to watch.
My biggest test interest is to see how well it works after 6 months of use. Silicone vs. metal utensils, dishwasher vs. hand washing. Great that it does what the commercial advertises, but does the coating last, does it need repeated oil seasoning over time, or is it disposable and useless after a few cooking tests.
Totally agree, all pans work really well out of the box! Lol
Same. Unless they've invented some new non-stick coating technology that lasts forever (and they absolutely would be advertising that if they did) then it's going to stop being non-stop eventually. "Forever" Pan seems like false advertising
@@tagsby81 the coating lasts just long enough for the written warranty to expire, usually. 😔
Why are you not supposed to use aerosol sprays in these things?
How about regular old dish-washing liquid? I notice he was cleaning with water only.
To be fair James does do reviews of how products fair after use. I’m sure he’ll do the same for this one.
Ok now ya gotta do a video on how you rank all these pans and how they've all held up over the years. I'm always in the market for a good nonstick pan and would love a video where all the important info for all these pans is in one place.
I love my ninja pots and pans! Got them because of your review happy to see you’re still using them too!
Sorta unrelated, but it's nice to see you still using those Dreamfarm kitchen tools after all these years. Might consider some for myself because of that!
I love the Clongs, i got them after seeing James's video for them.
Ninja finally started selling their products in Europe and I bought bunch of their products because of your videos. I must say they really make great stuff I am happy with all my purchases.
I recently bought the 10” Ninja Never Stick skillet and really like it. One of the things I like about it is the weight. It isn’t as light weight as regular non-stick skillets, but not as heavy as a cast iron skillet. It didn’t come with a lid, but I have several that will fit it just fine. It can also be used in the oven to fairly high heat. I don’t recall the degree, but it’s up there around 450 degrees. I will likely get the 12”, too.
I always appreciate your honesty in your reviews. Keep them coming.
THANK YOU FOR DOING THIS.I ALWAYS WANTED TO SEE HOW THIS PAN DOES&ALL.U PUT IT THRU SOME TESTS&THEN SOME.LOVE UR HONESTY&ALL.
I have an Emeril pan that I bought several years ago. I use it often and it works just like the day I bought it. I spray it with a little bit of oil and go for it. I got rid of all the rest of my coated pans since I got this one. It’s an amazing pan!
Yeah, but if it has aluminum dots on the bottom, it stinks when it gets hot.
@@Bob_Adkins No dots on mine. It's all stainless steel. I love it!
@@Paul0451 So they were originally made better, with solid SS bottom.
I have the Green Life ceramic pans purchased about 9 or 10 years ago. They still lok and cook great. I never, ever use metal utensils.
I used to have one of those, I ended up not liking it because the bottom was too thin and it distributed heat unevenly, plus the non-stick wasn't great. It was OK though.
I looked at those…I have Elena Garcia ceramic, with white interior. I love the white! I was looking to replace my 11” diameter deep pan because I messed it up with over heating and I still want that white interior. The diameter and depth make it really useful for one pot dishes, too. Faster than a pot, since it has such a big surface area.
I don’t use metal, don’t scrub with abrasives, and now I’ve learned my lesson on the very important heat limit…
I saw people talking about the blue diamond pan I’ve had my blue time and pan for about 3 1/2 years now I wanna say it works 93% as good as day one. In my opinion that’s amazing
It's rare and very useful to hear from people that have used a pan for multiple years, so thank you! Most Amazon reviews are useless as they are based only on initial impressions and almost any non-stick pan will perform well when new. One reason I like this channel is that it follows up on older products.
Oh yes, I LOVE my Blue Diamond pans, they are aces in my my book!
Quite the precise measurement.
Wow that is good, I've got the graniterock pro, I've been using it everyday for the last couple years and I want to say it performs about 80% as well as the day I got it. It does require spraying if you don't want things like eggs to stick to it, but it still is otherwise much much less sticky/easier to clean than an ordinary pan.
CU rates blue diamond a Best Buy! It survived harsh testing.
