@@RexTaxi NO! i legit wanna see icecube written well. I want to see what icecube can be like without freesmart, without book, icecube could lowkey be a fan favorite if the writers cared enough to flesh her out
I think a cool way for jacknjellify to do an all-stars season would be if they announced the new season and had voting like they did at the start of BFDIA so that viewers could vote for who they wanted to join the season (with the benefit of all these characters having screentime), and the twenty or so characters with the most votes could be fairly labeled the most popular contestants, worthy of all-stars.
Everyone in BFDI season 1 can be considered an all-star(other than spongey cuz he’s too fat), so think of an all-star as anyone’s perception of the characters
I can understand what you're trying to say with Clock, but I feel like someone who was forgotten by both the characters, fans, and writers for half a season, then being an early boot in the other isn't great for an all-star
I’d replace Clock with Cake. I know, my favorite character is Cake, I get it, but he might do better than Clock, not only is he more worthy for all stars considering he made it farther than clock, but he also has a past with Loser making it perfect for being involved in the Winner and Loser Arc. If we don’t replace with Clock, I’d replace him with Grassy.
@@BLUEFLAME-xc2kr they are the same season just that people quit the game mid season meaning td and pencil are the only ones to have appeared in every season
i think the allstarts should be the people that made it to the final 10 in seasons so. firey, leafy, bubble, flower, spongy, rocky, ice cube, david, pencil, tennis ball, ruby, book, bomby, nickel, coiny, fries, pin, needle, taco, blocky, woody, lollipop, teardrop, and gelly boy!
I think dora should be in allstars because she had so much potential to bfdi and bfb And she wasn't getting that much screen time and she might be a strong character
I would change clock and nickel for black hole and tree, seeing as they are fan favorites and death pact being arguably the fan fav team. It needs more representatives. They could also give something for fanny to do and i think it would be interesting to see them on a team that doesnt agree with their morals whatsoever.
Contestants I would add: Marker, Woody, Blocky, Pen, Eraser, 8-Ball, Firey Jr, and Nonexistenty. Firey Jr could have a potential friendship with Firey and finally interact with him for the first time! 8-Ball could finish his arc with GB and maybe use his better leadership skills from TPOT 11 to assist his team! Nonexisty was literally rejected THREE TIMES to debut. He didn’t have enough votes to join in BFDI, he had enough votes to join BFDIA but because he “isn’t present” he couldn’t join. He couldn’t join TPOT because apparently 41+1= 0 (He still counts as a contestant because why wouldn’t he be up for debuting in BFB 16) so this would be a great opportunity for him to really shine!
Regarding loser, I can see what you’re saying(and I’d probably take the once in a lifetime thing too) but you have to remember that loser proceeded to completely cut contact and ghost winner for…ever, which is still messed up considering they built losercake together, to winner, it felt like loser abandoned them and never looked back, not regretting anything. Even if I took the chance, it’s unrealistic I would never talk to best friend again. Other than that, nice video!
