EFSAS Interview with Professor Pervez Hoodbhoy on the current state of affairs in Pakistan

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 129

  • @rakadus
    @rakadus Рік тому +22

    14:22 The answer to this question gives the deeper challenge that remains unanswered.
    The Professor side stepped the question of being a convert. This inability to own up to one's past and defensiveness to put under the carpet the atrocities of the past is the core challenge. The day this society accepts the reality of its "predecessors" is when they can move forward.

    • @gopalramanathan7062
      @gopalramanathan7062 Рік тому

      You have pointed out the truth. But most of those who call themselves “Pakistani”, including this celebrity Professor dare not own up the truth:
      ua-cam.com/video/55x9ndmkUpA/v-deo.html

    • @HOG1070
      @HOG1070 Рік тому +1

      spot on

    • @rakeshvishwas4331
      @rakeshvishwas4331 Рік тому +1

      Very true

    • @salimalvi5178
      @salimalvi5178 Рік тому

      Islam, Christianity & even Marxism asks converts hate everything native. These legions/gangs were formed to REgal political power to enslave, rob and colonize natives.
      Good old professor may not be very clear about Nuclear particles but he clearly knows that the Economic World Order is in hands of those who use these legions to keep this economic world order staying alive. If the professor starts loving his ancestors who converted to escape Jiziya Tax, loss of properties, rape and death then he will lose his special status in Pakistan and in the West.
      Pakistan can't be a nation because nations are built by natives but most Pakistanis especially all the so called elite & Anglicized ones hate everything native.

    • @anshuraj4277
      @anshuraj4277 Рік тому +1

      Who cares.. He is free to believe anything

  • @AnujKumar-wj3ju
    @AnujKumar-wj3ju Рік тому +18

    Every Muslim in the world 🗺 is converted to Islam 🐫 🕌 mostly using sword ⚔ including founder of Islam 🐫 🕌 Muhammad, Since he was not a born Muslim.

    • @gopalramanathan7062
      @gopalramanathan7062 Рік тому

      Those who have the guts to challenge it have long fled the Cultists lands and live in the land of the Kafir: ua-cam.com/video/55x9ndmkUpA/v-deo.html

    • @jamesb9499
      @jamesb9499 Рік тому

      YEAH but Mohammed had sword in his hand.

  • @gopalramanathan7062
    @gopalramanathan7062 Рік тому +9

    The greatest tragedy of Papisthan is the sacred Sindhu river still flows through the heart of this accursed entity 🆘
    The urge for the Professor to clutch for a symmetry between Papisthan and Bharath is pathetic. Bharat 🇮🇳 has just begun to be tough on Papisthan and it’s going to get tougher every single day. Bharat will ensure that PoJ&K (including GB) is liberated and soon integrated with BHARAT 🇮🇳 There shall be no common borders between Papisthan and Communist China and we will ensure it. Then we will see to it that Papisthan meets the same fate as Yugoslavia 🛑

  • @ashalivarma4623
    @ashalivarma4623 Рік тому +20

    If anyone thinks Hafeez Saeed is in jail, it is delusional.

    • @whatchamacallit78
      @whatchamacallit78 Рік тому +1

      Do not disrespect the guy.

    • @Striker-jg9kv
      @Striker-jg9kv Рік тому

      ​@@whatchamacallit78or else what? Is rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish ganduudin namazi Hafeez salwar wearing bhanduve khusra saed going to "come out of jail" to avenge his disrespect 😂😂😂

    • @media-rn6zc
      @media-rn6zc Рік тому

      ​@@whatchamacallit78And why? He is a islamic apologist

  • @jnanendradas4650
    @jnanendradas4650 Рік тому

    I have great respect for the professor. I hope people like him should have been in the policy making for Pakistan.

    • @ramanv.r3422
      @ramanv.r3422 Рік тому +1

      I had too. ut today it has diminished a little. He did not say why and how Pakistan became 98 % muslims from what it was at independence.

