國外聲樂老師對比 張靚穎 黃霄雲 姚貝娜《我用所有報答愛》Vocal Coach Rozette Comparison Reaction
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 лис 2023
- Join this channel to get access to perks｜加入會員提前解鎖完整版影片:
/ @clubzeromedia
*Performance videos and instrumentals may have been censored due to copyright concerns. Please visit our Bilibili for full-versions of the reaction: space.bilibili.com/7295246
Stayed tuned for more professional vocal coach reaction videos!
Follow Rozette on UA-cam: @RozetteSaaangs
Follow Rozette on TikTok: / rozettesaaangs
Artist Booking: clubzeromedia.com/rozette
#zhoushen #vocalcoach #reactionvideo #张靓颖 #黄霄云 #姚贝娜 #我是歌手 #iamsinger - Розваги
三位歌手都非常优秀，演唱的时候，各自有自己的风格。不过，最让我感动的，还是黄霄云，只要了解她演唱这首歌的背景都知道，当时她正被全网网暴，处于人生最困难的时候，尽管如此，她还是用这首来表达了对这个舞台的热爱，对支持她的粉丝的感谢。最后一点，她的版本的结尾，是目前为止，个人认为最惊艳的版本。
声乐老师真的很厉害，很专业
張靚穎的原唱版本無可替代
投张靓颖一票。因为看完视频，只记住了张靓颖的声音。
那是因为你耳朵太浅
我猜喜欢 张 的是因为她的歌声最有女人味。符合这首歌。❤
@@user-hc3hv7lc9z 张靓颖的声音确实比较有辨识度的，不论技巧
張靚穎應該是選秀出道的天花板了，尤其在那個沒有修音，科技等等的白金年代。
她還有無數個神級現場值得老師看看！報答愛只是她一個不起眼一面。熱推All of me, 畫心，一路之下, loving you爵士版等等。
哈哈 我也推薦了一路之下！畢竟是連JJ都起立鼓掌尖叫的表演
過譽了。張靚穎很好但還沒到神級，在一些細節上黃霄雲處理的更細膩
她唱 時間都去哪了，也很棒, 改編情感都是。
我也熱推all of me。看到知音人留言真開心，
@@yen2948 我也留言推薦了時間都去哪兒了哈哈
@@yxuen3051 Fifth Element的歌她唱得還不夠神麼… 黃曉雲確實很厲害，從小就學習專業美聲，科班出身。張靚穎實話說嗓音條件確實沒有黃曉雲好，有時belting得有些費力。但張是無師自通的，敢於挑戰，又有那麼多經典作品。她也是很少見的低音渾厚，頭聲超高的同時又很柔美的歌手。只要她不要勉強地去衝很高的強混，她就很神啊
为什么不给老师多看几个张靓颖 她有太多神级现场可以react了🥹🥹🥹🥹🥹
姚貝娜的天賦和技巧都已經是無可挑剔了，但如果喜歡她的人應該有注意到她似乎是想透過歌傳達她融入後的感情。印象裡她幾乎沒有用炫技或浮誇的表演方式，反而像是讓歌聲把聽者帶入她營造的情境。其他的流行歌手好像沒人選擇這樣的方式，而這是我最喜歡姚貝娜的原因。只是她離開的太早了，沒有能帶給大家更多的好歌。
😢😢😢😢
然后 那英还选了首要她炫技的歌 决赛 真的造孽
@@Peachu_n_Goma_Home 🤣🤣🤣 黃明志有首歌就叫 "飆高音"
其实这位老师听出来了姚贝娜的技巧和能力很扎实，并且感觉出她受过的训练。
唱歌的技巧的作用是什么？是为歌曲服务的，是为了更好的表达歌曲深意，烘托歌者的感情。不过普通老百姓确实只要吃大饼油条就足够满足，也容易理解。什么复杂的料理方法，素材等说了也不懂，也不会感兴趣。只要有酱油，盐，糖和麻辣烫就行。非常直接通俗，容易感动到。
很喜歡老師跟旁邊的畫外音一起討論的感覺，更豐富了😍😍
三位都是實力派都唱的很棒，老師忍不住都要提一下周深，超可愛❤，是粉絲都懂～
老师也太神了吧！能听出来是电影的片尾曲！请收下我的膝盖🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤，太崇拜老师了！😊
張靚穎有唱過第五元素的The diva dance，有官方版 非常精彩！大推 ，黃霄雲官方版也有唱過 很適合出一集一同講評
周深版本有英文和日文字幕，老師便會明白這首歌的意思。而周深在交響樂團的伴奏下唱出感情，使人陶醉其中，音樂家譚盾更高度讚揚周深。當然這三位女歌手也很出色。
我就最喜欢周深唱的版本😊
周深唱出另一種不同于三位女性的情懷.