@AnimatinObjects I'm pretty sure he probably thought Winner was doing the same because he went on without him, so he got too scared and cut contacts with Winner
I think Blocky should join BFDI allstars because he never joined BFDIA or IDFB, he does amazing pranks like trying to help Woody become like him and he was also eliminated 3 times in BFDI and BFB and also he was the star of the show and he changed so he was a bully then in 2023 he was kind of nice to some people so thats why Blocky should join
RIGHT!! she literally placed 3rd in tfi, placed 7th in bfdi, placed 12th in bfdia and has even competed in the MOST episodes out of any bfdi contestant how is she not here
heres my elimination order of my characters there’s 24 contestants and there are reasons so here it is 25th place: flower: her teammate pillow apparently wanted to con her out. so she wanted to disguise as flower! she went to the other team helping them. people thought it was flower so it was a 3-7-2-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0 24th cloudy: he was really obsessed with collecting things. and he collected a really strange and wierd item. SO THEY VOTED HIM OUT. 23rd+22nd: pen & pin. so i can not explain how this can go down!! 21st: donut. donut can be an unlikeable character but really unlikeable is where people cross the line!!!! 20th: match. you can guess for yourself rejoin: cloudy. he bribed four to let him rejoin for the cure to solve X’s value. little did four know, it’s fake 19th+18th ruby pencil ruby was bickering and throwing a fit because pencil yelled at her. and pencil was mean. very mean! last elimination before the new 4 teams, 17th puffball. puffballs evil plan caused massive damage to the team. now the four new teams!! the new teams are Culcy chickens Licking lemons Criminal clams and Lot Locks on the culcy chickens are winner, cloudy, yellow face, and naily on the Licking Lemons are taco, basketball, grassy, and fries! i’ll finish the teams tomorrow pls let it slide this time PLEASE
I like this, but I'd say replace nickel with woody since he was very loved and still is and now has a chance to maybe redeem himself from the whole "pranking" arc he had. Also, about loser, I agree, he was very good in bfb, but the writers made him so egotistical and selfish after he rejoined (unfairly, by the way) as you can see in his elimination episode and previous post-split episodes. Him abandoning Winner wasn't that bad in itself, but the thing that pushed me over the edge was that nobody really knew winner since loser never gave him credit, which is messed up since loser cake was invented by the two of them. He is kinda overhated, but I still really don't like him. I think here would be an okay season for him because of arc potential though.
Also there should be six more: Stapy: He could redeem Foldy Foldy: Foldy could start targeting FreeSmart Book: Why not? Rocky: … Blocky: Friendship with Woody Woody: Friendship with Blocky
I think Tree should of been in instead of Clock. Clock is extremely unpopular, was literally DEAD for a good portion of BFB, is forgton by BOTH the viewers and contestants. Tree is extremely popular, is well-liked, could have an arc with Fanny, and Tree is just a better pick.
I swear this guy is making reasonable (for lack of better word) reasons and the only thing i see in the comments is "what about insert character" like wtf
Bomby I feel SHOULD be in an all stars season as he is the first recommend character, plus, like every character except pin, got a major glow up in BFDIA. Also I feel like cake has the most unused potential by far out of every character, so I feel like at least one less popular character deserves to be in it in order to gain popularity and I think it should be cake. (I just love cake ok)
8-Ball has a very large amount of unused potential. (I just love 8-Ball ok) But honestly Cake should’ve been around for a couple more episodes before getting eliminated because I was pretty shocked to see him go.
I feel like Balloony should be in there, he had so much potential with all of the sacrifices he did to the team in BFB pre split, and he got like no screentime, he had an unfair elemination with all of the other characters in the team are popular or overrated, ans plut just give the boy a chance, he needs screentime fr how little he was in BFB
i wish yellow face was here i can see why you didnt put him in but people still think yellow face is racist or maybe they're racist and dont like yellow
My all star cast: Bfdi: Pen Eraser Blocky Snowball Firey Bubble Leafy Pencil Match Teardrop Pin Coiny Flower Bfdia: Gelatin Ruby Book Fries Puffball Bomby Yellow face Bfb and tpot: Grassy Eggy Lightning Black hole Tree Winner Price tag Lollipop Tell me if i missed anyone!
Ehhh I don’t think fries is meant for all stars, I think spongy would be there considering the Cary likes spongy and because I feel like they would figure out a way to do something with him. I don’t think match would be in it either and I don’t think Ruby or bubble would be in it
My cast for BFDI all stars are: David, Dora, Yellow Face, Roboty, Robot Flower, Firey, Rocky, TB And Purple Face I think they would have a good interaction
Maybe you should replace grassy with rocky as even as much as i hate both, (i hate rocky more) he actually fits in there more, and hes also been in every season so far and i feel like rocky just fits *better* in allstars than grassy
I think it’s better to have a fresh season without the veterans or anyone that competed like the failed debuters or even some reccomended character a season all to non veterans. Or just all the characters that haven’t competed
Semi well made video. Dont get me wrong i enjoyed it but some picks just dont make sense. Like im sorry but an all stats season should have contestands who performend really good in atleast one season. Characters like Clock,Match,Loser,Puffball,Winner and Nickel besides being fans of some of them (im a huge Match and Puffball enjoyer.) Never really performed that good in any season if i have to honest.
