Think its a little harsh to talk about how bad they played this season when they have their top 17 for like 7 rounds total thru the year... They had a injury ridden season with times requesting from the NRL to extend the squad past 30 to even field a team.
They still under performed for a team that was at the very least supposed to make finals. As for the individuals criticised, i think it's fair due to their performances this season.
@Odd1x The team as a whole under performed due to injury throughout the season, its not fair criticism. You see it across many teams, what can halves do/ outside backs do when forwards are out, not a whole lot. What can you do with attacking football with main halves/ half out, not a ton cleanly. Like please rewatch the games from this season and actually critique the games based on merit. Expectations were they should make finals sure, but it was a tight season with 5-11 being pretty even win loss. Broncos Best 17 2024 1. Reece Walsh 2. Jesse Arthars 3. Selwyn Cobbo 4. Kotoni Staggs 5. Deine Mariner 6. Ezra Mam 7. Adam Reynolds 8. Corey Jensen 9. Billy Walters 10. Payne Haas 11. Brendan Piakura 12. Jordan Riki 13. Patrick Carrigan Interchange 14. Tyson Smoothy 15. Kobe Hetherington 16. Fletcher Baker 17. Xavier Willison Round 1 - In Taupau/ Out Willison Round 2 - In Taupau/ Out Willison Round 3 - In Madden, Willison/ Out Reynolds, Haas Round 4 - In Sailor, Hunt, Oates/ Out Walsh, Piakura, Haas Round 5 - In Sailor, Hunt, Oates/ Out Walsh, Haas, Willison Round 6 - In Madden, Oates, Hunt, Sailor/ Out Reynolds, Mariner, Haas, Piakura Round 7 - In Madden, Oates, Hunt, Sailor/ Out Reynolds, Mariner, Haas, Piakura Round 8 - In Oates, Madden/ Out Mariner, Mam Round 9 - NO CHANGE Round 10 - In Oates, Rogers(Madden was injured, NRL request submitted for player outside 30 to play), Gosiewski/ Out Arthars, Reynolds, Baker Round 11 - In Karapani, Madden, Oates, Mozer, Gosiewski/ Out Walsh, Reynolds, Arthars, Walters, Baker Round 12 - In Karapani, Madden, Gosiewski/ Out Arthars, Reynolds, Baker Round 13 - BYE Round 14 - In Sailor, Oates, Madden, Gosiewski/ Out Walsh, Arthars, Reynolds, Willison Round 15 - In Sailer, Karapani, Madden, Gosiewski/ Out Walsh, Baker, Reynolds, Arthars Round 16 - BYE Round 17 - In Sailor, Gosiewski, Karapani, Taupau/ Out Walsh, Haas, Carrigan, Riki Round 18 - In Oates, Madden, Karapani, Taupau/ Out Staggs, Reynolds, Riki, Baker Round 19 - In Sailor, Oates, Rogers, Mozer, Karapani, Taupau/ Out Walsh, Cobbo, Reynolds, Haas, Carrigan, Baker Round 20 - In Oates, Taupau/ Out Cobbo, Baker Round 21 - In Mozer, Taupau, Oates/ Out Baker, Smoothy, Piakura Round 22 - In Oates, Mozer, Taupau/ Out Cobbo, Smoothy, Baker Round 23 - In Karapani, Rogers, Sailor, Taupau, Mozer/ Out Cobbo, Mam, Haas, Smoothy, Baker Round 24 - BYE Round 25 - In Sailor, Rogers, Karapani, Taupau/ Out Walsh, Mam, Haas, Baker Round 26 - In Sailor, Karapani, Rogers, Mozer, Taupau/ Out Walsh, Mariner, Mam, Smoothy, Baker Round 27 - In Sailor, Oates, Rogers, Hunt, Mozer, Te Kura, Taupau/ Out Walsh, Staggs, Mam, Piakura, Haas, Willison, Smoothy So 1 game for the whole season where their best 17 played. Theres the potential argument for Taupau>Baker in pecking order, but that doesnt fix anything.
@@chiddiru6114 Look I get it. We can judge players on individual performances regardless of what forced changes were made during the season. Deine Mariner didn't make all those errors and missed tackles because of the constant shuffle in the lineup.
@@Odd1x You can say specifically a player under performed, but you cant say the team as a whole under performed when its extremely clear they pretty much never had a full team on the park.
I think Marty will get a spot over Te Kura atleast to start the season. Also im not a Billy basher but he will definitely serve more as a 14 for injury cover. Mozer seems like a player who builds into a game instead of an impact 14.