黃霄雲仿彿天使般的歌聲
金燦燦的吟唱
就像從天界傳遞到人間的仙音
真的做到了餘音繞樑三日不絕於耳的境界
也只有她能讓我驚嘆不已了
+1
可惜了沒有加入周深的live版本，雖然不是女生，但感情和技術甚至更好，尤其是他最後唱的8個“風雨”，每一個都不同。在唱功都很高的歌手中，理解歌詞準確表達的高唱商更重要，與文化修養和閱歷也有關
黃霄雲 天才級歌手
如果加上周深更讓人期待⋯
28:10
老師真的為她聲音感到驕傲
也為她的離開感到哀傷
我相信老師最真實的反應
雖然基於專業評判票投張珍
但心裡愛的那把聲音其實是黃霄雲
聽到高弱結尾那邊
倒抽一口氣後連續的讚嘆
就跟我初聽這首歌時的反應一模一樣
老師妳入坑了！！！
This is truth！
老师其实比谁都懂，原唱赋予这首歌的灵魂，后来者模仿的再牛也还在原唱者当初营造的框架里。黄霄云技术方面其实不比张靓颖差，各有最擅长的地方。但她目前的音乐人格还不够健全，还处于模仿和摸索的阶段，慢慢来吧，希望她越来越好，光是会唱太可惜了。
這三位是我最愛的中國女歌手前三名
黄霄云技巧最好
张靓颖姚贝娜則是有自己的特色
面包當時2O歲，能和兩大前輩比，已很榮幸了，好不過她們是正常的，不過。。。。。。有的是時間，她現在不斷的進步，盼未來😊
終於可以看到老師對這首歌的reaction ✌️!by the way,姚貝娜是我非常欣賞的歌手，可惜天妒英才😔
我用所有、所有、所有报答爱，所以张靓颖的版本我才能体会到所有。
好专业，就是电影夜宴主题曲
老师耳朵好利，能听出姚贝娜的技巧和方法更“老派”--她是学院派扎实学出来的。
三位都是很棒的歌手，但是周深的版本是我个人最爱！
这首歌周深和交响乐团合作的现场也是可圈可点， 老师其实也可以评一下的。
最爱周深的版本，最有感情！！
超喜歡這首黃霄雲的版本❤
我最喜歡姚貝娜的演繹，情感更細膩，更打動人
想聽老師評價盛夏光年,想看陳冰、艾薇、林憶蓮跟袁婭維神仙打架XD
Great idea! 5
这个好
连续看了很多期节目了，不得不说，屏幕左边的这位男生，真的是在过程中没有学到什么。已经好几次在被老师问不管是歌手还是歌曲的背景资料时一问三不知了。如果这是老师提项目，老师找乐曲，作为上课一部分地现场拿出来给左右两位听的话，当然情有可原。可是，看起来这男生是在这个项目里起了很主导作用的，歌曲看起来都是他找的，大部分时间里都是他在以“我更了解”的身份在介绍一些东西，可往往说得很表面。而且不是专业技能或歌唱技巧/知识方面的“不知道”，而是对项目内容没有做好基本的准备。
I have watched many episodes of the show in a row, have to say, the guy on the left of the screen really seems didn’t learn anything in the process of doing this project. There have been several times that Coach asked about the singer or the background information of the song, he continued to be "i don know". If this was part of their class/coaching: the teacher prepared the clips, and plays it out for the two students on the spot to listen to as part of coaching, of course it would be excusable. However, it seems that this boy has played a leading role in this project. He seems to be the one choosing and preparing the singers/clips; most of the time, he introduces info in a way of "I know better", but often It's very superficial. And it’s not “not knowing” in terms of professional skills or singing skills/knowledge, but rather a lack of basic preparation for the project content.