You should try a carbon steel pan I recently got one and it surprised me how well it worked after properly seasoning
Clean a carbon steel shovel, then oil shovel, hold shovel inside fire in your firepit n heat it up....then get ur steak and cook in shovel above fire. The shovel has no holes, which in return keeps tons more juices towards better eatting. Hope ya give this a gander as well 👍
@@begoodbebetterbeblessedix3766 😳
@@begoodbebetterbeblessedix3766 Guga foods and Steven Raichlen have entered the chat
I had enough of my gotham steel copper pans that once again failed me and bacon/eggs stuck horribly bad. Lasted maybe 2 years and all of them are garbage. Have a chef grade nonstick pan that sticks now and a ceramic pan that also sticks terribly bad. I was searching for a quality nonstick pan and then after reading some reviews i asked myself why waste money on another pan thats just going to fail? So i looked up carbon steel pans that should last a lifetime and with a proper seasoning should always last and can be redone if needed. So im looking and trying to decide between two pans: Mauviel M Steel and BK Cookware. Im leaning the BK as its cheaper for a bigger pan. Update: I bought a 2pk on amazon of the viking pans and they are so so. I heavily seasoned them as recommended and at first they worked quite well. Remember to never use more than medium heat and if anything less because these pans get hot. I think this is half the reason why im loosing my non stick seasoning on them now. I always use olive oil but i think its low heat tolerance is getting burnt off and now eggs/bacon stick again. Im gonna have to use a propane burner outside to smoke them and re-season. Maybe i should find/use a different oil thats more heat tolerant? Regardless they are easy to clean and still work better tham my nonsticks.
You must be kidding ! people actually cook cheese sandwiches in a frying pan !? rather than sticking the things under the grill ?
I had a set of the Emeril pans... they didn't hold up well after about a year. Switched those out to a set from Ninja, same deal, didn't hold up well after about a year. Now trying out a hexclad set, we'll see how they do. I like the idea of more durability with the stainless steel layers coupled with the (likely not *as* good) nonstick of Teflon. Time will tell.
they wont hold up either its all a scam to get your money
stainless steel will last a really long time if you take care of it
Well, how'd the hexclad do??
I’m actually more impressed with the Hex Clad at this point. Plus it looks a lot cooler too, in my opinion.
My hex clad pan has been fantastic, my favorite “non stick” pan.
With non-stick pans, long-term durability is the #1 criteria. Most of them are great day 1. Hex Clad has, by now, stood the test of time. Yes, it may not be quite as good as a day 1 non-stick, but it is way more reliable in the long run.
@@lazulin I agree completely
@@lazulin you really shouldn’t be buying long-term durability non stick cookware. just buy cast iron and stainless pans that will last forever, keep them seasoned, and buy a cheap little restaurant supply non stick pan for $8 and use it until the Teflon wears. Way less hassle
Seems that way, but that hexclad was $130 and an extra $50 for a lid. I pulled the trigger on the Ninja never stick premium 12.5" from Bed Bath, with 20% online discount just this last week for 40+ but a lid would have been another $30! I went to the local thrift shop today and dug through a box of glass pan lid covers. got one that seriously was never used. $1.50. Even had the small vent in it, the $30 ninja lid doesnt have any vent holes...
Great job. One suggestion--you should have put the prices of each pan above when you did your lineup at the beginning of the vid.
James your videos are so good i been waiting all day to watch a 26 minute video for a pan ill prolly never buy .i unironically look forward to the shrimp and chicken tests
I pretty much abandoned the whole nonstick pan thing years ago. Eggs are the only thing I can see having a sticking problem. I almost always use stainless steel (I also have a cast iron pan). It's durable (should last a lifetime) cleans up well with hot soapy water, and cooks well. I like the idea of it not wearing out.
I just bought a 40$ matte enameled cast iron pan slow baked some chicken wings in bbq sauce yesterday for 3.5 hours and everything washed out perfectly chicken fell off the bone. Washing that pan was as tough as washing the plate I used. Amazing. LOVE IT!!!
In order to get "the slide" around you get on eggs. You need to have a higher heat and taper it down.
In my experience, when it comes to pans that need to be seasoned, like cast iron, I find that there is a "break-in" period.
After a few uses and seasonings, it begins to perform at its best. Some sooner over others.