Hot take but i hate the idea of an all star season. It's like the object show equivalent for football's european superleague (if you're a football (not the american one) fan and you get what i mean)
An Allstar season means all the characters are stars 🌟
Also subscribe and share your own allstar casts
First comment?!
Nah
might be dumb, but i think icecube could be nice in an allstar season. shes a good character imo
@@theaisocool I agree and book should be in it to
@@RexTaxi NO! i legit wanna see icecube written well. I want to see what icecube can be like without freesmart, without book, icecube could lowkey be a fan favorite if the writers cared enough to flesh her out
I think how they’d be selected is the past winners automatically join and the viewers would vote 16 oldies,and 8 newbies
Or.. past finalists!
I think a cool way for jacknjellify to do an all-stars season would be if they announced the new season and had voting like they did at the start of BFDIA so that viewers could vote for who they wanted to join the season (with the benefit of all these characters having screentime), and the twenty or so characters with the most votes could be fairly labeled the most popular contestants, worthy of all-stars.
Woody and Blocky not being here is a crime. Woody is my favorite character. And Blocky is cool.
Everyone in BFDI season 1 can be considered an all-star(other than spongey cuz he’s too fat), so think of an all-star as anyone’s perception of the characters
Woody is also my fav character, I would sell my kidney for him
@@6000.wow just wow
I can understand what you're trying to say with Clock, but I feel like someone who was forgotten by both the characters, fans, and writers for half a season, then being an early boot in the other isn't great for an all-star
I LOVE NICKEL I DIDNT EXPECT YOU TO PUT HIM IN YASSSS
Same
I’d replace Clock with Cake. I know, my favorite character is Cake, I get it, but he might do better than Clock, not only is he more worthy for all stars considering he made it farther than clock, but he also has a past with Loser making it perfect for being involved in the Winner and Loser Arc. If we don’t replace with Clock, I’d replace him with Grassy.
That would be nice
I completely agree beacause is such a fun helpful character
Cake is a girl
@@Sotiras_Friend no he’s not, check the wiki
Tpot cake is better than Tpot clock
Teardrop ain’t the only one to compete in every competition based season. As pre split and post split are combined
Post split and pre split are to different seasons
Pre: Battle for BFDI
Post: Battle for BFB
@@BLUEFLAME-xc2kr if that’s the case then TPOT isn’t season 5
@@BLUEFLAME-xc2kr instead battle for BFB is correct?
Ok ok shut up SHUT UP!
@@BLUEFLAME-xc2kr they are the same season just that people quit the game mid season meaning td and pencil are the only ones to have appeared in every season
Fries is one of my favourite characters so ye also I like the little goober nickel
i think the allstarts should be the people that made it to the final 10 in seasons so.
firey, leafy, bubble, flower, spongy, rocky, ice cube, david, pencil, tennis ball, ruby, book, bomby, nickel, coiny, fries, pin, needle, taco, blocky, woody, lollipop, teardrop, and gelly boy!
I’m surprised book did not make the cut
Like actually after BFDIA 14
Pretty sure that’s because Book is probably gonna make it to the finales in bfdia
Bfdia 14 made EVERY Bfdia character at the time, nickel went from B tier to S tier
My Bfdi all stars (yes bias alert 🚨)
Bfdi: firey, leafy, bubble,flower,Tennis ball, golf ball,teardrop,pin,coiny,pencil,snowball,match,needle
Bfdia:gelatin,fries,ruby,yellow face,puffball,bomby
Bfb:Lollipop, basketball, marker,Grassy
Tpot: winner
I think dora should be in allstars because she had so much potential to bfdi and bfb And she wasn't getting that much screen time and she might be a strong character
5:01 as one of those pin fans, i think pin should go next bfdia episode
Omg yay(I hope bubbleis in it)
I hope pencil is in it
And pin
(Bubble pencil and pin are my fav 3)
And I hope leafy will be in it.
OMG bubs your here too it’s fireboy
@@Buttersvr-ds7ft omg hi
Fries and Gelatin are also friends
they're more like frenemies
@ OK.