  • @ravindra7791
    @ravindra7791 Рік тому +7

    Key takeaway - No change of heart regarding terrorism by Pakistan as Dr PH confirms. Period

  • @govindrajan6598
    @govindrajan6598 Рік тому +2

    Parvez The establishment is still very much supporting the terrorists. Regularly terrorists are getting killed at the border while crossing

  • @muhammadkamalkhan3445
    @muhammadkamalkhan3445 Рік тому

    Dr.Hoodbhoy is very capable scholar.wrongly I may be taking him as speaking against the pub)ic emotions

  • @youtubewatcherdesi
    @youtubewatcherdesi Рік тому +1

    23% of Pakistan was non-muslim right after partition. If they could not tolerate their own kind of a different faith, how in the world will they tolerate true foreigners ?

  • @dharmicdarshan2049
    @dharmicdarshan2049 Рік тому +1

    Pervez believes on communist - foreigner islamist version of indian history written by JNU(communist) and ALIGARH-JAMIA (elite landlord islamist) .
    He loves Romila thapar (relative of Nehru and general thapar who supported china in 1962 war ) . Romila talks without primary reference in her books still pervej and other pakistani accepts her .
    Irfan habib ( relative of badruddin tayyabji - former president of INC and saif tayyabji ) he represents aligarh version of history . Demonised indians and glorified foreigner turks and their associates . He denied Berni and Minhaj primary sources of history to save the face of turks/central asian invaders . He denied archeological evidences of Prof. BB LAAL and other prominent archeologist .

  • @vasukinagabhushan
    @vasukinagabhushan Рік тому

    30:10 Pakistan has not stopped terrorism against India. Recently, there was a terrorist attack against India at Poonch.

  • @Usery2k919
    @Usery2k919 Рік тому

    Can someone explain to me why European Foundation for South Asia Studies only has videos about Pakistan on its channel? I think it should be called European Foundation for White Washing Muslim Crimes in South Asia.

  • @offred6013
    @offred6013 Рік тому

    Perfect ex of Once a mullah always a mullah.

  • @prakashraju9304
    @prakashraju9304 Рік тому

    Mr.Hoodbhoy says Pakistanis were not Indians or Hindus before becoming muslims, he also said that there were muslims majority areas which became Pakistan & Bangladesh. But he has to understand that Islam was not in united India until the Muslim invaders came to India. These islamic invaders forcibly converted Indians (Hindus) and they became majority in some areas. Looks like Hoodbhoy doesn't want to identify his forefathers with Hindus!

  • @bhojanrasikananda7794
    @bhojanrasikananda7794 Рік тому

    Pakistan is not a part of South Asia same as Turkey, Azerbaijan, Armenia, Georgia, Cyprus are not part of Asia, except for its numerous conflicts with neighbouring India. It has always been emotionally involved in MENA and would have done well to involve itself geo politically and economically with that region instead of obsessing with India.

  • @nerf2752
    @nerf2752 Рік тому +1

    Key takeaway -
    Pakistan sundas me hai - Pervez Hoodbhoy

  • @RohitKaul-TheRealOne
    @RohitKaul-TheRealOne Рік тому +1

    Pervezji, intellectuals like yourself should stop blaming India and everything else.
    I am a Kashmiri aborigine, we were decimated by islamic terrorists funded by Pakistan post 1987.
    Yes there were election issues in Kashmir, but so was in Bihar, up and so many states thanks to Congress.
    Dont put your Muslim hat when speaking dispassionately. Thats the tragedy with Pakistan that even intellectuals like yourself keep their islamic glasses on.

  • @venugopalmaganti8133
    @venugopalmaganti8133 Рік тому

    Except when he talked about INDIA, CHINA AND KASHMIR, Prof Hoodboy was largely rational - and who better than a Physics professor to talk about Delusions of masses, emanating out of religious fanaticism?

  • @bhavinsampat590
    @bhavinsampat590 6 місяців тому

    Hudhbhoy didn't talk purposefully about Kashmiri pundit massacres orchestrated by Pak establishment of 80s md 90s. Lakes of pandit flew kashmir in fear ..

  • @aanakrukavi
    @aanakrukavi Рік тому +1

    EFSAS is ISI front in Europe.

    • @farazmuzaffar8823
      @farazmuzaffar8823 Рік тому

      If it's ISI front how come they are openly criticizing the ISI? What evidence do you have? Do you mind sharing it?

    • @aanakrukavi
      @aanakrukavi Рік тому

      @@farazmuzaffar8823 It is part of Al Taqqiya.