同感 希望男生可以多做一些功课 除了把视频找出来之外 多做一点点 当然也很感谢他的开始
同感
This is an OST of a movie called 夜宴.
老师蛮厉害的，听这首歌会想到周深，事实上周深和作曲的谭盾老师有合作过这首歌。应该有改编过, 周深用歌声，衬托整个交响乐团的演奏。(而且那场演唱还翻唱了Coco的月光爱人 。) 要是这三个版本再加上周深的版本会更棒。😊
可惜沒有放周深的.
老师感觉很准，我记得这是《夜宴》的主题曲，一部中国的莎士比亚式的悲剧电影。
姚贝娜的去世真的是所有人都觉得惋惜的。
三个都是很厉害的歌手，但是我更加喜欢黄霄云的版本
我也認為原唱最好。張的音樂技巧、情感及戲劇張力都拿捏的非常完美，當然這是在她無懈可擊的歌聲基礎上。有時候在一首曲子裡塞入過多的元素，可能是高超的歌唱技巧可能是過多的情感表達，會讓人感覺有點煽情有些過，聽起來感覺有點負擔有點膩，聽不完全曲會想關掉。
看到这段时评，非常感动。这位老师的评点非常精准。
老師心情好好，看得出好興奮🥳
Hope that there will be reaction for Zhou Shen too as he sang this song with the orchestra conducted by Mr. Tan Dun (a winner of Academy Award for Best Original Score).
Yes, best version of this song !
It's just so weird that the guy next to the host (I suppose he is Chinese???) made so many wrong comments about this song. This song is the theme song of The Banquet and is composed by Tan Dun, a Chinese born American composer who receives Grawemeyer Award, Academic Award and Grammy Award, and yes Jane sang this song during the Grammy Award ceremony as well. The music is quite western style and of course you will feel more easy to connect to.
这三个都是我的爱❤❤❤
This is for a movie on the end!!! Rozette is a master!!!
周深也有唱這首歌喔
跟譚盾合作的，只是我覺得收音不是很好，那場也唱了大魚。
Everytime I hear the singing of 姚贝娜 (The third singer), I can't hold back my tears. She was such an angel of a singer. Sad to see her leave so early :(
这首歌真的好好听！
Gosh, first time to listen to a song, and it makes me cry 😭😭😭
So astute, Disney vibe for 1st singer.
周深也唱过现场😂
依舊期待張惠妹amei的reaction ❤️❤️
Very pro. Comment , great
老师是个善良的人😊😊
终于看见张靓颖
This song is indeed the ending theme of the movie
老师和我一样都好爱黄霄云❤
應該給老師看看張靚穎同年在我是歌手唱的all of me
把周深唱的版本一起听就好啦！超喜欢深深唱的，但这几位歌手的唱功也很不错的👍
She’s so smart🙈the song is indeed from a movie. 夜宴is the Chinese name of the film.
Rozette Jane was the original singer for this song, which was also the theme song for 2006 movie The Banquet夜宴 starring the famous Zhang Zi Yi章子怡 from Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon卧虎藏龙.
Also this song which Translate to "I Repay Love With All I Have" was written by famous Oscar award winner Tan Dun谭盾。
下次聽姚的魚，那首每聽必哭。還有也許明天，可以跟林憶蓮和張惠妹合唱版一齊做。
老师前面17秒的动作突然想起台湾的董明轩，但是老师这里的才是正版的，美！
这首歌的作曲水平太高了
《我用所有報答愛》是电影《夜宴》的主题曲
哈哈，she is dam accurate!!