Honestly, I'm impressed by the pan... if I was buying it for me. However, I'm looking for a pan for my mother who is of the opinion that metal tools are the best tools, no matter what the pan manufacturers say. She can, will, and has, scratched up non-stick pans less than 30 minutes after receiving them. So I had hoped that this Emeril pan might work for her, as it is light and is advertised as being able to stand up to her. I'm sad that the reality is otherwise. But the Hexclad is my other choice, so I'm glad to see that you have had good luck with that one for so long.
S
I'm not sure why this showed up in my feed, but I watched the whole thing. Thanks!
I've NEVER had a non stick pan last longer than 6 months. I think I tried them all at one time other. I use SS or cast iron now, they work. Get back with me in 6 months of daily use and see if it works as good as new.
I've had nonstick pans last me for years, if they are only lasting 6 months then one must be doing something wrong. I have cast iron, stainless and non stick that I treat each with care. But I reach for the nonstick the most because it's easier.
I had an Al clad last 30 years
I love your videos.
I always use a hand mixer to mash potatoes or turnip in the pot. Not a ”pan” so to speak, but same difference. I use stainless steel pots for this.
My grandmother in law just bought us this whole set haha. Good to see they compares pretty well against these other top tier pans.
My husband got me "The Rock" set from Starfrit and my oh my ---are they the best pans I've ever owned. After heavy usage "As a chef" and dishwashers ---metals tools, everything! They are still nonstick and pretty amazing. I had them for now 5 years! No scratch! Just some decoloration.
Nice, I checked it out, if that stuff is 5 years old then my graniterock stuff is probably a knockoff of this stuff. It works really well though.
@@Phynastor oh yeah no, its not called graniterock. Its Starfrit TheRock set. It have an engraved logo on the handle. I've seen lots of chef using those pans before, and they are 100% oven proof depending if you get the ones with the metal handles.
They also have a coper version, which have a more "kitchen" style? I bought one and its older than my 5 year set. Its still nonstick and I never seasoned it, and I put it in the dishwasher too. A lot more heavy duty than the regular The Rock set.
I am buying some!
Lucky! Both of mine are no longer nonstick. Also, when I've removed them from the dishwasher and wipe down any leftover drops of water, a black residue from the bottom of the pan is left on my towel.
@@LC.1990 ive saw some ppl talk about that in their reviews. Strangely mines never did that so I cant speak for that experience. I mean fabrication defaults are a thing, as I bought some of the stuff on this channell to be totally not working like his did! Might be similar in these cases.
Many years ago I bought an Emeril stainless cook set and was always very happy with it. I later found out it was actually made by Allclad. I don't know who produces this though.
I'll stay with my All-Clads ... a nonstick pan I use 3-5 times a week is just starting to stick a little after 2 1/2 years. Its big brother, which gets used once every couple of weeks, is still perfect.
China!
Good review and love the extra reality check on the end where you expose the difference in what they advertise vs what they actually give you.
In this one I see that advertising getting pulled once they suffer some false advertising suits.
Yeah, like some of those claims are ridiculous sure, but the dishwasher thing is just a pure bruh moment. And the ad should definitely be pulled and the POS who thought of some of those claims should be jailed.
I should also mention from what i've heard from video games, apparently in the US it's not false advertising if it's not mentioned on the package. So if it's the same case for this, then I think our false advertising laws are way too forgiving.
@@thequadrupleagent4130 I'm not a lawyer but it does seem to meet the broad definition of false advertising in the United states. Which is defined as...
False advertising is defined as the act of publishing, transmitting, or otherwise publicly circulating an advertisement containing a false, misleading, or deceptive statement, made intentionally or recklessly to promote the sale of property, goods, or services.
Have you seen the OXO Mira Tri-ply stainless nonstick pans? Supposed to heat more evenly than anodized nonstick pans and more efficiently on induction.
Would love to see how that pan lives up to your standards.
Awesome channel!
As someone who's done some fairly serious cooking over the last 20 years and owned every pot, pan, knife and kitchen gadget under the sun, here's the one observation that I can make consistently - no matter the advancements in cookware technology, all coated / non-stick, and even most stainless steel cookware, will fail eventually, no matter how much you follow the usage and care instructions.