  • @vasukinagabhushan
    @vasukinagabhushan Рік тому

    This is not the right time for India to normalise relations with Pakistan.

  • @nandkishordeodhar5741
    @nandkishordeodhar5741 Рік тому

    Nandkishor Deodhar
    Mr pervezji has put forth necadteuth of present pakistan can Pakistan come out problem s of mullas moullavis madarse military corrupt politicians and extremism and financial problems

  • @professoraftab7488
    @professoraftab7488 Рік тому

    Pervez Hoodbhoy is annoyed because Imran introduced a curriculum based on religious ground,to which he dislike.

  • @shekar7367
    @shekar7367 Рік тому

    Dr. Hoodboy is ignorant of history of Pakistan. He is factually incorrect when he says that majority of Pakistani's are not converts. Infact your founder Mr.Jinnah himself is descendent of a hindu grandfather and so are descendents of the Bhutto family. Majority of the Pakistani's have been converted to Islam by force with the conquests of northwestern parts of the sub continent by the muslim invaders from persia, central asia and afganistan. Today majority of Pakistani's are led to imagine that their heritage is linked to other cultures other than that of the subcontinent ??. How realistic is that ?. Prof Hoodboy also has his own anti India bias when he fails to ackowledge the achievements of ancient India's contribution to sciences and mathematics etc. Modern India's achievements are no less...just look up the list of Indian origin nobel prize winnners in differnet fields !!. Prof Hoodboy looks depresssed and dejected at the fate of Pakistan and the way it turned out. He is spot on when he said that it all comes to education, education and education !!!. He is doing his best by staying in Pakistan and trying to change the system and its narrative. His pain at the turn of events is understandable. I kind of relate to Prof Hoodboy's view about the academic standards of Pakistani universities. I, as a graduate student in the US once had a lab partner from Pakistan (Lahore) who was a PhD student and she hardly knew the basics of calculus needed for calulations in enzyme kinetics in industrial fermentations course, she is ignorant of the basic process and methodology of conducting typical lab experiments. Pakistan and Pakistani's are cut out from the same fabric of north Indian culture, but the over emphasis on religion and dogmatic thinking ruined Pakistan economically and politically. For heavens sake de-emphasize religion and do not bring religion into everything. Afterall its a metphysical subject and abstract and human beings are not supposed to kill each other with it.

  • @MDVaashir
    @MDVaashir Рік тому +1

    What wrong in learning Qur'an & Islam ??

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому +4

      if u read quran atmost u can become hate spewing maulvi or truck driver

    • @latchmansukhdeo4896
      @latchmansukhdeo4896 Рік тому +2

      Everything

    • @gopalramanathan7062
      @gopalramanathan7062 Рік тому

      What’s wrong? What’s wrong in being brainwashed to follow a cult like Nazism, Fascism or Communism ⁉️ Islam and Koran is worse🛑

    • @MagD12361
      @MagD12361 Рік тому +1

      U cannot code using verses in the Quran.

    • @11pke
      @11pke Рік тому

      you learn not to think or use your brain. Just turn into simpletons

  • @DemocraticnewsroomGulshanKumar

    INDIAN media landscapes are much to very much diverse than USA UK, European countries
    1lakh newspapers ,400 Plus TV channels, telecast, broadcast publish news in more than 100 Plus languages
    Which doesn't exist in entire world

  • @ashalivarma4623
    @ashalivarma4623 Рік тому +8

    Of course Hindus converted! What are you saying.

    • @gopalramanathan7062
      @gopalramanathan7062 Рік тому

      Even the Professor would indulge in prevarication! The truth is the spread of madrassa whether in Papisthan, India or elsewhere is sign of the spread of cancer called Islam, make no mistake. It needs irradiation to be rid of it‼️

  • @liebedich7680
    @liebedich7680 Рік тому +6

    As in Pakistan, Laloo & co. And Mamta Bano tried similar tactics in education in West Bengal and Bihar. This is the corrupt mind's line of least resistance with maximising Mollah in corrupt practices. This is not peculiar to Pakistan, it has something to do with venality of politician, to work for the lowest common denominator: the target segments shall be the madarasa kids, Other non muslim deprived classes; now depraved by the politicians such as Kejruddin, with all sorts of freebies.
    So these kids when grown up, shall be masters in whatsapp, Tick-tock, or even twitter, and then end up becoming truck drivers, toilet cleaners, airport janitors and provide bulk of the critical mass for shaheen baug type stirs!