下集预告是姚贝娜哟，好期待
想看老師聽更多姚貝娜唱的作品
应该听一听周深的现场版本，跟交响乐团合作的现场，真的非常棒
+1,周深唱得好有感情！
怎么没有放上周深与交响乐团合作的live 版本一起做reaction 呢？😢
The composer of this song is Tan Dun, a very famous classical music composer. He also got the oscar award in original music.
it's a theme song from a movie, it's a lovely movie about unrequited love and complicated relationships, plot loosely based on hamlet, but in an ancient china setting
这么多年了，还是最爱靓颖❤❤
像迪士尼音乐主要是这首歌的编曲和音程是在国外学习音乐的世界音乐大家谭盾的作品，属于宏大和爱的主题的大歌曲 所以老师的感觉没错
Second one really snow-white style singing . Birds would fly down to listen her singing
推薦 All of me 張靚穎，我是歌手中唱的
夜宴的主题曲，谭盾谱曲的，获得香港紫金奖，最佳电影歌曲.也是我最喜欢一首歌，我也经常做横向比较
姚貝娜是沒有時間啊，她09年才離開文工團，11年乳癌，14年再復發，她根本沒時間進步，沒時間改變，沒時間適應調整自己的唱法。
Totally agree with your ranking, Zhang brings us to her world while Ghost just show us the song only!
在bilibili和油管反复横跳的我发现这次Rozette老师自己的正片歌曲放的不一样欸！不过自然的和华丽的我都喜欢 ♥
It’s the theme song for the Chinese movie “Night Banquet” I like the 2nd singer better bcoz she brings out her emotions and takes me right into the story the moment I heard her voice.
张靓颖在讲故事。黄霄云在用这首歌回应当时铺天盖地的针对她的网暴，同时告别舞台。
周深在谭盾的音乐会上唱得很棒啊
深深唱這首歌的視頻我有看到很棒。
老師真的好專業!!! 這首曲子確實是一電影片尾XDD 電影名是
同一首歌，但姚貝納唱出來時我，有點泛淚。被感動哭了。個人是覺得姚貝納唱出的歌讓我想像出更多的畫面，唱歌我感覺就像一齣戲（電影），看人怎去詮釋。
讓老師聽聽靚穎的第五元素the diva dance🎉
和 Rozette 一样，碰到好歌好的曲子都想看看周深会是怎样诠释的
真的敲碗姚贝娜cover的《也许明天》，谭维维张惠妹林忆莲曾一鸣都有节目cover过
I got to know Xiaoyun by playing the gacha game honkai impact 3rd. She sang one of the soundtracks (Oracle). And after that i absolutely fell in love with her voice and can't get enough.
個人認為這些人唱的體悟不同，有些是遺憾 有些是離別 有些是告別（威~
推荐歌曲-谭维维(乌兰巴托的夜)
JaneZhang is a really good singer, I think you should do a reaction on 天下無雙 also by JaneZhang(】張靚穎《天下無雙). I was looking for a live version of that performance, and for many years I couldn't find it, but there is now. It was used as the end credit song to Return of the Condor Heroes, and I just thought it was hauntingly beautiful. It really fits with the fantasy element of the show, and I wanted to see a live version so bad because the recorded version is just so ethereal and unreal. I dont mean it sounds fake, it just sounds so clean and knowing how she sounds live, I'm just super curious how she's going to pull it off live. Also XiaoYun(Ghost) also did a cover of it. So you can do both in 1 video.
Personally I think as a song I would close my eyes to listen to, having understood the lyrics, I prefer YoBeiNa's version, I like where hers is less "dramatic" I thought it felt somewhat warmer than the other two.
But for a movie soundtrack I can imagine JansZhang's version is better, as in accompanied by the visual and the story, because when you're watching the experience is a bit different when you are somewhat already moved by the story and already have a visual. I would think the purpose of hers was to accompany the visual elements that's already made, and I think it's perfect for that.
But to be honest XiaoYun's while impressive, to me wasn't moving the way the other 2 did. It felt like it lacks that story telling part of it. I knows Rozette mentioned about singers being able to be touching is because they have good control on their vocal instruments. But I still feel there's a difference between a singer that truly understands and feeling the lyrics as they sing, and the ones that don't. For one there's the ones that have lived through it, and then there's another that while haven't leaved through it have the lyrics really resonate with them, and they are really feeling that lyrics as they sing. And Ghost isn't any of the two, I'm not saying she doesn't understand it on a deeper level, Im saying maybe she's feeling the music more than she's feeling the lyrics, you know?