The only cookware that truly stands the test of time is cast iron. Clean it properly after every use, with a non-abrasive scrubber, elbow grease and water (no soap after the very first wash - EVER!), immediately dry thoroughly and wipe the inside with a thin layer of oil. Do that, and you'll have the best, non-stick and longest lasting piece of cookware in your arsenal.
I bought my first cast iron skillet some 20 years ago, and to this day, it performs just as good, if not better than the early days of when I bought it. All I did was follow the method mentioned above and it's served me well. Yes, cast iron is heavy, and maybe not practical for some... but performance wise, it'll never let you down :)
I've been using cast iron my whole life and I agree with most of what you say, however if you properly season your cast iron you can use a mild dish soap and warm water to clean it and it will not remove the seasoning. Just wipe it down with oil before you store it and bring it to temp before you start cooking the next time. Oh, and it never hurts to cook bacon on it a few times a month.
Also, something I didn’t know for years; you get a microscopic amount of iron every time you eat something cooked in your cast iron. Good to prevent anemia.
@@3rdpig A fair point, and some cast iron manufactures do say you can do that. But best to avoid it IMO :)
Couldn't agree more on the bacon point either. And whenever I have it on hand, I like to also rub the inside of my skillet with a knob of duck fat. Not only great for developing the seasoning, but flavor too!
I've had my Emeril set for almost a year. I'm a cook by trade and am CONSTANTLY impressed by these pans. I wish the restaurant I work at had them! Aside from a few scratches where my parents put knives in them to soak🤦 They STILL work flawlessly. And are the go to pan EVERY MEAL. EVERY DAY!
I’m trying one for fun ,will see how it goes
Do you season it from times to times or nothing right out of the box and just clean it as usual?
If anything, James is thorough and fair.
I bought the Legasse Forever pan three years ago. I am very hard on my pans, I use knives forks and I even used scouring pads. Now the pan has scratches on it. But the scratches hardly show up. The pan is still worn but nothing sticks. I have always used fat/oil since I do not like the flavor of my dishes without it. It amazes me often how well this pan holds up. I have the set but I only use the 8" pan every day. I want a 10" pan but they only sell sets. I will review your other pans to see who has single 10" pans. I don't really want to give him business because he screwed me with his rotisserie unit. But I am not one to cut off my nose the spite my face. Love your videos. Thank you
There are plenty of reviews of the Hex Clad where they look at it magnified after these tests and it shows a lot of break down of the materials, which is going directly into your food.
I'd like to see these reports. Can you link to any of them? Cheers.
I bought the Blue Diamond pans based on your pan reviews. I found it to be the best price so gave it a chance. I love these pans. They are the ones I reach for and I used them just about every day.
I've had mine for about a year and stuff is starting to stick, but hey, for the price, I'd say they're worth it!
I remember all the reviews of the other pans.....I've learned two things...
I've been watching you since 2017.
Time has really flown by......lol
And he’s only gotten more freakin’ awesome! My first was an ice cream scoop years ago. It was notable because of Breyer’s ice cream left out retained it’s shape and James joked about what could it be made of that would cause that!
I just want to say, I really enjoy your reviews. I have come to your channel about 3 times now to search and see if you have done a review on something I have thought about getting. I thought about getting this pan but, for me, the "life time" being 7 years and not actual life time was the deal breaker.
I've been really happy with my granite stone pans. Bought a few different sizes and been generally happy with them. Totally agree with you. If your pan is not gonna hold up, leave those claims out of the infomercial. And that 7 year "lifetime guarantee" is laughable. Again, something you shouldn't say in the commercial if it isn't true. Easy fix, don't say it and people won't be disappointed lol. Great review as always. Even was the first in again to hit that like button. Got it at 10 seconds in 😜
I love the Granitestone pans too. I bought them based on James' review. The Granitestone pans are indestructible.
@@shellymac7597 same here! He really made me want to try them and I love them!
Bought my granitestone pans based on James review and they are great. Unfortunately, my wife is not a great cook and uses high heat and aerosol spray to cook eggs in them! This is why we can't have nice things.