The trio of blocky,pen and eraser shouldve all made it,they all have lasted pretty long in the seasons they are in,except blocky but he rejoined.
Bfdi All-stars should be animated in either the tpot style or the bfdi is back style
I would change clock and nickel for black hole and tree, seeing as they are fan favorites and death pact being arguably the fan fav team. It needs more representatives. They could also give something for fanny to do and i think it would be interesting to see them on a team that doesnt agree with their morals whatsoever.
Clock for an all stars cast is an INSANE choice lol
Clock thinks he's on the team 💀
I think they should do a season with the hotel guests as the contestants, or maybe have the viewers vote on the cast like in bfdia
This is me before whaling the video, I hope you choose to add gelatin and ruby.
Contestants I would add: Marker, Woody, Blocky, Pen, Eraser, 8-Ball, Firey Jr, and Nonexistenty.
Firey Jr could have a potential friendship with Firey and finally interact with him for the first time!
8-Ball could finish his arc with GB and maybe use his better leadership skills from TPOT 11 to assist his team!
Nonexisty was literally rejected THREE TIMES to debut. He didn’t have enough votes to join in BFDI, he had enough votes to join BFDIA but because he “isn’t present” he couldn’t join. He couldn’t join TPOT because apparently 41+1= 0 (He still counts as a contestant because why wouldn’t he be up for debuting in BFB 16) so this would be a great opportunity for him to really shine!
Regarding loser, I can see what you’re saying(and I’d probably take the once in a lifetime thing too) but you have to remember that loser proceeded to completely cut contact and ghost winner for…ever, which is still messed up considering they built losercake together, to winner, it felt like loser abandoned them and never looked back, not regretting anything. Even if I took the chance, it’s unrealistic I would never talk to best friend again. Other than that, nice video!
@AnimatinObjects I'm pretty sure he probably thought Winner was doing the same because he went on without him, so he got too scared and cut contacts with Winner
@@CloudimationsOfficalso you're saying that loser went on without loser
Yes finnally I found a UA-camr in the os community who also thinks death pact is overrated oh my god yesssss thank the gods
I think Blocky should join BFDI allstars because he never joined BFDIA or IDFB, he does amazing pranks like trying to help Woody become like him and he was also eliminated 3 times in BFDI and BFB and also he was the star of the show and he changed so he was a bully then in 2023 he was kind of nice to some people so thats why Blocky should join
COME NOW TAKE THE STEP
What's an All-Star Season without My Bro Eraser?!!
Bro just made bfdi season 1 with a bit of recommended characters
Here would be my take on an all star cast (26 chars):
- Firey
- Leafy
- Bubble
- Flower
- Rocky
- Pencil
- Tennis Ball
- Blocky
- Snowball
- Coiny
- Golf Ball
- Teardrop
- Needle
- Pin
- Bomby
- Book
- Nickel
- Fries
- Puffball
- Fanny
- Tree
- Black Hole
- Basketball
- Grassy
- Robot Flower
- TV
nickel and clock over book is crazy
I feel like ice cube should have been here even though she’s underrated-
FR and she's prob gonna get out in tpot 14 just because of the bfdia 11 situation like bro it's not that deep
RIGHT!! she literally placed 3rd in tfi, placed 7th in bfdi, placed 12th in bfdia and has even competed in the MOST episodes out of any bfdi contestant how is she not here
lightning should have gotten in i mean he has a lot of potential
He was the 8th boot that’s not an all star
heres my elimination order of my characters
there’s 24 contestants and there are reasons so here it is
25th place: flower: her teammate pillow apparently wanted to con her out. so she wanted to disguise as flower! she went to the other team helping them. people thought it was flower so it was a 3-7-2-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0
24th cloudy: he was really obsessed with collecting things. and he collected a really strange and wierd item. SO THEY VOTED HIM OUT.
23rd+22nd: pen & pin. so i can not explain how this can go down!!
21st: donut. donut can be an unlikeable character but really unlikeable is where people cross the line!!!!