這首歌表達的是：我們需要珍惜現在 珍惜眼前人 不要等到失去了 才想通了要去愛幫助自己的人。回憶相思已晚
还是最喜欢深深以及原唱张靓颖的版本。张靓颖的演绎如同老师所说更具戏剧性，有个人特色；而深深的演绎优美入耳、动情入心，总是不由自主地沉浸其中，不会想到什么唱功好牛高音好厉害之类的，就是单纯的享受单纯的感动，耐听、听不腻，完全只为歌曲本身的最好呈现最恰当表达服务。黄霄云的演绎感觉嗓音好听、唱功好好，就是无法被打动，也没觉得有什么个人特点；与黄霄云同龄的女歌手反而是刘柏辛(Lexie)印象更深刻，唱功不输，富于感染力，个人风格强烈
唱功不输是认真的吗..........刘柏辛确实很有风格但是完全是更现代（更production-focused）的歌手啊。唱功和黄霄云比你能说出“不输”我只能说你真的不懂唱功
最怕有人把自己想法和主观当成唱功或者是演绎高低的点评😅 黄霄雲从一开始就为了唱自己，张珍如果唱的是电影里的爱，那她唱的是自己的爱 对舞台和一直支持她的爱 单纯如此而已，也贡献了只有自己能唱的版本 最磅磗版本，这版给张靓颖唱她恐怕支撑不了。
@@khaisiang1806 不太明白第一句。我想说的是，唱歌不是炫技，技术是手段、是为歌曲表达服务的，仅有技术还不够，就像画匠与画家不是一回事。作为一名听众，好听、美感、感动、沉浸感都有，耐听听不腻，华语歌手只有深深，个人感受。
@@xia8900 这点专业歌手谁不懂？我看歌手舞台上没人真正意义上的“炫技“，并不是所有歌风格是注重美感和沉浸感的。有些歌是为了震撼和爆发，比如战歌类的大歌。我现在说的这点是音乐有很多类型，不一定会表达同样的，也有可能经过改编成不同的表达方式。
@@khaisiang1806 震撼和爆发也能兼具美感。另外一首歌不可能从头到尾都是震撼和爆发，所谓起承转合。深深的几首偏震撼/爆发/气势磅礴的大歌个人也反复听、不厌倦，华语的，其他歌手的就不行
簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍
遇廣告看完看🈵
我等太久了 太期待了 omg
Jane Zhang is definitely one of the best c-pop female vocalists who’s also popular. Can’t wait to see more of your reaction to Jane’s performances.
Recommendations:
- 一路之下 (she switched to a super high head voice suddenly that made a lot of jaws dropped; this can be compared with the original singer, Zhang Jie’s performance. Jie is considered one of the best male singers in mainland too.)
- 时间都去哪儿了 (she rearranged the song and added Young and Beautiful by Lana Del Ray, and she sang some whistle tones in this)
- Fifth Element’s song from the movie (the opera part’s so beautiful and easy to listen too since she’s not classically trained)
If you prefer making comparisons, I’d definitely recommend comparing Fifth Element’s song sung by Jane Zhang, Dimash (male), and Ghost (Xiaoyun)
I have to mention that JJ (one of the most reviewed singers in this channel) was amazed by Jane’s 一路之下 that he stood up and jaw dropped too lol
+天下無雙
哇 我要去听看看学习了，whistle note my highest note is G6, 36 years old female here. 🙂唱 她的 如果这不是爱情 被说过好听很有女人味。
再来推荐一个张靓颖自己的歌（偶然间翻到），这个肯定是无修音现场：ua-cam.com/video/yLKob08x2-A/v-deo.htmlsi=k2CsPJjl9iK58_v0
另外一边多了个小姐姐🤩
「My only 」
「The lonely goatherd 」
These two songs from 「Zhou Shen」are very “Yodel “～～
I like 「My only」so so much～～
非常讚同諸君看法！最希望加入周深。
怀念姚贝娜，接受她的器官捐赠者，为她延续生命活得更精彩！
癌症去世还能捐献器官啊
Highly recommend Jane ZHANG’s version of “ All of me”
Ms. Rozette often asks questions about the background of the song or the singer while doing reaction, but it seems the host or the person behind the screen often didn't do enough homework about it
好想看老師聽A-Lin唱歌的影片！
想听老师点评谭维维的《乌兰巴托的夜》