@@gregthompson709 I started labeling pots, pans and knives after my previous roommate kept putting them into the fucking dishwasher. Animals.
@@gregthompson709 One of the reason I am not married.
I love my new Ninja Never Stick. It is not as light as a regular nonstick skillet, nor is it as heavy as a cast iron skillet. At 73, and with the onslaught of arthritis, cast iron and the lovely enameled cast iron Dutch ovens are way too heavy for me. But the Ninja can be used in the oven whereas many regular nonstick skillets can’t be. It could be the weight and thickness difference that made the Ninja heat up more slowly than the Emeril pan. Thank you for this excellent review, James!
Do the smooth surface pans “swirl” more easily than the slightly pebbled pans?
Fantastic review, comparisons & explanations. Thanks so much for this. Be well.
One way that you can measure how evenly a pan heats up (which would have answered some questions about the Ninja vs the Emeril) is by spreading a thin, even layer of flour on the bottom of it when cold and then watching it brown/burn as it comes up to temperature. Usually thinner, faster-heating pans suffer from having very uneven heating.
And they warp, too! No problem with gas or induction, but that's a problem with a glass top.
I bought a pair of Granitestone Diamond Pro pans at Costco. It suggested not using a spray on oil so I don't. No DW cleaning either but that's fine since I don't have one. It scratches easily even though I don't use metal. I do like it even with the shortcomings. I love these reviews because only time will tell. I like oil with pancakes because of the crispy edges.
This is my problem too: I hate when pans are getting scratched. Trying to figure which one doesn’t scratch no matter how much it costs.
Hexclad
They will all scratch, especially if you don't treat them well and don't use non-metal utensils. Get cast iron if you don't want scratches. Every pan with a "non-stick coating" will wear and scratch, it's science.
@@Grizazzle came to say cast iron is the only scratch resistant pan!
I remember my mom had old, heavy black cast iron pan, it could withstand anything.
enamel cookware
If you were selling this pan from a large wagon in a old west town, I’d buy one !
Great demo !
Great video as always! I have an 8" WMF non-stick pan, I don't know if they are available in the US, and have been cooking with it for about 3 years now, and it is as good as the day I first got it. My other non-stick is a T-Fal Titanium, which I have had for almost 2 years, and it is also as good as the day I got it. Of course, I would never think of allowing any metal utensils near either of them, and they are always hand washed. I would bet they will last the rest of my life, along with my 100-year-old, or so, cast iron skillets - which I will have to leave to someone in my will. 😁
When I moved into my condo the previous owners left an old scratched-up T-fal pan behind. Though I've never used it without oil, I can see it performing these tests just about as well.
One note on the pancakes: If you use those "just add water" mixes, take a look at the ingredients. Almost all of them have "butter powder" in them, so pretty much regardless of pan used, it's not likely to stick since you're basically adding butter anyway. I know these pans are pretty solid on the non-stick so it doesn't matter much, but something to keep in mind for the future of testing ;-)
I don’t do much shopping unfortunately but I LOVE watching your videos and learning about these items
Same 🥲 To hell with poverty!
"I'm going let this egg sit, I'm not touching it"
[immediately proceeds to touching it]
Another great review!!! I have been watching your for years now and have purchased many products based on your videos. I have never once been disappointed!!! Just curious...do you keep the apartment just for videos? Thanks for great content!
Did you ever do a follow up on the Hexclad pan ? Would be interesting to see how it's holding up if you're still using it. From this video it still looks pretty good.
Yeah I would love a follow up on the hexclad
Bought some Hexclad a few months ago. It's not as nonstick as an out of the box nonstick pan, but it's decent, and you can treat it like cast iron. Even use steel wool on it. Bullet proof pans imo.
When you do the mixer test, use a paper towel to see if it picks up any dust
Man!! You are the best!
This is the best video out there for testing stuff!
It is complete, accurate & informative.
New subscriber!!
Thanks a million.
Btw, I just got the 8'' & 9½'' pans as a gift. I wonder if I will change the ones I have already ( got 1 Gotham Orange one + a The Rock one which does the job ) or if should I switch to the Emeril ones.
In the end, you said it perfectly, no matter if advertised as the best pan out there, you still need to use common sense!!