    • @gopalramanathan7062
      @gopalramanathan7062 Рік тому

      Those who are desperate for power sell anything to get it including Mamata, MK Stalin, Lallu Prasad, Sashi Tharoor, Pinnarayi Vijayan, ….. the list is long. Few have the nerve:
      ua-cam.com/video/55x9ndmkUpA/v-deo.html

  • @prasad7553
    @prasad7553 Рік тому +2

    The main issue is oversized army. Army eats away a major share of budget. Generals control a large part of economy and donot pay taxes. Pakistan claims of Arab lineage one time and Turkish another time.

  • @ashalivarma4623
    @ashalivarma4623 Рік тому +3

    Sajid Mir and Khalistanis and TLP are supported by the Pak Army.

  • @agrippa-theskeptic9346
    @agrippa-theskeptic9346 Рік тому +2

    There is nothing called South Asia.
    This is a term coined by Pis’stani academics in USA to break free from India.
    We Indians call it the Indian subcontinent!

  • @shashankjp88
    @shashankjp88 Рік тому +2

    As per Pervez Hoodboy, Pakistanis were not converted but were Muslims originally. 😮
    What has he been smoking recently

    • @msdolly6101981
      @msdolly6101981 Рік тому

      Vego effect 😅

    • @shashankjp88
      @shashankjp88 Рік тому

      @PavitShokeen8 Not true, China was ravaged by Chenges Khan and was plundered by Japan during WW2. They have been ahead of India for a couple of decades (maybe another 2 decades in future) since they got a great leader early on in the mid and end of the 19th century
      But calling Chinese civilization greater than India can only come from an idiotic mind that grew up in a Hinduphobic atmosphere
      Read about Bhodidhrarma or accounts of Tibetian monks who were present during the Bhudda's generation and immediately after that. Pervez hoodboy is no better than a mullah when it comes to such points, he is vomiting his opinions without doing any reading or study

  • @somnathde8680
    @somnathde8680 Рік тому +6

    Indians should learn, how a country is destroyed due to overdose of religious sentiments.
    Dr Hoodbhoy explained so well.

    • @shashankjp88
      @shashankjp88 Рік тому

      Overdose of a religion stuck in medieval times. Use some brain rather than following a book or a youtube video blindly

    • @anjan67
      @anjan67 Рік тому +1

      There is no comparison. Please don’t insult us by comparing Islam with sanatam Dharma!!!

    • @salimalvi5178
      @salimalvi5178 Рік тому

      ReLigion is legion/gang to grab REgal political power. It was created first by Romans & then after seeing Roman success, Arabs created second legion/gang. These two gangs destroyed natives all over and enslaved/colonized them. Dharma is organic and native.
      China was smart - it killed these two legions wearing burkha of Marxism and even they threw away that burkha in 1978. China treats MohMadism as Mental disease and so puts MohMadden males in concentration camps like mental asylums and uses MohMadden wombs to breed Haan Chinese kids

    • @salimalvi5178
      @salimalvi5178 Рік тому

      In Sanskrit and any Indian languages there is no word Aryan. There is word Arya and so derivatives like AryaPutra and AryaPutri. Arya means noble, not Angrezi Noble Class, Royalty or Bible-walas but someone with pure & high character. Aryan word was invented by East India Company in 1830s just as Neo East India Company, the real establishment of the West, invented proof of Saddam's Weapons of Mass Destruction to attack EyeRaq & lynch Saddam in 2003. Real History or Itihas is written on the DNA to make RNA. Al Baqistanis have the same DNA as Dharmic Indians but their RNA is different as MohMadism makes them cut their own roots and kneel/Sazda in front of foreign brutes who did MohMadMasti on their Abbujans & TeresaKhudai on their Ammijans with their 4skinless Marxes. There is no Kashi, Mathura, Mumbai, Karveer, Ganga, Yamuna, Hastinapur near Ural mountain and anywhere else. Anglos had York in their land so they named 5 boroughs around Manhattan (a native American settlement) as New York. Dravid literally means wise ones who lived near great water source. By that definition most Dharmic folks are Dravid since they consider rivers and lakes sacred and live next to them. Adi Shankara who revived Sanatan Dharma and removed perverted practices of Boudh & Jain, e.g., extreme Gandy like Ahimsa and dereliction of Dharma/duty in pursuit of wordy Spirituality, came from Kerala, a place full of canals, rivers. So he was David.
      Known history of India is about 60,000 years but AbraHarami legions/gangs say that the universe was created by a male God 4000 years back. You decide who is rewriting It has. History is His Story who paid for writing it. Let Islam run its course and make Al Baqistan an ISIS land, after all Anglo's first ISIS (Islamic State of Indian Subcontinent) Baqistan was created using Khalifa Al Lundoni Chiknah Jinah, British created Last Popat Gandy & Khalifa Al Lootyani ConAngrez TaimuridMughal Fake-KaamRaid Bandit NoWheru just as second ISIS was created using Khalifa Al Baghdadi