I think that maybe replace Te Kura with either Taupau or Baker for more experience. I think Te Kura needs abit more time not in first grade. Besides that, really nice lineup! Can you do the cowboys 1-17 next or soonish??
I expect Mozer to be 9, I think Madge will quickly realise he’s our best 9. I would also argue we should play Paix at 14, but also I don’t know that it’s likely Walters falls out of the 17 entirely. Also being reported up here that Hetherington is set for a bigger role. May see him on the edge and Piakura back on the bench like 2023, where Tbf he was very effective
Love your videos man here is mine as a broncos fan Walsh Arthars Staggs Mariner Cobbo Hunt Reynolds Carrigan Mozer Haas Riki Piakura Hetherington Walters Jensen Willison Te’Kura We never recovered from losing Flegler we used to bash teams in the middle & nobody could hang but Hetherington is a better 13 than our backup props are 8/10s so move Carrigan back to his most played position in the front row. Madge also took Kobe off the transfer list bc he rates him so I think this is likely. Otherwise when Jensen gets subbed the drop off is enormous, much rather he keeps the levels high as an interchange forward for us I rather selwyn at centre but Madge has already said Mariner is gonna be the centre and selwyn only trained on the wing we really missed his mileage from kick returns bc we don’t fatigue and waste Reece on physical kick returns Only other difference we had really was 9s and I think it’s a coin toss
By finals it’ll hopefully be the same forwards there but let’s be real Reynolds gets an injury so the backs: Walsh Arthars Staggs Mariner Cobbo Mam Hunt
Billy is a ok play but he oh hunt might be utility coz they could cover more position then mozer who sud start at 9 just so he can find his combo with 6 n 7
Think its a little harsh to talk about how bad they played this season when they have their top 17 for like 7 rounds total thru the year... They had a injury ridden season with times requesting from the NRL to extend the squad past 30 to even field a team.
They still under performed for a team that was at the very least supposed to make finals.
As for the individuals criticised, i think it's fair due to their performances this season.
@Odd1x The team as a whole under performed due to injury throughout the season, its not fair criticism.
You see it across many teams, what can halves do/ outside backs do when forwards are out, not a whole lot.
What can you do with attacking football with main halves/ half out, not a ton cleanly.
Like please rewatch the games from this season and actually critique the games based on merit.
Expectations were they should make finals sure, but it was a tight season with 5-11 being pretty even win loss.
Broncos Best 17 2024
1. Reece Walsh
2. Jesse Arthars
3. Selwyn Cobbo
4. Kotoni Staggs
5. Deine Mariner
6. Ezra Mam
7. Adam Reynolds
8. Corey Jensen
9. Billy Walters
10. Payne Haas
11. Brendan Piakura
12. Jordan Riki
13. Patrick Carrigan
Interchange
14. Tyson Smoothy
15. Kobe Hetherington
16. Fletcher Baker
17. Xavier Willison
Round 1 - In Taupau/ Out Willison
Round 2 - In Taupau/ Out Willison
Round 3 - In Madden, Willison/ Out Reynolds, Haas
Round 4 - In Sailor, Hunt, Oates/ Out Walsh, Piakura, Haas
Round 5 - In Sailor, Hunt, Oates/ Out Walsh, Haas, Willison
Round 6 - In Madden, Oates, Hunt, Sailor/ Out Reynolds, Mariner, Haas, Piakura
Round 7 - In Madden, Oates, Hunt, Sailor/ Out Reynolds, Mariner, Haas, Piakura
Round 8 - In Oates, Madden/ Out Mariner, Mam
Round 9 - NO CHANGE
Round 10 - In Oates, Rogers(Madden was injured, NRL request submitted for player outside 30 to play), Gosiewski/ Out Arthars, Reynolds, Baker
Round 11 - In Karapani, Madden, Oates, Mozer, Gosiewski/ Out Walsh, Reynolds, Arthars, Walters, Baker
Round 12 - In Karapani, Madden, Gosiewski/ Out Arthars, Reynolds, Baker
Round 13 - BYE
Round 14 - In Sailor, Oates, Madden, Gosiewski/ Out Walsh, Arthars, Reynolds, Willison
Round 15 - In Sailer, Karapani, Madden, Gosiewski/ Out Walsh, Baker, Reynolds, Arthars
Round 16 - BYE
Round 17 - In Sailor, Gosiewski, Karapani, Taupau/ Out Walsh, Haas, Carrigan, Riki
Round 18 - In Oates, Madden, Karapani, Taupau/ Out Staggs, Reynolds, Riki, Baker
Round 19 - In Sailor, Oates, Rogers, Mozer, Karapani, Taupau/ Out Walsh, Cobbo, Reynolds, Haas, Carrigan, Baker
Round 20 - In Oates, Taupau/ Out Cobbo, Baker
Round 21 - In Mozer, Taupau, Oates/ Out Baker, Smoothy, Piakura
Round 22 - In Oates, Mozer, Taupau/ Out Cobbo, Smoothy, Baker
Round 23 - In Karapani, Rogers, Sailor, Taupau, Mozer/ Out Cobbo, Mam, Haas, Smoothy, Baker
Round 24 - BYE
Round 25 - In Sailor, Rogers, Karapani, Taupau/ Out Walsh, Mam, Haas, Baker
Round 26 - In Sailor, Karapani, Rogers, Mozer, Taupau/ Out Walsh, Mariner, Mam, Smoothy, Baker
Round 27 - In Sailor, Oates, Rogers, Hunt, Mozer, Te Kura, Taupau/ Out Walsh, Staggs, Mam, Piakura, Haas, Willison, Smoothy
So 1 game for the whole season where their best 17 played. Theres the potential argument for Taupau>Baker in pecking order, but that doesnt fix anything.