20th: match. you can guess for yourself
rejoin: cloudy. he bribed four to let him rejoin for the cure to solve X’s value. little did four know, it’s fake
19th+18th ruby pencil ruby was bickering and throwing a fit because pencil yelled at her.
and pencil was mean. very mean!
last elimination before the new 4 teams, 17th puffball. puffballs evil plan caused massive damage to the team.
now the four new teams!!
the new teams are Culcy chickens
Licking lemons
Criminal clams
and Lot Locks
on the culcy chickens are
winner, cloudy, yellow face, and naily
on the Licking Lemons are taco, basketball, grassy, and fries!
i’ll finish the teams tomorrow pls let it slide this time PLEASE
Just say the damn thing
Meh.
@@Crow-s5qfine i’ll edit it
I thought bro would pick fries first 💀
I like this, but I'd say replace nickel with woody since he was very loved and still is and now has a chance to maybe redeem himself from the whole "pranking" arc he had.
Also, about loser, I agree, he was very good in bfb, but the writers made him so egotistical and selfish after he rejoined (unfairly, by the way) as you can see in his elimination episode and previous post-split episodes. Him abandoning Winner wasn't that bad in itself, but the thing that pushed me over the edge was that nobody really knew winner since loser never gave him credit, which is messed up since loser cake was invented by the two of them. He is kinda overhated, but I still really don't like him. I think here would be an okay season for him because of arc potential though.
I’m shocked book, blocky and eraser didn’t make the cut
Me personally I would add Woody for more character development and end off his story
0:50 I love bubble so tysm :D
I hope donut will be a all stars he my favorite food character
For my bfdi all stars I just did people who make it to merge lol
Also there should be six more:
Stapy: He could redeem Foldy
Foldy: Foldy could start targeting FreeSmart
Book: Why not?
Rocky: …
Blocky: Friendship with Woody
Woody: Friendship with Blocky
U shall have asked in the BFDI II 2024 tour
I think Tree should of been in instead of Clock. Clock is extremely unpopular, was literally DEAD for a good portion of BFB, is forgton by BOTH the viewers and contestants. Tree is extremely popular, is well-liked, could have an arc with Fanny, and Tree is just a better pick.
I swear this guy is making reasonable (for lack of better word) reasons and the only thing i see in the comments is "what about insert character" like wtf
I think there are a lot of them from the first season
Hot take, cake could have had an amazing arc with him hating loser and finding new friends, like book! He was robbed
basically bfdi but bfb/tpot personalities
Bomby I feel SHOULD be in an all stars season as he is the first recommend character, plus, like every character except pin, got a major glow up in BFDIA. Also I feel like cake has the most unused potential by far out of every character, so I feel like at least one less popular character deserves to be in it in order to gain popularity and I think it should be cake. (I just love cake ok)
Yeah
8-Ball has a very large amount of unused potential. (I just love 8-Ball ok) But honestly Cake should’ve been around for a couple more episodes before getting eliminated because I was pretty shocked to see him go.
Coy pin and coy is a great duo
I actually really like grassy idk why people hate him for no reason he built up friendships with sb and basketball so why do people even hate him
Bro made half normal bfdi cast lol
Creative
The letters B are missing, where are Book, Bomby, Barf Bag or Blocky?
Glad Ma Boy Coinys In
I kinda wished one of the debuters were here too...
Dude winner was literally in it
He’s probably talking about failed debuters
So many bfdi characters
I feel like Balloony should be in there, he had so much potential with all of the sacrifices he did to the team in BFB pre split, and he got like no screentime, he had an unfair elemination with all of the other characters in the team are popular or overrated, ans plut just give the boy a chance, he needs screentime fr how little he was in BFB
I love you for saying this
@@serialjammer4095 Why?
NOBODY ever gaf about balloony
@@serialjammer4095 True, it’s also sad because he’s like my favorite character in the show
Balloony should’ve joined TPOT I don’t understand still till this day why they didn’t make someone like Ice Cube or Rocky in BFB Post-Split.
i wish yellow face was here i can see why you didnt put him in but people still think yellow face is racist or maybe they're racist and dont like yellow
8:45 Shout out to the Gang 😏
I legit never knew your voice sounded like this lol
ngl this would be a great season
Firey, Leafy, Bubble, Flower, Gelatin, Teardrop, Lollipop, Pin, Coiny, Needle, Fanny, Black Hole, Snowball, Grassy, Ruby, Book, Tennis Ball, Golf Ball, Pen, Eraser. 20 Contestants.