    • @prakwandutta2861
      @prakwandutta2861 Рік тому

      When they are in minority they have forced you to be secular??
      We are not Abrahamic faith period.
      And indian are not dumb like pakistani..
      INDIA will be next Israel which have to fight Islamist with zero sympathy for Koranic nonsense (jihad, halaala, triple talak) and should implement NRC, UCC,mulana- wakaf free society.

  • @rpforyou
    @rpforyou Рік тому +1

    Dr. Hudbouy ji O pray god that your next birth should be in India. I belive there is next birth and that depends in your karma. I lostin you very keenly and can say yhat you aree a good humanbeeing with good karma. Dr. Sahab I am 3 years younger to you and MSC Physics

  • @SriRam-bv3gs
    @SriRam-bv3gs Рік тому +1

    😂😂 I don’t think Pakistanis should crib about religion being taught too much in school ,because country came into existence for Islam . Only thing they should worry that non implementation of Sharia law even after 76 yrs existence 😂😂

  • @abanishaan
    @abanishaan Рік тому

    15:25 Well Professor Hoodboy doesn't consider Pakistani Muslims are not converted Muslims.I disagree with Professor Hoodboy. Its well known fact that most of Indian subcontinent Muslims are converted Muslims. Pakistanis Muslims don't look like Arabs or West Asians. If go and check out our DNA then we are from same ancestors. Yes, you are right most of the Pakistani and Indian muslims are converted and their ancestors are Hindus. Due to that most of the Pakistani and Indians muslims use Hindu surnames like Bajwa, Cheema, Sandhu, Sethi, Malik, Rana, Naikoo, Rajput, Bhatt, Dhar, Guru, Shah, Raja, Patel, Butt, Talha, Gill, Watto, Wani, Suri etc etc. Many Pakistani Muslim consider them as Jats(Agriculturallist in north India)and Rajputs(Warrior class Hindus)

  • @KaramjitSingh-yv6tj
    @KaramjitSingh-yv6tj 5 місяців тому

    Hoodbhoy sir, love to hear you Because there is always something to learn from you. People like you are few in number in any country.I have a suggestion for Pakistan. Hoodbhoy is a treasure. A lot can be taken from the treasury for the country.I am from India respect you very much

  • @pittsburghpatrika1534
    @pittsburghpatrika1534 Рік тому

    The learned physics professor should confine himself to Pakistani history. Hie grasp of Indian demographics, ethos, cultural, literary history and philosophical traditions is shallow at best. The professor should know that india had 5000 years of history. Maybe he should travel in India without the help of his fellow travelers’ help and see India with an open mind. He should go beyond Lucknow, Bhopal , Delhi, Punjab, and travel to other parts and revise his ideas on India on the basis of his personal observations.

  • @NibaranNath-bx4ee
    @NibaranNath-bx4ee Рік тому

    No hung parliament but new and young faces will dominate the parliament and professor Pervez sir will be honoured to head the govt and pak will be put on a prosperous track to achieve the justice for all pakistani

  • @agrippa-theskeptic9346
    @agrippa-theskeptic9346 Рік тому

    36:03 … make borders in Kashmir soft …
    Ain’t happening!
    You don’t win anything at a table which you never head!

  • @mohammadazeem955
    @mohammadazeem955 Рік тому

    If can’t speak English well he can talk in Urdu. Dr speak Urdu as well.