I never use a mixer in a pan!! It's just stupid even if the ad shows that!
The actual durability test is how the pan performs after 50 or 100 uses and being cleaned carelessly. My cast iron frying pan has been used hundreds of times and is indestructible.
Cast iron are the best
Think we will buy one. I love my cast iron skillet, but it would be nice to have a good skillet without having to pull out the heavy cast iron each evening.
Great review, as always. Thank you!
So far my mom has totally destroyed every as seen on tv pan. Just from her cooking alone. The only one that seems to hold up and keep coming back. Is the old school cast iron skillet. In fact shes destroyed a couple electric and gas stoves with that thing 😂
Damn, would be better if she was open to some basic cooking instruction.
@@bipbop3121 I know she won't even listen to me. It's where she likes to use metal cooking utensils that destroy any protective coating on the skillet or pots and pans. I've even gone as far as replacing all her cooking utensils with wooden ones. But she still uses metal forks and knives on some meals. You don't want to know how much teflon coating I've eaten over the decades thinking it was black pepper 😂
I love all your videos and have been watching all of them for over 2 years. Just want you know know I always watch each one.
You should test all the pans at once to see if the old still stands up to the newest, maybe do an egg in each. Be cool to which one holds up.
I love the way you brought out the thermal Imager. you know take any shortcuts with these hats and that's awesome
Pro-tip use a thin layer of Mayo instead of butter for grilled cheese. It will be so crispy & brown beautifully & doesn't taste like Mayo!
Why would you waste mayo for that when butter is way cheaper anyway ? :O
And who wants crispy grilled cheese a preference is soggy with butter damn delicious but not healthy.
@@franktrinidad142 because it makes the bread crispy not soggy & I don't think real butter is cheaper than Mayo & you use way less.
@@johnree6106 frankly I could take them either way especially if I don't have to cook it lol
@@tatchik77 Yes agree with not having to cook them, and yes I would eat both ways just have a preference because that's how my mom cooked them 😋
Thanks for posting I guess I have tried so many new bangle non-stick pans always go back to a hundred year old cast iron
I’m also wondering if all these different cooking surfaces on all these new age pans are safe for our health…
In 10 - 20 years they're going to say the same things as they now do about teflon
They're probably fine when new. The coatings are designed to be stable at normal cooking temperatures. They shouldn't leach anything out.
Teflon for sure is bad for you if fumes are inhaled during manufacturing but it's safe to touch and even ingest in small quantities in solid form (hence why it's used on pans). I'm not sure if any of these brands use a different material or blend of materials though.
@@NiSE_Rafter there is some evidence that Teflon is bad for you outside of the manufacturing process.
@@Briaaanz Do you have a source? AFAIK PTFE on its own is inert unless it get extremely hot and PFOA was phased out of the production process a decade ago.
Edit: I should say I'm not a Teflon/PTFE fanboy or anything trying to defend it, I'm just genuinely curious. Personally, I cook mainly on a cast iron skillet.
@@NiSE_Rafter google says that PTFE produces some dangerous fumes when heated above 300°C (572°F). Otherwise, it's not toxic. I don't think anyone would cook at this temperatures.
i have the blue diamond and works like it says it does. use mind 6,7 or more times per week. planning on getting the next size up.
I low-key watch this channel 20% of the time just for the eggs 😜
At Costco they had some guy pushing Hexclad pans and he did the mixer thing. Sure enough, the eggs that followed came right out. I was tempted but they were pricier than I wanted. Good review.
Yes, I'm gonna spend 25 minutes watching somebody talk about a cooking pan. If I could go back in time 30 years and tell my high school self that this would be the highlight of my day, what would he say? I guess he'd be happy that Pearl Jam still exists and we have tickets for MSG on September, 11. But then he'd be confused as to why I mentioned that date as if it has some type of importance.
Unexpectedly profound comment 😳
You missed that side-1,steak-2 picked up its own juice char when you slid it around. That's a veeery nice bonus. Downside, like any thin-wall pan you're getting bottom-dome.
I have wasted my money on those "Coated Pans" . Everyone one of them has failed regardless of manufacture .I have had my Hexclad pans for 2.5 years. They still perform like new!