@@chiddiru6114 Look I get it. We can judge players on individual performances regardless of what forced changes were made during the season. Deine Mariner didn't make all those errors and missed tackles because of the constant shuffle in the lineup.
@@Odd1x You can say specifically a player under performed, but you cant say the team as a whole under performed when its extremely clear they pretty much never had a full team on the park.
A lot of the team being selected for origin doesn't help either haha
Cam u do Cronulla Sharks next please😁
I like that side
I think Marty will get a spot over Te Kura atleast to start the season. Also im not a Billy basher but he will definitely serve more as a 14 for injury cover. Mozer seems like a player who builds into a game instead of an impact 14.
I think that maybe replace Te Kura with either Taupau or Baker for more experience. I think Te Kura needs abit more time not in first grade. Besides that, really nice lineup! Can you do the cowboys 1-17 next or soonish??
Baker ain’t a first grader
I don't want Baker anywhere near the best 17, respectfully.
I expect Mozer to be 9, I think Madge will quickly realise he’s our best 9. I would also argue we should play Paix at 14, but also I don’t know that it’s likely Walters falls out of the 17 entirely.
Also being reported up here that Hetherington is set for a bigger role. May see him on the edge and Piakura back on the bench like 2023, where Tbf he was very effective
2025 gonna be the broncos redemption arc
Love your videos man here is mine as a broncos fan
Walsh
Arthars
Staggs
Mariner
Cobbo
Hunt
Reynolds
Carrigan
Mozer
Haas
Riki
Piakura
Hetherington
Walters
Jensen
Willison
Te’Kura
We never recovered from losing Flegler we used to bash teams in the middle & nobody could hang but Hetherington is a better 13 than our backup props are 8/10s so move Carrigan back to his most played position in the front row. Madge also took Kobe off the transfer list bc he rates him so I think this is likely. Otherwise when Jensen gets subbed the drop off is enormous, much rather he keeps the levels high as an interchange forward for us
I rather selwyn at centre but Madge has already said Mariner is gonna be the centre and selwyn only trained on the wing we really missed his mileage from kick returns bc we don’t fatigue and waste Reece on physical kick returns
Only other difference we had really was 9s and I think it’s a coin toss
By finals it’ll hopefully be the same forwards there but let’s be real Reynolds gets an injury so the backs:
Walsh
Arthars
Staggs
Mariner
Cobbo
Mam
Hunt
I rate Patty back in the front row and that's great news about Kobe. Hopefully that actually pans out.
Billy is a ok play but he oh hunt might be utility coz they could cover more position then mozer who sud start at 9 just so he can find his combo with 6 n 7
Please do sharkies
can you do a dolphins predicted squad please?
1 Walsh 2 aurthers 3 staggs 4 mariner 5 cobbo 6 billy Walters 7 Reynolds 8 haas 9 hunt 10 Willson 11 pikura 12 riki 13 Patty Carrigan 14 mozer 15 jenson 16 Kobey Hetherington 17 Marty tapu
Can you pls add Ben Hunt to the broncos in rll4? Love the vids thanks
Wait. Didn't we sign Grant Anderson? Wouldn't he be center?
I think that's for next season
He’s signed for 2026
I would swap mariner and cobbo
#10 Payne Haas. Always No.10 🔥
curious who your #9 is?
Cory Paix, Hooker of The Year this season in the Hostplus comp
nothing special still avrge
ua-cam.com/users/shortsgdQcL8wMaGs?si=hFm_KOYpjXEVCdDO rugby league 25