  • @msdolly6101981
    @msdolly6101981 Рік тому

    Why soft borders? We dont want another 26/11

  • @ringuanung1876
    @ringuanung1876 10 місяців тому

    Hoodboy spoked truth...

  • @tfaqir
    @tfaqir Рік тому

    Sir you are trying to paint a target on your back. I love you and respect you and want you to be safe and happy so you can teach the generations to come. If you keep thinking this deep you'll be on antidepressants soon, if not already. Find a way to hide your anger and use Klingon guile.

  • @whatchamacallit78
    @whatchamacallit78 Рік тому +8

    I am a Hindu and an Indian.
    I have lived in to the times of Dr. Hoodboy. I have listened to him for so many years. It's a delight to hear him. I hope the almighty gives him more years than mine.

    • @media-rn6zc
      @media-rn6zc Рік тому +4

      Forgot to mention that he is islamic apologist

    • @priyamastibhati
      @priyamastibhati Рік тому +3

      He is very anti-India and especially anti-Hindu. May be he has his own limitations to appease the authorities.

    • @piyushdas079
      @piyushdas079 Рік тому +1

      YOU ARE NEITHER

    • @Bengalifirst
      @Bengalifirst Рік тому

      @@media-rn6zcwhat’s your qualifications again? Have I read any of your papers on science? Please don’t casually insult someone to support your argument it just shows how petty you are .

    • @Bengalifirst
      @Bengalifirst Рік тому +1

      @@priyamastibhatihe is an nationalist there is nothing wrong in it but he is an academic too !! Learn from it make yourself better .

  • @unknownindian6531
    @unknownindian6531 Рік тому

    Hè cleverly said by two we became almost 90% without explaining why

  • @madasurkrishnamurthy6056
    @madasurkrishnamurthy6056 Рік тому +1

    I am an Indian and respect you Hoodboy sir.Wish that you are safe in a country like Pakistan

    • @agrippa-theskeptic9346
      @agrippa-theskeptic9346 Рік тому

      Hoodbhoy is a pseudo Islamist, Hindu hating embittered old man!

    • @salimalvi5178
      @salimalvi5178 Рік тому +1

      He is not much different from English speaking Stephen College graduate Zia, Oxford graduate Jihadan Benezir her Abbu and Jinah.

    • @msdolly6101981
      @msdolly6101981 Рік тому +1

      Respect him for what? Because he speaks English? 😅

    • @agrippa-theskeptic9346
      @agrippa-theskeptic9346 Рік тому

      What’s a Hoodboy?
      Yaar, kam se kam naam toh theek se spell kar.
      Develop some sense of quality!

    • @agrippa-theskeptic9346
      @agrippa-theskeptic9346 Рік тому

      @PavitShokeen8 seriously?
      You must also be believing in Santa Claus!

  • @Bababakhtura
    @Bababakhtura Рік тому

    Thanks Junaid . It’s very interesting discussion ❤

  • @Bababakhtura
    @Bababakhtura Рік тому

    Salute to professor saheb

  • @vijaypoola8733
    @vijaypoola8733 Рік тому

    Make him education n science minister and give him freedom to set syllabus and policies. The future generations of Pakistan will thrive on the foundation he is going to lay down.

    • @salimalvi5178
      @salimalvi5178 Рік тому

      Osama was civil engineer. Most 9/11 terrorists were very well educated.

    • @msdolly6101981
      @msdolly6101981 Рік тому

      Paper degree doesn't change mindset

  • @pankajsrivastava7203
    @pankajsrivastava7203 Рік тому

    And doctor .. India does not enjoy Pakistani economic distress

    • @dineshshetty875
      @dineshshetty875 Рік тому +1

      Atleast I enjoy the bhikaaripan of Pakistan.. And I enjoy daily

  • @faheemiqbal6336
    @faheemiqbal6336 Рік тому

    Great hoodbay ❤❤

  • @gurinderjitnagra7199
    @gurinderjitnagra7199 Рік тому +2

    God bless you Parvez Sir lighthouse for South asia

  • @RHRHVL
    @RHRHVL Рік тому

    For such as esteemed intellectual am sadly unable to understand his short sighted perspective & view of Hindu civilization.