6:38 YESSS!!!!! GOOD CHOICE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This is why I love Loser ♥️
HOW DARE YOU NOT PUT YELLOWFACE. But thanks anyway for putting fries... Ig...
My all star cast:
Bfdi:
Pen
Eraser
Blocky
Snowball
Firey
Bubble
Leafy
Pencil
Match
Teardrop
Pin
Coiny
Flower
Bfdia:
Gelatin
Ruby
Book
Fries
Puffball
Bomby
Yellow face
Bfb and tpot:
Grassy
Eggy
Lightning
Black hole
Tree
Winner
Price tag
Lollipop
Tell me if i missed anyone!
Cast idea: lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop, lollipop and lollipop.
Honestly instead of Nickel you should've put Book or Bomby
Good allstrars prediction
5:18 What do you mean, nickel is great >:(
My cast:
35 objects
S1: Match, Pin, Coiny, Flower, Golf Ball, Tennis Ball, Pencil, Woody, Snowball, Bubble, Pen, Needle
S2: Puffball, Gelatin, Donut, Book, Fries, Ruby, Nickel
BFB/TPOT: Clock, Loser, Cake, Taco, Gaty, Grassy, Tree, Liy, Winner, Lightning, Fanny, Marker, Pillow, Remote, Naily, Lollipop, Black Hole
Why not Bomby, he’s the first recommended character
Ngl I'd swap Clock for Blackhole or Rocky but this list is good
Secret 25th contestant: Nonexisty
I think pillow should be in all stars :)
WHAT ABOUT THE HOST? MAYBE THE WINNER OF TPOT WITH THEIR NEW POWERS???”
What about the audience favorite? Profily?
Ehhh I don’t think fries is meant for all stars, I think spongy would be there considering the Cary likes spongy and because I feel like they would figure out a way to do something with him. I don’t think match would be in it either and I don’t think Ruby or bubble would be in it
Needle or I riot.
My cast for BFDI all stars are: David, Dora, Yellow Face, Roboty, Robot Flower, Firey, Rocky, TB And Purple Face I think they would have a good interaction
YF , PF and RF all have F’s in their abbreviations
Alright get out-
@@Spacey871 why what did I do wrong?
LOSER IS GOATED AND IF YOU SAY OTHERWISE YOUR SO WRONG, HES SO FUNNY
Maybe you should replace grassy with rocky as even as much as i hate both, (i hate rocky more) he actually fits in there more, and hes also been in every season so far and i feel like rocky just fits *better* in allstars than grassy
I agree with all of this tbh
Awwwwww I wanted yellow face to join
book is a all star
I think it’s better to have a fresh season without the veterans or anyone that competed like the failed debuters or even some reccomended character a season all to non veterans. Or just all the characters that haven’t competed
We already seen a lot from the veterans and there’s no reason to see those characters compete again… Probably still’d watch it though-
Pin wins
I’m sorry but match is no way an all star
Snowball wins
Nah I don’t think he does
yeah o promise he won’t
I hope
Yeah my boi
Snowball doesn't win (probrably)
Am i seeing the all-star color session
I already know fries is winning from the start
Fries wins no question
Semi well made video. Dont get me wrong i enjoyed it but some picks just dont make sense.
Like im sorry but an all stats season should have contestands who performend really good in atleast one season.
Characters like Clock,Match,Loser,Puffball,Winner and Nickel besides being fans of some of them (im a huge Match and Puffball enjoyer.) Never really performed that good in any season if i have to honest.
No pillow :(
Hot take but i hate the idea of an all star season. It's like the object show equivalent for football's european superleague (if you're a football (not the american one) fan and you get what i mean)
P good but ild replace clock and needle with book and basketball
book being left out is kinda of illegal
oh man theres no marker my fav i want it in your guess please :(
I think the all stars should be 1000 caracther its not much