Thank you for showing this
I was confused about which set of pans to buy. Now I know
I wanna see to what degree these pans are bulletproof 🤷♂️
Hit up Demolition Ranch channel and ask Matt to check it out. he has done many of pans.
Awesome video! Keep up the awesome work! Hope to see a juicer review in the near future 😎
Those pancakes 🥞 look great. I’m impressed, course I don’t review pans like you do. I bought my wife pioneer women and one of the pans was complete trash. We had to throw it away because we cooked eggs in it and it burned and stuck to the pan. I couldn’t get it out and it then was stained permanently. Thanks for the informative videos.
That happened to one of my friends she loves Pioneer woman stuff but one of the pans she used was trash.
Try using All Clads latest pans. I have recently purchased 5 individual pans and have been very satisfied. They have done everything that you have shown in your video comparisons
Please review this pan a year from now. Let's see if you can still do the swirl... :)
The packaging on the 8" skillet I purchased at a store stated it worked will all type cooktops including INDUCTION but it DOES NOT WORK ON INDUCTION COOKTOP.
These are the EXACT same pan as the Ninja Pro - I mean exactly, just a different logo.
Just get any t-fal or calphalon or any other decent teflon non-stick pan and try to take care of it until finish wears down. If you don't use metal silverware in it and be careful you'll probably get 2-3 years out of them. I got three tramontina from costco that are fine enough.
Even if it's a good pan if somebody standing up there telling me that you'll never have to buy another set of pans for the rest of your life and they're talking about a non-stick I'm sorry those do not last forever I doubt it will even last 7 years. I don't see how people get by with that kind of stuff false advertisement they tell you that it can take one thing but then the instructions tell you not to do that guarantee it for life but they don't let you know that life in their term is 7 years. Just that simple fact alone with weird warranty discrepancies and things makes me not want to buy a product so I'll just buy a T-Fal 👍🏻
I'm curious about Ikea's copper pan called the Oumbarlig for $19.99. It has really great reviews and I'd like to know if it could hold up to some of these recent non stick pans.
thanks.
If there's that much misleading information in the advertising, there's no way I'd trust this pan no matter how good it might be.
how is that even legal anyways
@@richardbottom9843 I'm pretty sure it's not, but then again, when the FTC investigated No Man's Sky, they only cared about what was on the box and not any of the interviews or trailers. So, if they act the same for this, then they could get away with it despite the tv ad being a complete lie.
@@thequadrupleagent4130 No Man’s Sky devs at least had the gumption to eventually do everything they promised in the end
@@lunavixen015 Yes I know they did have one of the best redemption arcs in video game history.... I don't think the shady company selling as seen on tv pans is going to do the same.
i still like my granitestone pan, only issue i've had is food does stick to the rivets that connect the handle because they are inside the pan but are bare metal with no nonstick coating. i guess they didn't plan for food to get up that high but when you stir it around it does get on them
The bottom line is that with non-stick pans, you ALWAYS have to replace them after 3-4 years because the Teflon WILL wear out and degrade. So don't spend a lot of money on a non-stick pan.
With the steaks, I have stainless steel All Clad and steaks and other meats naturally release after the surface has browned.
Finally, I would suggest you test cookware with "thermal shock" for warping. The average user won't let a pan cool down before shocking with cold water to clean. Cheaper, thinner pans will warp which renders them useless on a ceramic cooktop because they will no longer heat evenly.
These advertisers are promising the world to make a buck, but the reality is that there is NO non-stick cookware that will last a "lifetime" unless they are using the lifespan of a hamster.
Man, your Americans have it rough. In Australia, that scratch test would be considered false advertising, and the company would instantly need to refund.
Secondly, that whole "customer needs to pay return shipping"vis completely illegal in Australia. If there's an issue with an item under the terms of the warranty, it's the companies responsibility to handle all incidental costs.
Americans sure enjoy getting themselves reemed by big business!
Edit: yeah you can't buy this pan in Australia, a scam like this would be destroyed by the ACCC and they'd be laughed out of the country. I'm honestly shocked you let advertisers just outright lie to you in the US. Have you got no cosumer protection laws at all?